Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
TOPIC-
CONDITION RESTRAINING ALIENATION OF PROPERTY AND ITS EXCEPTION
Submitted by
RAGHIB NAUSHAD
Roll No. 45 of
BA LLB (Hons.), Sem., III (R)
Faculty of Law
Jamia Millia Islamia.
In
November, 2018
CERTIFICATE
The material borrowed from other sources and incorporated in the research
paper has been duly acknowledged.
INDEX
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT……………………………..…4
INTRODUCTION…………………………………....5 to 6
IMPORTANCE………………………………………6 to 7
RESTRAINT ON TRANSFER……………………..8 to 16
EXCEPTIONS……………………………………..16 to 18
BIBLIOGRAPHY……………………………………….19
4
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
INTRODUCTION
Ownership of the property carries with it certain basic rights, such
as a right to have the title to the property, a right to possess and
enjoy it to the exclusion of everyone else, and a right to alienate it
without being dictated to, save in accordance with a provision of
law. An absolute right to dispose of the property indicates that the
owner can sell it for consideration or can donate it for religious or
charitable purposes he may gift it to anyone, mortgage it or put it
up for lease. Save with the help of law, no other person can
interfere with this power or right of the owner or dictate to him,
what should be the manner of alienation, should he alienate or not,
or even what kind of use it should be put to. In short, this right of
alienation, that is one of the basic rights of the owner, cannot be
unreasonably encroached upon by anyone through a private
agreement. This general rule is applicable despite there being an
express contract to the contrary, and prevents the transferor from
controlling the power of alienation of the transferee once the
interest in the property is transferred.
IMPORTANCE
Understanding what the role the right to exclude plays in defining
property is important for several reasons. First, having a better
grasp of the critical features of property may promote a clearer
understanding of the often-arcane legal doctrine that surrounds this
institution. Second, understanding the domain of property is an
important preliminary step in developing a justification or critique
of property from the perspective of distributive justice. Third,
formulating a more precise conception of property may be
necessary in order to offer a complete account of constitutional
provisions that protect “property.” In any event, for those who are
learning the concept of the law of property, the question is one of
intrinsic interest, whether or not it has any payoff in resolving more
immediate concerns.
1
AIR 2010 Mad. 34.
10
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
(2) Inheritance being a thing laid down by the State for rea-sons of
public policy, a private person cannot lay down a mode of
inheritance unknown to the law. Thus if a testator grants property
to a person and his eldest nephew and the eldest nephew of such
nephew, and so forth, here the mode of inheritance not being legal,
2
(1931) 35 CWN 993
3
1872 9 Beng LR 37
11
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
(3) Under the Hindu Law, in the case of a gift, the donee must be a
person in existence and, therefore, the life-estate of Jitendra‟s
unborn son is illegal.
(7) The result is, as to everything after Jitendra‟s life estate, there
was an intestacy, and the plaintiff would succeed, not as legatee,
but as heir in spite of his being expressly disinherited. A general
provision in the will that the heir at law shall be disinher-ited is
ineffectual, without a valid bequest to another person.
Illustrations:-
(i) A condition that transferee shall not transfer the property by way
of gift, is a partial restraint and thus valid.
4
(1867). LR 2 PC 4
14
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
5
(1925) 47 All 884
6
AIR 1935 All 493, 157 Ind Cas 897
7
1958 AIR 255, 1958 SCR 895
15
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
8
AIR 2015 SC 334
9
ILR 2000 KAR 3450
16
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
EXCEPTIONS:-
Section 10 provides two exceptions to the rule against
inalienability. First, Section 10 does not prohibit conditions or
limitations in the case of a lease, which are beneficial to the lessor
or those claiming under him. Second, property may be transferred
for the benefit of a woman who is not a Hindu, a Muslim, or a
Buddhist, such that she shall not have the power to transfer the
property or change her interest therein during her marriage. This
exception is based on the doctrine of coverture that operated in
England in the nineteenth century. There, women could be given
property for their enjoyment without the right to alienate the
property during her marriage. The rule protected women from
being forced to alienate their property in favor of their husbands.
However, despite the abolition of the doctrine of coverture in
England, this exception continues to remain on the statute books in
India.
Lease:-
Conditional transfer is valid in the case of lease where the
condition is for the benefit of the lessor or those claiming under
Court has held that this section does not carve out any exception
with regard to perpetual or permanent lease. Thus, any condition
Married women:-
Restraints on the power of alienation in dispositions in favour of
married woman, who are not Hindu, Mohammedans or Buddhists,
will be valid. This proviso was introduced to serve a similar
purpose as English law in this regard. The English Courts
recognized the rule that it was open to the settler or transferor to
insert a clause in the deed of settlement or transfer, by way of a
restraint on anticipation, that is, to restrain her from anticipating the
The section is enacted to check that the transferor shall not impose
an absolute restraint on the power to alienate that interest or right
which was transferred to the transferee. Therefore, a limited
interest in property can be created in favour of a transferee, but a
restraint on the power to alienate that limited interest will be
invalid.
19
PROPERY LAW ASSIGNMENT , FOL, JAMIA, 2018-19
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
1. Dr. G.P. TRIPATHI, THE TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT,
9th edn., 2018, (CENTRAL LAW PUBLICATION).
WEBSITES
1. www.indiankanoon.com
2. www.scconline.com
3. www.manupatra.com
4. http://www.academia.edu/14343318/Sec_10_and_11_of_TP_Ac
t_1882
5. https://www.lawteacher.net/free-law-essays/property-
trusts/property-carries-with-it-certain-basic-rights-law-
essays.php