PAPER CRITERIA/ RUBRICS

(You may find example on pages 3-4)

1a. Journal Article

Please analyze recommended article given to you with the format prepared
Page | 1
Your name : e.g:
Attendance list number : e.g:
Your phone number : e.g
Your mail : e.g

How do you write your paper from Journal (fill in the form first)
No Items : Description and Examples
1 Put all writers’ complete names, e.g :
2 Put when the article is published in :
(a bracket) e.g
3 Journal article or Chapter title, e.g :
4 Journal Name, put it in italic, e.g :
5 a. Journal volume, :
(issue), and
pages, (see e.g: A)

b. Journal volume and

pages (without issue), (see e.g: B)

6 Put your reference, (ses e.g A and B): :

7. Email code : Name-List Number-MPKB2018
Yessy Markolinda-13-MPKB2018
8. Send to my email : drsawirman@gmail.com

B. Papers Format
a. Abstract translation (10%)
b. Create your own Map Concept or Diagram or Carricature (25%)
c. The Main Points (50 %)
d. Author’s/their/his/her conclusion and critical review (5 %)
e. Face Validity (10 %)

C. Papers Rubrics
Provide a comprehensive description of your critical review exceed six pages (in one
and half space) in terms that you understand. Your analysis should include all of the
following items:

Content Validity
(90%)
 1. Translate article abstract (10%)
2. Explain fully and clearly how the writers put the main points of each (sub) chapters,
numbers, each pages accordingly (50%).
3. Map the points with the special diagram or map concept and give explanation! (20%)
Page | 2
4. Explain fully and clearly author’s/their/his/her conclusion additional information (10%).
5. Face validity (10%).

Face validity
(10%)

Rubrics Features

Very good Good Bad

1. Illustration/space 2 1 0

2 Typing 2 1 0

3 Quotation (book year, 2 1 0

page/s)

4 Coherence 2 1 0

5 Consistency (use APA 2 1 0

Style)
Total 10

Padang, 2018-08-13
Ws and seal
Dr. Sawirman, M.Hum.
 Page | 3
PAPER CRITERIA/ RUBRICS

1b. Journal Article

Please analyze recommended article given to you with the format prepared

Your name : e.g: Sawirman

Attendance list number : e.g: 15
Your mail/phone number : e.g (0821741....15)/ buat email dengan nama sendiri
e.g drsawirman@gmail.com

How do you write your paper from Journal (fill in the form first)
No Items : Description and Examples
1 Put all writers’ complete names, e.g : Raymond Williams, Roland Barthes, Noam
Chomsky, Erich Fromm, and so forth.
2 Put when the article is published in : (2018)
(a bracket) e.g
3 Journal article or Chapter title, e.g : The ecology of science and language
4 Journal Name, put it in italic, e.g : Discouse and Society

5 a. Journal volume, : (e.g: A)

(issue), and 16 (3), 586-612.
pages, (see e.g: A) It means:

b. Journal volume and

pages (without issue), (see e.g: B) (e.g: B)
81, 36-38.
It means:

6 Put your reference, (ses e.g A and B): : (e.g: A)

Williams, R., Barthes, R., Chomsky, N., &
Fromm, E. (2018). The ecology of science and
language. Discouse and Society, 16 (3), 586-612.

Or

(e.g: B)
Williams, R., Barthes, R., Chomsky, N., &
Fromm, E. (2018). The ecology of science and
language. Discouse and Society, 81, 36-38.
7. Email code : Name-List Number-BID2019
 Yessy Markolinda-13-BID2019
8. Send to my email : drsawirman@gmail.com

Page | 4
B. Papers Format
f. Abstract translation (10%)
g. Create your own Map Concept or Diagram or Carricature (25%)
h. The Main Points (50 %)
i. Author’s/their/his/her conclusion and critical review (5 %)
j. Face Validity (10 %)

C. Papers Rubrics
Provide a comprehensive description of your critical review exceed six pages (in one
and half space) in terms that you understand. Your analysis should include all of the
following items:

Content Validity
(90%)

1. Translate article abstract (10%)

2. Explain fully and clearly how the writers put the main points of each (sub) chapters,
numbers, each pages accordingly (50%).
3. Map the points with the special diagram or map concept and give explanation! (20%)
4. Explain fully and clearly author’s/their/his/her conclusion (10%).
5. Face validity (10%).

Face validity
(10%)

Rubrics Features

Very good Good Bad

1. Illustration/space 2 1 0

2 Typing 2 1 0

3 Quotation (book year, 2 1 0

page/s)
4 Coherence 2 1 0

5 Consistency (use APA 2 1 0

Style) Page | 5
Total 10

Padang, 2018-08-13
Ws and seal
Dr. Sawirman, M.Hum.
CHAPTER IN A BOOK CRITERIA/ RUBRICS
(You may find example on pages 7-8)

2a. Chapter in a book

Please analyze recommended article given to you with the format prepared

Your name : e.g:

Attendance list number : e.g:
Your phone number : e.g
Your mail : e.g

How do you write your paper from book chapter (fill in the form first)
No Items : Description
1 Put all writers’ complete names :
2 Put when the article is published in :
(a bracket)
3 Chapter title :
4 Book title, put it in italic :
5 Pages (in a bracket) :
5 Place and publisher :
6 Put your reference :
7. Email code : Name-List Number-BID2019
Yessy Markolinda-13-BID2019
8. Send to my email : drsawirman@gmail.com

B. Papers Format
k. Article brief overview (10%)
l. Create your own Map Concept(s) or Diagram(s) or Carricature(s)
(25%)
m. The Main Points (50 %)
n. Author’s/their/his/her conclusion and critical review (5 %)
o. Face Validity (10 %)

C. Papers Rubrics
Provide a comprehensive description of your critical review exceed six pages (in one
and half space) in terms that you understand. Your analysis should include all of the
following items:
 Content Validity
(90%)

1. Describe article overview (10%)

Page | 6
2. Explain fully and clearly how the writers put the main points of each (sub) chapters,
numbers, each pages accordingly (50%).
3. Map the points with the special diagram or map concept and give explanation! (25%)
4. Explain fully and clearly author’s/their/his/her conclusion (5%).
5. Face validity (10%).

Face validity
(10%)

Rubrics Features

Very good Good Bad

1. Illustration/space 2 1 0

2 Typing 2 1 0

3 Quotation (book year, 2 1 0

page/s)

4 Coherence 2 1 0

5 Consistency (use APA 2 1 0

Style)
Total 10

Padang, 2018-01-23
Ws and seal
Dr. Sawirman, M.Hum.
 Page | 7

PAPER CRITERIA/ RUBRICS

2b. Chapter in a book

Please analyze recommended article given to you with the format prepared

Your name : e.g: Sawirman

Attendance list number : e.g: 15
Your mail/phone number : e.g (0821741....15)/ create your own email
e.g drsawirman@gmail.com

How do you write your paper from Journal (fill in the form first)
No Items : Description and Examples
1 Put all writers’ complete names, e.g : Raymond Williams, Roland Barthes, Noam
Chomsky, Erich Fromm, and so forth.
2 Put when the article is published in : (2018)
(a bracket) e.g
3 Chapter title, e.g : The ecology of science and language
4 Journal Name, put it in italic, e.g : Discouse and Society

5 Pages (in a bracket) : (17-26)

6 Put your reference(s) : Williams, R., Barthes, R., Chomsky, N., &
Fromm, E. (2018). The ecology of science and
language. In R. Williams, R. Barthes, N.
Chomsky, & E. Fromm (Eds). Discouse Studies
(pp. 30-47), New York: Guilford Press.
7. Email code : Name-List Number-MPKB2018
Yessy Markolinda-13-MPKB2018
8. Send to my email : drsawirman@gmail.com

B. Papers Format
 p. Article overview (10%)
q. Create your own Map Concept or Diagram or Carricature (25%)
r. The Main Points (50 %)
s. Author’s/their/his/her conclusion and critical review (10 %)
t. Face Validity (10 %)
Page | 8
C. Papers Rubrics
Provide a comprehensive description of your critical review exceed six pages (in one
and half space) in terms that you understand. Your analysis should include all of the
following items:

Content Validity
(90%)

1. Describe your own article overview (10%)

2. Explain fully and clearly how the writers put the main points of each (sub) chapters,
numbers, each pages accordingly (50%).
3. Map the points with the special diagram or map concept and give explanation! (25%)
4. Explain fully and clearly author’s/their/his/her conclusion (5%).
5. Face validity (10%).

Face validity
(10%)

Rubrics Features

Very good Good Bad

1. Illustration/space 2 1 0

2 Typing 2 1 0

3 Quotation (book year, 2 1 0

page/s)
4 Coherence 2 1 0

5 Consistency (use APA 2 1 0

Style) Page | 9
Total 10

Padang, 2019-01-23
Ws and seal
Dr. Sawirman, M.Hum.