See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/324389410

The Analysis of the reservoir type and temperature of the Tiris Geothermal
Prospect, Probolinggo, Jawa Timur

Conference Paper · September 2012

CITATION READS

1 61

5 authors, including:

Agus Suprianto Wahyudi Wahyudi

Universitas Jember Universitas Gadjah Mada
7 PUBLICATIONS   2 CITATIONS    22 PUBLICATIONS   7 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Wiwit Suryanto
Universitas Gadjah Mada
76 PUBLICATIONS   236 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Development for Near Surface Exploration View project

STUDI PENERAPAN ENTROPI PERMUTASI PERMUTASI DAN PROBABILISTIC POWER SPECTRAL DENSITY UNTUK MONITORING AKTIVITAS DAN PERKIRAAN ERUPSI GUNUNGAPI
DI INDONESIA View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Agus Suprianto on 10 April 2018.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.



ANALISIS TIPE RESERVOIR DAN SUHU LAPANGAN PANASBUMI

TIRIS PROBOLINGGO JAWA TIMUR

A. Suprianto1, 2, Wahyudi2, W. Utama.3, Suharno4 dan W. Suryanto2

1. Universitas Jember,
2. Universitas Gadjah Mada,
3. Istitut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember,
4. Universitas Lampung

ABSTRAK
Lapangan panasbumi tiris terletak di wilayah Kabupaten Probolinggo tepatnya di bagian
timur Gunung Lamongan. Data geokimia diambil dari 15 lokasi. Dua lokasi Sungai Tancak
dan Air Sumur Tiris dianalisis geokimia berdasarkan metode, geotermometer, geoindikator,
dalam rangka menentukan karakteristik reservoir dan keadaan suhu sistem panasbumi Tiris
Kabupaten Probolinggo Jawa Timur. Hasil sementara menunjukkan bahwa karakteristik
reservoir bersifat basa dengan suhu reservoir lebih dari 280o C.

THE ANALISYS OF THE RESERVOIR TYPE AND TEMPERATURE OF THE

TIRIS GEOTHERMAL PROSPECT
PROBOLINGGO JAWA TIMUR

A. Suprianto1, 2, Wahyudi2, W. Utama.3, Suharno4 dan W. Suryanto2

1. Universitas Jember,
2. Universitas Gadjah Mada,
3. Istitut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember,
4. Universitas Lampung

ABSTRACT
The Tiris geothermal prospect situated within the Probolinggo District, Jawa Timur
Province, eastern the Gunung Lamongan. Geochemical data collected from fiveteen
location. Two location were analised using geochemical methods of the geothermometer
and geoindikator, doe to determine the reservoir characteristic and temperature conditions
of the Tiris geothermal system, Probolinggo District, Jawa Timur Province. The tentaive
result indicated that the the characteristic of the reservoir sould be sodium with temperature
more than 280o C.

1. INTRODUCTION

The Tiris geothermal field is located on one of the major volcanic areas spread throughout
the country. Therefore, the country has many hot springs with a variety of temperatures
ranging between 38 oC and 50oC. The hot springs are located mainly on major active

ϭ



fractures and old crater lake volcanic areas one of which is air panas Tancak di Desa
Segaran Kecamatan Tiris and Danau vulkanik Ranu Bedali, Ranu Klakah, Ranu Segaran.

The air panas Tancak is one of the prospective areas in Probolinggo District Jawa Timur
Province. The map location is shown in Figure 1.

The Tiris geothermal field is located near the Pandak, Argopuro and Old Tengger volcanic
rocks, which is Quarter in age. The Leprak Formation composed sedimentary unit,
intrusive of the granite. The geothermal area covered by Tertiary sedimentary units
assumed to be cap rock. The rocks of the Tiris geothermal field are divided into ten zones
that are characterized in Figure 2.

The geothermal manifestation spreads throughout an area including travertine and swampy
areas formed by hot water emergence and leakage, boiling hot springs, lake of carbonate
water. The results of chemical analysis of hot and cold water samples have been evaluated
for fluid using Giggenbach diagrams.

2. CHEMICAL COMPOSITIONS OF THE WATERS

The geochemical study is based on discharge water samples collected from the discharge
of two hot water springs. These samples were collected in June 2010. Samples were
untreated and included acidified water. Chemical analyses of Na, K, Mg, SO4, SiO2 pH,
Cl, HCO3.

The average chemical compositions of the geothermal water from the Sungai Tancak and
Sumur Desa Tiris are presented in Table 1. The discharge water from Tancak hot water are
of the chlorate type with alkaline pH (6-7) and with total dissolved solids in range the of
400-700 mg/kg. The samples form Sungai Tancak, a HCO3 are predominate cations with
concentration more than 1500 mg/l, SiO2 and Cl respectively 116 and 458 mg/kg, SO4 is
less, about 1 mg/kg. The anion Na, K and Mg respectively 306, 306 and 238. In contrast,
waters discharged from Sumur Tiris are neutral (pH-6-7) composite of the Na, K, Mg,
SO4, HCO3, SiO2 and Cl respectively 8, 11, 18, 1, 186, 53, 27in mg/kg.

The chemical compositions of the waters were classified on the basis of major ions using
the Cl-SO4-HCO3 triangular diagram of Giggenbach (Figure 3). All samples plot to area
of mature waters and can be classified as Cl-rich geothermal water which formed by the
interaction of geothermal fluids with the host rock and dilution with low salinity water at
depth (White and Muffler, 1971).

The Tiris possesses great potentiality for the utilization of geothermal energy. The region
has been centre of attraction to a number of visiting national scientists, encouraging them
to collect and analyze geothermal water samples at different localities on a sporadic basis.
One of such studies has determined the temperature and reservoir characteristic.

Ϯ



3. ESTIMATION OF THE RESERVOIR

Even though the above table suggests that none of the springs have a huge mass flow rate,
a number of springs emerging in the vicinity could have lowered the flow rate. Water
containing chloride concentration more than 450 mg/kg. No high concentration of silica is
observed relative to discharge temperature in all spring waters. The waters at sumur Tiris
lying in this region have relatively high chloride, suggesting that the waters are fairly
mature as indicated by the Giggenbach’s diagram of concentrations of the major anions,
Cl, SO4 and HCO3. This is illustrated in Figure 3. Figure 3 suggest that the reservoir is
carbonat with high consentration of HCO3.

Table 1. Geochemical data from the Sungai Tancak and Air Sumur Tiris geothermal field.

Sampel Na K Mg SO4 HCO3 SiO2 Cl

Sungai Tancak 306 63 238 1 1585 116 458

Sumur Desa Tiris 8 11 18 1 186 53 27

4. SUBSURFACE TEMPERATURE ESTIMATION

Chemical geothermometers are used in order to estimate the reservoir temperature. The
important criteria for chemical geothermometer application to thermal spring are the pH,
temperature and discharge rate of the spring. Some of them give unreliable results such as
either lower than spring temperature or extremely high temperature. These equations are
based on geothermometers for chalcedony and quartz, which assume hat these minerals
used in geothermometers, are not in equilibrium with rock – water interaction in reservoir.

The silica and cation geothermometers were used for the evaluation of subsurface
temperature for discharges (Table 1). The Source of temperature equations: T–measured
temperature, T: Na-K– Fournier and Truesdell (1973), T: Na-K – Giggenbach (1988), T-
Fournier (1977) were used. The sample form Sungai Tancak suggest that the reservoir
temperatures is about 287oC. The Na-K geothermometer of Giggenbach (1988) suggested
reservoir temperature temperatures is about 297oC.

The Na-K-Mg triangular diagram shows the equilibrium between the geothermal fluids and
rock and reservoir temperature (Figure 4). By considering the diagram presented in Figure
4, the Tiris hot springs plot in the immature water part, so using the chemical
geothermometers is not reliable according to the theory used to establish the diagram. In
this Na-K-Mg diagram all the samples have not gained equilibrium with rock, presumably
due to fast circulation of luid through the rock fractures. This causes the water to be
mature, considering the ion exchange processes that, equilibrium has not been reached yet

ϯ



with rock minerals because of circulation flow. Figure 4 shows that samples from studied
geothermal fall on the full equilibrium line, suggested attainment of the (Sungai Tancak)
has temperature between 287 - 297oC.

3. CONCLUSION

The geothermal waters discharged from Sungai Tancak geothermal field and Sumur Tiris
within the Sub-Disrict of Tiris, Probolinggo District, jawa Timur Province are of carbonate
type with a high concentration of HCO3 and moderately Cl. The chemical compositions of
reservoir waters indicate that the reservoir is located in the liquid dominant zone and
geothermal waters come from an old geothermal system. The water composition from
Sumur Tiris is carbonate and chloride water. Thermal fluid is in equilibrium with reservoir
rocks, which can be the product of water-rock interaction at high temperature. Common
geothermometers have been used for estimating the subsurface temperature. The results
from Na-K geothermometers and Na-K-Mg geoindikcator, indicate that the reservoir
temperature. The calculated temperatures using Na-K geothermometers and Na-K-Mg
geoindikcator is more than 280oC. However, the fact or temperature may confirm with the
measurement well temperature arter drilling.

Figure 1. The topography map location of the Sungai Tancak and Air Sumur Tiris
geothermal field.

ϰ


Figure 2. The geological map of the Sungai Tancak and Air Sumur Tiris geothermal field.

Cl
SDT: Sumur Desa Tirisr

80 STn: Sungai Tancak

60

40

20

SO4 HCO3
20 40 60 80

Figur 3. The diagram of the Sungai Tancak and Air Sumur Tiris reservoir characteristic.

ϱ
 

Na/1000
SDT: Sumur Desa Tirisr

80 STn: Sungai Tancak

150
60 200 100

250
40

300

20

K/100 Mg^0.5
20 40 60 80

Figur 4. The diagram of the temperatures of the Sungai Tancak and Air Sumur Tiris
geothermal reservoir.

4. REFERENCES

Fournier, R.O.: and White, D. E. and Truesdell, A. H. Chemical Geothermometers and

Mixing Models for Geothermal System, Geothermics, 5, (1977), 41-50.

Fournier, R., and Truesdell A.: An Empirical Na-K-Ca Geoindicators, Geochim.

Cosmochim. Acta, 37, (1973), 1255-1275. Giggenbach, W.: Geothermal Solute
Equilibria. Derivation of Na-K-Mg-Ca Geoindicators, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 52,
(1988), 2749-2765.

Geocemical indicators of subsurface temperature. U.S. Geol. Survey J. R. 2, (1974), 259-

262.

Giggenbach, W. F. Geothermal Gas Equilibria. Geochemica Cosmochemica Acta 31,

(1988).

Giggenbach, W.F.: Chemical Techniques in Geothermal Exploration. In: D’Amore,

F(coordinator), Application of geochemistry in geothermal reservoir development.
UNITAR/UNDP publication, Rome, (1991), 119-142.

White, D.E., and Muffler, L.G: Vapour-dominated Hydrothermal System Compared with
Hot Water System. Economic Geology, 66, (1971), 75-97.

ϲ

View publication stats