Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Review
Reviewed Work(s): EARLY HISTORY OF BUDDHISM IN CEYLON (or "State of Buddhism in
Ceylon as revealed by the Pāli Commentaries of the 5th century A. D.") by E. W.
Adikaram and E. W. Adikram
Review by: V. V. Gokhale
Source: Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, Vol. 28, No. 3/4 (July-
October 1947), pp. 313-315
Published by: Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/44028075
Accessed: 04-07-2019 14:14 UTC
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
This content downloaded from 59.144.9.6 on Thu, 04 Jul 2019 14:14:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
EARLY HISTORY OF BUDDHISM IN CEYLON (or
" State of Buddhism in Ceylon as revealed by the Pāli
Commentaries of the 5th century A. D. 99 ) by E. W.
Adikaram, M.A., Ph.D. ( Lond. ), published by D. S.
Puswella, Migoda (Ceylon ) 1946, Pp. X+154+L.
The sub-title, put into brackets, represents the proper subject
of this doctorate thesis, prepared under the guidance of the
veteran Pāli scholar, Dr. W. Stede. The book is divided into two
Parts. In Part one, consisting of four chapters, the author gives
a brief survey of his materials and tries to assess the nature of
their contents, firstly by discussing the older sources to which
references are found in the Pāli commentaries, and then by
illustrating some of the differences that exist between the com-
mentaries and the canon and those between one commentary and
another. He has drawn interesting infererences concerning espe-
cially the Porāņas, who according to him may be the same persons
as the Pubbacariyas and maybe closely connected with the Porāņā-
cariyas and Atthakathâcariyas, but not the same as the Porāņa-
kattheras. The chapter on the Bhāņakas ( Reciters ) is more
instructive. The author is not aware of any reference to the
Reciters of the Khuddakanikâya in any of the commentaries,
although the word 4 Khuddakabhāņaka ' occurs in the Milinda-
pañha. This fact seems to support strongly the theory, that the
Sutta Pitaka consisted originally of only four Ägamas ( as in the
Chinese tradition) instead of the five Nikayas represented in
Pāli, and that the term ' Nikäya ' ( group ) might itself indicate a
later re-arrgangment of the canonical material on the subject of
the 1 Dhamma ' as distinguished from the ' Vinaya ( Olderiberg ,
Studien zur Geschichte des buddhistischen Knon, NGGW. 1912 ).
Part Two, containing ten chapters and covering nearly three-
fourth part of the whole book, deals mainly with the early history
of Buddhism in Ceylon, during a period of about one thousand
years ( roughly, 500 B. C. to 500 A. D. ). It may be said, in
general that in trying to establish historical facts, Dr. Adikarm
is very willing to give a long rope to the commentators and later
authorities, even where they seem to be manifestly reproducing
ppre hearsay, and prefers to err? if neęci be, orç the sitlf}
This content downloaded from 59.144.9.6 on Thu, 04 Jul 2019 14:14:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
314 Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute
This content downloaded from 59.144.9.6 on Thu, 04 Jul 2019 14:14:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Reviews 315
1927 ). On the Lokuttaravāda school,
thrown by a thorough investigation
literature, found in the Tibetan monasteries. Chapter VII
accompanied by a useful map of ancient Ceylon deals with
references to the ancient geography of Ceylonese Buddhism.
Chap. VIII describes generally the ethics of life, adopted by
the Buddhist monks and laymen. Chap. IX deals with the
growth of the ritual, connected with the Caityas, including the
relics, the Bodhi-tree and the images, and with the recitation of
the Parittas. The last Chapter ( X ) describes the position of the
Buddhist deities : Brahmà, Sakka, the Four Great Kings, Yama,
Māra, Metteya etc. and concludes with a brief sketch of the
Buddhist cosmography, which has hitherto formed an important,
though not yet properly explored, source of comparative Indian
mythology. Among the Appendices are found lists of personal
and place names in Ceylon and useful collections of quotations
from the Porāņas and the Porāņaka theras, occurring in the com-
mentaries. The Bibliography ( Pp. XXXIII-XXXV ) should have
been more exhaustive. The author having concentrated himself
on the works of Buddhaghosa, the problém of the " Vimuttimagga
and Visuddhimagga", initiated by Nagai and treated exhaustive-
ly by P. V. Bapat in his thesis, bearing that title ( Poona, 1937 )
should not have escaped his attention. ( See my review in the
Visva-Bhāratī Quarterly Vol. V, pt. i ( 1939), Pp. 92-94 ). The
original and thoroughly critical view taken by Dharmananda
Kosambi about the personality of Buddhaghosa in his Introduc-
tion to the DevanāgarI edition of the Visuddhimagga published
by the Bharatiya Vidyâ Bhavana ( Bombay, 1940 ) has also not
come to the notice of the author. A good Index closes this neat
and attractive volume, containing a comprehensive, laborious,
systematic and useful collection of data from the Pāli commen*
taries of the fifth century A. D. Some of the misprints that have
come to my notice are: p. 9 : the third paragraph should bear
the title 4 Upasena ' ; p. 94*. read 'fifth' instead of 'first' in
line 23 ; Index * p. XLVI, under 4 Nikayasangraha' add p. 92 n ;
p. IL under 'Upatissa' read 143 instead of 142, and under
4 Vaitulya-vãdins ' read 105 instead of 104.
V. V. Gokhale
This content downloaded from 59.144.9.6 on Thu, 04 Jul 2019 14:14:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms