Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
V l
Values Near
N Wind
Wi d Turbines:
T bi
An Overview of Research Findings and
Where to Go From Here
Ben Hoen
L
Lawrence Berkeley
B k l National
N ti l Laboratory
L b t
NEWEEP Webinar
May 5,
5 2010
This presentation was made possible in part by funding by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of
Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Wind & Hydropower Technologies Program
– Previous Literature
↓$ ↓$ ↑$ ↑$
• This linkage is well studied generally, but not for wind facilities
• The home/land is often the largest asset in resident’s portfolio
• Prior to wind facility construction, impacts (e.g., visual and
auditory) to individual properties are difficult to quantify
– Previous Literature
– Other
Oth Disamenity
Di it RResearch
h
• Where To Go From Here
10 Energy Markets and Policy Group • Energy Analysis Department
Berkeley Lab Research Approach
Responds
p to Limitations of Previous Work
• Conduct literature review of previous wind / property value studies and
wind facility public acceptance surveys, as well as potentially analogous
studies
t di on otherth di
disamenities
iti ((e.g. roads,
d power lilines, power plants)
l t )
• Collect large amount of data on residential sales transactions occurring
both pre- and post-construction surrounding a representative sample of
wind facilities at multiple locations in the U.S.
• Visit each home to determine wind turbine visibility and to collect other
important information about the home (e.g.,
(e g the quality of the scenic vista)
• Use multiple statistical models to explore magnitude and statistical
significance of potential effects, relying primarily on hedonic model
• Test for the presence of all three stigmas – Area Stigma, Scenic Vista
Stigma, and Nuisance Stigma
• Rigorously analyze the data
data, culminating in an LBNL report and at least
one journal paper
11 Energy Markets and Policy Group • Energy Analysis Department
Berkeley Lab Project Involves Most Data-
p
Rich and Comprehensive Analysis
y To Date
Research Questions
1) Is there evidence that views of turbines measurably affect sales prices?
2) Is
I there
th evidence
id th
thatt proximity
i it tto turbines
t bi measurably
bl affect
ff t sales
l prices?
i ?
3) Do the results change over time, and are there other observable impacts?
Relevance
Provides stakeholders in siting/permitting processes greater confidence in the
likely effects of proposed wind energy facilities, allowing greater consensus
on often-contentious setback requirements, viewshed valuations and non-
participating landowner arrangements.
Team
B. Hoen (Subcontractor to LBNL), R. Wiser (LBNL), P. Cappers (LBNL),
M. Thayer (San Diego State University), G. Sethi (Bard College)
Funder
U.S.
U S Department of Energy,
Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable
Energy, Wind & Hydropower Technologies Program
12 Energy Markets and Policy Group • Energy Analysis Department
Collected Sales Data from 10 Study Areas
Surroundingg 24 Wind Facilities in 9 States
7,459 Residential Sales Transactions
1,754 Pre-Announcement, 4,937 Post-Construction, and
768 Post-Announcement-Pre-Construction
Custer Cnty, OK
2 Facilities: 98 WTG,
1,113 Sales
Howard Cnty, TX
46 WTG,
1,311 Sales
4,937
What Is a Hedonic Pricing Model?
AgeatSale -0.006 0.0004 0.00 4,937
AgeatSale Sqrd
Sqft 1000
0.00002
0.28
0.02
0.000003
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
4,937
4,937
4,937
• Well respected model used by economists and real
Acres
Baths
ExtWalls Stone
CentralAC
0.09
0.21
0.09
0.01
0.02
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.00
4,937
1,486
2,575
estate
t t practitioners
titi ffor over 40 years
Fireplace 0.11 0.01 0.00 1,834
FinBsmt
Cul De Sac
Water Front
0.08
0.10
0.33
0.02
0.01
0.04
0.00
0.00
0.00
673
992
87
• Heterogeneous residential sales data are used
Cnd Low -0.45 0.05 0.00 69
Cnd BAvg
Cnd Avg
Cnd AAvg
-0.24
Omitted
0.14
0.02
Omitted
0.01
0.00
Omitted
0.00
350
2,727
1,445
• Measures marginal price differences between homes
Cnd High
Vista Poor
Vista BAvg
0 23
0.23
-0.21
-0.08
0 02
0.02
0.02
0.01
0 00
0.00
0.00
0.00
337
310
2,857
that vary by the variables of interest,
interest after controlling for
Vista Avg
Vista AAvg
Vista Prem
Omitted
0.10
0.13
Omitted
0.02
0.04
Omitted
0.00
0.00
1,247
448
75
other characteristics
WAOR Omitted Omitted Omitted 519
TXHC
OKCC
IABV
-0.75
-0.44
-0.24
0.03
0.02
0.02
0.00
0.00
0.00
1,071
476
605
• Controlling characteristics include square feet, acres,
ILLC
WIKCDC
PASC
-0.09
-0 14
-0.14
-0.31
0.03
0 02
0.02
0.03
0.00
0 00
0.00
0.00
213
725
291
bathrooms fireplaces,
bathrooms, fireplaces age
age, condition and scenic vista of
PAWC
NYMCOC
NYMC
-0.07
-0.20
-0.15
0.03
0.03
0.02
0.01
0.00
0.00
222
346
469
the home, location, etc.
Post Con NoView Omitted Omitted Omitted 4,207
View Minor
View Mod
View Sub
-0.01
0.02
-0.01
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.40
0.58
0.94
561
106
35
• Variables of interest include view of turbines, distance
View Extrm 0.02 0.09 0.80 28
Mile Less 0 57
Mile 0 57to1
-0.05
-0.05
0.06
0.05
0.40
0.30
67
58
from turbines, and development period (e.g. before or
Mile 1to3 0.00 0.02 0.80 2,019
Mile 3to5
Mile Gtr5
0.02
Omitted
0.01
Omitted
0.23
Omitted
1,923
870
after construction began)
"Omitted" = reference category for fixed effects variables
"n" indicates number of cases in category when category = "1"
Model Information
• Estimates and significance levels are important
Model Equation Number 1
Dependent Variable LN_SalePrice96
Number of Cases
Number of Predictors (k)
F Statistic
4937
37
442.8
Other Models Used in Analysis
Adjusted R Squared 0.77
Repeat Sales and Sales Volume Models
$ ↓$
By separating out scenic vista
vista,
a potential bias is removed from
measurements of the effects of
the view of wind turbines
15 Energy Markets and Policy Group • Energy Analysis Department
Five Qualitative Ratings Are Used for
Qualityy of Scenic Vista
Each home is
given a
scenic vista
Poor rating, based Premium
on field visits
Moderate Substantial
17 Energy Markets and Policy Group • Energy Analysis Department
To Test for Area and Nuisance Stigmas,
Distance to Nearest Turbine at Time of Sale Is Determined
Five Distance Bands
Are Created
Nuisance Stigma
• Inside of 3000 Feet
• Between 3000 Feet
and 1 Mile
Area Stigma
• Between 1 and 3
Miles
• Between 3 and 5
Miles
• Outside of 5 Miles
“Sold Homes” include all homes sold both before and after construction of the wind facility
– Other
Oth Disamenity
Di it RResearch
h
• Where To Go From Here
19 Energy Markets and Policy Group • Energy Analysis Department
Base Hedonic Model Results:
There Is Strong Statistical Evidence that the
Quality of the Scenic Vista Affects Sales Prices
25%
Average Percentage Differences In Sales Prices
ces
20%
As Compared To Reference Category
ge Differenc
15%
All differences are statistically
10%
significant at the 1% level
5%
Average Percentag
The reference category consists of transactions for homes with an Average Vista
Vista, and that occured
after construction began on the wind facility
15%
No differences are statistically
10% significant at the 10% level
5% 1 7%
1.7% 2 1%
2.1%
Percentage
Reference
0%
Category
-1.2% -0.5%
-5%
Average P
-10%
-15%
A
-20%
20%
-25%
No View of Turbines Minor View Moderate View Substantial View Extreme View
(n=4207) (n=561) (n=106) (n=35) (n=28)
The reference category consists of transactions for homes without a view of the turbines,
and that occured after construction began on the wind facility
15%
No differences are statistically
10% significant at the 10% level
5%
e Percentage
1.6%
Reference
0% Category
-0.4%
-5%
-5.3%
5 3% -5.5%
5 5%
Average
-10%
-15%
-20%
20%
-25%
Within 3000 Feet Between 3000 Feet Between 1 and 3 Miles Between 3 and 5 Miles Outside 5 Miles
(n=67) and 1 Mile (n=58) (n=2019) (n=1923) (n=870)
The reference category consists of transactions for homes situated more than five miles from the nearest
turbine, and that occured after construction began on the wind facility
20%
Price Changes Over Time
Average percentage difference in sales prices as compared to reference category
Averagge Percentage Differences
15%
10% Reference Category
Outside of 5 Miles
5% More Than 2 Years
Before Announcement
0%
-5%
-10%
-15%
Less Than 1 Mile Between 1 and 3 Miles
-25%
More Than Less Than After Less Than Between More Than
2 Years 2 Years Announcement 2 Years 2 and 4 Years 4 Years
Before Before Before After After After
Announcement Announcement Construction Construction Construction Construction
The reference category consists of transactions of homes situated more than five miles from where the nearest
turbine would eventually be located and that occurred more than two years before announcement of the facility
– Previous Literature
– Previous Literature
This presentation was made possible in part from funding by the Office of
Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Wind & Hydropower
g
Technologies Program
g of the U.S. DOE under Contract No. DE-AC02-
05CH11231