Help Sitemap

Logged in as mishra766 [Logout]

You can:
Review articles
Change your password

For Authors For Librarians Orders Inderscience Online News

OSPEERS > User > Reviewer > IJMP_239380 > Evaluation Form Information

PAPER EVALUATION FORM Submission ID: IJMP_239380

Dr. Sunil Mishra Mishra, You are reviewing the paper "Application of TAM model in Teaching & Learning – A behavioral study on Social Media"
submitted for "International Journal of Management Practice"

[Read Article's Full-Text - View more options, including uploading annotated files]

Your review and recommendations have been saved and the editor has been notified.
If you want to upload an annotated file for the editor and for the authors, please click here and use the "Browse" and "Upload" buttons
Thank you for your help and advice.

Reviewer Originality of the work: Acceptable

27/04/19 Subject relevance: Good
04:23 PM Professional/industrial relevance: Good
Completeness of the work: Acceptable
Acknowledgement of the work of others by references: Good
Organization of the manuscript: Acceptable
Clarity in writing, tables, graphs and illustrations: Good
Likelihood of passing the "test of time": Acceptable
In your opinion, is the technical treatment plausible and free of technical errors?: No
Have you checked the equations and/or statistics? (if applicable): Yes
Are you aware of prior publication or presentation of this work?: No
Is the manuscript free of commercialism?: Yes
Is the paper too long?: No

RECOMMENDATION : Acceptable with minor revisions

Suggestions which would improve the quality of the paper but are not essential for publication:
The methodology part does not talk about the measures adopted from where which could have been included to validate the findings
 of the author.
Changes which must be made before publication:
1. Hypotheses defined twice on page number 6 so from any one place it should be deleted.
2. Grammatical errors are there in the overall paper which needs to be rectified.
3. In text referencing are not properly cited as per APA style.
4. The word hypothesis to be used as plural instead of singular.
5. Content is plagiarised in second paragraph of Theoretical and Practical Implications heading which is taken from - Joey F. George,
(2004) "The theory of planned behaviour and Internet purchasing", Internet Research, Vol. 14 Issue: 3, pp.198-212, https://doi.org
/10.1108/10662240410542634
Similarly, at page number 4 First and last paragraph needs to be made plagiarism free.
Confidential comments only for the editor:
The paper titled "Application of TAM model in Teaching & Learning – A behavioural study on Social Media" has been written down
nicely and well framed. Further, the methodology section nicely explained and use of SEM strengthen the findings of the research. But
before going for publication the above suggested changes need to be incorporated.

Add comments:

Contact us | About Inderscience | OAI Repository | Privacy and Cookies Statement | Terms and Conditions | Copyright © 2019 Inderscience Enterprises Ltd.