Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
net/publication/249771933
Article
CITATIONS READS
0 80
3 authors, including:
Ariovaldo Bolzan
Federal University of Santa Catarina
78 PUBLICATIONS 569 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ariovaldo Bolzan on 10 February 2014.
Abstract. In this work, a case study of recycling of polymeric wastes through pyrolysis is carried out. These
wastes were originated from companies of the South of Brazil and are considered critical regarding their
generated volume and harmfulness degree. The studied wastes were: Polypropylene(PP), Acrylonitrile
Butadiene Styrene(ABS) and paint sludge waste. In this work it was developed a methodology for the
optimization of a multiproduct pyrolysis reactor operation, where the biggest challenges are: to generate non-
toxic products and insert them into the market with competitive price, to return the invested capital to
develop, to assemble and to operate the pyrolysis plant, as well as, to utilize a viable method of optimization
for a batch multiproduct production system. For that, this work is composed by three main parts: a) online
data acquisition through an experimental system assembled in bench-scale; b) gathering information, in field,
about the region where the pyrolysis plant is to be inserted; and c) development of an optimization software.
The optimization of the multiproduct pyrolysis plant consisted in the actualization, in a month, of the
production sequencing and of the operational set points that are needed to reach the objectives of the
production planning, through the maximization of a profit function. This function involved economical and
technical data such as, temperature and batch time, prices and, processed waste and produced oil amounts,
consumed and generated amounts of combustible gases as well as restrictions on the raw material and
product’s demand. This optimization problem was solved through a solution methodology using Genetic
Algorithms. The result is a flexible computational code that permits rescheduling to accommodate today’s
fast changes in market requirements, production capacities and operational conditions.
1. Introduction
In the last years, Brazil has produced approximately 3 millions tons of harmful industrial waste per year,
however only 22% is treated adequately. The South and Southeast regions have the main states that generate
such waste, according to the website of the Ministry of Environment. In the South region, the Rio Grande do Sul
state generates circa 300.000 tons of industrial solid wastes and 63,6% are considered harmful. Caxias do Sul
city has been chosen as the study region of this work for being the third bigger metal-mechanic pole in Brazil.
The city has 5.865 industries that generate a high volume of industrial waste of plastic and paint, not only for the
generated volume but also for its degree of perilousness. Nowadays, the two main destination of these wastes
are: incineration and industrial landfills, which cause serious environmental and social risks, mainly due to the
high volume of gas generated in the incineration process and the increasing proximity of landfills to the city. An
alternative for the rationalisation of the use of such polymeric wastes through pyrolysis was utilised in this work.
Pyrolysis is a thermal decomposition in the absence or with a minimum of oxygen with simultaneous generation
of gases and liquids. These products can be used to supply energy to the process or can be commercialised as
chemicals or fuel. A detailed study, involving technical and economical viability was carried out as well as the
production planning and suitable supervision of a multiproduct pyrolysis reactor. The utilisation of genetic
algorithms as the solution strategy was due to its success as a method of operational research in several problems
of large scale, and also due to its capacity of simultaneous determination of production planning, scheduling and
operational conditions, besides the scientific curiosity in using the fundamentals of genetics with the evolution
theory as an alternative for the solution of an environmental issue.
2. Literature review
Technologies of waste treatment for energy recovery represent an interesting alternative in treatment of
industrial solid wastes. Incineration is the method most used, but the high costs for pollution control of
incinerators as well as chemical composition of several polymers, especially those containing chlorine, are
demanding alternative treatments. Bockhorn (1999) defined pyrolysis as a procedure compared to the
incineration and it has as main advantages the economy on gas washing and absence of several oxygenated toxic
compounds. However, it is a fact that several polymers need a considerate amount of energy to break up the
molecules. Caputo and Pelagagge (2002a) showed that only plants with direct utilisation of the generated fuels
are economically viable. Germany and Japan have the biggest industrial pyrolysis plants for the conversion of
wastes into energy, fuel and gas with different types of feeding: packing materials, woodworking wastes, wastes
from varnish factories (Meneghetti et al., 2002), municipal solid waste (Caputo and Pelagagge, 2002b) and other
wastes with high calorific power (Bébar et al., 2002).
The processing of several types of wastes makes the pyrolysis to be compared to a multiproduct plant in
batch mode, where these several wastes can be pyrolysed in the same equipment. The modelling of a
multiproduct batch plant integrates several process operations in a complex way, typically planning, scheduling,
supervision and data acquisition. The best way for integration is reached through a formulation and solution of
mathematical models appropriately structured. Most of these models consider a hierarchical decomposition
scheme where the planning problem is represented by a model that adjusts the production objectives to
maximize profit and, in the lower level, the scheduling problem is reduced to a sequence of sub problems that
have to reach the objectives adjusted by the planning problem. The integration of the two levels is performed by
a heuristic method (Birewar and Grossmann, 1990, Susara and Grossmann, 2003 and Kin et al., 2003). In this
work, the integration is determined through a solution strategy that uses genetic algorithms that solve
simultaneously planning, scheduling and supervision problems of a multiproduct pyrolysis batch reactor,
generating always-viable solutions. This is a large scale problem and difficult to solve due to the complexity of
the involved chemical reactions as well as restrictions to demand and time horizon involved during the search
for the optimum solution, making inadequate the use of conventional optimization methods. Several research
works that have been developed in this area are limited to the study of scheduling of flow shop and job shop
machines, where genetic algorithms have shown great solution potentiality in an effective and efficient way.
(Srikanth and Barkha, 2004, Jensen et al., 2003, Wang et al., 2000).
2nd Mercosur Congress on Chemical Engineering
th
4 Mercosur Congress on Process Systems Engineering
3. Methodology
The first step of the optimization process of a pyrolysis plant of industrial solid waste is the characterisation
of the region to place the plant, aiming to determine the type of waste to be processed, average generation rate
and equipments capacity. After studying the fundamentals of such equipments, the gas and liquid pyrolytic
products were characterised and a new research was performed in the study region to determine the demand and
economic value of these products. The economic potential of the region for those products was confirmed then
an experimental apparatus was set to collect temperature and batch time data, electrical power consumed by the
reaction and mass and composition of the resulting products of pyrolysis of three types of industrial solid waste.
These variables were utilised for modelling the product yield, energy consumption and energy produced by the
reaction and these variables were also used to classify the obtained oils. These models were incorporated to the
multiproduct batch plant, integrating production planning, scheduling and supervision. With the maximum
profit determination, an economic analysis was carried out through the determination of the annual rate of
income over the investment. Figure 1 shows a flowchart of the utilised methodology.
Products N Exit
are viable
Rate of
demand Y xj
of wastes Epi
Online data acquisition
Eci
Price of
Experimental Multiproduct batch
products
data adjustment plant modelling
Production planning
Optimisation Scheduling production
Operational conditions
ROI Economic analysis
Profit
T R P (1)
Maximize ∑ ∑ QRit PRit + ∑ QP jt PP jt − GLt C t − 0.2CTPt
t =1 i =1 j =1
Subject to:
Tmini ≤ TRi ≤ Tmaxi i = 1,..,R (2)
tmini ≤ tRi ≤ tmaxi i = 1,..,R (3)
QRit ≤ Omaxit i = 1,..,R t = 1,....,T (4)
QPjt ≤ Dmaxjt j = 1,..,P t = 1,....,T (5)
R i = 1,..,R t = 1,....,T (6)
GLt = ∑ (GC it − GPit )
i =1
T t = 1,....,T (7)
CTPt = 1,25 ∑ C t
t =1
R Nbit i = 1,..,R t = 1,....,T (8)
∑ ∑ (t i )k ≤ H t
i =1 k =1
QRit, QPjt, GPit, GCit, CTPt,TRi, tRi, ti ≥ 0 i = 1,..,R t = 1,....,T (9)
Eq. (1) shows the maximisation of the profit function, which is the difference between income and
manufacturing costs. Eq. (2), (3), (4) and (5) are restrictions that limit the values of temperature, batch time and
processed waste amounts and produced oil amounts, respectively. Eq. (5) expresses the liquid mass of
combustible gas in period t, which is the difference between the total mass of produced and consumed
combustible gas in period t. Eq. (8) is a restriction of time horizon that limits the time spent for processing all
wastes during the time t and Eq. (9) shows the non- negativity restrictions.
3.6. Optimization
The strategy to insert the scheduling and supervision problems into the planning problem was done utilising
an optimization method based in genetic algorithms. In the method utilised, every population string is formed by
the following sequence of variables: type of waste, temperature and processing time, and the string length is
determined by restrictions of products demand, wastes availability and time, Eq. (4), (5) and (8). A fitness value
was attributed for each string, which is the same of the objective function, associated to the profit. Scaling was
utilised in the beginning of optimization, aiming to keep the competitiveness level amongst the strings. Two
strings from the population, with probability associated to the value of their fitness, were random selected. It
means, as higher is the profit, higher is the probability of selection (roulette). Before crossover, all the
restrictions of the model were tested, avoiding useless calculation. Crossover was performed amongst the same
genes or variables in their different parents, with probability of a pair of selected individuals are crossover,
being dependent on the crossover rate. The mutation operator was applied through a draw for each gene, with
probability of gene mutation, being dependent on the mutation rate. The operator elitism was also utilised,
passing 10% of the best individuals of the population from one generation to the next, without making any
change to them. The procedure described from the selection operator was repeated for each generation, where
2nd Mercosur Congress on Chemical Engineering
th
4 Mercosur Congress on Process Systems Engineering
the new population was generated with the same size of the initial population and the value of the objective
function equal or higher at each generation. This new obtained population resulted in a representative sequence
of the production sequencing and temperature data as well as batch time for each of the wastes, in a pre-defined
time horizon. The proposed algorithm also incorporated a rescheduling strategy to face the frequent changes of
products and price and demand variations, becoming dynamic. A generative type of rescheduling was utilised
(Bael, 1999).
4. Results
The research carried out in the industrial city of Caxias do Sul, located in South of Brazil has shown that the
main generated industrial solid wastes, for their volume as well as for their degree of perilousness, were:
Polypropylene (PP), Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) and polyurethanic paint (paint sludge), with the
following generation rate: 7.500, 2.500 and 30.000 Kg/month, respectively. Pyrolysis reactions were carried out
over the conditions shown in Table 1.
In these conditions, for the three types of feeding, the reaction generated a gaseous phase comprising of CH4,
C2H6, C2H4, C2H2, C3H8 and C3H6. The composition of the liquid phase was also determined by gas
chromatography and, initially, divided into functional groups due to the great variety of liquid products. Table 2
shows the obtained results for paint waste (left column) and PP waste (right column). ABS waste resulted
basically in 100% of aromatic compounds in all experiments.
The added value to the produced oil depends on its classification according to experiments of the Agência
Nacional de Petróleo (Brazilian National Petroleum Agency). Results in Table 3 show that all produced oils
have calorific power, viscosity and specific mass of combustible oil; however, the flashing point of the obtained
oil from the paint waste characterizes it as inflammable.
The yield of the produced oils by the pyrolysis reaction was defined as the ratio between the generated mass
of oil and the fed mass of solid waste. Figures 1and 2 show the influence of temperature and batch time over the
yield of the obtained oil from the ABS e paint sludge wastes.
Figura 1 – Influence of temperature and batch time over the yield of the obtained oil from ABS waste
Figura 2 - Influence of temperature and batch time over the yield of the obtained oil from paint sludge waste
The obtained curve for PP was similar to the ABS one. The yield data as a function of time were
experimentally adjusted.
2nd Mercosur Congress on Chemical Engineering
th
4 Mercosur Congress on Process Systems Engineering
The experimental system allowed the online acquisition of temperature, batch time and tension data. The
tension data was utilised to heat an electrical resistor of 16.55 ohms surrounding the reactor. It was possible to
measure the electrical power every 5 seconds and therefore determine the consumed energy from the beginning
of the experiment until the reaction temperature (transient energy) as well as the necessary energy to keep the
reaction temperature (permanent energy). The transient energy was described as a function of fed mass of waste
and variation of the reaction temperature from the beginning of heating until the reaction temperature was
stabilised, which was considered stable in the range of set point ±5ºC. Ten distinct experimental runs were
performed, changing the mass from 0 to 800 grams and temperature from 400 to 650ºC. Electrical tension data
were converted to power knowing the value of electrical resistance and the conversion of power to energy was
carried out integrating the power curve versus time using the Simpson’s rule. The permanent energy was
determined as a function of fed mass of waste, reaction time and average reaction temperature, which was
considered as the average temperature in the steady state, represented by the interval of the temperature of the
set point ± 5ºC, during 90 minutes. The total quantity of energy consumed to processes the waste i (Eci) was the
sum of transient and permanent energy. With the mass and composition of the obtained gases, the combustion
heat of the mixture (Epi) was determined over the conditions shown in Table 1.
In all cases the adjust of experimental data showed a correlation coefficient around 0,99 and the minimum
percentage of variance explained by the model was 98,6%.
Data from Table 4 were utilised to simulate production planning and sequencing as well as the operational
conditions of pyrolysis of industrial solid wastes, using Genetic Algorithms in real codification as optimization
method.
The obtained results for production planning and after rescheduling (values in parentheses) are shown in
Table 5. The rescheduling proposed a reduction in the price of combustible gas from R$ 0,69/Kg to R$ 0,40/Kg.
2nd Mercosur Congress on Chemical Engineering
th
4 Mercosur Congress on Process Systems Engineering
It is observed that before rescheduling, ABS and paint wastes were processed until the maximum allowed by
the restrictions of waste offer. Most of the profit was due to the income from paint waste purchase and selling of
combustible gas. Lowering the price of combustible gas from R$ 0,69/Kg to 0,40/Kg, the most significant
difference is then in the income from selling combustible oil, that therefore surpass the income from gas selling,
leading to an increase in processing of PP waste until its maximum limit, with the reduction of the number of
paint waste batches.
Using the monthly profit obtained in the simulation and a total investment of R$ 88.489.00, the monthly rate
of income over the investment was 21,7% per month.
5. Conclusions
The utilised optimization methodology, with the simultaneous determination of planning and scheduling, is
flexible allowing rescheduling to absorb the variations of market demand, production capacity and operational
conditions, in a viable computational time. It can be used for several wastes where products yield and involved
energy are determined without previously knowing the kinetics and heat of the pyrolysis reactions. The
pyrolysis plant has shown economically viable, producing combustible oil and gas, being energetically self-
sustainable and with most of the income generated from the production of combustible gas.
Nomenclature
Sets: Dminj= minimum demand of products generated by
i = 1,...,R wastes; waste i;
j = 1,...,P oils; Ht= length of period t;
k = 1,..., Nbit batches of waste i in time period t; Omaxit = maximum offer of waste i in time period t.
t = 1,...,T time periods. PPjt= market price of oil j in period t;
Parameters: PRit= market price of waste i in time period t;
Ct= unit cost of combustile gas in time period t; Tmaxi= maximum temperature to process waste i;
Dmaxj= maximum demand of products generated tmaxi= maximum time to process the waste i;
by waste i; Tmini= minimum temperature to process the waste i;
2nd Mercosur Congress on Chemical Engineering
th
4 Mercosur Congress on Process Systems Engineering
tmini= minimum time to process the waste i; GPit= total quantity of combustible gas produced of
Ts= setup time; waste i in time period t;
Nbit= number of batches of waste i in time period t;
Variables:
QPjt= total quantity of product j produced in period t;
CTPt = total cost of production in period t;
QRit = total quantity of waste i processed in time
Eci=total energy consumed to processes the waste i;
period t;
Epi=total energy produced from waste i;
ti = time of one batche of waste i;
GCit= total quantity of combustible gas consumed to
TRi = temperature of reaction of waste i;
processes the waste i in time period t;
tRi = time of reaction of waste i;
GLt= liquid mass of combustible gas in period t;
xj =yield of oil j;
References
Bael, V. P. (1999). - A Study of rescheduling strategies and abstraction levels for a chemical process scheduling problem.
Production Planning & Control, 10, 4, 359.
Bébar, L., Martinák, P., Hájek, J., Stehlík, P., Hajný, Z., Oral, J. (2002). - Waste To Energy In The Field Of Thermal
Processing Of Waste. Appl. Therm. Engng.,22, 897.
Birewar, D. B., Grossmann, I. E. (1990) - Simultaneous Production And Scheduling In Multiproduct Batch Plants. Ind. Eng.
Chem. Res., 29, 570.
Bockhorn, H., Hentschel, J., Hornung, A., Hornung, U. (1999b). - Environmental Engineering: Stepwise Pyrolysis of Plastic
Waste. Chem. Eng. Sci., 54, 3043.
Bockhorn, H., Hornung, A., Hornung, U., Jakobströer, P. (1999a). - Modelling of Isothermal and Dynamic Pyrolysis of
Plastics Considering Non-Homogeneous Temperature Distribution and Detailed Degradation Mechanism. J. Anal.
Appl.Pyrolysis., 49, 53.
Caputo, A. C., Pelagagge, P. M. (2002a). - RDF Production Plants: I Design and Costs. Appl. Therm. Engng, 22, 423.
Caputo, A. C., Pelagagge, P. M. (2002b). .- RDF Production Plants: II Economics and Profitability. Appl. Therm. Engng, 22,
439.
Jensen, M. T. (2003). - Generating Robust and Flexible Job Shop Schedules Using Genetic Algorithms. IEEE Trans. Evol.
Comput.,7, 3, 275.
Kim, Y.K., Park, K., Ko, J. (2003). - Integration of Process Planning and Job Shop Scheduling. Comput.Oper.Res., 30, 8,
1151.
Meneghetti, A., Nardin, G., Simeoni, P. (2002). - Waste-to-energy Application In An Industrial District. Appl. Energy, 72,
443.
Ministry of environment (2003). – Industrial Wastes In: www.mma.gov.br/port/sqa/prorisc/residuos/corpo.html and
www.mma.gov.br/port/sqa/prorisc/residuos/resperi.html.
Srikanth, K. I., Barkha, S. (2004). - Improved Genetic Algorithm for the Permutation Flowshop Scheduling Problem.
Comput.Oper.Res., 31, 4, 593.
Susara, A., Grossmann, E. I. (2003). - A Strategy for the Integration of Production Planning and Reactive Scheduling in the
Optimization of a Hydrogen Supply Network. Comput.Chem.Eng., 27, 12, 1813.
Wang, D., Fang, S. (1997). - A Genetic Based Approach For Aggregated Production Planning In A Fuzzy Environment.
IEEE Trans. Syst., Man and Cybernetics. – Part A: Systems And Humans, 27.