Case: Hamilton county ju

Probability of cases appealed and

Total cases Appealed Reversed Probability of cases

Courts disposed cases cases being appealed

Common Pleas Court 43945 1762 199 0.040095574

Domestic Relations 30499 106 17 0.0034755238

Court
Municipal Court 108464 500 104 0.0046098245

Common Pleas Court

Total cases Appealed Reversed Probability of cases

Judges disposed cases cases being appealed

Fred Cartolano 3037 137 12 0.0451103062

Thomas Crush 3372 119 10 0.0352906287
Patrick Dinkelacker 1258 44 8 0.0349761526
Timothy Hogan 1954 60 7 0.0307062436
Robert Kraf 3138 127 7 0.040471638
William Mathews 2264 91 18 0.0401943463
William Morrissey 3032 121 22 0.0399076517
Norbert Nadel 2959 131 20 0.0442717134
Arthur Ney, Jr. 3219 125 14 0.0388319354
Richard Niehaus 3353 137 16 0.0408589323
Thomas Nurre 3000 121 6 0.0403333333
John O'Connor 2969 129 12 0.0434489727
Robert Ruehlman 3205 145 18 0.0452418097
J.Howard Sundermann 955 60 10 0.0628272251
Ann Marie Tracey 3141 127 13 0.0404329831
Ralph Winkler 3089 88 6 0.0284881839

Judge Thomas Nurre ranks the best since we can see that the probability of r
least and so we can conclude that he is the best Judge compar

Domestic Relations Court

 Total cases Appealed Reversed Probability of cases
Judges disposed cases cases being appealed

Penelope Cunningham 2729 7 1 0.0025650421

Patrick Dinkelacker 6001 19 4 0.003166139
Deborah Gaines 8799 48 9 0.0054551654
Ronald Panioto 12970 32 3 0.0024672321

Ronald Panioto ranks the best since we can see that the probability of reversal
so we can conclude that he is the best Judge compared to

Total cases Appealed Reversed Probability of cases

Judges disposed cases cases being appealed

Mike Allen 6149 43 4 0.006993007

Nadine Allen 7812 34 6 0.0043522785
Timothy Black 7954 41 6 0.0051546392
David Davis 7736 43 5 0.0055584281
Leslie Isaiah Gaines 5282 35 13 0.0066262779
Karla Grandy 5253 6 0 0.0011422045
Deidra Hair 2522 5 0 0.0019825535
Dennis Helmick 7900 29 5 0.0036708861
Timothy Hogan 2308 13 2 0.0056325823
James Patrick Kenney 2798 6 1 0.0021443888
Joseph Luebbers 4698 25 8 0.0053214134
William Mallory 8277 38 9 0.0045910354
Melba Marsh 8219 34 7 0.0041367563
Beth Mattingly 2971 13 1 0.0043756311
Albert Mestemaker 4975 28 9 0.0056281407
Mark Painter 2239 7 3 0.0031263957
Jack Rosen 7790 41 13 0.0052631579
Mark Schweikert 5403 33 6 0.0061077179
David Stockdale 5371 22 4 0.0040960715
John A.West 2797 4 2 0.0014301037

Karla Grandy and Deidra Hair rank the best since we can see that the probabili
the least and so we can conclude that he is the best Judge compa
milton county judges
f cases appealed and reversed

Probability of cases
being reversed

0.0045283878

0.0005573953

0.0009588435

ommon Pleas Court

Probability of cases Probability of reversal given Rank

Rank Rank
being reversed an appeal

14 0.0039512677 6 0.0875912409 5
4 0.0029655991 4 0.0840336134 4
3 0.0063593005 12 0.1818181818 14
2 0.0035823951 5 0.1166666667 9
10 0.0022307202 3 0.0551181102 2
7 0.00795053 15 0.1978021978 16
6 0.0072559367 14 0.1818181818 14
13 0.0067590402 13 0.1526717557 12
5 0.0043491768 9 0.112 8
11 0.0047718461 10 0.1167883212 10
8 0.002 2 0.0495867769 1
12 0.0040417649 7 0.0930232558 6
15 0.0056162246 11 0.124137931 11
16 0.0104712042 16 0.1666666667 13
9 0.0041388093 8 0.1023622047 7
1 0.0019423762 1 0.0681818182 3

e that the probability of reversal given an appeal is the

is the best Judge compared to the others

mestic Relations Court

 Probability of cases Probability of reversal given
Rank Rank Rank
being reversed an appeal

2 0.0003664346 2 0.1428571429 2
3 0.0006665556 3 0.2105263158 4
4 0.0010228435 4 0.1875 3
1 0.000231303 1 0.09375 1

he probability of reversal given an appeal is the least and

e best Judge compared to the others

Probability of cases Probability of reversal given

Rank Rank Rank
being reversed an appeal

20 0.0006505123 7 0.0930232558 4
9 0.0007680492 11 0.1764705882 10
12 0.0007543374 10 0.1463414634 6
15 0.0006463289 6 0.1162790698 5
19 0.0024611889 20 0.3714285714 18
1 0 1 0 1
3 0 1 0 1
6 0.0006329114 5 0.1724137931 9
17 0.0008665511 13 0.1538461538 7
4 0.0003573981 4 0.1666666667 8
14 0.0017028523 18 0.32 16
11 0.0010873505 14 0.2368421053 14
8 0.0008516851 12 0.2058823529 13
10 0.000336587 3 0.0769230769 3
16 0.0018090452 19 0.3214285714 17
5 0.0013398839 16 0.4285714286 19
13 0.0016688062 17 0.3170731707 15
18 0.0011104942 15 0.1818181818 11
7 0.0007447403 9 0.1818181818 11
2 0.0007150518 8 0.5 20

can see that the probability of reversal given an appeal is

e is the best Judge compared to the others