Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Grace Hills
GT Independent Research pd 2
10 May 2018
I. Abstract
The standard treatment for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder consists primarily of
medications with little focus on alternative treatments or therapies. The default for many
patients may develop an addiction to the drug. It is important for medical professionals to
Mind Body Medicine, in which a trained practitioner utilizes the influence the mind has
over the body to treat both psychological and physiological conditions with relaxation
techniques, such as meditation. This research seeked to evaluate the benefits of treating
PTSD with complimentary medicine, specifically Mind Body Medicine. Multiple Mind
Body Medicine modalities were examined for their efficacy in treating PTSD. This paper
also analyzed published data that demonstrates the benefits of Mind Body Medicine in
treating PTSD in two post-war communities, Kosovo and Gaza, and described the
Table of Contents
Introduction-------------------------------------------------------------------------page 3
Literature Review------------------------------------------------------------------page 4
Rationale----------------------------------------------------------------------------page 10
Data Collection---------------------------------------------------------------------page 10
Analysis--------------------------------------------------------------------page 14
Data Conclusions---------------------------------------------------------page 16
Conclusion--------------------------------------------------------------------------page 16
References--------------------------------------------------------------------------page 18
II. Introduction
Mind Body Medicine is a type of alternative modality that utilizes the connection
between the brain and the body to improve mental and physical health. A variety of
biofeedback, autogenic training, and guided imagery, etc. Each of these modalities is
proved to have positive effects on an individual's physical and mental health. Recent
research indicates that Mind Body Medicine is especially useful to treat conditions such
as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), in which both the physical body and the mind
event, often experienced through flashbacks in the form of sleep disturbances (“Post
Traumatic Stress Disorder,” 2007). Left untreated, PTSD can be a debilitating condition,
due to its unpredictableness. While wealthy countries have access to the needed
medicines that can cure most psychological and physiological diseases like PTSD, areas
Hills 4
that don’t have access to good healthcare are in desperate need of Mind Body Medicine,
as it does not require a medical professional. According to data collected in 2014, the
United States designates 17.10% of its GDP to health expenditures, while Middle Eastern
Countries, such as Bangladesh and Indonesia, designate 2.80% of their GDP (The World
Factbook, 2019). Similarly, countries in Africa devote little of their GDP to healthcare
despite their large populations. Data collected from a cross country study for African
countries found that the “population of individuals over the age of 65 had no impact on
total health expenditure,” (Xu, Saksena, & Holly, 2011) indicating that African
governments do not satisfy all of their citizens health needs, due to lack of money
designated to health care. The CMBM leads a national training program that is designed
limited access to basic needs. Many of these impoverished areas are also areas that are
impacted by war. Such areas, like Gaza and Kosovo, are known to be home to many
people living with PTSD. The CMBM works with organizations such as the Red Cross
and various school systems to share and teach Mind Body Medicine techniques, in order
Medicine improves PTSD symptoms, depression, quality of life, sleep, anxiety, and stress
Meditation is one of the most commonly used Mind Body Medicine modalities,
system, thus slowing down the level of arousal the individual is experiencing.
Simultaneously, the sympathetic nervous system will slow down, creating a sense
activates regions in the brain involved with attention, the autonomic nervous
system and the left-sided anterior brain, which is associated with positive
emotional states. Immune function also improves during meditation because more
focusing on and imagining a calm surrounding, the individual can create a ‘mental
escape’ that allows them to cope with the present issues in their life (“Guided
Imagery,” 2019). Guided imagery decreases anxiety and is used to shorten the
recovery process for surgical patients (Tusek, Church, Strong, Grass, & Fazio,
1997). During autogenic training, another Mind Body Medicine technique, the
Health,” 2016). Essentially, the autogenic training participant tricks their brain
into believing that they are experiencing certain pleasant sensations based on what
they are thinking of. Biofeedback is another useful tool that can “measure body
functions and give… information about them so that [the individual] can learn to
Hills 6
control them… [it is the use of] electronic devices to teach [the individual] to
produce changes in [their] body that are associated with relaxation, such as
summary, these Mind Body Medicine modalities are all especially useful in areas
unpredictable attacks. The entire population of 1.8 million has been affected by
political violence to some degree. Unemployment and poverty levels are high, and
access to basic needs (clean, sanitation, power, feed, and health care) is limited.
Since 2005, The Center for Mind Body Medicine (CMBM) has trained 600
group support. These trained leaders have spread the knowledge of Mind Body
Medicine to more than 150,000 children and adults. Currently, there are 40,000
people participating in the mind body skills group in Gaza, thanks to the CMBM
efforts to work with organizations such as the Ministries of Health, Education and
Social Welfare, the United Nations Relief and Work Agency, and 200
international and local NGOs (Staples, Atti, Ahmed, & Gordon, 2011). Mind
Body Medicine has also been shared with other post war communities, such as
Kosovo. War in the Balkans has led to many reports of PTSD in adolescent, as the
Kosovo conflict lasted from 1998 to 1999 in which many students lost one or both
imagery, autogenic training, quiet and active meditations, and biofeedback. These
Mind Body Medicine modalities were shown to enhance the student’s sense of
control, lower sympathetic arousal, decrease anxiety, and improve mood (Gordon,
Staples, Blyta, & Bytyqi, 2004). These Mind Body Medicine interventions have
them on how to practice and share alternative treatments that do not require a
back of the mind,” 2001). Repeated traumas and traumas in early childhood make
the individual more susceptible to developing PTSD. When children are exposed
to environmental stressors, like abuse, while their brain is still developing, they
may develop a greater constant fear of their surroundings. The support of friends
and family the individual receives while working through their conditions is
crucial to healing, otherwise the PTSD symptoms may increase in severity due to
the perceived skepticism from loved ones. Those who live with PTSD are at a
much higher risk of developing other conditions such as diabetes, coronary artery
disease, depression, and addiction. Sleep disturbances are another major symptom
affects the social lives of trauma victims as well, since they frequently have
trouble connecting with friends and maintaining stable relationships. PTSD does
not only have social and psychological effects, but can also be studied from a
biological perspective. The amygdalae produce fear, reading signals and sending
messages to other parts of the brain, which filter the signals before reacting.
However, for individuals with PTSD, these filters frequently fail to distinguish
between real threats and those that can be safely ignored, leading to a constant
improving mood; however, not everybody uses or has access to these drugs. Data
collected from the US in 2019 shows that of the veterans returning from Iraq and
experienced brain injury, 25% show signs of substance abuse, but only 50% have
received treatment (StateStats, 2019). The fact that only half of the veterans with
PTSD have received treatment suggests that a more affordable and accessible
treatment option would be beneficial. Mind Body Medicine and other alternative
therapies are not only a safer and more affordable treatment option in the US, but
are also extremely beneficial in areas without access to standard health care.
Hills 9
A series of publications done by the the CMBM has shown that Mind Body
Medicine decreases PTSD symptoms, improves overall mood, and improves sleep
PTSD, found that participating in mind body skills groups reduced PTSD
(Gordon, Staples, He, & Atti, 2016). These results were consistent with a pilot
study conducted to evaluate the impact of yoga on PTSD in veterans, which found
& Uddo, 2013). The study conducted in Gaza also found that participating in
mind body skills group improves overall mood, reducing depression and anxiety
(Gordon et al. 2016). Gordon’s data was verified with a randomized control trial
evaluating the effect of Kundalini Yoga on people with PTSD, which found that
yoga participants improved in positive affect, perceived stress, anxiety, stress, and
evaluating a Kundalini yoga program found that yoga participants were much
more emotionally stable, aware, and positive (Jindani & Khalsa, 2015a). With
disturbances, which are also associated with PTSD. The randomized control trial
evaluating the effect of Kundalini Yoga on people with PTSD also found that
Jindani’s findings were confirmed by the pilot study that evaluated the impact of
improvement in sleep quality and daytime dysfunction (Staples et al. 2013). Since
many post-war communities do not have access to, or are not able to afford drugs
that help with sleeping, such as melatonin and benzodiazepines, they rely on
alternative therapies.
IV. Rationale
Meta-analysis was the most realistic approach for data collection because
experiment was unlikely, access to raw and descriptive data through the CMBM
published journals would allow for a meta-analysis. The four data sets were found from
scholarly sources with similar methodology. The data was analyzed in a new way
because it consisted of multiple types of research methods which allowed for new insight,
V. Data Collection
1 Mind–Body James S. 11 The study evaluated the effects of a (w/2) While both studies
Skills Gordon, August 10-session mind-body skills group on evaluated the effects of
Groups for Julie K. 2016 level of depression, anxiety, and Mind Body Medicine on
Post- Staples, quality of life. The study was PTSD, study 1 used a mind
traumatic David Y. conducted on 92 Palestinian adults with body skills group as the
Stress He, Jamil PTSD, in Gaza. The paper found that modality, while study 2 used
Disorder in Ahmed those participating in the MBSG had Kundalini Yoga as the
Palestinian Abdel Atti significantly reduced PTSD, modality. Both studies
Adults in depression, anxiety, and improvements evaluated the efficacy of
Gaza in quality of life. treating depression with
Mind Body Medicine, but
See Figure A only Gordon’s study found
an improvement. Both
showed an improvement in
Hills 11
2 A Yoga Farah 3 A pilot randomized control trial was (w/3) While both studies
Interventio Jindani, August conducted to evaluate the impact of evaluated the effects of
n for Post- Nigel 2015 Kundalini Yoga treatment on PTSD Kundalini yoga, study 2 was
traumatic Turner, symptoms and overall well being. The quantitative, while 3 was
Stress: Sat Bir S. study involved participants with PTSD qualitative. Both studies
A Khalsa who were randomly assigned into an 8 found that Kundalini yoga
Preliminary session Kundalini Yoga treatment and improved stress and anxiety.
Randomize the control group. The data shows that (w/4) Study 2 focused on
d Control both groups had improved PTSD treating PTSD with
Trial symptoms, but yoga participants Kundalini yoga, while study
showed greater improvements in sleep, 4 focused on treating PTSD
positive affect, perceived stress, in veterans with yoga, in
anxiety, stress, and resilience. general. Study 2 found that
PTSD symptoms improved,
See Figure B while study 4 found that
Hills 12
PTSD hyperarousal
symptoms improved but
total PTSD score did not.
Study 2 showed that the
participants overall well
being improved, while study
4 found that yoga had no
improvement on quality of
life. Both studies found that
the participant’s sleep
quality improved.
3 A Yoga Farah A. 2015 A qualitative descriptive study was (w/4) Study 3 was a
Interventio Jindani, conducted to understand how qualitative study that was
n Program G.F.S. individuals with PTSD perceive a conducted to evaluate the
for Patients Khalsa Kundalini yoga program. Jindani and effects of Kundalini yoga on
Suffering Khalsa recorded telephone interviews PTSD, while study 4
from of 40 individuals for 30-60 minutes evaluated the effect of yoga
Symptoms after participating in an 8-week on PTSD in veterans. Study
of Post- Kundalini yoga treatment. 4 found that there were no
traumatic improvements in quality of
Stress 1)‘I would say my biggest benefit has life, while study 3 found that
Disorder: been that I am more emotionally the participants were much
A balanced. Often after class, I would feel more emotionally stable,
Qualitative really strong and balanced and really, aware, and positive.
Descriptive really alert, but like deep calm. I would
Study be able to return to that feeling the days
I wasn’t in class.’’
2)‘‘I feel stronger.also more, gentle.just
a lot more hope. A lot of my.thinking
was very.stunted. This was very
empowering. I do not feel so small
anymore.
3)‘‘With yoga, I had a connection of
mind, body, and spirit. During the
practice and when you become aware
of those three things, or be aware of
them, it seems like things
are more possible. I had more peace,
the idea of finding increased peace of
mind.
I mean what could be richer than a
sense of you know a spirit; my spiritual
self.’’
Hills 13
See Figure C
Figure A
Hills 14
Figure B
Figure C
Analysis
mind body skills groups, kundalini yoga, and yoga) improves PTSD, depression,
Hills 15
quality of life, sleep, anxiety, and stress. While most of these findings were
consistent, there were a few conflicting results. For instance, Study 4 found that
there were no improvements in quality of life, while study 2 and 3 found that
stable, aware, and positive. Additionally, Study 2 found that PTSD symptoms
improved, while study 4 found that PTSD hyperarousal symptoms improved but
the total PTSD score did not.This discrepancy in results was largely due to the
fact that the compiled data consisted of multiple Mind Body Medicine
modalities.The data examines the effects of a mind body skills group, kundalini
yoga, and regular yoga on PTSD. The effects of these modalities may be too
different to generalize all three techniques as “Mind Body Medicine.” The results
indicate that Mind Body Medicine improves PTSD, however this improvement is
dependent upon the modality used, and furthermore the participant. For instance,
the first three studies were done on participants with PTSD, but their experience
was unspecified. The fourth study used was on veterans, which were consistently
less affected by the Mind Body Medicine modalities. This may be because the
PTSD in veterans was much more severe than the participants in the other three
studies who were unspecified. This concludes that Mind Body Medicine
however individuals, such as veterans, who have a higher PTSD score may need
have some limitations. Data was only gathered on a few different types of Mind
Hills 16
Body Medicine modalities (mind body skills group, kundalini yoga, and yoga)
when in reality there are dozens of other modalities considered Mind Body
Medicine. Also, not all of the studies used had specified participants (ie. veterans)
which make my results limited in evaluating the effect of Mind Body Medicine on
and narrowing of the participants in order to get results that were (1) more
indicative of Mind Body Medicine as a whole, and (2) more accurate pertaining to
one group of people with PTSD would improve the clarity of the findings.
Data Conclusion:
These results will lead future researchers to investigate the effect of Mind
indicated that Mind Body Medicine efficacy is dependent upon the severity of
PTSD. Overall, these results indicate that Mind Body Medicine improves PTSD
symptoms, depression, quality of life, sleep, anxiety, and stress in individuals with
Medicine does improve PTSD, but it is also dependent upon the modality used
VI. Conclusion
training, biofeedback, yoga, and mind body skills groups improve the mental state of an
state due to the activation of the left-sided anterior portion of the brain. Guided imagery
Hills 17
allows individuals to cope with issues in their life by imaging a ‘mental escape.’
Biofeedback measures bodily movement and impulses which allow the individual to have
a greater awareness and control over their body. Mind Body Medicine is especially
attacks, the CMBM has traveled to Gaza to teach various Mind Body Medicine
modalities. Research conducted in Gaza shows that participating in mind body skills
guided imagery, autogenic training, quiet and active meditations, and biofeedback that
enhanced sense of control, lowered sympathetic arousal, decreased anxiety, and improved
mood. (Gordon et al.) Other techniques such as yoga found a significant improvement in
sleep quality and daytime dysfunction in veterans experiencing PTSD (Staples et al.)
When comparing studies in the meta-analysis, it is clear that Mind Body Medicine
had an overall positive effect on PTSD; however the improvement of PTSD is dependent
upon the modality used and the participant. Mind Body Medicine is seen to improve
PTSD in individuals who have low PTSD scores, rather than those, such as veterans, who
have higher PTSD scores. This finding suggests medications may be more effective for
individuals with more advanced PTSD. Additional research is necessary to investigate the
effect of Mind Body Medicine on specified types of people with PTSD, such as veterans,
References
“At the back of the mind; Post traumatic stress disorder; Diagnosing post traumatic stress
disorder.” (2001, June 23). The Economist, 359( 8227), 4. Retrieved from
http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A75710310/GPS?u=glen20233&sid=GPS&xid=65df
1cc5
CIA. (2019). Country comparison: Health expenditures. In The world factbook. Retrieved from
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/resources/the-world-factbook/fields/358
rank.html
“Fear itself; Post-traumatic stress disorder.” (2015, October 24). The Economist, 417( 8961),
56(US). Retrieved from
http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A450171243/GPS?u=glen20233&sid=GPS&xid=536
a8a91
Gordon, J. S., Staples, J. K., Blyta, A., & Bytyqi, M. (2004). Treatment of posttraumatic stress
disorder in postwar Kosovo high school students using mind–body skills groups: A pilot
study. Journal of Traumatic Stress: Official Publication of The International Society for
Traumatic Stress Studies, 17( 2), 143-147.
Gordon, J. S., Staples, J. K., Blyta, A., Bytyqi, M., & Wilson, A. T. (2008). Treatment of
posttraumatic stress disorder in postwar Kosovar adolescents using mind-body skills
groups: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 69(9), 1469.
Gordon, J. S., Staples, J. K., He, D. Y., & Atti, J. A. A. (2016). Mind–body skills groups for
posttraumatic stress disorder in Palestinian adults in Gaza. Traumatology, 22( 3), 155.
Gustafson C. (2016). James Gordon, md: The Potential of Mind-Body Self Care to Free the
World From the Effects of Trauma. Integrative medicine (Encinitas, Calif.), 15(2), 54-60.
Jindani, F. A., & Khalsa, G. F. S. (2015a). A yoga intervention program for patients suffering
from symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder: A qualitative descriptive study. The
Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 21( 7), 401-408.
Jindani, F., Turner, N., & Khalsa, S. B. S. (2015b). A yoga intervention for posttraumatic stress:
A preliminary randomized control trial. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative
Medicine, 2015.
Lee, M. (2009, December 15). Calming your nerves and your heart through meditation.
Retrieved April 12, 2019, from TIN website:
http://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2009/issue61/
“Post-traumatic stress disorder.” (2007). In World of Health. Detroit, MI: Gale. Retrieved from
http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/CV2191501026/SCIC?u=glen20233&sid=SCIC&xid
=68866970
Staples, J. K., Atti, A., Ahmed, J., & Gordon, J. S. (2011). Mind-body skills groups for
posttraumatic stress disorder and depression symptoms in Palestinian children and
adolescents in Gaza. International Journal of Stress Management, 18( 3), 246.
Staples, J. K., Hamilton, M. F., & Uddo, M. (2013). A yoga program for the symptoms of
post-traumatic stress disorder in veterans. Military medicine, 178(8), 854-860.
StateStats. (2019, March-April). State Legislatures, 45( 2), 33. Retrieved from
http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A583251750/GPS?u=glen20233&sid=GPS&xid=329
11735
Tusek, D. L., Church, J. M., Strong, S. A., Grass, J. A., & Fazio, V. W. (1997). Guided imagery.
Diseases of the colon & rectum, 40( 2), 172-178.
Xu, K., Saksena, P., & Holly, A. (2011, December). The determinants of health expenditure.
Retrieved from
https://www.who.int/health_financing/documents/report_en_11_deter-he.pdf