Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
2
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The word 'leader' appeared in the English language around 1300 A.D. (Oxford
ENGLISH DICTIONARY, 1933) and the term 'leader-ship' turned up in about 1800
A.D. (Stogdill 1974). However, the issues of leadership are as old as human
civilization. As soon as some individuals began dominating others, organising to fight
aliens and protecting their own people, they emerged as leaders. Even some animals
are known for dominating and leading their flock. Earlier, tribal heads, kings and
warriors were recognised as leaders. They were superiors and masters. Later, a similar
superior it was noticed in other areas where religious preachers and reformists,
political figures, mafia kings and godfathers, intellectual giants, industrialists,
revolutionaries, sportsmen, artists and the top men in almost every sphere of society
were respected as leaders.
(Mukhopadhya, 2005, page 140) Leadership is associated with management and the
principal of a school act as a leader and his/her leadership style influences the
management of the institutions. The idea of leadership has been used in a variety of
ways, most commonly in referring to the "leader" as an outstanding member of a
class. Leadership is an essential innate capacity of the individual manifested with
equal facilities, regardless of the situation in which the leader finds himself (Bhatt and
Sharma, 1992). Leadership can be understood better in terms of what the leader does
rather than who the leader is.
1.2 DEFINITION
In the word of Rauch and Behling "leadership" is defined as the process of
influencing the activities if an organised group toward goal achievement.
Leadership may be considered as the process (act) of influencing the activities of an
organised group in its effort toward goal setting and goal achievement (Stogdill, 1950,
p.3).
Leadership is a purposeful relationship, which occurs episodically among participants,
who use their individual skills in influence, to advocate transforming change (Michael
S. Kearns, 2005).
3
Leadership is the ability to step outside the culture to start evolutionary change
processes that are more adaptable. (E.H. Schein, 1992).
QUOTES OF LEADERSHIP
"The task of the leader is to get his people from where they are to where they have not
been" - Henry Kissinger.
"Great leaders are almost always great simplifiers, who can cut through argument,
debate, and doubt to offer a solution everybody can understand" - General Colin
Powell.
Leadership is a social influence process in which the leader seeks the voluntary
participants of subordinates in an effort to reach organisation goals. A leader is a person
who delegates or influencing others in order to meet specified objectives. In the 21st
century/Millennium Century any organisation needs effective leaders who understand
the complexity of the rapidly changing global environment. If the task is highly
structured and the leader has good relationship with the employees, effectiveness will
be high on the part of the employees. The study further revealed that democratic leaders
take care to involve all members of the team in discussion and can work with a small
but highly motivated team.
expect support from the members of a collectivity as well as the right to control and
regulate their activities within the institutional frame-work.
Historically speaking, we do not come across any society, whether a modern complex
society like a nation state or a proverbial society such as tribal community of the
primitive type that functions without a leader or a set of leaders, although there are
infinite variations in the types, characteristics and careers of those leaders. There are
different types of leaders who exert differential degrees of influence on the variegated
structure of social organisation. Max Weber’s typology of authority – charismatic,
traditional and legal – is classic. Killian distinguishes among three types of leadership
in social movements – the charismatic leader, the administrative leader and the
intellectual leader.
The charismatic leader simplifies and symbolises the values; the administrative leader
promotes them; and the intellectual leader elaborates and justifies them by providing
the ideology of the movement. In modern mass society leader functions in numerous
specialised capacities and accordingly, we have the administrator, the bureaucrat, the
supervisor, the policy maker - the expert, the ideologist, the charismatic leader, the
political boss, the symbolic leader and parent-figure.
1.4 Now, let us turn to some specific theories of leadership. During the past sixty years
social scientists have advanced different theories of what makes for good leadership,
focusing first upon one aspect and then upon another. This shifting focus in the
theoretical formulations of the leadership concept may be explained in terms of five
(5) basic approaches.
1) The Trait Approach:- During the first decade of the 20th century leadership
research focused on the leader himself, to the virtual exclusion of other
variables. Hundreds of studies have been made comparing the physical,
intellectual, or personality traits of leaders and followers. These studies were
guided by the assumption that leadership effectiveness could be explained by
isolating psychological, physical and demographic characteristics which were
presumed to differentiate the leader from the other members of his group.
However, they failed to make any substantial contribution to our
understanding of the dynamics of leadership, for universal traits proved
6
The principal insistence of interaction theories ... is that the major variables in
terms of which leadership might be understood are (1) the leader’s personality
(2) the needs, attitudes and problems of followers, (3) the group itself, in terms
of both interpersonal structure and syntality and (4) the situation in terms of
both the physical circumstances and the group task 41.
Lasswell and Kaplan (1965) put forth the following propositions:42
(1) Acquisition and maintenance of leadership is a function of the prestige of
the leader. The leader is not only powerful but respected as well. Thus leaders
are likely to be recruited from among the select within group whose
composition varies with the prevailing conditions.
leadership. If these would have been the important traits Napolean or Hitler or
even mahatma Gandhi would never have been the leaders.
Choudhury (2001), said the above leadership style has a place in management
practice. A good leader knows when to use them and when not to sue them.
The autocratic style works best when the labour force is un-skilled. The
democratic style works best in the rapidly changing organisation. It creates the
kind of free environment in which skilled workers-engineers, technicians,
crafts people seem to thrive. The free-rein style works best with professors,
research-scientists- people who want to work independently and have shown
the ability to do so. It is a relatively rare-style in industry.
1.13 OBJECTIVES:
The following are the objectives of the study.
1) To study the leadership styles of DERT, DIET and CTE
2) To find out the leadership style of Teacher Educator in relation to:
a. Training
b. Interpersonal Relationship
3) To study the leadership style of Principal’s / Head’s of Institution of DERT,
DIET and CTE.
1.14 HYPOTHESIS:
1.15 DELIMITATION:
The study is delimited to DERT, DIET and CTE of East Khasi Hills and Jaintia Hills,
Meghalaya.
CHAPTER - II
LEADERSHIP STYLE:
Cheng (1991) examined the leadership style of principals and organizational process
in secondary schools. A survey was conducted involving 64 secondary schools and
672 teachers in Hong Kong. Results indicated a strong relationship of leadership style
to organizational process.
Jain (2000) in her study “Leadership Style and Organizational Effectiveness” revealed
that Indian head teachers generally use a variety of leadership styles. The most
common are authoritarian and task oriented styles. The two styles were found to be
significant predictors of organizational effectiveness. She also declared that these two
styles have deep roots in Indian culture.
Sudha (1997) investigated the leadership effectiveness in secondary schools of Delhi
and found that effective leadership results in overall effectiveness of the school. It
also emphasizes the identification of the head teacher with the group, not his or her
separation from it. It also suggested that leadership is organizational and functional
and is related to managerial skills in achieving the objectives of the
Government/Government Aided and private schools in a rapidly changing school
climate.
Adeyemi (2004) identify 3 types of leadership styles used in Nigerian schools. These
are the autocratic, democratic and laissez faire leadership styles. He argued that the
autocratic leader is an authoritarian. He directs group members on the way things
should be done. He also gives orders which are to be obeyed whether or not the
members of staff have initiatives. All powers are concentrated in his hand such that
when he is away, it would be difficult for the staff to know what to do. Power and
decision-making reside in the autocratic leader.
Campbell, Bridges & Nystrand (1993) the authoritarian leadership style is used when
leaders tell their employees what they want done and how they want it accomplished,
without getting the advice of their follower. This style results in the group members
reacting aggressively and apathetically in the work environment. They further suggest
that authoritarian style should normally only be used on rare occasions. This often
results in unending industrial disputes in an organization hence affecting the
achievement of the overall goals and objectives. The participative or democratic
leadership style involves the leader including one or more employees in the decision
18
making process in determining what to do and how to do it. However, the leader
maintains the final decision making authority. Using this style is not a sign of
weakness; rather, it is a sign of strength that your employees will respect.
Nzuve (1999) stresses that an effective teacher pays more attention to planning work
and special tasks and permits teachers to participate in decision-making processes in
an effort to achieve school goals. Using this style is of mutual benefit it allows them
to become part of the team and allows you to make better decisions.
Okeniyi (1995) and Adeyemi (2007) on the other hand, the democratic style of
leadership emphasizes group and leader participation in the making of policies.
Decisions about organizational matters are arrived at after consultation and
communication with various people in the organization. The leader attempts as much
as possible to make each individual feel that he is an important member of the
organization. Communication is multidirectional while ideas are exchanged between
employees and the leader.
According to Goldman (2002), democratic organizations typically have the following
six characteristics: policies are determined by a group of organizations, technical and
job performances measures are discussed so they are understood by all, leaders
provide advice to members in regards to implementing tasks, members are free to
choose with whom they work, the group determines the distribution of task, and
leaders try to be objective in giving praise and criticism.
Chandan, 1987 defines leadership style is the ingredient of personality embodied in
leaders that causes subordination to follow them. Oyedeji (1998) and Adeyemi (2004)
as such, a leadership style occupies an important position in school management.
Okumbe (1998) on the other hand defines leadership styles is particular behaviour
applied by a leader to motivate subordinates to achieve the objectives of the
organization. The school principal is in a unique position as the manager or
administrator who controls schools’ resources for the purpose of achievements
educational goals and can accelerate the process of schools development or can
demolish the progress of education.
Ukeje (1999) observes that leadership means influencing people to work willingly
with zeal towards the achievement of the corporate goals. A leader cannot work alone;
he must have people to influence, direct, carry along, sensitize and mobilize towards
19
the achievement of the corporate goal. The manner that leader performs these roles
and directs the affairs of the organization is referred to as his/her leadership style.
Leadership style therefore is the way a leader leads. Some leaders are more interested
in the work to be done than in the people they work with while others pay more
attention to their relationship with subordinates than the job. Whether a leader
emphasizes the task or human relations is usually considered central to leadership
style.
Goldman (2000) states that leaders using a democratic style of leadership build
consensus through participation, but these leaders also expect a higher level of
excellence and self direction. From my own experience I have observed that these
leaders have time to listen and share ideas with their followers. They also tend to be
more flexible and are responsive to ones needs. They are able to motivate teachers to
participate in decision-making and are respectful. The democratic style of leadership
emphasizes group and leader participation in the making of policies. Decisions about
organization matters are arrived at after consultation and communication with various
people in the organization. Communication is multidirectional while ideas are
exchanged between employees and the leader.
Sasheeka, (2011) on leadership style of principals in Sri Lanka showed that most
principals practiced democratic leadership style in most instances. He found out that
principals tend to show autocratic leadership in the process of school administration
but however the teachers expect principals to act as democratic leaders with regard to
school activities and teacher motivation.
20
CHAPTER - III
METHODOLOGY
21
3.1 INTRODUCTION:
Best and Kahn (1998), to carry out any type of research investigation, data must be
gathered with which to test the hypothesis. Many different methods and procedures
have been developed to aid in the acquisition of data. Each is particularly appropriate
for certain source of data, yielding information of the kind and in the form that can be
most effectively used.
The present dissertation entitled “Leadership styles of Teacher Educators of DERT,
DIET and CTE in East Khasi Hills District and Jaintia Hills District of Meghalaya”.
3.3 POPULATION:
In the present study the population comprises of
i. Two DIETs
ii. TWO CTEs
iii. 1 DERT/SCERT
Table 3.1
Types of Institution Number of Teacher Educators
/ Head Principals
(1) Directorate of Educational and Training (DERT)
(2) District Institute of Education and Training (DIET)
(3) College of Teacher Education (CTE)
CHAPTER - IV
CHAPTER - V
CHAPTER - VI
APPENDICES
27
L.P.S-BL
L.I. Bhushan
Ex Professor and Head
Department of Psychology
Bhagalpur University
Bhagalpur
28
CONSUMABLE BOOKLET
L.I. Bhushan (Bhagalpur) L.P.S-BL
L.I. Bhushan (Bhagalpur) (English Version)
Date
Name ________________________
Father’s Name _________________ Education ___________________
Date of Birth __________________ Religion _______________ Caste ____________
Sex Male Female Occupation _____________
29
REFERENCE
Alias, H.(2005). Leadership Style and Learner Out-come in Adventist Secondary Schools
Ph.D. Education Web www.http://aiias.edu/iet/vol_17/17cc_231_248.htm
Bhatt, D.B. and Sharma, R.S. (1992). Educational Administration Emerging Trends.
Kanishka Publishing House, Delhi
Eagly, A.H.(1992).Gender and Leadership Style among School Principals: A Meta Analysis.
Educational Administration Quarterly, 28(1), 76-102
Hardin, N.T.(1995). Principal’s Leadership Style, Personality Type and School Climate
Research in the Schools, 2(2), 39-45
Lipham, M.J. and Hoeh, A.J.(1974). The Principalship: Foundations and Functions.
New York: Harper and Row, Publishers
Najafi, M.(1994). Investigating the relationship between Leadership Style and Effectiveness
of Education in Villages by Jihad Construction Stressing Fielder Model.
(M.A.) Thesis
Ross, J. and Gray, P.(2006). School Leadership and Student Achievement: The Meditating
Effects of Teacher beliefs. Canadian Journal of Education, 29(3), 798-822
Sharpe, R.(2000, November 20). As Leaders, Women Rule Business Week, p.74
Waters, J.T., Marzano, R.J. and Mc Nulty, B.(2004). Leadership that Sparks Learning,
Educational Leadership, 61(7), 48-51. W.N:0409403461010
Yildrim, O.C., A Car, A Bull and Sevine, L.(2008). Relationship between teachers Perceived
Leadership style, Student’s Learning Style and Academic Achievement: A
Study on High School Students. Educational Psychology, 25(1), 73-81
Young, P.(2004). Leadership and Gender in Higher Education. A Case Study. Journal of
Further and Higher Education, 18(1), 95-106