Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
org
Original Research
Introduction: This study examined whether prenatal perceived stress levels during pregnancy were associated with preterm labor or preterm birth.
Methods: Perceived stress levels were measured at 16 weeks’ gestation or less and between 20 and 24 weeks’ gestation in a sample of 1069 low-
income pregnant women attending Temple University prenatal care clinics. Scores were averaged to create a single measure of prenatal stress.
Preterm birth was defined as the occurrence of a spontaneous birth prior to 37 weeks’ gestation. Preterm labor was defined as the occurrence of
regular contractions between 20 and 37 weeks’ gestation that were associated with changes in the cervix.
Results: Independent of potential confounding factors, prenatal perceived stress was not associated with preterm labor (odds ratio [OR], 1.10;
95% confidence interval [CI], 0.69-1.78; P = .66); however, prenatal stress trended toward an association with preterm birth (OR, 1.49; 95% CI,
1.00-2.23; P = .05). The strongest predictor of preterm labor was a history of preterm labor in a prior pregnancy. Women with a history of preterm
labor were 2 times more likely to experience preterm labor in the current pregnancy than women who did not have a preterm labor history (OR,
2.16; 95% CI, 1.05-4.41; P = .04). Historical risk factors for preterm birth, such as African American race, a history of abortion, or a history
of preterm birth, were not related to preterm labor. The strongest predictor of preterm birth was having a history of preterm birth in a prior
pregnancy (OR, 2.55; 95% CI, 1.54-4.24; P ⬍ .001).
Discussion: Prenatal perceived stress levels may be a risk factor for preterm birth independent of preterm labor; however, prenatal stress was not
associated with preterm labor. Risk factors for preterm labor may be different from those of preterm birth.
J Midwifery Womens Health 2014;59:374–379 c 2014 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives.
Keywords: vulnerable populations, labor support, preventive health care, preterm labor, preterm birth
3 Temple University obstetric clinics. Women who attended Risk Factor of Interest
their first prenatal care appointments prior to 16 weeks’ ges- Perceived Stress
tation were approached by a trained research assistant and in- During both baseline and follow-up interviews, maternal per-
vited to participate in the study. Eligible, consenting women ceived stress during the pregnancy was measured using the 4-
completed a baseline questionnaire prior to 16 weeks’ gesta- item Cohen’s Perceived Stress Scale (PSS).20 Each item in the
tion and a follow-up questionnaire between 20 and 24 weeks’ scale was rated using a 5-point scale ranging from 0 (never) to
gestation. Information about preterm labor and preterm birth 4 (very often). To obtain a prenatal PSS score, scores across the
outcomes was collected via medical chart review. An ancil- 2 collection points were averaged, as has been done by previ-
lary validity study was conducted and found excellent med- ous investigators.12 A median split of the sample was used to
ical record reproducibility for pregnancy outcome informa- generate a dichotomous prenatal stress score: participants ei-
tion comparing 2 medical record abstractors. Only partici- ther had a prenatal stress level during the pregnancy below or
pants who gave birth at Temple University Hospital (n = 1069 equal to the median average stress score or above the median
of 1560) were included in this assessment of stress and preg- average stress score.
nancy outcomes. All study procedures received institutional
review board approval.
Outcomes
Preterm Labor
Study Participants
Preterm labor was defined as the occurrence of regular con-
Eligible women lived in Philadelphia and reported a single- tractions between 20 and 37 weeks’ gestation that were asso-
ton pregnancy less than 16 weeks’ gestation at baseline, as de- ciated with changes in the cervix.6 The outcome of preterm
termined by last menstrual period and confirmed by ultra- labor was assessed via medical chart review using hospital la-
sound. Women who lived outside Philadelphia or experienced bor and delivery medical records.
an induced abortion, ectopic pregnancy, multiple gestations,
or a molar pregnancy were excluded. Women diagnosed with Preterm Birth
a bicornuate uterus or fibroids and women who were non– Consistent with the standard definition for preterm birth
English or non–Spanish speaking were also excluded. set by the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology,
preterm birth was defined as a birth prior to 37 completed
weeks’ gestation.21 The outcome of preterm birth was assessed
Study Measures
via chart review of the hospital labor and delivery medical
Background/Covariates records. Last menstrual period per the first ultrasound was
used as the gold standard to assess gestational age at both en-
Demographics
rollment and birth.
Participant age, race, marital status, and educational attain-
ment, which served as a proxy for socioeconomic status, were
evaluated at baseline.16 Statistical Analysis
All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS version 20
Potential Confounders (SPSS for Windows, Chicago, IL). Frequency distributions
Information on a history of previous preterm birth, preterm were constructed for prenatal perceived maternal stress dur-
labor, or induced abortions; prepregnancy body mass index ing the pregnancy, the occurrence of preterm birth, history of
(BMI); current smoking status; current use of marijuana; and preterm labor, potential covariates, and potential confounding
history of hypertension or preeclampsia during a previous factors. Bivariate associations between the main independent
pregnancy were assessed at baseline. In addition, detection variable (prenatal stress during the pregnancy) and the
of vaginal infections such as BV, trichomoniasis, candida, or occurrence of preterm labor or preterm birth were assessed
Chlamydia trachomatis during the current pregnancy, cer- using binary logistic regression analyses. The comparison
vical length as measured at the first recorded ultrasound, and group included women who did not experience preterm
treatment with drugs for preterm labor were evaluated dur- labor, premature rupture of membranes, or preterm birth;
ing the medical chart review. All variables were included in thus, women without pregnancy complications were com-
the analysis to assess for confounding because prior studies pared with women experiencing preterm labor or preterm
have indicated that these factors have been related to the oc- birth. In addition, comparisons of median PSS scores by
currence of preterm birth.16-19 the 2 separate outcome categories were performed using the
Abbreviations: PTB, preterm birth; PTL, preterm labor; PROM, premature rupture To identify the risk factors for preterm labor, women who ex-
of membranes. perienced preterm labor were compared with women who did
a
Perceived stress measured by the Cohen Perceived Stress Scale at 2 times. Scores
across the 2 collection points were averaged to create the score. not experience pregnancy complications (ie, no preterm la-
bor, no preterm birth, and no premature rupture of mem-
branes). Median prenatal perceived stress during the preg-
Mann-Whitney test, as the distribution of prenatal perceived nancy did not differ significantly between women who expe-
stress was found to be nonnormally distributed. Variables rienced preterm labor and the comparison group of women
identified as related to preterm labor or preterm birth in the without major pregnancy complications (4.75 vs 4.5, respec-
univariate analyses (P ⬍ .10) were entered into a separate tively; U = 0.62, P = .54). A history of preterm birth showed
multivariate regression analysis for the particular outcome. a nonsignificant trend toward association with preterm labor
For the multivariate regression analysis, odds ratios and 95% (odds ratio [OR], 1.90; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.01-
confidence intervals were computed. A list-wise deletion 3.60; P = .05). Having a history of preterm labor was signifi-
method was used to handle missing data (ie, only participants cantly associated with preterm labor (OR, 2.47; 95% CI, 1.34-
with follow-up and outcome data were used for the respective 4.55; P ⬍ .001).
analysis).
Preterm Birth
RESULTS
Median prenatal perceived stress levels during pregnancy
Sample Characteristics were significantly related to the occurrence of preterm birth.
There were 1069 eligible women included in this analysis. Specifically, median (SE) perceived stress level among women
Sixty-four percent of the sample was African American, and who gave birth at term was 4.5 (2.5) compared with 5.0 (2.6)
the majority were young and single (Table 1). Forty-one per- among women who experienced preterm birth (U = 2.81,
cent of participants had less than a high school education, and P = .01). Other variables that were associated with preterm
based on prepregnancy BMI, 25% of participants were over- birth included single marital status (OR, 0.62; 95% CI, 0.41-
weight, and 30% were obese. About one-quarter of the sample 0.94; P = .02), history of preterm birth (OR, 2.60; 95% CI,
reported having an induced abortion (24%), 11% previously 1.70-3.99; P ⬍ .001), chlamydia during pregnancy (OR, 0.45;
had at least one preterm birth, and 9% had a history of be- 95% CI, 0.22-0.91; P = .03), and treatment for preterm la-
ing treated for preterm labor. As shown in Table 1, the median bor during the pregnancy (OR, 9.72; 95% CI, 5.26-17.96;
(SE) level of prenatal perceived stress during the pregnancy, as P ⬍ .001). The average prenatal PSS score (OR, 1.43; 95% CI,
averaged across the 2 collection periods, was 4.5 (2.5), which 1.04-1.98; P = .03), African American race (OR, 1.43; 95% CI,
was consistent with the mean PSS levels seen in similar preg- 1.00-2.01; P = .05), and history of induced abortion (OR, 1.71;
nancy populations.22 95% CI, 1.07-2.73; P = .02) were related to preterm birth.
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; LMP, last menstrual period date; OR, odds
Vaginal candidiasis in 0.52 0.18-1.50 .23
ratio. current pregnancy
a
Adjusted for marital status, smoked marijuana since LMP, candidiasis, chlamydia,
history of preterm birth, history of preterm labor, shortened cervical length, and Chlamydia trachomatis 0.55 0.23-1.29 .17
Prenatal Stress Scale score.
b
Perceived stress measured by the Cohen Perceived Stress Scale at 2 times. Scores in current pregnancy
across the 2 collection points were averaged to create the score.
Preterm labor in current 10.7 5.45-21.05 ⬍ .001
pregnancy
Multivariate Models for Perceived Stress during Prenatal stressb 1.49 1.00-2.23 .05
Pregnancy and Occurrence of Preterm Labor or Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; CI, confidence interval; OR, odds ratio.
Preterm Birth a
Adjusted for race, marital status, education level, current smoker, history of
preeclampsia, history of preterm birth, history of abortion, prepregnancy BMI,
bacterial vaginosis, candidiasis, chlamydia, treated for preterm labor, and Prenatal
Preterm Labor Stress Scale score.
b
Perceived stress measured by the Cohen Perceived Stress Scale at 2 times. Scores
In the final regression model predicting preterm labor, a his- across the 2 collection points were averaged to create the score.
tory of preterm labor was the strongest predictor of experienc-
ing preterm labor in the current pregnancy (OR, 2.16; 95% CI,
preterm birth but not preterm labor has not been previously
1.05-4.41; P = .04; Table 2). Contrary to our hypothesis, pre-
reported.
natal perceived stress was not significantly related to the risk
To date, the relationship between perceived prenatal stress
of preterm labor.
and preterm labor and preterm birth has been somewhat un-
clear, with some studies reporting a positive relationship,16
Preterm Birth whereas a small number of other studies have shown no
relationship.24, 25 These mixed findings have been partially at-
In the final regression model predicting preterm birth, per-
tributed to challenges surrounding the measurement of stress,
ceived stress retained a modest but nonsignificant associa-
the variation in assessment tools used, and the timing of stress
tion with the risk of preterm birth, independent of other de-
assessment in the prenatal and postpartum periods.26 The
mographic and behavioral risk factors such as race and his-
current study adds some clarity to this literature by demon-
tory of preterm birth (OR, 1.49; 95% CI, 1.00-2.23; P = .05;
strating that prenatal perceived stress was associated with
Table 3). As expected, another factor predictive of preterm
the incidence of preterm birth independent of other estab-
birth in this sample was having a history of preterm birth (OR,
lished correlates of preterm birth such as history of preterm
2.55; 95% CI, 1.54-4.28; P ⬍ .001), which is consistent with the
birth, history of preterm labor, history of abortion, and race.
literature.23
These data also suggest that perceived prenatal stress affects
preterm labor differently than preterm birth and that re-
DISCUSSION
searchers should separately examine factors linked to preterm
This study examined the relationship between prenatal per- birth not due to preterm labor. Furthermore, that more than
ceived stress and the occurrence of preterm labor and preterm half of the preterm births experienced in this cohort were not
birth in a sample of low-income minority women. These re- precipitated by preterm labor or premature rupture of mem-
sults suggested a role for perceived prenatal stress in increased branes provides further support for the notion that other un-
risk of preterm birth even after adjusting for the treatment of derlying causes for early birth must be addressed, in particu-
preterm labor in the pregnancy (as indicated by a trend toward lar, fetal distress and maternal comorbidities.
increased risk), but the study found no relationship between Results from this study have some potential clinical impli-
prenatal perceived stress and preterm labor. The finding that cations. Not surprisingly, medical history characteristics such
prenatal perceived stress in the prenatal period was related to as history of preterm birth and preterm labor were significant