Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Research
Methodology
Chapter - 4
Research methodology
The idea of this chapter is to draw the broader understanding on the research
methodology that has been used to conduct this research work. This chapter
explains research approach, and the research strategy used in this thesis.
Furthermore, the data collection, sample selection, questionnaire design, the ways to
evaluate the validity and reliability of the obtained results will be discussed. For this
study reliability test, descriptive statistics, T- test, ANOVA, Chi-Square and Factor
analysis were used to analyze data. Beside Excel 2010, SPSS 17.0.0 package was
used to perform required calculations. Construct validity of measures was
determined for the validation of an instrument. For accurate relationship, among
variable construct validity of measures is exceptionally important and it depends on
the aptitude of the researcher to appropriately measure the variables. Cronbaeh’s
alpha was calculated to detennine the internal reliability of the tool.
148
The quantitative research seeks to quantify the data and, typically, applies some
form of statistical analysis. Whenever a new marketing research problem is being
addressed, quantitative research taken must be preceded by appropriate qualitative
research (Malhotra & Dash, 2011).The data in quantitative approach are numbers
and lends itself to statistical analysis in order to imply the characteristics of
something. This approach provides objectivity because the respondents are the ones
who provide the numbers; therefore researcher's opinion does not have any impact
on testing the hypothesis.
The idea of study started with knowing about branding practices in petro-retailing in
highly developed country and emerging economies. In the process of going through
various study researcher find that India as an emerging economy may replicate the
same idea as market deregulated and customer expectations are changing. For this
study, the deductive approach of study used. In the deductive approach, the
researcher develops a theory or hypothesis and then designs a strategy to test it.
Deduction is a very much planned approach in which there is the hunt to clarify
fundamental relationships and data are quantitative. The data are collected through
samples of adequately large size to simplify the results. As a part of this study some
hypotheses are formulated based on the existing literature and designed a strategy to
test them.
149
4.2.1. Exploratory Research
The exploratory research is one type of research design, which has its primary
objective the provision of insights into and comprehension of the problem situation
confronting the researcher. Exploratory research is used in case where the issue of
the study cannot be measured in a quantitative manner or where the process of
measurement cannot sensibly stand for particular qualities. Exploratory research
may also be used in cases where you must define the problem more precisely,
identify relevant courses of action, or gain additional insights before going on to
confirm findings using a conclusive design (Malhotra & Dash, 2011).
During the initial phase the research was exploratory design as researcher made an
attempt to understand the research problem while discussing the issues with few
industry experts, plociy makers and dealers/franchisee of the Oil Marketing
companies also consulted dealers to take their inputs. Thus, questionnaire was made
comprehensive covering all. aspects of brand building in petroleum retailing.
150
making. Conclusive research designs may be either descriptive or causal (Malhotra
& Dash, 2011).
The descriptive research assumes that researcher has much prior knowledge about
the problem situation. In fact, a major difference between exploratory and
descriptive research is that descriptive research is characterized by the prior /
formulation of specific hypotheses. The Descriptive research is preplanned and
structured and it is typically based on large representative samples. A descriptive
research design specifies the methods for selecting the sources of information data
(Malhotra & Dash, 2011).
151
Thus, questionnaire was made comprehensive covering all aspects of brand building
in petroleum retailing.
(Webb, 2000)Pre-testing, revision and further testing a questionnaire may very well
refine the research tool and increase the reliability of its ability to measure
consistently, but that does not necessarily mean that the validity will also be
increased.
The secondary data was collected from trade journals like Journal of Petroleum
Technology, International Petroleum Refining, DEW-Drilling & Exploration
World, Journal of Marketing etc. Data from Oil Marketing Companies (PSUs &
Private both), Research Organizations and Consulting Firms as also Government
Annual Reports like “Basic Statistics on Indian Petroleum & Natural Gas” Ministry
of Petroleum & Natural Gas etc has been utilized selectively and cautiously.
After selecting the outlets where respondents are to be met, the researcher
personally presented himself to the respondents. The selection of sample was done
at the judgmental and convenience of the researcher and respondents where select
inbound customers were approached and requested for their cooperation in filling
the questionnaire. A few of them were hesitant, another group was busy and not
able to spare time and the others responded well. Questionnaires were handed over
to the respondents and very limited intervention was there on the part of the
researcher in getting it filled. All the respondents were acknowledged then and there
itself.
4.4 Research Instruments (Questionnaire & Interview)
(Miller & Read, 1998) Good questionnaire should meet research objectives, obtain
valid and reliable data from the respondents, facilitate the interviewer’s task and
subsequent data processing and achieve and maintain the involvement of
respondents.
About 30 questions were drawn to make the questionnaire by keeping the objectives
of the study in consideration. Questions were grouped to draw quick data on the
basis of elements like Demographic Variables (questions 1-6), Consumption
Patterns, Brand Awareness and Brand Loyalty (questions 7-14), Factors Influencing
152
the Selection of Petroleum Retail Outlets (questions 15) Preferences on Non Fuel
Products (questions 16) Brand Recall(questions 17-21), Brand Communication
Variables(questions 22-24), Brand Loyalty(questions 25-27), Brand Association,
Customer Experience and Perceived Value(questions 28-30). There were questions
to which the answers were mutually exclusive and for others the answers were
equally likely (more than one option can be marked).
153
Non-probability sampling relies on the personal judgment of the researcher rather
than chance for the sample elements to get selected. Non probability samples may
yield good estimates of the population characteristics (Malhotra & Dash, 2011).
Judgmental and convenience sampling process is used as non-probability sampling
method. The initial research was to understand the management decision problem
and a qualitative exploratory research was conducted through industry expert
interviews and by interviewing dealers of oil marketing companies. Considering the
initial stage of the research and to gain in-depth understanding of the problem, non
probability sampling method has been found appropriate for the study. Judgmental
and convenience sampling has been done meticulously, considering the layout
design, ambience, location and availability of other factors at the petroleum outlets.
The turnover of automotive industry was more than 45% of the manufacturing GDP
of India during FY14. The importance of this industry to the national economy can
be seen by way of the size of its turnover compared to India’s GDP and contribution
across several other parameters:
The Indian Petroelum retailing has presence for roughly 50,000 outlets in which
IOCL leads with roughly 45.5 percent of market share followed by 20.6 percent by
BPCL and 18.4 percent by HPCL amng the PSUs outlets (Industry Performance
Review, 2015).
At present in Gujarat out of total 3042 outlets, IOCL leads with 1205 outlets
followed by BPCL WITH 695, HPCL with 676, Essar Oil Limited with 224,
154
Reliance with 223 and Shell with 19 outlets as per the IPR Feb.2015 (Industry
Perfomrance Review, 2015).
Currently in Gujarat in sales of Petrol (MS) and market share is concern, IOCL
leads with 42 percent followed by BPCL and HPCL with 23 percent each, while
Essar Oil Limited with 3.9 percent, Reliance with 2.5 percent and Shell 3.9 percent
only (Industry Perfomrance Review, 2015).
However, in Gujarat in sales of Diesel (HSD) and market share is concern, IOCL
leads with 45 percent followed by BPCL and HPCL with 22 percent each, while
Essar Oil Limited with 3.6 percent, Reliance with 2 percent only. Shell do not sell
diesel at present so no market share. However, the recent deregulation of Diesel as
well will help private OMCs to improve market share substantially (Industry
Perfomrance Review, 2015).
Gujarat is one of the developed states of India where role of branding has its own
importance due to a rich profile of the customers and presence of all Oil marketing
companies (PSU’s and Private both). PSUs have approx 3042 outlets in the state of
Gujarat. Currently Shell has its presence only in six states of India. These are
Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra, Assam & Gujarat.
Considering the presence of Shell along with other Major Players, in four major
cities of Gujarat viz Ahmedabad, Rajkot, Surat and Vadodara and as Essar and
Reliance are making efforts to settle down in these cities of Gujarat these four cities
has been primarily under the purview of the study. However, Reliance with
Jamnagar refinery which is one of the finest refineries in the Asia has also been
trying to anchor their role in the State in Petroleum retailing, Jamnagar has been
taken into the purview' of the study. Consequently, these five major cities
(Ahmedabad, Rajkot, Surat, Vadodara and Jamnagar) of Gujarat have been
identified for the field survey to accomplish the research objectives.
155
contributed by automobile companies while US$ 11 bn is contributed by
automotive component companies. Around 8% of the country’s R&D expenditure
also observed in the state and it shows improvement in fuel efficiency of passenger
vehicles resulting in fuel savings of 8.6 bn litres between FY06 and FY14
(CMIE, 2015)As per data released by the Society of Indian Automobile
Manufacturers, automobile sales grew by 8.3 per cent during 2014-15. A total of
23.3 million vehicles were sold during the year as against 21.5 million vehicles sold
during the previous year. Barring commercial vehicles, sales of all the segments
were higher during the year. Sales of passenger vehicles grew by four per cent to
3.2 million units during the year. While sales of passenger cars grew by 3.4 per
cent, that of utility vehicles grew by a faster 10.8 per cent. Two wheeler sales rose
by 9.3 per cent to 18.5 million units during the year. Sales of scooters and
motorcycles were up by 27.2 per cent and 4.3 per cent, respectively. Three wheeler
sales also grew by 12.8 per cent during the year. The commercial vehicles segment
was the only segment to post a fall. In overall data, commercial vehicle sales
declined by 1.3 per cent to 700,743 units. Although sales of medium & heavy'
commercial vehicles (M&HCVs) surged by 17.4 per cent, a 9.9 per cent fall in light
commercial vehicle (LCV) sales dragged the overall commercial vehicles segment
down.
156
4.5.4 Sample Size
Large samples give more reliable results, but it is not necessary to sample the entire
target population to achieve reliable results. To ensure proper coverage of required
information a total of 1051 customers has been surveyed. The researcher collected
data through survey from 1351 customers (220 from Ahmedabad, 188 Rajkot, 242
from Surat, 191 from Vadodara and 210 from Jamnagar).
(A.N.Sarkar, 2009) To understand the buying behavioural patterns and drivers for
petroleum and non-fuel products and services, A.T.Keamey conducted a
quantitative research with 500 consumers in Delhi (population size-1, 64, 37, 000 )
in 2009. In the same proportion, 1051 consumers were surveyed by the researcher
to study the consumer behaviour of Gujarat on branding in petro-retailing.
157
4.5.6 Data sorting, tabulation and analysis
Utmost care has been taken to avoid any data misrepresentation while compiling the
data. Responses for each question have been plotted on to prefixed tables and
tallying of the responses has been done. Data deduction has been used to arrive at
various levels of analysis. Percentage method of analysis has been used
predominantly as a tool. SPSS 17 has been used to conduct analysis of few areas
including testing of hypotheses.
Table No. 4.1: (Transport, 2015) Showing Vehicle Population (in Gujarat) as
on for the years 1999-00 to 2011-12
158
10 2009-2010 1497890 10374683 11872573
Table No. 4.2: (Transport, 2015) Showing details of Vehicle Population (in
Gujarat)types of vehicle wises as on for the years 1999-00 to 2011-12
159
Figure - 4.1: Trends in Sex Ratio in Gujarat (1901-2011)
TRENDS IN SEX RATIO 1901-2011
160
Source : (Census, 2011)
1S01 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011
161
1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011
http://censusgujarat.gov.in/Downloads/PPT/Paper-l/Paper-
1 %20of%202011 %20GUJARAT.pdf
162
Figure: 4.8 Position of Gujarat in India
163
aNSUSOrtNXOOM
164
Figure: 4.9 Map of Gujarat
PASSENGER VEHICLES
In Million Units
2009-10
2011-12
2007-08
2012-13
2013-14
2014-15
2015-16
200506
200809
200607
2010-11
2011-12
2014-10
/-OHOOZ
2015-16
2013-14
2012-13
200506
200708
200809
2010-11
165
Figure: 4.12 Production of Three Wheelers Trend (2005-2014)
............ -.........
................................................................................................................ ................-..................
0.88- uB3
0.80
0 56 0 50 Dib ......
2012-13
2008-07
2008-09
2009-10
2013-14
2014-15
2015-16
2005-08
2007-08
2011-12
2010-11
TWO WHEELERS
In Million Units
2012-13
90-9003
2006-07
2007-08
2009-10
2013-14
2014-15
2015-16
60-9003
2011-12
2010-11
166
References:
167
13. Webb, J. (2000). Questionnaires and their Design. The Marketing Review,
1,197-218.
168