Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
net/publication/295247351
Impact of the Number of Steps on the Fukuda Stepping Test in Older Adults
CITATIONS READS
2 104
3 authors:
Yves Lajoie
University of Ottawa
86 PUBLICATIONS 2,510 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Deborah Jehu on 10 October 2018.
Fo
rP
Impact of the number of steps on the Fukuda Stepping test
in older adults
ee
Manuscript ID Draft
rR
27 step test is recommended over the 100-step as it may have reduced measurement error.
28
29
30
ev
31
32
33
34 KEYWORDS Fukuda Stepping test, older adults, test-retest reliability, vestibular
ie
35
36
37 rehabilitation, within-subject variability.
w
38
39
40
On
41
42
43
44
45
ly
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 1 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 2 of 15
27 cause patients to progressively turn as they step in place. Indeed, patients with unilateral
28
29
vestibular lesions exhibit body rotation on the Fukuda Stepping test, usually towards the
30
ev
31
32 lesion side (Peitersen 1967). However, this result has been contested as no difference in
33
34 rotation was found between healthy individuals and patients with peripheral labyrinthine
ie
35
36
37 dysfunction (Hickey et al., 1990). More recently, 25% of patients with unilateral
w
38
39 vestibular dysfunction were found to have similar rotations as those obtained in healthy
40
On
41 individuals (Zhang & Wang, 2011). Furthermore, substantial body rotation on the Fukuda
42
43
44 Stepping test has been reported in healthy young and older adults (e.g. Previc & Saucedo,
45
ly
46 1992; Nyabenda et al., 2004; Paquet et al., 2014). In spite of these shortcomings, the
47
48 Fukuda Stepping test continues to be used by clinicians who practice in the field of
49
50
51 vestibular rehabilitation.
52
53 This study sought to examine whether the number of steps influences the outcome
54
55
56
of the Fukuda Stepping test. Bonanni and Newton (1998) compared the performance of
57
58
59
60 P a g e 2 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Page 3 of 15 Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics
27 portion of patients with dizziness, balance impairments and falls are elders (Stel et al.,
28
29
2003; Jönsson et al., 2004). In order to correctly interpret test results in older patients
30
ev
31
32 with dizziness and vestibular disorders, it is important to characterize performance in
33
34 healthy older adults on the Fukuda Stepping test.
ie
35
36
37 The specific aims were to compare body rotation, lateral displacement and
w
38
39 longitudinal displacement of the final body position obtained on the 50-step and 100-step
40
On
41 tests; to compare within-subject variability of measures between the two tests; and to
42
43
44 determine test-retest reliability with a 7-day interval for the two tests. It was expected that
45
ly
46 the extent of body rotation and linear displacements would be doubled on the 100-step
47
48 than on the 50-step test because there are twice the number of steps on the 100-step
49
50
51 compared to the 50-step test. It was also expected that within-subject variability of
52
53 measures would be larger on the 100-step than on the 50-step test.
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 3 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 4 of 15
27 Testing Procedures
28
29
The testing procedure was conducted in a large, quiet room. Participants were
30
ev
31
32 positioned in front of a starting line marked on the ground and were instructed to step in
33
34 place at a comfortable pace while staying on the same spot at all times. They were in
ie
35
36
37 socked feet, had their arms by their sides, and wore opaque goggles that completely
w
38
39 blocked their vision. Steps were counted by the investigator.
40
On
41 Three trials of each test were completed and the order of the test (50- or 100-
42
43
44 steps) was randomly determined. Participants did not receive any feedback about their
45
ly
46 performance. They kept the opaque goggles at all times and they were guided back to the
47
48 starting line by an assistant through a complex pathway after each trial so that they would
49
50
51 not gain information about their final position relative to the starting line. At the end of
52
53 each trial, participants’ final foot position was marked on the floor with a 20 cm piece of
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 4 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Page 5 of 15 Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics
27 measured with a ruler and recorded within 1 cm of accuracy. Negative signs were
28
29
attributed to counter-clockwise body rotation, lateral displacement to the left of the
30
ev
31
32 starting line and longitudinal displacement behind the starting line.
33
34
ie
35
36
37 Data Analyses
w
38
39 Signed values were transformed into absolute values and the two data sets were
40
On
41 used for analysis. First, outliers were identified with the use of IBM SPSS Statistics 20
42
43
44 software and removed from the two data sets. Outliers were defined as values 1.5 times
45
ly
46 or greater than those in the interquartile range representing 50% of the cases. Outliers
47
48 were found to represent 1.6% of all the data. After the within-subject variability analyses
49
50
51 were completed, data from the three trials were averaged and used for subsequent
52
53 analyses.
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 5 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 6 of 15
31
32 RESULTS
33
34 Table 1 lists signed and absolute mean and SD values of the three measures on the
ie
35
36
37 50-step and 100-step Fukuda tests. On the 100-step test, mean absolute values of body
w
38
39 rotation, lateral and longitudinal displacements were significantly larger than those
40
On
41 obtained on the 50-step test (Rotation z = -5.43, p < .001, r = .78; Lateral displacement z
42
43
44 = -5.69, p < .001, r = .80; Longitudinal displacement z = -4.55, p < .001, r = .64). For
45
ly
46 signed values, only the mean value of longitudinal displacement on the 100-step test was
47
48 significantly larger than that of the 50-step test (z = -3.36, p < .001, r = .48).
49
50
51 The mean of participants’ SD for each measure are listed in Table 2. The mean
52
53 SDs for all measures were significantly larger on the 100-step test than the 50-step test (p
54
55
56
< .001 for all paired t-tests).
57
58
59
60 P a g e 6 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Page 7 of 15 Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics
27 the number of steps was doubled. This effect was not observed with the signed values, as
28
29
mean signed body rotation and mean signed lateral displacement were not significantly
30
ev
31
32 different between the 50-step and 100-step tests (Table 1, first two columns). This finding
33
34 is consistent with previous research as Bonanni and Newton (1998) also reported that the
ie
35
36
37 signed values of rotation were not significantly different between the two tests.
w
38
39 Interestingly, they reported mean values (-14º for the 50-step test and -18º for the 100-
40
On
41 step test) that were similar to the current findings (-10º for the 50-step test and -20º for
42
43
44 the 100-step test). The negative signs indicate that on average, participants turned
45
ly
46 counter-clockwise regardless of the number of steps. A previous study showed that the
47
48 direction of rotation on the 100-step Fukuda test was significantly correlated to foot
49
50
51 dominance in healthy young adults (r = -.32), with counter-clockwise rotation reflecting
52
53 right foot dominance (Paquet et al., 2014).
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 7 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 8 of 15
27 sense of position and orientation in space (Wolbers and Hegarty, 2010). Perhaps body
28
29
displacements in the sagittal plane were better detected by these self-motion cues than
30
ev
31
32 displacements in the frontal plane in our older participants. Previous studies have shown
33
34 that sway in the medio-lateral direction when standing on one leg and when walking
ie
35
36
37 increased with age (Nitz et al., 2003; Schrager et al., 2008). Accordingly, it is possible
w
38
39 that the control of lateral displacements when stepping in place was difficult because
40
On
41 individuals were almost always in unipedal stance as their stance alternated between their
42
43
44 right and left leg. As a result, their center of gravity likely moved back and forth in the
45
ly
46 medio-lateral direction and these movements were probably larger than those in the
47
48 antero-posterior direction. Thus, perhaps the perception and control of displacements in
49
50
51 the frontal plane were more challenging for older adults than perception and control of
52
53 displacements in the sagittal plane.
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 8 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Page 9 of 15 Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics
27 is recommended that more than one trial of the Fukuda Stepping test be executed because
28
29
performance on one trial may not accurately represent typical performance. In addition,
30
ev
31
32 we found that within-subject variability was significantly larger on the 100-step than on
33
34 the 50-step test. This indicates that variations in test results from trial-to-trial were
ie
35
36
37 influenced by the number of steps. Because the 100-step test is more strenuous than the
w
38
39 50-step test, this may have contributed to the increased variability. Therefore, the 50-step
40
On
41 test should be favored over the 100-step test in order to avoid the excessive within-
42
43
44 subject variability in performance associated with the 100-step test.
45
ly
46 Mean values obtained at test and retest were not significantly different. Three
47
48 ICCs values for signed and absolute lateral displacement on the 100-step test and
49
50
51 absolute lateral displacement on the 50-step test were in the range of high reliability (ICC
52
53 ≥ .7). However, all of the other measures were moderately reliable with ICCs between .50
54
55
56
and .69. These ICCs are comparable with those previously reported for the Fukuda
57
58
59
60 P a g e 9 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 10 of 15
31
32 test over the 100-step test because it is likely associated with less measurement error and
33
34 it is less strenuous for patients. It is also recommended to perform more than just one trial
ie
35
36
37 to avoid unrepresentative results.
w
38
39
40
On
41
42
43
44
45
ly
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 10 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Page 11 of 15 Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics
27
28 Hickey SA, Ford GR, Buckley JG, Fitzgerald O’Connor AF. (1990). Unterberger
29
30
stepping test: A useful indicator of peripheral vestibular dysfunction? Journal of
ev
31
32
33 Laryngology and Otology 104:599-602.
34
ie
35 McGraw KO, Wong SP. (1996). Forming inferences about some intraclass correlation
36
37
w
41
42
43
dwelling women over 40 years of age. Clinical Rehabilitation 17:765-767.
44
45 Nyabenda A, Briart C, Deggouj N, Gersdorff M. (2004). A normative study of the
ly
46
47 vestibulospinal and rotational tests. Advances in Physiotherapy 6:122-129.
48
49
50 Paquet N, Taillon-Hobson A, Lajoie Y. (2014). Fukuda and Babinski-Weil tests: Within-
51
52 subject variability and test-retest reliability in nondisabled adults. Journal of
53
54 Rehabilitation Research and Development 51:1013-1022.
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 11 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 12 of 15
27 Takemori S, Ida M, Umezu H. (1985). Vestibular training after sudden loss of vestibular
28
29
function. ORL Journal of Otorhinolaryngology and Related Specialties 47:76-83.
30
ev
31
32 Trullier O, Wiener SI, Berthoz A, Meyer JA. (1997) Biologically based artificial
33
34 navigation systems: Review and prospects. Progress in Neurobiology 51:483-544.
ie
35
36
37 Tusa RJ. (2014). History and clinical examination. In: Herdman SJ and Clendaniel RA,
w
38
39 eds. Vestibular Rehabilitation. Fourth edition. Philadelphia, PA:FA Davis Company,
40
On
41 160-177.
42
43
44 Wolpers T, Hegarty M. (2010). What determines our navigational abilities? Trends in
45
ly
27
28
29
30
ev
31
32
33
34
ie
35
36
37
w
38
39
40
On
41
42
43
44
45
ly
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60 P a g e 13 | 13
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics Page 14 of 15
1
2
3
4
5 TABLE 1. Mean (SD) of Measures and Intra-Class Correlation Coefficients (95%
6 Confidence Interval)
7 Signed Absolute
8 50-step 100-step 50-step 100-step
9
10
Test
11 Rotation (º) -10 (38) -20 (88) 33 (22) 74 (45) *
12 Lateral (cm) -12 (49) -14 (120) 45 (30) 124 (61) *
13 Longitudinal (cm) 102 (57) 151 (116) * 103 (54) 165 (98) *
14 Retest
Fo
15
Rotation (º) -13 (42) -13 (101) 39 (29) 87 (55)
16
17 Lateral (cm) -15 (45) -12 (136) 43 (29) 121 (72)
18 Longitudinal (cm) 96 (47) 145 (91) 96 (47) 151 (84)
rP
19 ICC
20 Rotation .64 (.35-.79) .58 (.27-.76) .57 (.23-.76) .57 (.24-.76)
21 Lateral .57 (.24-.76) .77 (.60-.87) .71 (.50-.84) .72 (.51-.84)
22
Longitudinal .63 (.39-.80) .68 (.44-.82) .65 (.38-.80) .65 (.38-.80)
ee
23
24 ICC: Intraclass correlation coefficient.
25 * p<0.001 relative to the 50-step test.
26
rR
27
28
29
30
ev
31
32
33
34
ie
35
36
37
w
38
39
40
On
41
42
43
44
45
ly
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net
Page 15 of 15 Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics
1
2
3
TABLE 2. Mean SD of Three Trials
4
5 Signed Absolute
6 Test 50-step 100-step 50-step 100-step
7 Rotation (º) 19 42 * 16 29 *
8 Lateral (cm) 27 71 * 20 42 *
9
10
Longitudinal (cm) 15 58 * 15 52 *
11 * p<0.001 relative to the 50-step test.
12
13
14
Fo
15
16
17
18
rP
19
20
21
22
ee
23
24
25
26
rR
27
28
29
30
ev
31
32
33
34
ie
35
36
37
w
38
39
40
On
41
42
43
44
45
ly
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
URL: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/wpog Email: ellentaira@earthlink.net