Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/225285973
CITATION READS
1 1,948
7 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Call for Paper: Special Issue "Municipal Wastewater Treatment" in IJERPH View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Amin Mojiri on 27 May 2014.
Shuokr Qarani Aziz1, Lulusi2, Faridah A.H. Asaari2, Nor Azam Ramli2, Hamidi Abdul Aziz2,*, Amin Mojiri2,
Muhammad Umar2
1
Department of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Salahaddin –Erbil, Iraq
2
School of Civil Engineering, Engineering Campus, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 14300 Nibong Tebal, Penang, Malaysia
*
Corresponding author: Prof. Hamidi Abdul Aziz, Tel: + 60-45996215, Fax: + 60-45941009, E-mail:
cehamidi@eng.usm.my and cehamidi@yahoo.com
Road traffic noise has become an important factor in societal development. Traffic noise from motor vehicles can
inflict serious damage to human health and reduce labor productivity. Traffic noise measurements were taken at
two locations: Bukit Mertajam, a developing town in Malaysia, and Erbil City, the regional capital of Iraqi
Kurdistan. Field measurements were taken simultaneously with traffic volume measurements in Bukit
Mertajam, and then validated using various models. The NAISS model represented the field measurements
better than did the other models used. The noise level was higher during peak hours, particularly during
evenings when there were increased traffic volumes and a higher percentage of heavy vehicles. The average noise
level exceeded the guidelines set by the Malaysian government. The sound pressure levels (SPLs) for Erbil City
were higher during mornings, and decreased as distance increased. The correlation coefficient obtained for SPL
and the distance between the sound source and receiver indicates a good relationship.
Key words: Traffic noise pollution, Traffic volume, Sound pressure level, Malaysia, Erbil
1
Aziz et al.
Assessment of Traffic Noise Pollution in Bukit Mertajam, Malaysia and Erbil City, Iraq
control measures in these countries. Given the On the basis of the policy of the Malaysian
increasingly international orientation of our Public Works Department (PWD), we converted
society, the comparison of noise levels in the number of vehicles obtained to its equivalent
international locations can provide useful passenger car unit (PCU). Spot speed was
information on regulatory trends. It can also enable measured using a Kustom Falcon radar gun with a
comparative analysis of field data. The objectives speed range of 15–199 mph. Fifty samples were
of this work are to 1) study the trend of roadside collected with the radar gun. Vehicle speed was
noise generated from vehicle movement during measured at one point and the average of the data
peak hours at Arumugam Pillai and Permatang was taken as the value of traffic speed flow. Data
Batu Roads in Bukit Mertajam, Malaysia (different on the geometric dimensions of road sections, as
models were used to examined the relationships well as the number of lanes and their widths, were
among noise level, traffic volume, traffic also collected. Sound level measurements were
composition, traffic speed, and predicted potential performed using a sound level meter (GA
levels of noise caused by vehicular emissions); 2) 204/Castle Type 2 IEC 651 BS 5969 ANSI S1-4).
study noise generated from vehicular movements Traffic noise was measured using the sound
for Kirkuk, Shaqlawa, Peshawa Qazi, Koysinjaq, pressure level (SPL) index with an A-weighted
Kurdistan, and Barzani Namr Roads in Erbil City, scale expressed in decibel units, which convert the
Iraq; and 3) compare the noise levels measured in SPL value into Leq. The data were then clarified
Bukit Mertajam with those obtained for Erbil City, with a sound level meter (model 1800). The SPL
Iraq. To the best of our knowledge, this kind of was calculated using the following equation (Davis
research has not been conducted. and Cornwell, 2008):
2
Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 1(3), pp. 1-11, 2012
distance of 7.5 m (ISO 362); 70 m was adopted representative physical variable that quantifies
with the assumption that most vehicles in the noise emissions. Leq corresponds to the sound
traffic stream had already reached steady speed pressure of a fictions stationary noise that emits
(Burgess, 1997). Measurements were taken on one acoustic energy similar to that emitted by a non-
side of the road and data were averaged to stationary source (Cvetković et al., 1997). The
represent the results for each location. The equivalent continuous noise level in A-weighted
microphone was calibrated before and after each decibels (dBA) is widely recognized as a stable
noise sampling session. Results with a variation descriptor of motor vehicle noise (Cvetković et al.,
higher than 0.5 dB (A) were disregarded. 1997). Mathematical models for the prediction of
traffic noise usually extract the functional
2.2. Prediction models relationship between noise emissions and
measurable traffic and road parameters. The
Traffic noise prediction models are designed to classical functional relationships based on data
facilitate planning for new roads or account for measured through semi-empirical models, typically
changes in traffic noise conditions. Most regression analyses, are shown below.
mathematical models adopt Leq as the most
L
Leq 55.5 10.2 log Q 0.3P 19.3 log( ) Burgess (1997) (3)
2
Leq 10 log( N c N m 8N v 88N b ) 33.5 Fagotti and Poggi (1995 (4)
Leq 10 log( N c 11.7 N hv 3.1N b ) 44.3 Cvetković et al. (1997) (5)
3
Aziz et al.
Assessment of Traffic Noise Pollution in Bukit Mertajam, Malaysia and Erbil City, Iraq
Light lorries (vans), lorries, and buses are both studied areas. Noise level measurements were
classified as heavy vehicles by the Highway carried out during peak hour periods. Noise level
Planning Unit of Malaysia (1994). Heavy vehicles in Leq at Arumugam Pillai and Permatang Batu
are those designed for a gross weight of more than Roads varied between 74 and 76 dB(A), as shown
3.5 tons and predominately powered by 4-stroke in Figs. 2a and 2b, respectively. The average
diesel engines. As seen in Fig. 1d, the percentage background noise level for both locations was
of heavy vehicles was higher during evenings for between 60 and 65 dB(A).
Fig. 1c: Number of heavy vehicles for Arumugam Pillai and Permatang Batu Roads
4
Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 1(3), pp. 1-11, 2012
Fig.1d: Percent heavy vehicles for Arumugam Pillai and Permatang Batu Roads
The average noise level exceeded the guidelines level during the evenings can be attributed to the
of the Malaysian Department of Environment higher number of heavy vehicles passing the roads.
(DOE), which states that the Leq for urban areas Higher traffic noise levels due to heavy vehicles
should not exceed 55 dB(A) at daytime and 45 have also been reported in literature (El-Fadel et
dB(A) at night. Not much difference was observed al., 2002; Filho et al., 2004; Ma et al., 2006).
between the noise levels at each peak hour period, Although the noise levels at Arumugam Pillai
but the noise level in the early evenings between Road were higher than those at Permatang Batu
16:15 and 18:15 PM was higher than those in the Road, these were relatively less variable.
mornings and afternoons. A relatively higher noise
5
Aziz et al.
Assessment of Traffic Noise Pollution in Bukit Mertajam, Malaysia and Erbil City, Iraq
3.2. Analysis of traffic speed flow. The data on spot speed are presented in the
form of histograms in Figs. 3a and 3b. The spot
According to Li and Tao (2004), traffic noise level speed was within 35.4 and 70.8 mph for both
is influenced by traffic flow and speed. The roads. From the spot speed data, the size of the
average speed of traffic volume flow was obtained class interval was determined by substituting the
by taking 50 samples from the data collected using highest and lowest values of speed obtained for 50
a radar gun. The radar gun was aimed at vehicles at observations for both roads. Sturges (1926)
one point to determine their speed. The data suggests the following equation for estimating the
average was taken as the value of traffic speed size of class intervals.
Fig. 3a: Histogram of spot speed data for Arumugam Pillai Road
Fig. 3b: Histogram of spot speed data for Permatang Batu Road
R
I (6)
1 3.322 log n
6
Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 1(3), pp. 1-11, 2012
61.2 35.4
I (7)
1 3.322 log 50
= 3.875 ≈ 4
70.8 37.01
I (8)
1 3.322 log 50
= 5.087 ≈ 5
As calculated from the data shown in Figs. 3a distributions of spot speed data at Arumugam Pillai
and 3b, time mean speeds (average speed) were and Permatang Batu Roads are plotted in Figs. 4a
46.7 and 52 km/h with standard deviations of 7.26 and 4b. The 85th percentile was 54.5 km/h for
and 10.40 for Arumugam Pillai and Permatang Arumugam Pillai Road and 64 km/h for Permatang
Batu Roads, respectively. The cumulative Batu Road.
Fig. 4a: Cumulative distribution of spot speed data at Arumugam Pillai Road
Fig. 4b: Cumulative distribution of spot speed data at Permatang Batu Road
3.3. Noise prediction model Fagotti, and NAISS models were 71–74, 71.5–
73.5, and 75–76 dB(A), respectively, for
Three prediction models, namely Burgess, Fagotti, Arumugam Pillai Road.
and NAISS, were used. Data analysis was carried For Permatang Batu Road (Fig. 5b), the
out using Eqs. (3), (4), and (5) for each model, predicted Leq values ranged between 73.8 and 74.9.
respectively. Fig. 5a shows that that the Leq value Those determined by the Burgess, Fagotti, and
measured was between 75.8 and 76.3 dB(A), NAISS models were 69.7–71, 69–70, and 74.9–
whereas the Leq values predicted by the Burgess, 75.9 dB(A), respectively. The results of the
7
Aziz et al.
Assessment of Traffic Noise Pollution in Bukit Mertajam, Malaysia and Erbil City, Iraq
comparison of the different models show that the accurately corresponded to the values determined
NAISS model is more suitable for both locations by the NAISS model than to the other empirical
because the measured traffic noise values more relationships.
Fig. 5a: Leq comparison between different variants of traffic noise prediction model for Arumugam Pillai Road
Fig. 5b: Leq comparison between different variants of traffic noise prediction model for Permatang Batu Road
3.4. Noise level in Erbil City decreased for both roads (Fig. 6a). Fig. 6b shows
an almost similar trend for Peshawa Qazi and Erbil
Fig. 6a shows the SPL measurements for Kirkuk Koysinjaq Roads, where the highest SPL was
and Shaqlawa Roads. The SPL values were higher recorded during the morning followed by a
during the peak hours particularly during the decrease in mid-day hours. A sudden decrease in
mornings, and then decreased gradually until 11 SPL was observed for Peshawa Qazi Road after 12
AM. This decrease continued until 1 PM for PM. From 1 PM onwards, the increasing SPL trend
Kirkuk Road and 2 PM for Shaqlawa Road. From was similar to that observed for Erbil Koysinjaq
2 to 3 PM, the SPL increased and then gradually Road.
8
Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 1(3), pp. 1-11, 2012
Fig. 6b: Variation of SPL for Peshawa Qazi and Koysinjaq Roads
At the edge of the roads, SPL values of 50–85 on SPL for these roads. The increase in distance
dB were recorded. This result agrees with the between the sound source and receiver decreased
average value 85 dB mentioned by Davis and the SPL value. Correlation models can be used to
Cornwell (2008) and Kiely (1997). To observe the describe the variations in SPL values with distance.
changes in SPL level with distance, the noise level A mathematical model was derived to represent the
was measured at 0, 10, and 20 m for two nearby relationship of SPL and the distance between the
roads, namely, Kurdistan and Barzani Namr sound source and receiver (m).
Roads. Figs. 7a and 7b show the effect of distance
Where D is the distance between the sound determination (r2) for the mathematical model was
source and receiver (m). The coefficient of 0.9846, indicating a good relationship.
9
Aziz et al.
Assessment of Traffic Noise Pollution in Bukit Mertajam, Malaysia and Erbil City, Iraq
Fig. 7b: Variation of SPL for Barzani Namr Road at different distances
3.5. Comparison of the noise levels of Bukit evenings, the SPL decreased. The noise levels
Mertajam and Erbil City measured at various distances showed a decreasing
tendency with increasing distance from the
The traffic noise levels for Bukit Mertajam were receiver. Noise level can be reduced by designing
relatively lower than the values measured for Erbil vehicle enclosures for engines and producing
City in the mornings. The Leq values obtained for better-designed mufflers. Reductions in speed limit
Arumugam Pillai and Permatang Batu Roads (Figs. can also be considered because noticeable
2a and 2b) showed little variability in the peak decreases also occur at reduced vehicle speeds.
hours compared with those of Kirkuk, Shaqlawa,
Peshawa Qazi, and Koysinjaq Roads (Figs. 6a and REFERENCES
6b). The noise levels measured for evenings in
Bukit Mertajam were highly variable than were the Abo-Qudais S, Alhiary A (2007). Statistical
corresponding values for Erbil City. The Leq values models for traffic noise at signalized
observed for Erbil City showed a decreasing trend, intersections. Journal of Building
whereas those for Bukit Mertajam were at their Environment, 42(8): 2939–2948.
maximum during the evening hours. Agarwal S, Swami BL (2010). Comprehensive
approach for the development of traffic
4. CONCLUSION noise prediction model for Jaipur City.
Journal of Environmental Monitoring and
For both Arumugam Pillai and Permatang Batu Assessment, 172(1–4): 113–120.
Roads, traffic flow and volume were high during Al-Mutairi NZ, Al-Attar MA, Al-Rukaibi FS
the peak periods, and the highest PCU value was (2011). Traffic-generated noise pollution:
recorded during the evenings. Time mean speeds Exposure of road users and populations in
were 46.7 and 52 km/h with standard deviations of Metropolitan Kuwait. Journal of
7.26 and 10.40 for Arumugam Pillai Road and Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,
Permatang Batu Road, respectively. The 183(1–4): 65–75.
corresponding 85th percentile values were 54.5 and Barros CP, Dieke PUC, (2008). Choice valuation
64 km/h. The noise level in Leq for the studied of traffic restrictions: Noise, pollution, and
locations varied between 74 and 76 dB(A), while congestion preferences. Journal of Transport
the average background noise level was between Research Part D: Transport and
60 and 65 dB(A), which exceeds Malaysian DOE Environment, 13 (50): 347–350.
guidelines. Burgess AA, (1997). Noise prediction for urban
Among the three models used in this study for traffic conditions-related to measurements in
noise level measurements, the NAISS model the Sydney meteropolitan area. Journal of
proved more accurate followed by the Burgess and Applied Acoustics, 10(1): 1–7.
Fagotti models. The SPL was generally higher in Cvetković D, Praščević M, Stojanović V (1997).
the mornings for Erbil City. A drastic decrease was NAISS-Model for traffic noise prediction.
observed during the early afternoons followed by a The scientific journal FACTA Universitatis,
gradual increase between 2 and 4 PM. In the early
10
Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 1(3), pp. 1-11, 2012
Series: Working and Living Environmental Li B, Tao S, Dawson RW, (2002). A GIS based
Protection, 1(2): 73–81. road traffic noise prediction model. Journal
Davis ML, Cornwell DA (2008). Introduction to of Applied Acoustics, 63(6): 679–691.
environmental engineering. Boston, [Mass.]; Ma G, Tian Y, Ju T, Ren Z (2006). Assessment of
Montreal, McGraw-Hill International traffic noise pollution from 1989-2003 in
Edition. Lanzhou City. Journal of Environmental
Doygun H, Gurun DK (2008). Analysing and Monitoring and Assessment, 123(1–3): 413–
mapping spatial and temporal dynamics of 430.
urban traffic noise pollution: a case study in Morillas JMB, Escobar VG, Sierra JAM, Gomez
Kahramanmaraş, Turkey. Journal of RV, Carmona JT, (2002). An environmental
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, noise study in the city of Caceres, Spain.
142(1–3): 65–72. Journal of Applied Acoustics, 63(10): 1061–
El-Fadel M, Baaj SMH, Saliby E (2002). 1070.
Parametric sensitivity analysis of noise Nijland HA, Wee GPV (2005). Traffic noise in
impact of multi-highways in urban areas. Europe: A comparison of calculation
Journal of Environmental Impact methods, noise indices, and noise standards
Assessment Review, 22(2): 145–162. for road and railroad traffic in Europe.
Fagotti C, Poggi A (1995). Traffic noise abatement Transport Reviews: A Transnational
strategies: The analysis of real case not Transdisciplinary Journal, 25(5): 591–612.
really effective. Paper presented at the 18th Onnu MU, (2000). Road traffic noise in Nigeria,
International Conference for Noise measurement, analysis and evaluation of
Abatement, Bologna, Italy, 223–233. nuisance. Journal of Sound and Vibration,
Filho JMA, Lenzi A, Zannin PHT (2004). Effects 233(30): 391–405.
of traffic composition on road noise: A case Phan HYT, Yano T, Sato T, Nishimura T (2010).
study. Journal of Transportation Research Characteristics of road traffic noise in Hanoi
Part D: Transport and Environment, 9(1): and Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. Journal of
75–80. Applied Acoustics, 71(5): 479–485.
Highway Planning Unit (HPU) (1994). Traffic Public Works Department (PWD) (1986). A guide
study for Malaysia. Final report, Lee and on geometric design of roads. Public Works
Co. Consultant, Transportation Research and Headquarter’s Branch, Branch Road, Kuala
Engineering (Ltd.) and Institution for Lumpur.
Transport Studies, Kuala Lumpur. Sturges HA, (1926). The choice of a class interval.
Jamrah A, Al-Omari A, Sharabi R (2006). Journal of the American Statistical
Evaluation of Traffic Noise Pollution in Association, 21(153): 65–66.
Amman, Jordan. Journal of Environmental Zannin PHT, Calixto A, Diniz FB, Ferreira JAC,
Monitoring and Assessment, 120: 499–525. (2003). A survey of urban noise annoyance
Kiely G (1997). Environmental Engineering. in large Brazilian City: The importance of a
McGraw-Hill: London. subjective analysis in conjunction with an
Li B, Tao S (2004). Influence of expanding ring objective analysis. Journal of Environmental
roads on traffic noise in Beijing City. Impact Assessment Review, 23(2): 245–255.
Journal of Applied Acoustics, 65(3): 243–
249.
11