pale: Novetzler /2r2ot 2

{ssb lan ce 5 rQ /<,4 y'/o rne;t

lber.di/l Clarlu/a
3// Wei/,rhozrae Skee/
J-a c,ll s oa w7/e, f/o 11 J a 3 2 2 o 2

Be:4ssts/qnce

pe 4.,Qsst: /an <e 51< /t-,€/lornay C/arl u/a,

-L pray/oup/ease e/(u*e my hkuslo4rr)at'teverrJ
turi/e '%t's
/e//tr /ayo, d€kr receiuinJ a Sciezlt&L /alara lory f'pod7 *)a1
u.tas uohnoun /a rne /u.\qy /uy /ti <t anJ newr dts<laseJ h -y
jrr/,Vlis t)zfurrzrtkoa is noa, net r/y Jiscoucrn ! *7<1 utat2rcu)le
lo rne by n/ {zea/ fiarta/J 51<o57//,
-Ile tteu/y Jiscoutern J ct/ilence is a coprr aF /r5e 2-pazlrzezl oF
(rlr*bz/ /as fr2(otco.vo:z/ (rtae /abor4 /o*y 7epat12 ll<l SrQl.
yms. <uy'or Ae4z7 (o* u/lb heH QaJ /trzt'/"4 2y /tlglprpt-t/1ort.
fib /abor< lory f<potl/'s o€ a subak€t2 ccrlatc/y *i.-bu//"ls
(ttere 1a7nO"r<J microscop/c</1y ut'ht
"^et a/her, H// utcre {1r7J
{r,,ro
/*e Jqrnz uqqPon,The/a-boq/ory fv2otl f.bul *1" Vzrli.n l.tlirzooy
o€ 5eta2 bo/4.O"krtJ<ztt {ri? luu tAs/lV h< <2(}LVpa1,
fl/so Su<a/iQZ nvidnoc< Shouts V/suc/ 4eJ mrcrosropi<</gr<rzl-
a<llon o( ltts {rqae feu2(,/<J aeJ a?pqrea/b,t//<lfto/< tnlh<
/oaer l'y2/ ,oorltoa. fxkzt.K/la.t a€{he ho/eJ Qrn< r<VeQ/eJ h\e
preserlap o ( ((tbor2a.<ouj ./z(/ezlq/ c imuJg.). No otle* idth*rn,
0€ (10se F<?je lun-rbol u)eru (ounJ.
4:4 ch<rbu/<Tprtbr y'o my lz'<lh ap*lot-/y*12 b-{ar,z
/h - (t uv /t 5rh fu pns. <u ta r ( o2 lsm
at'//e J e a a ( y' o { {r<, J uporz
lr1. Qrt,//u/ his /.t/irnoo/ plas pa/ lnterrLl4l *)e uttbJou, 6<me
haJ b een / os /, lh e Eli d en c t D eu/y J t x ove.z { ptov e *1 e €ratn e
had been sub.z1//eJ lo lrle Depatknenl o € Crlr,zioz/ fq €or'cerzpal
6or l'slin2.
P/.Asa /nl mn 5ay Z arn a</u</ haoc€hce othaVlgt <o.ttatlleJ
kTese <i-lrTol,
'7fie e,yas1pq6/e Sclea/rQL .vldeace o( lhe /abor< 1o.1,, r€po,,-l
Coup/e tLitl lh. Po//<e fepctr/ <xonra/< me {ruq anT,rhvo/veneal
a;/h lhese cn'r4er., zr/u-rl utds /?o/ ,*7ere an/ *)e A/rZz'atzT2zssv'
n /h" 2ott'r{ f<pat1 alkr/ 1a r4<1.
45rq ch<"lu/n, lh< UzzkJ 5k/ut Supro.>zu (o.u/ bqs h</Jz
ly nabzqt ffus< <,Ku/Ptble euldeace 1o)zo<.tr 4lleal/o.z o€ lbe
po/t'ce repor/ qn{ hbe |ci<a/t'Q2 <uilerzce o€ *5" /</ora/oty */,4?
i /,tl ya ay ferp oz? rz'/ 1t'11, I o g < l rllu /is u" b u €or zl)e Ttop<..
fe-: u 1 / sz
aulrtorl/l<l 1o car.z<2/ anJ fu7o.pr.uoa/ h\z f<tu/1ta2hVa/fr.r1
in1uskZ", in ny <aaltc/lon fut 4/yeq+ (ot ctlzn.s Z di t eolccmm-
i 11.
]he eccuseJ oy tatt-a9r(u/// Co<U/<kJ h<tr2a oy'/tgWliaa lo lo
4/z/l*l/ry -bul 1o t2{ar.z lriz ror'as<rcn4r a€ /y'7u <^g2s1ez<. o{ z*1e
< Xcu/V a b / e e / /le a c e,,?5.? Cb z rl u/,t, t'/ i 5 k / trto2r t\/e ls oa
",?A4
lu/y /o m<b< ,l5e erat1"m.a/y'o (opzecl
T2 su/>pot 1 pQqy laok ?/ <<t< 2r7//<: V../aclq7z, 421 u,s.
407 </?26).
T Ja undeohzJ/ou sor'l tr2your t{ugu,r/ /622ot2 /e //e* you
qr< sl1// /o lh<ptac"se o€ cr.</lU /h< (ozz/1c1/oa 2V73r1/y
ltni[bou<vet'z Qtb-s<aI th< (oaat<tha Zn\egv//f Un//t t'tt'/1ya't
o{{er)zour aStlskec<- /o knc an /he t*l2onstlt2lf lo gtl2/
issu- bn€or- /fiupt-oper (u/,/a>tli<t 1o (o?rV< 11or pre u<a1*)z
?
f<tu//tgr tZfzl*ll iVaUt|e 1/7 m/ Urca2{o/y' conUz2//'a
45e Cbarb,/a, Z-giue./ou /r2yPretz/sstaz 1o Jiscus-r hy (ase
u,lth fiona/l 5/aos7//,
 P/va1g /.*me 5<,y Z a.72 a(lu</ thr?oc"ac- o ( co.n/z///1ij
/h-se <tlrnet02 J -T7ray (or1/o<tr ass/sy'ance /o brtbs lh<se
ex cu/p a b / e € v iy'eq a s5 b e €o r e /h e pnp e, a u lh ori 1/ n s # c 1 s/tq/1
exonorQ le me o € lhese crlmes,
-T rlTanh,rou {or.your llme ullh €ulur< ass/slancz ttt
lny Cctse,.//.<r -lee 4/r+(4.
Jzar.r" //
Huter/ zU.zh/yers
25r'r'A- 426-?
/rsl*ttrF/a*11<js)tj
 t STATE OF FLOHIDA o
DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL LAW ENFORCEMENT
P.O. BOX !489
TALLAHASSEE 32302

wlLLlAM A. r,loELSrRUP rELEPHoN€

COMMISSIONER 1'ALLAHASSEE REGIONAL CRIME LABORA'I'ORY 488'7880

JuIy 5, 19?G

TO: Honorable Dale Carson FDCLE Lab No. 76 05 11185

Sheriff, D'r val County Your No. 260140
Post Of[icc Box 2070
Jaclisonville, Florida 32202
l
ATTN; Deputy R. E, Mccoy lir->,
William A. Troelstrup
RE: CLITNORD WILLIAMS Commissioner
Death Invesligation
Jeanette WILLIAMS and
Nina MARSHALL
DUVAL COUNTY
05-02-76 D E. Ch:rm1
C rirlre Laboratory Analysl

SUBPOENAS PERTAINING TO THIS CASE SIIOULD BE DIRECTED AS

IOLLOWS: "ELORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL LAW ENFORCEMENT,
CRIME LABONATORY BUREAU, FDCLE LAB NO. 76 05 11185.'I

REFERENCE:

This report irns rcferencc to thc following exhibits rvhich rvero lcccivcd:rl- this llt'bolatoly
May 18, 19?6 via Registeled Mail 11511596.

DXTIIBITS:

llt ()rt(r (l) Iit'('(l.:16 citlil)cl tlrtttt:tgctl t:olttctl lt::rrl llrllcl. listcrl lrs rr:r:ovclr:rl l.rrrrrr
Itr:rrrl trl vit:lirrr. ,l. Willirrrrrs.

One (1) Iired ,38 calibcr damaged lead bullet listed as r.ecover.ed from lett
shouldcr of victirn ,I. WilIinms.

l'.\ Onc (l) clclotnlcd nlclullic fr:.rgucnt listcd ls Lccovr-.r.cd from.]. Williln.rs.
 T o
Flonorable Dale Carson 76 05 11185
July 5, 1976 Page Ivo

(corrtinued)

#4 One (1) fired .32 caliber dan.raged lead bullet Iisted as recovered from
J. Williams.
#5 One (1) fired .38 caiiber damaged Iead builet Iisted as recovered from
N. Marshall.
#6 One (1) fired .38 caliber lead bullet withflaltened base listed as recorered
from scene.

ti7 One (1) fired .38 caliber damaged semi-wadcutter Iead bullet.

#8a One (1) window iisted as recorered from scene.

#8b One (1) fired .38 caliber damaged lead bullet listed as recovered from
scene.

RIiSII I,'IS:

It:XIIIBITS JI1 li2 , 117 and 1l8b

'I'hese bullets lvcle conrpared rn icl'oscopicallJ. wlth each other'. AII lvcre fired from
the same rveapon,

These bullets beal rifling impressions of 8-grooves, right trvist, of dimensions typi-
cal of Arminius revolrrer in.38 Special caliber. Since this is not necessarily the
only brand possibly involved, any rveapon of the given specifications should be con-
sidered for submission to the laboratory.

EXIIIBITS /f3 and 1f5

These bullet portiols are .38 caliber and bear rifling impressious of only iimited
identificatiorl value r,vith rcspecl to thc particular weapon fronr rvhich fired, due to
inl 1;act/pene tl.nl"iou effccts. \trhile solne evidence of a relatio[shi1; rvas noted rvith
Lxlribits llL, #2, ll5, #7 rncl iiSb, it \yas too limited in amount and chalacler for con-
chlsivc ox:r nl in x I iol) r'estllts.

I;;XIIII]IT #4

'I'his bullet bears riflitrg irnpressious of 6-grooves, right trvist o{ dirnensious typical
of licgctrt, H&ll rutl {l&A )'cvolvcrs in.,ii2 calibcr. Sincc Lhcsc rlc not thc only braucls
l)ossil)l.y iuvolvotl, iuly rvc:lPon oI thc givon sl)cc il'icirLions slror,rld bc <:onsitlcr.ocl [or sLrb-
r)r i ss io[ to tl)c laborato].y.
 t o
Holorable Dale Carson 76 05 11185
Jrlly 5, 1976 Page'I'hlee

(continued)

EXHIBIT #8a

Visual and microscopical exarnination of this frame reyealed an apparent bullet hole
in the lorver right portion. Examination of the holed area revealed the presence of
carbonaceous material (smudge), No other indications of close range gunshot were
found.

llEMARI(S;

Exhibits #1 thror:gh #? and #8b were compared microscopically with subrnitted evi-
dcrrce bullets irl your casc nurnbers #57523, #433362, #262904 and with l.he uuidenl.i-
fied evidence arnmunition components in the open case files; all with negative resulis.

Ilxlribits ltl, ll2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7 a-nd #8b rvill be retained in the open case files
pending submission of suspect weapons.

Exhibit #8a was returned to your agency by UPS on June 17, 1976,

WAT/d,ec/ear/We