Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
in the
Management of Insomnia
Balancing
Pathophysiology
and Therapeutics
Distributed with
2 Target Audience
This activity has been designed to meet the educational needs
of physicians involved in the management of patients with
insomnia disorder.
Statement of Need/Program Overview
An estimated 40 to 70 million Americans are affected by
Faculty insomnia. According to these estimates, twice as many Americans
suffer from insomnia than from major depression. However, the
Larry Culpepper, MD, MPH—Co-Chair true prevalence of insomnia is unknown because it is
underdiagnosed and underreported. Recent updates in the
Professor and Chairman of Family Medicine
nosology and diagnostic criteria for insomnia have occurred as
Boston University School of Medicine well as advances in understanding pathophysiology, which, in
Boston University Medical Center turn, has led to the development of potential new treatments.
Boston, Massachusetts The burden of medical, psychiatric, interpersonal, and societal
consequences that can be attributed to insomnia and the
Tom Roth, PhD—Co-Chair prevalence of patients with insomnia disorder treated in primary
Director of Research care underscore the importance of continuing medical education
Sleep Disorders and Research Center (CME) that improves the clinical understanding, diagnosis, and
Henry Ford Hospital treatment of the disorder by primary care providers. This
continuing education activity is based on an expert roundtable
Detroit, Michigan
discussion and literature review and provides an update in
insomnia disorder.
Sonia Ancoli-Israel, PhD
Professor Emeritus of Psychiatry and Medicine Educational Objectives
Professor of Research After completing this activity, the participant should be better
University of California, San Diego able to:
• Perform a rapid assessment that leads to a diagnosis of
La Jolla, California
insomnia disorder
• Summarize the proposed pathophysiology of
Andrew Krystal, MD insomnia disorder
Director, Insomnia and Sleep Research Program • Evaluate current and emerging nonpharmacologic and
Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences pharmacologic therapies for insomnia disorder
Duke University Medical Center • Appropriately select therapy for individual patients
Durham, North Carolina with insomnia disorder
Accreditation Statement
Phyllis Zee, MD, PhD This activity has been planned and implemented in accordance
Benjamin and Virginia T. Boshes Professor in Neurology with the Essential Areas and policies of the Accreditation Council
Director, Sleep Disorders Center for Continuing Medical Education through the joint sponsorship
Northwestern University of Postgraduate Institute for Medicine and MedEdicus LLC. The
Chicago, Illinois Postgraduate Institute for Medicine is accredited by the ACCME
to provide continuing medical education for physicians.
Credit Designation
The Postgraduate Institute for Medicine designates this enduring
material for a maximum of 1.5 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit(s)™.
Physicians should claim only the credit commensurate with the
extent of their participation in the activity.
Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest
Postgraduate Institute for Medicine (PIM) requires instructors,
planners, managers, and other individuals who are in a position to
control the content of this activity to disclose any real or apparent
conflict of interest (COI) they may have as related to the content
of this activity. All identified COI are thoroughly vetted and
resolved according to PIM policy. PIM is committed to providing
its learners with high quality CME activities and related materials
that promote improvements or quality in healthcare and not a
specific proprietary business interest of a commercial interest.
Faculty Disclosures Method of Participation and Request for Credit
The faculty reported the following financial relationships or There are no fees for participating and receiving CME credit for
relationships to products or devices they or their spouse/life this activity. During the period October 10, 2013, through
partner have with commercial interests related to the content of October 31, 2014, participants must read the learning objectives
this CME activity: and faculty disclosures and study the educational activity.
Sonia Ancoli-Israel, PhD, had a financial agreement or affiliation PIM supports Green CME by offering your Request for Credit
during the past year with the following commercial interests in online. If you wish to receive acknowledgment for completing this
the form of Consultant Fees: Ferring Pharmaceuticals; Merck & activity, please complete the post-test and evaluation on
Co.; and Prudue Pharma L.P. www.cmeuniversity.com. On the navigation menu, click on
Larry Culpepper, MD, MPH, had a financial agreement or “Find Post-test/Evaluation by Course” and search by course ID
affiliation during the past year with the following commercial 9496. Upon registering and successfully completing the post-test
interests in the form of Consultant Fees: Boehringer Ingelheim with a score of 70% or better and the activity evaluation, your
Pharmaceuticals Inc.; Forest Labs; Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc.; certificate will be made available immediately.
Jazz Pharmaceuticals plc; H. Lundbeck A/S; Merck & Co.; Media
Pfizer Inc.; Reckitt Benckiser Pharmaceuticals Inc.; Sunovion Monograph
Pharmaceuticals Inc.; and Takeda Pharmaceuticals Inc.
Speakers Bureau: Merck & Co. Ownership Interest: M3 Disclosure of Unlabeled Use
(My Mood Monitor). This educational activity may contain discussion of published
Andrew Krystal, MD, had a financial agreement or affiliation and/or investigational uses of agents that are not indicated by the
during the past year with the following commercial interests in FDA. The planners of this activity do not recommend the use of
the form of Consultant Fees: Abbott Laboratories; AstraZeneca; any agent outside of the labeled indications.
Bristol-Myers Squibb; Eisai Inc.; Jazz Pharmaceuticals plc; The opinions expressed in the educational activity are those of the
Johnson & Johnson; Merck & Co.; Neurocrine Biosciences, Inc.; faculty and do not necessarily represent the views of the planners.
Novartis; Respironics, Inc.; Roche; Sunovion Pharmaceuticals Please refer to the official prescribing information for each
Inc.; and Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd. Contracted product for discussion of approved indications, contraindications,
Research: Abbott Laboratories; Astellas Pharma; Brainsway; and warnings.
National Institutes of Health; NeoSynch; Pfizer Inc.; St. Jude
Medical (for Advanced Neuromodulation Systems [ANS]); and
Disclaimer
Participants have an implied responsibility to use the newly
Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd.
acquired information to enhance patient outcomes and their
Tom Roth, PhD, had a financial agreement or affiliation during own professional development. The information presented in
the past year with the following commercial interests in the form this activity is not meant to serve as a guideline for patient
of Consultant Fees: Jazz Pharmaceuticals plc; Merck & Co.; management. Any procedures, medications, or other courses
Neurocrine Biosciences, Inc.; Novartis; Pfizer Inc.; Purdue of diagnosis or treatment discussed or suggested in this activity
Pharma L.P.; Speakers Bureau: Purdue Pharma L.P. Contracted should not be used by clinicians without evaluation of their
Research: Impax Laboratories, Inc.; Valeant Pharmaceuticals patient’s conditions and possible contraindications and/or
(for CeraVe). dangers in use, review of any applicable manufacturer’s product
Phyllis C. Zee, MD, PhD, had a financial agreement or affiliation information, and comparison with recommendations of
during the past year with the following commercial interests in other authorities.
the form of Consultant Fees: Ferring Pharmaceuticals; Jazz
Pharmaceuticals plc; Merck & Co.; Purdue Pharma L.P.; Takeda
Pharmaceuticals Inc.; Vanda Pharmaceuticals Inc.; and UCB, Inc.
Contracted Research: Philips Respironics. Ownership Interest: Teva
Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd.
The planners and managers reported the following financial
relationships or relationships to products or devices they or their
spouse/life partner have with commercial interests related to the
content of this CME activity:
The following PIM planners and managers, Laura Excell, ND,
NP, MS, MA, LPC, NCC, Trace Hutchison, PharmD, Samantha
Mattiucci, PharmD, CCMEP, and Jan Schultz, RN, MSN,
CCMEP, and the following MedEdicus editors and planners,
Casey Covrett, PharmD, BCPS, and Cynthia Tornallyay, RD,
MBA, CCMEP, hereby state that they or their spouse/life partner
do not have any financial relationships or relationships to
products or devices with any commercial interest related to the
content of this activity of any amount during the past 12 months.
3
4 Pathophysiology of Insomnia
Introduction Current research suggests that insomnia is a disorder of
An estimated 40 to 70 million Americans have insomnia.1 “hyperarousal” that is present 24 hours each day. The
According to these estimates, twice as many Americans suffer from pathophysiology of insomnia is multifactorial and may be thought
insomnia than from major depression.2 Patients with insomnia of in terms of dysregulation involving the following 3 components:
frequently report physical and emotional health problems, neurophysiologic hyperactivation of the sympathetic nervous
compromised social functioning, and daytime distress. Common system; neuroendocrine dysregulation of hormones associated with
risk factors for insomnia include female gender, advanced age, arousal; and cognitive/behavioral responses directed toward sleep
comorbid disease, and occupations involving shift work. that perpetuate arousal. Expert insights on the pathophysiology of
Importantly, comorbid medical disorders are becoming more insomnia from the roundtable discussion will be presented. Figure 1
appreciated as risk factors for insomnia. presents a schematic diagram of the 24-hour sleep-wake cycle.5
Work productivity is negatively impacted by insomnia. In the 2009 Dr Tom Roth: For years we had this idea that insomnia is an
US Workers America Insomnia Survey, presenteeism (low on-the-job abnormality of the sleep system. Increasingly, we have learned that
work performance defined in the metric of lost workday equivalents) insomnia is not an abnormality of the sleep system, but it is an
accounted for nearly 8 days of annual lost work performance per abnormality of the wake/arousal system. Over a decade ago, Saper
worker, equating to $2280 in individual-level human capital value. and colleagues proposed the flip-flop switch model of sleep-wake
When extrapolated to the entire US workforce over the course of a regulation,6 which contains 2 sets of mutually inhibitory neural
year, insomnia causes 252.7 million days of lost work performance, elements: wake-promoting influences on 1 side and sleep-promoting
resulting in a loss of $63.2 billion.3 influences on the other. The monoaminergic nuclei (MN) are a
major influence of the wake-promoting system, and sleep is
The magnitude of insomnia-related problems has spurred research,
resulting in an improved understanding of the disorder. Over the influenced by the ventrolateral preoptic nucleus (VLPO), which is a
past decade, several changes have been made with regard to the group of cells that generate non-rapid eye movement (NREM) and
nosology of insomnia, most notably the recent realization that rapid eye movement (REM) stages of sleep (Figure 2).5 In patients
insomnia is a disorder. In the past, insomnia was thought to be with normal sleep, the flip-flop switch makes sudden transitions
secondary to another medical condition. The Diagnostic and between sleep and wakefulness, which explains why a limited
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5), amount of time is spent in these transitional states throughout the
has recently renamed the diagnosis as insomnia disorder, course of a 24-hour day (Figure 3).6 In patients with insomnia,
emphasizing that insomnia is a disorder in its own right even however, their ability to turn off the wake-promoting influences of
though it typically coexists with other comorbid medical the flip-flop switch is weakened, resulting in extended periods of
conditions, including depression, anxiety, chronic pain, and time in transitional states and a prolonged state of wake.
cardiovascular diseases.4 In addition, the Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text For years we had this idea that insomnia is
Revision, diagnostic criteria have been updated in the DSM-5 to an abnormality of the sleep system. Increasingly, we
include more stringent measures regarding the chronicity of
insomnia-related symptoms. For the purpose of this monograph,
have learned that insomnia is not an abnormality
the term insomnia will be used as a disorder that meets the of the sleep system, but it is an abnormality of the
DSM-5 criteria, which include the following: (1) difficulty falling wake/arousal system. —Dr Tom Roth
and/or staying asleep; (2) the sleep difficulty is accompanied by
next-day symptoms of distress/impairment; (3) sleep-related
symptoms occur at least 3 times per week for a minimum of
3 months; and (4) symptoms persist despite adequate
Dr Andrew Krystal: There are a number of objective measures that
opportunities and circumstances to sleep.4
support this model of hyperarousal, including elevations in heart
Insomnia is a prevalent and costly public health concern that is rate and heart rate variability. For example, Bonnet and Arand
associated with significant long-term effects on physical, performed a 36-hour study that showed the heart rate increased and
psychological, and occupational functioning. In order to minimize the mean heart rate variability decreased in all stages of sleep in the
the societal impact of insomnia and the burden it creates on the group of people with insomnia compared to the control group of
healthcare system, families, and patients, clinicians need to people who have normal sleep.7 Studies have also found that
improve their recognition and treatment of insomnia as well as patients with insomnia, when compared to controls, have higher
coexisting medical conditions. This approach starts with having an metabolic rates throughout the course of a 24-hour day, further
initial discussion with patients regarding the quality of their sleep. suggesting arousal in the wake-promoting regions in the brain.8
Despite its prevalence, insomnia remains undertreated and Dr Larry Culpepper: There appears to be a neuroendocrine
underreported. Patients are reluctant to seek medical treatment, component to this condition as well. Vgontzas and colleagues
and sleep is not commonly discussed during office visits. This found that levels of adrenocorticotropic hormone and cortisol
continuing medical education/continuing education (CME/CE) were significantly elevated in patients with insomnia compared to
activity is designed to update readers on the pathophysiology of matched controls, which results in increased arousal and
insomnia, the interrelationships of insomnia and comorbid associated sleeplessness. In addition, patients with a higher degree
disease, and new directions in the management of insomnia. of sleep disturbance secreted more cortisol compared to those
with less sleep disturbance.9
Test Questions
Hour 0 Hour 24
NREM REM
Figure 1. A schematic diagram of the sleep-wake cycle. When transitioning into sleep, an individual begins in non-rapid eye movement (NREM) and
remains in this stage for approximately 85 minutes. After this initial stage of NREM, the brain switches to rapid eye movement (REM) for approximately
5 to 10 minutes before switching back to NREM. This 90-minute pattern continues throughout the night, with REM intervals becoming longer and
NREM intervals becoming shorter until wakefulness occurs. Disruptions in this defined pattern of sleep and wakefulness result in disturbances in sleep.
Adapted from Rogers and Holmes, 2012.5
Test Questions
6 24 hours a day that expresses itself periodically. The criteria for
insomnia disorder specify that sleep disturbances must occur at
least 3 days a week for a minimum of 3 months for us to consider
a diagnosis of insomnia.4
Dr Larry Culpepper: What do we know about the underlying
brain activity or factors that contribute to this hyperarousal?
Dr Andrew Krystal: I don’t think we know all that much about it.
We know the wake system is more active during sleep in patients
with insomnia, at least to some degree. Additionally, the
psychopathological and behavioral patterns of sleep appear to play
a significant role in some patients with sleep problems. For
example, when people experience multiple nights of bad sleep and
frustration within their sleeping environment, they begin to
develop the expectation of poor sleep. This expectation becomes a
perpetuating factor that creates stress and increased activity of the
sympathetic nervous system. In addition to the neuroendocrine
and physiologic components of hyperarousal, there appears to be
a behavioral/psychopathological element to this condition.
Please rate this past week’s severity of the None Mild Moderate Severe Very severe
following insomnia problems:
1. Difficulty falling asleep 0 1 2 3 4
Scoring: 0-7 No clinically significant insomnia; 8-14 Sub-threshold insomnia; 15-21 Moderate clinical insomnia; 22-28 Severe clinical
insomnia. Adapted from Morin et al, 2001.13
Test Questions
Table 3. DSM-5 Insomnia Disorder Criteria 780.52 (G47.00)
Test Questions
8 Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel: And since insomnia is its own disorder, Dr Larry Culpepper: It’s also important to remember that the
you treat it once you’ve made a diagnosis. very treatment of the comorbid condition itself may lead to
insomnia-related symptoms. Respiratory stimulants, selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors, beta blockers, and many other drug
And since insomnia is its own disorder, you treat it classes are associated with reports of disturbed sleep (Table 5).19
once you’ve made a diagnosis. —Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel Table 5. Common Medications That Contribute to Insomnia19
Drug class Medications
Antidepressants Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors
(fluoxetine, citalopram, sertraline, paroxetine),
Dr Larry Culpepper: I think what Dr Ancoli-Israel mentioned is venlafaxine, duloxetine
the single most important message to relay to primary care Decongestants Pseudoephedrine, phenylephrine
clinicians. In the past, we clinicians have been under the false
Cardiovascular Beta blockers, alpha-receptor antagonists, diuretics
impression that when an existing comorbid condition resolves—
for instance, depression—insomnia would go away as well. And Respiratory Theophylline, albuterol
that, quite often, is not the case. Stimulants Methylphenidate, ephedrine, amphetamines
Dr Tom Roth: If you look at people with depression when they Opioids Codeine, oxycodone
go into remission, the most common residual symptom is
difficulty sleeping. It is important to understand that the number
of residual symptoms linearly predicts time to relapse of Differentiating Circadian Rhythm
depression. The Sequenced Treatment Alternatives to Relieve Disorders From Insomnia
Depression (STAR*D) trial described the types and frequency of Insomnia is occasionally comorbid with other sleep conditions,
residual depressive symptoms and their relationship to including disorders in circadian rhythm. Table 6 lists common
depressive relapse after treatment with citalopram.15 More than circadian rhythm sleep disorders (CRSDs) that may occur in
90% of the patients with depression who went into remission had conjunction with insomnia20; however, the effective treatments
at least 1 residual depressive symptom, and the most common for CRSDs are very different, emphasizing the importance of
residual symptom domain was sleep-related disturbance differentiating sleep-related symptoms of CRSDs from insomnia.
(71.7%).15 The study revealed that having a greater number of
residual symptoms was associated with a higher probability of Table 6. Circadian Rhythm Sleep Disorders20
relapse. The point is that treating insomnia enables you to better Irregular sleep-wake rhythm disorder (ISWD) occurs when a person’s
manage coexisting disorders. sleep pattern is undefined, which typically includes a series of naps
throughout the 24-hour sleep-wake cycle. ISWD is common in elderly
Dr Andrew Krystal: As mentioned earlier, the error clinicians patients with comorbid medical disorders, such as Alzheimer’s disease.
have made in the past is undertreating insomnia, expecting Delayed sleep phase disorder (DSPD) is a pattern of going to bed late in
insomnia to get better once the symptoms of a comorbid the evening/early morning and sleeping until late in the afternoon. DSPD
condition improved. Moreover, clinicians should consider the is common in teenagers.
possibility of underlying comorbid conditions when patients Advanced sleep phase disorder (ASPD) is a pattern of early
present with symptoms suggestive of insomnia. Research shows evening sleepiness and early morning awakening. ASPD is common
that insomnia is a known risk factor for other disorders, most in elderly patients.
notably depression and anxiety. One of the classic studies, the Shift work disorder occurs when a person’s work hours are scheduled
Johns Hopkins Precursors Study, evaluated the associations during the normal sleep period.
between self-reported sleep disturbances and subsequent clinical
Non-24-hour sleep disorder occurs when the suprachiasmatic nucleus
depression among medical students (classes 1948-1964; mean does not receive light from the external environment, resulting in a
follow-up period of 34 years).16 Patients who reported insomnia sleep-wake cycle that shifts later each day. Non-24-hour disorder is
symptoms during medical school were twice as likely to develop common in patients who are totally blind.
clinical depression compared to those without insomnia Adapted from Sack et al, 2007.20
symptoms. Clinicians need to assess whether or not there are
underlying comorbid conditions, such as depression, which may Current and Emerging Treatment
be intensifying the symptoms of insomnia.
for Insomnia
Dr Phyllis Zee: There is also research to suggest that insomnia
may serve as a risk factor of cardiometabolic disease. A recent The Role of Behavioral Treatment Interventions in
study that evaluated the impact of sleep on levels of fasting Insomnia Disorder
glucose, fasting insulin, and estimated insulin resistance showed It is widely accepted that psychological and behavioral factors
that insomnia was associated with a 23% higher fasting glucose play significant roles in hyperarousal. Interventions that target
level and a 48% higher fasting insulin level in patients with type 2 these factors play an important part in the management of
diabetes.17 In addition, Vgontzas and colleagues evaluated the insomnia disorder (Table 7).21 Several studies have reported the
joint effects of insomnia and short sleep duration on diabetes effects of behavioral treatment methods administered to patients
risk.18 They showed that patients with insomnia and sleep with chronic insomnia.22 Patients reported significant increases in
duration of less than 5 hours were at significantly higher risk of sleep time as well as improvements in sleep latency, total wake
developing diabetes compared to people who have normal sleep. time, and sleep efficiency after behavioral interventions. The
Test Questions
Table 7. Common Evidence-Based Cognitive and Behavioral Therapies
for Insomnia21
Cognitive behavioral therapies target these
Sleep hygiene therapy involves teaching healthy lifestyle practices to negative learned responses and essentially reteach
improve sleep. Sleep hygiene is recommended to be used in conjunction
with other cognitive and behavioral therapies. Patients are instructed to an individual how to sleep. —Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel
(including but not limited to): avoid napping, maintain a regular exercise
program and healthy diet, sleep in a quiet, dark environment, and avoid
stimulants such as caffeine and nicotine at least 6 hours before bedtime.
Stimulus control therapy is designed to re-associate the bedroom with the Dr Larry Culpepper: Even a short course of behavioral therapy can
rapid onset of sleep. Once in bed, if the patient is unable to fall asleep in be very effective. In a study involving nurse practitioners trained to
what seems to be about 20 minutes (without looking at a clock), he or she
is instructed to leave the bedroom to engage in a relaxing activity and return provide behavioral therapy, individuals with chronic insomnia
to bed when sleepy (repeat this as necessary). The objective of stimulus either received a short course of behavioral therapy, consisting of
control therapy is to limit wake time in bed. Patients should be cautioned 2 intervention sessions and 2 telephone calls, or they received
about the possibility of daytime sleepiness during the course of therapy. printed educational materials.24 A total of 67% of the individuals
Sleep restriction therapy limits time in bed to the amount of time actually treated with behavioral therapy showed a clinical response, compared
spent sleeping (normally derived from a sleep log). This approach is to 25% in the control group. In addition, 55% of those in the
designed to improve sleep continuity by using sleep restriction to enhance behavioral treatment group no longer met the criteria for insomnia
sleep drive (the ability to sleep). Once sleep efficiency improves, the at study completion, compared to 13% in the control group.
allowed time in bed is gradually increased by 15 to 30 minutes over a period
of several weeks until optimal sleep duration is achieved. The objective of Behavioral therapy is achievable in the primary care setting and
sleep restriction therapy is to limit wake time in bed. Patients should be can be performed by a physician or another clinician.
cautioned about the possibility of daytime sleepiness during the course of therapy.
Relaxation training is a technique that uses muscle relaxation, guided Behavioral therapy is achievable in the primary
imagery, and/or abdominal breathing exercises to lower arousal states that
interfere with sleep.
care setting and can be performed by a physician or
another clinician. —Dr Larry Culpepper
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I) is a combination
of behavioral therapy (eg, sleep restriction, stimulus control) and
psychotherapeutic methods, which involve identifying dysfunctional
beliefs about sleep and replacing them with more positive alternatives.
Test Questions
10 Dr Phyllis Zee: Some patients have tried exercising in the late pharmacokinetics. The nonbenzodiazepines tend to have much
evening, but that has shown to actually phase shift (delay) shorter half-lives, which typically minimizes next-day sedation.
circadian rhythms. Not only does exercising late in the evening However, female gender and concomitant medications, such as
enhance symptoms of sympathetic arousal but, at the same time, clarithromycin, have been shown to influence the rate at which
you’re giving the wrong signal to the circadian clock. some of these medications are metabolized.
Dr Tom Roth: I do not think these insights are unique to sleep Dr Andrew Krystal: There appears to be differences among
medicine. For example, there are several different methods to agents within the nonbenzodiazepine drug class itself. When
treat obesity, but they are all roads to the same outcome. The escitalopram plus zolpidem controlled-release (CR) were
exact same thing is true for behavioral therapy. There is no secret administered to patients with insomnia and comorbid anxiety,
road to the goal of improving sleep, and it is up to the clinician, his sleep-related parameters improved but anxiety scores did not.29
or her resources, the patient’s interest, and the patient’s However, when escitalopram plus eszopiclone were administered
sophistication as to what the best road to that goal might be. to a similar patient population, both insomnia and anxiety scores
improved significantly. This difference appears to be related to the
Prescription Medications effects on additional GABAA receptor subunits, which are
Table 9 lists medications approved by the US Food and Drug associated with anxiolysis.30 The point is that these medications
Administration (FDA) for the treatment of insomnia. There are seem to differ clinically, and if you want to help people in terms of
myriad medications that are used to treat insomnia, including insomnia with comorbid anxiety, eszopiclone is probably a better
tricyclic antidepressants, antipsychotics, and herbal medications, adjunctive therapy than zolpidem CR.
which have not received regulatory approval for insomnia. Within
each medication class, there are differences in pharmacokinetic/ Dr Larry Culpepper: Studies have also found that eszopiclone
pharmacodynamic indices, which allow clinicians to prescribe improves insomnia and depression scores when coadministered
patient-specific interventions. Clinicians should consider the with fluoxetine.31 In addition to improvements in sleep parameters
following factors when selecting a pharmacologic agent: at each time point in the study, the eszopiclone cotherapy group
(1) symptom patterns; (2) comorbid conditions; (3) concurrent showed significantly greater changes in 17-item Hamilton Rating
medications; (4) contraindications; (5) side effects; and (6) cost. Scale for Depression (HAM-D-17) scores, and a significantly
With the exception of low-dose doxepin, the most recently FDA- greater number of patients achieved remission from depression.
approved medications have short half-lives and work during the Dr Phyllis Zee: There are some medications, including
first few hours of sleep, without significant sleep maintenance eszopiclone and low-dose doxepin, that are indicated for sleep
effects. In contrast, emerging therapies have longer half-lives and maintenance insomnia, whereas other medications, such as
will presumably have improved effects on sleep maintenance. zaleplon, are not (Table 9).
Expert guidance in the pharmacologic treatment of insomnia and
sleep-related disorders will be presented. Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel: I think that is a major point. An
important aspect of selecting insomnia medications is matching
Dr Andrew Krystal: The older sleep agents are the the medication with the patient’s sleep complaint. If a patient is
benzodiazepines, which potentiate inhibition mediated by having difficulty staying asleep, but not falling asleep, you have to
GABAA receptors through binding to a benzodiazepine site on the think about a medication in which the action is going to be
GABAA receptor complex. Benzodiazepines work on the sleep maintained during the second half of the night, as opposed to just
side of the flip-flop switch. Different subtypes of the GABAA the first half of the night.
receptor are located throughout the central nervous system, and
benzodiazepines bind to these receptors without specificity;
An important aspect of selecting insomnia
therefore, not only do they enhance sleep but they also shut down
different parts of the brain that we might not want them to, medications is matching the medication with the
leading to unwanted side effects, including balance and memory patient’s sleep complaint. —Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel
problems.27 Medications that potentiate GABAA receptor activity
by binding to the benzodiazepine binding site appear to have
some degree of abuse potential, but the abuse seems to be limited
to a subgroup of the population prone to substance abuse.
Generally speaking, the majority of people take these medications Dr Tom Roth: When you look at the existing treatment options that
for therapeutic purposes. Compared to benzodiazepines, work on the sleep system, none of the GABAA receptor agonists
nonbenzodiazepines demonstrate greater selectivity in terms of really have major sleep maintenance effects. They actually have sleep
preferential binding to a subset of GABAA receptors, affecting maintenance effects for 3, 4, and 5 hours at the max. The reason for
specific subunits that have regional effects in brain function. To that is very simple. If you have effects that last for 6, 7, and 8 hours
date, 6 subunits have been identified, and, with the exception of with medications that potentiate the GABA system, you are going to
eszopiclone, the nonbenzodiazepines preferentially bind the alpha have significant next-day impairment. This, in part, explains why a
1 subunit, which is primarily associated with sedation.28 Because lot of clinicians tend to use off-label medications, including atypical
the mechanism of action for nonbenzodiazepines is limited to the antipsychotics and antidepressants. Among approximately 900
alpha 1 subunit, they do not appear to relax muscles or provide million office visits that took place in 2006, an estimated 30 million
anxiolysis to the same degree as benzodiazepines. visits included a prescription for insomnia without depression listed
as comorbidity; nearly half of these prescriptions were for
Dr Tom Roth: A major difference between the classic antidepressants.32 Compared to medications that work on the
benzodiazepines and nonbenzodiazepines relates to GABA system, the majority of off-label medications have longer
Test Questions
Table 9. Commonly Prescribed FDA-Approved Insomnia Medications
Brand name Generic name Half-life FDA-approved indications Available doses
Histamine receptor antagonist (H1)
Silenor® Doxepin 15 hrs Sleep maintenance 3 mg, 6 mg
Melatonin receptor agonist (M1 and M2)
Rozerem® Ramelteon 2.6 hrs Sleep onset 8 mg
GABAA-receptor agonists: nonbenzodiazepines
*For all zolpidem products, the lowest available dose is recommended when initiating treatment in women
Sonata® Zaleplon 1 hr Sleep onset 5 mg, 10 mg
Edluar® Zolpidem 2.5 hrs Sleep onset 5 mg, 10 mg
(Sublingual tablet)
Ambien® Zolpidem 2.5 hrs Sleep onset 5 mg, 10 mg
ZolpiMist® Zolpidem 2.5 hrs Sleep onset 1 spray = 5 mg
(Oral spray)
Intermezzo® Zolpidem 2.5 hrs Middle-of-the-night awakenings 1.75 mg, 3.5 mg
(Sublingual tablet)
Ambien CR® Zolpidem 2.5 hrs Sleep onset 6.25 mg, 12.5 mg
(Controlled-release) Sleep maintenance
Lunesta® Eszopiclone 5-7 hrs Sleep onset 1 mg, 2 mg, 3 mg
Sleep maintenance
half-lives, resulting in sleep maintenance effects in 6, 7, and 8 hours. Dr Tom Roth: The best example of this is low-dose doxepin. In
These medications are effective because they target receptors the past, doxepin had been prescribed at doses as high as 25 mg to
involved in the wake system, including histamine, dopamine, and 100 mg for the treatment of insomnia. After a dose-response
serotonin. The wake systems are very important with regard to the study was performed, the hypnotic dose of doxepin was
pathophysiology of insomnia, and that may be why these determined to range from 3 mg to 6 mg.34 It’s not whether
medications are frequently prescribed in practice. doxepin is a good drug or a bad drug. The point is the drug’s
effects are dose dependent. At doses higher than 6 mg, doxepin
Dr Larry Culpepper: Since a number of clinicians prescribe
has significant anticholinergic effects. At doses ranging from 3 mg
off-label medications for the treatment of insomnia, the role of
to 6 mg, doxepin has limited anticholinergic effects and works
the FDA in the United States should be mentioned. The FDA has
primarily on the histamine receptor. So again, the problem with
clearly stated that hypnotic medications should be started at the
lowest possible dose and then titrated to the desired effect, using off-label medications is our lack of knowledge with regard
provided the titration can be performed safely and the lower dose to the dose-response relationships between safety and efficacy.
was ineffective. I think doxepin provides us with a clear example of that.
Nonprescription Medications
The FDA has clearly stated that hypnotic Dr Larry Culpepper: Nonprescription therapies are frequently
medications should be started at the lowest possible used by patients to treat insomnia-related symptoms, but there is
dose and then titrated to the desired effect, limited safety and efficacy data to support these therapies. For
provided the titration can be performed safely and instance, people occasionally use alcohol as a sleep aid, thinking
the lower dose was ineffective. —Dr Larry Culpepper this will improve their sleep. While alcohol has been reported to
help people fall asleep more quickly, this effect is offset by having
more disrupted sleep in the second half of the night.35
Test Questions
12 Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel: These side effects need to be avoided in evening (to keep them up later) and limiting light exposure in the
this population. Diphenhydramine, for example, has increased morning (to entrain a later wake time) would be an initial
rebound effects in the elderly (worsening of sleep compared to intervention in this type of patient. In patients with a delayed
pretreatment symptoms).36 Yet, the elderly are some of the phase disorder, the exact opposite would be prescribed. With
highest users of OTC sleep medications.37 regard to melatonin, it has demonstrated clinical benefit in
patients with CRSDs. Melatonin does not have a major role in the
Dr Andrew Krystal: A significant number of OTC sleep treatment of insomnia disorder45; however, in a patient who only
medications contain either diphenhydramine or doxylamine, has trouble falling asleep, one should consider the possibility of a
which have substantial anticholinergic effects. Consumers who delayed circadian rhythm. If an underlying circadian
see OTC sleep medications in the drug store frequently assume misalignment is present, a trial of low-dose melatonin may be
they are safer than prescription medications, but this is not useful. A low dose of melatonin would be 0.3 mg to 1 mg. It’s not
necessarily the case. approved by the FDA for the treatment of insomnia disorder.
Dr Phyllis Zee: In addition to OTC antihistamines, there are Dr Andrew Krystal: I think it’s important to emphasize that
numerous other medications that patients use to self-medicate, melatonin should not be taken right before going to bed.
rather than seeking medical attention. The 2002 National Health
Interview Survey data showed that more than 1.6 million US adults
use complementary and alternative medicine for sleep-related I think it’s important to emphasize that melatonin
symptoms.38 A total of 65% of those patients used biologically should not be taken right before going to bed.
based therapies, including herbal remedies, which have limited —Dr Andrew Krystal
safety and efficacy data and are not regulated by the FDA.
Dr Tom Roth: Falls and the risk for falling are important issues
with regard to insomnia and its treatments. The majority of data
seem to indicate that the causative factor, with regard to
Dr Phyllis Zee: I agree. Many patients with delayed sleep phase
medications, is total sedative load.39,40 If a patient is taking
medications with significant anticholinergic side effects while also disorder come to me indicating that they’ve tried melatonin, but
taking a sleep agent, there is a risk for falling. It is not linked to any it didn’t work. They usually have taken it right before bedtime,
single medication. Additionally, there are studies that show which is too late to advance the phase of circadian rhythms. To
insomnia is more of a risk factor than sleep agents.41 If you give a advance the timing of the sleep-wake cycle, the ideal time to take
medication for insomnia to patients and they sleep for 8 hours melatonin is 5 to 6 hours before the patient’s natural sleep time.
and do not get out of bed, they do not fall. However, if you have Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel: To add to what Dr. Zee was mentioning a
patients who have to get up 3 or 4 times a night because of an moment ago with regard to light, the best way for the advanced
underlying medical condition, then sleep agents are a risk. phase patients to avoid morning light is by wearing sunglasses
when they go outside because the mechanism is through the eyes.
Differentiating Treatments for Insomnia The light-dark cycle information is relayed from the retina to the
From Treatments for Circadian SCN primarily by the retinohypothalamic tract.
Rhythm Disorders Dr Tom Roth: Many elderly people are terrified of falling during
CRSDs occur when the timing of the endogenous circadian the night, so they keep a night light on. It is very important that
rhythm and the normal 24-hour sleep-wake cycle are offset. elderly people keep a night light by their bathroom but outside of
Circadian rhythms are coordinated by the suprachiasmatic the line of vision. We need light during the day, but we also need
nucleus (SCN), which is reset by light through the darkness at night.
retinohypothalamic tract.42 Although less potent than light,
Dr Phyllis Zee: If the patient needs a night light, recommend
melatonin, which is released by the pineal gland during the dark
a red filter because melatonin does not get suppressed very
cycle, resets circadian rhythm as well.43 Because they play key
easily with long-wavelength light, such as red. In contrast,
roles in stabilizing circadian rhythm, timed exposure to melatonin
and light are effective treatment methods in patients with CRSDs. short-wavelength light, such as blue, is more effective in
suppressing the secretion of melatonin from the pineal gland.
Dr Tom Roth: I would like to take a minute and have Dr Zee Short wavelength light also activates the sympathetic nervous
briefly explain the roles of melatonin and light in CRSDs. system, resulting in increased arousal.46
Dr Phyllis Zee: Light is the strongest entraining agent for the
circadian clock. Exposure to bright light in the early morning Emerging Therapies for Insomnia
induces phase advances, whereas light exposure in the evening Two separate research groups discovered orexin (also referred to
delays the phase of circadian rhythms.44 In patients with CRSDs, as hypocretin) neuropeptides, which are wake-promoting
the timing of light exposure (as a treatment intervention) is neurotransmitters produced by a cluster of neurons in the
targeted toward the patient’s presenting symptoms. For example, hypothalamus.47,48 Orexin peptides influence the patient’s
elderly patients often present with an advanced phase disorder, sleep-wake cycle, appetite, and autonomic nervous system,
which means they go to bed early at night and wake up early in the including effects on metabolic rate and behavioral responses to
morning. In this circumstance, increasing light exposure in the stress.47 The brain contains 50,000 to 80,000 orexin producing
Test Questions
neurons, which have extensive projections to many different regions Dr Larry Culpepper: We will need to adjust our thinking with
in the brain. The strongest projections appear to target wake- regard to these newer agents because they’re drastically different,
promoting regions that regulate arousal, including noradrenergic at least from a pharmacokinetic perspective. For example,
neurons of the locus coeruleus, histaminergic neurons of the suvorexant, an orexin receptor antagonist, has a half-life of
tuberomammilary nucleus, dopaminergic neurons of the ventral 12 hours.52 If this was a benzodiazepine that was affecting the
tegmental area, and serotonergic neurons of the raphe nuclei.49 GABA system, the sleep side of the switch, you could not use
The orexin neurons are predominantly active during periods of these medications because of the significant next-day impairment.
wakefulness and become less active during NREM and REM
sleep. Patients who have narcolepsy experience chronic sleepiness We will need to adjust our thinking with regard
and have an approximately 90% loss of functioning orexin
neurons, further suggesting the wake-promoting role of orexin
to these newer agents because they’re drastically
neuropeptides.50 Because orexin plays a significant role in the different, at least from a pharmacokinetic
wake cycle, recent research has exploited the clinical benefits of perspective. —Dr Larry Culpepper
antagonizing this receptor.
In phase III clinical trials, suvorexant, a dual orexin receptor
antagonist, significantly improved sleep onset and sleep
maintenance compared to placebo.51,52 However, while the Dr Tom Roth: If you look at low-dose doxepin, it has profound
efficacy of suvorexant was established, next-day impairment effects on sleep at the end of the night. If you look at the orexin
was a concern, warranting further evaluation of select doses. In and serotonin receptor antagonists, they have profound effects on
addition, research has shown that antagonizing serotonin sleep at the end of the night. That is a very important time
receptors (5HT-7) significantly improves sleep maintenance, because in those later hours you have already slept for 4 or
suggesting a potential role for agents with this effect in the 5 hours, and your homeostatic drive (the increased need for sleep
treatment of insomnia.53 In this final section, the roundtable due to extended periods of wakefulness) is way down. Most
panelists discuss emerging therapies and their potential roles in people experience wake time in the last 3 hours of the night, and
the management of insomnia. these medications are targeting those final hours of sleep. The
other factor you have to remember is benzodiazepine receptor
Dr Larry Culpepper: Turning the discussion toward emerging agonists work by simply shutting the brain down, and that makes
treatments, how do the orexin receptor antagonists and serotonin you fall asleep very, very quickly, which is what Dr Culpepper was
receptor antagonists affect the sleep-wake system? alluding to earlier. When transitioning patients from
benzodiazepine receptor agonists to these newer medications,
Dr Tom Roth: For the past 30 years, we’ve had medications that
patient education will become very important because the
work primarily on the sleep system through GABA mechanisms.
pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic indices of these medications
However, with the emergence of low-dose doxepin, orexin
are profoundly different. The onset of action of these newer
receptor antagonists, and serotonin receptor antagonists, there are compounds is not as fast as the medications that work on the
more medications focused on reducing arousal associated with GABA system; conversely, the duration of action of these newer
the wake system, rather than simply pushing sleep harder. Orexin agents appears to be longer.
receptor antagonists are probably the medications that are closest
to the finish line, and orexin is a major transmitter system that is Dr Sonia Ancoli-Israel: These medications may not help patients
involved in the arousal system. It feeds into the noradrenergic, get to sleep as fast as medications affecting the GABA system
histaminergic, and serotonergic systems. because orexin receptor antagonists, for example, are more
focused on extending sleep. Education will be necessary to reduce
Dr Phyllis Zee: In addition, when orexin neurons are firing during the patient’s expectation of rapidly falling asleep.
wakefulness, they inhibit the VLPO, which is the sleep-promoting
center in the brain. It’s not only activating the wake promoting
regions in the brain, but it’s also inhibiting the sleep center.6
Therefore, if you antagonize the orexin system, you can promote Final Thoughts
sleep by affecting both sleep and wake. Research suggests that insomnia is a condition of hyperarousal
Dr Tom Roth: When you give a patient zolpidem, you want it to go caused by a relative shift in the balance of activity of the
to the VLPO, but it binds receptors in the cerebellum as well, which sleep-promoting and wake-promoting systems towards an increase
causes ataxia. It does these things because the GABA system is so in activity in wake-promoting systems. Insomnia is not a symptom
widespread. In contrast, orexin is produced by a small group of cells of other disorders, but it’s comorbid with other medical conditions,
that are located in the lateral hypothalamus, with significant requiring its own intervention. Several studies, which have
projections to regions of the brain that promote arousal.49 When evaluated behavioral and pharmacologic therapy, support this
these medications are administered, they cause regional effects on direction in treatment. In addition, clinicians will not only need to
the brain versus the widespread effects we typically see with inquire about insomnia when comorbid conditions are present but
medications that potentiate the GABA system, which has a lot to do they will also need to inquire about comorbid conditions when
with receptor density. insomnia is present.
13
15
Balancing Pathophysiology
and Therapeutics