Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2.1 INTRODUCTION
2.2 STUDIES ON RETENTION STRATEGIES OF PRIVATE SECTORS
2.3 STUDIES ON RETENTION STRATEGIES IN IT SECTORS
2.4 STUDIES ON JOB ATTITUDE OF THE EMPLOYEES
2.5 CONCLUSION ON REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.6 RESEARCH GAP
2.7 NEED FOR THE STUDY
2.8 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
2.9 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
2.10 HYPOTHESES
2.11 SCOPE OF THE STUDY
2.12 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
2.12.1 RESEARCH DESIGN
2.12.2 SAMPLE OF THE STUDY
2.12.3 MEASURES USED TO COLLECT THE DATA
2.12.4 PILOT STUDY
2.12.5 ETHICAL ISSUES
2.12.6 DATA COLLECTION
2.12.7 ANALYSIS OF RESULTS
2.12.8 CHAPTERIZATION SCHEME
2.12.9 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
CHAPTER - II
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Employee retention issues are emerging as the most critical workforce
management challenges of the immediate future. Researchers have shown that in the
future, “successful organizations will be those which adapt their organizational
behavior to the realities of the current work environment where longevity and success
depend upon innovation, creativity and flexibility”. In fact, “the dynamics of the work
environment will have to reflect a diverse population comprised of individuals whose
motivations, beliefs and value structures differ vastly from the past and from one
another. This phenomenon is especially true in light of current economic uncertainty
and following corporate downsizings when the impact of losing critical employees
increases exponentially” (Caplan and Teese, 1997). “Critical analysis of workforce
trends points to an impending shortage of highly-skilled employees who possess the
requisite knowledge and ability to perform at high levels, meaning that organizations
failing to retain high performers will be left with an understaffed, less qualified
workforce that ultimately hinders their ability to remain competitive” (Rappaport,
Bancroft, & Okum, 2003) with managers facing a difficult challenge of motivating
and retaining the employees in an environment of increased uncertainties (Mitchell,
2002). “Retention rates generally falls as employees become distracted, confused and
preoccupied with potential outcomes immediately following an organizational
transition” (Bridges, 1991). In spite of the huge literature on identifying factors on
employee turnover which is reason employees to leave (Griffeth, Hom, & Gaertner,
2000), less is recognized about the aspects that induce employees to stay. Maertz &
Campion (1998) noted “relatively less turnover research has focused specifically on
how an employee decides to remain with an organization and what determines
retention processes should be studied along with quitting processes”.
Steel, Griffeth & Hom (2002) added “the fact was often overlooked, but the
reasons people stay were not always the same as the reasons people leave”. Retention
was a multifaceted concept which was not having single formula for retaining
personnel with a organization. Retention is perceived as “an obligation to continue to
22
dimensions, such as stress and alcohol abuse, and WLB had become closer and
intertwined.
26
groups had different views. The findings of the research enabled the development of a
structured argument in terms of what organizations need to start doing, stop doing and
continue doing with respect to the management practices employed for the retention
of highly talented people.
Chiboiwa M W et. al., (2010) taken up a case study of a major private sector
medical laboratory company in Zimbabwe. The result of the research showed that
labour turnover was higher amongst non-managerial employees. Similarly, majority
of the employees would soon quit the organization and lastly, the high rate of
employee turnover in the organization was largely attributed to poor reward system
administration.
Tseng C Y (2010) aimed to identify what retention factors are important in
retaining software development employees in the IT industry in Taiwan. Six retention
factors were examined. The findings of this study indicated that two unique and four
common retention factors could be related to software engineers and assistant
managers’ decisions to stay. One unique and five common retention factors could be
related to project leaders’ decisions to stay. In addition, these three different types of
software development employees were in different career stages.
Umer M. and Naseem M. A. (2011) investigated the impact of career
development, supervisor support, work environment, work life balance on employee
retention. A total of 50 interviews were taken from managers of different BPO
organizations in Pakistan. The variables had a significant and positive impact on
employee retention.
Kabera (2011) emphasized on Employee motivation, favourable working
conditions and individual security were some of the factors that influence staff
retention in private security firms in Nairobi.
Bairi J et. al., (2011) aimed to find effective employee retention plan for IT
sectors. The employee retention plan was evaluated at three IT MNCs. The data
collected was used for studying attrition and retention and its impact on KM. Findings
of the study provided evidence of various strategic, technological, and local issues
influencing the success of retention and its benefit to KM programs in global IT
service companies.
Plaatjies F C (2011) aimed to propose effective retention strategies for
employers within the financial environment, to retain their skilled IT workforce. The
field data were gathered by using twofold data collection technique: disseminating a
27
questionnaire and interviewing participants in this study. The fieldwork followed the
University of the Western Cape guidelines on research ethics. The outcomes of the
study showed that there was a strong correlation between having good HR retention
policies and procedures, and the management of these policies and procedures. The
findings suggested the importance of involving employees at all employment levels
to provide input on the development of these policies and procedures so that the
retention process is well understood across the firm.
Naidu K (2011) aimed to identify the key factors influencing the retention of
B players across generations and ethnic groups, and thereby developed a retention
framework that would contribute towards the improved retention of B players. The
study adopted a dual approach, incorporating a qualitative and quantitative
methodology. Interviews were conducted with key stakeholders to validate the
questionnaire and gain insights regarding the key retention variables that influence B
players. The key findings indicated that B players were most influenced by Financial
Reward &Recognition, Independence & Freedom and Leadership& Management
factors. A Factor Significance and Variable Importance Retention Framework was
developed to assist organizations to develop dynamic multidimensional strategies.
Aslam R (2011) investigated the relationship between work family conflict
(WFC), family work conflict (FWC) and turnover intentions of employees in three
public and three private sector organizations from services sector of Pakistan. This
study found positive but insignificant relationship between work-family conflict
(WFC), family-work conflict (FWC) and turnover intention of employees. Both
public and private sector employees are neutral regarding these variables.
Sleiderink D. E. M (2012) focused on talent management – in particular on
the identification and retention of talent – within Medisch Spectrum Twente (MST).
MST employs about 4000 employees of Netherlands were interviewed with current
talents at in order to investigate what their extrinsic and intrinsic needs were. Based
on the results, the top five most important extrinsic needs of talents at MST were
relationships with colleagues, followed by work conditions, job security, promotional
opportunities, and salary. The top five most important intrinsic needs of talents at
MST were autonomy, followed by opportunities for development and job satisfaction,
challenge, recognition and task significance. These results indicated how important it
was for an organization to have a commonly shared definition, criteria and a method
to identify talents.
28
relationship between experience in the job and employee retention and exit
interviews was a highly effective tool for improving the level of employee retention.
Significant relationship was not found between job satisfaction, educational
qualification and employee retention. The percentage of employee attrition varied
considerably across selected IT organizations which could be the result of the
different employee retention strategies followed by these organizations.
Chordiya K D. (2013) investigated to understand the reasons behind why do
ITeS professionals switch their jobs, to know why retention was needed & to
understand the various strategies adopted by BPO sector for retaining their
employees. It was revealed that most of the employees in BPOs were retained because
of the following factors such as competitive compensation, encouragement and
recognition, well equipped and safety environment, infrastructure, potential talent and
job involvement. The employee retention could be possible if an organization
practices these factors.
Atul Mathur A & Agarwal P. K. (2013) explored the influence of retention
strategies on employee turnover in sugar industry in India. Uttar Pradesh. Results of
the study showed that retention strategies had an impact on employee turnover.
Welfare benefits, personal satisfaction and organization culture, which were said to be
related with the employee turnover.
Narang U (2013) attempted to find out the influence of HRM practices (career
development opportunities, supervisor support, working environment, rewards and
work-life policies) on employee retention in the banks. Findings reveled that, career
development, allocation of rewards regarding work and work environment showed the
highest values in relation to their perceived level of retention with the concern. It
means that the respondents were more inclined towards their career growth, rewards
and want to work in an environment where they get support from their colleagues.
31
Nigeria. It was recommended that the private universities in Nigeria should sustain
and improve on the existing retention strategies for the survival of the organization.
Job security should be improved to encourage employees’ willingness to stay and be
committed to survival of the organization, also private universities should endeavour
to combine the practice of retention strategy variables and useless of single or
selective strategy and to watch its operating cost on retention strategies.
32
autonomy, environment of openness and trust, fair & equitable treatment in work
environment, effective utilization of employee skills and abilities, management
policies regarding reward and recognition of employee achievements and
developmental aspects in organization were the most influencing factors for
employee retention.
Yadav B S and Rokade V (2013) conducted study to find out the causes of
attrition and suggests the useful measures for employee retention. The survey was
done on 50 employees of HDFC Standard Life Insurance Company, using
convenience sampling method. A problem of employee turnover mounting
particularly at the lower level, most of the HDFC employees were satisfied with the
company policies, work-culture but still improvement was required in some of the HR
domain like performance appraisal, Job design, perks and benefits. The Work life
balance was the main reason to leave the organization.
Dyk J. V et. al., (2013) found that the employees’ satisfaction with retention
factors significantly predicted their job embeddedness. 206 respondents were from
South African client services companies. Retention factors such as training and
development, career opportunities, supervisor support and the characteristics of the
job were shown to significantly predict the participants’ sense of job embeddedness.
Satisfaction with training and development opportunities were the best predictor of
organizational fit and satisfaction with career opportunities were the best predictor
of organizational sacrifice.
Hlamalane M C (2014) designed to determine if manager support and work-
life balance can regulate the employee’s purpose to stay or leave the organization.
Non-probability purposive sampling was used with n = 172. The findings indicated
that manager support and work-life balance are predictors of intention to quit, with a
42% variance. The lack of manager support and work-life balance had an influence on
the intention to quit. The higher the manager support was perceived, the less the
intention to quit – the same holds true for work-life balance. The research identified
33
factors that could be predicted the intention to quit and highlighted insight such as
manager support and work-life balance as key issues to consider in increasing
retention. Manager support and work-life balance played a pivotal role in employee
retention.
Patgar S and Vijayakumar N (2014) explored the influencing factors of
retention strategies. The data was collected from 100 employees in the organizations.
The findings of the study suggested variables such competitive salary package,
convenient and flexible work hours, recognition and rewards for good performance,
career growth and promotion opportunities, job security and training and development
programs played vital role in influencing employees to stay or to leave the
organization.
Self D. R & Self T. B (2014) used multilayered approach, which was
discussed the efforts organizations can use to identify potentially counterproductive
employee behaviour and the steps the organizations should take to provide
appropriate developmental strategies/programs to assist counterproductive employees,
as well as, provide appropriate disciplinary action, as the situation dictates. It was
highlighted that the potential financial drain and performance threats
counterproductive employees create for organizations, offers explanations as to why
counterproductive employees were often allowed to stay on the payroll, and provided
suggestions for preventing the selection of counterproductive employees, for
providing appropriate developmental.
Suresh L and Krishnaraj R (2015) studied the factors influence the
employee retention in Pharmaceutical sector. It also thrown light on what
organizations need to do to retain their employees. 150 employees of 3 different
pharmaceutical companies in Chennai were responded in the study. The findings
suggested that organizations should learn from exit interviews, employee’s
grievances. Complaints should be treated seriously and if required counselling should
be done to retain the best talent. Employee engagement played an important role in
employee retention.
Aslam M (2015) investigated the influence of work life balance on employee
performance and the moderating effect of transactional leadership on relationship
between work life balance and employee performance in education sector of Pakistan.
The study used sample of 150 respondents from eight universities of Islamabad and
Rawalpindi. The findings of study revealed the work life balance had significant
34
positive effect on employee performance. The results also presented that transactional
leadership has significant moderating effect. The study recommended that
management of universities should consider the effect of work life balance while
making polices about leave and working load etc.
Oginni P & Saxena S (2015) attempted to explore the interrelationship
among the employee retention strategies and to identify the most prominent
employee retention strategies adopted by corporate sector. For this purpose, Primary
data for the research is collected with the help of questionnaire. The sample of the
study is 100 employees from 3 companies in corporate sector. Descriptive statistics
and correlation analysis had been performed to achieve the desired objective.
Results revealed that maximum focus was given to training and development
strategy and orientation strategy was found to be significantly and positively
correlated with all other strategies, except for training and development strategy and
employee’s idea and suggestion strategy. The rest of all the strategies were found to
be positively and significantly correlated with each other except for training and
development strategy.
Bidyut B. N & Barua M (2015) examined the relationships in between Job
security and employee retention, Job satisfaction and employee retention, Work life
balance and employee retention and Compensation with employee retention in the
Automobile service workshops of Assam. The result revealed that Job Security was
the most important factor for employee’s retention in their present job. The selected
100 respondents’ response was collected by visiting the authorised service
workshops of ten automobile manufacturers. Findings of this study had revealed that
the retention level of employees is above average and it was the high time for the
management attention towards enhancing the employee’s retention level.
Bharathi N. and Paramashivaiah P. (2015) examined whether variables had
an effect on involuntary attrition and personal factors on involuntary attrition,
voluntary attrition and behavioural intentions. The IT company’s employees from
Bengaluru city were selected for the study. Findings of the study revealed the facts
that Flexibility in work and time and communication flow in the company were the
environmental factors that required greatest attention for improvement. Coaching and
mentoring by superiors and career advancement were the training and development
factors that required most attention for improvement.
35
36
38
40
To understand the above problem, the present study is taken up to know the
perception of Employees and Management of among small, medium and large IT
companies, to explore the relationship between Employee Retention Strategy and Job
Commitment, Job Involvement and Job Satisfaction and to investigate the
demographic factors contributing to Employee Retention Strategy and Job
Commitment, Job Involvement and Job Satisfaction. Employee Retention in a
challenging task for the companies and it is depending upon the companies HR
policies, benefits and other facilities. Only few studied relating to the perception of
employees and management relating to retention strategy.
There are research gaps on various concepts on employee retention strategies.
Not many studies are documented in the area of Employee Retention Strategy along
with job commitment, job involvement, Job Satisfaction. Each company follows its
own Employee Retention Strategy and Employees Attitude towards the company
differs from each other. Present study is an attempt to fill up these gaps. The Research
Problem: Therefore, it was thought timely to identify and select the subject of
Employee Retention Strategy as a research problem.
41
retention have not been reported yet. Therefore, this study aims to understand the
factors influencing Retention Strategy and Job Attitude (Job Commitment, Job
Involvement and Job Satisfaction) among small, medium and large private IT sectors’
employees in Bengaluru city. The study aims at providing relevant information
required by Management to devise retention strategy specific to IT Sector among all
the three levels of IT sectors.
In this knowledge era, service sector plays a vital role, particularly IT sector
role is very important to satisfy the needs and expectations of their employees.
Because of a high standard of living, bunch of expectation, searching for new jobs
based on their requirements, and when it is not full-filled by the organization, it leads
to high attrition in this sector. The problem is very extremely acute in IT sector, with
employees joining and living within short span of time. Employee attrition is always
on the negative side of the organization and also it’s a challenging task and attrition
leads to loss of skilled workforce, loss in productivity, loss in market share and
profitability. Therefore, retaining of skilled workforce is vital task for the organization
in a changing environment. An attempt is therefore made to understand if there is a
significant difference in response among small, medium and large level of Indian IT
companies located in Bengaluru city and to help the management of these IT
companies to design an Employee Retention Strategy specific to their company to
control attrition. This study attempts to determine Employee Retention Strategy in
small, medium and large level of Indian IT companies located in Bengaluru city and
to explore the main retention strategy for IT sectors’ employees and also this study
attempts to understand about personal factors which influence employees to stay back
in the organization and strategy to retain the talented employees in the organization.
Employees are very important assets in any business for the success and
without them there is no business. However, according to the (2008) Bureau of
Labour Statistics, more employers today are finding that very less period
approximately 18 to 24 months’ service rendered by the employees. It has become a
key challenge in organizations to retain the best and most desirable employees. With
42
labour being unpredictable today's employers prefer to have a stable, committed and
flexible work schedule.
The job poaching and job hopping has become the order of the day, resulting in
high levels of attrition among IT companies. Retaining talented workforce in the
company is challenging task for management of IT companies. The study aims at
providing relevant information required by management to evolve retention strategy
specific to the IT Sector. The study aims to understand the factors influencing
Retention Strategy and Job Attitude (Job Commitment, Job Involvement and Job
Satisfaction), of IT companies located in Bengaluru city. The study also aims to
investigate differences between all the three types, small, medium and large of IT
companies and to suggest suitable employee retention strategy.
Research Questions
43
For this proposed study on Employee Retention Strategy (ERS) the following
objectives were formulated:
The following are the hypotheses formulated and tested in this study:
44
45
In the present study, quota and purposive sampling techniques are used and
1320 Employees and 30 HR managers are taken. Among them there were male and
female employees, who represents IT sectors from Bengaluru city, are taken as
samples for this study. Membership companies are classified into small, medium and
large companies.
46
47
Job Attitude Scale (JAS), was used to measure the attitude of the employees
towards their job. The scale focuses on three dimensions such as Job Commitment,
Job Involvement and Job Satisfaction. The Job Attitude Scale is a self -administered
one. This is also a five point Likert scale (ranging from 1= Strongly Disagree to 5=
Strongly Agree).
48
Before the final administration of the scales on main samples of the study, a
pilot study was conducted to verify the suitability of all the measures. This included
the composite sample of 540 IT employees and 30 IT HR managers. This sample was
also selected, from which the main sample was selected. Further reliability and
validity of the scales also has been checked for the sample in the study.
Table 2.07: Showing the Cronbach’s the reliability Coefficient for questionnaire
49
Table 2.08: Showing the Correlation Coefficient for the Variables under Study in
all Possible Ways
Characteristics
Job Flexibility
Compensation
Development
Commitment
Environment
Training and
Involvement
Satisfaction
Work Life
Working
Balance
Career
Job
Job
Job
Job
Variables
The above table clearly indicates (based on significant correlations) that the
scales are highly valued and are applicable for the present sample in the study.
50
groups based on the revenue of the sectors as small, medium and large IT sectors.
After classification of the IT sectors into three groups, companies were selected and
primary data was collected. In the collection of primary data, at initial stage
participants were informed about the purpose of the study and their consent was
taken. After taking the consent of the participants, demographic questionnaire was
administered to obtain an individual’s personal information. Then participants were
asked to answer for both the questionnaires. Participants have completed both of the
questionnaires that aim to assess retention strategy and job attitude. The responses
given by each person are carefully scrutinized for wrong marking and omission. The
answer sheets which are complete in all respects were retained and the rest were
rejected. Each response sheet is hand-scored.
51
Commitment, Job Involvement and Job Satisfaction) of small, medium and large
levels of IT sectors’ employees, the correlation technique is applied.
Chapter - I: Introduction
52
53
54