Sie sind auf Seite 1von 8

Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N.

An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards


professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

Original Research
An assessment of community pharmacists’
attitudes towards professional practice
in the Republic of Moldova
Maria CORDINA, Vladimir SAFTA, Ala CIOBANU, Nina SAUTENKOVA.
Received (first version): 19-Sep-2007 Accepted: 25-Nov-2007

ABSTRACT* pharmacy scored higher in the majority of


Pharmacy in Moldova is undergoing a period of questions.
transition. The professional practice is adjusting to a Conclusion: Pharmacists in Moldova appear to be
market-oriented economy from the previous Soviet deeply rooted in the traditional approach to the
system. The pharmaceutical sector has been practice of pharmacy pertaining mainly to
liberalised giving rise to a significant increase in the distributive practice model and are somewhat
number of community pharmacies. This has led to distant from the other models of practice such as
some adverse effects on the profession of pharmaceutical care, drug information and self-care.
pharmacy with pharmacists having considerable
difficulties fulfilling their professional aspirations and Keywords: Community Pharmacy Services.
possibly losing confidence in further developing Professional Practice. Moldova
their professional role.
Objective: To assess community pharmacists’
attitudes towards their professional practice and to EVALUACIÓN DE LAS ACTITUDES DE LOS
determine their perceived competence in various FARMACÉUTICOS COMUNITARIOS
pharmaceutical activities.
HACIA EL EJERCICIO PROFESIONAL EN
Methods: A questionnaire which addressed
managerial activities, dispensing activities, LA REPUBLICA DE MOLDOVA
pharmaceutical care activities, inter-professional
relationships, public health and competence was RESUMEN
mailed to 600 community pharmacists who were La farmacia en Moldova está sufriendo un periodo
asked to score the importance and perceived de transición. El ejercicio profesional se está
competence for each activity on a scale ranging ajustando a una economía de mercado desde el
from 0-5. In the case of pharmaceutical care anterior sistema soviético. El sector farmacéutico se
activities, pharmacists were asked to score their ha liberalizado dando lugar a un significativo
degree of agreement or disagreement as to whether incremento en el número de farmacias
it is the responsibility of the pharmacist to engage in comunitarias. Esto ha producido algunos efectos
specific pharmaceutical care activities. adversos sobre la profesión farmacéutica que tiene
Results: A total of 370 valid questionnaires were dificultades de cumplir sus aspiraciones
returned giving a response rate of 61.7%. profesionales y posiblemente perdiendo confianza
Managerial and dispensing activities were scored en el futuro desarrollo de su papel profesional.
the highest both in terms of perceived importance Objetivo: Evaluar las actitudes de los farmacéuticos
and competence. The more innovative comunitarios hacia su ejercicio profesional y
pharmaceutical care activities scored relatively low. determinar su percepción de competencia en varias
Overall scores relating to the importance of actividades farmacéuticas.
pharmacists engaging in public health activities Métodos: Se envió un cuestionario a 600
appear to be the lowest of the entire questionnaire. farmacéuticos comunitarios a los que se pedía que
Younger pharmacists between the ages of 22-30 puntuasen la importancia y la competencia
obtained significantly higher scores with regards to percibida con valores de 0-5 para cada una de las
the perceived pharmacist’s responsibility in actividades: gestión, dispensación, atención
engaging in various pharmaceutical care activities. farmacéutica, relaciones inter-profesionales, y salud
Respondents who practiced in an accredited pública. En las actividades de atención
farmacéutica, se pidió a los farmacéuticos que
puntuasen su grado de acuerdo o desacuerdo sobre
*
Maria CORDINA B.Pharm (Hons) PhD (QUB). si es responsabilidad del farmacéutico involucrarse
Department of Pharmacy, University of Malta. Msida en actividades específicas de atención farmacéutica.
(Malta). Resultados: Se recibieron 370 cuestionarios válidos
Vladimir SAFTA. Deputy Director. National Medicines con una tasa de respuesta del 61%. Las actividades
Agency, Ministry of Health and Social Protection. Chisinau de gestión y de dispensación fueron puntuadas las
(Republic of Moldova).
Ala CIOBANU. President of the Association of
más altas tanto en términos de importancia
Pharmacists of the Republic of Moldova. Chisinau percibida como de competencia. Las más
(Republic of Moldova). innovadoras actividades de atención farmacéutica
Nina SAUTENKOVA. Manager, Pharmaceutical Policy in puntuaron relativamente bajas. Las puntuaciones
NIS, Health Technology and Pharmaceutics. World Health totales relativas a la importancia de que los
Organisation, Regional Office for Europe. Copenhagen farmacéuticos se involucren en actividades de salud
(Denmark).

www.pharmacypractice.org 1
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

pública aparecieron en el lugar más bajo del pharmacies- staffed by pharmacy assistants were
cuestionario. Los farmacéuticos jóvenes, entre 22- granted permission to operate. In addition local
30 años, obtuvieron puntuaciones hospitals were allowed to open pharmacy outlets,
significativamente más altas sobre la percepción de which are, however, staffed by any available health
la responsabilidad del farmacéutico de involucrarse care worker in the area and not by pharmacists or
en varias actividades de atención farmacéutica. Los pharmacy assistants. The privatization of this sector
respondentes que ejercían en una farmacia has led to a situation whereby medical doctors have
acreditada puntuaron más alta en la mayoría de las been allowed to purchase pharmacies, usually in
preguntas. the clinic or hospital where they work leading to a
Conclusión: Los farmacéuticos de Moldova situation of conflict of interest where expensive or
parecían estar profundamente enraizados en la inappropriate drugs are prescribed to increase the
aproximación tradicional del ejercicio de la pharmacies’ profit margins at the detriment of the
2
farmacia, perteneciendo principalmente al modelo patient.
de ejercicio distributivo y, de algún modo, distantes
de otros modelos de ejercicio como la atención While theoretically under the Semashko model
farmacéutica, la información sobre medicamentos y patients received unlimited free services, the
el auto-cuidado. provision of modern pharmaceuticals was very
limited. Currently the spectrum of medicines
Palabras clave: Servicios de farmacias available has increased, however, access is still a
comunitarias. Ejercicio profesional. Moldova. problem due to costs of drugs placing specific
patient groups such those with chronic diseases in a
difficult situation as they may not afford to purchase
their medication leading to inadequate control of
their condition. The World Health Organization
through the Special Project for Pharmaceuticals in
INTRODUCTION NIS has drawn up and supported the use of a
National Essential Drugs List to encourage rational
4
The Republic of Moldova is a landlocked country, use of drugs in Moldova.
with about three million inhabitants, in Eastern
Europe, located between Romania to the west and As part of the reform in the health sector, under the
Ukraine to the north, east and south. Moldova was law on Evaluation and Accreditation in Health Care
formerly part of the Soviet Union and has been a (2001) a process of accreditation for pharmacies
Newly Independent State (NIS) since 1991. It is a has been set in motion. Pharmacies in Moldova
densely populated country with about 54% of the need to be accredited in order to be eligible to enter
population living in rural areas. Moldova has an an agreement with The National Health Insurance
economy which is in transition and is thus Company for drug reimbursement. The
undergoing reform in various sectors including the accreditation of pharmacies falls under the
health and social sectors.1 responsibility of the National Accreditation Council
which sets the required standards based on Good
Initially following independence Moldova inherited Pharmacy Practice Guidelines (GPP) issued by
5
the Semashko health care model from the former WHO. At present 338 pharmacies have been
Soviet Union, having a highly centralized structure accredited by the National Accreditation Council.
with key decision making and planning taking place This is envisaged as being a very constructive step
in the capital.2 The country’s health care system has which may lead to further positive developments in
since been decentralised into a regional (judet) community pharmacy.
system and since 1993 pharmacies were allowed to
become privatised with most being concentrated in There are currently about 3000 pharmacists in
towns leaving a number of rural settlements with Moldova, approximately three quarters of whom are
no/limited access to pharmacy.3 Currently there is a women. Students receive their pharmacy education
mixed system of state and privately owned at the University of Medicine and Pharmacy in
pharmacies.2 Official data indicates that there are Chisinau where they follow a 5 year university
about 1000 pharmacies putting the pharmacy to course which precedes a 2 year residency
population ratio at 1:3000. Pharmacies are licensed programme. Previously the training was modelled
and regulated by The Ministry of Health through the under the Soviet system with the course having a
6
National Medicines Agency. very strong emphasis on chemistry. However as
part of the reform in education taking place since
The large scale privatization was set in motion 1991 the aim is for the training to be in line with
following both an economic collapse and a European Union norms.7 Since the late 1990’s the
breakdown in the national prescription system, pharmacy curriculum has been revised and now
which led to the state having difficulties in ensuring includes more practice based subjects such as
an adequate and regulated drug supply. The pharmacotherapy and more recently topics related
privatization system was meant to address these to social pharmacy and pharmaceutical care have
shortcomings.2 This wide spread liberalisation, has been included.
however, led pharmacy to be increasingly seen as a
part of the commercial sector rather than a part of a The problems in the pharmaceutical sector during
professional system within healthcare. In order to the period of transition have adversely affected the
improve access to medicines in rural areas, profession of pharmacy with pharmacists having
pharmacy outlets - branches of licensed significant difficulties fulfilling their professional
aspirations and possibly losing confidence in further

www.pharmacypractice.org 2
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

developing their professional role. The aim of the The mean scores obtained for managerial and
study was therefore to assess community dispensing activities both in terms of perceived
pharmacists’ attitudes towards their professional importance and competence (Table 2) rank at the
practice and to determine their perceived higher end of the scale. Respondents’ scores
competence in various pharmaceutical activities relating to the pharmacists responsibility to engage
in pharmaceutical care activities presented in Table
3, appear to be lower, with the ones receiving a
METHODS mean score above 4 being the traditional
A questionnaire was mailed to 600 community pharmacist activities. The more innovative
pharmacists (one in every 5). These pharmacists pharmaceutical care activities scored the lowest
were randomly selected from a population of 3000 both in terms of perceived pharmacist responsibility
pharmacists. Pharmacists were given a deadline by as well as in terms on competence. Overall scores
which to return the completed questionnaires. The relating to the importance of pharmacists engaging
questionnaire consisted of 37 questions divided into in public health activities (Table 5) appear to be the
6 sections which addressed various aspects of lowest of the entire questionnaire; this being
practice. The questionnaire was translated into perceived by respondents as being the least
Romanian and back translated into English by a important activity of the pharmacist. It is also the
third party. The sections addressed were area where pharmacists felt the least competent
managerial activities, dispensing activities, especially when engaging in health screening
pharmaceutical care activities, inter-professional activities registering a mean perceived competence
relationships, public health and competence. For score of 2.9 (SD=1.78).
each of the above areas pharmacists were asked to Table 1 : Description of study population
score, on a scale from 0-5 (1= not important, (n=370)
5=extremely important) the perceived importance of Characteristic N %
each activity, they were also asked to separately Gender
score their perceived competence (0=not Male 50 13.5
competent, 5=extremely competent), in performing Female 320 86.5
each activity. In the case of questions related to Age
pharmaceutical care activities, which have been Age range 22-69
8 Mean age (SD) 43.9 (9.85)
adapted from a Odedina and Segal , pharmacists
were asked to score their degree of agreement or 22-30 35 9.5
disagreement (0=strongly disagree, 5=strongly 31-40 99 26.8
agree) as to whether it is the responsibility of the 41-50 144 38.9
> 50 92 24.9
pharmacists to engage in specific pharmaceutical
Practice Experience (years)
care activities rather than the perceived importance
1-10 52 14.1
of each activity. In addition respondents were also 11-20 104 28.1
asked to provide the following demographic 21-30 132 35.7
information: gender, age, years’ in practice and if >30 82 22.2
they practiced in an accredited pharmacy. The Practice in Accredited Pharmacy
questionnaire was initially piloted on 15 pharmacists Yes 260 70.3
through the Association of Pharmacists of the No 110 29.7
Republic of Moldova. They commented on
relevance, clarity and ease of understanding of There was a significant (p<0.01) positive correlation
questions. These comments were taken into between all questions relating to perceived
consideration in the final draft of the Romanian importance/perceived pharmacist responsibility (in
version. the case of pharmaceutical care activities) and
perceived competence, indicating that one
The data was gathered over a 3 month period parameter has a direct influence on the other.
between December 2006 and February 2007. Data
was entered into to SPSS and analysed using Males scored higher than females in 90% of the
Mann-Whitney U tests, Kruskal Wallis. Spearman’s questionnaire, obtaining significantly higher scores
rho correlation was also used. in terms of perceived competence related to:
ensuring that medicines are of good quality,
A p value of <0.05 was considered statistically planning and implementing strategies to resolve
significant. drug related problems (p<0.05); consulting with
other pharmacists about specific patient related
problems (p<0.05); providing general health
RESULTS
information to patients (p<0.05); providing updated,
A total of 370 valid questionnaires were returned. A unbiased medicines information to patients and
further 16 questionnaires were returned, however doctors (p<0.01); Males also placed significantly
these were considered to be invalid due to the higher importance than females on: providing
extensive amount of missing data. A response rate updated, unbiased medicines information to patients
of 61.7% was thus achieved. The demographic and doctors (p<0.05) and having access to
characteristics of the respondents are shown in appropriate informational services to enable efficient
Table 1. practice (p<0.05).

www.pharmacypractice.org 3
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

Table 2 : Respondents’ mean scores for managerial and dispensing activities


Perceived Perceived
Correlation between
Managerial activity Importance* Competence*
importance & competence
Mean (SD) Mean (SD)
Ensuring pharmacy is well supplied with
4.7 (0.59) 4.3 (1.32) r=0.247, p<0.01
medicines
Ensuring that medicines are of good quality 4.7 (0.60) 4.2 (1.41) r=0.383, p<0.01
Ensuring appropriate storage conditions for
4.6 (0.63) 4.3 (1.18) r=0.484, p<0.01
medicines
Ensuring that the environment within the
pharmacy reflects a professional setting both 4.5 (0.72) 4.2 (1.14) r=0.511, p<0.01
in terms of staff and facilities
Ensuring that the pharmacy has a private
area where the pharmacist can have a 4.0 (1.18) 3.7 (1.58) r=0.381, p<0.01
confidential conversation with the patient
Ensuring that the pharmacy makes a good
4.3 (0.90) 3.8 (1.39) r=0.559, p<0.01
profit
Dispensing activity
Dispensing a prescription item only against
4.2 (1.05) 4.2 (1.26) r=0.439, p<0.01
prescription
Assessing that a prescription is a legally valid 4.6 (0.70) 4.3 (1.26) r=0.555, p<0.01
Assessing the pharmaceutical and
pharmacological aspects e.g. appropriate 4.6 (0.67) 4.2 (1.31) r=0.467, p<0.01
dosage form, dose, frequency
Assessing appropriateness of medication for
the individual e.g. checking for contra- 4.4 (0.81) 4.1 (1.27) r=0.553, p<0.01
indication, interactions ect.
Assessing that the medication it the most
4.2 ( 0.91) 4.0 (1.23) r=0.413, p<0.01
economically viable for the patient
Double checking the prescription before
4.5 (0.94) 4.3 (1.26) r=0.675, p<0.01
dispensing
Providing the patient with information
4.6 (0.74) 4.4 (1.11) r=0.449, p<0.01
regarding the medicine
Explaining to the patient how to take the
4.7 (0.69) 4.4 (1.16) r=0.547, p<0.01
medication and for how long
Explaining the possible side effects to the
4.3 (0.96) 4.2 (1.20) r=0.535, p<0.01
patient
Ensuring that the patient has understood the
4.4 (0.91) 4.2 (1.16) r=0.551, p<0.01
information provided
* (0 =low; 5=high)

Table 3 : Respondents’ mean scores for pharmaceutical care activities


Perceived Pharmacist Perceived Correlation between
Pharmaceutical care activity Responsibility* Competence** responsibility &
Mean (SD) Mean (SD) competence
Assess patients’ health-related problem
3.9 (1.16) 3.8 (1.32) r=0.534, p<0.01
and medication requirements
Keep information (records) about the
patients’ medical condition/s, medication 3.4 (1.50) 3.3 (1.54) r=0.531, p<0.01
and progress
Be actively involved in the selection of the
3.9 (1.30) 3.7 (1.37) r=0.576, p<0.01
most appropriate medication for the patient
Explain to patients what they should
4.2 (0.95) 4.1 (1.19) r=0.552, p<0.01
expect from their medicine
Monitor patients’ progress after dispensing
3.4 (1.50) 3.2 (1.60) r=0.492, p<0.01
the medicine
Attempt to identify any drug-related
3.8 (1.26) 3.5 (1.42) r=0.438, p<0.01
problem patients may be experiencing
Plan and implement a strategy to resolve
3.6 (1.40) 3.3 (1.58) r=0.535, p<0.01
these drug-related problems
Have a procedure in place to evaluate the
3.6 (1.39) 3.3 (1.56) r=0.547, p<0.01
progress and outcomes of treatment
Communicate the patient’s progress on
3.6 (1.50) 3.3 (1.56) r=0.547, p<0.01
their drug therapy to their doctor
Refer the patient to the doctor when
4.6 (0.77) 4.4 (1.10) r=0.583, p<0.01
necessary
Recording all professional activities in a
manner that allows access to 4.2 (1.10) 3.7 (1.45) r=0.531 p<0.01
comprehensive information
* (0=strongly disagree; 5=strongly agree)
** (0=low; 5=high)

www.pharmacypractice.org 4
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

Table 4 : Respondents’ mean scores for inter/intra-professional relationships


Perceived Perceived
Correlation between
Activity Importance* Competence*
importance & competence
Mean (SD) Mean (SD)
Establishing a professional relationship
with doctors to enable joint therapeutic 4.3 (0.97) 3.9 (1.24) r= 0.478, p<0.01
management of patient
Consulting with other pharmacists about
4.1 (1.19) 4.0 (1.37) r= 0.619 p<0.01
specific patient problems
Establishing communication with other
healthcare professionals or agencies to 3.9 (1.16) 3.6 (1.39) r= 0.521, p<0.01
refer patients with social problems
* (0 =low; 5=high)

Table 5 : Respondents’ mean scores for public health activities


Perceived Perceived
Correlation between
Activity Importance* Competence*
importance & competence
Mean (SD) Mean (SD)
Be active in providing general health information
3.7 (1.38) 3.6 (1.37) r= 0.520, p<0.01
to patients
Provide update, unbiased information medicines
3.8 (1.46) 3.7 (1.44) r= 0.552, p<0.01
information to patients and doctors
Engage in health screening activities 3.0 (1.79) 2.9 (1.78) r= 0.691, p<0.01
Engage in health promotion activities 3.7 (1.46) 3.5 (1.47) r= 0.554, p<0.01
* (0 =low; 5=high)

Table 6 : Respondents’ mean scores for maintenance of competence


Perceived Importance
Activity
Mean (SD)
Have access to appropriate informational services to enable efficient practice 4.1 (1.20)
Regularly participate in high quality continuing education programmes to enable
4.3 (1.17)
competency improvement
Engaging in self-assessment of competence and professional activities 4.2 (1.26)
* (0 =low; 5=high)

Table 7 : Activities for which pharmacist practicing in accredited pharmacies obtained significantly higher scores
Perceived importance placed on activities
Ensuring appropriate storage conditions for medicines p<0.001
Ensuring that the environment within the pharmacy reflects a professional setting both in terms of staff
p<0.001
and facilities
Ensuring that the pharmacy makes a good profit p<0.05
Assessing that a prescription is a legally valid p<0.01
Assessing the pharmaceutical and pharmacological aspects of a prescription p<0.001
Assessing appropriateness of medication for the individual p<0.01
Double checking the prescription before dispensing p<0.05
Explaining to the patient how to take the medication and for how long p<0.05
Ensuring that the patient has understood the information provided p<0.001
Establishing a professional relationship with doctors to enable joint therapeutic management of patient p<0.01
Consulting with other pharmacists about specific patient problems p<0.001
Establishing communication with other healthcare professionals or agencies to refer patients with social
p<0.001
problems
Have access to appropriate informational services to enable efficient practice p<0.05
Engaging in self-assessment of competence and professional activities p<0.01
Perceived pharmacist responsibility in performing pharmaceutical care activities
Be actively involved in the selection of the most appropriate medication for the patient p<0.05
Explain to patients what they should expect from their medicine p<0.05
Attempt to identify any drug-related problem patients may be experiencing p<0.05
Refer the patient to the doctor when necessary p<0.01
Recording all professional activities in a manner that allows access to comprehensive information p<0.01
Perceived competence
Assessing that a prescription is a legally valid p<0.01
Refer the patient to the doctor when necessary p<0.001

Pharmacists within the younger age group of 22-30 expect from their medication (p<0.05); monitoring
years of age obtained significantly lower scores the patient’s progress after dispensing the
when compared to other age groups in terms of medication (p<0.001); establishing professional
perceived competence in: assessing the relationships with doctors to enable joint therapeutic
appropriateness of the medication for the individual management of patients (p<0.01) and in providing
(p<0.01); explaining to patients what they should updated unbiased medicines information to patients

www.pharmacypractice.org 5
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

and other doctors (p<0.01); However, these that respondents are not fully convinced that
younger pharmacists obtained significantly higher pharmaceutical care activities are the responsibility
scores as compared to other age groups when of the pharmacist and are still somewhat distant
indicating the perceived pharmacist’s responsibility from the concept of the pharmacist as a provider of
in engaging in the following pharmaceutical care patient care.
activities: assessing patients’ health–related
problems and medication requirements (p<0.01); When looking at the results in the light of the Total
monitoring the patient’s progress after dispensing Pharmacy Care model for pharmacy practice
the medicine (p<0.05); planning and implementing a proposed by Holland and Nimmo9, it appears that
strategy to resolve drug related problems; recording respondents identify mainly with the distributive
all professional activities in a manner that allows practice model and are rather distant from the
access to comprehensive information (p<0.05). This pharmaceutical care practice model, which includes
age group also placed significantly higher the tasks of assuming responsibility, on the patient
importance with regards to the pharmacist engaging care team, for modifying or dispensing,
in health screening activities (p<0.05). Pharmacists recommending, monitoring and evaluating a
over the age of 50 scored significantly higher than patient’s pharmacotherapy, to ensure the outcomes
other age groups with regards to the pharmacists of the pharmacotherapy provided.
perceived responsibility to have a procedure in When addressing inter/intra professional
place to evaluate the progress and outcomes of relationships, the results are reflective of the
treatment (p<0.01) and communicate the patient’s possible perceived barriers to establishing such
progress on their drug therapy to their doctor relationships in practice. In Moldova there is no
(p<0.01). structured approach to team work in patient care.
Pharmacists practicing in an accredited pharmacy The interaction between pharmacists and doctors
tended to score higher with 100% achieving higher varies and is dependent on the individuals involved.
scores in questions relating to perceived In the minority of cases professional relationships
importance/ perceived pharmacist responsibility for are good and patient oriented, with communication
pharmaceutical care activities and 53% scoring mainly taking place over the phone. However, in
higher in terms of perceived competence. general, this type of inter-professional relationship is
Accredited pharmacy pharmacists obtained somewhat strained and has been identified as a
significantly higher scores in activities shown in priority area for improvement by the Association of
Table 7. Pharmacists. The concept that a team based
approach to patient care is necessary for better
patient outcomes is well established, in general
DISCUSSION health care management. Barriers to establishing a
team based approach are well documented in the
The results obtained from this study are interesting international literature and present an ongoing
and provide an insight into pharmacists’ perceptions struggle.10-12
of their professional practice. There are a number of
trends which are evident, some of which are not Although WHO is supporting the concept of rational
surprising, while others are rather worthy of note. drug use and Moldova has established a National
Drug List, a National Formulary and standard
Respondents assigned relatively high scores to treatment guidelines have been developed, many
activities relating to pharmacy management and doctors do not follow these principles and
dispensing, both in terms of perceived importance polypharmacy, over prescribing and prescribing of
and perceived competence, indicating that they feel branded products is widespread. It is therefore
relatively comfortable and competent to conduct essential for pharmacists to work on developing
these activities. This is not unexpected since these good inter-professional relationships in order to be
activities are associated with the more traditional in a better position to enhance the appropriate use
functions of pharmacists. In fact the highest scores of medicines. In order to influence prescribing as
of the entire questionnaire (4.7) were assigned to 5
recommended by GPP and manage patients’ drug
the activities of ensuring a pharmacy is well therapy, pharmacists also need to identify more
supplied with medicines, ensuring that the strongly with the pharmaceutical care practice
medicines are of good quality and explaining to the model described above.
patient how to take the medication and for how long.
These activities form the backbone of the Public health activities received the lowest scores of
profession. They are mainly related to access and the entire questionnaire both in terms of perceived
supply of medicines and are well engrained in importance and competence. This appears to be the
pharmacists due to both training and tradition. weakest of all professional activities. These
activities fall within the drug information practice
In answering questions relating to pharmaceutical model9; a model which appears to be the most alien
care, i.e. to what degree respondents perceived the to respondents. Apparently pharmacists’ roles in
activities listed to be the responsibility of the health promotion and disease prevention are nearly
pharmacist, the scores were lower, most being non-existent in the views of politicians/policy makers
between scores of 3-4. The lowest (3.4) relating to and other health care professionals in Moldova. The
keeping patient records and monitoring patient’s latter two elements have also been highlighted as
progress after dispensing. Perceived competence in priorities within the health sector reform in Moldova,
conducting pharmaceutical care activities was also however the pharmacist’s involvement was not
lower than the more traditional activities. It appears envisaged.2 This situation does very little to

www.pharmacypractice.org 6
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

encourage pharmacists to be more proactive in this knowledge base of graduates changes and they
area. Health promotion and ill health prevention are move into practice, they will influence practice
listed as the first of the four main elements of GPP5 change to reflect the new knowledge base.14
and hence should be given due importance within
the profession. Various studies have demonstrated The factor which appears to have had the greatest
the community pharmacists’ contribution to health influence on the results is practicing in an
promotion and the positive effect in rural accredited pharmacy as illustrated in Table 7.
13
communities has also been established. Increased Respondents who practiced in an accredited
support, both in terms of education and pharmacy scored higher in most questions. They
infrastructure, should be given to pharmacists to placed higher importance on all professional
take on increased responsibility in this area. activities illustrating that practicing in a professional
environment has a positive effect on the attitude to
Competence issues received moderate scores, with professional practice. These findings support two
hardly any variations in terms of demographics. This criteria required for practice change suggested by
could be related to the fact that continuing Nimmo and Holland, the first being the need for an
education is mandatory in Moldova with environment conducive to the desired practice and
pharmacists needing to engage in 200 hours of the other motivation.15 The motivational factor being
continuing education over a period of 5 years, a present due to the prerequisite of the need for the
system in place since the Soviet era. pharmacy to be accredited for it to participate in the
national reimbursement scheme.
Gender appears to have exerted an influence on the
results, with males obtaining higher scores than
females in 90% of the questions. This is an CONCLUSIONS
interesting factor and may relate to females feeling
less confident in relation to professional practice. It Pharmacists in Moldova appear to be deeply rooted
may also be related to the fact that in former Soviet in the traditional approach to the practice of
times it was mainly men who held senior positions pharmacy pertaining mainly to distributive practice
within the profession. model and are somewhat distant from the other
models of practice such as pharmaceutical care,
In terms of age, younger pharmacists appear to drug information and self-care. It appears that
identify more with current trends in the practice of younger pharmacists identify more with the current
pharmacy such as professional activities related to trends in practice implying that they would be more
the delivery of pharmaceutical care by the receptive to embracing such models of practice.
pharmacist. While in relation to public health Accreditation of pharmacies has had a very positive
activities, ‘engaging in health screen activities’, influence on the pharmacists practicing in such
received the lowest score of the entire pharmacies as they have a better perception of
questionnaire, however, younger pharmacists professional activities placing more importance on
scored it significantly higher. These results are very such activities.
positive, encouraging and augur well for the future
of the profession. They also reflect the changes
occurring in the pharmacy curriculum which places CONFLICT OF INTEREST
increased emphasis on practice related subjects. None declared.
The findings also support the concept that as the

References
1. CIA World Fact Book Moldova. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/md.html#Econ.
(Accessed 30th August 2007).
2. MacLehose L in McKee M (ed) Health Care Systems in Transition: Republic of Moldova; Copenhagen, European
Observatory on Health Care Systems 2000; 4 (5)
3. United States Pharmacopoeia. http://www.usp.org/worldwide/dqi/regions/moldova.html (Accessed 30th August 2007).
4. Essential drugs in brief. Department of Essential Drugs and Medicines Policy. Health Technology and Pharmaceuticals
Cluster, World Health Organization, Geneva 2002; issue 6.
5. Good pharmacy practice in community and hospital settings: annex 7 to the thirty-fifth report of the WHO Expert
Committee on Specifications for Pharmaceutical Preparations. WHO technical report series no.885 Geneva,
Switzerland: World Health Organisation; 1999:93-101.
6. Menabde N, Stobbelar F. The patient in focus: A strategy for pharmaceutical sector reform in Newly Independent States.
World Health Organisation. Copenhagen 1998. pp13-29.
7. Tiron S, Arion V, Paiu M, Scalnii V, Satan V. Higher Education in the Republic of Moldova. Monographs on Higher
Education. UNSCO-CEPES. Bucharest, 2003.
8. Odedina FT, Segal R. Behavioural pharmaceutical care scale for measuring pharmacists activities. Am J Health Syst
Pharm. 1996; 3:855-65.
9. Holland RW, Nimmo CM. Transitions in pharmacy practice, part1: beyond pharmaceutical care. Am J Health-Syst Pharm.
1999;56:1758-64.
10. Cordina M, McElnay JC, Hughes CM. The importance that community pharmacists in Malta place on the introduction of
pharmaceutical care. Pharm World Sci. 1999; 21:69-73.
11. Hughes CM, McCann S. Perceived inter-professional barriers between community pharmacists and general
practitioners: a qualitative assessment. Br J Gen Pract. 2003; 53;600-6.

www.pharmacypractice.org 7
Cordina M, Safta V, Ciobanu A, Sautenkova N. An assessment of community pharmacists’ attitudes towards
professional practice in the Republic of Moldova. Pharmacy Practice 2008 Jan-Mar;6(1):1-8.

12. Cordina M, Nurmanbetova Nusupzhanovna F, Kulmagambetov Raikhanovich I, Sautenkova N. Pharmacy and


Pharmacists’ Perceptions of Pharmaceutical Care in Kazakhstan. Int J Pharm Pract. 2008;16:41-6.
13. Hourihan F, Krass I, Chen T. Rural Community Pharmacy: A Feasible site for health promotion and screening service
for cardiovascular risk factors. Aust J Rural Health. 2003;11;28.
14. Developing pharmacy practice: A focus on patient care. Handbook. World Health Organization in collaboration with
International Pharmaceutical Federation. 2006. WHO/PSM/PAR/2006.5.
15. Nimmo CM, Holland RW. Transitions in pharmacy practice, part 4: Can a leopard change its spots. Am J Health-Syst
Pharm. 1999;56:2458-62.

www.pharmacypractice.org 8

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen