TECHNICAL NOTE

Assessing the reproducibility of particle size

measurements using the Mastersizer 3000

A laser diffraction system is made up of two main components, the optical bench,
PARTICLE SIZE which collects the scattering data from a sample, and a dispersion unit which
must accurately deliver the sample to the optical bench. This technical note
describes how the optical bench and dispersion units are tested and how system
to system reproducibility of laser diffraction instruments can be assessed.

The Optical Bench

Figure 1 : Measurements of 58nm latex on 100 optical benches

The optical performance of a laser diffraction system is verified by measuring

standard reference materials. The performance of every optical bench produced
by Malvern Instruments is tested using a range of NIST traceable latex standards.
A range of latex sizes is required to produce scattering data over a wide enough
angular range to test all of the detectors. When the correct scattering signal is
recorded on all of the detectors then the measured particle size will be within a
certain tolerance of the specified latex size.

During production each optical bench is tested with a range of latex standards,
generating a significant data set from which the reproducibility of the optical
benches can be assessed. In this section the results of measurements of a

Malvern Instruments Worldwide

Sales and service centres in over 65 countries
www.malvern.com/contact ©2017 Malvern Instruments Limited
TECHNICAL NOTE

range of latex sizes, on 100 optical benches, are presented to demonstrate the
reproducibility of the optical benches.

Figure 1 shows the results of measurements of 59nm latex on 100 optical

benches. The scatter plot shows the measured Dv50 where the limits of the
size axis show the acceptable range of the results. The same data is also
represented in a box plot in Figure 1. Data sets for the other latex sizes are
similarly represented in box plots in Figure 2.

Table 1 : Statistics for latex data over 100 systems

Measured results

Latex size Lower Min Average Max Upper % RSD

limit Limit

58nm 56.7 58.3 59.2 60.2 61.4 0.77

102nm 98.4 101.2 102.2 103.3 105.6 0.52

147nm 141.8 147.6 147.9 148.2 152.2 0.10

707nm 693.8 702.6 704.0 705.9 720.3 0.11

0.994um 0.978 0.981 0.988 0.997 1.0 0.41

9um 8.648 8.807 8.845 8.889 9.4 0.19

Table 1 shows the statistics for measurements on 100 benches, including

the average, maximum and minimum values, compared to the target size
range. Table 1 also shows the relative standard deviation (RSD) over the 100
measurements. The RSD is less than 1% for all latex sizes across the 100 benches,
showing reproducibility better than the ISO standard states for repeatability of a
single sample [1].

The Dispersion Units

Optical performance is only part of a laser diffraction system, it is also important
to test the performance of the dispersion units as these are responsible for
accurately presenting the sample to the optical system. There are different
requirements of a sample used to test the performance of the dispersion unit; the
material must have a broader size distribution in order to test sampling from the
dispersion unit, it must also require some energy to suspend and disperse it so
that the dispersive performance of the accessory is tested.

2 Assessing the reproducibility of particle size measurements using the Mastersizer 3000
TECHNICAL NOTE

Figure 2 : Reproducibility data for 6 latex standards on 100 benches

Malvern has developed a Quality Audit Standard (QAS) which meets all of the
requirements of ISO 13320 for a certified reference material. Glass beads are an
appropriate reference material for laser diffraction as they are spherical particles
with well-known optical properties.

The particle size distribution of the sample must be greater than one decade in
size. The width of the size distribution is specified as the ratio of the Dv90/Dv10
which must be between 1.5 and 10. For QAS the Dv90/Dv10 is approximately 2.3,
see Table 2.

Sampling bias is removed from the measurement process by using a single shot
sample. These single shot vials are produced by riffling down from a master batch
into appropriate masses for each dispersion unit.

A full measurement procedure is defined for each dispersion unit [2] setting such
parameters as measurement duration, stir speed, air pressure and vibration rate
to ensure full dispersion of the material. 

The target size and pass/fail criteria for QAS have been measured on a reference
laser diffraction system which has been verified using NIST -traceable polystyrene
latex standards. Therefore, as a reference material, QAS is indirectly traceable
to NIST. The pass/fail criteria have been set, according to the ISO standard as
follows; the Dv10 must be within 3% of the target value, the Dv50 within 2.5% and
the Dv90 within 4%.

The performance of each dispersion unit is assessed by measuring QAS

samples using a single optical bench. Each system is tested during production
and a significant data set has been acquired from which system to system
reproducibility can be assessed.

The reproducibility of the dry dispersion units, Aero S, was assessed by measuring
QAS samples using 100 dispersion units. In Figure 3 the scatter plot shows Dv50
from these 100 measurements vs accessory number, a line has been added to

3 Assessing the reproducibility of particle size measurements using the Mastersizer 3000
TECHNICAL NOTE

show the target value and the size axis extends to ± 2.5% of the target value. The
same data is also represented in a box plot in Figure 3.

The average values and RSDs from these QAS measurements using the Aero S are
shown in Table 1. The RSDs are less than 1% for all parameters, demonstrating
system to system reproducibility better that the repeatability of a laser diffraction
measurement, as stated in the ISO standard.

The reproducibility of the wet dispersion units was tested by measuring 100 QAS
samples on each of the wet dispersion units, Hydro MV, Hydro LV and Hydro EV.
The Dv50 vs. accessory number for all 300 wet QAS measurements is shown in
Figure 4

Figure 3 : Scatter plot and box plot of 100 QAS measurements using the Aero S

The statistics from the wet measurements are shown in Table 2. When the data
from all wet units is combined the RSDs are less than 1% showing excellent
reproducibility across the range of dispersion units. The RSDs for individual
dispersion units are even lower.

This level of reproducibility between the dispersion units simplifies the process of
transferring methods and specifications between sites and different dispersion
units.

Table 2 : QAS reproducibility data on all dispersion units

Accessory Dv10 μm Dv50 μm Dv90 μm

Average %RSD Average %RSD Average %RSD

Aero S 38.23 0.41 62.64 0.30 89.49 0.39

Hydro EV 36.08 0.35 60.82 0.15 88.74 0.52

Hydro MV 36.67 0.37 61.28 0.29 89.33 0.63

Hydro LV 36.83 0.57 61.95 0.38 89.62 0.44

All Wet 36.53 0.99 61.35 0.81 89.23 0.67

4 Assessing the reproducibility of particle size measurements using the Mastersizer 3000
TECHNICAL NOTE

Conclusions
The reproducibility of laser diffraction instruments requires both the optical bench
and dispersion units to be tested. A range of latex standards have been measured
on 100 optical benches in order to test bench to bench reproducibility. The results
show a relative standard deviation over the one hundred measurements of less
than 1%.

The reproducibility of the dispersion units have been tested by measuring QAS
samples on one hundred of each type of dispersion units. This showed a relative
standard deviation of less than 1% for the 100 measurements on each dispersion
unit, and across all of the wet dispersion units combined.

Figure 4 : Dv50 vs accessory number, for 300 wet dispersion units

References
• ISO13320 (2009). Particle Size Analysis - Laser Diffraction Methods, Part 1:
General Principles
• QAS measurement procedure

5 Assessing the reproducibility of particle size measurements using the Mastersizer 3000
 TECHNICAL NOTE

Malvern Instruments Malvern Instruments is part of Spectris plc, the Precision Instrumentation and Controls Company.
Limited
Grovewood Road, Malvern, Spectris and the Spectris logo are Trade Marks of Spectris plc.
Worcestershire, UK. WR14
1XZ

All information supplied within is correct at time of publication.

Malvern Instruments pursues a policy of continual improvement due to technical development. We therefore

reserve the right to deviate from information, descriptions, and specifications in this publication without notice.
Malvern Instruments shall not be liable for errors contained herein or for incidental or consequential damages in
connection with the furnishing, performance or use of this material.

Malvern Instruments owns  the following registered trademarks: Bohlin, FIPA, Insitec, ISYS, Kinexus, Malvern,
Malvern 'Hills' logo, Mastersizer, MicroCal, Morphologi, Rosand, 'SEC-MALS', Viscosizer, Viscotek, Viscogel and
Zetasizer.

©2017 Malvern Instruments Limited