Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Delhi Postal
under Registration No
‘u’ Number DL-SW-17/4194/16-18
u(sw)-12/2019-2021
UNDER
At Lodi 'U' NUMBER
Road, PSO on dated 28-29.03.2019 U(SW)-12/2016-2018
licence to post
At Lodi Road, PSONewspaper
on dated 28-29.01.2017 LICENCE TO POST
ISSN 0376-7256
Newspaper Regd No. 25597/73
Regd. No. 25597/73 without prepayment
WITHOUT
published on PREPAYMENT
22 MARCH, 2019
DL-SW-17/4194/16-18
APRIL, 2019
Indian Highways Advance Month, APRIL, 2019
INDIAN HIGHWAYS PUBLISHED ON 27 JANUARY 2017
`20/-
FEBRUARY 2017
About SAICPL
SMART INNOVATIVE INFRA SOLUTIONS - WORKING TOWARDS BETTER TOMORROW
(An ISO 9001-2008 Certified Company)
Indian Highways
SA Infrastructure Consultants Pvt. Ltd along with its subsidiary UPHAM International Corporation and QUEST Engineers &
Consultants are focused on delivering multi-disciplinary infra projects with innovative ideas of International Standards. The
Group forms an ambious consortium of consultancy firms with commitment to provide high quality specialized consultation
into the field of Highways, Structures and Design.
Volume : 47 Number : 4 Total Pages : 60
Sectors
Services
SA Infrastructure synchronizes every aspect of engineering with imbibed commitment to deliver high quality infrastructure and development consultation
that glorifies a new world. We have successfully carried out numerous consultancy projects in Civil infrastructure development, transportation, primary &
secondary highway networks, Project Management under BOT/Annuity Model, Resource Management, Social aspects including poverty alleviation and
Institutional support.
Bridges : Including VUP, Flyovers, rehabilitation, ROB and Inspection Report Some of the Major Projects
and Conditional Survey.
Corporate Address : 1101, 11th Floor, Tower A-II, Ansal Corporate Park, Sector 142, Noida - 201 301, Uttar Pradesh, INDIA A view of Kadthal-Armoor NH Project in Andhra Pradesh
Tel : +91-120-6148000 / Fax : +91-120-6148090 www.sainfra.com Email : info@sainfra.com
Edited and Published by Shri S.S.Nahar, Secretary General, Indian Roads Congress, IRC HQ, Sector-6, R.K.Puram, Kama Koti Marg, New Delhi - 110 022.
Printed by Shri S.S.Nahar
Edited on behalf by
and Published of the
ShriIndian
S.K. Roads Congress
Nirmal, at M/s.
Secretary I G Printers
General, IndianPvtRoads
Ltd., 104, DSIDC Complex,
Congress, IRC HQ,Okhla Industrial
Sector-6, R.K.Area, Phase-I, New
Puram,
Delhi - 110 020. Kama Koti Marg, New Delhi - 110 022. Printed by Shri S.K. Nirmal on behalf of the Indian Roads Congress
at M/s. Aravali Printers & Publishers Pvt. Ltd. https://www.irc.nic.in
.
.
!
!/
0
#
/
1#
2
3#4 5 !6 7 5 8 95 !6
5
#
!6
:
1 4
4
#5 ;; 5
+7 <
# = >
25
#
B
;5
?. @@A@)@$$
#4
2
1
4
1 2
BC 5
# !
94
!
"
#
$$%%$ &
'()%$"")$)%%% *+,' -
.
.
.
Indian Highways
Volume : 47 Number : 4 ● APRIL, 2019 ● ISSN 0376-7256
Indian Roads Congress
Founded : On 10th December, 1934
Contents
From the Editor's Desk 4-5
Advertisements 8, 9, 10 & 58
Technical Papers
Measurement of Aggregate-Bitumen Interface Bond Strength using Binder Bond Strength Test 11
By Nihit Nigam, Vinamra Mishra & Dharamveer Singh
No part of this publication may be reproduced by any means without prior written permission from the Secretary General, IRC.
The responsibility of the contents and the opinions expressed in Indian Highways is exclusively of the author(s) concerned. IRC and the Editor
disclaim responsibility and liability for any statements or opinion, originality of contents and of any copyright violations by the authors. The
opinion expressed in the papers and contents published in the Indian Highways do not necessarily represent the views of the Editor or IRC.
Printed at: M/s Aravali Printers & Publishers Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi-110 020 `20
In Construction contracts a dispute arises when a claim is asserted by one party and denied by the other party
on whatever grounds. Mere failure or in action to pay dues does not lead to the inference of existence of
dispute. Dispute entails a positive element of assert and denying, not merely inaction to acceded to a claim
or a request. Whether in a particular case, a dispute has arisen or not, has to be found out from the fact and
circumstances of the case. In the event of any dispute between the parties, the first attempt should be to
resolve the dispute through Conciliation.
It has been observed that most Claims as raised by the Contractors under the Arbitration are invariably on
account of failure of department to hand over encumbrance free site, delay in acquisition of land, shifting of
utilities, forest clearance, delay in making of Interim payments or final payment under the Contract, delay
in decision on issues as sought for by the Contractor as required for execution of work, delay in approval
of drawings as submitted by the Contractor or delay in issue of drawings by the Department, dispute or
difference as regard interpretation of implementation of a clause or provision of Contract, a decision taken
by the Executive Engineer is beyond the provisions of Contract, Contractor not satisfied with the decision
of the Executive Engineer on any of the issue(s) raised by the Contractor, failure to issue a variation order
where required, dispute as regard any compensation event, idling of resources, machinery and equipment on
account of prolongation of stay at site for reasons attributable to the department.
In General Conditions of Contracts (GCC) there is a provision for settlement of disputes. The dispute shall be
referred to the Dispute Review Expert (DRE) within 14 days of the notification of dispute. DRE shall give a
decision in writing within 28 days of the receipt of notification of dispute. DRE is generally provided for works
costing upto Rs.50.00 Crore. Dispute Review Board of three members (one from employer, one from contractor
and one to be nominated by designated authority in contract, for works costing more than Rs.50.00 Crore. Data
and the cost shall be divided equally between the employer and the contractor. Whatever decision is reached
by the DRE/Dispute Review Board, either party if unsatisfied by the DRE decision may give notice to the other
and refer the decision of DRE to Arbitration within 28 days of the DRE’s written decision. If neither party refers
the dispute to arbitration within the next 28 days, the DRE’s decision shall be final and binding.
In case of dispute or differences arising between the employer and a domestic contractor relating to any matter
arising out of or connected with the contract agreement, is not settlement by DRE/Competent Authority then
it shall be settled through arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Reconciliation Act, 1996. The
Arbitration Tribunal shall be of Sole Arbitrator or 3 Arbitrators one of each to be appointed by the employer
and the contractor and the third arbitrator to be chosen by the two arbitrators appointed by the parties to act
as the Presiding Arbitrator. In case of failure of the two arbitrators appointed by the parties to reach upon
a consensus for presiding arbitrator within a period of 30 days from the appointment of the Arbitrators, the
Presiding Arbitrator shall be appointed by the Executive committee of Indian Roads Congress or any other
designated authority mentioned in the contract.
The Arbitral Tribunal (AT) shall decide the dispute submitted to arbitration, in accordance with the substantive
laws for the time being in force in the country. The substantive law in the country are “The Indian Contract
Act, 1872, the Limitation Act, 1963, the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended by the Arbitration
and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015 and the rulings given by the Supreme Court of India etc. While
deciding and making an award, the AT shall, in all cases, take into account the terms of the contract and trade
under the present usages applicable in the transactions. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 in the matters
of arbitral proceedings with more than one arbitrator, any decision of the AT shall be made by a majority of
all its members.
In some contracts, in case any party fails to nominate their arbitrator within 30 days of intimation given
by other party, the IRC council is also authorized to nominate arbitrator on behalf of defaulting party. IRC
council is authorized to nominate presiding arbitrator if arbitrators from both the parties fail to select a
presiding arbitrator. The IRC registers and prepares a panel of retired Chief Engineers from Central and State
Governments as arbitrators. As and when there is a request for arbitrators from any employer/contractor, the
same is proposed for the work. In Highway contracts of NHAI, arbitration is to be carried out in accordance
with the rules of the arbitration of the SOCIETY FOR REDRESSAL OF DISPUTES (SAROD)
It has been observed that the General Condition and Special condition of contracts are not reviewed from
time to time by employers. The contract conditions need to be reviewed periodically so that these are in line
with the Substantive law of the country. Ambiguity left in the contract delays execution of works and leads
to disputes. These contract condition needs to be balanced for both the parties with simplified procedures for
decision making. In some States the official language is Hindi. The contract documents GCC, SCC are in
English language. There is a need to make General Condition of Contract, SCC in hindi language.
The Employer ought to be fully aware of the obligations under the contract and must be ready to perform the
same well in time. The major obligations of the employers are handing over encroachment free site, issue of
good for construction drawings, due and timely payment to the Contractor. The engineers need to be trained
in contract management.
IRC is in the process of revision of MoRTH Specifications for Road and Bridge Works. Ambiguity in
specifications sometimes leads to delay in execution of work and Arbitration. Readers are requested to send
feedback on specifications as well as other contract documents so that they can be addressed during their
revision and thus minimizing any scope of their misinterpretation for smooth implementation of projects.
Shri I.K. Pandey joined Ministry of Road Transport & Highways in September, 1984 as
Assistant Executive Engineer and rose to the position of Director General (Road Development)
& Special Secretary. He was graduated in the year 1982 in Civil Engineering and pursued
a course of Masters in Foundation Engineer in 1996. He has also successfully completed a
course in Environment Impact Assessment & Auditing (EIA&A) from University of Bradford,
United Kingdom and a course in Advanced Bridge Engineering at TIC (Tokyo International
Centre), Japan. He has worked in the Ministry in various capacities and also in National
Highway Authority of India (NHAI) as General Manager (Tech) and Chief General Manager
(Tech). During his career spanning over 35 years he had successfully got executed numbers
of prestigious Highways projects including major bridges. He has contributed in preparation
of specification and codal provision of IRC as Convenor/Member of various IRC Technical
Committees. He has also steered the work of ING-IABSE for disseminating knowledge in the
field of Bridge Engineering through workshops and seminars across the country.
Quality Systems
Quality has been the main stay in construction industry since beginning of civilization however, quality
has been considered by various stakeholders in different manners and silos. What is required is to
understand the quality as a way of life and philosophy. Quality has to be ensured since beginning from
planning stage and continue to be observed through various stages of design, construction and there-
after during its service life for proper maintenance. All stake holders must shoulder their responsibility
for the role they have been assigned for ensuring quality of product and desired service during life time.
Having said that, attention has to be paid to achieve total quality management.
Infrastructure sector specially highway and bridge construction are being executed on EPC mode of
contract. Under the EPC mode of contracts responsibilities has been assigned to the EPC contractor
to design construct and maintain ensuring the quality. Expert Consultants are being engaged at every
stage i.e. for preparation of detailed project report, supervision of the contract during construction and
further during maintenance period to look into the quality aspect and ensure quality system and quality
assurance.
More often, it is observed that there has been laxity on the part of the client to leave everything to
the Authority engineer and the contractor to achieve the desired quality standards and completion of
works as per specifications. Provisions under the EPC contract has led to complacency on the part of
Authority engineer as well, who believe that the quality remains the responsibility of the contractor who
is responsible for design and proof checking through a reputed consultant or engineering institutions.
Authority Engineers have also misunderstood the EPC document to believe that their responsibility
lies with checking of only specified percentage of the quantity or number of test prescribed for each
category or type of test for qualifying category by the Contractor, whereas provisions are made to
randomly carryout test check everyday and any deficiency observed to be got rectified. However, during
recent inspection, it was observed that TL/Material Engineer of AE are not observing this test check
regularly and they failed to check and sign the Quality Register for years together. Such a callousness
has led to premature failure of cement concrete Pavement recently been constructed under various
projects. There has been failure of temporary works, which led to collapse of span during construction.
Safety during construction is a completely neglected subject.
This only indicates that the basic premise contained in EPC Contract and AE’s contract are not met. Had
it been there, recently observed failure would not have occurred. Here comes the duty of the client to
watch whether Contractor, AE/ IE and safety consultants are discharging their responsibilities diligently
and at required frequency and quality systems are followed scrupulously.
I would appeal to all the clients to pay attention on these matters to ensure quality of works to pre-empt
failure and ensure delivery of safe and durable infrastructure.
(I.K. Pandey)
Visit us at
Booth FS.909
BUILT
FOR INDIA
AMMANN AFT 500 ASPHALT PAVER
Looking for productivity on larger asphalt road projects? The Ammann AFT 500 Paver is the answer.
The machine features many advantages for the operating crew, such as unmatched overview for best
process control at all time. The AFT 500 offers the power, the traction and the screed options to pave
roads as wide as 7 metres.
Ammann India Private Ltd., Plot No.2,143,144, AT - Ditasan, Post - Jagudan, State Highway,
Ditasan, Mehsana, Gujarat, PIN Code: 382710
Phone + 91 27 626 62 200, Fax + 91 27 626 62 222, ankur.tiwari@ammann-group.com
For additional product information and services please visit : www.ammann.com
PMP-2240-00-EN | © Ammann Group
06-04-19 Sat 11.00 AM Specialized Bridge Structures including Sealinks Committee (B-9)
Abstract
The present study is focussed to examine the suitability of Binder Bond Strength (BBS) test to evaluate bonding failure at
aggregate-bitumen interface under different moisture conditioning regimes. Bonding failure in bituminous pavement due
to moisture is one of the prime reasons for failure of a pavement system. The BBS test can measure bond strength between
bitumen and aggregate before and after moisture conditioning. In this research work, bond strength of VG30 binder
and basalt aggregate was evaluated under different moisture conditioning regimes, namely, (a) standard conditioning
at 40°C for 24 h, (b) varying temperature conditioning at 25°C, 40°C and 60°C for 24 h, and (c) prolonged conditioning
for 96 h at 40°C and 60°C. In addition, comparison of bond strength of VG30 and VG10 with basalt aggregate was
studied. The study revealed that lower viscosity grade binder (i.e., VG10) will have reduced bond strength with aggregate.
It was observed that aggregate-bitumen bond strength decreases after moisture conditioning. In addition, prolonged
conditioning for 96 h significantly reduced the bond strength of VG30-basalt system compared with standard conditioning
for 24 h. Furthermore, decrease in bond strength with increase in conditioning temperature was observed, irrespective of
conditioning duration. Moreover, failure pattern was observed to be cohesive before and after moisture conditioning in
all the cases. Thus, it was concluded that, BBS test is suitable to quantify bond strength and identify failure mechanism
under varying conditioning regimes (i.e. conditioning temperature and duration). The BBS test may be helpful to estimate
bonding potential of aggregate and bitumen rather than stripping value test which is frequently used as a qualitative
approach in India.
1
B. Tech, Civil Engineering Department, PEC University of Technology, Chandigarh, Email: nihitnigam.beciv14@pec.edu.in
2
Ph.D. Student, Email: vinamramishra89@gmail.com
3
Civil Engineering Department, Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
Assistant Professor, Email: dvsingh@civil.iitb.ac.in
(TSR) (AASHTO T283), boiling water test (ASTM it can potentially be used as a replacement of stripping
D3625) and Hamburg Wheel-Track Device (HWTD) test value (IS: 6241-2008) test which is a subjective approach
(AASHTO T 324). In addition, surface free energy (SFE) and is widely used in India. Moreover, the BBS test may
of aggregate and bitumen can also be utilized to estimate provide practicing engineers a quick approach to identify
bonding potential between aggregate and bitumen (Habal inappropriate aggregate-bitumen combinations prior to
and Singh 2017, Singh and Mishra 2018). However, construction.
these test methods are not capable to directly report 2. Objectives and Scope of study
bond strength at failure surface (i.e. aggregate-bitumen
interface). Bonding failure at aggregate-bitumen interface The main objective of the present work was to study
can be quantified using Binder Bond Strength (BBS) test the feasibility of BBS test to measure bond strength of
introduced by Moraes et al. (2011) which is now widely bitumen with aggregates. Specifically, the following sub-
used by researchers (Moya et al. 2013, Huang and Lv objectives were outlined.
2016). It measures the force required to debond bitumen a) Evaluate bond strength between basalt and VG30
from aggregate surface in unconditioned (24 h at 25°C) binder under different moisture conditioning regimes,
state and moisture conditioned (24 h at 40°C) state namely:
(AASHTO T 361-16). Moraes et al. 2011 characterizes
i. Standard Conditioning: 24 h dry conditioning
moisture damage at aggregate-bitumen interface using
at 25°C, followed by 24 h moisture
BBS test method. It was concluded that bonding failure
conditioning at 40°C.
in dry condition is cohesive, whereas, failure may be
adhesive or cohesive after moisture conditioning. In ii. Varying conditioning temperature: 24 h dry
addition, bond strength was also found to be dependent conditioning, followed by 24 h moisture
on aggregate type and source. Similarly, Bahia et al. 2012 conditioning at 25°C, 40°C and 60°C.
found that moisture conditioning changes the failure iii. Prolonged conditioning: 24 h dry conditioning,
mode from cohesive to adhesive. They also reported that followed by 96 h moisture conditioning at
bonding failure is dependent on conditioning time. Ling 40°C and 60°C.
et al. 2016 studied the bond strength of cold mix asphalt
using BBS test approach to validate boiling water test. b) E
valuate effects of viscosity grade (VG10 versus
Huang and Lv et al. 2016 evaluated the bond strength VG30) binder type on bond strength with basalt.
of aggregate-bitumen system at different moisture 3. Background on Binder Bond
conditioning durations (1 h, 2 h, 4 h, 8 h, 24 h, 48 h Strength Test
and 96 h). Rapid decrease in bond strength was observed
The BBS test is a modified version of Pneumatic
for the first 24 h after which slight drop in strength was
Adhesion Tensile Testing Instrument (PATTI) developed
observed.
by Canestrari et al. 2010. It provides quick, repeatable
However, in Indian scenario, stripping value test (IS:6241- and reproducible results to evaluate bonding failure
2008) and TSR tests are frequently used methods to study between bitumen and aggregate (Moraes et al. 2011). It
moisture damage in bituminous pavement. As discussed, evaluates the pull-off tensile strength (POTS) required to
these test methods do not answer the failure mechanism cause failure at aggregate-bitumen interface by measuring
and do not represent actual field conditions (Ghabchi burst pressure (BP). BP is the force required to pull off
et al. 2013). Hence, the present study is motivated the metallic stub used to bond bitumen with substrate
to examine BBS test to investigate bond strength of surface as shown in Fig. 2. BP (kPa) is converted to POTS
aggregate-bitumen system and to quantify bonding (MPa) using Eq.1. The test is generally conducted after
failure. Bond strength of unmodified VG-30 binder with dry and wet conditioning as per AASHTO T 361-16. In
basalt aggregate was evaluated using standard BBS dry conditioning, samples are kept at room temperature
test approach (AASHTO T 361-16). Since, moisture for 24 h, while, in wet conditioning, the samples are
damage is a time dependent phenomenon, the effect of kept submerged under water at 40°C for 24 h. Usually,
prolonged moisture conditioning at 96 h was also studied. the ratio of POTS after wet conditioning (POTSwet) to
Moreover, the effect of conditioning temperature (25°C, POTS after dry conditioning (POTSdry), which is known
40°C and 60°C) and binder type on bond strength was as bond strength ratio (BSR) (Eq.2) is used to quantify
also studied. It was observed that the BBS can address bonding potential of aggregate-bitumen system. Higher
bonding failure under different conditioning regimes and BSR is desirable for higher bonding potential. Fig. 2
4. Materials and Methodology aggregate and bitumen was evaluated using PATTI
In the present research work, VG-30 and VG-10 binder Quantum Gold Adhesion Tester (Fig. 2). Fig. 3 shows the
and basalt aggregate were used, which are commonly used detailed experimental layout showcasing different test
for road construction in India. The bond strength between conditions considered in the study.
Bond Strength evaluation using BBS test approach was stirred and poured in a silicon mold (Fig.5 (a)).
The bond strength (or POTS) between aggregate and Preparation of BBS test sample: The aggregate sample
bitumen was determined using BBS test in accordance was placed in oven maintained at 60°C to attain application
with AASHTO T 361-16. Determination of bond strength temperature and the stubs were placed in oven at 150°C
involves following procedure described below: for 30 min. Thereafter, bitumen from silicon mold was
transferred on top of heated stub surface (Fig.5 (b) & Fig.5
Aggregate preparation: It involved cutting of aggregate (c)). The binder was allowed to melt on stub for nearly
block samples into small levelled surface using a diamond 10 s, after which the stub was pressed against aggregate
saw cutter (Fig.4 (a)). Thereafter, levelled surface was surface without twisting. The samples were then allowed
polished using Silicon Carbide (SiC) grit powder (Fig.4 to conditioned dry (Fig.5 (d)) and wet (Fig.5 (e)).
(b)). The aggregate surface was polished using 1000
SiC grit powder. The sole purpose of aggregate surface Testing: The stub was then surrounded by piston and
polishing is to ensure uniformity in surface roughness reaction plate using a ring support (Fig.6). The reaction
plate was tightened in such a way that small gap between
throughout the aggregate. The polished aggregate
piston and reaction plate could be maintained. Using
surface was then cleaned using ultrasonic bath (Fig.4 (c))
adhesion testing device, maximum POTS and BSR was
maintained at temperature 60°C to remove residual dust
evaluated using Eq. 1 and Eq. 2, and failure pattern was
resulted due to polishing. To remove moisture, the clean
recorded. The failure is said to be cohesive if more than
and polished aggregates (Fig.4 (d)) were then kept in oven
50% bitumen remains adhered to the aggregate surface
at 110°C for 24 h. or otherwise it is adhesive. In addition, combined failure
Bitumen preparation: The binder sample was kept in oven (i.e. adhesive and cohesive) may be obtained if binder is
at 150°C to attain fluidity. The binder after attaining fluidity partially adhered to the aggregate surface.
Fig. 4 Aggregate preparation: (a) Saw cutter; (b) Aggregate polishing; (c) Ultrasonic bath; and (d) Polished aggregate
after cleaning
Fig. 5 (a) Bitumen in Silicon mold; (b) metallic stub; (c) stub filled with bitumen; (d) BBS sample in dry
condition; and (e) Moisture conditioned BBS sample
(a) (b)
Fig. 8 Variation of (a) wet POTS, and (b) BSR at
for 96 h was found to be 1.98 MPa (Fig. 9 (a)), which
Different Conditioning Temperature
in case of moisture conditioning at 60°C for 24 h was
5.3 Bond Strength Evaluation under Prolonged 2.40 MPa (Fig. 8). Hence, it was observed that presence
Conditioning of moisture for prolonged duration at aggregate-bitumen
Fig. 9 shows the POTSwet of basalt with VG30 binder interface jeopardize bonding failure. Similar to standard
subjected to 96 h moisture conditioning at 40°C and 60°C conditioning, cohesive failure pattern was observed.
for three samples. The average POTSwet at 40°C for 96 h Conditioning for prolonged duration may increase the
was found to be 2.37 MPa (Fig. 9 (a)). Hence, compared diffusion of water into binder (Varveri et al. 2016), which
with standard conditioning (average POTSwet=2.47 may exacerbate debonding of aggregate-bitumen interface
MPa), POTSwet decreases to 2.37 MPa after 96 h of as obtained in the present study.
conditioning at 40°C. Similarly, average POTSwet at 60°C In addition, when samples were conditioning at 40°C,
the percentage reduction in POTSwet after 96 h moisture that reduction in POTSwet is more prominent with increase
conditioning was found to be 4% (2.47 to 2.37 MPa) in conditioning temperature. The reduction in POTSwet
compared with sample conditioned for 24 h. However, decreases the bonding potential between basalt-VG30, as
when conditioning temperature increases to 60°C, the reflected by BSR (Fig.9 (b)). The average BSR decreases
percentage reduction in POTSwet was observed to be from 0.88 to 0.74 when the conditioning temperature
17.5% (2.40 to 1.98 MPa). Hence, it was also observed increases from 40°C to 60°C (Fig.9 (b)).
a b
Fig. 9 (a) Wet POTS, and (b) BSR after Prolonged Conditioning for 96 h at 40°C and 60°C
5.4 Effect of Binder Type on POTSdry behaviour with aggregate surface.
Fig. 10 shows the effect of binder type on POTSdry
with basalt aggregate. It was observed that average
POTSdry for VG10-basalt combination was found to be
1.18 MPa, which in case of VG30-basalt combination
was found to be 2.69 MPa. The reduction in POTS
was expected with a softer binder or lower viscosity
grade binder. Softer binder has open microstructure
(Varveri et al. 2016) compared with hard grade
binder, which may allow quick diffusion of water
into the binder resulting in decreased bonding with
Fig.10 Effect of binder type on POTS
aggregate. However, it is important to understand that
6. Concluding Remarks
binder with higher viscosity may not always improve
bonding with aggregates. Hence, detailed analysis The present study introduced recent approach for
evaluation of bond strength between aggregate-bitumen
with different binder types (modified and unmodified, system using BBS test. The BBS test at VG30-basalt
aged and unaged etc.) is required to examine bonding interface was conducted using standard test approach
and under different moisture conditioning regime (i.e. ii. Aguiar-Moya, J. P., Loría-Salazar, L. G., Salazar-
conditioning time and conditioning temperature). In Delgado, J., Corrales-Azofeifa, J. P., & Hajj, E. Y.
addition, the effect of binder type on bond strength was (2013). Evaluation of adhesion properties of costa
rican asphalt mixtures using the bitumen bond
studied. Based on limited study on selected aggregate and
strength (BBS) and contact angle measurement
bitumen, the following conclusions were drawn: tests.
i. The POTS of aggregate-bitumen system decreases iii. Bahia, H., Moraes, R., & Velasquez, R. (2012). The
after moisture conditioning, evaluated using BSR effect of bitumen stiffness on the adhesive strength
which indicated 8% reduction on bond strength. measured by the Bitumen Bond Strength test. In 5th
ii. The bond strength was found to decrease with Eurasphalt and Eurobitume Congress, Istanbul,
increase in conditioning temperature. Turkey.
iii. Compared with standard conditioning duration iv. Canestrari, F., Cardone, F., Graziani, A., Santagata,
(24 h), bond strength was also found to decrease F. A., & Bahia, H. U. (2010). Adhesive and cohesive
with increase in conditioning duration (96 h), properties of asphalt-aggregate systems subjected
implying detrimental effect on bond strength to moisture damage. Road Materials and Pavement
Design, 11(sup1), 11-32.
on aggregate-bitumen system after prolonged
moisture conditioning. v. Ghabchi, R., Singh, D., Zaman, M., & Tian, Q. (2013).
A laboratory study of warm mix asphalt for moisture
iv. Low viscosity binder (VG10) showed lower bond
damage potential using surface free energy method.
strength compared with higher viscosity grade In Airfield and Highway Pavement 2013: Sustainable
binder (VG30). A reduction of 56% in bond strength and Efficient Pavements (pp. 54-63).
was observed, which indicates that binder viscosity
may significantly affect the bond strength. vi. Habal, A., & Singh, D. (2017). Moisture Sensitivity
of Asphalt Mixes based on Surface Chemistry
At last, the BBS test method was found to quantifying of Aggregates and Asphalt Binders. Indian
bond strength between aggregate and bitumen under Highways, 45(9).
different conditioning regimes, indicating its suitability to vii. Huang, W., & Lv, Q. (2016). Investigation of Critical
determine bonding failure under different environmental Factors Determining the Accuracy of Binder Bond
conditions. Moreover, it addresses failure mechanism Strength Test to Evaluate Adhesion Properties of Asphalt
which may play vital role in selecting aggregate-bitumen Binders. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 45(4),
system. Hence, it is recommended to use BBS test which is 1270-1279.
a quantitative approach. Further, bonding characteristics viii. IS:6241-2008, Method of Test for Determination of
also depends on the aggregate surface texture and type of Stripping Value of Road Aggregates
aggregate and bitumen used. Therefore, further research ix. Ling, C., Hanz, A., & Bahia, H. (2016). Measuring
work is required to understand debonding mechanism moisture susceptibility of Cold Mix Asphalt
considering effects of aggregate texture and different with a modified boiling test based on digital
types of aggregate-bitumen systems using BBS test imaging. Construction and Building Materials, 105,
approach. 391-399.
Acknowledgement: We would like to acknowledge x. Moraes, R., Velasquez, R., & Bahia, H. (2011).
Measuring the effect of moisture on asphalt-
the support of Department of Earth Science, IIT aggregate bond with the bitumen bond strength
Bombay for providing necessary tools required to test. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the
prepare aggregate samples. The authors would also Transportation Research Board, (2209), 70-81.
like to acknowledge to DST, India for funding project xi. Singh, D., & Mishra, V. (2018). Different methods of
No. DST/TSG/STS/2-15/76 through which BBS selecting probe liquids to measure the surface free
instrument was purchased. energy of asphalt binders. Construction and Building
Materials, 175, 448-457.
Reference
xii. Varveri, A., Avgerinopoulos, S., & Scarpas, A.
i. AASHTO. (2016). “Standard Method of Test for (2016). Experimental evaluation of long-and short-
Determining Asphalt Binder Bond Strength by Means term moisture damage characteristics of asphalt
of the Binder Bond Strength (BBS) Test” T361-16, mixtures. Road Materials and Pavement Design, 17(1),
Washington, D.C. 168-186.
has become a very important urban structure over the The traffic intersection at Jalukbari touches the approach of
period catering for ever increasing traffic intensity due to the bridge and the existing roads. The flyover is 244 metres
unremitting growth of the city. It was opened to traffic in long and have six lanes. Each three-lane carriageway has
April 1962 by then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. The separate foundations, substructure and superstructure.
Lachit Borphukan Park is situated on the south end and
Three numbers of loops and ramps each, an underpass and
Chilarai Park situated on the north end of the bridge. The
approach embankment made up of retaining walls touch
bridge was built for the North Frontier Railway.
the existing roads in all direction providing a signal free
intersection to majority of the North eastern states.
2. NEW SARAIGHAT BRIDGE
2.1 General
The Brahmaputra, is the longest river in Asia, having
a multi-channel river system having a high braiding
tendency.
The nature and behaviors of Brahmaputra is quite different
than that of other Indian rivers - its Flow concentration,
unpredictable shifting of main course, innumerable sand-
bars, deflected flow pattern coupled with high bed scour
Fig. 2: Old Saraighat Bridge on the Right & New Bridge tendency make difficult for successful constructions
on the Left. besides having inconsiderable suitable construction period
Guwahati is the largest city in Assam and one of the .
fastest developing cities in India. With the rapid growth The flood discharge of Brahmaputra (Fig 4) is 90400 M3/
of population in the city and ever-increasing traffic on old sec (4th in world) with an observed average velocity of
bridge which connects rest of India North East, the road 5.00 m/sec. reaction in terms of conservatism leading to
traffic problems were also increasing at an alarming rate huge financial drain on the country’s exchequer.
resulting in perennial traffic jams on the bridge. To ease
out this problem, NHAI (National Highway Authority Of
India) proposed new Saraighat bridge around 40 metres
south of the existing old Saraighat bridge in the year 2006.
The bridge, which will connect the city’s south and north
banks, is expected to reduce the pressure of traffic on old
Saraighat bridge, however the same necessitated later
Signal free elevated corridor at Jalukbari junction ( Fig 3 )
as a Gateway North East.
methodology and materials, plant & machineries Joints culminating in a longest single continuous girder
movement/ logistics to desired locations. bridge in India. The bridge superstructure is realised by
cast-in-situ balanced cantilever method of construction.
Early onset of monsoon, prolonged monsoon and The deck section has a 9.0 m carriageway with 2.0 m
unprecedented flash floods pose constant disruption in wide footpath on one side and anti-crash barrier on both
works. The peak working season is practically, reduced to sides of carriageway, with the overall deck-width of
4 months only i.e, from 15th Nov. to 15th March. 13.875 m. The deck is supported on POT-fixed and POT/
PTFE-sliding bearings, placed on hollow R.C. piers with
2.2 Salient Features of the Bridge
semi-circular cut and ease waters, the latter resting on
The vital urban transportation link new Saraighat bridge double-D caissons. The bridge is located in the highest
is a three-lane bridge across the river Brahmaputra to seismic zone V. A line of two Fixed POT bearings is
connect Guwahati city with North Guwahati parallel to provided on the central pier and the guided POT/PTFE-
1275 m long existing Saraighat Rail cum Road Bridge. sliding bearings are provided on all other supports.
The bridge consists of continuous spans of 105m + 150m Shock Transmission Units (STUs) are provided to
+ 8x122.948 m + 150 m + 105 m giving the total length better distribute the horizontal seismic forces among the
as overall length as 1493.584 m between Expansion supports.
The main bridge (Fig 5) is flanked by viaducts on either 6631 t in superstructure of main bridge. The foundations
side. The northern end viaduct on Amingaon side has and substructure together has around 83600 cum of M35
6 spans of 24 m each with total length of 144 m. The grade of concrete embedded with 4550 t of reinforcement
southern end viaduct has on Guwahati side has 4 spans of steel.
27 m with total length of 108 m. This contract was an item rate contract with the complete
The main bridge superstructure has around 18500 cum of designs made available during tender stage itself. However,
M50 grade of concrete in combination with 9300 cum of original designer was not available during the execution after
M60 grade of concrete. While the High Tensile strands the award of the job for any clarifications on the designs and
was around 1500 t, the un tensioned steel accounted for drawings. The contract like this where the final design of the
structure is dictated by construction methodology to be used metres and in some cases up to 10m even.
is well suited for lumpsum contracting model where designs
3. FOUNDATIONS
are done by contractor himself. As that it may be, during
the construction of the viaduct the structural cracks appeared The main bridge has 11 numbers ( P7 to P17) of pier well
on the piers. It was quite apparent that the reinforcement foundations out of which 7 numbers are constructed by
provided in the piers were inadequate. Therefore the decision floating steel caissons while rest are constructed by island
was taken to get the entire design rechecked as such the job method. Generally well foundations are 16 m by 10 m size
was almost like a design build contract. double D wells being designed with the top of 3.0 m thick
well cap at RL 40.0 m and founding levels at RL -11.40 m.
While redesigning superstructure of main bridge it was
The design scour is around the RL 7.684 m providing the
found that depth of the girder needs to be increased but
grip of around 19.0 m. However, due to redesigning during
as viaducts were completed already, increasing the height
construction, the final founding levels are varying and for
of Girder was not possible. So for a short length Concrete
some foundations had to be taken down to the RL-21.10 m
strength had to be augmented to M60 grade from M50
making the total depth of double D well foundation to 61.0
grade.
m. Existing Saraighat Bridge is just 40m (upstream) away
All these designing activities have eaten up sufficient from new Bridge & under influence zone of foundation
working times which lead to the delay in completion of of existing Bridge. Special precaution has been taken
the project. Time cycle for casting of segments by CLC while execution of well foundation works of new Bridge
gantries has been increased due to increase in quantity of under high current of water and sand blow which could be
Reinforcement steel & H.T. Strands for Superstructure encountered during the sinking of new wells which may
while redesigning. jeopardise the old bridge.
The designed founding level of wells as per the tendered At some locations protruded Reinforcement steel were cut
design was found to be inadequate. The depths of the due to abrasive action of silt content in water coupled with
revised founding levels were generally increased by 5 high water current during the flood.
To sink double D wells of 61 m deep & to keep tilts & shifts current. The short working season warranted additional
within a permissible limit, utmost caution has been taken precautions like, sinking of wells up to safe grip (below
by adopting pre-defined methodology of sinking. Well scour level), removing obstructions / dredged materials
foundations which were very near to crude oil pipeline accumulated near the well for clear water passage, if
at P7 & P17 locations were completed successfully plugging of well was not possible at the end of working
without diverting these pipelines. Special structures were season, covering of the at the top etc.
to be designed & constructed for support of these Oil Even in working season, it is very difficult for execution
Pipelines. of deep caisson foundations against heavy water current in
Brahmaputra river at this location has an annual River Brahmaputra because of the narrow passage way of
mean discharge of 46,100 m3/sec with the water at this location. As the bottom of Well cap is at LWL
of RL 40.0m additional coffer dam has been constructed to
maximum recorded discharge of 72,400 m3/sec. On
retain the water for executing the Well cap.
the alluvial soil bed, the river rolls at the maximum
mean velocity of 5m/sec. Early Flood / Flash Flood in When well foundations are chosen where the velocity
and depth of the water is low, sand islands or artificial
cofferdams (Fig. 8) are constructed, providing sand bags
to support the sand in the location of pitching of cutting
edge. The sand island or construction of cofferdam bund is
an ingenuous application, which is in practice in India for
many years. Here, the island is made to bring the ground
level above water level and wells are constructed on the
level surface. The four of the foundations near the banks
were constructed using this technology.
and the tilting, is controlled by dredging the appropriate with sand filling up to scour depth.
compartment. Normally, the tilt of 1 in 80 and shift of 150
mm is considered to be tolerance limits and the design
caters for the same.
Cranes and grabs were deployed for well sinking. It was
ensured that the could bite into the soil and be closed
when operated from top. The length and breadth in both
opened and closed condition was kept as small as possible,
yielding maximum quantum of earth carrying capacity.
The concrete grade of M35 was produced in the batching
plant installed on Guwahati side as well as at the crushing
plant on Amingaon side was transported by transit mixers.
In the river, transit mixers were mounted on the barges and
concrete placement (Fig. 9) was done either by pumping
Fig. 10: Fabrication, Slipping & Floating of Caissons
At depths more than 5.0 m, particularly for foundations P9
to P15 the bottom section of steel caisson (cofferdam) was
constructed in a fabrication yard (Fig. 14), brought to the
edge of the river on a rail track and slipped into river via a
judiciously designed tilting slipway and floated to the location.
The floating caissons were designed to achieve the desired
stability and the draught requirement during floatation. Then
the caisson was towed to the location by tugs and held in
position by tethering arrangement for concreting.
Once in position, the caisson was lowered by filling up the
annular space between the double wall with water to sink
and embed to the riverbed. Further the space was filled
Fig. 9: Concrete Transportation, Placement & Bottom
up with concrete due to which the sinking progressed.
Pluggin by Tremie.
As the caisson sank due to concreting of steining in lifts,
or by cranes. Once the founding levels were reached, the further formwork sections were added and the process
bottom plugging was completed using tremies followed continued.
4. SUBSTRUCTURE
The piers were hollow tapering from the top of well cap
with the size 14m x 7m to the bottom of pier cap to the
size of 12m x 5m.
In the direction of the water flow on both ends the circular
ease waters of radius 3.5m at bottom tapering to 2.5m at
top have been provided in piers with in the above size. The
thickness of hollow piers were 1.0m uniform from top to
bottom.
In new Saraighat bridge STUs were very effectively used supports . There are 3 Nos. of STU’s installed in each pier
(Fig14). In this bridge, first time STUs have been adopted having max. capacity of load 4000 kn. In total 30 Nos. of
in such a large magnitude perhaps in India. The total STU has been installed on all piers except central Pier of
length of the main bridge of 1.50 km is conceptualized by the bridge which has fixed bearing. The approx. weight
a single girder between piers P6 to P18 having 12 spans of STU is around 3 MT and it is kept in position with the
(2*105+2*150+4*129.948). The expansion provision help of 12 Nos. vertical bolt of dia. 40 mm and grade 12.9,
at P6 & P18 locations being 450 mm, the construction the capacity of bolt is 60T. The STU’s are fixed to the pier
was done by cast in situ balanced cantilever construction cap with 10 Nos. of horizontal bolt of length 9.2 meter on
method. Shock Transmission Units (STU) are provided either side of base plate fixed on the vertical side of the
to distribute the horizontal seismic forces among the pier caps.
Fig. 15: Bearing Layout within Bridge System & their Forces, Translation and Rotation
The central pier P12 is equipped with fixed and the river sides by penultimate spans P7-P8 & P17-P16 of
longitudinally guided bearings without STUs, while the 150m lengths each. In the river portion there are 8 spans
other piers are provided with 3 numbers STUs of 4.5 MN of 122.948 m each. The cross section for both spans (L)
capacity and 2 numbers longitudinally guided bearings. 150 m and 122.948 m varied from root depth (h) of 8.0 m
As the structure is idealized to originate expansion and to mid span depth (t) of 3.5 m (Fig 16 ).
contraction from pier P12, on either side as the piers are moving
outwardly, longitudinal movement absorption capacity of
STUs as well as bearing keeps on increasing as can be seen
from the Fig 15.In the absence of STUs, the central pier
would have to be catered for approximately 80 MN instead
of 6.3 MN and the expansion provision requirement at P6
and P18 locations would have been unmanageable. Perhaps
the largest single girder bridge of 1.5 Km in India would not
have been possible without the provision of STUs.
5. SUPERSTRUCTURE
5.1 Design Aspects
As has been depicted in the Fig 5 the bridge is a continuous
bridge from P6 to P18 where the abutment spans P6-P7
& P17-P18 are 105m in length that are flanked towards Fig. 16: Cross Sectional Details of Superstructure
The charts of parametric studies conducted by José Diogo on lower side (2.28) compared to that of recommended
Honórioas as a part of master thesis titled Conceptual guidelines and practice for both 150 m and 123 m
design of long-span cantilever constructed concrete spans. In fact one of the challenges to designer was
bridges is produced in Fig 16. to mate 150 m penultimate spans with the adjacent
The ratio h/t values remain an average 3 to 4.2 for 123 m span and adhering to recommended parametric
various span lengths as per the conventional design dimensioning according to relationships depicted in
recommendations. In Brahmaputra bridge the same is Fig 17.
• Deflections caused during cantilever construction • Deformations of the continuous system after
• Deformation of cantilever segment before closure closure at midspans, the stressing of continuity
due to dead load of cantilever segments, traveler tendons and placement of superimposed dead
and closure segment. load
to undergo additional deformations for the following within 65 cum embedded with steel reinforcement of 15 t.
reasons:
i. Residual plastic deformation due to self-weight
and cantilever prestressing,
ii. Residual loss of prestress in cantilever tendons
iii. Continuity prestress, including its losses,
iv. Removal of cantilever gantry (which is a reverse
loading on continuous structure),
v. Release of temporary bearing restraints if any
(which too is a reverse loading on continuous
structure),
vi. Superimposed dead load,
vii. Residual foundation settlement and column
deformation occurring after closure – if any. Fig. 20: Planned Movement of Gantries
The calculation of items (2) to (7) above is made for final Depending upon the sequence of construction, 5 numbers
continuous system. Item (1) is calculated for cantilevers, of form travellers were deployed for this project. The
taking in to account the redistribution of moment due to form travellers’ movement (Fig. 20) were planned
change of system. optimally to suit sequence of construction and speedy
5.2 Construction Aspects expedition of the project.
The entire superstructure was realised by cast in situ The each form traveller (Fig. 21) was indigenously
balanced cantilever method of construction (Fig18) designed and manufactured at site itself and finally load
tested before being put in to use. The travellers were
designed for the handling load of 160 t, live load of 360kg/
m^2 and self-weight of 80 t acting at 1.625 m eccentricity
from the edge of last cast segment.
1)
Gantry Unlocking : 1 Day When measured deflections were compared to the
predetermined ones, further corrections were to be introduced
2)
Gantry Movement : 0.5 Day
in consideration of circumstances like the following:
3)
Gantry Locking : 1 Day
4)
Gantry Alignment : 0.5 Day • Temperature difference due to solar radiation, heat
5)
Reinforcement fixing, of hydration, etc,
binding and fixing of shuttering : 5 Days • Any particular thermo-hygrometric condition e.g.
high humidity under bridge deck which passes at
6)
Cable Profiling : 1 Day
low height over a water surface,
7)
Stopper Fixing/checking : 1 Day • Settlement / rotation of foundation, and
8)
Concreting : 1 Day • Any additional load on the bridge, e.g. construction
9)
Cable threading/waiting period load, furnishing, etc.
of concrete for achieving 70% • The difference in the theoretical and actual creep
strength for post tensioning. : 5 Days and shrinkage losses.
Total = 16 days. During the cantilever operation, the cantilever is the system
During the construction as the cantilever progression takes in constant evolution as such no fixed level is available.
place, the deck had to be stabilised against the overturning The ‘difference’ between segment joints was not only in
and also had to be restrained against translation as most of level but also in slope.
the piers were supported on longitudinally guided POT/
PTFE bearings.
The 14 numbers of 19K15 stabilising (Fig. 23) cables were
anchored to pier cap from bottom of pier table in addition
to 4 numbers of sand jacks. The translation or sliding of
the deck during construction was restrained by freezing
the bearings through end stoppers anchored by PT bars.
In order to be able to follow the evolution of cantilever
deflections towards the goal as indicated above in the camber Fig. 24: Elements for Geometry Control of Cantilever
correction section, two survey points were placed in the top Arm During Construction
slab concrete of each new segment, one over the axis of each
The pre-pour survey check served to fine-tune the traveller
web, say 100 mm behind the front edge of the segment. The position in respect of the already built part of the cantilever
level of each point represented the level of segment next to the arm. The main concern was to set the traveller to the right
segment joint in subsequent survey checks. The longitudinal projection in respect of the previous segment. At this time
profile constituted by the points would be a polygon whose the deflection of the traveller proper had to be introduced
angles determine the final road profile. as an additional camber.
The post pour survey check served to determine the as- • Continuous superstructure of Single PSC Box
built shape of the longitudinal profile in respect of the Girder of 1494 m in length having an finger type
desired profile at that step, in particular the position of the expansion joints at the ends of capacity 500mm
newly poured segment with respect to the previous one. with overall deck width of 13.875.
• Successful completion of shoring to maintain stability
of approach road of existing Saraighat Bridge.
• The use of STUs in large magnitude for the first
time in the country. Perhaps the adoption of the
above STUs helped in withstanding earthquake
on 25th April’ 2015 in Nepal & North Eastern
part of India on 7.3 in Richter Scale. This Bridge
structure under construction sustained this massive
earthquake without any damage.
• Indigenously designed, manufactured and load
tested 5 numbers of gantries in use at a time.
• Specially designed stabilizing and bearing freezing
Fig. 25: New Saraighat bridge during & after construction arrangement for peculiar bearing layout provided
In order to achieve the desired longitudinal Deck-profile, with in bridge system.
the geometry control should focus on the difference of slope • Special attention to pre camber monitoring during
as-built between subsequent segments; this could be done superstructure construction.
graphically e.g. by drawing the longitudinal profile made
7. REFERENCES
up by the bolts in each web line. Whenever the discrepancy
was detected between the desired curve and as built curve, i. José Diogo Honório, Conceptual design of long-span
it had to be corrected over a few following segments. cantilever constructed concrete bridges, TRITA-
BKN. Master thesis 254, Structural Design & Bridges
6. CONCLUSIONS
2007 ISSN 1103-4297, ISRN KTH/BKN/EX-254-SE.
Bridging the mighty river Brahmaputra is one of the major ii. V N Heggade, Bearings & their configurations with
challenges for bridge engineers and could be done only by in bridge system, The bridge and Structural Engineer,
an experienced and techno savvy bridge builder. Vol 43/Number 4/December 2013, pp 23-35.
Some of the achievements while overcoming the challenges iii. Dr. V. K. Raina, Avinash Y. Mahendrakar, Amrendra
were : N. Singh, Philosophy of CAMBER-CORRECTION
• Successful completion of 11 numbers of Double to obtain correct deck-profile in cantilever
D type Well Foundations with 57m avg. depth construction…. Bhramaputra Bridge at Guwahati,
without any major problems of tilt & shift in the India, ING-IABSE seminar Mysore 2014 on Elevated
river Brahmaputra. transport corridors. Pp 160-169.
Abstract
Subgrade is an important layer of a pavement which provides the support to the pavement and possesses the sufficient
stability under adverse traffic and loading conditions. For safe and cost effective construction of pavement, the subgrade
should be constructed with a suitable filling material that may be locally available. The soil found in regions of Bihar is
mainly of cohesive in nature and have low strength. Therefore, it is required to go for stabilization using locally available
materials. An attempt has been taken to consider the use of Ganga sand as a stabilizer to existing soil. In this paper laboratory
investigations have been carried out to evaluate the properties of individual soils and their mix. The experimental results
shows that Atterberg’s limits decreases, MDD and CBR initially increases and then decreases with addition of Ganga sand
in increasing proportion. Maximum socked CBR has been found at optimum proportion of 40% soil and 60% Ganga sand.
Whereas, maximum UCS have been found at optimum proportion of 70% soil and 30% Ganga sand. Finally overall thickness
of the pavement has been computed and compared while considering pure soil as well as at the optimum proportion and
found thirty percent of saving in the thickness.
mixing and intercalation layers of sand. It can be seen that 1.1 Need for Utilization of Ganga Sand
the addition of sand is capable of reducing the swelling
There are many road development programs are going
action. Kollaros G., Athanasopoulou A.(2016) carried
on related to road development in our country such as
out an experimental program to highlight the physical
PMGSY, NHDP etc. Generally for rural roads there
mechanisms of stabilization of an expansive soil by adding
are directive to use locally available materials for road
an inert material (sand). The findings of the laboratory
construction so that the transportation cost can be
testing procedures presented substantial improvement in
reduced. The Ganga sand is locally available in states
strength with the addition of sand percentages up to 60%
of Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and West Bengal
by weight of soil, as well a noticeable alteration in the
and it may also prove a good modifier. Therefore, as
moisture-density relation. Kumar Amrendra et al (2014)
locally available material for road construction in these
studied the effect of mixing different proportions of foundry
states the Ganga sand can be a very good alternative for
sand, fly ash and tile waste with clayey soil on compaction
reducing required thickness of pavement, quantity of
and California bearing ratio. The highest value of maximum
materials required and cost of construction. Apart from
dry density was achieved for clay-foundry sand-fly ash-
this, there are many other problems related to silting
tile waste mix of 54:36:10:2.25. The California bearing
of sediment in Ganga River such as meandering of the
ratio value of clayey soil improved significantly i.e. from
river, decreasing the discharge capacity, decreases in
2.43% to 7.35% with addition of foundry sand , fly ash
required effective depth for water transport and many
and tile waste in appropriate proportion.Likhitha. H et al
flood related problems. By utilizing the river Ganga
(2018) investigated the improvements in the properties of
sand these problems can also be minimized up to some
expansive soils, as road subgrade stabilized with cement,
extent. Therefore, the use of Ganga sand in subgrade
and M-sand (manufactured sand) in varying percentages.
construction of the roads is not only beneficial for road
The result shows that the stability of the Black cotton soil
construction but also for the river Ganga.
can be increased by making use of the stabilizers such as
cement and M-sand. Prasad C. R. V., Sharma R. K. (2014) 2. Scope and objective
assessed the effectiveness of clayey soil blended with Beas
In this paper, different engineering properties of the soil
sand and fly ash for soil stabilization. The results show
and the river Ganga sand have been studied. An attempt
substantial improvement in compaction and California
was made to study how the river Ganga sand may be
bearing ratio of composite containing clay, sand and fly
effectively utilized in combination with the soil to get
ash (70: 30: 10).Roy Tapas Kumar (2013) used of various
an improved soil material which may be used in road
types of sand with varying proportions ranging from 5%
construction. The objectives of the study are:
to 15% as admixture to cohesive soil and to evaluate their
different properties e.g. plastic properties, compaction i. To investigate the engineering properties of soil to
properties and strength properties in terms CBR of the be used as subgrade material and the river Ganga
mixtures. Results shows the better improvement in the sand.
compaction characteristics as well as in the CBR for ii. To investigate the engineering properties of soil
addition of fine sand up to 15% with the soil and identified mixed with the river Ganga sand in different
as cost effective mix proportion for the construction of proportions (soil: Ganga sand:: 90:10, 80:20,
70:30, 60:40, 50:50, 40:60, 30:70).
subgrade of flexible pavement. Sharma Ravi Kumar,
Kumar Amrendra (2013) showed with addition of foundry iii. To work out the most appropriate proportion of
sand and fly ash to clayey soil, its strength and compaction the soil and the Ganga sand mixes on the basis of
maximum MDD and CBR value.
characteristics are improved.
iv. To compare the required thickness of the pavement
Many researchers have been investigated the characteristics for unmodified soil and for most appropriate
of cohesive soil in addition of various sands along with proportion of the Soil-Ganga sand mixes.
other additives. Few papers are found where only various
3. ENGINEERING PROPERTIES OF THE
types of sand are used to stabilize the soil. However,
MATERIALS USED
Soil stabilization using Ganga sand for subgrade
characterization is not found. This paper deals with the The materials used in this study were locally available
utilization of Ganga sand in the stabilization of subgrade soil and the Ganga sand. The river Ganga sand is obtained
soil. A characteristic of soil was investigated using without from the river Ganga near NIT Patna campus. According
and with Ganga sand in different proportions and analysis to Indian standard soil classification system the soil was
was made for its suitability. classified as low plastic clay (CL) and the Ganga sand
was classified as poorly graded sand (SP). The Grain size shown in Fig. 1. The engineering properties of the soil and
distribution curves for the soil and the Ganga sand are the Ganga sand are shown in the Table-1.
The CBR tests for soil, Ganga sand and their composites The unconfined compressive strengths of the soil, Ganga
were carried out as per IS: 2720)- 1987 (Part-16) in both sand and their composites were determined as per IS: 2720
soaked and unsoaked conditions to evaluate their load (Part 10)-1991. The variation in unconfined compressive
bearing capacities. The unsoaked CBR characteristics are strength of Soil-Ganga sand the mix is shown in the
shown in the Fig. 6 and soaked CBR characteristics are Fig.8.
shown in the Fig. 7.
Fig. 6, shows that the variation in soaked CBR. It is
observed that on increasing the proportion of the Ganga
sand and decreasing the proportion of the soil in the mix, the
soaked CBR increases. Similar trend is also found by (Ali
Firat Cabalar and Waleed Sulaiman Mustafa, 2015).The
increase in soaked CBR is due to increase in compaction
and the strength of the Ganga sand. The soaked CBR
is maximum for the mix containing 40% soil and 60%
Ganga sand and is equal to 18.78%. On further increasing
the Ganga sand content, the soaked CBR decreases as the
compaction of the Soil- Ganga sand decreases. Fig. 8: Variation in UCS of Soil-Ganga sand Composites
From the Fig. 8 it is obtained that the UCS of the
pure soil is 1.293 kg/cm2 .On replacing the soil with
the Ganga sand, initially the compaction of the mix
increases and the cohesion decreases. But initially the
UCS value increases due to the increase in compaction
is predominant. Therefore, on increasing the Ganga sand
content, initially the unconfined compressive strength
of the mix increases and it is maximum for the mix
containing 70% soil and 30% Ganga sand. On further
Figure 6: Variation in Soaked CBR of Soil-Ganga sand
increasing the proportion of the Ganga sand, the UCS of
Composites
the soil Ganga sand composite goes on decreasing. This
Fig. 7, shows that the variation in unsoaked CBR. It is is due to decrease in cohesion. As per Aravind Pedarla
observed that on increasing the proportion of the Ganga sand et al (2015), UCS values increases with increase of sand
and decreasing the proportion of the soil in the mix, initially content whereas as per Ali Firat Cabalar and Waleed
the unsoaked CBR increases. This may be due to increase in Sulaiman Mustafa (2015), UCS values decreases with
compaction and the strength of the Ganga sand. The unsoaked increase of sand content in clay.
CBR is highest for the mix containing 40% soil and 60%
4.4 Thickness Implications
Ganga sand and is equal to 26.37%. On further increasing
Ganga sand content, the unsoaked CBR decreases as the The soaked CBR of pure soil was 2.33 % and the maximum
compaction of the Soil and Ganga sand mix decreases. soaked CBR of the Soil-Ganga sand composite was 18.78%
for the composite having 40% soil and 60% Ganga sand.
The code (IRC:37-2012) has maximum limit for soaked
CBR as 15%. Therefore the thickness of the pavement
was evaluated by taking a maximum value of CBR of
soil-Ganga sand composite as 15%. Using IRC:37-2012
guidelines (Plate-8), the design thickness of pavement was
evaluated corresponding to 2, 5, 10, 20, 30, 50,100,150
msa (million standard axle) for both the pure soil and the
stabilized soil-Ganga sand composite. The comparison of
Fig. 7: Variation in Unsoaked CBR of the Soil-Ganga the thickness required for soil and the optimum soil-Ganga
sand Composites sand composite is shown in the Fig. 9.
3 IRC:86-2018 Geometric Design Standards for Urban Roads and Streets 600.00 30.00
(First Revision)
8 IRC:SP:63-2018 Guidelines for the Use of Interlocking Concrete Block 500.00 30.00
Pavement (First Revision)
14 IRC:SP:121-2018 Guidelines for Use of Iron, Steel and Copper Slag in 600.00 30.00
Construction of Rural Roads
Copies of these publications can be obtained from IRC Office against cash payment. For more details please contact
Sale Section of IRC: + 91 11 2338 7759 and E-mail: ircsale1934@gmail.com
S S Joshi 1
Abstract
The curing of cement concrete plays a vital role in assisting gaining strength. But, at Project Site it is often relegated to
back seat while often and invariably by everyone expressed concern for. In this Technical paper while on one hand the
significance of ‘Curing’ of Cement concrete has been brought to the fore, a mechanism comprising of possible measures to
ensure adherence to this important activity without requiring much persuasion, has also been suggested.
Tech Director & Team Leader, URS Scott Wilson India Private Limited, Email: ssjoshi70@rediffmail.com
1
that if during this stage, the evaporation rate of bleed 5. Significance of Concrete Curing
water is more than the rising water from within concrete It is well known to all, the importance of timely curing of
mass then shrinkage (Plastic shrinkage) is manifested. cement concrete. Strength in general goes southward in
It is here that the function of curing comes into play by absence of curing. At Project site, this fact has been verified/
maintaining the concrete surface from drying out and thus determined through/ by conducting tests on samples and
avoid plastic shrinkage. observing the compressive strength of cement concrete of
Between initial set and final set intermediate curing would various grades kept in different condition/ situation. The
be needed if the finishing is complete prior to final set. relation of degree of curing and corresponding impact
This may be in the form of barrier which prevents the loss on compressive strength noted/recorded and analyzed as
of moisture from the concrete surface e.g. covering the mentioned hereunder:
concrete surfaces with plastic sheet, water proof papers, 6. Experiment of testing (Compressive
etc. strength of concrete) done at
After final set, meticulous curing will have to be done Project site
as per procedure selected e.g. water curing, ponding, i. Apparatus/Appliances:-
wet covering, impermeable membrane curing, curing
●● Cube moulds of 150mm x 150mm x 150mm.
compound, etc.
●● CTM (– 2000 kN capacity)
4. CURING: - Types of Concrete Curing
ii. Material:-
a. Water Curing
●● Cement: OPC-53 grade
●● By Ponding ●● Aggregate: Source from Nangal, Rajasthan
●● Sprinkling, fogging & mist curing
●● Fine Aggregate: Source from Nangal, Rajsthan
●● Wet Covering
●● Curing compound: Source from Shalicure–
b. Impermeable membrane curing (Aluminum based)
●● Form work iii. M
ix design summary of M-15,M-20,M-25,M-30,M-
●● Plastic Sheeting 35,M-40,M-45 (Summary of material and mix design,
c. Membrane Curing/ Curing compound vide Table-1)
4.1 Caveat for Membrane curing Casting of Concrete Cubes: 150mmx150mmx150mm
cubes were cast with following concrete grades:
For concrete with low w/c ratio, the use of curing
compounds may not be suitable for curing. When hydration a. M-15 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
takes place, the relative humidity of interior concrete b. M-20 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
drops leading to self drying of concrete. Under such
c. M-25 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
circumstances, wet curing provides an external source
of water to replenish the water utilized in the hydration d. M-30 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
process. Curing compounds may also prevent the bond e. M-35 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
between the hardened and the freshly placed concrete f. M-40 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
overlay e.g. curing compounds should not be applied to two
lifts pavement construction. Similarly, curing compound g. M-45 (3 sets of 6 cubes each)
should not be applied to concrete surface which will be Now, concrete cubes, so cast-have been put under following
receiving plasters, decorative paints, etc. as it affects the different degree of curing/ curing condition/ situation:
adhesion.
i. Concrete cubes kept in site water tank @ (27±2)
d. Steam curing oC (normal water curing)
At times, we need to go in for steam curing to get the early ii. oncrete cubes were applied with curing
C
strength of concrete, etc. compound and kept in normal condition
iii. Concrete cubes were kept under direct Sun The ambient temperature and humidity also recorded.
Casting and testing of samples have been done from
March 14 to April 14. When temperature and humidity
range was “20.20C to 43.00C” and “20.00% to 82.00%
respectively.
Testing of concrete cubes:
Concrete cubes were tested for its compressive strength
in calibrated CTM machine (vide, Fig.1) for ‘7’days and
‘28’days. Comparison of average compressive strength
(average of 6 cubes test results) vis-à-vis, different
condition/ situation are tabulated in Table-2 & Table-3 for
M-45, M-40, M-35, M-30, M-25, M-20 & M-15 grades of
Fig. 1: Testing of Concrete Cube cement concrete.
Table-1
CONCRETE MIX DESIGN DATA
Admixture
Coarse Aggregate
(Kg/Cum)
Cement OPC 53 Fine Aggregate (kg/Cum)
Concrete Source:-Kunal
Grade (kg/Cum) Source:- Nangal
Conchem ( Kuna
Stone Quary
Plast Pc-100) Water (Kg/
Cum)
Crushed
River
Sand
Content Sand 20
Grade Type (Gwalior 10 mm Qty.
(kg/cum) (Banash mm
Stone
River)
Quarry)
M15 300 436 436 548 548 2.55 182
Table-2
Compressive Strength of Cement Concrete in Different Condition of Curing
Minimum Maximum
Temperature Ranging during the month 20.20c 43.0 0c
Humidity Ranging during the month 20.00% 82.00%
Average 7 days Compressive Strength of Cement Concrete in Different Condition of Curing
systematic variation and cannot be termed as conclusive). Contractors/ Concessionaires are primarily concerned with
However, one thing is certain that the absence of curing progress (pouring of concrete) only and at every inspection/
causes the drop in strength and in our experiment the drop visit, the inadequate curing is often the point of discussion
in compressive strength of 28 days is seen to the extent and concern of all Project Site. Even putting checklist in
of 34% when no curing is done i.e. under direct Sun Vs the process/ system towards curing activity does not seem
Water curing @ (27±2)oC. to yield the desired result. There has been growing need to
Thus, while all possible effort has been made to adhere address the issue of curing compliance at site.
to maintain the uniform parameter while casting cubes, 8. Mechanism to ensure adherence
curing and testing, yet the utmost control available in
R&D labs was not possible at Project Site and statistical 8.1 To meet this perennial challenge it is considered to
limitation is also certainly a factor which may have further bring in a mechanism in the system itself which shall be
influenced the quality of result. capable of causing Contractor/ Concessionaire to doubly
ensure the curing of cement concrete at Project site.
It is also seen that if curing compound is properly used then
it also works and the Compressive strength is seen less It is a proven and time tested proposition to put in place a
than that with normal water curing by 3.94% to 13.57% punitive and deterrent measure against non observance of
(Hence generally water curing is also recommended to any requisite measure and thereby ensuring compliance. In
be supplemented over curing with Curing compound for EPC/ BOQ contract, it is worthwhile to insert/ introduce
important structures). a ‘sub-item’ of curing activity alongside concrete items as
As is evident in all graphs vide Fig 3 that the compressive a part component of concrete work. While, during bidding
strength in 28 days significantly (upto 34%) drops down the full Rate of concrete is required to be quoted by the
due to inadequate/absence of curing, vis-à-vis standard Contractor/ Bidders then its bifurcation, as under may
water curing. apportion the rate/ amount of corresponding curing/m3 of
concrete by a predetermined ratio. (The apportionment of
7. Curing at Project Site curing component may be put a bit more than maximum
It is generally observed that the curing at Project Site is often drop of 28 days strength % i.e. more than 34%, say 40%
one of the items which is mostly neglected. Majority of for all grades of cement concrete in the item itself)
For Example:
Item Quantity Total Rate INR Apportionment of rate Amount
INR INR
Concrete 60%
60,000/- 6,00,000/-
P/L RCC-M40 Total rate 100m3 10,000/-
Concrete 40% 40,000/- 4,00,000/-
Here, care has been taken to apportion disproportionately component respectively. (In Contract Agreement/ CA,
high rate towards curing component, e.g. if for concrete such provision may be included for the purpose of
(M-40) total Bid rate is @ INR 10,000/m3 then concrete ensuring enforcement of curing and for enforcement of
and curing shall be assigned say 60% and 40% of total punitive measures. Thus, monetary component of curing
rate in priced BOQ item itself. The bidder while bidding per cubic meter of concrete work shall be readily available
shall put total rate and also bifurcated rate as per already for enforcement).
fixed apportionment mentioned under respective item. No However, in the event of contractor’s inability or willful
contractor shall ever take a chance to neglect curing for non compliance, curing may be got done at his risk and
fear of losing disproportionately high sum. cost which may be easily got arranged with the kind of
In case of projects under PPP mode (any variants of PPP disproportionately high and lucrative rate associated with
mode, viz, BOT, DBFOT, etc.) the identical approach may the same. (Such provision of getting work done at the risk
be adopted. Applicable rate of concrete of any specified and cost, in the event of non compliance by the Contractor,
grade may be computed by means of applicable SOR and must also be incorporated in the Contract Agreement/ CA
updated to the reference year. Now further apportionment for EPC/ PPP works).
may be done 60% and 40% towards concrete and curing Thus, the ultimate aim of curing compliance, which is a
significant component imparting strength to the structure absence of it is immense. Generally at Project site it is
and other attributes, may be ensured to the great possible not appreciated to the extent it deserves and often on
extent. routine basis becomes a contentious issue in relation to its
Stringent Punitive measure for habitual defaulter (curing) implementation, amongst Client/ Consultant and
Contractor/ Concessionaire.
There may be stringent deterrent provision included
to be applied for the habitual delinquent Contractor/ In order to doubly ensure ‘curing’ at site it is considered
Concessionaire who is in habit of regularly violating, the prudent to tilt the balance a bit disproportionately on
concrete curing e.g. if in a month time the Contractor/ higher side towards curing by apportioning about ‘40%’
Concessionaire is found to be a defaulter on this count for cost component of concrete work. It looks quite justified
three times the recommendation for debarring in Projects in doing so as absence/ inadequate curing impairs the
involving structure works may be made to the competent compressive strength (and other associated strength)
Authority by the supervision Consultant/ IE. (Such permanently and irreversibly. Merely, imposing normal
enforcement provision must be incorporated in the terms damages by charging proportionate amount may not serve
of contract/ CA). the very purpose of ensuring Curing compliance at site. And
hence, by injecting punitive element, its apportionment is
8.2 Alternative to Curing hiked and in this paper a reasonable apportionment of 40%
R&D (Research & development wings) must also be considered to meet the objective. Delinquent and habitual
assigned a task to address this issue of curing by resorting defaulters (Contractors/ Concessionaire) may be debarred
to such alternative mechanism which is better and easier for bidding works/ Projects involving major structures for
in implementation. For example, we know that the need certain periods. So, also if our Scientist fraternity, in near
of curing of cement concrete is to effect/ compensate the future comes out with a magic economic additive solution
loss of moisture due to increase in temperature which is to be mixed during concrete mixing to dispense with the
attributed to exothermic reaction. If by some means, the need of curing itself as cited in 9(B) then it will be a great
reaction is allowed to happen but without exothermic day for all Stakeholders.
attributes by adding/ including certain additives in the
The existing punitive measure as mentioned in MoSRT&H
concrete mix then the whole “Curing” issue can be resolved
for acceptable sub standard Concrete work does not cover
by avoiding the need for “CURING “itself. This will be
Curing Component as mentioned below vide section 1700
the best possible redressal means of present day absence
of MoSRT&H:-
of curing menace, provided it is not cost prohibitive.
The discount to be offered for acceptable substandard
9. Conclusion
work, as defined in section 1700 (Sub-Section 1718-Rate)
Within restraint of sample size, concrete cubes cast and of MoSRT&H is as under
tested at Project site invariably reveals that role of “curing”
(Design Strength-Observed Strength)
of concrete is quite significant in developing compressive
strength (and hence other associated strength) of cement Reduction in Rate =
concrete. The indicative cube strength within limitation Design Strength
of sample size, Project site limitation and prevailing The observed strength is as per concrete cube strength,
temperature & humidity it is seen that the compressive which is cast during construction and normally kept in
strength drops to 34% (maximum) in 28 days under direct Curing tank. Thus, the reduction in strength, if any, does
Sun vis-à-vis normal water curing imparted by immersing not include Curing component, but improper material,
in a water tank which speaks volumes about the role of mixing, workmanship.
curing.
References
Similarly with curing compound also the concrete attains
i. IS: 10262-2009
the required strength though the compressive strength
obtained is a bit less (86.43% to 96.06%) than that with ii. IS: 516-1959
conventional water curing (In the instant case cube iii. Article on significance of Concrete Curing by Mr. SB
strength immersed in water tank). Thus, if water is easily Kulkarni & Mr. Clinton Pereira, Dy. Manager (Tech.)-
available then water curing is the best option. UltraTech
Though, the arrangement required to ensure curing at iv. Specifications for Road And Bridge Work (5th Version)
site does cost very little but the strength reduction in of MoRT&H
!
!/
0
#
/
1#
2
3#4 5 !6 7 5 8 95 !6
5
#
!6
:
1 4
4
#5 ;; 5
+7 <
# = >
25
#
B
;5
?. @@A@)@$$
#4
2
1
4
1 2
BC 5
# !
94
!
"
#
$$%%$ &
'()%$"")$)%%% *+,' -
.
.
.
Delhi Postal Registration No dl-sw-17/4194/19-21
Delhi Postal
under Registration No
‘u’ Number DL-SW-17/4194/16-18
u(sw)-12/2019-2021
UNDER
At Lodi 'U' NUMBER
Road, PSO on dated 28-29.03.2019 U(SW)-12/2016-2018
licence to post
At Lodi Road, PSONewspaper
on dated 28-29.01.2017 LICENCE TO POST
ISSN 0376-7256
Newspaper Regd No. 25597/73
Regd. No. 25597/73 without prepayment
WITHOUT
published on PREPAYMENT
22 MARCH, 2019
DL-SW-17/4194/16-18
APRIL, 2019
Indian Highways Advance Month, APRIL, 2019
INDIAN HIGHWAYS PUBLISHED ON 27 JANUARY 2017
`20/-
FEBRUARY 2017
About SAICPL
SMART INNOVATIVE INFRA SOLUTIONS - WORKING TOWARDS BETTER TOMORROW
(An ISO 9001-2008 Certified Company)
Indian Highways
SA Infrastructure Consultants Pvt. Ltd along with its subsidiary UPHAM International Corporation and QUEST Engineers &
Consultants are focused on delivering multi-disciplinary infra projects with innovative ideas of International Standards. The
Group forms an ambious consortium of consultancy firms with commitment to provide high quality specialized consultation
into the field of Highways, Structures and Design.
Volume : 47 Number : 4 Total Pages : 60
Sectors
Services
SA Infrastructure synchronizes every aspect of engineering with imbibed commitment to deliver high quality infrastructure and development consultation
that glorifies a new world. We have successfully carried out numerous consultancy projects in Civil infrastructure development, transportation, primary &
secondary highway networks, Project Management under BOT/Annuity Model, Resource Management, Social aspects including poverty alleviation and
Institutional support.
Bridges : Including VUP, Flyovers, rehabilitation, ROB and Inspection Report Some of the Major Projects
and Conditional Survey.
Corporate Address : 1101, 11th Floor, Tower A-II, Ansal Corporate Park, Sector 142, Noida - 201 301, Uttar Pradesh, INDIA A view of Kadthal-Armoor NH Project in Andhra Pradesh
Tel : +91-120-6148000 / Fax : +91-120-6148090 www.sainfra.com Email : info@sainfra.com
Edited and Published by Shri S.S.Nahar, Secretary General, Indian Roads Congress, IRC HQ, Sector-6, R.K.Puram, Kama Koti Marg, New Delhi - 110 022.
Printed by Shri S.S.Nahar
Edited on behalf by
and Published of the
ShriIndian
S.K. Roads Congress
Nirmal, at M/s.
Secretary I G Printers
General, IndianPvtRoads
Ltd., 104, DSIDC Complex,
Congress, IRC HQ,Okhla Industrial
Sector-6, R.K.Area, Phase-I, New
Puram,
Delhi - 110 020. Kama Koti Marg, New Delhi - 110 022. Printed by Shri S.K. Nirmal on behalf of the Indian Roads Congress
at M/s. Aravali Printers & Publishers Pvt. Ltd. https://www.irc.nic.in