Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
theory of the
universe
contents
&
contexts
H. Kragh,
Centre for Science Studies,
Aarhus University
The 1950s: is cosmology a respectable science?
Cosmology is a field where ”personal taste will greatly influence the choice
Deceleration parameter q0 = -1
d 2 R / dt 2
q0 2
Matter density ρ = ρcrit ≈ 5 × 10-28 g cm-3 RH
Matter creation rate = 3ρH ≈ 10-43 g s-1 cm-3
”The steady state model is the one that can be disproved most easily by
observation. Therefore, it should take precedence over other less
disprovable ones until it has been disproved.”
Non-empirical testing:
Does the SS theory lead to consequences that are
contradictory, or highly bizarre?
Whitrow’s paradoxes
1. Time-scale problem
2. Redshift-magnitude relationship
6. Formation of galaxies
H = 500 km/s/Mpc
T = 1/H = 1.8 Gy
”the steady-state
theory does not fit
the real world.”
m - M ≈ 5 log(cz) + (1 – q0)z Cosmological tests,
1956-64,
magnitude-redshift:
steady-state model.
Angular diameter-redshift test
R. Alpher & R. Herman, ”Evolution of the universe,” Nature 162 (1948), 774-75.
1965: Discovery of the cosmic
microwave background
R. Dicke
Y. Zel’dovich
J. Peebles
Ca. 1970: A new paradigm of
cosmology (hot big bang).
Growing institutionalisation
etc.
QSSC (quasi steady-state cosmology)