Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Schaeffler 12
active eDifferential
The active differential
for future drive trains
Dr. Tomas Smetana
Thorsten Biermann
Prof. Dr. Bernd-Robert Höhn, FZG Munich
Franz Kurth, FZG Munich
Dr. Christian Wirth, ZG GmbH Garching
final drive speed due to the specified kinematic vantages, a significantly modified differential Le wheel Right wheel
conditions. When the vehicle travels round a design was selected and is described below.
bend, the differential speed on the wheels is
Drive torque
Drive torque
compensated by a rotary motion of the differen- The principle of lateral
tial pinion in the differential. The torque (disre-
garding the locking rate) is also evenly distribut-
torque distribution a) c)
ed to both wheels by this differential pinion. The Transmissions, as shown in Figure 1, enable the
split can be symbolized by a scale beam which is torque to be individually distributed to the
Slip Slip
represented by the pinion and ensures that the wheels of a drive axle. Due to different circum-
same circumferential forces and, therefore, the ferential forces on the wheels, a yawing mo- -10 % 10 % -10 % 10 %
same torque is applied to both axle drive bevel ment can be generated about the vertical axis
gears of the differential. of the vehicle with which the driving dynamics
and driving stability can be influenced directly. b)
If the rotary motion of the differential pinion,
In contrast to ESP, the vehicle is not braked by
as shown in Figure 2, was coupled directly with
intervention of the control system. These so-
an actuator, the actuator would be driven by
called torque-vectoring transmissions, which
this differential motion. Conversely, a differen-
are used on the rear axle, can in contrast to cur-
tial motion could be induced on the differential
rent ESP systems effectively prevent driving
pinion and a differential speed generated be-
situations, in which the vehicle tends to drift
tween the wheels by specifying an actuator
over its front wheels (understeer), and, there-
speed. Because the scale beam is unbalanced
externally by the drive torque of the actuator,
fore, increase vehicle safety and vehicle dy-
Figure 3 Relationship between wheel slip and drive torque
12
the torque split in the differential also changes.
This means the desired effect of being able to
namics.
The control of wheel torques is always carried
The design of the each axle is driven by one main electric motor
and one electric control motor, which gener-
specify any theoretical torques and speeds on
the wheels would be achieved.
out using speed control of the wheels. The pre-
vailing slip conditions generate the differential
active differential ates the differential torques between the
wheels of the relevant axle. The active eDiffer-
ential can be basically subdivided into the
torque between the wheels. Figure 3 shows the
Actuator relationship between wheel speed and drive Overview assemblies “planet stage with the final drive
ratio”, “differential” and “superimposing trans-
torque. It is initially assumed in State A that the
The electric, active dif-
Pinions vehicle is travelling straight ahead, and both rear
ferential differs funda-
wheels are rotating at the same speed and are
mentally from current
driving with the same torque.
axle differentials. A fi-
There is equal drive slip on both wheels. The left nal drive unit as in the
wheel is now braked and the right wheel is si- design described be-
multaneously driven so hard that the total drive low is not previously
torque on the vehicle remains constant. State B known. The selected
Figure 2 The principle of the active differential shows the relationship between the braking combination of plane-
torque of the left wheel and the required brake tary gear sets in the as-
slip. The drive torque on the right wheel must be sociated transmission
A fundamental advantage of the active differen- increased to State C in order to keep the drive is also new. There are
tial design is that no additional assemblies are force as constant as possible despite the braking many transmission de-
required because the torque distribution is influ- torque on the left rear wheel. Figure 3 shows the signs, which could be
enced directly in the differential. The actuator operating point required on the slip curve of the used to implement the
remains stationary when the wheels are rotating right wheel. design of the active dif-
at the same speed, and only supports torque if ferential, each offering
It can be deduced from the operating points of
there is active redistribution. specific advantages de-
both slip curves that the distribution of drive
pending on the applica-
A disadvantage of the design shown in Figure 2 torques on the driving axle requires a change of
tion.
is the low ratio between the actuator torque wheel speeds and vice versa. Therefore, it is
and the differential torque, as well as the co- necessary for one wheel to accelerate in rela- The final drive unit Electric Planet Differenal Superimposing stage Control motor
rotation of the actuator around the wheel ax- tion to the other in order to generate the dif- shown in Figure 4 was tracon stage with
les. In order to benefit from the advantages ferential torque for the torque-vectoring func- designed for a mid- motor final drive rao
without suffering the above mentioned disad- tion. size vehicle in which Figure 4 The design of the active differential
mission”. The assemblies are arranged together tribution, to lower torques for the control motor. Efficiency and range
with the traction and control motors coaxially If the sun is rotated relatively to the internal-
in relation to the output shafts of the differen- geared wheel, the planets of the spur gear dif- The amount of braking torque that can be regenerated on the drive axle is increased by selectively
tial. ferential are forced to rotate at a relative speed, allocating torque to the wheels. If the braking torque of a wheel is limited, for example, due to
whereby a speed difference occurs between the insufficient vertical tire forces (wheel on the inside of the curve), an increase of the braking torque
The differential wheels. The speed of the radial, inner planet of on the other wheel is still possible by distributing the torque within an axle. This means the full
the spur gear differential corresponds to the potential for regeneration is used, which improves the efficiency and the range.
A spur gear differential distributes the wheel
speed of the differential pinion in accordance Driving dynamics
torques evenly [1] when the control is inactive.
with Figure 2.
This can comprise, as shown in Figure 4, a plan- Different drive torques and braking torques on the wheels of an axle result in a yawing moment
etary gear with two suns and three planet pairs Both identical sub-transmissions of the superim- about the vertical axis of the vehicle. This yawing moment is actively used to increase dynamics
which mesh with each other, but other differen- posing transmission share a common center bar. during rotary and steering motions. The more agile drive performance not only results in increased
tial designs are also conceivable. The drive pow- The sun of one planetary gear is fixed to the driving pleasure, it also improves driving safety, for example, in the case of avoidance maneuvers
er of the traction motor is fed to the transmis- housing, the other sun is connected to the con- or when the vehicle breaks away.
sion via the final drive ratio, which can be trol motor. The internal-geared wheel of one
designed as a planetary gear. The center bars of planetary gear is connected with the sun of the Traction
the final drive transmission and the differential coupling gear, the internal-geared wheel of the A normal drive axle controlled by a differential does not achieve maximum traction on road
are connected. The planets of the differential second planetary gear is connected with the in- surfaces that have different non-skid properties (μ-split), because the torques of both wheels
mesh with both suns which are each connected ternal-geared wheel of the coupling gear. must always be equal and the lowest torque is decisive. Selective allocation of torque
to one wheel. It is of elementary importance maximizes the drive torques of both wheels and at the same time prevents individual wheels
If a torque is generated by the control motor,
that spur gear differentials in the form described
here can be combined with additional planetary
the superimposing transmission rotates both
internal-geared wheels of the identical plane-
spinning. 12
gears. The three pairs of differential planets in Assisted steering
tary gears towards each other, i.e. an opposing
the spur gear differential in principle fulfill the Different driving forces on the wheels of a steered axle generate torque about the axle’s steering
torque is applied to the sun of the coupling
function of the axle drive bevel gears in a bevel pivot when the axle kinematics are designed appropriately. This allows steering lock or assisted
gear relative to the internal-geared wheel. If
gear differential. They compensate the speed steering to be realized by targeted lateral distribution of torques. The objective is to replace other
the control motor is stationary, a differential
difference between the wheels and roll against assisted steering systems and to also enable emergency avoidance maneuvers to be carried out
motion of the differential planets is not possi-
each other. automatically.
ble, because in this case the sun and the inter-
Conversely, a differential speed can be generat- nal-geared wheel of the coupling gear rotate at Comfort
ed between the wheels by inducing a relative the same speed. The wheels also have the same
movement of the planet pairs in the spur gear speed as a result. If the superimposing trans- Negative effects such as the influence of side winds and sensitivity to lane grooves can be
differential in accordance with the principle mission is not actuated, no differential torque controlled using dynamic lateral distribution of torque. Furthermore, the generation of corre-
from Figure 2. This task is performed by the su- is applied, the wheel torques are identical (if sponding yawing moments allows the uniform drive performance to be set, for example. With a
perimposing transmission in the presented transmission losses are neglected) and the con- constant curve radius for a specified steering angle irrespective of the load or vehicle speed, as far
transmission concept. When a vehicle is travel- trol motor does not support any torque. The as this is physically possible.
ling straight ahead, there is no relative speed dif- control motor is also passive when the vehicle
ference between the differential planets of the travels round a bend, where the control motor
The transmission concept shown in Figure 4 was drive unit is firmly connected to the vehicle and
spur gear differential. rotates without a load. If the transmission (e.g.
developed to meet the specified requirements. the drive to the wheels is via side shafts. This has
in case of a defect) is deactivated, it operates
The direct wheel drive can perform the desired an advantageous effect on driving pleasure and
The superimposing like a conventional differential with a slightly
function of laterally distributing torque, but in a driving dynamics.
increased lock value.
transmission comparison, the innovative Schaeffler final drive
The control motor and the superimposing trans-
unit can impress with the features described be-
The superimposing transmission comprises Range of functions of the low.
mission are able to generate the required differ-
ential torques of approximately 1000 Nm at any
three planetary gears, two of which are of iden- active eDifferential system The drive power is generated solely by a traction time. The power of the relevant electric motors
tical design. In Figure 4, the left planetary gear in
motor, and only one power electronics system is for the direct wheel drive must be scaled accord-
the superimposing transmission shares the cen- The development goal for the “active eDifferen-
required as a result. Optimization of the electric ingly (e.g. 80 kW per wheel to enable the normal
ter bar and one planet with the differential. This tial” system is to combine the functional advan-
motor with regard to efficiency and/or weight is differential torques to be generated in the normal
design, which allows an additional, planetary tages of direct wheel drive with the benefits of a
benefited by selection of a favorable final drive speed ranges).
gear to be integrated comparatively easily, is final drive via a differential, without incurring
ratio.
usually called a “reduced coupling gear”. The the corresponding disadvantages. The realiza- Significantly less electrical system power is re-
coupling gear is used to reduce the high wheel tion of lateral torque distribution, in particular, In contrast to the wheel hub motor, the unsprung quired to enable the distribution of torque than
torques, which can be generated with lateral dis- leads to a range of decisive advantages. masses are not increased due to the fact that the with drive systems which have one electric motor
not to end up with uneconomically high quality ogy in order to contribute meaningful develop- Finally it should be noted that the active eDiffe-
requirements on the other hand. A doctoral the- ment work for its components and to provide rential does not exist as a real prototype, but
Ø 340
sis is planned about this very subject at the FZG the customer with optimum support. solely as an initial design (Figures 6, 7). Schaef-
Munich. fler is currently at the start of development, for
Further motivations for implementing this trans-
which it is seeking strong development part-
The development of new manufacturing technolo- mission are future business areas which optimal-
560 ners and customers due to the technological
gies is required to enable particularly economical ly combine Schaeffler and Continental technolo-
risks.
production. New and innovative lubrication con- gies. At this point, reference should be made to
cepts must be developed with regard to product control strategies which are being pursued by
functionality, which enable both cooling and lubri-
cation of the components, while keeping losses to
Continental and the TU Darmstadt, for example,
in the “Proreta” project. As part of this project,
Literature
a minimum. automatic braking and avoidance maneuvers
Total weight approx. 143 kg were analyzed and implemented in vehicles driv- [1] Biermann, T.; Smetana, T.: Schaeffler light-
Electrical engineering, Figure 7 Dimensions and weight of the prototype
en by internal combustion engines. Publications weight differentials – A family of differen-
about this topic contributed significantly to the tials reduced in space and weight; 9th
control and software idea of the active eDifferential. Schaeffler Symposium, 2010
conclusions about the differential torque to be
As explained at the beginning of this paper,
provided on the wheels, it is feasible to either
there are different control strategies for the lat-
calculate wheel torques based on wheel speeds
eral and longitudinal distribution of torque, de-
and stored characteristic curves, which appears
pending on the driving condition, which must be
harmonized appropriately:
disadvantageous in view of the uncertainties, or
to carry out direct, torque-sensitive recording of
12
Efficiency and range: Maximization of the the required information, for which, however, a
regeneration phases system must be firstly developed.
Driving dynamics and driving safety: Furthermore, a suitable traction motor with the
Implementation of the “active eDifferential” necessary key data must be developed which inter-
acts ideally with the transmission. The control mo-
Traction
tor must operate dynamically in the low-speed
Assisted steering range. However, it must also be economical and
meet the requirements for the controllability of
Comfort functions
the transmission.
Although there are existing control strategies for
conventional drives with torque vectoring (BMW
X6, Audi S4, Mitsubishi Lancer Evo) which have
clutch actuators, there are no existing, state-of-
Summary
the-art controls for systems with electric motors.
The active eDifferential system is a drive concept
Furthermore, a priority control between the above
which could form the optimum platform for future
mentioned control strategies must be intensively
control strategies. The final drive unit combines
developed.
the spur gear differential with an intelligent lateral
The vehicle reaction must be clear, reproducible distribution of torque. When used on both axles,
and easy to control for the customer. The “braking the active differential also enables the distribution
feeling” for the driver must be reproducible irre- of torque in the longitudinal direction of the vehi-
spective of the level of regeneration. Other vehicle cle.
dynamics control systems such as ABS or ESP must
Schaeffler does not intend to become a trans-
not be impaired. The safety systems must be com-
mission manufacturer with this innovative ap-
bined in an appropriate manner.
proach. Technologies, which Schaeffler can gen-
With regard to electrical engineering, high sen- erally provide, are, for example, planet carriers
sor scan rates are required than with vehicle sta- and the previously described lightweight differ-
bilization to enable the system to operate in a ential, along with the actual transmission bear-
higher cycle range for controlling sensitivity to ing support. The components supplier must also
lane groove and side winds. To enable precise have a core understanding about drive technol-