Sie sind auf Seite 1von 13

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/229094398

City Profile: Baguio

Article  in  Cities · January 2011


DOI: 10.1016/j.cities.2011.05.002

CITATIONS READS

12 9,238

2 authors:

Ronald C. Estoque Yuji Murayama


National Institute for Environmental Studies University of Tsukuba
62 PUBLICATIONS   695 CITATIONS    231 PUBLICATIONS   2,192 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

New Springer Journal: Euro-Mediterranean Journal for Environmental Integration View project

Mobile Geospatial Data Collection View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Ronald C. Estoque on 14 September 2018.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Cities 30 (2013) 240–251

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Cities
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/cities

City profile

City Profile: Baguio


Ronald C. Estoque a,⇑, Yuji Murayama b
a
Division of Spatial Information Science, Graduate School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Japan; Don Mariano Marcos Memorial State University,
Philippines
b
Division of Spatial Information Science, Graduate School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Japan

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Baguio, planned as a convalescent-cum-recreational center and a highland refuge by American colonizers,
Received 23 September 2010 has evolved into a highly-urbanized regional center. The availability of essential urban services and facil-
Received in revised form 25 February 2011 ities has helped transform the settlement into the summer capital of the country, a major educational and
Accepted 5 May 2011
tourist center, the seat of the regional government and, in recent years, an emerging industrial and health
Available online 17 June 2011
service center north of Metro Manila. Congestion arising from rapid population growth and uncontrolled
urban expansion are exerting pressure on the city’s amenities, resources and the natural environment.
Keywords:
This profile traces the city’s evolution as a hill station to a highly urbanized regional center, and discusses
Baguio
Hill station
and analyses its plans for future development. Systematic planning, cooperation and good governance are
Population crucial to address the many challenges that the city faces, and to allow for its sustainable development in
Summer capital the future.
Urbanization Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Philippines

Introduction of 489 in 1903 (OCPDC, 2002), the city is now a home to 301,926
people (NSO, 2007) and is one of the highly urbanized entities in
From 1980–1990, the 5.1% annual urban growth rate in the Phil- the country today. The development and availability of basic and
ippines was considered one of the highest in the developing econ- essential urban services and facilities have helped transform the
omies of Asia (Mercado & Manasan, 1998). Such growth was city into a major educational, tourist, and government center in
controlled by a mixture of factors related to the history, geography, the region. In recent years, Baguio city has emerged not only as a
as well as the ‘‘sectoral’’ macroeconomic and explicit spatial leading industrial center, but also as a health services center north
policies influencing the development of urban areas (Mercado & of Metro Manila. However, rapid urbanization and population
Manasan, 1998; NEDA, 1996). growth are straining the city’s resources. Such developments are
In the Philippines, the explosive and unabated growth of urban beginning to take a toll on the people’s well-being and on the envi-
areas is considered one of the most important indicators that char- ronment. Having reviewed the city’s geographical characteristics,
acterize the country’s development process (Cariño & Corpuz, history, and its socio-economic conditions, this paper looks at
2008). In the early 1950s, just a little over 5 million [or around Baguio’s evolution as a hill station to a highly urbanized regional
27% of Filipinos] were residing in cities. By the early 1990s, the center. Current environment-related issues are identified, and this
country’s urban proportion had risen to well over 29 million, or al- is followed by a discussion and analysis of the city’s plans for
most 49% of the country’s population. This rose further to more future development, and a summary and concluding remarks.
than 53 million [over 60% of the population] in 2005. It has been
projected that about 117 million, or 84% of Filipinos, will be urban
residents by 2050 (Cariño & Corpuz, 2008). Geographical background
As the only American hill station in Asia (Crossette, 1999; Reed,
1999) and the only hill station in the Philippines, Baguio city, the Baguio city is located 16°250 N and 120°360 E on Luzon Island,
country’s summer capital, enjoyed economic, political and social Philippines, approximately 250 km north of Manila (Fig. 1).
prominence for more than a century. Compared with a population Although it functions independently as a chartered city1, Baguio
is situated within the province of Benguet in the Cordillera

⇑ Corresponding author. Address: Division of Spatial Information Science, Grad- 1


A chartered city, which includes a number regarded as Highly Urbanized City, is
uate School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Tsukuba, 1-1-1 accorded significant powers of self-government and individual representation as a
Tennodai, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8572, Japan. congressional district (which are otherwise based on provincial and congressional
E-mail address: purplebee80@yahoo.co.uk (R.C. Estoque). district boundaries, respectively).

0264-2751/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.cities.2011.05.002
R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251 241

Fig. 1. Location and elevation maps of Baguio city and its adjacent municipalities. Data source: 1995 Topographic Map (NAMRIA, 1995).

Administrative Region (CAR). The more developed portion lies in the range of Northern Luzon. Baguio city is, on the average, 8 °C cooler
northern half of the city (Saldivar-Sali & Einstein, 2007). The city, than the lowlands. Its average temperature ranges from 15 °C to
approximately 57.49 km2 in area, extends 8.2 km from west to east 23 °C, seldom exceeding 26 °C even during the warmer months
and 7.2 km from north to south (OCPDC, 2002). It has a perimeter (Saldivar-Sali & Einstein, 2007). It is generally lower at the end
of about 31 km, being bounded by the municipalities of La Trinidad and beginning of the year; the lowest temperature of 6.3 °C was re-
(the provincial capital of Benguet) in the north, Itogon in the north- corded on January 18, 1961, while the city’s all-time high temper-
east, Tuba in the west and Sablan in the northwest. Politically and ature of 30.4 °C was recorded on March 15, 1988 (Basilan &
administratively, it is divided into 129 barangays.2 Vicente, 2008).
Generally, the city’s climate is characterized by two pronounced In terms of accessibility, Baguio city can be reached from the
regimes: a dry season from November to April, and a rainy season western lowland areas via three national roads, namely Naguilian
from May to October. Baguio city’s rainfall record of 1168.1 mm in Road, Kennon Road and Marcos Highway (Figs. 1 and 6). It is also
24 h on July 14–15, 1911 (Jennings, 1950) is among the highest in accessible via the Ambuclao Road and Halsema Highway from
the world. From 1950–2003, the average annual rainfall in Baguio the northeastern highlands and through the Baguio–Bua–Itogon
was 3648 mm (Saldivar-Sali & Einstein, 2007). In October 2009, the Road from the eastern part of the city.
rainfall in the city was extremely high due to a tropical cyclone,
rendering a rainfall record of 462 mm for that month, almost four
A brief history of Baguio City
times the monthly average (Papa, 2009). Rainfall is generally high-
er in Baguio than in the rest of the country: for instance, it receives
Towards the end of the 19th century, increasing numbers of
twice the volume of rainfall usually experienced in Manila (Saldi-
Westerners became attracted to the cooler mountain towns in
var-Sali & Einstein, 2007).
the highlands of South and Southeast Asia in the belief that lengthy
As a hill station, Baguio city is famed for its cool climate owing
stays in such climates greatly benefited the body and spirit (Reed,
to its elevation from 950 to 1650 m asl. Most of the developed
1999). One of these popular mountainous destinations was the
areas are on a 1500 m high plateau in the Cordillera mountain
province of Benguet in the Cordillera region, the location of Baguio
city. Benguet had been under the control of the Spanish, whose re-
2
Barangay is also known by its former Spanish adopted name, the barrio. It is the
gime in the Philippines lasted more than 300 years (1521–1898). In
smallest administrative division in the Philippines and is the native Filipino term for a 1898 when the Americans first came to Kafagway, the original
village, district or ward. name of Baguio city, there were only few houses and no roads
242 R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251

(Gutierrez & Cariño, 2009). The area was used for herding cattle In the early 1900s, the Americans established the first civil gov-
and horses during the dry months of the year while during the ernment in the province of Benguet (Doronila, 2009), with Kafag-
wet season, it was all marshland with a shallow lake. The favorable way, later renamed Baguio, designated as the capital. Baguio was
climate and the high potential of the area for development as a thought to be derived from the native Ibaloi word ‘‘bigyiw,’’ which
holiday destination, convalescent-cum-recreational center and as is a moss-like green plant that grew around the area where Burn-
a refuge to escape from ‘‘tropical fatigue’’ were the reasons why ham Park is now located. In June 1903, the Philippine Commission
the Americans proposed Baguio as a place to develop. passed a resolution making the town of Baguio the summer capital

Fig. 2. (a) The preliminary plan for Baguio in 1905 (Redrawn by the City Planning Office) Source: OCPDC (2002); (b) Aerial photograph of Baguio city in 2009 (Source: Google
Earth, 2009). These two maps show that despite some revisions made on the Burnham plan through the years, its main features like the Burnham Park, government and
commercial center still exist and remain significant landmarks in present day Baguio city.
R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251 243

of the country (Doronila, 2009; Guerra, 2006). Also included in the


resolution was the call for the construction of buildings and trans-
portation routes. In 1905, a modern city (Baguio city), envisioned
to accommodate up to 25,000 people, was planned and laid out
(Fig. 2a) by Daniel H. Burnham, an American architect and city
planner (Alabanza, 2007; Doronila, 2009, Gutierrez & Cariño,
2009).
In 1909, Baguio was declared the second chartered city in the
Philippines, after Manila (Doronila, 2009; Gutierrez & Cariño,
2009). Some of the major construction projects and improvements
that took place from the early 1900s up to the Second World War
included the establishment of the telephone system, Baguio Gen-
eral Hospital, Philippines Constabulary School (the predecessor of
the Philippine Military Academy), water system, sanitary camp, Ba-
guio airport, hydroelectric plant, the Baguio Central School, and the
construction of Kennon Road that connects Baguio and Manila and Fig. 3. Population by age group in Baguio city, 2000.
other lowland areas.
After a history of steady development, Baguio city suffered a
setback when Japan occupied the Philippines in 1941. A garrison increasing demand for specialized elderly services, steps must be
and a concentration camp were set up in the city during the war taken to institutionalize specialized geriatric care services.
(Reed, 1999). The city is also known as the place where Japanese
generals signed their capitulation in 1945. After the war, much Economy and employment
has been done to transform Baguio city into one of the bustling
metropolises in the country and a leading urban center north of The city’s economy largely depends on commercial wholesale
Metro Manila. Today, it functions as an educational, trading, tour- and retail services. Besides providing employment, business taxes
ism and administrative hub in northern Luzon, apart from being from such services generate substantial income for the city. There
the ‘‘Summer Capital of the Philippines.’’ are some 9907 legitimate businesses operating in various parts of
the city (OCPDC, 2002). The majority of the economic activities,
representing 86% of the total, include commercial retailers
Socio-economic conditions (49.49%), real estate leaser/boarding house operators (13.55%), ser-
vices/contractors (11.70%), restaurants and cafes (6.21%), and
Demography wholesalers (4.92%). Baguio city also hosts a special economic zone
(SEZ) under the Philippine Economic Zone Authority (PEZA). The
Based on the population census by the NSO (2007), Baguio city SEZ caters to nine foreign firms. The largest of these is Texas Instru-
has a population of 301,926. Starting from two groups of native Fil- ments Philippines, Inc., a leading producer of semi-conductor parts
ipinos (Ilocanos and Igorots: Wilson, 1955), the city’s population and accessories for the world market. The production output in the
now includes other native groups like Pangasinenses, Tagalogs, SEZ accounts for the bulk of the exports from the Cordillera Region
and Kapampangans from across the country, as well as foreign where Baguio city is its regional capital. There are also small and
nationals who have opted to settle in the city (Acupanda, 2007). medium scale handicraft industries such as woodcraft, metal craft,
The city’s population has now become diverse. Ilocano is the most garments production, food processing and ceramics production.
common mother tongue dialect, spoken by 50% of households, fol- These local products are unique for their ethnic and personal
lowed by Tagalog (23%) and Pangasinense (4%). Close to 10% speak touch. However, the local and indigenous industrial enterprises re-
the indigenous Cordillera dialects including Ibaloi and Bontok (3% main underdeveloped as alternative major sources of income.
each), while the remaining 13% speak other languages and dialects The city generates its income from the Internal Revenue Allot-
(OCPDC, 2002). Baguio’s households are relatively conversant in ment (IRA) coming from the national government and tax and
English. The variety of languages and dialects indicates that signif- non-tax revenues. IRA is a local government’s share (in this case,
icant migration has taken place, also accounting for the large pop- Baguio city) of revenues from the national government, which is
ulation growth. largely based on land area and population (RA 7160, 1991). The
Statistical data by the NSO (2000) revealed a sex ratio of 104 tax and non-tax revenues include local taxes generated from per-
females to 100 males. The city has a very young population, with mits and licenses, services, business and other miscellaneous
68.70% below 30 years of age (Fig. 3). To support such a young pop- sources (OCPDC, 2002; OCT, 2010). Baguio’s income has been con-
ulation structure, there is the need to provide services to sustain tinuously increasing from 1996 to 2009 as reflected in Table 1,
socio-economic welfare in health and nutrition, education, public peaking at 27% annual increase for the 1998–2000 period following
safety and protection, etc. Equally important is the need to provide the full implementation of the city ordinance on tax collection
services for the elderly. Unfortunately, such services are currently (OCPDC, 2002). This income is utilized to support the city’s differ-
inadequate (OCPDC, 2002). As a proactive strategy to address the ent projects and public facilities and services.

Table 1
Baguio city income, 1996–2009 (in million PhP).

Particulars 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2009


Internal revenue allotment 134.46 177.87 215.69 226.41 236.26 274.46 323.32 400.66
Tax and non-tax revenue 146.65 171.99 324.28 226.41 236.26 502.31 532.32 519.45
Total 281.11 349.87 539.97 584.08 719.22 776.76 855.68 920.11
Total% annual increase – 12.23 27.17 4.08 11.57 4.00 5.08 7.53

Data sources: OCPDC (2002), OCT (2010).


244 R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251

Fig. 4. Some of the most popular tourist destinations in Baguio city. (From left to right: The Mansion, Burnham park/lake, Camp John Hay & Baguio Cathedral). The Mansion,
formerly known as Mansion house, was built in 1908 and served as the residence of the US Governor-general who was then the administrator in the Philippines. It is currently
the official summer residence of the President of the Philippines. Burnham Park was named after its planner himself, Daniel H. Burnham, an American city planner, who
designed the original plan for Baguio city. This park is well known in the entire country. Camp John Hay was established in 1903 to serve as a military reservation of the U.S.
army. This former rest and recreation facility of the US Armed Forces is now a popular tourist destination in the city with its world-class golf course and other amenities. The
Baguio Cathedral has also been a major landmark in the heart of the city. It served as an evacuation center during the Second World War. Sources: OCPDC (2002);
www.baguio.gov.ph; www.gobaguio.com; www.innsison.com.

Table 2
Total foreign tourists visited the Philippines and CAR from 2000 to 2009 (103). Source: NSCB (2010).

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Philippines 1841.8 1698.1 1848.9 1806.9 2187.6 2497.7 2697.0 2911.3 2944.1 2819.2
CAR 53.9 47.5 41.1 53.7 57.4 70.6 76.8 92.6 113.1 89.9
% To total (Philippines) 2.9 2.8 2.2 3.0 2.6 2.8 2.8 3.2 3.8 3.2

Another fast growing sector in the city is education, which gen- festivals that continue to attract visitors, most notably the annual
erates an average annual income of PhP2 billion. This has helped Flower Festival or Panagbenga3 that is celebrated every February.
sustain the city’s income for the last few decades (Cabreza, Caluza, Besides being a very popular tourist destination, it is also a
& Dauigoy, 2009). The education sector has also become the city’s gateway to other tourist hot spots in the north. Hence Baguio city
primary profit center (Cabreza et al., 2009), coinciding with the de- plays a very strategic role in the region’s tourism industry. In
cline in tourist arrivals in the wake of the world financial crisis 2005, the Cordillera region welcomed 866,242 tourists, of whom
(NSCB, 2010). Currently, Baguio city is regarded as the education 91.1% were domestic visitors, 8.2% were foreign travelers and
center of northern Luzon in the Philippines catering to both local balikbayans4 were the minority at 0.7% (NSCB, 2006). The cool cli-
and foreign students. This is due not only to the good standards mate and fresh green and peaceful environment of Baguio, not
of the learning institutions in the city but also to the moderately found elsewhere in the Philippines and for which the city is noted,
cool conducive environment the city provides. Public and private make it a favorite destination for many, especially those who wish
schools and universities can be found in the city. The city’s literacy to relax and escape from the excessive heat of the lowlands. This is
rate is 98% (www.baguio.gov.ph, 2009). the city’s strongest selling point. Thus, during the said year, Baguio
The agricultural, industrial, and service sectors provide remained the favorite destination in the region with total tourist
employment for the residents of Baguio. The three major sources arrivals making up nearly 74% of the region’s total. It was estimated
of income for families in the city are salaries and wages (61%); that the tourism industry in the whole region generated PhP5.4 bil-
entrepreneurial activities (20%); and other activities (19%) lion in tourist expenditures (NSCB, 2006). Tourism activities and
(OCPDC, 2002). Most of the salary and wage earners derive their the tourists themselves add to increased consumption of the city’s
income from employment in service-oriented private enterprises. goods and services. The top ten countries that account for foreign
Entrepreneurial activities are the second major source of income, tourist arrivals from 2000 to 2009 are USA, Korea, Japan, Germany,
while other sources include net-shares from crops produced, live- Canada, France, Australia, China, UK, and Netherlands (NSCB, 2010).
stock raised by individual households, rentals, and the like. In fact, The comparative statistics of the total foreign tourists visited the
more than 70% of the industries generating employment for the Philippines and the Cordillera region from 2000 to 2009 are pre-
residents of the Cordillera region as well as those in the nearby sented in Table 2.
provinces and municipalities are situated in the city (Agoot,
2010). This highlights the city’s role as a regional center as far Land use of Baguio city
as employment in the region is concerned. Baguio’s employment
rate has improved from 91.4% in 2002 to 95% in 2010, which is At the time when mountain tribes (Igorots) named Ibalois and
higher than the national employment rate of 92.7% (Agoot, Kankanaeys settled in Baguio, it was a wide expanse of pasture
2010; Lopez, 2010). and grazing land, partly planted with coffee and partly used as
grazing ground for cattle and horses. Besides one main horse trail,
Tourism there were numerous cart trails leading to various parts of the city
(Reed, 1999). Although they may not be in the same geographic
Despite some setbacks experienced during the recent years due location, the three images presented in Fig. 5 give an idea of how
to the world financial crisis (NSCB, 2010), Baguio city remains a the old and new landscapes of Baguio city look.
prime tourist destination in northern Luzon and summer capital
of the country. The city boasts several tourist attractions, including 3
Panagbenga is an Ilocano term which means onset of the blooming period of
historical landmarks, cultural heritages, natural, religious, and flowers.
man-made features, some of which are shown in Fig. 4. Parks 4
Balikbayan (Balikbayans – plural) is a Filipino term referring to people of Filipino
and gardens also abound in the city. The city hosts events and ancestry who are citizens or residents or of temporary status in a different country.
R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251 245

Fig. 5. Old and current landscapes of Baguio city. Fig. 5a shows a part of Baguio city in the early 1900s (Source: Baguio City Hall). Fig. 5b shows a 2010 picture of the fully
urbanized, relatively flat and hilly area (Quirino Hill) in Baguio city. Fig. 5c shows a 2011 picture of Quirino Hill, one of the barangays in the northern part of the city. To its left
is the Buyog watershed.

Based on the existing land use map of the city (Fig. 6) (OCPDC, revisions to adapt to the current situations, it has retained some of
2002), forest reserves/watersheds in the city occupy a total area of its significant features (Fig. 2). Third, the resolute exercise of colo-
521.23 ha. Some of these reservations, however, have been par- nial authority by the U.S. Philippine Commission successfully com-
tially encroached upon by settlers. No buffer zones were con- pleted essential infrastructure projects during the initial
structed around these reservations like in the case of the Buyog development stage in the early 20th century, despite many set-
watershed (Fig. 5c). Parks and industrial areas occupy 48.83 and backs. The commission stood by its belief that Baguio city would
130.39 ha, respectively, of the city’s total land area. Open areas be beneficial to both Westerners and the Filipinos as a highland
covering 1951.8 ha are vacant/idle areas but include private claims health resort and recreational center. Finally, the continuing pro-
and ownerships. Open areas at the periphery have steep slopes, cess of Filipinization by western government officials, who encour-
making them unsuitable for the construction of buildings. The rest aged Filipinos to build summer homes in the city and to use the
of the area is utilized for an airport, abattoir, dumping site and facilities, opened the door for Filipinos to patronize and foster what
cemetery. The complete statistics of the land use of the city are was conceptualized and built in the locality. In 1920–1930s, Amer-
given in Table 3. ican influence dominated the social, educational, political, and eco-
nomic life of the city. However, the process of change started soon
after the transfer of authority at the local and provincial levels to
Urban growth and development Filipinos. The process marked the city’s next step in its journey to-
wards its major transformation.
Urbanization is a vital factor in the demographic changes in Ba- During the last two decades, the expansion of Baguio city’s
guio city. Baguio’s distinctive transformation is the product of four built-up area (urban, residential, industrial, institutional, and areas
factors (Reed, 1999). First, the original intentions for Baguio as a occupied by other man-made structures) has been tremendous.
convalescent-cum-recreational center when it was first planned Fig. 7 shows the spatial distribution and expansion of built-up
are still relevant today. Second, the Burnham Plan. Despite periodic areas from 1988 to 2009. The built-up area in the city increased
246 R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251

Fig. 6. Land use map of Baguio city (OCPDC, 2002).

Table 3 towards to these locations and the trend may still continue if not
Land use in Baguio City. Source: OCPDC (2002).
monitored and controlled. Despite the frequent lack of contiguity,
Land use Area (ha) Percentage many of the built-up expansions are observed along the areas near
Residential 1760.96 30.63 the roads (see Fig. 6 for the road names), specifically Kennon Road
Commercial 201.35 3.50 in the south, Marcos Highway in the west, Naguilian Road in the
Institutional 410.02 7.13 northwest, Ambuclao Road and Halsema Highway in the northeast,
Park 48.83 0.85
Baguio–Bua–Itogon Road in the east, and Loakan Road in the south-
Forest/water reserves 521.23 9.07
Special economic zone 288.10 5.01 eastern side. This reflects the importance of accessibility on the
Open areas 1951.80 33.95 expansion of built-up areas in the city. Fig. 7 also shows that
Roads/creeks 309.71 5.39 built-up areas have already begun expanding towards the perime-
Industrial 130.39 2.27 ter of the city’s administrative boundary, and even outside it.
Agrarian reserves 96.57 1.68
After more than 100 years of its existence, Baguio city has been
Airport 1.72 0.03
Cemetery 20.13 0.35 transformed physically, economically and politically. With a popu-
Abattoir 5.60 0.10 lation of 841 in 1904, composed of 811 Igorots and 30 Ilocanos
Garbage dumping site 2.59 0.05 (Wilson, 1955), the figure swelled to 301,926 in 2007 (NSO,
Total 5749.00 100.00
2007), with a daytime population of around 700,000 (See, 2010).
This tremendous population increase for a relatively small city
has far outstripped its designed ceiling of 25,000 people. During
from 1075.86 ha in 1988 to 1972.71 ha and 2985.12 ha in 1998 and the early 20th century, building of houses in the city by the locals
2009 respectively, at a rate of 8.45% per year for the last 21 years was even encouraged and inspired by city officials (Gutierrez &
(Estoque & Murayama, 2010). The extent of urban development Cariño, 2009). Over the years, however, the population grew very
in Baguio city varies greatly among the barangays, ranging from rapidly. Moreover, the city’s annual population growth rate (APGR)
1% to 100% of their respective areas. The number of fully built-up has always been higher than the national growth rate (Table 4).
barangays had increased from six in 1988 to 46 in 2009. This In comparison to the other great hill stations in Asia such as
means that nearly two barangays per year became fully built-up Simla in India, Murree in Pakistan, Nuwara Eliya in Sri Lanka, Cam-
between 1988 and 2009. Most of these barangays are situated eron Highlands in Malaysia, Bogor in Indonesia, and Da lat in Viet-
within the central business district (CBD). nam (Crossette, 1999), Baguio is the second largest in terms of
Built-up areas tend to be quite fragmented due to the existence population density. Bogor has the largest population density, at
of institutional reserves like forest reservations and parks that limit 8737 persons/km2 (BPS – Statistics Bureau, 2010) followed by
further development. Also, very steep slope areas command lesser Baguio with a population density of 5252 persons/km2 (NSO,
demand. Nevertheless, there is no assurance that these areas will 2007). The lowest population density among these great hill
not be built-up in the future. People have already begun moving stations is Cameron highlands with 49 persons/km2 (DOSM, 2010).
R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251 247

Fig. 7. Urban growth of Baguio city, 1988–2009. These maps were extracted from the land use/cover maps derived from 1988, 1998, and 2009 satellite images, with accuracy
levels of 86.86%, 87.18% and 89.10%, respectively. Source: Estoque and Murayama (2010).

Table 4
Historical growth of population in Baguio City and the Philippines. Sources: Population data: NSO (2007), OCPDC (2002), www.census.gov.ph (2010).

Census year Baguio city Philippines


Population Population densitya (no. of persons/km2) APGRc (%) Population Population densityb (no. of persons/km2) APGRc (%)
1903 489 8.51 – 7635,426 25.47 –
1918 5464 95.04 63.59 10,314,310 34.41 2.34
1939 24,117 419.50 16.26 16,000,303 53.38 2.63
1948 29,262 508.99 2.37 19,234,182 64.16 2.25
1960 50,436 877.30 6.03 27,087,685 90.36 3.40
1970 84,538 1470.48 6.76 36,684,486 122.38 3.54
1975 97,449 1695.06 3.05 42,070,660 140.35 2.94
1980 119,669 2081.56 4.56 48,098,460 160.45 2.87
1990 183,142 3185.63 5.30 60,703,206 202.50 2.62
1995 226,883 3946.48 4.78 68,616,536 228.90 2.61
2000 252,386 4390.09 2.25 76,506,928 255.22 2.30
2007 301,926 5251.80 2.80 88,566,732 295.45 2.25
a
Computed using the existing land area of Baguio City (57.49 km2).
b
Computed using the existing land area of the Philippines (299,764 km2).
c
Annual population growth rate, computed as: APGR = ((((Census period 2–Census period 1)/Census period 1)  100)/census year interval).

Like Baguio, Bogor also faces problems associated with rapid planning areas. In Vietnam, rapid urbanization has also been
urbanization. It is now part of the Jakarta Metropolitan Region, reportedly changing Da lat’ s landscape and natural beauty due
otherwise known as Jabotabek. Simla, the ‘‘Queen of Hills’’, is to the lack of urban planning (Vietnam News, 2010). In Pakistan,
no exception. Its poorly planned infrastructural development Murree, like Baguio city, was full of potential for development.
(Jreat, 2004; Misra, 2008) cannot keep pace with rapid urbaniza- This led to a proposal for a New Murree Project aimed at
tion. This popular hill station in India, accommodating 141 per- developing a lavish tourist city. That was, however, before the
sons/km2 (Chaudhry, 2003), is now one of the largest towns in Punjab government set the project aside since Murree had
the entire Himalayan region (Jreat, 2004). Administratively, Simla already been declared as an environmentally sensitive area (The
comprises the Simla municipal corporation and the Simla Nation – Pakistan, 2009).
248 R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251

Environment-related issues Table 5


Sources of CO2 (tons) in Baguio City, 1998–2000. Source: Clemente (2006).

The uncontrolled population and urban growth, and the Type 1998 1999 2000 2010*
occurrence of natural disasters have exacerbated environmental Residential 40,539 41,871 45,055 101,094
problems. In particular, risks and natural disasters, waste manage- Commercial 19,428 22,257 25,504 85,694
ment, water management, greenhouse gasses emissions are the Industrial 9498 9224 9008 6911
current environment-related issues confronting the city today, Transportation 106,898 116,094 126,097 290,134
Buildings 4258 4402 4764 8399
requiring immediate attention.
Transportation 688 801 922 3304
Specifically, due to high population density, the city is now fac- Street lighting 1233 1289 1511 93,249
ing congestion. This situation has begun putting pressure on peo- Water and sewage 178 95 134 61
ple to settle on steep slopes that are hazard-prone. For example, Total 182,720 196,033 212,994 588,845
Quirino Hill in the northern part of the city (Fig. 5b and c) is already *
Data for 2010 are projections.
very congested despite its rugged topography. In fact, the city is
prone to earthquakes, causing landslides especially on unstable
slopes. Landslides are common in faulted zones, where unstable
slopes are dominant. The July 16, 1990 earthquake resulted in
widespread landslides that caused numerous deaths and massive
property destruction. Such losses could have been mitigated by
engineering and geologic intervention or by a hazard assessment
and proper zoning of the city. Furthermore, Baguio city is situated
along the path of typhoons that pass the Philippine Area of Respon-
sibility (PAR). For the past 51 years, about 19 tropical cyclones af-
fected the city each year (OCPDC, 2002), of which an average of 4
were tropical depressions, five tropical storms and 10 typhoons.
According to records, the highest number of tropical cyclones
was 32 in 1993 (linked to la niña), while the lowest number was
11 in 1998 (linked to el niño).
Furthermore, the voluminous wastes generated have caused
serious problems in waste disposal. The latest statistics show that
residential areas generate 84.28% of the city’s wastes, 12.33% by
the city market, 2.8% by commercial and 0.58% from other sources
(OCPDC, 2002). While there are efforts to minimize the city’s
wastes at the source through various programs such as waste seg-
regation and/or material waste recovery and disposal, these have
not taken off the ground due mainly to the attitude of the residents
and limited space for storage of recyclable waste. Presently, as re-
ported by the municipal office, the dumpsite receives a daily aver-
age of 180.08 metric tons of garbage. Without meaningful
intervention, the lifespan of the city’s dumpsite will only be good
for the next couple of years.
Shortage of water has also been a growing concern due to the
increasing demand. Water supply in the city comes from four Fig. 8. Traffic condition in Baguio city. Photo (a) shows some parked vehicles on the
left side and people cueing for ‘‘Jeepney’’ transport on the right side (2010). Photo
sources, namely wells, springs, surface diversions, and rain basin. (b) shows a heavy traffic at the CBD with street vendors along the street (Gregerson,
Water consumption in the city is increasing at an annual rate of 2005).
2.9% (OCPDC, 2002). Residential units are the biggest water con-
sumer, followed by commercial establishments. The fast pace of Deforestation (including forest conversion) arising from urbaniza-
urbanization of the city has pushed settlements into protected tion (Alangui & Rovillos, 2009; Nomadicasian, 2010; See, 2007) has
areas. The rampant squatting in these areas affects water quality. been contributing to the deterioration of air quality in the city (See,
Watershed areas, like the Buyog Watershed (Fig. 5c), and other 2007). Table 5 shows the sources of carbon dioxide emissions in
sources of water must be protected, for example, by establishing the city.
buffer zones and constant monitoring. With the increasing demand Furthermore, while the presence of the major arteries and high-
for water, additional sources must also be explored and developed ways (Fig. 6) enhances the city’s accessibility, their convergence in
to cope with the requirements of the growing populace. the central business district (CBD) renders the traffic circulation
The deterioration of the city’s air quality, which is caused by system very inefficient. The concentration of urban services at
green house gases (GHG) emissions and dust particles, has also the CBD is another major cause of traffic congestion (Fig. 8), with
been a growing concern despite the ratification of the Republic uncontrolled parking within the CBD and the lack of parking areas
Act No. 8749, otherwise known as Philippine Clean Air Act of aggravating this problem. Also, although the presence of an airport
1999. GHG is derived mainly from combustion by vehicles, emis- in the city enhances its accessibility, residents in the vicinity are
sions from lights and methane from solid waste. Dust particles, also utilizing the runway as an access road, hampering airport
on the other hand, are very small particles generally below one mi- operations.
cron in diameter. They may remain suspended in the atmosphere
for weeks (OCPDC, 2002). Furthermore, the deforestation in the
city area during the last two decades has not been fully stopped. Plans for future development
This is despite the implementation of the Republic Act 705, 1975
or the Revised Forestry Code of the Philippines, aimed at ensuring After a strong earthquake hit the Philippines, and especially
full protection and management of the country’s forest resources. Baguio city, on July 16, 1990, concerned government officials
R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251 249

reviewed the issues of uncontrolled urban expansion and environ- integrated plan covering the economic, social, environment, infra-
mental degradation. It was noted that congestion, resulting from structure, development administration and financing, and land use
rapid population growth in Baguio city, was fast spreading towards aspects for the development of the city. The ultimate goal for the
the adjoining municipalities of La Trinidad, Itogon, Sablan, and plan period was to enhance the quality of life of the populace
Tuba. It was thought such expansion could adversely affect the nat- through realizing its resource potential. It was an attempt to satisfy
ural resources of not only the city but also those in the adjoining the ever-increasing needs of the people through rational allocation,
areas. Thus, in 1994, a European Community-assisted BLIST (Ba- judicious utilization, optimum generation, timely conservation and
guio, La Trinidad, Itogon, Sablan and Tuba) (Fig. 1) urban master protection of the city’s limited resources. Specifically, the plan was
plan was formally launched. The plan was aimed at directing prepared to (a) guide the orderly development of the city to pro-
development of the BLIST area, of which Baguio city was one of mote health, safety, welfare and convenience of the population,
the municipalities. Several issues that needed the cooperation of (b) provide/delineate guidelines for the use of natural resources,
these municipalities were identified, such as those concerned with (c) translate socio-economic policies into a physical plan, (d) pre-
water supply and distribution, solid waste management, transpor- serve special natural features and environmentally critical areas,
tation management, tourism management, and housing develop- (e) serve as basis for reclassifying land; promote an efficient circu-
ment (BDUPP, 1994). lation system and, (f) allocate and delineate land use to promote
Basically, the plan incorporated two alternative structures that sustainable development (OCPDC, 2002).
could implement the BLIST projects. These were the consultative In the implementation of this plan, the city was also guided by
forum and the metro authority. In the case of BLIST, a consultative six development thrusts and four development goals. The develop-
forum consists of the representatives from the member-municipal- ment thrusts were as follows: (a) stir economic growth, (b) en-
ities, national, regional and provincial government agencies like hance and sustain tourism, (c) step up infrastructure and utilities
the National Economic Development Authority (NEDA), non- development, (d) pursue human development to improve the qual-
government organizations, and private sectors. The idea is that ity of life, (e) protect and conserve the environment, and (f) en-
the forum can provide the general policy direction on BLIST-wide hance participatory local governance. The development goals
issues and those that would have an impact on more than one local were (a) maintenance and preservation of the city’s cultural and
entity. At the same time, local entities can directly control projects, natural environment, which formed the foundation of the city’s
service functions, and planning activities that can be managed total progress, (b) promotion of socio-economic equity, (c)
locally. On the other hand, as explained in the BLIST master plan, enhancement of economic growth in the city, and (d) improvement
a metro authority is a body, which subsumes most or all major of access to urban facilities and services.
political and administrative powers and responsibilities currently Despite the plan being comprehensive, it was not able to ad-
undertaken by individual BLIST authorities. Unfortunately, LIST dress fully the two potential threats of urban decay, namely uncon-
held the opinion that this endeavor was just for Baguio city and trolled population growth and urban expansion. The increase of
the other municipalities would only serve as a catchment area population for the census years 2000 and 2007 (Table 4), and the
and an extension of the city. Thus, the LIST authorities did not favor urban expansion from 1998 to 2009 (Fig. 7), which are practically
the latter during the public consultations because of these two within the plan period, indicated that much more needed to be
fundamental reasons: first, the urban population was currently done to arrest the root causes of the problem. The lack of a clear
concentrated in Baguio city only. Hence, the creation of ‘‘Metro’’ stand on the issue of population control and housing policy, and
BLIST would only be appropriate once BLIST population has spread with an indecisive urban development framework would only
into or increased in the other municipalities. Second, the necessity aggravate the city’s current problems of congestion and environ-
of establishing a metro authority would only be urgent if inter- mental deterioration.
local issues were not resolved within political boundaries. Aside Just before Baguio’s centennial anniversary celebration in 2009,
from these reasons, however, there was one more unpopular city officials and urban planners revisited Burnham’s plan. The first
explanation why LIST authorities could not agree to the Metro con- plan for Baguio prepared in 1905 by architect Daniel H. Burnham
cept. It was feared that the concept would cause a quarrel over was inspired by the design of Washington DC, which emphasized
political jurisdiction between Baguio and other Benguet town gov- the role of government through the strategic positioning of admin-
ernments, especially the LIST municipalities. istrative buildings (Fig. 2). Crossette (1999) mentioned that after
Such disagreements led to the adoption of the consultative for- he was tasked to plan for Baguio, Burnham had predicted multiple
um as the more workable and acceptable structure, comprising functions that Baguio could potentially have, such as being a resort
equal representation from all BLIST members. Thus, on February for health and recreation, marketing center for the region, an
19, 1994, the BLIST authorities signed a Memorandum of Agree- administrative capital, and a city where people of all income
ment to bind these town governments in the implementation of groups would live and work. Some distinctive features of the Burn-
the BLIST master plan under the consultative forum structure. As ham plan included the Burnham Park with its lake and playing
it turned out, the forum did not fare well since its structure was fields, the municipal center (now the City Hall), the commercial
weak, and it lacked a legal basis to channel financial support from district, and the mansion for the governor-general. As years went
the national government to BLIST. Furthermore, the lack of support by, other features like the teachers’ camp for training and relaxa-
from the LIST municipalities also aggravated the problem. Whereas tion, schools, hospitals, government offices, hotels and more parks
the plan was comprehensive, it failed to outline clearly the benefits were added.
that LIST municipalities could receive (Ngalob, 2009). One can only In fact, many ambitious predictions in the plan have been real-
ponder: had various misconceptions on metro authority by the LIST ized. The other components of his plan that have not materialized
administrators been corrected from the inception of the project, include the proposed ceiling population of 25,000 and environ-
might the outcome have been different? mental protection. In the earlier years of the city, Burnham had
With the unfavorable outcome of the BLIST project and an been an advocate of ‘‘green zones’’ like those that he was able to
uncontrolled population growing amidst urban expansion, alarmed introduce in the United States (Cabreza, 2008). In his plan for Ba-
Baguio city government officials scrambled to draw up plans to guio, he emphasized that the ridges and hilltops should remain
avert the threat of urban decay. One of the most significant devel- natural (Crossette, 1999). He also campaigned for the protection
opment plans implemented at the start of the 21st century was the and conservation of the forest resources to protect the indigenous
Comprehensive Land Use Plan for 2002–2008. This was an species in the area. However, development pressures and later plan
250 R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251

revisions clouded this vision and the concept of a cool summer re- and efforts of the city government and the city constituents to-
treat for 25,000 people gave way to a rapidly growing multi-func- gether. Responsive development plans must be drawn up and
tional city. Remaining forest covers are continuously deforested, implemented effectively and efficiently.
and ridges and hilltops have already been conquered (Fig. 5b and The integration of adjacent municipalities in the newly recon-
c) as a consequence of the growing demand for various land uses. stituted BLISTT development framework may help address conges-
After revisiting Burnham’s plan in 2009, government officials tion and environment-related issues while giving the other
thought that the principles behind Burnham’s plan could still be municipalities much better opportunities to improve in the future.
adopted so that the previous bad practices would not recur in Good governance must be put in place and policies that stress pro-
the adjacent municipalities. After gaining insights from their previ- tection of environment and conservation of its natural resources
ous attempt to unite BLIST municipalities to work towards a com- should be implemented without any further delay. Lastly, what-
mon goal, local government officials formally began reconstituting ever governing structure BLISTT may finally adopt in the future,
the BLIST concept, adding one more municipality (Tublay). This as long as selfish political interests are set aside and as long as
newly reconstituted BLISTT aims to strengthen what was started there is cooperation in the name of sustainable development and
to ensure sustainable development of Baguio city and the adjoining common good, there is every reason for optimism.
municipalities (BLISTT, 2009). At present, the BLISTT Strategic
Development Framework is still being re-formulated. Prior to this, Acknowledgments
the following were already set up: (a) the BLISTT Mayor’s Forum
membership (Mayors of BLISTT municipalities, Director of NEDA- The authors wish to thank the City Profiles editor and three
CAR, Governor of Benguet province, Congressman of Baguio city, anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments and sugges-
and Commissioner of the Baguio Centennial Commission), (b) the tions on the earlier version of the paper. The financial support from
BLISTT technical working group, and (c) the agreement on partici- the MEXT scholarship program of Japan for post-graduate studies;
patory cost-sharing to defray funding requirements for the formu- the assistance of Ms. Ria S. Estoque, and the Baguio city officials
lation and implementation of a new BLISTT master plan (BLISTT, and staff during the field visits and data gathering; and those
2009). Currently, BLISTT has also been one of the urban growth who, in one way or the other, have contributed to the completion
nodes in northwestern Luzon identified by the Northwestern of this manuscript, are gratefully acknowledged.
Growth Quadrangle Commission of the Philippines.

References
Summary and concluding remarks
Acupanda, K. (2007). Baguio’s many people. Baguio Midland Courier. Baguio city,
Philippines.
Baguio’s status as the summer capital of the country, its grow- Agoot, L. (2010). Baguio’s 95% rate higher than national rate. Baguio Midland Courier,
ing socio-economic activities and employment opportunities, and Baguio city, Philippines.
Alabanza, J. (2007). Looking back: Planning Baguio City in the 1900s, 1970s, and 1990s.
the development and availability of basic and essential urban ser- Baguio Midland Courier. Baguio city, Philippines.
vices and facilities are the major factors that inspired and encour- Alangui, W., & Rovillos, R. (2009). UP Baguio bares climate change program. Ti Similla,
aged people to flock to this city. Its continuous growth and Baguio city, Philippines.
Basilan, J., & Vicente, K. L. (2008). Baguio wakes up to coldest morn in 2008: Mercury
development has helped in its evolution as a hill station to a highly drops to 10.8 degrees Celsius. Philippine Daily Inquirer, Manila, Philippines.
urbanized regional center. Over the years, however, population Baguio and Dagupan Urban Planning Project (BDUPP) (1994). Baguio (Urban BLIST)
growth has been rapid and urban sprawl has been widespread main volume, final report. Baguio city, Philippines.
Baguio, La Trinidad, Itogon, Sablan, Tuba, Tublay (BLISTT) (2009). Memorandum of
without regard for seismic and geologic hazards and the city’s understanding. Baguio city, Philippines.
capability to provide the necessary services. The population of BPS – Statistics Bureau (2010). Population (2010 census final). Badan Pusat Statistik –
Baguio has greatly surpassed the maximum number of people that Statistics Indonesia.
Cabreza, V. (2008). Baguio takes second look at Burnham Plan. Philippine Daily
the city was envisioned to accommodate. From the 2007 census, Inquirer, Manila, Philippines.
this relatively small city, of just 57.49 km2, now supports about Cabreza, V., Caluza, D., & Dauigoy, E. K. (2009). Education: The way of the future for
12 times more than its carrying capacity. Due to the ever-increas- Baguio. Philippine Daily Inquirer, Manila, Philippines.
Cariño, B., & Corpuz, A. (2008). Towards a strategic urban development and housing
ing demand for better living conditions, Baguio city’s carrying
policy for the Philippines. Philippine Institute for Development Studies,
capacity, in terms of natural, physical and socio-economic re- Philippines.
sources, has reached critical status. All these continue to adversely Chaudhry, M. (2003). Guide to trekking in Himachal: Over 65 treks and 100
affect the city’s quality of life in particular while placing the city at destinations. Indus Publishing Company, New Delhi.
Clemente, L. O. (2006). Integrating climate change in local governance: The case of
risk in general. Baguio city, Philippines. Paper presented during the Sixteenth Asia-Pacific
Against the backdrop of a looming crisis caused by over-popu- Seminar on Climate Change: Asia-Pacific Regional Approach to Climate
lation, rapid urbanization, and socio-economic problems, ecologi- Friendly and Climate Change-resilient Society, Jakarta, Indonesia, 5–8
September 2006.
cal concern is now moving to the center stage. Greater emphasis Crossette, B. (1999). The great hill stations of Asia. USA: Basic Books.
is being placed on the conservation of the natural environment Doronila, A. (2009). Analysis: Baguio city’s renewal rests on its uniqueness. Philippine
in tandem with economic development. Thus, there is an urgent Daily Inquirer, Manila, Philippines.
Department of Statistics of Malaysia (DOSM) (2010). Population and housing census
need to take steps to arrest environmental deterioration to ensure of Malaysia 2010. DOSM, Malaysia.
a better and cleaner environment as well as conservation of re- Estoque, R. C., & Murayama, Y. (2010). Detecting and analyzing land use/cover changes
sources for future generations. Amidst this current situation, the in a hill station: A case study in Baguio City, Philippines. Paper presented during
the Center for Spatial Information Science (CSIS) Days 2010, Kashiwa Campus,
city’s potential for further development being one of the great hill Chiba – University of Tokyo, Japan, November 11–12, 2010.
stations in Asia should remain a source of strong motivations and Gregerson, C. (2005). The traffic along Kayang Street in Baguio City. Philippines
inspirations to keep moving forward. However, at this point of (#5750). <http://www.phototour.minneapolis.mn.us/5750> Accessed 28.01.11.
Guerra, G. (2006). Supreme Court Baguio summer session: A retrospect. Supreme Court
the developmental process, every move is critical. The future of
Public Information Office, Philippines.
the city depends on what will be done now and in the next few Gutierrez, C. B., & Cariño, J. K. (2009). The Baguio centennial yearbook. Heritage
years. The city must rise to the challenge to address the problems Promotions, Baguio city, Philippines.
of urban expansion in the name of modernization and sustainabil- Jennings, A. H. (1950). World’s greatest observed point rainfalls. Monthly Weather
Review, 78, 4–5.
ity, taking into consideration the significant roles that Baguio city Jreat, M. (2004). Tourism in Himachal Pradesh. New Delhi: Indus Publishing
plays, and its potential. There is a need to put all the initiatives Company.
R.C. Estoque, Y. Murayama / Cities 30 (2013) 240–251 251

Lopez, E. H. (2010). Employment rate in January 2010 reaches 92.7%, jobless rate at Office of the City Planning and Development Coordinator (OCPDC) (2002).
7.3%. Manila Bulletin, Manila, Philippines. Comprehensive land use plan: Baguio city, 2002–2008. OCPDC, Baguio city,
Mercado, R. G., & Manasan, R. G. (1998). Metropolitan arrangements in the Philippines.
Philippines: Passing fancy or the future megatrend? Philippine Institute for Office of the City Treasurer (OCT) (2010). City revenue report. Baguio city,
Development Studies, Philippines. Philippines.
Misra, H. N. (2008). Eco-planning for Hill cities: The case of Shimla. In A. K. Dutt, H. Papa, A. (2009). Rainfall in Baguio is 4 times its monthly average. Philippine Daily
N. Misra, & M. Chatterjee (Eds.), Explorations in applied geography. New Inquirer, Manila, Philippines.
Delhi:Prentice-Hall of India Private Limited. Reed, R. R. (1999). City of Pines: The origins of Baguio as a colonial hill station and
National Mapping and Resources Information Authority (NAMRIA) (1995). regional capital. Baguio city, Philippines:A-Seven Publishing.
Topographic map of Baguio city. NAMRIA, Manila, Philippines. Republic Act (RA) 7160 (1991). Local government code of 1991. Congress of the
National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) (1996). National urban Philippines, Manila, Philippines.
policy agenda. NEDA, Philippines. Saldivar-Sali, A., & Einstein, H. H. (2007). A landslide risk rating system for Baguio,
Ngalob, J. B. (2009). The 1992 BLIST urban planning project and organizational Philippines. Engineering Ecology, 91, 85–99.
milestones of the newly reconstituted BLISTT. NEDA, Baguio city, Philippines. See, D. A. (2007). Baguio air pollution worsening: Almost twice over normal level.
Nomadicasian (2010). Baguio city’s Pine forest undergoes massive land conversion. Northern Philippine Times, Baguio city, Philippines.
Hubpages Inc., <http://hubpages.com/hub/Pine-Forest-Destruction> Accessed See, D. A. (2010). Urbanization affects Baguio, experts say. Manila Bulletin, Manila,
28.01.11. Philippines.
National Statistical Coordination Board (NSCB) (2006). Did you know that the The Nation – Pakistan (2009). Punjab government sets aside New Murree Project.
Cordilleras posted a 2.5% increase in tourist arrivals in 2005? Fact Sheet, NSCB – <www.nation.com.pk> Accessed 28.01.11.
Cordillera Administrative Region, Philippines. Vietnam News (2010). Urbanization threatens Da Lat. <http://
National Statistical Coordination Board (NSCB) (2010). Nearly 700 thousand foreign vietnamnews.vnagency.com.vn> Accessed 28.01.11.
tourists visited the Cordilleras in the past 10 years. Fact Sheet, NSCB – Cordillera Wilson, L. L. (1955). Skyland of the Philippines. Baguio city, Philippines: Baguio
Administrative Region, Philippines. Printing and Publishing Co.
National Statistics Office (NSO) (2000). Census of population and housing. NSO, www.baguio.gov.ph (2009). The official website of Baguio city, Philippines.
Philippines. www.census.gov.ph (2010). The official website of the National Statistics Office of
National Statistics Office (NSO) (2007). Census of population and housing. NSO, the Philippines.
Philippines.

View publication stats

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen