A project proposal presented to the

faculty of Civil Engineering

Saint Louis University

In partial fulfillment of the course

requirements in Ce 520- Prestressed
Concrete Design

By:
CRISTOBAL, Sharmaine B.
GALINGAN, Maureen Joy D.
CABALTERA, Cy
SABAS, Dom Vincent L.
VALDEZ, Carlo R.
 Handbook of Rubrics
Saint Louis University
School of Engineering and Architecture
Rubric for Design Projects

Level of Achievement
CRITERIA EXCELLENT (75-100) GOOD POOR
2 1
APPLICATION OF No errors in 1
1 1 Missed one or more Little or no
DESIGN identifying and to
C1 to to concepts or misapplied understanding of
SPECIFICATIONS applying appropriate 1
3 2 a provision design provisions
AND PROVISIONS provisions 0
0 0

1 No errors in applying All applicable design

SELECTION OF 9 1 Little or no
6 applicable design provisions considered
OTIMUM/ to to understanding of
C2 to provisions and but with multiple errors
ECONOMICAL 1 selecting the best
2 efficient processes for in selecting the best 8
DESIGN 5 design
0 selecting best design design

1
Members, joints, 9 Members, joints, Loads,
6 1 Little or No
Loads, Load to Load combinations
C3 ANALYSIS to to understanding of
combinations analysis 1 analysis moderately
2 8 structural analysis
all done correctly 5 done correctly
0

Presentation of report
Neat presentation,
1 is good, clear and
well-organized, clear 5
PRESENTATION 1 concise, logical with 1 Unintelligible or
and concise, logical, to
C4 AND VISUAL to minor erasures and to unusable solutions and
excellent grammar, 1
APPEAL 1 with correct grammar, 4 presentation
punctuation, 0
5 punctuation,
paragraphs (if any)
paragraphs (if any)

1 Neat presentation, Neat presentation,

5
DESIGN 1 well-organized, clear well-organized, clear 1 Extreme deficiencies in
to
C5 DETAILS/DRAWING to and concise,all and concise ,with most to design details and
1
S 1 necessary components of the necessary 4 drawings
0
5 present components present

 A score of zero may be given for criteria that are not at all satisfied.
 GROUP EVALUATION

NAME ASSIGNMENT RATING REMARKS SIGNATURE

CRISTOBAL,
Sharmaine B. 10/10 Participative

GALINGAN,
Maureen Joy 10/10 Participative
D.

CABALTERA,
10/10 Participative
Cy

SABAS, Dom Participative

10/10
Vincent L. (kasingpetan)