Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
INTRODUCTION
The ill-fated secondary dam was constructed in 1972. Fig. 1 shows the
site location of the dam. A typical cross section is given in Fig. 2. The
plan view of the dam is shown in Fig. 3. The crest length of the em-
bankment is 217.0 m; the lowest ground level is 153.2 m; and maximum
height of the dam is 28.0 m. The leading dimensions of the dam are
given in Table 1. The total quantity of earth, filter material, and rock
pitching incorporated in the dam was 223,000 m3.
It was a homogeneous dam with a silty clay core. An inclined chimney
drain, a blanket filter, and a toe drain were provided. The upstream and
'Assoc. Prof, of Civ. Engrg., Univ. of Garyounis, Benghazi, Libya.
Note.—Discussion open until July 1, 1983. To extend the closing date one
month, a written request must be filed with the ASCE Manager of Technical and
Professional Publications. The manuscript for this paper was submitted for re-
view and possible publication on June 9, 1982. This paper is part of the Journal
o i 1 n ^ e / n ^ C ^ l ? n g i n e e r i n S ' V o L 109 ' N o - 2- February, 1983. ©ASCE, ISSN 0733-
9410/83/0002-0244/$01.00. Proc. No. 17752.
244
The Wadi Qattarah area consists of two distinct zones, a coastal plain
extending to a southerly treading cliff line and an upland and an upland
zone extending eastward from the cliff-line to the Jebel Akhdar moun-
tains. The coastal plain rises to elevations of 200 m above sea level at
the base of cliffline while in the upland zone elevations extend 600 ASL.
The upland zone is dissected by a number of Wadis, one of which is
Wadi Qattarah.
245
Earthfitt Material
K>
en
247
(D (2) (3)
Wadi limestone oolitic, greyish white, porous, soft 14
Qattarah with chert nodules
Benghazi limestone, whitish grey, medium grained, 13
weakly cemented, bedded
limestone, whitish grey, fossiliferous, weakly 8
cemented, beds of 1 m-2 m
dolomite, marly yellow 10
limestone, fine-grained, porous, bedded 6
limestone, light grey, fossiliferous, fine-grained 18
recrystallized, hard bed of 1.5 m-3.5 m
limestone, yellowish grey, fossiliferous fine- 7
grained recrystallized, hard beds of 2 m-4 m
248
FIG. 5.—A View of the General Topography of the Area Across the Failed Dam
249
175
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Univ. of Alabama At Birmingham on 05/18/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
IB 19 20 21 22 23 21 25 26 27 2B 2S 30 17 (8 19 20 21
Novtmbtr 1977 OtctmUr 1977
DATES
The annual rainfall of the area varies between wide limits from year
to year. Most of the rainfall occurs in winter (November-February) when
evaporation is small. The seasonal temperature variation in this region
is also large. Table 4 summarizes the climatological data for this region.
250
251
2 liquid limit 35
3 plastic limit 12
4 percentage finer than No. 200 95
sieve
5 percentage sand 43
6 percentage silt 25
7 percentage clay 32
8 permeability, in meters per 1.6 x 10"6
second
9 classification of soil
AASHO A-6
unified CL
10 cohesion, in kilograms per centi- 0.5 effective stress parameters
meter squared
11 angle of internal friction 26° consolidated—undrained
test
12.9 maximum dry density, in grams 1.74 standard Proctor Test
per cubic centimeter
13 optimum moisture content 19
14 compression index Cc 0.14
90
so
•* 70
•c
.ft
v?>tLL
1
SA MPL ES FALL WITHIN
| so J H E 1UNI3E SHOWN
T 1
**
V.
£ <o LJ
C
S 30
<•.
6
MWA
°- 20
0.1 . 0-0i
Diameter in mm
FIG. 9.—Particle Size Distribution of Soil Samples from Secondary Dam Core
252
showed extensive cracking in the dry season (Fig. 10). These cracks dis-
appear in the rainy season; the soil itself becomes muddy at the surface.
The seasonal cracking is severe and extensive and is commonly observed
at all sites where this type of soil is encountered in this region. The
cracks vary in width from 1 mm to as much as 8 mm. These are well
interconnected forming a regular maze pattern. Blocks of soil 150 mm
x 150 mm can be lifted easily out of the dried soil mass.
Cracking of the core may lead to leakage and erosion (7). To study
the behavior more in detail, a program of laboratory tests was under-
taken. The object of these tests was to identify the factors influencing
the width and spacing of the cracks. Soil for this purpose was collected
from the core of the failed dam. Laboratory samples were prepared,
varying in size, compactive effort, and moisture content. The samples
were prepared in moulds commonly used in laboratories for concrete
cube testing. Each sample was carefully taken out of the mould and
placed in the over (110° C) for three days. It was then taken out of the
oven, allowed to cool to room temperature, and then kept under dis-
tilled water for 12 hr. In one series of this program of testing, the soaked
253
Soil Range
number Parameter Minimum J ° Maximum Comment
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Univ. of Alabama At Birmingham on 05/18/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
samples were air-dried for a day and then put again in the oven, thus,
repeating the whole cycle. Table 7 gives the details of this testing
program.
Each sample was carefully examined before and after putting it in the
oven or under water. Results of these tests can be summarized as
follows:
These results are qualitative only, but confirmed the main suspicion that
during the long, hot summer severe cracking of the core took place,
particularly at places where compaction was poor.
Dispersive Nature of Soil.—A review of case histories of earth dam
failures (1,2,12) shows that in semi-arid areas a significant cause of fail-
ure is dispersive piping. A feature common to many of these cases is
that failure occurred after heavy rains in the catchment area following
a long drjr period during which the water level was low. Failure of the
secondary dam in Wadi Qattarah also occurred in similar circumstances.
It was thought necessary, therefore, to determine if the core of the failed
dam was of dispersive soil.
254
calcium 34.0-40.0
magnessium 21.5-25.5
sodium 67.5-70.0
potassium 0.25-0.38
2 anions (milliequivalent per liter)
bicarbonate 1.0-2.0
chlorides 109.0-114.0
sulphates 11.0-13.5
nitrates 3.5-4.0
3 sodium adsorption ratio 12.4-12.6
4 PH 7.8-7.9
ANALYSIS
N
Percent Sodium - °"00' = N
<"'00>
TOs CatMgtk
( All measured mill) equivalent per litre of Saturation Extract}
Vs. ZONE A
E2
\ ZONE C All 25 Simptts ————-?
ZONE B
-
0-2 OS 10 S 10 20 SO 100 200
Total Dissolved Solid in Saturation Extract (m. ea./litre)
1. The silty clay of which the core was constructed was moderately
dispersive.
2. In the semi-arid climate, the core suffered extensive cracking, par-
ticularly around the concrete conduit where compaction might be poor.
3. Heavy rains led to flash floods and a rapid build up of reservoir
levels and consequent high gradients of water flowing through the
cracks formed in the core.
4. Under these circumstances, the soil rapidly dispersed starting from
the walls of the cracks formed on the downstream side, progressing rap-
idly backwards.
Gravel
Sand 43 46
Silt 25.0 28.0
Clay 32 18
Liquid limit 35 37
Plastic limit 12 16
Plasticity index 23 21
Activity 0.8 1.1
Classification CL CL
a
pH = 7.5.
b
pH = 5.9.
257
1. The spillways and the conduit should be designed for larger ca-
pacity to cater for flash floods.
2. Greater care should be exercised in compaction of the core. In par-
ticular, compaction a r o u n d any discontinuity, such as the conduit,
should be controlled carefully.
3. Remedial measures to rehabilitate a failed d a m having a dispersive
clay core are most expensive. It is essential, therefore, that such soils
are identified at the earliest stage. Preventive measures can t h e n be in-
corporated in the earth d a m at the design stage.
4. Identification of dispersive nature of soil should be carried out by
several techniques. Results of one technique alone may not be conclusive.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
APPENDIX.—REFERENCES
258
259