Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ennWell
AEI
Asian Energy
INFRASTRUCTURE
September 2000
R e a p in g t h e f r u its
o f r e fo r m
PO W ER -G EN A s ia : R e s t r u c t u r in g E G AT
C E P SI: N a p o c o r ’s c h a l l e n g e
AEI
A s i a n E n e r g y
Contents
R egu lars
TalkBack 3
News & Views 7
Regulatory Review 15
Equipment 68
S p e cia l D ep a rtm en ts
Challenges for tomorrow: CEPSI, Manila 17
EGAT restructuring: POWER-GEN Asia, Bangkok 19
Chinese language feature: Manjung Moves on 52
F ea tu res
Regional Focus 25
Southeast Asia: new market opportunities.
Market Restructuring 33 Project Focus 58
Post-crisis Asia: time for reform? A E i assesses the Captive generation cuts costs. The Amarvilas Oberoi
incentives to implement reform. Hotel in Agra, India, is close to completion. A concern of the
hotel was how to ensure reliable electricity and steam supply.
Utility IT 39 Fuel Focus 64
Stay informed: Asian energy producers and distributors In for the long haul? Asia’sfinancial crisis, high costs and
will face increased demands for information reporting. inflexibility has slowed the growth of the liquefied natural gas
A E i looks at lessons that can be learned from Sweden. trade. But production is expanding, and competition among
sellers with it. How will the market for this highly politicized
fuel shape up as market power shifts in favour of electricity
Transmission & Distribution 43 generators and other buyers?
The “1-Shape”project: a logistical challenge. A E i looks
at a project for the construction of 15 new substations for
the Provincial Electricity Authority of Thailand. N e w s in Brief
SembCorp buys into Australia Page 7
TNB sells Port Dickson units to Indonesia Page 9
IPP Projects 46 China gas moves attracts oil majors Page 11
Manjung moves on. Despite an interruption caused by the
More Indian power delays Page 13
Asian crisis, Malaysia’s Manjung project is back on track.
PennWell Global Energy Group Asian Sales Circulation Manager This is a quarterly supplement to Power Engineering International, ISSN 1069-4994, which
is published monthly by PennWell Global Energy Group, PennWell House, Upshire,
PennWell House, Matt Bennett Stacy Baker Essex EN9 3SR, United Kingdom. Tel: +441992 656 600. Fax: +44 1992 656 700.
Horseshoe Hill, Upshire, mattb@singnet.com.sg
Chairman ©Copyright 2000 by PennWell Corporation, 1421 S. Sheridan Rd., Tulsa, OK 74112. All
Essex EN9 3SR, US Sales Frank T. Lauinger rights reserved. Officers of PennWell Publishing Co. are: Frank T. Lauinger, Chairman;
United Kingdom. Annette Pieniazek Bob Biolchini, President and Chief Executive Officer; Jim Pfister, President and Chief
Phone: +44 1992 656 600 President/CEO Operating Officer; Tom Stone, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer;
Design & Production Director Bob Biolchini W. Stephen Zimmerman, Vice President.
Fax: +44 1992 656 700
Martin King Power Engineering International, editorial offices are at: PennWell House, Upshire,
W orldwide Web: President/COO Essex EN9 3SR, United Kingdom. Tel: +44 1992 656 600. Fax: +44 1992 656 700.
martink@pennwell.com James Pfister
http://www.power-eng-intl.com
Subscriptions/circulation and reader enquiry office: Power Engineering International,
Senior Designer Senior Vice President/CFO PennWell Global Energy Group, 1421 S. Sheridan Rd., Tulsa, OK 74112. Paid annual
Managing Editor & Neal Honney Tom Stone subscription rates: Worldwide $170, E.U. $146, U.S.A./Canada $140, United Kingdom
Associate Publisher $114. Single or back copies: Worldwide $16, U.S.$10.
Designer Vice President/Corporate Services
Junior Isles Karl Weber U.S.A. circulation only: Power Engineering International, 'PERIODICALS POSTAGE
W. Steve Zimmerman PAID AT RAHWAY NJ". Subscription price is $140 Periodicals Postage Paid at Rahway
juniori@pennwell.com NJ. Postm aster send address corrections to: Power Engineering International, C/0
Corporate Headquarters
Senior Editor Mercury Airfreight International Ltd. 365 Blair Road, Avenel, NJ 07001.
PennWell Corporation Circulation and subscriber enquiries
Sian Green ® “ Power Engineering International" is a registered trademark of PennWell Corporation.
1421 S. Sheridan Road, Tulsa P.O. Box 1440, Tulsa, OK 74101 USA POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Power Engineering International, PennWell
Editorial Assistant OK 74112 USA Telephone: +1 918-831-9427 Global Energy Group, P.O. Box 1440, Tulsa, OK 74101 USA.
Charlotte Gliddon-Bush Telephone: +1 918 835 3161 Fax: +1 918-832-9295
Fax: +1 918 831 9834 E-mail: pei@omeda.com
Publisher
Nick Ornstien
International Sales
Dan Noyau
Vice President, Publishing Director,
Global Energy Group
Robert W. Smock
ABP Member
American Business Press
The IMF recommended the creation of Currently, PLN has 50 per cent excess 5.3 per cent in 1998. Exports increased
greater transparency in the issuing of govern capacity over and above what it requires on from $74.3 billion in 1998 to $76 billion
ment loans, subsidies and enforcement of the main grids of Java and Bali, exclusive of in 1999. Imports however fell by $0.2 bil
laws and regulations relating to the area of IPPs. The crisis has delayed or cancelled lion from $59.3 billion in 1998 to $59.1
procurement. The government has many ongoing projects and it seems clear billion in 1999.
announced several reform initiatives since that IPP schemes may have to operate at a The Malaysian government announced
receiving the IMF bailout package, including loss until the Indonesian economy recovers its intentions to privatize the electricity
the planned privatization of several sectors of and PLN’s financial condition improves. industry in 1990. In the same year, TNB
its economy. ACG projects that the surplus in 2005 is was incorporated under the Companies Act
To stimulate recovery, liberal trade financ expected to be around 1250 MW vis-a-vis and took over the liabilities of the National
ing needs to be made available to export the official forecast of around 2800 MW of Electricity Board (NEB). In 1992, TNB
companies, monetary policy should be annual new capacity requirement between was listed on the Kuala Lumpur Stock
eased to facilitate corporates in redeeming 1996 to 2005. Exchange. The year 1996 witnessed the
Ministry of Energy, Posts and Telecom
munications urging TNB to restructure
"The Indonesian government does not expect the creation o f the into three core business units.
multi-seller, multi-buyer market in the Java-Bali grid before 2003." In 1997, TNB underwent corporate
restructuring under which two wholly
their debt obligations, the banking sector M alaysia owned subsidiaries - TNB Generation Sdn.
ought to be restructured, and the subsidy Asset liability mismatch, with regard to Bhd. and TNB Engineers Sdn. Bhd - were
on electricity needs to be brought down. maturity and currency denomination, led created. Subsequently in 1998, TNB identi
The private sector in Indonesia was to the onset of the financial crisis in fied five power plants for divestment. As a
allowed to produce electricity under the Malaysia. As a consequence, the economy result, the 330 MW Malacca power plant
Licensed Electricity Generation Scheme in plunged into a recession, the asset portfolio was sold to Powertek in 1998. To manage
1992. In 1994, a major deregulation pack of the banking sector deteriorated in quali the hydro generation assets, which were not
age was announced and the status of PLN ty and private investment expenditure fell to be divested, TNB created TNBG Hydro
was changed from a “State Corporation” to by 30.5 per cent in 1998. Sdn. Bhd. in 1998.
a “Limited Liability Company”. In 1995, The government introduced selective In the same year, Electricity Supply
PLN established two subsidiaries for com exchange and capital controls in order to Department formulated the Grid Code as
mercial operations. According to the power arrest the flight o f capital and to check an operational standard for the IPPs. In the
sector restructuring policy launched in speculation on the Malaysian Ringitt. The following year, the government undertook
1998, restructuring was scheduled for first half of 1998 was characterized by strin a study for reorganising Peninsular
completion in 2003. PLN also embarked gent fiscal and monetary policies which Malaysia’s electricity industry to move
on a restructuring plan for the financial, were relaxed in the latter half of 1998. To towards an Electricity Pool Model.
corporate and special contracts divisions. A boost infrastructure development, the gov As of 2000, consultations were on for the
team was also established for restructuring ernment set up the Infrastructure design of a plan for the restructuring of
and rehabilitation. Development Fund. Malaysia’s electricity supply industry
In 1999, Asian Development Bank The National Economic Recovery Plan (MESI). The Electricity Bill 2000 and the
(ADB) sanctioned a $400 million loan has led to the appreciation in the value of Energy Commission Bill 2000 had been
aimed at power sector restructuring. The the Ringitt, increasing levels of foreign forwarded to the Malaysian Parliament for
Indonesian Directorate General of direct investment (FDI) and international approval. The IGSO task force, appointed
Electricity and Energy Development, financial assistance. GDP registered a by the Technical Group, was in the process
Department of Mines and Energy, selected growth of 0.9 per cent in 1999 and grew of preparing the MESI restructuring plan
KEMA Consulting to develop rules for a by $5.2 billion to $75.1 billion. The infla for approval by the Malaysian government.
competitive market for the Indonesian tion rate fell to four per cent in 1999 from In terms of asset sale to private sector, TNB
electricity supply industry (ESI).
The project, which is to be funded by
ADB, consists of two phases. Phase one
will facilitate the design of a single buyer
market which will serve as an interim
measure until the development of a
competitive multi-buyer market. Phase
two will develop tire market rules gov
erning the multi-buyer market. The gov
ernment however, does not expect die
creation of the multi-seller, multi-buyer
market in the Java-Bali grid before 2003.
It will, in the future, provide power to
Malaysia, the Philippines, and Singapore.
In Indonesia, the IPP programme
started in 1990 and the first IPP was
commissioned in 1997. Currently,
there are some 27 IPPs that face the
brunt of the crisis and PLN’s deterio
rating financial position. Only three
IPPs have been commissioned while six
others are ready to start generation.
These power producers face a grave risk
Figure 2. Crisis hit nations: greenfield demand forecast
of PPA renegotiation with PLN.
Thailand
Short-term debt in excess of international
reserves, high gearing ratio of corporates
and liberal credit facilities leading to risky
investments, led to the financial crisis in
Thailand. The crisis led to the GDP plum
meting by eight per cent in 1998, a decline
in manufacturing sector by 12.8 per cent, a
decline in private investments by 40 per cent
and a high unemployment rate of 5.3 per
cent of total labour force in 1998. The gov
ernment countered the crisis by relaxing its
initial tight fiscal policy stance and easing the
monetary policy in the latter half of 1998 to
lower interest rates. GDP was projected to
grow by 2.5 per cent in 2000. which is in sharp contrast to the residual ‘neighbouring power markets’, ‘power
The process o f electricity reform in surplus of around 1250 MW in 2005 fore trade barriers’ and ‘power trade negotia
Thailand has been active since 1992 when casted by ACG. Today Thailand officially tions’ may not be be so far away. The fun
the government announced the revision of has a ‘large reserve margin’ instead of damentals for these situations already exist
policy to encourage private sector partici ‘massive power surplus’. Perhaps it is a in the differences in power surplus and
pation in the power sector. In 1994, necessary window dressing to assist in the tariffs among Asean nations.
Electricity Generating Public Company successful sale o f assets. In ACG’s perception, the concept of inter
Ltd., the first public subsidiary was estab national grids are most sustainable when the
lished. This was followed by the sale of A s e a n tr a n s m is s io n grid buyer and seller nations have a substantial
Rayong combined cycle plant to EGCO, a For countries in the Southeast Asian economic difference between them. The
the wholly-owned subsidiary of EGAT. In region, the availability of an interconnect projects in the supplier nation are essentially
1996, EGAT was restructured into six ing grid would make eminent sense from an export industry assured of demand and
operating units and five business units. In the perspective o f coordinated supply side foreign export earnings. The recipient
1998, the government set out a three phase management. New capacity in the presence nation is assured of reliable and competitive
plan for EGAT to be undertaken in three of such a functional and feasible regional power. There is little conflict of interest and
vears. In 1999, Parliament passed the State grid would then be planned by mutual con energy security issues are not as critical.
Enterprise Corporatization Bill under sultations between the member countries, An example o f such an arrangement is the
which EGAT was to be privatized. This led taking into account the demand and supply one between Bhutan and India. Thailand’s
to protests by unions against privatization. o f electricity for the whole region. plans to purchase power from hydro capac
Currently EGAT has four operating units Such coordinated supply side manage ity in Laos is a similar proposition. By the
and six business units but is to be restruc ment would lead to not only better alloca same token the power trade possibility
tured in the next four years (see page 19) tion o f the collective pool of resources of between India and Pakistan is a non-starter.
In February 2000, 53 proposals from the member countries, but will also serve to In view of the similarities between the
SPPs totalling 2134 MW had been accepted satisfy the demand of local pockets of economies of the Asean countries, an inter
by EGAT. Thailand’s revised Power shortages in a country which is closer to connecting regional transmission grid faces
substantial complexities. These necessitate
close coordination between the member
"As o f June 2000, the Asean electric utilities agreed on the countries regarding setting up of new gen
eration capacities, quantum of load flow
concept o f a regional transmission grid."
and a commitment to honour purchase
agreements.
Development Plan (PDP), demands that the neighbouring country compared to the As most o f the Asean region moves
21 216 MW of new capacity is to be added domestic grid. towards power pools, the interconnections
between 1999-2001, of which 10 443 MW Most of the above countries already have will serve to further create a more compet
is to be developed by IPPs (4597 MW is to some form of an interconnecting network. itive environment. In the future, IPPs and
be built by IPPs by 2003). To date, only two For example, such a network exists privatized assets may access trans-national
of the seven approved IPP Phase I schemes between Singapore and Malaysia and opportunities but also face trans-national
have been able to arrange project finance. between Malaysia and Thailand. As o f June competitive pressures.
The other five IPPs have delayed their 2000, the Asean electric utilities agreed on
projects by one to three years. the concept of a regional transmission grid.
.4s of February 2000, EGAT renounced its A grid interconnecting all o f the above ACC is a strategic consulting firm focused on
investment plans for the three power pro countries, however, needs to be tempered the power and energy sectors. ACC recently
jects, citing unattractive returns as the rea with the issues o f energy securin' and the completed a nine month, multi-client study
of 25 countries in Asia - Asia Power 2000
son. Subsequently, it terminated its PPAs present surplus power capacity conditions and Beyond. Portions of this article are
until three SPP projects totalling 230 MW. existing in most Southeast Asian coun sourced from the study.
Thailand’s pre-crisis demand forecasts tries. For all the ‘official’ bonhomie Contact Details Updated
were extremely aggressive. The official between the Asean countries, political and Email: ceo.gis.acg@gmail.com
forecast for annual capacity addition in the competitive pressures may override ‘sys Website: www.gis-acg.com
period 1996-2005 was around 1500 MW tem-sense’. Heated debates over access to