Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
AND MONTENEGRO
by Mehmet Tütüncü
2017
SOTA PUBLICATIONS / SOTA YAYINLARI
Series editor: Mehmet Tütüncü
CORPUS OF TURKISH ISLAMIC INSCRIPTIONS /
<m:3ʈ;4)53ʈ<)*-4-:ʈ,ʈBʈ;ʈ
Forthcoming:
8. 5MPUM\BMSQʈJZIPQUOQT)UUIZʈ*:)0ʈ5/ʈ4RODOS
),);1¼6,)7;5)6415ʈ:);15QUIZQ-[MZTMZ·3Q\IJMTMZ·
5MbIZ\I̫TIZÜ, Haarlem 2018
9. Mehmet Tütüncü, 5IT\I¼LI<ZSʈbTMZQ5IT\I*aSm[\IL;IZIaÜ^M
5IT\I<ZS̪MPQ\TQɦQ, Haarlem 2018
10. 3MZQU<ZSUMV3IZIUIVWɦ]TTIZÜ,M^ZQ3Q\IJMTMZQ, Haarlem 2019
11. Fathi Jarray, Inscriptions des Momuments de la Regence Tunis a l’époque
Ottomane, Haarlem 2019
12. Fathi Jarray, Cadrans solaires de Tunesie, Haarlem 2012
13. 3ZWVWTWRQS<ZS1[TIU3Q\IJMTMZQ0QKZQ!\IZQPTMZQIZI[Ü
Haarlem 2019
CORPUS OF OTTOMAN INSCRIPTIONS
FROM ALBANIA AND MONTENEGRO
by Mehmet Tütüncü
<ZS^M)ZIX,VaI[Ü)ZI̫\ÜZUI5MZSMbQ
:M[MIZKP+MV\ZMNWZ<]SQ[PIVL)ZIJQK?WZTL
CORPUS OF OTTOMAN INSCRIPTIONS FROM ALBANIA
AND MONTENEGRO
MEHMET TÜTÜNCÜ
ISBN 978-90-6921-010-0
+WXaZQOP\5MPUM\<\VK
)TT ZQOP\[ ZM[MZ^ML 6W XIZ\ WN \PQ[ JWWS IVL UIa JM ZMXZWL]KML
\ZIV[TI\ML[\WZMLQVIZM\ZQM^IT[a[\MUWZ\ZIV[UQ\\MLQVIVaNWZUWZ
Ja IVa UMIV[ MTMK\ZWVQK UMKPIVQKIT XPW\WKWXaQVO IVL ZMKWZLQVO
or otherwise, without prior written permission of the publisher and
KWXaZQOP\PWTLMZ
<PMQV[KZQX\QWV[NZWU\PM6I\QWVIT)ZKPIMWTWOa5][M]UÅO[!
_MZMXPW\WOZIXPMLJa)]ZWV<IZM\PMLQZMK\WZWN 6I\QWVIT+WI[\TQVM
)OMVKa <W PQU Q[ IT[W OQ^MV \PM ZQOP\[ NWZ X]JTQKI\QWV ?Q\P PQ[
XMZUQ[[QWV_MZMXZWL]KM\PQ[XPW\W[PMZMITT\PMKWXaZQOP\[JMTWVO\W
him.
Publisher:
;7<):M[MIZKP+MV\ZMNWZ<]SQ[PIVL)ZIJQK?WZTL
Haarlem / Netherlands
Tel: + 31 23 5292883
Email: sotapublishing@gmail.com
?MJ"www.turkistan.org
Ottoman Inscriptions from Albania and Montenegro 5
Contents
Introduction 7
Second Part
Inscriptions of the cities 1732 – 1913 86
/aZWSI[\ZW-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ
3I^IRI
,MT^QVM
8MbMM>WOMT
)StIPQ[IZ3Z]RI
Berat 135
Tirana 157
<WUJ[\WVM[NZWU6I\QWVIT)ZKPIMTWOa5][M]UQV<QZIVI
ʈ̫SWLZI
3WZtM/ZQKM
8ZMbI
4QJWPW^I
Tepedelen 232
,]ZM[,ZIt
1V[KZQX\QWVWN -TJI[IV+TWKS<W_MZ
Mehmet Tütüncü 6
Third Part
1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU5WV\MVMOZW·!
1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU;\IZQ*IZ
1V[KZQX\QWVNZWU\PM.WZ\ZM[[WN mTOV
1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU8WLOWZQKI
-`IUXTM[WN <WU[J[\WVMNZWU5WVM\MVMOZW !
Tombstones from Marubi Collection 291
*QJTQWOZIXPa
+PZWVWTWOa)TJIVQI
+PZWVWTWOa5WV\MVMOZW
)J[\ZIK\QV*W[VQIV;MZJW+ZWI\QIV
Abstract in Albanian 307
)J[\ZIK\QV<]ZSQ[P
5IXQVLQKI\QVO1V[KZQX\QWV[ZMOQWVITLQ[\ZQJ]\QWV !
Ottoman Inscriptions from Albania and Montenegro 7
INTRODUCTION
7N KW]Z[M\PQ[Q[VW\ITT\PMQV[KZQX\QWV[M^MZaLIaVM_QV[KZQX\QWV[IZM
LQ[KW^MZMLQV[WUMNWZOW\\MVXTIKM[WZLMXWZ\[WN U][M]U[*]\\PQ[Q[
IVI\\MUX\\WUISMIXZW^Q[QWVITQV^MV\WZa#?PI\PI^M[]Z^Q^MLNZWU
aMIZ[WN 7\\WUIV<]ZSQ[PPMZQ\IOMIVLZ]TMQV)TJIVQI<PMZMIZM
IT[W ^MZa LIUIOML IVL MZI[ML QV[KZQX\QWV[ _PQKP KIV¼\ JM ZMIL _Q\P
VISMLMaM;W_MPI^MTMN\\PQ[]VZMILJ]\X]JTQ[PML\PMXPW\WOZIXP[
QV \PM PWXM \PI\ W]Z )TJIVQIV KWTTMIO]M[ _QTT _WZS WV \PMU _Q\P
UWZMLM^MTWXMLUM\PWL[WN TQOP\VQVO)T[W[WUMQV[KZQX\QWV[_MZMTMN\
]V\ZIV[TI\MLQV\W-VOTQ[PJMKI][MWN \PMQZXWM\Za7]ZUIQVIQU_I[\W
UISM\PMXZQUIZaUI\MZQITI^IQTIJTM[W\PI\\PM[XMKQITQ[\[KW]TL_WZS
on them.
<PM [\WVM QV[KZQX\QWV[ KIV JM LQ^QLML QV\W \_W KI\MOWZQM[" <PM
Mehmet Tütüncü 8
J]QTLQVOWZZMVM_ITQV[KZQX\QWV[WVKMZ\IQVIZKPQ\MK\]ZIT_WZS[IVL#
\WUJ[\WVMQV[KZQX\QWV[?MKW^MZIXMZQWLWN aMIZ[JM\_MMV
IVL!<PMTIVO]IOM[WN \PMQV[KZQX\QWV[IZMUIQVTa<]ZSQ[PIVLQV
\PMJMOQVVQVOXMZQWLIT[W)ZIJQK_I[][ML<PMZMQ[IT[WWVMQV[KZQX\QWV
QV\PM/ZMMSIVLWVMQV8MZ[QIV4IVO]IOM?MLQLVW\KWUMIKZW[[IVa
inscriptions in Albanian.
<PMJWWSQ[[\Z]K\]ZMLI[NWTTW_[<PMÅZ[\XIZ\KWV[Q[\[WN \_MV\aNW]Z
QV[KZQX\QWV[QV)TJIVQI<PQ[XIZ\PI[JMMVWZLMZMLKPZWVWTWOQKITTa
<PMÅZ[\\_MT^MQV[KZQX\QWV[ [\QTTM`Q[\IVLIZMUWZMWZTM[[
traceable. The second 12 inscriptions are from the years 1608 until
_PQKP IZM WVTa ZMKWZLML Ja -^TQaI iMTMJQ 6W \ZIKM WN
these inscriptions can be found.
<PMÅZ[\QV[KZQX\QWV[IZM\PMWTLM[\QV[KZQX\QWV[OZW]XML\WOM\PMZ1\Q[
ZMUIZSIJTM\PI\WVTa[M^MVWN \PM\_MV\aNW]ZQV[KZQX\QWV[IZMXZM[MZ^ML
?MSVW_WN \PMW\PMZ[WVTa\PZW]OP\PMTQ\MZI\]ZMIVL-^TQaIiMTMJQ
_PW_ZW\MLW_VQV[KZQX\QWV[WN _PQKPWVMQ[[\QTTM`\IV\<PM[IQL
QV[KZQX\QWVJMTWVO[\W;]T\IV;]TMaUIV1IVLQ[NZWU)^TWVaI>TWZx
7VMW\PMZQV[KZQX\QWVNZWU0I[IV*ITQbILM5W[Y]MQV-TJI[IVQ[
LM[\ZWaMLJ]\_MPI^MIVM`KMTTMV\XPW\WIVLKIVKWUXIZM\PM\M`\_Q\P
-^TQaIiMTMJQ¼[*W\PWN \PM[MQV[KZQX\QWV[IZMKWZZMK\TaKWXQMLJa-^TQaI
iMTMJQ?M\PMZMNWZMLQLVW\PM[Q\I\M\WQVKT]LM-^TQaIiMTMJQ¼[ZMKWZL[
in our corpus.
<PM[MKWVLXIZ\WN \PMJWWSQ[KT][\MZMLZMOQWVITTaIN\MZNWTTW_QVO
IXI\\MZVWN KQ\QM[1V[KZQX\QWV[IZMOZW]XML\WOM\PMZIKKWZLQVO\WKQ\a
TQUQ\[IVLKQ\aVMQOPJW]ZPWWL[
<PMPQMZIZKPaIUWVO\PMKQ\QM[Q[WZOIVQbML_Q\P\PMWTLM[\QV[KZQX\QWV
NW]VLQV\PMKQ\aZIVS[\PMKQ\aI[ÅZ[\[W\PMWTLM[\QV[KZQX\QWVIN\MZ
Q[NZWU-ZOQZQSI[ZQ-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ<PQ[Q[\PMÅZ[\KQ\aQV\PM[MKWVLXIZ\IVL
ITTSVW_VQV[KZQX\QWV[NZWU-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ_QTTNWTTW_PMZMKPZWVWTWOQKITTa
MIKPW\PMZ<PM[MKWVLWTLM[\QV[KZQX\QWVQ[NZWU3I^IRIM\K
<PQ[ UM\PWL WN \PM PQMZIZKPa WN \PM KQ\QM[ OQ^M[ ][ VM`\ TQ[\ WN KQ\QM[
/aZWSI[\ZW -ZOQZQSI[ZÜ 3I^IRI ,MT^QVx 8MbM M >WOMT 3Z]RI
)StIPQ[IZ<QZIVIʈ̫SWLZI3WZtx8ZMbI4QJWPW^I<MXMTMVM,]ZZM[
,ZIt-TJI[IVIVL>TWZx)^TWVaI<PQ[UM\PWLOQ^M[\PMWXXWZ\]VQ\a
\WNWTTW_KPZWVWTWOQKITTaLM^MTWXUMV\WN QV[KZQX\QWV[I[_MTTI[KQ\QM[
Ottoman Inscriptions from Albania and Montenegro 9
1V[KZQX\QWV[KIVJMOZW]XMLIT[WIJW]\\PMQZN]VK\QWVITQ\a1V[KZQX\QWV[
NZWU)TJIVQIKIVJMLQ^QLMLQVKI\MOWZQM[*]QTLQVO1V[KZQX\QWV[IVL
Tombstones.
Building inscriptions
<PM QV[KZQX\QWV[ WV J]QTLQVO[ PI^M OZMI\ PQ[\WZQKIT QUXWZ\IVKM <PMa
IZM ÅZ[\PIVL LWK]UMV\[ )VL \PMa OQ^M ]VSVW_V QVNWZUI\QWV WZ I
ZQKPMZ^QM_WN \PMIK\QWV[WN KMZ\IQVXMZ[WV[1VW\PMZKI[M[\PMaUISM
PQ[\WZaKWUMITQ^MNWZ\PMOMVMZI\QWV[WN W]ZIOMIVLOQ^M][I\I[\MWN
\PM^IVQ[PML7\\WUIVK]T\]ZM<PMQV[KZQX\QWV[IZM[WUM\QUM[\PMWVTa
M^QLMVKMWN LM[\ZWaMLJ]QTLQVO[IVLIZMIT[W[WUM\QUM[IUIVQNM[\I\QWV
WN \PMZ]TQVO;]T\IV\WUISMPQ[XZM[MVKMNMT\WV\PMNIZMLOM[WN \PM
empire. The inscriptions of the Elbasan of Fatih Sultan Mehmed, for
QV[\IVKMIZM\PMWVTaUI\MZQITM^QLMVKMWN .I\QP¼[+WVY]M[\IVL\PMa
IZMNW]VLQVOKPIZ\MZ+Q\aIVL)TJIVQI¼[7\\WUIVZ]TM
*4)+3074-*-<?--6!)6,
.ZWU\PMXMZQWLJM\_MMV!IVLVWQV[KZQX\QWVPI[[]Z^Q^ML
<PMZMI[WVNWZ\PMXPa[QKITIJ[MVKMWN \PM[MQV[KZQX\QWV[Q[]VSVW_V
Sultanic Inscriptions
There are six inscriptions that are directly ordered by Ottoman sultans.
IVLIZMQV[KZQX\QWV[NZWUMIZTaKWVY]M[\[IVLWZLMZ[NWZ\PMJ]QTLQVO
WN \PM.WZ\WN -TJI[IVJa;]T\IV5MPUML11IVL!IZMZM[XMK\Q^MTa
Mehmet Tütüncü 10
Tombstones
<PMZMIZMQV\W\IT\WUJ[\WVM[ !
!! ! IVLIZMLM[\ZWaMLJ]\SVW_VNZWU\PM
TQ\MZI\]ZM\PMZM[\Q[[\QTTXPa[QKITTaXZM[MV\<PMZMIZM\WUJ[\WVM[
_Q\P\PM<]ZJMQV[KZQX\QWV[\PQ[UISM[UWZMI[\PMPITN WN \PMKWZX][
<PMWTLM[\<WUJ[\WVMQ[LI\ML!1V[KZQX\QWVIVLQ[NZWU*MZI\
! +PZWVWTWOQKITTa \PMZM Q[ I OIX WN aMIZ[ JM\_MMV \PM
WTLM[\IVL\PM[MKWVLWTLM[\\WUJ[\WVM\PI\[]Z^Q^ML)LMU<WX\IVQ
LI\ML! NZWU3Z]RI1V[KZQX\QWV
ÿTLFOEFSJZFMJ.VTUBGB1BāB[BEF.FINFE
64 Tiran 1217 1802/03 NBSCMF *OTJUV
1BāB
65 Tiran 1235 1819/20 .PMMB5BIJS NBSCMF *OTJUV
ʈ̫SWLZI<WUJ[\WVM[
.QN\MMV \WUJ[\WVM[ NZWU ʈ̫SWLZI IZM QVKT]LML QV \PQ[ _WZS <PM[M
\WUJ[\WVM[ IZM UW[\Ta LIUIOML JZWSMV IVL JILTa XZM[MZ^ML W]Z
collection mainly contains tombstones from the 19th century. The
\WUJ[\WVM WN ;]TMaUIVQJVBMaVMT)OINZWU*IZQ[\PMJM[\XZM[MZ^ML
IVLUW[\JMI]\QN]TTa_ZQ\\MV<PMPMILOMIZQ[IT[WQV\IK\
Earlier Literature
There is not much literature about Ottoman Inscriptions in Albania.
There are four main sources.
-^TQaI iMTMJQ QV PQ[ ;MaIPI\VIUM ÅZ[\ \QUM ZMKWZLML QV[KZQX\QWV[
NZWU7\\WUIV)TJIVQI-^TQaI>Q[Q\ML)TJIVQIQVIVLPI[_ZQ\\MV
PQ[;MaIPI\VIUMQV-OaX\:WJMZ\,IVSWٺIVL:WJMZ\-T[QMX]JTQ[PML
I \ZIV[TI\QWV WN \PM )TJIVQIV \ZI^MT[ WN PQ[ *WWS WN <ZI^MT[ QV
7VTaWVMWN -^TQaI¼[ZMKWZLML1V[KZQX\QWV[PI[[]Z^Q^ML\PM]VNWZ\]VI\M
\QUM[<PQ[Q[VZQV)^TWVaI)VW\PMZWVMNZWU-TJI[IVPI^MJMMV
TW[\J]\\PMZMQ[IXPW\W\PI\_MKIVKWUXIZM_Q\P-^TQaI¼[\M`\VZ
ITTW\PMZQV[KZQX\QWV[ZMKWZLMLJa-^TQaIPI^MJMMVTW[\
2. Another author who has published Inscriptions from Albania was
.ZIVb*IJQVOMZ1VPQ[:]UMTQ[KPM;\ZMQNMVQV! PMPI[X]JTQ[PML
two inscriptions of Fatih Sultan Mehmet from Elbasan.
3. Another indispensable source for the study of Ottoman Inscriptions
Mehmet Tütüncü 12
Q[)TJIVQIV[KPWTIZ>M`PQ*]PIZIRI0MPI[ZMKWZLMLUIVaQV[KZQX\QWV[
L]ZQVO WZ JMNWZM \PM K]T\]ZIT ZM^WT]\QWV WN ! 0Q[ UIV][KZQX\ QV
6I\QWVIT 0Q[\WZa 1V[\Q\]\M ZMUIQVML ]VX]JTQ[PML 1 PI^M ][ML PQ[
UIV][KZQX\NWZ\PMTW[\QV[KZQX\QWV[IVLZMXZWL]KML[WUMXIOM[NZWUPQ[
UIV][KZQX\I[QTT][\ZI\QWV1\Q[[\QTTIXQ\a\PI\W]Z)TJIVQIVKWTTMIO]M[
PI^MVW\X]JTQ[PML\PQ[^MZaQUXWZ\IV\XZQUIZa[W]ZKMNWZ\PMPQ[\WZa
of Albania.
?MPI^MKPW[MV\WNWTTW_\PM7\\WUIV^MZ[QWVWN \PMXTIKMVIUM[.WZQV[\IVKM
-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ
WZ
-ZOQZQ
NWZ\PMUWLMZV
/aZWSI[\ZW
IVL
)^TWVaI
NWZ\PM
UWLMZV )TJIVQIV
>TWZx
WZ _M[\MZV
>ITWVI
*]\ 1 PI^M IT[W ][ML _PMV
ZMNMZZQVO \W \PM K]ZZMV\ [Q\]I\QWV IT[W \PM UWLMZV )TJIVQIV WZ 5WV\MVMOZQV
[XMTTQVO)[TWVOI[\PMZMQ[\PMZMQ[ILIVOMZWN KWVN][QWV1PI^MX]\IT[WUWLMZV
^IZQIV\WN VIUM[QVJZIKSM\[<P][)StIPQ[IZ3Z]RI7\\WUIVIVLK]ZZMV\
)TJIVQIV[XMTTQVO[WN XTIKMVIUM[IZMOQ^MVPMZM]VLMZ
ʈ̫SWLZIIT[Wʈ[SMVLMZQaM ;PSWLxZ
,ZIt ,]ZZx[
)StIPQ[IZ 3Z]RI3Z]Rx
-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ /aZWSI[\ZW
,MT^QVM ,MT^QVx
<MXMLMTMV <MXMTMVM
3WZtM/ZQtM 3WZtx
)^TWVaI >TWZx>ITWVI
mTOV =TKQVRIT[W,]TKQOVWQV1\ITQIV
7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU)TJIVQIIVL5WV\MVMOZW
)KSVW_TMLOMUMV\[
<PQ[JWWSQ[I_WZSWN KWWXMZI\QWV_Q\PV]UMZW][QVLQ^QL]IT[IVLQ\Q[
NWZUMIOZMI\XTMI[]ZM\W[\IZ\_Q\PIVIKSVW_TMLOMUMV\WN \PMUIVa
LMJ\[1W_M?Q\P\PMNMIZWN TMI^QVO[WUMWVMW]\1_W]TLNWZMUW[\TQSM
to start with two persons: Gianclaudio Macchiarella and Auron Tare. I would
TQSM\W\PIVS\PMUNWZ\PMQZKWWXMZI\QWVIVLI[[Q[\IVKMQVUaQV[KZQX\QWV
hunt in Albania and its periphery. I met Gianclaudio Macchiarella for
\PMÅZ[\\QUMQVL]ZQVOI[aUXW[Q]UWV*MS\I[PQ[UQV)TJIVQI
0M_I[ZM[MIZKPQVO\PMWTL7\\WUIVKQ\aWN ,MT^QVx_PMZMPMNW]VL
I NM_ JZWSMV \WUJ[\WVM[ ?M [XWSM IJW]\ \PM OZI\ٻQ \PI\ PM KIUM
IKZW[[QV/RQV)TM`Q¼[5W[Y]M0MQV^Q\MLUM\WOW\W,MT^QVxIVL\W
PI^MITWWSI\\PMQV[KZQX\QWV[PM[\]UJTML]XWV<PQ[_I[\PM[\IZ\WN
our cooperation which lasted until March 2015 when he passed away
]VM`XMK\MLTa <PQ[ JWWS Q[ LMLQKI\ML \W PQ[ UMUWZa 1\ _I[ \PZW]OP
Gianclaudio that I met Auron Tare who sent me inscriptions from
<MXMTMVM-ZOQZQSI[ZÜIVLW\PMZKQ\QM[\WZMIL)]ZWV¼[MV\P][QI[U_I[
QV[XQZQVO\W[Ia\PMTMI[\
METHODOLOGY: EXAMPLE:
16;+:18<176)3i)0ʈ;):3:=2)->:-6-;7ɥ4=
*QJT"1XXMV!XX5IKPQMT3QMT)TJIVQIXX !
1V[KZQX\QWVNZWU@.W]VLI\QWV1V[KZQX\QWV
1LMV\QÅKI\QWV<IJTM
After the description there is a table of 5/6 columns where the
characteristics of the inscription are summarised and the inscription is
QLMV\QÅML
1st Column+I\ITWO]MV]UJMZ
2nd column+Q\a_PMZM\PMQV[KZQX\QWVQ[KWUQVONZWU
4th Column Date <PM LI\M WN \PM QV[KZQX\QWV QV /ZMOWZQIV AMIZ
),0
5. Text. After the tables, the reproduction of the texts of the inscriptions
NWTTW_ <PM )ZIJQK WZ <]ZSQ[P \M`\ WN QV[KZQX\QWV[ IZM OQ^MV QV )ZIJ
TM\\MZ[<]ZSQ[P\M`\[IZM\ZIV[KZQJMLQV\PM<]ZSQ[P^MZ[QWVWN \PM4I\QV
ITXPIJM\*MKI][MWN \PM^IZQI\QWVWN KWV[WVIV\IVL^W_MT[QOV[QV\PM
QV[KZQX\QWV[VW\M^MZa[QOVWZLW\\PI\IZM][MLQV\PMQV[KZQX\QWV[IZM
OQ^MVJ]\IUM\PWLQ[][ML_PMZMQVITT\PMTM\\MZ[_Q\P[WUMVMKM[[IZa
^W_MT IVL KWV[WVIV\ [QOV[ W^MZ \PMU IZM OQ^MV .WZ \PM NMI\]ZM[ WN
\PMKITTQOZIXPaIVL^W_MTWZKWV[WVIV\UIZSMZ[WVMKIVTWWSI\\PM
reproduction of the inscriptions.
(Inscriptions 1-24)
Mehmet Tütüncü 18
*QJT"1XXMV!XX5IKPQMT3QMT)TJIVQIXX !
.QO.W]V\IQVWN -^ZMVW[*MOQV3Z]RI)StIPQ[IZ
.QO1V[KZQX\QWVJa-^ZMVW[*MOWTLM[\7\\WUIV\ZIKMQV)TJIVQI
Ottoman Inscriptions from Albania and Montenegro 19
Text:
sahibü’l-hayrat
^Mb{Z¼TI¼bQUOIbQ
-^ZMVW[[MVM
<pZQPQ\I¼UQZQKML{L
Fi sene 1125
Translation:
<PMW_VMZWN OWWLLMML[
IVL\PM/ZMI\>QbQMZ
-^ZMVW[QV\PMaMIZ
The date of repair 1125
1XXMVIVL_Q\PPQU3QMTZMIL[J]\Q\Q[KTMIZTa^Q[QJTM\PI\JM\_MMV
IVL\PMZMQ[VWÅO]ZM;W\PMQV[KZQX\QWVKIVWVTaJMNZWU\PMaMIZ
,WK]UMV\-!!.ZWU<WXSIXQ8ITIKMQ[ITWVOTIZOMIVLMTMOIV\Ta
written document of 22 lines. The upper section, which probably
KWV\IQVML\PM\]OPZIIVLILLZM[[MMWN \PMLWK]UMV\Q[UQ[[QVO
General Info
Document is written on the occasion of the Conquest of Kruja in 1478.
1\Q[LI\MLI\\PMMVLQV\PM)ZIJQK[a[\MU:MJQ]T[IVQ_Q\PW]\OQ^QVO
an explicit year. But from the content we can deduct that this year is
Hijri 883 or 1478. Therefore, the document is dated 5 July 1478.
"%
$ISJTUJBO$BMFOEBS ")
.VTMJN$BMFOEBS
%BZ
.POUI +VMZ 5VFTEBZ
3BCJVMBIJS
:FBS
0W_Q\_I[LQ[KW^MZMLIVLLMKQXPMZML
<PMLWK]UMV\_I[NWZ\PMÅZ[\\QUMUMV\QWVMLJa<IP[QVlb<WXSIXÜ
;IZIaÜ5bM[Q)Z̫Q^QVLM.I\ÜP11;]T\IV5MPUMLM)Q\JMTOMTMZ*MTTM\MV
!XX!XIOM
He notes that it is a document about the conquest of Kruja Castle and
\PI\\PM]XXMZXIZ\Q[UQ[[QVO
1\ _I[ N]Z\PMZ VM^MZ UMV\QWVML QV \PM TQ\MZI\]ZM 1V I LQ[K][[QWV _Q\P
Auron Tare I mentioned this document and indicated that this could
PI^MLM\IQT[IJW]\\PMKWVY]M[\)N\MZWJ\IQVQVOIKWXaWN \PMLWK]UMV\
LMKQXPMZQVOZMUIQVMLIOZMI\\I[S1\_I[_ZQ\\MVQVI[\aTMIVLTIVO]IOM
that was not easily decipherable by most experts. Ultimately Professor
<PIKS[\WV?PMMTMZNZWU\PM0IZ^IZL=VQ^MZ[Q\a_I[IJTM\WLMKQXPMZ
\PMLWK]UMV\IVLXZW^QLM][_Q\PI\ZIV[TI\QWVWN \PMKWV\MV\
Content
Mehmet Tütüncü 296
.QO8PW\WNZWU5IZ]JQ+WTTMK\QWV
Ottoman Inscriptions from Albania and Montenegro 297
Text:
<p-bMTLMV
4M^PQSILMZLMJ]aIbÜTUÜ̫JI̫ÜUI
-KMT[M^SMaTMUQ̫JMVQLIɦTIZJI̫ÜVI
*QZV
ZIMZQ[QXIUIV[ÜbSITLÜU
<IPIUUTMLMUMaQXVQPpaM\LVLU
*]NIVQLVaILIVtÜS]XS]Z\]TL]U
0MVbSILMUJI[UÜ̫QLQU[MSQbaI̫ÜVI
)VVMUJIJIUISZIJITIZIɦTI̫\ÜTIZJI̫ÜUI
3IZLM̫TMZ]V]\UIa]JaIb[ÜVUMbIZ
\I̫ÜUI
;MZ\NMVSQPIbZM\Q̫MPZQaIZQLMV
U̫QZLM^TM\T\IPQZXI̫I^M
\NMVSTPIbZM\Q̫MPZQaIZQLMV
5QZITIa1bbM\TA][]N JMɦ
MNMVLQVQVPMU̫QZMTMZQ0IVQNMPIVÜUÜV
ruhuna fatiha sene
Translation:
<PQ[_I[UaLM[\QVa_ZQ\\MVQV\PMJWWSWN LMKQ[QWV[
1_I[[MVL\W\PMPQOPUW]V\IQV[\WLQM\PMZM
1_I[KI]OP\JaITQOP\_PQKPNI[KQVI\MLUM
I could not endure and therefore returned
1TMN\\PQ[]V\PIVSN]T?WZTLIVL[I^MLUa[MTN
I was only 8 years old when I died,
5aNI\PMZIVLUW\PMZPI^MUW]ZVMLNWZUM
5aJZW\PMZPI^M_ZQ\\MV\PQ[
Stone
0IVQNM0IVÜU[Q[\MZWN
+WTWVMTA][]N *MɦNZWU\PM1UXMZQITZQÆM\ZWWX[
IVL5IZ[PITTLM^TM\T<IPQZ8I̫IPMILWN \PM1UXMZQITZQÆM\ZWWX[
Read a fatiha for her soul
<Py[Q[IT[WI^MZaZMUIZSIJTM\WUJ[\WVM1\Q[NWZI_WUIVOQZT_PW
XI[[ML^MZaMIZTaI\IVIOMWN ;PM_I[[Q[\MZWN \_WNIUW][7\\WUIV
7ٻKMZ[5IZ[PITT<IPQZ8I̫IIVL5QZITIaKWTWVMTA][]N JMɦ<PMa
PI^MPWVW]ZMLPMZ_Q\PI^MZaZM^WT]\QWVIZa\WUJ[\WVM?PQKPKWV[Q[\[
WN XIZ\[7VMXIZ\]XXMZXIZ\KWV[Q[\[WN IVMTMOa[XMKQIT_ZQ\\MVNWZ
Mehmet Tütüncü 298
her, the second part is written inside the form of a portrait of a womens
JWLa _PQKP [aUJWTQbM[ 0IVQNM PIVQU <PM \ZIV[Q\QWV JM\_MMV \PM
XIZ\[KWV[Q[\[WN I[QUXTM?WZL
Ua[\WVM
_PQKPQ[\PMTI[\?WZLWN
\PMMTMOa
.QO8PW\WNZWU5IZ]JQ+WTTMK\QWV
Ottoman Inscriptions from Albania and Montenegro 299
Text:
̪MPQL5IɦN]Z
iI^]̫<WXt]
°
)PUML-UQVJMɦ
Ruhuna Fatiha
;MVM°
Translation:
5IZ\aZIVLZMKMQ^MZWN OWL[UMZKa
+PI^][WN IZ\QTTMZa)PUM\MUQV*Mɦ
Read a fatiha for his soul
AMIZ°
5MPUM\<\VK
6. Bibliography:
-^TQaIiMTMJQ)TJIVQI,IVSWٺ:-T[QM:-L[-^TQaIiMTMJQQV)TJIVQI
IVLILRIKMV\ZMOQWV[3W[W^W5WV\MVMOZW7PZQL<PMZMTM^IV\[MK\QWV[WN \PM;MaIPI\VIUI
MLQ\ML_Q\P\ZIV[TI\QWVKWUUMV\IZaIVLQV\ZWL]K\QWV>WT>4MQLMV*W[\WV3TV
,MVS\I̫!!5][\INI,MVS\I̫3IZIUIV¼LISQ3TI[QS,M^QZ7[UIVTÜ+IUÜTMZQ>ISÜÆIZ
Dergisi @@>!![ !8TI\M
,MVS\I̫5][\INI,MVS\I̫3IZIUIViM̫UMTMZQ3Ü^ÜTKÜUAIaÜVTIZÜ3Ia[MZQ[
<\VK5MPUM\!¹;MaIPI\VIUM¼LM3Q\IJMTMZ^M-^TQaI¼VÜV0I\\p\^M0ISSpSTÜɦÜ
0ISSÜVLIº=4=;4):);1->4ʈA)i-4-*ʈ>-;-A)0)<6)5-;-587BA=5=6Q[IV
)VSIZI<ZSQaMAIaÜV"iIɦÜVÜV;ÜZILÜ̫ÜAIbIZÜ-^TQaIiMTMJQ0IbÜZTIaIV6]ZIV<MbKIV
AIXÜ3ZMLQaIaÜVTIZÜ1[\IVJ]T![!
<\VK5MPUM\
7V\PM<ZIQTWN -^TQaIiMTMJQ[1V[KZQX\QWV[IVL/ZI\\ٻQ
A
UIZQ][Y]MILUIZM+]T\]ZITM^Q[]ITMMUI\MZQITMLITT)LZQI\QKWITT1VLQI;KZQ\\QQVUMUWZQILQ/QIVKTI]LQW
Macchiarella, IK]ZILQ5I\\QI/]QLM\\QM;IZI5WVLQVQ-]ZI[QI\QKI-LQbQWVQ+I.W[KIZQ
>MVMbQI+INW[KIZQX
?Q\\MS8I]T!¹-QVM_MQ\MZM¹1V[KZQN\ºLM[-^TQapiMTMJQº<ZSQaI\5M[KU]I[Ü@1>!
[
A3A!! 1@-^TQapiMTMJQ;MaIPI\VIUM0IbÜZTIaIVTIZ;MaQ\)TQ3IPZIUIV
AKMT,IɦTÜ:WJMZ\,IVSWٺAIXÜ3ZMLQAIaÜVTIZÜ1@+QT\ʈ[\IVJ]T!!
BIZbaKSQ !5^BIZbaKSQ-)ZVL\^M/^;\ZI\QUQZW^QK¹,QM)TILïI5W[KPMMQV
.WȔIº?Q[[MV[KPIN\TQKPM5Q\\MQT]VOMVI][*W[VQMV]VL0MZKMOW^QVI11*IVL?QMV ![
5MPUM\<\VK
Chronology - Albania
Chronology number Inscription number Year
1. )SKIPQ[IZ3Z]RI-^ZMVM[WOT].W]V\IQV VZ
2. -TJI[IV.WZ\ZM[[;]T\IV5MPUML VZ
3. -TJI[IV.WZ\ZM[[;]T\IV5MPUML VZ
4. 4M[P.WZ\ZM[[;]T\IV;]TMaUIV VZ !
5. )SKIPQ[IZ6I[]PJMO VZ
6. ʈ̫SWLZI5][M]U=TIUI*Ma0IUIUQ VZ !!
7. )^TWVaI;]T\IV;]TMaUIV5W[Y]M VZ !!
8. )^TWVaI1TaI[8I[I.W]V\IQV VZ ! !
9. Kanina Fortress nr. 9
10. *MZI\=bO]Z5W[Y]M VZ !
11. *MZI\<WUJ[\WVM VZ !!
12. -TJI[IV0I[IV*ITQbILM5W[Y]M VZ
13. -TJI[IV+MTMJÜMNMVLÜ5MbIZ\I[Ü VZ
14. *MZI\3I[ÜU)OI.W]V\IQV VZ
15. -TJI[IV5QUIZUMPUML)OI.W]V\IQV VZ
16. Berat Saat Mosque Huseyin pasa nr. 16 1071 1660/61
17. -TJI[IV;QVIV8I̫I5W[Y]M VZ
18. -TJI[IVAIPaIJMObILM<]ZJM[Q VZ
19. Elbasan taríhi Taun nr. 19 ***
20. -TJI[IV>ISÜbILM\]ZJM[Ü VZ
21. 8MSQVPIZQ[bILM5W[Y]MH VZ
22. 8MSQV)JL]ZZIPUIV8I̫I5W[Y]M VZ
23. -ZOQZQSI[ZÜ;]T\IV*IaMbQL5W[Y]M VZ 3IVLQaMSIbI[Ü
24. *MZI\0][MaQVXI[I5W[Y]M VZ
25. -ZOQZQSI[ZÜ<MSSM5W[Y]M VZ '''
26. 3I^IRI3]JJMTQ5W[Y]M VZ
27. ,MT^QVI*IJI)bQb<MSSM VZ !
28. -ZOQZQSI[ZÜ8IbIZ5W[Y]M VZ
29. 8MbMM>WOMT5W[Y]M VZ
30. -ZOQZQSI[ZÜ0I[IV0IT^M\Q<MSSM VZ
31. )SKIPQ[IZ5][\INI*IJI,WTTUI<]ZJM VZ !!
32. *MZI\0IT^M\Q<MSSM VZ !
33. )SKIPQ[IZ)LMU)OI<WX\IVQ<WUJ[\WVM VZ !
34. ʈ̫SWLZI<WUJ[\WVM VZ !!
35. <QZIVI-\PMU*Ma5W[Y]M VZ !!
36. *MZI\<WUJ[\WVM VZ !!!
37. ,MT^QVI<WUJ[\WVM VZ !!
38. ʈ̫SWLZI<WUJ[\WVM VZ! !!
39. <QZIVIUMbIZSQ\IJM[Q VZ!
40. <QZIVI<WUJ[\WVM VZ
41. ʈ̫SWLZI<WUJ[\WVM VZ !
42. ʈ̫SWLZI<WUJ[\WVM VZ !
43. )SKIPQ[IZ5][\INI*IJI,WTTUI<]ZJM VZ
44. ʈ̫SWLZI0IKQ0IUbI<]ZJM VZ
45. ʈ̫SWLZI<WUJ[\WVM VZ
46. 3I^IKI+TWKS<W_MZ VZ
47. Tepelene Castle nr. 104 1819
48. <QZIV3IXTIV8I[I<]ZJM[Q VZ !
49. <QZIV<WUJ[\WVM VZ !
50. <QZIV-\PMU*Ma5W[Y]M VZ
7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU)TJIVQIIVL5WV\MVMOZW
Chronology Montenegro
*IZ2]LOM.W]V\IQVVZ
*IZ*IZ]\PIVMXW_LMZ0W][MVZ
*IZ*IZ]\PIVMXW_LMZPW][MVZ !
Bar Sultan Ahmed Mosque nr. 118 1122 1711/12
mTOV.WZ\ZM[[VZ!
mTOV.W]V\IQVWN ;S]ZIVZ !
Bar Fountain inside Fortress nr. 121 1169 1756/57
*IZ;SIVRM^QK5W[Y]MVZ !
8WLOWZQKI5W[Y]MVZ
Ujemira Fountain nr. 124 1330 1911/12
5MPUM\<\VK
7^ISVRQOIWJRMLQVR]RMVI\XQ[MQbXMZQWLIW[UIV[SM)TJIVQRMBJQZSI]OTI^VWU
]STR]Ȕ]RMVI\XQ[MVISIUMV]VMSMLZ^MVMVI\XQ[M\MUITQJZWROZIÅ\I6I\XQ[QVI
SIUMV]UWO][MXWLQRMTQ\Q]L^QRMSI\MOWZQRM"
VIOZIŋM^QVIUIQTQWJVW^TRMVQVI\XQ[QVIXWRMLQVQUIZPQ\MS\WV[SQULRMTQUI
VILOZWJVQVI\XQ[QSWRQXWSZQ^IR]ZIbLWJTRMWLOWLQVI\RQbUMŋ]Q!
OWLQVM
3VRQOIRM[\Z]S\]ZQZIVIVI[TRMLMȎQVIȔQV8Z^QLQW[M[I[\WRQWLL^ILM[M\QȔM\QZQ
VI\XQ[IQbXZ^WOZIbLWJTRIW[UIV[SM^TILI^QVM])TJIVQRQWLLW
OWLQVM7^IRLQWRMPZWVWTWíSQXWZMLIV8Z^QPL^IVIM[\VI\XQ[I QLITRM
XW[\WRMQUWO][M]OTI^VWUXZWVIȎQ;TQRMLQQPLZ]OQPL^IVIM[\VI\XQ[I
SWRQ[]M^QLMV\QZIVQ[IUWWL[\ZIVMX]\WXQ[KI-^TQRMȓMTMJQRM
=LZ]OWULQRMT][]VI\XQ[QVISWVOWLQVM7^LRMRM]ZMOQWVITVQU[UQ[TWU
XZIȎMVIX]\IVRIOZILW^I6I\XQ[Q[]OZ]XQZIVQ[PWLVWOZIVQKIUIOZILW^IQOZIL[
SQUȔM\^Z\QUI0QRMZIZPQRI]V]\IZ[IUQPOZILW^IRMXW[\I^TRMVI\ISWLI[]VIR[\IZQRQ
VI\XQ[QXZWVIŋMV]VMSWUOZIL]Q[\Q[\I^TRITQVIXZ^WURM[\WQ\ISWZMLWU<ISWVI
R[\IZQRQVI\XQ[VISWV OWLQVMSWRQXW\QȔMQbOZILI-ZOQZQSI[ZQ/aZWSI[\ZW7^IR
OZILRMVIXZ^WUURM[\]]LZ]OWULQRMT]SVRQOM)[^QLZ]OQXWbVI\QVI\XQ[QQbVRMOI
XZI\Q\MPZWVWTWíSQRMLVQLZ]OM,Z]OQVIR[\IZQRQVI\XQ[RMQb3I^IRMQ\L
7^IUM\WLIPQRMZIZPQRMOZILW^ILIRMVIU[TRMLMȎQXWXQ[OZILW^I"
/aZWSI[\ZW3I^IRI,MT^QVI8MbMM>WOMT)SȔMPQ[IZ3Z]RI<QZIVI;SILIZ/WZȔM
3WZKI8ZMbI4QJWPW^I<MXMTMVM,ZIȔ,]ZZM[-TJI[IVIVL)^TWVaI>TWZI
7^IUM\WLIXWZMLW[\ITWOIXZ]ïIVIUUWO]ȎVW[\LI[TQRMLQUWQLIXZI\QUW
PZWVWTWíSQZIb^WRVM[IUWVI\XQ[I^MȎQ[IUQPOZILW^I
=XW[MJVWUXWOTI^TR][]]STR]ȔMVQVI\XQ[QMXQOZIÅQb+ZVM/WZMSWRQ[]VI[\ITQ]
W[UIV[SWUZIbLWJTRILWSRMWVIJQTILQWXZW^QVKQRM;SILIZ1b+ZVM/WZMRM]S]XVW
]STR]ȔMVWVI\XQ[IMXQOZINI[IPQ[\WZQR[SQPWJRMSI\IQ VI\XQ[IMXQOZINI[IVIL
OZWJVQP[XWUMVQSI3IWXZQTWO[]LWLIVMQNW\WOZIÅRMVILOZWJVQPXTWȔIQbJWOI\M
5IZ]JQNW\WOZIN[SMSWTMSKQRM12
7^ISVRQOIXZ]ïI[^MWJ]P^I\IVXWOTML[^QP^Z[\IVI\XQ[I7L^ZTWJWOI\QPLWRISW
W[S]LVQPWLSWUXTQSW^IVQPLWVIRW[VW^VQRQPQVIRRMLVW[\I^VQRQPMTMUMVI\ISITQOZI
ÅRMWLSZITRM^[SQPLWX]ȔSQP\MWLXMZbQR[SQPLWIZIX[SQPLW\]Z[SQPXWMUIQXWMbQRM
<WLIRMUWO]ȎVW[\LI[MW[RM\QW[RMȎIR^QíMRMbQȔVMI\UW[NMZM]7[UIV[SWR)TJIVQRQ
SWRIRMXW[\WRITI[^MLW!OWLQVM
8ZM^MW"5]PIUML>ITRM^IK
11 5MPUM\<]\]VLï]RMZWŋMV!OWLQVM]3IZIUIV]<]Z[SI<ZMV]\VWïQ^QQZILQ]0WTIVLQRQ
,QXTWUQZIWRMVI-SWVWU[SWUNIS]T\M\]=VQ^MZbQ\M\I)U[\MZLIU8WZML\WOIí\WOIRM!!OWLQVMW[VW^IW
\ZMV]\VWWJVIíIN]VSKQR]LQZMS\WZIQ[\ZIïQ^IȔSWOKMV\ZI;7<);7<)RM[SZIȎMVQKIQb^MLMVIWLXWȔM\VQP[TW^I
PWTIVL[SMSZI\QKM¹.WVLIKQRIbIQ[\ZIïQ^IVRIVIXWLZ]ȔR]\]Z[SWOQIZIX[SWO[^QRM\I¹<ZMV]\VWQUI^TI[\Q\I
Q[\ZIïQ^IVRIQZIbTQȔQ\MX]JTQSIKQRMW[TRMLMȎQU\MUIUI"7[UIV[SQ*ITSIV;ZMLWbMUTRMQ;ZMLVRQ1[\WS
12 =PQ[\WZQRQITJIV[SMNW\WOZIÅRMVIRXWbVI\QRIRM¹LQVI[\QRIº5IZ]JQ=OZIL];SILIZ]VIWJITQ
;SILIZ[SWO2MbMZIȔ]^I[M^MTQSISWTMSKQRISWRIJZWRQ^QíMWLNW\WOZIÅRI.W\W\MSI5IZ]JQ6IR[\IZQRM
NW\WOZIÅRMLI\QZIR]QbXMZQWLI · !8QM\ZW5IZ]JJQ\ITQRIV[SQ[TQSIZQNW\WOZINRM bJWO
XWTQ\QȔSQPXZWJTMUIMUQOZQZIW])TJIVQR]]SWRWRRMXWSZMV]WXW[IWNW\WOZINISWRQ[MXZW\MOV]WSZWbȔIS\ZQ
generacije.
7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU)TJIVQIIVL5WV\MVMOZW
4QJZQx[P\xQ[\Z]S\]Z]IZ[QUxXW[P\x8RM[IMXIZxXxZJxPM\VOIVRxbM\MSI\xZ
UJQ[PSZQUM \x XMZQ]LPx[ [x XIZx \x []VLQUQ\ W[UIV Vx ;PYQXxZQ VOI
^Q\QLMZQVx^Q\QV3RWXRM[xx[P\xZMVLQ\]ZVxUxVaZxSZWVWTWORQSM
,aUJxLPRM\x UJQ[PSZQUM\ M XIZI MSbQ[\WRVx MVLM LPM RIVx XIS
I [P]Ux \x OR]ZU]M[PxU VLxZ[I LaUJxLPRM\x UJQ[PSZQUM\ M \RMZI
VLxZURM\^Q\M^M RIVx\xZMORQ[\Z]IZI^M\xUVOI-^TQIiMTMJQ]
8RM[IMLa\xRIVxUJQ[PSZQUMYxLI\WRVxXI[^Q\Q\\xKQTx\QSMUQZMVLQ\]Z
[QUJI[SZIPQVI^MLPMYa\M\M^M5JQ[PSZQUM\RIVx\xOZ]X]IZI[xJI[PS]VxJIbx
\xS]ÅR^M\xYa\M\M^MIXW\xTIORM^M\xKIS\]IZI:MVLQ\RIJxPM\SZWVWTWORQSQ[P\
VOI Ux Q PMZ[PUQ LMZQ \MS Ux Q ^WVQ 3x[P\] UJQ[PSZQUQ Ux Q ^RM\xZ XI[ ^Q\Q\
x[P\xVOI/RQZWSI[\ZI3ax[P\xYa\M\QQXIZxVxXRM[xVMLa\xLPM\xORQ\PI
UJQ[PSZQUM\MVRWP]ZIVOI/RQZWSI[\ZIQSMUQ^MVLW[xSZWVWTWORQSQ[P\VRxZQXI[
\RM\ZQ\5JQ[PSZQUQQLa\xUxQ^RM\xZx[P\xVOI3I^IRIM\R
3RW UxVaZx M ZMVLQ\RM[ VI RMX TQ[\xV M UxXW[P\UM \x Ya\M\M^M" /RQZWSI[\xZ
3I^IRx,MT^QVx8MbxM>WOxT3Z]Rx<QZIVx;PSWLxZ3WZtx8ZMbx4QJWPW^x
<MXMTMVx ,]ZZx[ -TJI[IV LPM >TWZx 3RW UM\WLx VI U]VLx[WV \¼Q XxZKRMTTQU
SZWVWTWORQSQ[P\[QbP^QTTQUQVMUJQ[PSZQUM^MI[P\]MLPMI\x\xYa\M\M^M
6x VRx SIXQ\]TT \x ^MtIV\x RIVx XxZN[PQZx UJQ[PSZQUM VOI 5ITQ Q BQ Q KQTQ ORI\x
XMZQ]LPx[W[UIVMJxV\MXRM[xVx8ZW^QVKxVM;PSWLZx[6OI5ITQQBQXxZN[PQPMV
UJQ[PSZQUM^MXZI[PIZSQ\MS\WVQSMLPM UJQ[PSZQUMO]Zx^IZZM[P;Q[P\WRKx
XxZN[PQPMVNW\WOZIÅO]Zx^IZZM[PVOISWTMS[QWVQQXI[]ZNW\WOZIÅSQ5IZ]JQ\
4QJZQ RMX VRx XI[YaZx XIVWZIUQSM \x \x ORQ\PI TTWRM^M \x UJQ[PSZQUM^M 6OI
UJQ[PSZQUM\Ux\x\PRM[P\I\MSUx\xLM\IR]IZI\VOII\WUMSITQOZIÅ\x\PRM[P\x
\MSI\WUMSITQOZIÅUx\xVLxZTQS]IZVOI[PSZQUM\VxOR]PxVMWJWZZQ\XMZIVLWZIS
LMZQ\MSI\W\x[P\ZM[I^M\x\PRM[P\IVOIXWMbQ\xVxXMZ[Q[P\\MSI\WVx\]ZYQ[P\
LPMIZIJQ[P\L]SMLPxVxSx[P\]VRxVLRM[Q\xXZMS[PUM\xI\UW[NMZx[[xTIZUQ[x
OR]Px[WZM\x;PYQXxZQ[x7[UIVMLMZQVx^Q\QV!
Përkhtim: Ardian Muhaj
*]SQ\IX)ZVI^]\T]S¼\IJ]T]VIV7[UIVTÜSQ\IJMTMZQVQVJQZ\WXT]aIaÜVÜLÜZ
3Q\IJMTMZQVJaStWɦ]VT]ɦ]\I̫JQZSIt\IVM[Q\IP\IbMZQVÜMaIbÜTUÜ̫^MJQZ
SItMT^ML]^IZaIbUI[ÜOZI\ٻWLIJ]T]VUIS\ILÜZ
<I̫SQ\IJMTMZQSQSÜ[UIIaZÜTUIS\ILÜZ5QUIZQM[MZTMZQVaIXÜU^MaIaMVQTMV
UM[Q^M[QTM[QaTMaIbÜTIVaIXÜSQ\IJMTMZQ^M5MbIZ\I̫ÜSQ\IJMTMZQ
<WXTIUWTIZISaÜTÜVLIV!aÜTÜVISILIZaÜTTÜS[ZMV7[UIVTÜ
LM^ZQVMIQ\\WXTIUSQ\IJMJ]ZILIaIaÜVTIVUIS\ILÜZ
3Q\IJÜVaIXÜ[Ü̫]̫MSQTLMLQZ"
1TSJTUSZWVWTWRQSWTIZISaÜTTIZÜVIIQ\\WXTIUSQ\IJMLMV
WT]̫U]̫\]Z aÜTTIZÜVLIaIbÜTUÜ̫^M7[UIVTÜVÜVQTSLM^ZM[QVQV
aVM\QKQTMZQ^M;]T\IVTIZÜVIIQ\\WXTIUSQ\IJMPITIUM^K]\\]Z
aÜTTIZÜVIIQ\SQ\IJMLMVQ[M[ILMKM-^TQaIiMTMJQVQV[MaIPI\VIUM[QVLM
aIbÜTLÜɦÜQtQVPIJMZLIZWT]aWZ]b
ʈSQVKQJTUQ[M!SQ\IJMJ]T]VUIS\ILÜZ*]JTULMSZWVWTWRQSÜ[UMV
\MZSMLQTUQ̫^MaÜTÜVLIV[WVZIaIbÜTUÜ̫SQ\IJMTMZ̫MPQZTMZMOZM
[ÜZITIVUÜ̫\ÜZ)ZVI^]\T]S¼\IaÜTÜVLVI[WVZIJ]T]VIVMVM[SQSQ\IJM
-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ̫MPZQVLMVLQZ-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ̫MPZQVQJIbITIZISJ]̫MPQZ^MtM^ZM[
QVLMSQSQ\IJMTMZaIbÜTUÜ̫\ÜZ-ZOQZQSI[ZܼVLIV[WVZI\IZQPQMVM[SQSQ\IJMQ[M
3I^IRI¼LILÜZ>MJ]̫MSQTLM̫MPQZTMZJQZJQZTMZQVQ\ISQXM\UMS\MTMZ*aTMKM
aIbÜTIVSQ\IJMTMZQV̫MPQZTMZMOZM[ÜZITIUI[Ü̫]̫MSQTLMLQZ-ZOQZQSI[ZÜ3I^IKI
,MT^QVI8MbMM>WOMT)StMPQ[IZ3Z]RI<QZIVIʈ̫SWLZI/ZtM3WZKI
8ZMbI4QJWPW^I<MXMLMTMV,ZIt,]ZZM[-TJI[IV^M)^TWVaI*aTMKM
)ZVI^]\T]S̫MPQZTMZQVLMSQ\IJMTMZQV\IZQPQOMTQ̫UM[QVQ\ISQXM\UMSQUSIVÜ
WTUIS\ILÜZ)aZÜKI)ZVI^]\T]S\IZQPQVLMVMUTQJQZZWTWaVIUÜ̫WTIV<M
XMLMTMVTQ)TQ8I̫I^MWɦ]TTIZÜVÜVʈ[\IVJ]T¼LISQUMbIZ\I̫TIZÜIaZÜJQZJI̫TÜS
PITQVLMJ]JTUV[WV]VIQTI^MMLQTUQ̫\QZ
3Q\IJÜV*TUQ[M aÜTÜVISILIZʈ̫SWLZI[IVKIɦÜVIJIɦTÜWTIZIS
aVM\QTUQ̫WTIV3IZILIɦÜV/VMa\IZINÜVLISQ*IZmTOV^M8WLOWZQKI
SQ\IJMTMZQVLMVWT]̫UIS\ILÜZ3IZILIɦ¼LIVaIXÜUSQ\IJM[QJ]T]VU]̫^M
J]VTIZI UMbIZ\I̫ÜZVMɦQITÜVUÜ̫\ÜZ3Q\IJÜV[WVJTUVLMQ[M)ZVI^]\
T]S\IUM̫P]ZNW\WɦZINtÜ5IZ]JQIQTM[QVQVSWTTMS[QaWVTIZÜVLIJ]T]VIV\IVM
UMbIZ\I̫ÜZVMɦQSWVU]̫\]Z
3Q\IXJ]̫MSTQaTM7[UIVTÜ)ZVI^]\T]S¼]V]VbMVOQV\IZQPQVLMVSM[Q\TMZ
[]VUIS\ILÜZBMVOQV^MNISQZSIZUI̫ÜS^MJI[Q\SITQOZIÅ8ILQ̫IPTIZIIQ\
SQ\IJMTMZLMVaWS[]TTIZIIQ\UMbIZ\I̫TIZÜ<ZStMaWɦ]VWTUISTIJQZTQS\MQTS
LM^QZTMZLMIZIXtIaI^M[WVLM^QZTMZLM.IZ[KITQ[IVS]TTIVÜUÜLIJ]VIMSTMVM
JQTQZ*]̫MSTQaTMJ]ZILISQSQ\IJMTMZ!aÜTÜVISILIZLM^IUMLMV7[UIVTÜ
)ZVI^]\T]ɦ]V]VtWSLQTTQtWSST\ZT^MSWbUWXWTQ\PI^I[ÜVÜIS[M\\QZUMS\M
dir.
7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU)TJIVQIIVL5WV\MVMOZW
7\\W
7\ \WUI
\WUIV
UI V1V
V 1V[K
1V[KZQ
[KZQX\
ZQX\QW
X\QWV[
QWV[N
V[ NZW
N ZWU
ZWU)T
U )TJI
)TJIVQ
JIVQI
VQ IIV
IIVL
IVL5W
L5WV\
5WV\MV
V\ MVMO
MV MOZW
MO ZW !!
5MPUM\<\VK
5MPU
5MPUM\<
PU <\
<\V
\ VK
V
7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU)TJIVQIIVL5WV\MVMOZW
7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[
V[N
V[ NZW
N ZWU)TJIVQIIVL5WV\MVMO
ZW MOZW
MO ZW
Short biography:
5MPUM\<\VKIOZIL]I\MNZWU)U[\MZLIU=VQ^MZ[Q\a
in 1988. He is the chairman of Research Centre for Tur
SQ[PIVL)ZIJQK_WZTLQV6M\PMZTIVL[<PQ[ZM[MIZKPKMV\ZM
studies the Ottoman empire and its European, Asian and
)NZQKIVXZW^QVKM[0MQ[\PMMLQ\WZWN <]ZSQ[P1[TIUQK1V
[KZQX\QWV[[MZQM[WN \PMZM[MIZKP+MV\ZM0M_WZS[K]ZZMV\Ta
WV7\\WUIV5MLQ\MZZIVMIV*ITSIV[IVL6WZ\P)NZQKIIVL
western relations.
MUIQT"U\]\]VK](OUIQTKWU
Selected Publications:
*WWS["
1. 5MPUM\<\VKML+I]KI[][?IZIVL
Peace, Haarlem, 1998
2. 5MPUM\<\VKML<]ZSQ[P2M_Q[P
-VKW]V\MZ[";\]LQM[WV<]ZSQ[P2M_Q[P
:MTI\QWV[\PZW]OP\PM)OM[0IIZTMU
3. 5MPUM\<\VK<]ZSQ[P2MZ][ITMU
!7\\WUIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWU
Jerusalem and Other Palestinian Cities,
Haarlem, 2006
4. 5MPUM\<\VK<]ZSQ[P8ITM[\QVM
!!)aa]JQL5IUT]SIVL7\\W
UIV1V[KZQX\QWV[NZWUIT3PITQT0MJZWV
Nabi Musa, and other Palestinan Cities,
Haarlem, 2008
5. 5MPUM\<\VK+MbIaQZ¼LM7[UIVTÜ
ʈbTMZQaÜTTÜS<ZS0ISQUQaM\QVLMV
+MbIaQZLMV3Q\IJMTMZ-[MZTMZ8WZ\ZMTMZ
ʈ[\IVJ]T
6. De Prins en de Pasja, 400 jaar Nederland
<]ZSQRM<PM8ZQVKMIVL8I[PI8ZMV[^M
8I̫I_Q\P0][MaQV;MVIVL0IVVWLM
>ZQM[,MV0IIO
7. Mehmet Tütüncü, Ottoman Inscriptions
QV*ITSIV[IVL+MV\ZIT-]ZWXM)TJI
VQI5WV\MVMOZW*]TOIZQI5IKMLWVQI
;MZJQI+ZWI\QI:WUIVQIIVL0]VOIZa
0IIZTMUNWZ\PKWUQVO
5MPUM\<\VK