Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
– ICT tools have to match with the type of group and its task;
And they have to be supportive for the group processes
Research suggests:
In individualistic cultures (EU, USA) people prefer direct
expression of opinions; In virtual groups they prefer
synchronous communication, through telephone,
video and chat.
In collectivist cultures (Asia, Africa) people are sensitive
to non-verbal signals and group relations. In virtual
groups people prefer asynchronous communication, to
be able to express themselves more carefully: e-mail
12/29/2018 MS-204 BIA 11
Group Decision Support Systems
(GDSS)
• a DSS whose design, structure, and usage reflect the way in
which people cooperate to make a particular decision or type
of decision
• Plus, Avoids
– Dominant Behavior
– Groupthink
– Stubbornness
• Slow
• Expensive
• Usually limited to one issue at a time
Same-Time Same-Time
Same-Place Different-Place
(Most widely used GDSS-
(team room, tools, audio
computers with projectors, voting
conferencing, screen sharing, chat)
tools)
Different-Time Different-Time
Same-Place Different-Place
(audio/video conferencing,
(voice mail, email, bulletin boards)
document sharing)
Advantages of GDSS
• Anonymity – drive out fear leading to better decisions
from a diverse hierarchy of decision makers
• Parallel Communication – eliminate monopolizing
providing increased participation, better decisions
• Automated record keeping – no need to take notes,
they’re automatically recorded
• Ability for virtual meetings – only need hardware,
software and people connected
• Portability - Can be set up to be portable… laptop
• Global Potential - People can be connected across the
world
• No need for a computer guru – although some basic
experience is a must
12/29/2018 MS-204 BIA 34
Disadvantages of GDSS
• Cost –infrastructure costs to provide the hardware and
software/room/network connectivity can be very
expensive
• Security – especially true when companies rent the
facilities for GDSS; also, the facilitator may be a lower-level
employee who may leak information to peers
• Technical Failure – power loss, loss of connectivity, relies
heavily on bandwidth and LAN/WAN infrastructure –
properly setup system should minimize this risk
• Keyboarding Skills – reduced participation may result due
to frustration
• Training – learning curve is present for users, varies by
situation
• Perception of messages – lack of verbal communication
could lead to misinterpretation
12/29/2018 MS-204 BIA 35
Typical GDSS Process
1) Group Leader (and Facilitator?) select software, develop
agenda
2) Participants meet (in decision room/Internet) and are
given a task.
3) Participants generate ideas – brainstorm anonymously
4) Facilitator organize ideas into categories (different for
user-driven software)
5) Discussion and prioritization – may involve ranking by
some criteria and/or rating to the facilitators scale
6) Repeat Steps 3, 4, 5 as necessary
7) Reach decision
8) Recommend providing feedback on decision and results
to all involved
• Single Location
• Multiple Locations
1. Single PC
2. PCs and Keypads
3. Decision Room
4. Distributed GDSS
• Group Members
• Facilitator (Chauffeur)
Other Resources
• People
• Whiteboard
• Handouts
• Opinion Meter
12/29/2018 MS-204 BIA 50
Individual Resources
• Constructing a GDSS
1. Construct (or Rent) a Decision Room
2. Acquire Software
3. Develop Procedures
4. Train a Facilitator
5. Put It All Together
• Can
– Use Someone Else's Facility
– Rent One
– Use a Dual Purpose Computer Lab