Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Milkfish (Chanos chanos Forskaal) Consumption in the Philippines and the Docosahex-
aenoic Acid Level of the Cooked Fish
Milkfish consumption and the e#ects on the proximate composition and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA)
level of three cooking methods (Paksiw, Sinigang and fried) used to prepare milkfish were determined.
Total moisture content, crude fat, crude protein and the total ash of the dishes were analyzed. Fatty acid
methyl esters (FAMEs) were analyzed through gas chromatography. Results showed that milkfish is eaten
once to twice a week by Filipino households. Proximate analysis revealed that Paksiw had the highest
moisture content, and Sinigang had the highest crude fat content. Sinigang had a significantly lower crude
protein content compared to raw fish, fried fish had the highest crude protein on a wet basis and Paksiw on
a dry basis. The DHA level for Paksiw was not significantly di#erent from raw milkfish, but DHA level for
Sinigang and fried milkfish were significantly di#erent from the raw sample. Di#erent cooking methods
can thus cause changes in the proximate composition and DHA content of milkfish.
Keywords : Docosahexaenoic Acid (DHA), Milkfish, proximate composition, fatty acid composition, milkfish consump-
tion
top three cooking methods were standardized. Method (AOAC Method 30*.+2), crude fat was determined
Standardization of Recipes The three most common using Soxhlet Extraction Method (AOAC Method 3,*.-3
cooking methods for milkfish were Paksiw, milkfish C). The Kjeldahl Method (AOAC Method 3//.*.) was
boiled in water and vinegar ; Sinigang milkfish boiled in employed to determine crude protein and Dry Ashing
water with a tamarind soup base ; and fried. These were (AOAC Method 3,-.*-) was performed to check total ash
standardized based on the recipes and methodology of the samples.
described by the respondents of the survey. The amount Analyses were performed in triplicate for statistical
and kind of each ingredient, cooking time and tempera- validity. Identification and exclusion of outliers was de-
ture used per recipe was set such that the resulting prod- termined using a Q-test. Results are expressed using the
uct was consistent in flavor, texture and doneness. mean and standard error of the mean (SEM). Analysis of
For Paksiw, the milkfish was first thawed at room Variance (ANOVA) was used to determine significant
temperature for + hour and -* minutes. Then it was di#erence among treatments at a῍*.*/. Duncan’s Multi-
sliced into three and iodized salt was added. The thawed ple Range Test was used to detect which treatment is
milkfish and the other ingredients (i.e., eggplant, onion, significantly di#erent from the others.
ginger, garlic, jalapeno, iodized salt, black pepper, vinegar Fatty Acid Analysis The raw and cooked milkfish
and water) were placed in a covered pot. The ingredients samples were brought to the Standards and Testing Divi-
were allowed to boil for . minutes or until the mixture sion of Industrial Technology Development Institute
reached +*+῎. The dish was then allowed to simmer for (STD-ITDI) in the Department of Science and Technology
+* minutes. (DOST) Complex, Taguig, Metro Manila for fatty acid
For Sinigang, the milkfish was thawed for + hour and -* profiling. The amount of DHA in the samples was deter-
minutes. The scales were removed and the fish sliced mined based on the results of the fatty acid profile.
into three. In a pot, tomatoes, onions, radish, and salt Samples of fresh and used oil in frying were also sub-
were boiled for / minutes at 33῎. Then, the fish were mitted for analysis.
added and allowed to simmer for 0 minutes. Swamp cab- Fat was extracted from raw, Paksiw, Sinigang and fried
bage and jalapeno were added and the dish was allowed milkfish using the Soxhlet Method. Fatty acids were
to simmer again for . minutes, after which the swamp liberated and esterified using the AOAC (+33*) Method
cabbage was removed from the pot and set aside. Tama- 303.-- (Boron Trifluoride Method).
rind mix was added to the dish and the swamp cabbage Fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) were analyzed by gas
was placed back in the pot immediately prior to serving. chromatography using a DB-WAX column (-* mῌ*.,/
For the frying treatment, milkfish was thawed for + mm i.d., with *.,/ mm film thickness) in a Shimadzu GC +.
hour and then sliced into three. Iodized salt was then A equipped with flame ionization detector. The injection
rubbed all over the fish that was then allowed to stand at temperature was set at ,/*῎ and initial column tempera-
room temperature for + hour. In a frying pan, the cook- ture was set at ./῎ for , minutes and programmed to rise
ing oil was heated to ,**ῌ,+*῎ before immersing each fish at +*῎ per minute until the final ,/*῎ was achieved.
slice. Each slice was cooked for 3 minutes. Detection temperature was set at -**῎. Helium was
The fish samples used in the three dishes were acquired used as the carrier gas with an initial injection volume of
from the Lingayen Public Market, Lingayen, Pangasinan. *., ml. FAMEs were identified on the basis of their reten-
The size of the milkfish used ranged from ,3*ῌ-+* mm and tion time versus authentic lipid standard obtained from
weighed -**ῌ--* grams. The fishes were cultivated in Nuchek Prep Inc (Elysian, MN).
freshwater fishponds and fed using filamentous green The significant di#erences in the DHA contents of the
algae. four samples were analyzed using Analysis of Variance
Sensory evaluation was conducted to determine accept- (ANOVA) at /ῌ level of significance. Duncan’s Multiple
ability of the dishes. A nine-point hedonic scale was Range Test was also performed to detect which samples
used to rate acceptability. A rating of 1 or above, similar are significantly di#erent. Student’s t-test was used to
to moderate, meant that the characteristic of the product determine whether there were any significant di#erences
being examined was acceptable. The fishes were in the fatty acid profiles of fresh and used cooking oils.
harvested on March ,**, for the sensory evaluation.
Sample Preparation Samples were obtained from Results and Discussion
each of the standardized dishes for chemical analysis. Survey The respondents (n῍,,*) were classified ac-
Samples were consisted of the cooked fish meat and other cording to their annual income in order to show whether
ingredients like the vegetables and broth (for the Paksiw there are certain di#erences between households falling
and Sinigang dishes). The cooked fish meat was flaked into di#erent income groups and their attitude towards
prior to homogenization with the other ingredients. Ali- fish consumption. When the respondents were asked to
quots of the resulting homogenates were then subjected list the kind of fish they usually eat, milkfish ranked first,
to proximate and fatty acid analysis. followed by tilapia and then by round scad. Figure +
Proximate Analysis The standardized formulation of shows the top ten most commonly consumed fish as
Paksiw, Sinigang and fried milkfish together with a raw determined by the survey.
sample were subjected to proximate analysis. Total The respondents were also asked to indicate the three
moisture content was analyzed using Vacuum Oven most convenient ways of cooking milkfish. The top
Consumption and DHA Levels in Milkfish (Paper #*.*0,) 129
Fig. +. Top ten most commonly consumed fish in Filipino households (nῌ,,*)ῌ
Fig. ,. Top ten common cooking methods for milkfish in Filipino households (nῌ,,*)ῌ
130 C. BAYAGA & G. DEVEZA
three cooking methods were Sinigang, Paksiw and frying. consumed in a wet form, its importance in nutrient intake
Figure , shows the top ten responses. calculations should be acknowledged (Mai, et al.+312).
Table + shows the relationship between frequency at Moisture The moisture content of the milkfish
which each household eats milkfish and classification of sample was lower than that reported in the Philippine
the household with regards to annual family income. Food Composition Table (FCT) (FNRI, +331). This may
Income was classified into - groups. Group A earns ῏ be because the samples were harvested during the dry
2*,*** PHP/year ; group B earns 2*,***ῌ+,*,*** PHP/year ; season of March, after the eggs were fertilized in January
and, group C earnsῐ +,*,*** PHP/year. Of the ,,* house- during the wet or rainy season in the Philippines. In the
holds, //./ῌ belonged to group A ; -*.3ῌ belonged to study of Mustafa and Medeiros (+32/), the moisture con-
group B ; and, +-.0ῌ had annual incomes belonging to tent of catfish fillets was lower in samples harvested in
group C. August (summer season) than those harvested in Decem-
It can be inferred from the table that the frequencies at ber and April. This shows that harvesting season a#ects
which families eat milkfish is generally similar in the total the moisture content of fishes.
population. The category ῌ+ῌ, times a week” has the Paksiw had the highest moisture content among the
highest frequency (n῎+,2), followed by “-ῌ. times a four treatments (00.0ῌ), but this was not significantly
week” (n῎..) and “,ῌ- times a month” (n῎-,). di#erent from that observed for raw milkfish at /ῌ level
Proximate Analysis The proximate compositions of of significance. The moisture content of raw milkfish
raw, Paksiw, Sinigang and fried milkfish are summarized was also not significantly related to Sinigang (0,.-ῌ).
in Table , (wet basis) and Table - (dry basis). Results are Since Paksiw and Sinigang involve boiling in water, no
expressed as mean῍standard error of the mean (SEM). major moisture loss or gain occurred.
Mai, et al., (+312) reported that when data are expressed The moisture content of Paksiw was significantly
as dry weight, the changes indicate real weight changes di#erent from that of Sinigang with the lower moisture
more accurately. This has the advantage of relating content possibly attributed to the proportional increase in
more accurately to the actual gain or loss of lipids and the crude fat content.
thus aids comparison between sample treatments. The The moisture content of fried milkfish (//.,ῌ) is sig-
assumption is made that changes in protein, carbohy- nificantly lower than the other treatments and is compa-
drates and other components are minor. Since food is rable to the FCT value of /0.2ῌ. This is because frying
Table +. Frequency of milkfish consumption per income group of the Filipino households surveyed (nῌ,,*).
Table ,. Proximate composition on a wet basis for raw, Paksiw, Sinigang and fried
milkfish*ῌ
Table -. Proximate composition on a dry basis for raw, Paksiw, Sinigang and fried
milkfish*ῌ
Consumption and DHA Levels in Milkfish (Paper #*.*0,) 131
has a dehydrating e#ect on food. frying. Since milkfish can be categorized as a fatty fish,
Crude Fat There were no significant di#erences in it has a greater tendency to absorb oil during cooking
crude fat content between raw (+*.3ῌ) and Paksiw (3.+,ῌ), compared to non-fatty fish (Mai, et al., +312).
and between Sinigang (+0.3ῌ) and fried (+0.1ῌ) milkfish The high crude fat content of Sinigang may be
at /ῌ levels of confidence. However, the crude fat of raw attributed to the proportional increase due to lower mois-
and Paksiw was significantly di#erent from Sinigang and ture content compared to Paksiw and raw milkfish.
fried milkfish. Sinigang also has lower moisture and crude protein con-
On a dry basis, the crude fat content of raw, Paksiw, tent that contributes to a proportional increase in the
fried and Sinigang milkfish are not significantly di#erent. crude fat content.
However, the crude fat content of Paksiw and Sinigang Crude Protein Sinigang has significantly lower levels
were significantly di#erent. The crude fat content of of crude protein (+3.*ῌ) compared to raw (,,.0ῌ), Paksiw
Sinigang is also not significantly di#erent from fried milk- (,,.0ῌ) and fried milkfish (,/.1ῌ). Sinigang is cooked in
fish, but fried milkfish was significantly di#erent from more water that may cause leaching out of water-soluble
Paksiw and raw milkfish. proteins during cooking. The collagen from milkfish is
The crude fat in the fried sample (+0.1ῌ) was higher hydrolyzed and this causes gel formation. This can be
than the value given in the Philippine Food Composition observed in Sinigang after being kept in cold storage.
Table (+*..ῌ). The increased crude fat percentage of The protein content of raw, Paksiw and fried milkfish
fried milkfish is due to oil absorption associated with were not significantly di#erent from each other on a wet
Table .. Fatty acid profile of raw, Paksiw, Sigang and fried milkfish as percent
weight of total fatty acids.
132 C. BAYAGA & G. DEVEZA
the method that has the least e#ect on the proximate Bulletin of the Faculty of Fisheries, Hokkaido University. --
composition on its wet and dry bases compared to raw (+) : -/ῌ.+.
fish samples. It also exhibits the least DHA decrease Carlson, S.E., Werkman, S.H., Rhodes, P.G., Tolley, E.A. +33-.
Visual-acuity Development in Healthy Infants : E#ects of
among the three cooking methods.
Marine-Oil Supplementation. Am J Clin Nutr. /2 : -/ῌ.,.
Further studies on the e#ect of di#erent seasons, water Frenoux, J.R., Prost, E.D., Belleville, J.L., Prost, J.L. ,**+. A
type and other cooking methods on milkfish should be Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid Diet Lowers Blood Pressure and
undertaken. The amount of each fatty acid per total fat Improves Antioxidant Status in spontaneously Hypertensive
or per gram of sample (mg fatty acid/g sample) would also Rats. J Nutr. +-+ : -3ῌ./.
help in preparing baseline data for recommendations for Hardman, W.E., Reddy Avula, C.P., Fernandes, G., Cameron, I.L.,
pregnant and lactating mothers. Measurement of fatty ,**+. Three Percent Dietary Fish Oil Concentrate Increased
E$cacy of Doxorubicin Against MDA-MB ,-+ Breast Cancer
acid profiles, especially DHA, of other fish and seafood
Xenografts. Clin Cancer Res. 1 : ,*.+ῌ,*.3.
would be useful for comparing which fish or seafood Innis, S.M., Nelson, C.M., Rioux, M.F., and King, D. J. +33.. Devel-
would be more beneficial to human beings. opment of visual acuity in relation to plasma and erythrocyte
omega-0 and omega-- fatty acids in healthy term gestation
Acknowledgement The authors acknowledge with thanks the infants. Am J Clin Nutr. 0* : -.1ῌ-/,.
O$ce of the Vice-Chancellor for Research and Development Kinsella, J.E. +320. Food Components with potential Therapeutic
(OVCRD), University of the Philippines, Diliman for providing Benefits : The n-- Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids of Fish Oil.
the funds for this research and Dr. Victor C. Gavino of the Food Technol. ῌ : 23ῌ31.
University of Montréal, Canada for his comments and sugges- Makrides, M., Neumann, M., Simmer, K., Pater, J., Gibson, R. +33/.
tions on the research methods. Are Long Chain Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids Essential Nutri-
ents in Infancy? Lancet. -./ (230-) : +.0-ῌ+.00.
References Nawar. +33*. Lipids in Food Chemistry. Fennema, O.R. (ed.). New
Association of O$cial Analytical Chemists. +33*. O$cial Meth- York : Marcel Dekker, Inc.
ods of Analysis. +.th ed. Skibsted, L.H., Mikkelsen, A. and Bertelsen, G. +332. Lipid Derived
Association of O$cial Analytical Chemists. +33/. O$cial Meth- O# Flavor in Meat. Ch. +* in Flavor of Meat, Meat Products and
ods of Analysis. +0th ed. Seafoods. Shahidi F. (ed). London : Blackie Acad and Profes-
Bagarinao, T.U. +333. Ecology and Farming of Milkfish. Iloilo sional.
City : SEAFDEC Aquaculture Department. The Philippine Food Composition Tables. +331. Taguig, Metro
Bautista, MN, del Valle, M. J. and Orejana, F.M. +33+. Lipid and Manila : Food and Nutrition Research Institute, Dept. of Sci-
Fatty Acid Composition of Brackish water and Freshwater ence and Technology.
reared Milkfish (Chanos chanos Forskaal). Aquaculture 30 : ,.+ῌ Tiangson, C.L.P, Gavino, V.C., Gavino, G, and Panlasigui, L.N.
,.2. ,**-. Docosahexaenoic acid level of the breast milk of some
Cabling Jr., F, Takama, K and Zama, K. +32,. Lipids of Milkfish. Filipino women. Int J Fd Sci Nutr. /. : -13ῌ-20.