Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Impact of Acculturation
Julie Y. Bunnak
Psy7540
e-mail: jbunnak@capellauniversity.edu
Impact of Acculturation
The process of assimilation and integration into the host culture, acculturation can be
problematic for many newly transplanted members to the United States. Extremely stressful and
difficult for many, language barriers, culture identity issues, social alienation, and racism can
create difficult barriers. Finding these challenges difficult to overcome, life stressors can create a
variety of stress-related problems, like anxiety, depression, and even the physiological
manifestations of stress-related illnesses (Gupta, Leong, Valentine, & Canada, 2013). Many who
suffer from the acculturation process often fail to pursue appropriate treatment or social support
systems, since the seeking of psychological counsel can carry a negative stigma emanating from
the culture of origin. Acculturation and acculturative stress will be examined and defined. Social
issues, impact of cultural conflicts, negative stereotypes and stigmas associated with immigrant
life, and possible treatment options for acculturation stress will also be discussed.
Acculturation is the process of adapting into a different culture other than one’s own. The
implication of acculturation is that two cultures reside and intermingle throughout the adapting
process. The process also creates cultural and psychological change for the individual. A cultural
advantage for acculturation is the learning of new strategies and practices that one can adopt and
integrate into personality and self-identity. However, disadvantages of acculturation can include
acculturation stress, conflict, bias, segregation, and self-isolation (Xia, Do, Xie, 2013).
Acculturation stress occurs when difficulties arise after immigration and adaptation
process. While many immigrants are faced with stressors during this phase, some may lack the
social support and coping strategies to handle them appropriately. Separation from family,
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 3
friends and familiarity of country is a large stressor for the new immigrant. Unfamiliar customs
and cultures may leave the individual feeling bewildered and uncertain with how to appropriately
respond to the host culture. For some, families must be broken apart because of a lack in funds to
bring each member to the new land. One parent or both parents may initially immigrate to the
new land and leave children behind to be taken care by other family members. They must then
find work and save enough money to bring the rest of the family to the new land. In these
instances, the individual or individuals may feel lonely, frustrated, isolated, and incomplete
without the partner or children that are left behind. Latin-Americans are more likely than their
peers to develop psychological issues because of these issues (Leong, Park, Kalibatseva, 2013).
Fluctuations in income and unemployment may also create acculturative stress. Families
may be forced into lengthy bouts of unemployment and are then unsure how to provide for their
families. Those who have moved from the country of origin to seek out a better life may feel
disconcerted and disparaged upon the realization that they are making much less than they had
The language barrier is also another facet to acculturative stress. Such issues may be
detrimental when seeking employment, finding medical help, or even searching for appropriate
resources to help get through the process. Parents and children that suffer from the language
barrier may come across delays in the enrollment of school for children, as there may be issues in
communicating with teachers and peers. Parents may not understand what is expected of them by
school administrators; the transference of past educational records may end up being delayed in
the process (Xia, Do, & Xie, 2013). F. Leong, Y.S. Park, and Z. Kalibatseva (2013) states that a
large academic achievement gap exists between Latino children and white students; scoring
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 4
much lower in the areas of reading and math. This can be due to parental time-constraints in
helping children with homework because of work or unemployment issues and the language
barrier; not understanding what is expected of them by teachers and school administrators.
verbally, and behaviorally, some immigrants are chastised, berated, and alienated from society
for being different from the social norm. Lambasted for stealing jobs and contributing to
overpopulation levels, immigrants have been treated horribly by many in western society. In
actuality, increases in immigration has had positive impact on the economic growth of the
country. The ACLU (2018) reports from a study done in 1994, immigrants increase the output
and appeal for labor. Along with high productivity, immigrants also pay billions in annual taxes,
stimulating investment and the inception of jobs, and reinvigorate collapsed communities.
carried over from the homeland. Individuals who leave the home country because of civil unrest
or refugee situation can experience many difficulties in assimilating to the host culture. M.L
Santa Maria and T. Cornille (2007) found that immigrants who are separated from family are
particularly prone to PTSD; specifically, those individuals who had to leave spouses and children
back in the homeland. They also found that Latino-Americans had the highest reports of PTSD
imperative that these values are clear. For individuals going through acculturation, understanding
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 5
the value systems during the process can create a more harmonious transition period. It is also
imperative to note that value systems can be different amongst the various cultural groups. It
does not make one culture better or more advanced than the other but understanding the cultural
Individualism is the value that the individual takes precedence over the group. Whereas,
collectivism is where the group ideology takes precedence over the individual. The United
States, Australia, and U.K. scoring high on the individualism scale and all apprize autonomy,
honesty, privacy, freedom, and personal goals. This prevailing social attitude of independence
saturates the mind of each member to propel themselves to achieve success, as long as it does not
infringe upon the rights of others. Collectivistic cultures; like China and Singapore, devote
themselves to what is best for the group, family, or community. Decisions are made in the
consideration of group welfare. These societies value training, teamwork, the improvement of
skills, physical fitness, and intrinsic rewards that accompanies proficiency in those skills. Most
families are hierarchical in design and value harmony more than honesty (Triandis, 2001).
In a collectivistic and hierarchical society where men are the breadwinners or providers
for the family group, being forced into lengthy unemployment or reversal of roles with their
spouses may feel emasculating and shameful. The individualistic value system that prizes
independence and success may also create tumultuous feelings in a person who was originally
believed in collectivistic viewpoints. For example, a husband was proud in his past culture for
able to provide well for his family. Seeing the family content made him happy and fulfilled.
However, after moving to a country with an individualistic value system, he is no longer able to
work well with his co-workers in his new job because they do not value the same type of
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 6
teamwork he is used to. He can no longer provide for his family the way he used to, due to
language barrier issues. His wife experiences discrimination issues which makes her unhappy
and his children are struggling in school. This culture clash can create psychological stress which
may be difficult to overcome. C. Kim and H.E. Sung (2016) discuss high issues of intimate
partner violence that occurs in the Chinese community because of the inability to find
The inability to find appropriate means to alleviate psychological and acculturation stress
amongst the immigrant community may also lead to a variety of psychological distress issues.
Acculturation and acculturation stress are both very high predictors of alcoholism (Park, Anastas,
Shibusawa, & Nguyen, 2014). In the Asian-American sub-groups, Filipino immigrants consume
more alcohol than either Chinese or Vietnamese immigrants. The study also supports that the
process of acculturation may shape drinking patterns, as individuals begin to adapt to the
Models of Acculturation
A large variety of theoretical models explain the process of acculturation and issues that
arise. The first model is adapted from John Berry’s Theory of Acculturation. Berry postulates
that two specific key factors are involved in the acculturation process; cultural maintenance and
contact/participation. Through cultural maintenance, the individual seeks to preserve the pre-
existing cultural identity that they have valued. Contact and participation propels the individual
to become involved with the dominant or host culture. Based on the interaction of the two key
factors, four acculturation strategies begin to emerge. In the very first strategy, assimilation, the
individual no longer retains cultural identity, but seek direct interaction with other cultures.
Individuals who have chosen to assimilate may change preference for language that is used,
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 7
adoption of dominant behavior, attitudes, and core values, and seek memberships within the
social group they wish to assimilate into. In the second strategy separation, which occurs when
the individual places values in the original culture and withhold interaction with individuals from
the dominant or host culture. Individuals maintain the core values of their original culture in the
third strategy; integration and interact with those from the dominant and host culture. In the last
strategy marginalization, individuals no longer hold their core values important and also choose
to not interact with those from the dominant or host culture. For immigrants going through the
acculturation process, biculturalism is the last phase people try to achieve. Biculturalism occurs
when individuals have successfully integrated two or more facets of their original cultural
identity with the dominant culture. Values and perspectives may be from the original or host
The Schumann Acculturation Model is linked directly to the acquisition of new language.
According to Schumann, language is acquired through social distance. If one fails to learn the
new language, then there is perceptually, a psychological distance between the two cultures
within the mind of the person. The larger this psychological distance is, the harder it will be for
the individual to learn. There are eight factors involved that can influence the psychological
distance. The first is social dominance; where one group is deemed more powerful than the other
and integration; where the two or more groups are deemed as equal. Enclosure occurs when self-
sufficiency of the individual increases the distance between cultures, cohesiveness is created
when close groups or friendships increases the distance. Size also impacts distance, as larger
groups tend to be further in distance, and cultural congruence pertains to the extremes in cultural
difference in its influence to distance. The seventh factor considers the attitudes of cultural
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 8
group, in that negative attitudes to the individual’s own culture will increase distance, and length
of time stayed in the specific culture will influence distance (Schumann, 1978).
Another concept within the acculturation spectrum is the term melting pot. Melting pot
refers to a society where various types of people conglomerate and blend together. While some
societies consist of individuals of the same race, culture, and religion, many members of this
Diffusionism
Originally an anthropological term, Diffusionism is used to account for the spread of culture, art,
language, music, myths, religion, social organization, and even technological ideas from one
culture. Classical evolutionists explained this concept as psychic unity of humankind, feeling that
all societies and cultures are intertwined and have passed from one into another. Upon greater
inspection of the various cultures, one would see similar commonalities through this type of
psychic medium. The originality of the similarities may have been created in one culture, but
through trade and communication, these ideological concepts were introduced from main culture
Theorists believe the reason that diffusionism occurs is because there is some sort of value in the
concept; whether economic, intrinsic, functional, or even political value. The other argument is
that various cultures may have originated the concepts at similar time, after which it was diffused
to other cultures. Another common question that classical evolutionists ponder is why do only
some cultures obtain the concept and not others? Some answer that perhaps there were obstacles
surrounding the concept at a given point in the historical timeline. Geographical, transportation,
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION 9
monetary, communication obstacles are all feasible explanations as to why certain cultures
obtain the concept and others do not. It is also possible that original concepts have been modified
to meet the needs of the differing culture, thusly losing its original format (Dearing, 2009).
From an anthropological perspective, developed societies also are normally the creators
of original concepts and the under-developed countries are the receivers. The culture with higher
complexity are seemingly always the providers of new cultural trait for the lower advanced
societies. Diffusionism almost never works the other way around; from the lower complexity
society to the higher. Historically, diffusionism also takes time to pass on the cultural trait.
There are various long-term factors in the process of acculturation. Language is a primary
factor that can keep one from assimilating into host culture. Difficulties in communicating with
the host culture can prevent from job attainment, which secures income for the family. Language
can also affect grade levels for children, as many who do not speak the language can be left
behind gradewise. P. Tummala-Narra, A. Deshpande, and J. Kaur (2016) discuss how coping
mechanisms, self-perception, and family support can influence the handling of acculturation
challenges, stressors, environment assimilation, and resiliency for immigrant children. Immigrant
families often attempt to seek out social support with the cultural community within the host
country. Children who felt connected to families and the ethnic community were more resilient
and better at coping with life stressors than children who felt less connected. Children can find
strength from feeling connected and understood when others of a similar background share
Coping skills and social support are extremely important during the acculturation phase.
Individuals who do not cope well may find themselves with economic issues. Poverty may also
be the result of a lack in coping skills, as the attainment of job and job security may become
difficult because language barrier. Jobs acquired may also not pay well to fully support the
family unit. Individuals with better paying jobs in the mother-country may find themselves
acculturation stress can result in lower socio-economic status. This often means receiving lower
paying jobs, living in poorer neighborhoods, fewer educational opportunities for children,
compounded stress factors for parents, and a necessity for multiple jobs to provide enough
In the context of religion and multi-cultural acceptance, the United States as a society has
been very open and accepting of religious differences. Various temples, synagogues, and
churches reside in every state and can become the foundation for immigrants to finally find
peace and strength through the acculturation process. For many ethnic groups, religion and
spirituality are fundamentally the cornerstone of the culture. Religious leaders and community
can also become extended members of the family; leading to possible support systems that lonely
and isolated people desperately need to feel less alone. Essentially, people who struggle through
issues also tend to do well with others who share similar backgrounds. A bond formed through
similarity of cultural, religious, and community beliefs can be what people who go through the
acculturation process need in order to retrieve their lost self-identity (Young-An & Trusty,
2017).
Social norms refer to the common behaviors that are acceptable in a given society.
Normative standards of behavior are not consistent throughout the various cultures, however, as
what one culture deems as normal, may not be considered abnormal behavior in another. For
example, in an individualistic culture, holding hands or kissing is a vulnerable behavior that must
be only shared with an intimate partner. Two women or two men holding hands would garner
stares or disapproval in some cultures; or whispers denoting the individuals must be LGBT.
However, in many collectivistic ethnic societies, the act of kissing is considered a standard way
to greet another. Hand-holding is also a common behavior for two female and male friends in
other cultures, as well. Again, individualistic and collectivistic perspectives intermingle with
culture and perception. People who adhere to individualistic perspectives will normally behave
in ways that shows resiliency and independence within the society. Vulnerability is pushed aside
for self-control and positive self-image is akin to putting forth an air of confidence and
assurance. In collectivistic societies that apprize connectivity and group acceptance, the act of
holding hands or expressing affection is not castigated. Singling oneself out would normally be
frowned upon and seen as boastful behavior (Triandis, 2001). For the individual traversing
through the acculturation process, exhibiting behaviors that are culturally acceptable in the old
culture without fear of prejudice or bigotry may offer peace of mind and allow one to feel
Social media has also provided and outlet for individuals who lack the social support
system of family and friends. Staying in touch with loved ones through video conferencing or
facebook, individuals feel less alone and isolated (Leong, Park, Kalibatseva, 2013). Social media
or online access can also help people discover like-minded support resources and groups to
interconnectedness is not only crucial to alleviating acculturation stress but helps to establish
both mental and overall health. Lack of social interactions increases stress, weakens the immune
system, causes depression, and creates are variety of psychological and physiological issues for
Gender Roles
Culture often shapes gender roles. In various societies, there are distinct lines between
masculinity and femininity and the roles that individuals play in order to be acceptable gender
specific people within that society or culture. Culturally appropriate female roles within various
societies is to be the home-maker; they must stay home and do the cooking, cleaning, and
caretaker to the children. Men are taught at an early age that they must be the bread-winners for
the family unit and engage in masculine activities when at home; like mowing the lawn or fixing
items in the house. However, roles are slowly beginning to change in this new era. Women are
now active members of the workforce and men equally care for the children and household
chores. For many cultures, the transformation is slow, however individualistic and complex
societies embrace the change. Roles are starting to reverse in collectivistic cultures, but in many
instances, change takes time and not everyone embraces the role reversal (Neculaesei, 2015).
For the acculturation immigrant struggling to understand these changes in gender roles,
being forced to change this value belief may be difficult. For a patriarchal member of the
household who is suddenly forced into the position of making less than the spouse and taking
care of the children, sudden changes may force the individual to feel confused, emasculated, and
frustrated. Likewise, for the matriarch of the house who is suddenly propelled into a male
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION
13
dominated position. Entering the workforce in the late stage of life can feel bewildering,
Treatment
For treatment, looking at problem solving from independent versus collectivistic value
systems is ideal. As a mental health professional, one would do best to find ways to motivate
individuals from both value systems. Those with an individualistic viewpoint would be
motivated through an individual incentive, whereas those with a collectivistic perspective would
be motivated by having their “team” succeed. Collectivistic clients would do well in family
therapy; where working with the family group would be ideal. For those suffering through
PTSD, the presence of parents or spouse may be necessary for treatment and recovery.
Essentially, treatment that includes the family unit may produce more favorable results (Santa-
Verbal and Non-verbal communication is key for the therapist helping a multicultural
individual. Speech must be clear and concise, without disrespectful tones that can be construed
communication is very important to help the client feel at ease, making the client feel
acknowledged, and supported throughout the session. Behaviors like eye-contact, forward
leaning, and slow but natural hand movements that are complimentary to what the client is
stating can not only provide support but can make the therapist appear more likeable.
example, while the “thumbs up” action is culturally appropriate in western society, the gesture in
in various Asian cultures means that one is angry or hateful towards the other. Some cultures
also refrain from direct eye-contact, deeming the gesture demeaning or aggressive, whereas lack
of eye-contact can appear disrespectful, cold, and disconnected for others. Utilizing empathy;
quite specifically ethnocentric empathy, in this way can help the therapist establish quick rapport
with the ethnic client (Wei, Li, Wang, & Ko, 2016).
ten distinct guidelines are available to help the psychological professional understand the level of
competency one has when counseling a multicultural client. Guideline 1 states that psychologists
know that identity and self-definition are both fluid and complex. Essentially, change it shaped
by environment and social interactions, thus clients should be not held to specific ideologies. Be
respectful of perspectives, but also ready to support the client when change does occur.
Guideline 2 encourages the psychologist to understand the interplay of culture, attitudes, and
belief systems comprises the client’s self-identity. Seeking understanding or further training or
research into how culture plays a part in the client’s life would be ideal. Likewise, it is not wise
to hold onto assumptions, biases, and speculations about any individual or community.
Competent psychologists also understand the importance of language and how it shapes the
individual, families, and community. Psychologists should also learn how life stages and
transitions affects the client; especially the level of acculturation stage the client is in which will
help lead them to bicultural understanding and acceptance. From a socio-cultural context,
psychologists also seek to understand how families, communities, and organizations impact the
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION
15
life of the client. Including specific individuals in the healing process may be feasible to foster
Specific Therapies
For the clients with acculturative stress, solution-focused brief therapy is a supportive
process that can work very well. In this therapy, clients are the facilitators of sessions. They lead
the sessions by knowing what areas that is needing improvement. Counselors are not the experts
in this form of therapy, but instead respects the thoughts and perceptions that the client has.
Client brings forth what they wish to change or improve and can even reframe the goal to find
the correct or most appealing solution (Cheung & Jahn, 2017). This theory does not focus on the
past or what causes the symptoms, but instead emphasizes the goal of the client and helping the
client achieve change. The present and future is the focus of therapy. Cognitive-Behavior
therapy that focuses primarily on altering perceptions has also been seen as effective when
treating ethnic and multicultural clients suffering through acculturation issues (Pan, Ng, Young,
& Caroline, 2017). For assessment, the Riverside Acculturation Stress Inventory (RASI) has
been shown to effectively measure the level of acculturative stress amongst Asian-American
students. Utilizing this inventory and scale can help the therapist determine the level of issues
Conclusion
viewpoints, values, and belief systems can help the individual feel complete and worthwhile.
When one is uprooted from all they know and propelled into a life where language barriers, lack
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION
16
of familiar faces or social support system, and even struggling with a financial burden, life can
be difficult and crippling. For the individual suffering through acculturation stress, difficulties in
understanding that acculturation is not a lifestyle, but only stages of a process that must be
experienced, one eventually becomes a wiser and more empathetic individual who eventually
will embody the belief and values of two cultures. The individual will then have the best of both
worlds.
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION
17
Reference
https://www.aclu.org/other/immigrants-and-economy
https://www.apa.org/about/policy/multicultural-guidelines.PDF
Berry, J.W., Phinney, J.S., Sam, D.L., Vedder, P. (2006). Immigrant Youth: Acculturation,
332.
Cheung, C.W., & Jahn, S.A.B. (2017). Closing the Acculturation Gap: A Solution-Focused
Approach with East Asian American Families. The Family Journal: Counseling and
Gupta, A., Leong, F., Valentine, J.C., & Canada, D.D. (2013). A Meta-Analytic Study: The
Kim, C., & Sung, H.E. (2016). The Effects of Acculturation on Intimate Partner Violence
Among Chinese Immigrants in New York City. Journal of Family Violence, 31, p. 325-
336.
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION
18
Leong, F., Park, Y.S., & Kalibatseva, Z. (2013). Disentangling Immigrant Status in Mental
Health: Psychological Protective and Risk Factors Among Latino and Asian American
Meghani, D.T., & Harvey, E.A. (2015). Asian Indian International Students’ Trajectories of
Miller, M.J., Kim, J., & Martinez, V.B. (2011). Validating the Riverside Acculturation Stress
Neculaesei, A.N. (2015). Culture and Gender Role Differences. Cross-Cultural Management
Pan, J.Y., Ng, P., Young, D.K.W., & Caroline, S. (2017). Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral
Park, S.Y., Anastas, J., Shibusawa, T., & Nguyen, D. (2014). The Impact of Acculturation and
Acculturative Stress on Alcohol Use Across Asian Immigrant Subgroups. Substance Use
Santa-Maria, M.L., & Cornille, T. (2007). Traumatic Stress, Family Separations, and Attachment
Schumann, J.H. (1978). The Pidgination Process: A Model for Second Language Acquisition.
Steinberg, S. (2014). The long view of the melting pot. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 37(5), p. 790-
794.
IMPACT OF ACCULTURATION
19
Torres, C.A., Crowther, M.R., & Brodsky, S. (2017). Addressing Acculturative Stress in
Psychotherapy: A Case Study of a Latino Man Overcoming Cultural Conflicts and Stress
Tummala-Narra, P, Deshpande, A., & Kaur, J. (2016). South Asian Adolescents’ Experiences of
211.
p. 907-924.
Wei, M., Li, C.I., Wang, C., & Ko, S.Y. (2016). Finding Benefits from Acculturative Stress
p. 633-644.
Xia, Y., Do, K.A., Xie, X. (2013). The Adjustment of the Asian American Families to the U.S.
Context: The Ecology of Strengths and Stress. Faculty Publications, Department of Child,
Young-An, R., & Trusty, J. (2017). Impact of Social Support and Coping on Acculturation and