Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The relationship between international human rights law and international humanitarian IHL provisions and principles protecting civilians[edit]
law is disputed among international law scholars. This discussion forms part of a larger
discussion on fragmentation of international law.[5] While pluralist scholars conceive Principle of distinction[edit]
international human rights law as being distinct from international humanitarian law,
proponents of the constitutionalist approach regard the latter as a subset of the The principle of distinction protects civilian population and civilian objects from
former.[6] In a nutshell, those who favor separate, self-contained regimes emphasize the the effects of military operations. It requires parties to an armed conflict to
distinguish at all times, and under all circumstances, between combatants and The principle of non-discrimination is a core principle of IHL. Adverse distinction
military objectives on the one hand, and civilians and civilian objects on the other; based on race, sex, nationality, religious belief or political opinion is prohibited in
and only to target the former. It also provides that civilians lose such protection the treatment of prisoners of war,[46] civilians,[47] and persons hors de combat.[48] All
should they take a direct part in hostilities.[38] The principle of distinction has protected persons shall be treated with the same consideration by parties to the
also been found by the ICRC to be reflected in state practice; it is therefore an conflict, without distinction based on race, religion, sex or political
established norm of customary international law in both international and non- opinion.[49] Each and every person affected by armed conflict is entitled to his
international armed conflicts. [39] fundamental rights and guarantees, without discrimination. [50] The prohibition
against adverse distinction is also considered by the ICRC to form part of
Necessity and proportionality[edit] customary international law in international and non-international armed
conflict.[51]
Necessity and proportionality are established principles in humanitarian law.
Under IHL, a belligerent may apply only the amount and kind of force necessary Women and children[edit]
to defeat the enemy. Further, attacks on military objects must not cause loss of
civilian life considered excessive in relation to the direct military advantage Women and children are granted preferential treatment, respect and protection.
anticipated.[40] Every feasible precaution must be taken by commanders to avoid Women must be protected from rape and from any form of indecent assault.
civilian casualties.[41] The principle of proportionality has also been found by the Children under the age of eighteen must not be permitted to take part in
ICRC to form part of customary international law in international and non- hostilities.
international armed conflicts. [42]
Principle of non-discrimination[edit]