Star http://www.thestar.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=229&fArticleId=vn200...

IOL News | IOL Sport | IOL Business | IOL Jobs | IOL Entertainment | IOL Travel | IOL Motoring
| IOL Property | IOL Parenting | IOL Classifieds | More »

Article

Manto's mentor isn't even a nurse

Share |
27 February 2004, 02:04
The woman who devised the beetroot, spinach, garlic and olive oil diet espoused by health minister Manto
Tshabalala-Msimang was a nurse for nine months - 15 years ago - and is no longer registered to practise in
South Africa.

Tine van der Maas, who says she taught herself about nutrition by reading many books and Internet
articles, explained her diet at a meeting of provincial health ministers last year and a Southern African
Development Community meeting in 2002 at the request of the health minister.

With the blessing of Tshabalala-Msimang, she has given the foods to hundreds of patients desperately ill
with Aids

in South African hospitals.

"She's quoting me the whole time," said Van der Maas on Thursday of Tshabalala-Msimang's statements
about the foodstuffs in parliamentary meetings.

"You don't need anti-retrovirals if you are eating these foods," she said in an interview.

"I'm not a quack. If I am, expose me and put me in jail and lock me up. I would be giving people false
hopes, and that is the most horrendous thing to do."

Van der Maas says more than 800 patients have been given the foods at an Mpumalanga hospital, 1�500
in an Umtata hospital and 42 at a hospital in Limpopo. She claimed a total of 42�000 South Africans

1 sur 5 28/10/2010 12:35

Star http://www.thestar.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=229&fArticleId=vn200...

follow her nutritional advice. Van der Maas said that she and her mother, a social worker, came up with
the diet together and have worked without pay for three years.

Her youngest patient had been a three-month-old baby.

The diet consists of a whole lemon blended or grated, mixed with extra virgin olive oil and water; crushed
garlic; ginger cut in small pieces; spinach, beetroot; several vitamin supplements and a solution containing
extracts from the African potato.

Tshabalala-Msimang on Thursday confirmed her support of these programmes in hospitals.

The minister said that she had met over 100 patients who had "got up and walked" after following Van der
Maas's advice.

"Nobody is saying that this diet cures HIV. All we are saying, is that it boosts the immune system. I've
seen the results with my own eyes. There's no doubt in my mind that it works," said the health minister.

Doctors who had been very sceptical had "really embraced the programme", she said. "In medicine
sometimes you do things, and you prove them scientifically later."

The immune-boosting properties of the foodstuffs Van der Maas recommends are being researched at the
Bloemfontein Technical University.

When asked whether her emphasis on nutrition might slow down the provision of anti-retrovirals, the
minister said: "The comprehensive plan talks about choices.

"It helps people make informed choices."

Asked whether she could describe the rise in CD4 counts, the health minister said: "All I'm saying is that
I've seen people get up and walk."

Two of Van der Maas's "patients" interviewed by the Cape Times were:

A man who had a CD4 count of 520 when he began the diet in May last year. After six weeks his CD4
count was 650, he said

Nozipho Bengu, whose mother MP Ruth Bengu

spoke out in parliament about her daughter having HIV, has been on Van der Maas's diet for a year.
Nozipho's CD4 count was 55 when she began the diet. After two months of the diet, her CD4 count rose
to 134

"I was extremely sick. The diet played a very big role (in making me better)," she said.

A healthy CD4 count ranges from around 700 to 1 200. Doctors recommend that patients with a count
lower than 200 take anti-retrovirals.

Demetre Labadarios, head of the human nutrition department at Stellenbosch University and Tygerberg
Academic Hospital, said that to claim that people would recover from advanced Aids with a certain diet
was to "raise false hopes", given the current lack of scientific evidence supporting such diets.

"If we had magic bullets, HIV and Aids wouldn't be around," he said. "Nutrition on its own for the
management of HIV and Aids, helpful as it is, is grossly inadequate and the people concerned should
know that. There is alarm in the scientific community because of these unclear statements, which imply a
lack of understanding of basic physiological principles."

2 sur 5 28/10/2010 12:35

Star http://www.thestar.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=229&fArticleId=vn200...

An editorial late last year in the South African Medical Journal, which is regarded at the voice of the
medical community, was based on an article by Labadarios and came to the same conclusions.

This article was originally published on page 1 of The Cape Times on February 27, 2004

RSS feeds available

About Star
Contact Us
About Us
Advertising
Readership
Terms & Conditions
Subscribe

Booking Deadlines

Sister Newspaper Sites

Cape Argus
Cape Times
Daily News
Isolezwe

3 sur 5 28/10/2010 12:35

Star http://www.thestar.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=229&fArticleId=vn200...

Pretoria News
The Mercury
The Post
The Star

Online Services
Book a Flight
Business Directory
Car Insurance
Compare and Save
Gauteng property
Insurance for Women
Life Insurance
Maps & Direction

Medical Aid
Online Shopping
Personal Loans
Property Search
Travel Specials
UK and Euro Lottery

Weather

Johannesburg 7 day forecast

High: 23°C; Low: 23°C;
Rain: 60% [more cities]

4 sur 5 28/10/2010 12:35

Star http://www.thestar.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=229&fArticleId=vn200...

RSS Feeds | Newsletters | Contact Us | About Us | Advertising | Readership | Terms & Conditions
| Subscribe | Booking Deadlines

© 1999 - 2010 & Independent Online (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.

Reliance on the information this site contains is at your own risk. Please read our Terms and Conditions of
Use and Privacy Policy. Independent Newspapers subscribes to the South African Press Code that
prescribes news that is truthful, accurate, fair and balanced. If we don't live up to the Code please contact
the Press Ombudsman at 011 484 3612/8.

5 sur 5 28/10/2010 12:35