Plant Maintenance (ME-426) Batch 2015-16

Assessment Rubric for Complex Engineering Problem covering CLO3: Apply failure analysis techniques on
various equipment’s.
Problem Title: “To Perform Failure Mode Effects Analysis (FMEA) of any Mechanical Related Process”
S.No Performance Excellent Good Fair Poor
Report (Demonstrate Assignment guideline
knowledge of topic, Spelling Assignment guideline followed but some steps Assignment guideline not Assignment guideline
and Grammar are Correct followed, proper citation, needs followed completely, not followed,
,Proper layout/schematic diagram improvemeent,P&ID/PF P&ID/PFD/layout not P&ID/PFD/layout not
citation,indexing,Figure legible, problem statement D/layout not legible/clear, citation not drawn, citation not
No.,follow assignment clearly explain images made legible/clear, citation proper, some grammatical done, grammatical
guidelines, problem statement it excellent. Information proper, no grammatical mistake, proper figure mistake, no proper
clear,P&ID/PFD/Schematic clearly relates to the main mistake, proper figure numbering & labeling. (3- figure numbering &
layout drawn, information in topic,. (7 marks) numbering & labeling. 4 marks) labeling. (1-2 marks)
1 sequential manner )(7 marks) (5-6 marks)
Demonstrated a thorough Have knowledge of the
knowledge of the subject subject matter. Majority
Presentation (Content Relates Demonstrated a basic Demonstrated little or
matter. Opinions were of presentation was on-
to knowledge of the subject no knowledge of the
supported by fact wherever topic. Opinions were
topic,detailed,accurate,Posture matter. Presenter used subject. The
possible. Entire presentation supported by fact
/Eye unrelated presentation was too
focused on the topic. Made wherever possible.
Contact, formal dressing ) (4 material to pad the brief or too long.(1
eye contact Posture was good for
marks) presentation.(2 marks) marks)
throughout the audience. (4 most of the presentation.
2 marks) (3 marks)
Answer all question (s) Answer some question Wrong answers (0
Viva (4 marks) -
3 correctly (4 marks) (s) correctly (2 marks) marks)
Group Seat # Group Merit # Date
Instructor Signature Marks
Total Marks obtained
Report (Max.Marks 7) Presentation (Max.Marks 4) Viva (Max.Marks 4) (out of 15)
Marks obtained