Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
22 March 2018
Project Tenor 11 -
Confidential working
papers - Part 11
This confidential working paper to the Detailed Report, provided to the National Bank of Moldova (the "NBM" or
the "client") on 22 March 2018, was prepared by Kroll at the request of the client. Kroll has agreed to the
client's request that a copy of this confidential working paper may be submitted to the Moldovan General
Prosecution Office, the Anti-Corruption Prosecution Office and the Agency for Recovery of Criminal Assets
(the "Moldovan Authorities") only subject to the Moldovan Authorities maintaining this confidential working
paper as strictly confidential. The client and the Moldovan Authorities agree that this confidential working
paper to the Detailed Report is strictly confidential and is intended solely for the use of the client. Any other use
is strictly prohibited and the client and the Moldovan Authorities have agreed that no such use will occur. Any
communication , publication, disclosure, dissemination or reproduction of this confidential working paper to
the Detailed Report or any portion of its contents to third parties is subject to the advance written consent of
Kroll. Kroll assumes no direct, indirect or consequential liability to any third party or any person other that the
client for the information contained herein, its interpretation or applications, or for omissions, or for reliance
by any such third party or other person thereon . To the extent information provided in this confidential working
paper to the Detailed Report is based on a review of publicly-available records, such information, as
presented, relies upon the accuracy and completeness of those records, which have not been corroborated by
Kroll. Statements herein concerning financial , regulatory or legal matters should be understood to be general
observations based solely on Kroll's experience as risk consultants and may not be relied upon as
financial , regulatory or legal advice, which Kroll is not authorized to provide. All such matters should be
further corroborated through appropriate legal channels with appropriately qualified advisors in these areas.
Contents
1. Introduction ..... .. ..... ......... .. ................... .............. .. ..... .. ..... ... ... .. .. ....... .. ... .... .... .. ................ .. 3
2. Evidence Paci< - Funds traced to llan Shor .. ................... ... .. ..... ....... .......... .. ... .. ..... .. .... ... .4
3. Evidence Paci< - Funds traced to Alexandr Maclovici .. ...................... .... .. ... ..... .. .. ... ... .... 66
4. Evidence Paci< - Funds traced to Olga Bondarciuc .. .... ..... .. ... ...... ...... .... .. ...... ............ .. 116
1. Introduction
This document (the "Evidence Packs") is the second part of the confidential working papers
("Confidential Working Papers Part II") to the Detailed Report, issued as a final version on 22
March 2018 , in accordance with the Letter of Engagement dated 8 December 2017 (the "8 th
December LOE"). It provides the details of tracing for a sample of the individuals identified in
Confidential Working Papers Part I as follows :
• llan Shor;
• Alexandr Maclovici ; and,
• Olga Bondarciuc.
Kroll's analysis has identified that not only did Mr Shor play a key role in the administration of the
suspected fraud ; he also received funds linked to the suspected fraudulent loans granted to the
Shor Group.
In section 2.2, a number of payments received by him that originate from proceeds of loans issued
by BEM and UB are set out.
1
This is the USO (equivalent) figure . Transfers we re made in MDL, EUR and USO.
Pri vileged and confidential 4
Evidence Pack - Funds traced to llan Shor: Overview
A further 20 payments were identified , totalling USO 1,707,010.90 (equivalent) . The payments were
made to Mr Sher's ABLV bank accounts (account numbers LV54AIZK0000010083121 and
LV61AIZK0000020367517) , and his account at Gazprombank, Russia (account number
42601978000210000052).
, i;r-./
/
Loan a::cou,,t 14 2150 l976 5
Lo-!:1ref1;rer1~ii6-06/l[ lQ din l7j04i 2Gl4
(6Er-1)
I
17 i•14i 2-..J l 4
aJR 2TO,Q:J<J
Detailed Report) five days earlier on 5 June 2014. The EUR 119,720 portion was transferred
through two ABLV entities before it was transferred to Shor's ABLV account.
~
/
Loan a:::count 14220010 0004 323496
Lo.en reference N:" 147/ 13 din 06.11.2013
(U\5)
05/ 06/20!4
MDL l I 00,000
~-
L:::•e.1c:::cc~.Jnt 1"1221}0 !OC-0046559i6
Lt'c~ref: !74/13 d.n 15/! 2/2013
(U 6)
I
lS/1 2/ 2i1!3
=~.. 7r5.000
Apropro-(cm Srl
·r
!.5/1 2/2013
"'T""
Otvi~lan Top LLP
T
16/ 12j2Q13
=T"·
1S/ 12i 20 ! 3 ----'>--• ol ~ - - - - - - l6/12i~Jt3
EUR 7,755,00<) - E\JP.~· ,os3,c-00
11,,
-
.;;
----=1S/ 12/7.SSJ,000
2013
-
6rend, Mar'r:elir.g Ltd Ne::;n,lc! System s UP ii~.., Ser n~:i Ser
(ASL•!) (A5LI/) \___ 2.;,1 12/ 20t3 (A5LV) {::~wrcmba~~!.:}
a i.:t 31 502.00G
2.3 Example 1
Example 1 involves a series of transactions from a loan granted to SC Dufremol SRL by BEM,
which , according to transaction descriptions on the bank statement, was made for the purchase of
computer equipment. Tracing shows the series of transactions and the flow of funds from SC
Dufremol SRL's loan account at BEM (account number 14215019785) to Mr Shor's ABLV account
(account number LV54AIZK0000010083121 ). Tracing identified a portion of the loan funds, USO
93,700, was paid to Mr Shor the next day, on 25 April 2014. According to transaction descriptions,
the funds appear to have been used to pay a company called "Tropical Collections".
The funds were transferred throguh the following accounts before a portion was transferred to Mr
Shor's bank account:
• SC Dufremol SRL, BEM (account number 22249019782768) ;
• Maltby Solutions LP, ABLV (account number LV30AIZK0000010374456); and
• Branch Marketing Ltd, ABLV (account number LV82AIZK0000010373132) .
According to bank statement data, payment descriptions indicate that the transfer to the ABLV
account in the name of Mr Shor was for a "Loan". The bank statement for this account shows that
these funds were transferred onward on the same day to an account no 7707-700576-002 at the
Bank of Maldives in the name of Tropical Collections Maldives . The payment description indicates
that the payment was for an invoice related to hotel costs.
In total, Tropical Collections received a total of USO 193,574.01 from this account (in April 2014).
It appears that these transactions are linked to Mr Shor's wedding, as, according to a social media
post, Mr Shor and his wife got married in 2014 in the Maldives. Reports about the wedding were
dated 14 January 2014, three months before the payments made to Tropical Collections . A
translated extract of this report is included below:
Si:?~EI'.; :.s:11::l ;.ad h:::· i: .l:b<.nd. ~.Io>:k,\.,:. n :11: t; :011~\:·':' 1:?•.!: Si!c: . :!l.:ii r:i::.! •·•::-:· ~.h:: =~-.-cmd
1
ti :::•:. -:·j:~ v::Cd::::;. :,:,u-k p:;-!.c•.: 1J:1 t:1,.:- :,.,.zf:·u:~t. !:·. :.!:e ).[2.~tii·,'="~ l::i.::.:,cl:-. ,rn •1:.:t:1'.1s:·:-..• ':..,:,;,::tii.
:..k~::i u:~~!,):: wii!1 b:.-1:..:.~:iul •,·:h:·.o: ~-.:.:~ti l:,:,;it·b.•~:.
-J2:::; i11:. ,):1 h':r :-t:-2i ri o:1?1~ .Sa,;1, Shot. :·.e,·':'.:.!e:d tr.~t :?l:'r hc:bc :Ld !:;.<l Z!:s:k-:-i Ii -::· f-.;;r
i:: c.rri,110.: ic,;· lh•: s.;.:1,:or:C. tim£·. "l }<J\"f .::;;,:q::ri~t:!>. t:.:-t=~.:::.dl~- rC'::,.;::t: ~ cJz;c::. i :~!; '.l!"'.§ ! :::z~·J
o u r ~..:-c-?r.(. ·.,·,:-dtil:J$ i1: ~h1.~ :•,!;~l d ~,- -Js . I diC 11~: ! ;..: ~p l;' C~ n·h.at i. ::-u:·p1~!0:· [ wJs ,:, :-:;,e:tl::Z'.
rm tt:rr!hi~: •~:-: \it,.,cL .. ~r:\~ ·.-:ril-?r, \1!", h~n biog.
(Source: http:llthewoman.md/jasmin-si-ilan-shor-s-au-casatorit-pentru-doua-oara-maldivel)
This loan was repaid partially by two other loans issued to Shor Group companies as follows :
• Loan Nr 250/2014 issued by BS to Alutus Com Sri on 22/10/2014 (EUR 1 million)
• Loan Nr 06-06/1/52 issued by BEM to Voximar-Com Sri on 16/12/2014 (EUR 1 million)
An additional amount (EUR 545,000) was received from SC Dufremol Srl's MDL account on 22/10/2014.
The ultimate source of this amount could not be determined during the scope of work set out in this
report.
Figure 4: Summary of the repayment of the loan (source of funds for Example 1)
I
22/10{20 14
I
16/ 10/20!4
::LP. l r 0,000 ::LP. 1 loo ,ooo
22li0/20 !~
I
l?/!Oj20i~
:'UR j,ro,, c,o EUR i r0,000
-
fcirmi~o!d L!.P
(Privatbcr,1-:)
-,,.T.,
i-1<DStM Level LL?
I
22/ 10/201-4
EUR Sr, 050
17/10/ 20 14
EU::t i ,000,000
! 7/10/ 201&,
Eli;;: 1.000,000
ElP. s5s,ooo 22/!0/20 14 22/i0/ 20 1~
We!entos LP Kolten House LP EUR 855,000 SC Dufremol Sri EUR i.-100,000 Loon accciunt 14215019785
(Priv~tbank) (Pris•a !b~n~_) :'LP. Loan reference Nr 06-06/1/10 d'.n 17-04-201.:;
(5:'M)
,/ ·
22f1Dl2C114
MDL .; EUR s~s.ooo
/
/
/
SC Dufrcmol Sri
MDL
!PEM)
Statement details
Bank BEM
Account holder SC Dufremol Sri
Country of company Moldova
registration
Account number 22249019782768
Account currency EUR
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 17/04/2014
Crediting amount 2,400,000.00
Credit from Loan account (BEM)
Description (as per statement) UTILIZAREA MIJLOACELOR DE CREDIT CONFORM
CONTRACT DE CREDIT NR.06-06/1/10 DIN 17.04.2014
PENTRU PROCURAREA MARFA- TABLETE PC, CONFORM
CONTRACT F/NR DIN 10.04.2014 INVOICE F/NR DIN
10.04.2014
Summary description Release of loan number 06-06/1/10
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
(Oate) (Debit) (Credit) biii aie. Ern. n-:-ao Eia aaiea eia. ia~ia-;-aiea 1eao. (Counterpartv) Gene. e1a e,aa. 6Ei ;;;aaaii'i.
UTILIZAREA MIJLOACELOR DE CREDIT CONFORM CONTRACT DE CREDIT SC DUFREMOL SRL
NR.06-06/1/10 DIN 17.04.2014 PENTRU PROCURAREA MARFA-
TABLETE PC, CONFORM CONTRACT F/NR DIN 10.04.2014 INVOICE F/NR
11/04L2014 2,400,000.00 POl 14215019785 BECOMD2X609 DIN 10.04.2014 1002600042306
(N) MALTBY
SOLUTIONS LP,39
DUKE
'FR/NR DIN 10.04.2014'PLATA IN AVANS PENTRU PROCURAREA 5TREET,EDINBURG,UN
MARFA -TABLETE PC NF CONTR FR/NR OIN 10.04.2014 INV FR/N DIN ITED KINGDOM OF
17/04/2014 2,400,000.00 103 LV30AIZK0000010374456 10.04.2014 GREAT BRITAIN
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 17/04/2014
Crediting amount 2,400,000.00
Credit from SC Dufremol Sri (BEM)
Description (as per statement) FT14107223039788, ienakosais maksajums, nr.
FAAS410708830500, SC DUFREMOL SRL STR TIGHINA 12
CHISINAU, MOLDOVA, BANCA DE ECONOMII S.A.
(BECOMD2XXXX), konts MD83BE000022249019782768, OUR,
PREPMT FOR GOODS - TABLETS PC NF CONTR W/NR DD
10.04 .2014 INV W/NR DD 10.04.2014
Summary description Prepayment for goods
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments According to the funds tracing methodology, the EUR 4,332,700
transfer to Branch Marketing Ltd (ABL V) was from two inward
transfers as follows:
Fig ure 6: Funds from Oanmira and SC Oufremo/ Sri mixed in Maltby Solutions LP accoun t and transferred
to Branch Marl<eting Ltd
Danmira - ~
{Metro bank)
17/04 / 20 14
'· · ono
EUR 2, 150,_ u table}
(EUR 1, 9 3.,, , 700 attr1~ ~
·
As detailed in Figure 5, the funds from SC Dufremol SRL and the funds received from Danmira
(Metrobank, Russia) were mixed in the account of Maltby Solutions LP . Therefore the funds from these
two sources are indistinguishable. In addition, as described in the Detailed Report (Section 11), the
funds from a group of accounts at Alef Bank (Russia) and Metrobank (Russia) were also treated
as funds related to the suspected fraud, as they appeared to relate to a circular transfer of funds
between these accounts, the Latvian accounts and accounts at the Three Moldovan Banks.
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 29.10.2013 ITdz 26.06.2014
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darTjuma veids,
datums informacija par darTjumu Debets Kredits
FT14107223000431, ienakosais maksajums, nr. ASW26992/170414, Balance b/fwcl EUR 321 .38
KIO9909380074 DANMIRA //MD2044 , R ESPUBLIKA MOLDOVA,
17.04.2014 KISHINEV, UL. ME SHTERUL MANOLE, D. 12//, METROBANK +2 150 000.00
(MBNKRUMMXXX), konts 40807978200010053503, OUR, PAYMENT
FOR COMPUTERS UNDER CONTRACT DD 16.04.2014
FT14107223039788, ienakosais maksajums, nr. FAAS410708830500,
SC DUFREMOL SRL STR TIGHINA 12 CHISINAU, MOLDOVA, BANCA
DE ECONOMII S.A. (BECOMD2XXXX), konts
17.04.2014 +2 400 000.00
MD83BE000022249019782768, OUR, PREPMT FOR GOODS -
TABLETS PC NF CONTR W/NR DD 10.04.2014 INV W/NR DD
10.04.2014
FT14107752733580, val0tas konvertacija, nr. 98, 217155.27 EUR=>
17.04.2014 -21 '7 155.27
300000.00 USO, kurss 1.3815
FT14107584770145, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
17.04.2014 -4.00 Balance b/fwd EUR 4 ,33, 162.11
4332700.00 EUR no 17/04/2014
FT14107584770145, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 99, BRANCH
17.04.2014 MARKETING LTD ., konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, Bo3spar -4 332 700 .00
111HBeCTll11..lll11il
FT14112376789270, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 944, BRANCH
22.04.2014 MARKETING LTD., reg . nr. 135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +720 820.00
VIHBeCTll11..l"1111 :
FT14112787590184, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma surnma
22.04.2014 -50 .00
720760.00 EUR no 22/04/2014
FT14112787590184, izejosais maksajums, nr. 100, SUNRISE COTTON
LP, AS 'PRIVATBANK' (PRTTLV22XXX), konts
22.04.2014 -720 760 .00
LV66PRTT0265017145800, SHA, Payment according -to contract from
17 .03.14 for electronics ·
FT14114471056753, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 948, BRANCH
24.04.2014 MARKETING LTD., reg . nr. 135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +20 000.00
VIHBeCTll11..lll1111
FT14114856974221, komisija par mal<sajuniu , maksajuma summa
24.04.2014 -50.00
20000.00 EUR no 24/04/2014
FT1411485697 4221, izejosais maksajum~. nr. 102, AERO AGENTS
LLP, JSC CITADELE BANKA (PARXLV22XXX), konts
24.04.2014 -20 000 .00
LV47PARX0009342630001, SHA, Payment according to invoice
1318-2 014 for transport services
FT14114317905021, ieksbankas mal<sajums, l<OMll1CCll1fl 38 Bb1A8"-IY
24.04.2014 nOATBep~(,QeHll1fl 38 nnare~c-FT14114856974221 20000.00 EUR OT -3 .00
24/04/2014
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 17/04/2014
Crediting amount 4,332,700.00
Credit from Maltby Solutions LP (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT14107584770145, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 99,
MALTBYSOLUTIONS LP, reg . nr. SL 14130, konts
LV30AIZK000001037 4456,B03BpaT IIIHBeCTIIIL.1111111
Summary description Return on investment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was EUR 12,460.94. The EUR 4,332,700
transferred onwards as follows:
Figure 7: Transfer of amount received from Maitby Solutions L.P to various accounts
23/04i2014 /../
EUR 218, 550 / ----2-5/:-::0-
4/-::2::
0:-14: : - - -7
I / EUR 176,607 · USO 244,000 "
I /
L7/04/ "2!}14
EUR 4,332, i\JO
,,. 23~20 14
EUR 56,066 · USO 77,500
,,
Maltby S~luiions L
0 Brandi M.;rkeling Ltd Brand, Markeiing Ltd
(A6LI/) ELR 24/04/2014 USO
(ll.BL\J) , EUR 109,974 · USO 15 1, 500 (ASL\/j
I
I ""
I
I ""28/04/ 2014
I EUR 4 3,100
25/04i"J.O 14 (EUR 3 1,044 atirib,utablej
EUR 3?6,000
I ""
I
I " '--
I
¥
'" ~
www.abl v.com
Konta parskats
No 30.07 .2013 ITdz 15.06.2015
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, dari]uma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT14097376181164, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
07.04.2014 -4.00
1622100.00 EUR no 07/04/2014
FT14097376181164, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 926, HAMILTERO
07 .04.2014 -1 622 100.00
COLOR LIMITED, konts LV55AIZK0000010373133, 1/1Heecrnu111111
FT14098254005604, valutas konvertacija, nr. 927, 160421 .97 EUR=>
08.04.2014 -160 421 .97
220500.00 USO, kurss 1.3745
FT14100709146868, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
10.04.2014 -4._00
100050.00 EUR no 10/04/2014
FT14100709146868, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 930, ROMANFORD
10.04.2014 -10Q 050 .00
SOLUTIONS LP, konts LV60AIZK0000010365671, I/IHBECTllll...\111111
FT14101026273030, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 91 , MALTBY
11 .04.2014 SOLUTIONS LP, reg. nr. SL 14130, konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, +2 700 000.00
Bo3epaT 1t1Heecrnu111iii
FT14101026273102, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
11 .04.2014 -4.00
2700000.00 EUR no 11/04/2014
FT14101026273102, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 931, VEGWORK
11.04.2014 -2 700 000 .00
IMPEX LP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390, illHBecrnu111111
FT14101773604686, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 92, MALTBY
11.04.2014 SOLUTIONS LP, reg. nr. SL14130, konts LV30AIZK00000103744\6, +145 200.00
Bo3epaT 1t1Heecrnu111iii .
FT14101180424237, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
11.04.2014 -4.00
56550.00 EUR no 11/04/2014
FT14101180424237, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 932, HAMILTERO
11 .04.2014 -56 550.00
COLOR LIMITED, konts LV55AIZK0000010373133, IIIHEiecT1t1U1t11t1
FT14101180424570, komisija par maksajumu, mal_<Sajuma sum ma
11 .04.2014 -4 .00
51100.00 EUR no 11/04/2014
FT14101180424570, ieksbankas maksajums, nr' 934, VEGWORK
11.04.2014 -51 100.00
IMPEX LP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390, i11Heecrnu111111
l
FT14101231522078, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
11 .04.2014 -4 .00
39700 .00 EUR no 11/04/2014 '
FT14101231522078, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 933, TORPROM
11 .04.2014 -39 700.00
UNIVERSAL LP, konts LV22AIZK0,0~.0010369168, IIIHeecrnu111111
FT14105786151765, ieksbankas' maksajums, nr. 96, MALTBY
15.04.2014 SOLUTIONS LP, reg. nr. SL 14130, konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, +574 800.00
Bo3epaT 111Heecrnu111iii '-
FT14105605087610, kom.isija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
15.04.2014 -4.00
771800.00 EUR no 15/04/2014
FT14105605087610;Jeksbankas maksajums, nr. 936, VEGWORK
15.04.2014 -77 1 800 .00
IMPEX LP, konts LV7,1AIZK0000010371390, IIIHeecT1t1U1t11t1
FT14105955307977, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
15.04.2014 -4 .00
10600.00 EUR.rib 15/04/2014
FT1410595,5307977, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 937, KLASS IKA
15.04.2014 INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, konts LV76AIZK0000010367517, -10 600.00
illHBeCTillU~ill
•.)
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT14107965301748, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
17.04.2014 -4 .00
200050.00 EUR no 17/04/2014
FT14107965301748, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 942, VEGWORK
17.04.2014 -200 050.00
IMPEX LP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390, VIHaecrn1.11-11-1
FT14112376789189, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
22.04.2014 -4 .00
2400050.00 EUR no 22/04/2014 (
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 25/04/2014
Crediting amount 244,000 .00
Credit from Branch Marketing Ltd (EUR) (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT14115230559651 , valatas konvertacija, nr. 953, 176606.83
EUR =>244000 .00 USO, kurss 1.3816
Summary description Currency conversion
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was USO 550.50, treated as nil in accordance with
the funds tracing methodology. The inward transfer of USO
244,000 was paid out as part of the following transfers :
Figure 8: Transfer of funds from Branch Marketing Uc/ to Mr Shor ancl other accounts
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 30.07.2013 lldz 15.06.2015
Valota USO
Parskata periods 30.07.2013 -15.06.2015
Sakuma atlikums +0.00 Debeta apgroz1jums -75 697 39 1.72
Beigu atlikums +0.00 KredHa apgrozijums · +75 697 391.72
(t.sk. nakotne pieejamas summas) (t.sk. nakotne pi~e]amas summas)
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
DarlJuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT14107585239340, valotas konvertacija, nr. 939, 72451 .19 EUR=>
17.04.2014 +100 200.00
100200.00 USO, kurss 1.383
FT14107361446036 , komisija par maksajumu. maksajuma summa
17.04.2014 -5 .54
100200.00 USO no 17/04/2014
FT14107361446036, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 941, llan Sor, konts
17.04.2014 -100 200 .00
LV54AIZK0000010083121, 3a~M
FT14113648543067, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 945, 56065.98 EUR=>
23.04.2014 +77 500.00
77500.00 USO, kurss 1.3823
FT14113806220033, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
23 .04.2014 -5.53
77300 .00 USO no 23/04/2014
FT14113806220033, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 946, MALTBY
23.04.2014 0
77 300.00
SOLUTIONS LP, konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, VlHsecn11-t1>11>1
FT14114037389808, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 949. 109973.87 EUR=>
24.04.2014 +151 500.00
151500.00 USO, kurss 1.3776
FT14114214565206, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
24.04.2014 -5.53
151500.00 USO no 24/04/2014
FT14114214565206, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 951, MALTBY
24.04.2014 -151 500.00 Balance b/fwd USO 550 .50
SOLUTIONS LP, konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, VlHBecrnLt1>11>1
FT14115230559651 , valOtas konvertacija, nr. 953, 176606.83 E4R ,;,>
25.04.2014 +244 000.00
244000.00 USO, kurss 1.3816 ·
FT14115845779369, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma sum ma
25.04.2014 5 53
93700.00 USO no 25/04/2014 - . Balance b/fwd USO 244,544.97
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 25/04/2014
Crediting amount 93,700.00
Credit from Branch Marketing Ltd (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT14115845779369, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 955, BRANCH
MARKETING LTD., reg. nr. 135,034, konts
LV82AIZK0000010373132,3a~M
Summary description Loan
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments USO 93,574.01 is within+/- 1% of USO 93,700
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 25.10.2010 IT dz 15.06.2015
2.4 Example 2
Example 2 shows the flow of funds from a UB account in the name of Sri lnfoton Com
(222488560886) to Mr Shor's ABLV bank account (LV54 AIZK 0000 0100 8312 1). Tracing identified
a portion of the loan funds (EUR 119,720) was paid to Mr Shor on 10 June 2014, five days after
the loan was issued to Sri lnfoton Com on 5 June 2014.
The funds were transferred through the following accounts before a portion was transferred to the
ABLV bank account in Mr Shor's name:
• Sri lnfoton Com, UB (account number 222488560886);
• Maltby Solutions LP, ABLV (account number LV30AIZK0000010374456); and
• Branch Marketing Ltd, ABLV (account number LV82AIZK0000010373132).
According to the payment descriptions in the bank statements the transfer to the ABLV account in
the name of Mr Shor was for a "Loan". The bank statement for this account shows that these funds
were transferred onward on the same day, to account GR9401720530005053043500311 at Piraeus
Bank (Greece) in the name of Touristikes Ependiseis Kapsi. The payment description indicates that
the payment was for an invoice related to hotel costs.
The loan was initially partially repaid by funds from two loans granted by UB to Storad Grup Sri,
another Shor Group company on 03/11/2014 . The loan funds were transferred through a series of
accounts at Privatbank (Latvia) and Versobank (Estonia) before they were transferred to the
account of Sri lnfoton Com and used to repay loan Mr 147/13. These loans were in turn repaid by
an overdraft granted by Privatbank (Latvia) to an account in the name of Globus Corporation LP (a
Core Laundering Account as defined in Section 8 of the Detailed Report) on 05/11/2014. The
overdraft was repaid in the course of the switch of loan exposure between BEM and BS on 25 and
26 November 2014, detailed further in Section 6 of the Detailed Report . The loan repayments are
summarised in the figures below.
Figure 10. Repayment of loan to Sri Info/on Com from loans to Storad Grup Sri
•I,
-1--_;,
Loan account 14220(),11000047'10498 Loan account 142200500004740'198
loan rererence Nr 113/14 din 23.10.2014
/ " ' ' " " ' " N, 116/14 din 31.10.2014
~03/11/2014
03/11/201'1
MDL 11,620,481
MOL 29,808,000
04/11/2014
MDL 46,3SO,O~ / D L 6,747,899
04/11/20 14
EUR 1,363,414
Welentas LP
(Privatbank) Inv~r~ia~~=~:) LP ----U~~~~£:~.~~o
03/11/2014
EUR 623,751
(EUR 343,604 transferred to Hostas Level LLP)
I
03/11/2014
uso 2,05 1,835 -------
03/11/2014-----
USD 2,051,835 --........_ 'arioustransre ;._~
03/11/2014 04/11/2014
EUR 1,002,207 Bannyster LLP Hostas Level LLP Various sources
USO EUR 1,142,262 USD
I
03/11/2014 / (ABLV) (EUR 286,277 transferred to ~rl Infoton Com) (Privatbank)
<••=-~----7,·•"'""'=
EUR 1,600,000 03/11/2014
04/11/2014
EUR 1,~63,312
0'1/11/201'1
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -~04/11/201'1 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ • USO 2,021,880 ·> EUR 1,614,920
EUR96,102 -- (EUR 1,550,921 transferred to Srt lnfoton Com)
Oastlnger LLP
(Privatbank)
~ !
---------==as l evel LLP
1/ 11/2014--------- 04/11/201..--------- .....~_• EUR
EUR 96,102 ------- EUR 1,792,198 (Privatbank)
04/11/2014
EUR 1,4'12,388 -> MDL 26,739,85'1.18 1
04/11/2014
11 Mgt1 i.~~~~cioo ~
Srt lnfoton Com EUR 445,912 ·> MOL 8,266,584.20 Sri Infoton Com
EUR - - - - - - - MDL Loan account 112200100004323'198
(UB) (UB) Loan refere nce Nr 117/ll din 06.11.2013
Figure 12: Repayment of overdraft to Glob us Corporation LP (Privatbank) as part of the Switch
LOANS ISSUED (Banca Sociala)- USD 956.3 million Fortuna United LLP
(BS)
~-
Caritas Group (BS)
(.i
I
I I I I I
lr 2r 2r 164.6
l
lr ":1 .-_39 2
Jasterport LP (BS) · --
Tennant Shipping LP
t
39.2
Vercell solutions LP
76.5
l,..._ - 3 3,5 - - - - ~
-c.._
~-- •~····· ····•
I
,,// '
Europe Consulting LP
Globus Corporation LP Transmark Export LP
.
3 . 7 ~.commerce LP
- .
Overdraft 167
Overdraft 387.8
Overdraft 166.9
/\
Hansa Investment LP Mego Exports LP Spectra Ventures LP Nord LP ~ .
I
Overdraft 405.4
, . -...
N
2.4 • 220.5
·.._... ...... .. ..:... ...... .. .. ...• ~ f·· .... ... --... -.. -.209.3.. ...... --.. , .. .. .. . . . .. .. 5.~ . .. . .... 2/28.7 - • .. . . .. - - ~ .
... !t'
I
Privatbank
3.7 3u
- 0.9 " ~
Terios Systems
~j (Victoriabank) Ii!
KEY:
,,_-.J
~U
j ._.
f;l,ifM
Provolirom SRL (BEM \ /
2.4
Voximar-COM SRL (BEM)
v.
Loan account 142200400004740498
Loan reference Nr 113/14 din 23.10.2014 Loan account 142200500004740498
Loan reference Nr 116/14 din 31.10.2014
\ 05/11/2014
MDL296,'\
I
05/11/2014
i4D,680,00D
i
05/11/2014
EUR 19,871,154 -> MDL 369,247,770
I
Storad Grup Sri
EUR
(UB)
I
05/11/2014
\05/11/2014
EUR 7,219,400
\
05/11/2014
/
Dastinger LLP
(Privatbank)
l"·"'
EUR 3,447,996
05/11/2014
\ ;R4D,5D0
05/11/2014
EUR42,000\
EUR!l,16\
05/11/2014 05/11/2014
7D,7D9,256
Globus Corporation LP
(Privatbank)
i
05/11/2014
EUR 21, 870,954
V
Privatbank overdralt
Statement details
Bank UB
Account holder Sri lnfoton Com
Country of company Moldova
registration
Account number 222488560886
Account currency MDL
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 05/06/2014
Crediting amount 11,000,000.00
Credit from Loan proceeds
Description (as per statement) Eliberarea creditului in conf. cu contr. de credit Nr. 147/13 din
06 .11 .2013
Summary description Release of loan number 147/13
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments MDL 11,000,000.00 is within +/- 1% of MDL 11 ,000,002.32
D;1ta Nr. dor. Dl'hit Credit Othil (,·:duta) I C rctlil (,·.ilul.1) Conl Cuntr.ii,:cntul Cotlfisn1I B:1m:acurc.fJ10nth:nta Dcslin:.ati u 11la1ii
0:'i .fHi.2014 l7K0663:'i I l .fl(HJ.002.32 0.00I l l.UIJ0.002.32 fl.00l 22246K56flR8697K (R) SRL I I0UKG000024 I8 IB .C.'UNIBANK'S.A. ICump;unrc vnlutci
11 :04 INFOTON COM confonn ccmci din
05 .06.2014, ems 18.87,
(582936 EUR)
2.4.2 Example 2, Transaction 2 - Transfer from Sri lnfoton Com (UB) to Maltby
Solutions LP (ABLV) 0 EUR 582,936
Statement details
Bank UB
Account holder Sri lnfoton Com (EUR)
Country of company Moldova
registration
Account number 222468560886978
Account currency EUR
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 05/06/2014
Crediting amount 582,936.00
Credit from Sri lnfoton Com (MDL) (UB)
Description (as per statement) Cumparare valutei conform cererei din 05.06.2014, curs 18.87,
(582936 EUR)
Summary description Currency conversion
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
Figure 14: Transfer of loan proceeds from Sri lnfoton Com to Ma ltby Solutions LP
Credit 81tnc:1
D111:1 Nr. do,. Dchit Cn•ilit Di.-hil (,·alull1) C11111 Cuntrui.:l·ntul Cuilfim1I Dcstinatiu 11l;nii
(rnluta) rnrcspontJcnt:1
05.0(,.2014 7R066Jl 0.00 10,994 ,522.72 0.00 SR2,9J6.00 2224K8560RKG (RJ SRL INFOTON COM 1001160000 B.C'UNIBANK'S.A. Cump;,.rarc v:ilu1ci
I 1:04 2418 confom1 ccrcrci din
05.ll6.2014, curs 1K.87,
l5R293(, EUR)
0l.06.2014 7807941 10,994,) 22.72 0.00 )82,936.00 0.00 /LVJ0AIZK0000UI 0374416 MALTBY SOLUTIONS LP c/flipscstc /400886442300 PLATA IN AVANS PT
11 :06 39 DUKE AIZKLV22 TEHNICA DE CALCUL
STREET.EDINBURGH. CONF CONTR F/NR
UNITED KINGDOM OD 30.0l.2014 JNVO
JCEF/NR DD
J0.0~.2014
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 05/06/2014
Crediting amount 582,936.00
Credit from Sri lnfoton Com (UB)
Description (as per statement) FT14156517640399, ienakosais maksajums, nr.
FAAS415603713200, SRL INFOTON COM MOLDOVA,
CHISINAU, STR. TIGHINA, 12,, JOINT STOCK COMMERCIAL
BANK UNIBANK (JSCUMD2XXXX), konts
MD58JS000222468560886978, OUR, PREPMNT FOR TEHNICA
DE CALCUL CONF CONTR F/NR DD 30.05.2014 INVOICE F/NR
DD 30.05.2014
Summary description Prepayment for computers
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments EUR 582,936 is within+/- 1% of EUR 583,000
Figure 15: Tran sfer of funds received from Sri lnfoton Com to Bra nch Marke ting Ltd
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 29.10 .2013 ITdz 26 .06.2014
Darijuma
datums I
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids, Balance b/fwd EUR 434.82
datums informiicija par darijumu De bets Kredits
FT14156517640399, ienakosais maksajums, nr. FAAS415603713200,
SRL INFOTON COM MOLDOVA, CHISINAU, STR. TIGHINA, 12,.
JOINT STOCK COMMERCIAL BANK UNIBANK (JSCUMD2XXXX),
05.06.2014 +582 936 .00
konts MD58JS000222468560886978, OUR, PREPMNT FOR
TEHNICA DE CALCUL CONF CONTR F/NR DD 30.05.2014 INVOICE
F/NR DD 30.05.2014
FT14156540915067, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
05.06.2014 -4.00 Balance b/fwd EUR 583 ,366.82
583000.00 EUR no 05/06/2014
FT14156540915067, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 166, BRANCH
05.06.2014 MARKETING LTD., konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, Bo3apar -583 cioo.oo
IIIHBeCTl11l.jlllj;i
FT14157005640600, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1071, BRANCH
06.06 .2014 MARKETING LTD., reg. nr. 135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +15 350.00
111HB€CTllll.jllllll
FT14157073354400, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
06.06.2014 -50 .00
15312.00 EUR no 06/06/2014
FT14157073354400, izejosais maksajums, nr. 168, EASTEX
RESOURCES LTD, TALLINN BUSINESS BANK LTD
06.06.2014 -15 312.00
(TABUEE22XXX), konts EE040000009320041423, SHA, Payment
according to contract from 03.06.14 for electronics
FT14157031097058, ieksbankas maksajums, l<OMIIICClllfl 38 Bb1A8YY
06.06.2014 nOATBep~<.QeHlllfl 3a nnare~< FT14157073354400 15312.00 EUR .or -3.00
06/06/2014 '
FT14160047230582, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1080, BRANCH
09.06.2014 MARKETING LTD., reg . nr. 135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +25 500.00
IIIHBeCTllll.jllllll
FT14160710284321, komisija par maksajumu, maksa)uma sum ma
09.06.2014 -50.00
25500.00 EUR no 09/06/2014
FT14160710284321, izejosais maksajums, nr. 172, AGERCOM GRUP
SRL, BC BANCA SOCIALA SA (BSOCMD2XXXX), konts
09.06.2014 -25 500.00
MD41 BS000002224703085302, OUR, Payment according to contract
from 07 .05.14 for computers
FT14174510604076, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 174,294.81 USO=>
23.06.2014 +215.17
215.17 EUR, kurss 1.3701 , ··.
FT14174944231751, ieksbankas:maksajums, nr.1104, BRANCH
23.06.2014 MARKETING LTD., reg. nr.135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +10 000.00
IIIHBeCTllll.jllllll
FT14174975780012, komi§ija ·par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
23.06.2014 -4 .00
10000.00 EUR no 23/06/2014
FT14174975780012, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 175, COMPANY
23.06.2014 SERVICES INC., konts LV43AIZK0001140111300 , FINANCIAL - 10 000 00
CONSULTANCY SERVICES
\
FT14175909676086, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
24.06.2014 -4.00
408.00 EUR ri•, o
',._,
24/06/2014
FT14175909.676086, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 176, BRANCH
24.06.2014 MARKE_TING LTD., konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, Bo3apar -408 .00
IIIHBefT~ljllli:i
FT1_;f177964573206, ieksbankas maksajums, komisija par konta
26.06.2014 -100.99
~legsanu,
Darijumu saraksta beigas
,\
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 05/06/2014
Crediting amount 583,000.00
Credit from Maltby Solutions LP (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT14156540915067 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 166,
MALTBYSOLUTIONS LP, reg. nr. SL 14130, konts
LV30AIZK000001037 4456,Bo3spaT I/IHBecrn41111il
Summary description Return of investment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was EUR 1,318,300.97 . The credit of EUR
583,000 was attributed to the following debits:
1,9.
IEDRj 720 was 12aid to llan Sor (ABL~ - .91.nount traced for tile.
fpy_rposes of this examiSM
EUR 10,208 of EUR 36,765 which was converted to USD 50,000
- amount not traced for the purposes of this example
EUR 16,550 was paid to llan Sor (ABLV) - amount not traced for
the purposes of this example
EUR 118,806 was converted to USD 152,000 - amount not
traced for the purposes of this example
EUR 25,500 was paid to Maltby Solutions LP (ABLV)- amount
not traced for the purposes of this example
EUR 19,450 was paid to Vegwork impex LP (ABLV) - amount not
traced for the purposes of this example
EUR 19,750 was paid to Hamiltero Color Limited (ABLV)-
amount not traced for the purposes of this example
Figure 16: Transfer of funds received from Maltby Solutions LP to various accounts
I
06/06/'1f114
EUR 36, 765 - USD 50 ,000
(EJR l0, 206,al:t!ibutable )
I
09/06/2014
EUR l ll,606 · USD 152,000
I
l2/06/2v 14
-
EUR 37,010: USD 50,000
J,
Brand, Marketing Ltd
USD
(A.BLlf)
www.abl v.com
Kanta parskats
No 30.07.2013 ITdz 15.06.2015
Darijuma
datums I
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT14155677250190, izejosais maksajums, nr. 1065, BRANCH
04.06.2014 MARKETING LTD, EUROBANK CYPRUS LTD (ERBKCY2NXXX), -2 76 700 .00
konts CY45018000060000200100218505, SHA, Transfer maney
FT14156376004988, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 100, HAMILTERO
05.06.2014 COLOR LIMITED , reg. nr. 4166558, konts LV55AIZK0000010373133, +476 900.00
BoaspaT IIIHBeCTilll\lllM Balance b/fwd EUR 1,318,300 .97
FT14156540915067, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 166, MALTBY
05.06.2014 SOLUTIONS LP, reg. nr. SL 14130, konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, +583 000.00
BoaspaT IIIHBeCTIIIL\IIIM
FT14156540931168, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
05.06.2014 -4.00
220400.00 EUR no 05/06/2014
FT14156540931168, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1068, VEGWORK
05.06.2014 ·· -220 400 .00
IMPEX LP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390, L-1HBeCTilll\illill
FT14156540931248, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
05.06.2014 -4 .00
840160.00 EUR no 05/06/2014
FT14156540931248, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1069, TORPROM
05.06.2014 -840 160.00
UNIVERSAL LP, konts LV22AIZK0000010369168, L-1HBeCTilll\l1111
FT14157532286027, valutas konvertacija, nr. 1070, 71349.76 EUR:;>
06.06.2014 -71 349.76
97000 .00 USD, l<Urss 1.3595 ' .'
FT14157005640600, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
06.06.2014 -4 .00
15350.00 EUR no 06/06/2014
FT14157005640600, ieksbankas maksajums, nr.1071, MALTBY
06.06.2014 -15 350 .00
SOLUTIONS LP, konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, L-1HB9C;T11411111
FT14157905759074, val0tas konvertacija, nr. 1073, 70484.58 EUR=>
06.06.2014 -70 484 .58
96000.00 USD , kurss 1.362 ·
FT14157833412308, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
06.06.2014 -4 .00
74000.00 EUR no 06/06/2014 \
Balance b/fwd USO 609 ,540.63
FT14157833412308, ieksbankas maksajums, .ilr.1075, VEGWORK
06.06.2014 -74 000.00
IMPEX LP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390°,. L-1HB9CTIIIL\illl1
Balance b/fwd USO 572,775.92
FT14157795688800, val0las konvertacij,;i·,·nr. 1076, 36764.71 EUR=>
06.06.2014 -36 764.71
50000 .00 USD, kurss 1.36
FT14157019403016, komisija par m'~ksajumu, maksajuma summa
06.06.2014 -4 .00
16550.00 EUR no 06/06/2014 . .'
FT14157019403016, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1078, llan Sor, konts
06 .06.2014 -16 550.00
LV54AIZK0000010083121,JaCiM
FT14160694787017, valO~s-konvertacija, nr.1079, 111805.81 EUR=>
09.06.2014 -111 80 5.81
152000.00 USD, kurss 1.3595
FT1416004 7230582,.komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
09.06.2014 -4 .00
25500.00 EUR no 0fl/b6/2014
FT14160047230582, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1080, MALTBY
09.06.2014 -25 500.00
SOLUTIONS Ll1; konts LV30AIZK0000010374456, L-1HBeCTilll\illill
FT14160047,230744, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
09.06.2014 -4. 00
19450.00,EUR no 09/06/2014
FT14160047230744, ieksbankas maksajums, nr.1083, VEGWORK
09.06.2014 -19 4 50.00
IMPEXLP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390, L-1HsecTilll\illill
FP14160566873705, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
09.06.2014 -4.00
19750.00 EUR no 09/06/2014
·FT14160566873705, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1082, HAMILTERO
09 .06.2014 -19 750.00
COLOR LIMITED, konts LV55AIZK0000010373133, L-1HBeCTillllillill
FT14160288270139, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
09.06.2014 -4.00
107000.00 EUR no 09/06/2014
FT14160288270139, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1084, VEGWORK
09.06.2014 -107 000.00
IMPEX LP, konts LV71AIZK0000010371390, L-1HBeCTilll\illl1
FT14161503491392, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
10.06.2014 -4.00
119720.00 EUR no 10/06/2014
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registriicijas numurs, darijuma veids, Balance b/fwd EUR 272 ,696.11
datums informiicija par darijumu De bets Kredits
FT14161503491392, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1085, llan Sor, konts
10.06.2014 -119 720.00
LV54AIZK0000010083121, 3a~M
FT14162000218981, komisija par maksajumu , maksiijuma summa
11.06.2014 -4 .00
43050.00 EUR no 11/06/2014
FT14162000218981, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1086, Ilona Sor, konts
11.06.2014 -43 050.00
LV28AIZK0000010366441, Aorosop Ja~Ma OT 02.04.14
FT14163076607132, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
12.06.2014 -4.00
9100.00 EUR no 12/06/2014
FT14163076607132, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1087, llan Sor, konts
12.06.2014 -9 100 .00
LV54AIZK0000010083121, 3a~M .. •·
13.06.2014
FT14164736030700, ieksbankas maksajums , nr, 1093, llan Sor, konts
-30 145.00
LV54AIZK0000010083121, 3a~M
13.06.2014 FT14164006240619, komisija par maksajurriu; maksajuma summa
-50.00
(16.06.2014) 50100.00 EUR no 16/06/2014 ,·
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 10/06/2014
Crediting amount 119,720.00
Credit from Branch Marketing Ltd (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT14161503491392 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1085, !Ian Sor,
kontsLV54AIZK0000010083121, 3a1t1M
Summary description Loan
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments EUR 119,656.00 is within+/- 1% of EUR 119,720.00
Figure 17: Transfer from Mr Shor's ABL V account to Touristike s Ependiseis Kapsi
...,.r
::1 _____ 10/06 / 20 14 _ _ __,..:E
_ _ _ _ _ rn /06i 20 14 _ _ _ _ _
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 25.10.2010 ITdz 15.06.2015
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT14160672791242, ieksbankas maksajums, KoM111cc111H 3a BblAaYy
09.06.2014 nOATBep>KAeHll!H 3a nnaTell< FT14157281480407 16500.00 EUR OT -3 .00
09/06/2014
FT14161503491392, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1085, BRANCH
10.06.2014 MARKETING LTD., reg. nr. 135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +119 720.00
3aiiiM
10.06.2014 FT14161768602295, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
-50.00 ·
(11.06.2014) 119656.00 EUR no 11/06/2014
FT14161768602295, izejosais maksajums, nr. 22, TOURISTIKES
10.06.2014 EPENDISEIS KAPSI AE, PIRAEUS BANK SA (PIRBGRAAXXX), konts ·· 1
-11 9 656. 00
(11.06.2014) GR9401720530005053043500311, SHA, Payment according to
invoice for ho tels
FT14161675808588, ieksbankas maksajums, KoM111cc111H 3a BblAaYy
10.06.2014 nOATBep>KAeHll!H 3a nnaTe~< FT14161768602295 119656.00 EUR OT -3.00
10/06/2014
FT14162534987840, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 132, Ilona Sor, reg.
11 .06.2014 +43 100.00
nr. 0960409888888, konts LV28AIZK0000010366441, 3AI/IM
11.06.2014 FT14162871319395, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
-50.00
(12.06.2014) 22971.75 EUR no 12/06/2014
FT14162871319395, izejosais maksajums, nr. 25, KLINIKUM DER- ·
UNIVERSITAT MUNCHEN, BAYERISCHE LANDESBANK, .
11.06.2014
MUENCHEN (BYLADEMMXXX), konts DE41700500000000020040, -22 971 .75
(12.06.2014)
SHA, Advance payment for inpatient treat men! SHOR MINA ·: date of
brith 25.1 2.52., number 22149059 · ·
FT14162230145108, ieksbankas maksajums, KoM111cc111R ·:ia BblAaYy
11.06.2014 nOATBep~<,QeHll!H 3a nnaTe~< FT14162871319395 22971.75 EUR OT -3.00
11/06/2014
FT14162445259795, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
12.06.2014 -50 .00
20000.00 EUR no 12/06/2014 '
FT14162445259795, izejosais maksajums, hr. 24, VECTOR
INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LTD, FBME BANK LTD
12.06.2014 -20 000 .00
(FBMECY2NXXX), konts CY7511501001052535EURCACC001, SHA,
Payment according to invoice 06/J-2 fqr goods
FT14163100077847, ieksbankas m?k'sajums, KoMIIICCIIIH 3a BblAaYy
12.06.2014 noATBep>KAeHIIIH 3a nnaTe~( FT14162445259795 20000.00 EUR OT -3.00
12/06/2014 '~.
2.5 Example 3
Example 3 involves a series of transactions whereby loan proceeds from UB granted to Shor Group
company Apropro-Com Sri (account number 22244856093697) on 18/12/2013 were transferred
through a series of accounts at ABLV before the funds were transferred to a Gazprombank account
held in the name of Mr Shor (account number 42601978000210000052).
The funds were transferred through the following accounts before they were transferred to Mr
Shor's Gazprombank account:
• Apropro-Com Sri, UB, (22244856093697);
• Division Top LLP, ABLV, (LV77 AIZK 0000 0103 5653 8);
• Branch Marketing Ltd, ABLV, (LV82 AIZK 0000 0103 7313 2) ;
• Neonila System LLP, ABLV, (LV43 AIZK 0001 1401 1343 4); and,
• llan Shor, 2 ABLV, (LV54 AIZK 0000 0100 8312 1).
According to the payment descriptions, the loan was granted for the advance payment of jewellery
and accessories. They payment description for the final transfer from llan Shor's ABLV account to
the Gazprom bank account in his name stated that the transfer was for "Maney transfer", which most
likely refers to "Money transfer". No reference of the advance payment for jewellery and
accessories (as per the description of the initial transfer of the loan) was identified in the payment
description for th is transfer.
The loan was initially repaid by funds from an overdraft granted by Privatbank (Latvia) to an account
in the name of Transmark Export LP on 05/11/2014. The overdraft was repaid in the course of the
switch of loan exposure from BEM to BS on 25 and 26 November 2014, detailed further in Section
6 of the Detailed Report. The loan repayments are summarised in the figures below.
2
llan Shor's name has been spelled as "Shor" throughout this report, however, the ABLV records show the spelling as
"Sor".
Figure 18: Repayment of ioan Nr 174113 from overdraft to Transmarl< Export LP (Privatbanl<)
--
Privatbank overdraft
05/11/2014
EUR 10,_027,467
-
Transmark Export LP
(Privatbank)
05/11/2014
EUR 10,027,400
EURrOO
05/11/2014
EUR 47,000
_ _ _ _ _ EUR 5,499,145 _ _ _ __,. 05/11/2014 - - - - -
EUR 3,385,072 EUR 7,755,000 /
Fidan Properties LLP EUR 1,019,700 Apropro Com Sri Loan account 142200100004655978
(Privatbank) EUR 113,300 UB Loan reference Nr 174/13 din 18.12.2013
EUR 10,450
Figure 19: Repaym ent of overdraft to Transmark Export LP (Privatba nl<) as part of the Switc/7
..
Caritas Group (BS)
ljf ••
Danmira SRL (BS
lil-41J
Davema com SRL (BS)
.,.
Contrade SRL (BS)
;,,.;
t
39.2 Transferred to Fortuna United LLP
I
184.6
I
215.7
I
227.4
I
164.6
I
I
:...__ 39 · 2- -
l l
16r Jasterport LP (BS)
1 1 Tennant Shipping LP
Vercell solutions LP
t
39.2
74.2 /
23.9
Overdraft 387.8 Overdraft 167 I
Overdraft 166.9
"fl,u=" I\
Hansa Investment LP Mego Exports LP Nord LP ~
Overdraft 405.4
2
.... ... .., .. . ······ l
T
228.7 .4~ -
.. :{ '
-· 209.3
l
Privatbank
3.7 / o.9 W:::
:-:::;i \ Tenos Systems
I
"" ■ (V1ctonabank)
KEY:
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 18/12/2013
Crediting amount 7,755,000.00
Credit from Apropro-Com Sri loan account (142200100004655978)
Description (as per statement) Eliberarea creditului in conf. cu contr. de credit Nr. 174/13 din
18.12.2013
Summary description Issuing of credit contract Nr 174/13
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
Figure 20: Transfe r of loan funds from Apropro-Com Sri to Division Top LLP
Sold initial:
Data Debit lvaluta\ Credit (valuta l Cont Contraeentul Banca coresuondenta Destinatia olatii
I
18.12.2013
18.12.2013
18.12.2013
14:32
14:42
14:52
0.00
7,755,000.00
0.00
7,755,000.00 142200100004655978
0.00 /L V77 AIZK000001035653
84.17 222468560936
(R) APROPO-COM SRL 174/13
DIVISION TOP LLP
(R) APROPO-COM SRL
B.C'UNIBANK'S.A.
/400886442300
B.C.'UNIBANK'S .A.
Eliberarea creditului in conf. cu contr. de credit Nr. I 74/13 din 18.12.2013
PL IN AV ANS PT BIJUTERII SI ACCESOR I CONF CONTR F/NR DD
Cumparare valutei conform nota plata 5904188 din 18.12.2013
I
18.12.20 13 14:53 84.17 0.00 17580100004655498 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Plata comisionului pentru exarninarea cererii de credit in conformitate cu
18. 12.20 13 I6:44 0.00 3,877.50 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Cumparare valutei conform nota plata 5904187 din 18.12.2013
18.12.20 13 16:44 3,877.50 0.00 17580100004655978 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Plata comisionului pentru eliberarea creditului in conformitate cu contract de
20.12.2013 12:08 0.00 4,085 ,463 .84 222468560936840 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Convertarea valutei conform cererei din 20.12.2013
20.12 .2013 12: 14 4,085,463 .84 0.00 /L V77 AIZK00000 1035653 DIVISION TOP LLP /400886442300 PL IN A VANS PT BIJUTERII SI ACCESOR I CONF CONTR F/NR DD
31.12.2013 11:36 0.00 28,004.17 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C'UNIBANK'S .A. Cumparare valutei confonn cererei din 31.12.2013
31.12.2013 11:37 28,004 .17 0 00 173600100004655978 (R) APROPO-COM SRL 174/13 B.C.'UNIBANK'S .A. Plata dobanzii in conformitate cu contract de credit Nr. 174/13 din 18.12.2013
21.01.2014 10:28 0.00 1,000,000 .00 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Cumparare valutei conform cererei din 21.01.2014
21.01.2014 10:34 1,000,000.00 0.00 /L V77 AIZK00000 1035653 DIVISION TOP LLP /400886442300 PL IN AV ANS PT BIJUTERII SI ACCESOR I CONF CONTR F/NR DD
22 01.2014 I0:47 0.00 1,088,843. 00 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Cumparare valutei confonn cererei din 22.0l.20I4
22.0l.20 I4 11 :46 1,088,843 .00 0.00 /L V77 AIZK000001035653 DIVISION TOP LLP /400886442300 PL IN AV ANS PT BIJUTERII SI ACCESOR I CONF CONTR F /NR DD
27 .01.2014 11 :02 0.00 1,208,560 .00 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A . Cum para re valutei confo1m cererei din 27 .01 .2014
27.01.2014 11 :03 1,208,560.00 0.00 /L V77 AIZK00000 I035653 DIVISION TOP LLP /400886442300 PL IN AVANS PT BIJUTERII SI ACCESOR I CONF CONTR F/NR DD
31.01.2014 16:48 0.00 64,625.00 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Cumparare valutei conform cererei din 31.01.2014
31.01.2014 16:48 64,625 .00 0.00 173600100004655978 (R) APROPO-COM SRL 174/13 B.C.'UNIBANK'S .A. Plata dobanzii in conformitate cu contract de credit Nr. 174/13 din 18.12.2013
28.02.2014 10:59 0.00 129,649.00 /L V87 AIZK00000 I 036460 BELMONT UNITED LP ABL V BANK, AS PAYMENT ACCORDING TO CONTRACT FROM 20.02.14
28 .02.2014 12:35 62,578 .54 0.00 173600100004655978 (R) APROPO-COM SRL 174/13 B.C'UNIBANK'S .A. Plata dobanzii in confonnitate cu contract de credit Nr. 174/13 din 18.12.2013
28.02 .2014 15:16 67,070 .00 0.00 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S .A. Vinzare valutei conform cererei din 28.02.2014
31.03 .2014 16:42 0.00 61,393.75 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S .A. Cumparare valutei conform cererei din 31.03.2014, curs 18.58
31.03.2014 17:28 61,393.75 0.00 173600100004655978 (R) APROPO-COM SRL 174/ 13 B.C.'UNIBANK'S .A. Plata dobanzii in conformitate cu contract de credit Nr. 174/13 din 18.12.2013
30.04.2014 15:04 0.00 61,393.75 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Cumparare valutei confonn cererei din 30.04.2014, curs 18.77
30.04.2014 15:04 61,393 .75 0.00 l 73600100004655978 (R) APROPO-COM SRL 174/13 B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Plata dobanzii in conformitate cu contract de credit Nr. 174/13 din 18.12.20 13
30.05 .2014 10:54 0.00 61,393 .75 222468560936 (R) APROPO-COM SRL B.C.'UNIBANK'S.A. Cumparare valutei conform cererei din 30.05 .2014 , curs 18.92
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 18/12/2013
Crediting amount 7,755,000.00
Credit from Apropro-Com Sri (UB)
Description (as per statement) APROPO-COM SRL STR. TIGHINA 12 CHISINAU MOLDOVA,
JOINT STOCK COMMERCIAL BANK UNIBANK
(JSCUMD2XXXX) , konts MD34JS000222448560936978, OUR,
PREPMNT FOR BIJUTERII SI ACCESORI CONTR W/N DD
16.12.13 INVOICE WIN DD 16.12.13
Summary description Prepayment for jewellery and accessories
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
Figure 21 : Transfer of funds received from Apropro-Com Sri to Branch Marketing Ltd
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 14.09.2012 ITdz 19.03.2014
Dari]uma
datums/
valutesanas Dari]uma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13330039374338, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 281, BRANCH
26 .11.2013 MARKETING LTD., reg. nr. 135,034, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, +30 750.00
IIIHBeCTll1L.\1<11<1
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 18/12/2013
Crediting amount 7,755,000.00
Credit from Division Top LLP (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13352703977454, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 46, DIVISION
TOP LLP, reg. nr. OC376459, konts LV77AIZK0000010356538,
B03BPaT VlHBeCTI/IL\vllll
Summary description Return of investment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments EUR 7 ,758,000 is within+/- 1 % of EUR 7,755 ,000
Figure 22: Transfer of funds received from Division Top LLP to Neonila Systems LLP
www.ablv. com
Kanta parskats
No 30.07.2013 ITdz 15.06.2015
DarTjuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13227013406473 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 393, ~(us
15.08.2013 OPERATIONS LTD., reg . nr. 132,467, konts LV59AIZK0000010366659, +500 .00
IIIHB8CTl'11..\1'11'1
FT13231302852663 , ieksbankas maksajums, m. 405, PLUS
19.08.2013 OPERATIONS LTD ., reg . nr. 132,467, konts LV59AIZK0000010366659, +6 378 000 .00
IIIHBeCTl'11..\1'11'1 .
-1
FT13231930902409 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 1, IT-LOG ALLIANCE
19.08.2013 :. -298 000.00
LLP, konts LV83AIZK0000010347506, IIIHBeCTl'11..\1'11'1
FT13231930909445, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
19.08.2013 -5 .33
241000.00 USO no 19/08/2013
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
---
FT13352485033323, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 394, 9312 .90 EUR=>
18.12.2013 -9 312.90
12700.00 USO, kurss 1.3637
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 18/12/2013
Crediting amount 7,758,000.00
Credit from Branch Marketing Ltd (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13352703990008, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 396, BRANCH
MARKETING LTD, konts LV82AIZK0000010373132,
VIHBeCTliH.\1/11/1
Summary description Investment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was EUR 639.49 (treated as nil according to the
tracing methodology).
Figure 23.· Tra nsfer of funds received from Branch Marketing Ltd to Mr Shor
Privileged an d confidential 59
Example 3 Transaction 4
Account cover page
Neonila System LLP ABL V Statement Extract (EUR)
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 25.05.2009 ITdz 24.06.2014
DarTjuma
datums I
valutesanas DarTjuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
'
29.05.2009 200905295630132, overdrafta izsniegsana +43.57
200905295630131, valotas konvertacija,
29.05.2009 -43 57
(#1 ), Konv. 30 .00 EUR <= 43.57 USO , kurss - 1.45236768
200906016530020, ieksbankas parskaitijums, .
(#54), PARSELOT LTD. , reg. Nr. 5940320, AS AIZKRAUKLES BANKA,
01.06.2009 +500 .00
konts LV38AIZK0001140081126, PAYMENT FOR CONSALTING
SERVICES ',
Neonila System LLP to llan Sor - EUR 4,083,000 and EUR 3,502,000
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13248155679056, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 92, PLUS
05.09.2013 OPERATIONS LTD ., konts LV59AIZK0000010366659, BoJapaT -279 700.00
1'1HBecn11.1i,i1,1
FT13358254495065, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 96, BRANCH Balance b/fwd : EUR 183,617 .50
24.12.2013 MARKETING LTD., konts LV82AIZK0000010373132, B03epaT -183 000.00
IIIHBeCTllll.jillli\
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 18/12/2013
Crediting amount 4,083,000
Credit from Neonila System LLP (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13352012596881, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 94, NEONILA
SYSTEM LLP, reg. nr. OC344125, konts
LV43AIZK0001140113434, Payment according to Loan
Agreement from 17 .12 .13
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd (credit of EUR 4,083,000 on 18/12/2013) was EUR
787.93 (treated as nil in accordance with the tracing
methodology) .
Figure 24: Transfer of funds rece ived from Neonila Systems LLP to a Gazprombank (Russia) account in tile
name of Mr Shor
v,.,wv.,, ablv.com
Konta parskats
\·
Dar"ijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids ,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
has held management or directorship positions at Shor Group companies Asigromex Srl 2 in 2010 and
ICS Grand lmobiliare SRL. Additionally, an account at Alef Bank in the name of Maclovici was used to
fund UB shareholders Marina Tauber and Viorel Melnic in August 2012 (see Section 7 of the Detailed
Report).
Kroll has treated all amounts received from Alef Bank accounts as linked to the suspected fraud
based on a number of links that were identified between these accounts and the onward dissipation of
loan funds through the Core Laundering Mechanism . Additional detail regarding amounts received
from Russian accounts is included in Section 11 of the Detailed Report.
Kroll has traced two of the payments, which were made to Maclovici's ABLV bank
account (details below) to identify the source of the fund flows and to provide evidence to Maclovici's
receipt of suspected fraud funds. Kroll has traced two payments made to an account in
Maclovici's name totalling USD 19,900 with the description "Account replenishment":
A further 12 transactions were identified, totalling USD 159,991 (equivalent). These payments all
included the translated description "account replenishment" and were made to Maclovici's ABLV
account LV65AIZK0000010358015.
Details of fund flows for traces 1 and 2 are included in this evidence pack. All traces were conducted in
accordance with the forensic funds tracing methodology ("tracing methodology"), described in detail in
Section 9 of the Detailed Report.
4
Approximately EUR 1.6 million of the EUR 3.8 million transfer was used to fund the Roseau cession agreement in BEM .
detailed in Section 7 of the Detailed Report.
5
As noted above and detailed in Section 11 of the Detailed Report, amounts received from accounts at Alef Bank were
treated as linked to suspected fraud funds .
Marim; Tcuber
(Alef• Bank)
I
27/06/ 2013
EUR 3r~.,:.:,.;
I
27i06/20 13
EUR3r ,, 100
~
-=-
- 27/06/2013 27}06 ,'20 13
--EUR 2, 19~,soo --==- --E'-IR 91.~68 -'uso 119 ,00,j-
L:-1
~
27/C,612013
--USO 1°19,800 --
- 27/06 {2013
- -USO 9,800 --="
-
Regional Group Ltd Plus Operations Ltd Plus Operations Ltd Ion Cojocaru Alexandr Madovici
(AB LV) ELR USD (AB LV) (ABLV)
(AB L\') ~AB!..\'~
6
As detailed in Section 8 of the Detailed Report, the blending and splitting of funds occurred frequently in
transactions within Core Laundering Accounts to disguise the source of funds and provide additional layering
between the source and the end destination .
~
/
A;:er::om G'n.·~ S?..L
{SC 6~n::~ $ode!.! SA)
I
29/0S/ 2013
;,,D, 5!r9,6S5
29/06/2013
I
MDL 5 !.999,55} USD 3,040,650
I
29/0S/ 20l3
E\R 3140,660
3.3 Example 1
Example 1 involves a series of transactions and the flow of funds from Marina Tauber's bank
account with Alef Bank (Russia, account number 40820978000000134529) to Maclovici's ABLV
account (Latvia, account number LV65AIZK0000010358015). Tracing identified a portion of these
funds, USO 9,100, was paid to Maclovici on 27 June 2013.
The funds were transferred through the following accounts, all on the same date, prior to a portion
being transferred to Maclovici's bank account:
• Armadale Business Services LLP, ABLV (Latvia, account number
LV07 AIZK0000010356537) ;
• Regional Group Ltd, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV49AIZK0000010367518) ;
• Plus Operations Ltd, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV59AIZK0000010366659); and
• Ion Cojocaru, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV55AIZK0000010111330).
The purpose of the payment received from Marina Tauber's account at Alef Bank as stated in the
bank statement description was shown to be in relation to an agreement dated 19 June 2013 . No
further details relating to the purposes of the funds were determinable from the payment
description.
As described in more detail in Section 11 of the Detailed Report, funds from a number of accounts
at Alef Bank (Russia) in the name of individuals and Shor Group companies , including that in the
name of Marina Tauber, were used to further disguise the flow of funds. Funds were transferred in
a circular mechanism between these accounts and accounts used in the Core Laundering
Mechanism. These funds were treated as being linked to the onward transfer of loan funds from
the suspected fraud at the Three Moldovan Banks.
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 27/06/2013
Crediting amount 3,824,000.00
Credit from Marina Tauber (Alef Bank)
Description (as per statement) FT13178018222470, ienakosais maksajums, nr.
ASW23526/270613 , TAUBER MARINA REPUBLICA MOLDOVA,
CHISINAU, UL. MITROPOLITA DOSOFTEYA, 97-1-45, ALEF
BANK (ALEFRUMMXXX), !<ants 40820978000000134529, OUR,
PAYMENT BY AGREEMENT DD 19.06.2013
Summary description Payment by agreement on 19 June 2013
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
Figure 3: Transfer of funds rece ived from Marina Tauber (Metro/Jank) to Regional Group Ltd
27/06/ 20 13 27/06j 20 13
EUR 3,8 24,000 EUR 3,3 24 . 100
Marina Tauber Arm adale Business Services LLP Regional Group Ltd
Alef-Bank rP.8Ll/j ABLVl
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 18.09.2012 lidz 02.05.2014
Valota EUR
Parskata periods 18.09.2012 - 02.05.2014
Sakuma atlikums +0.00 Debe ta apgrozljums -·15 520 800.00
Beigu atlikums +0.00 Kredlla apgrozljums +15 520 800.00
(t.sk. nakotne pieejamas summas) (t.sk. nakotne pieejamas summas)
Dari]uma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13176147694207, ienakosais maksajums, nr. ASW83923/240613,
COISMAN NADEJDA REPUBLICA MOLDOVA, CHISINAU, UL.
25.06.2013 GRADINA BOTANIKA, 12-141 A , ALEF-BANK (ALEFRUMMXXX), konts +4 395 000 .00
40820978600000134521, OUR, PAYMENT BY CONTRACT N26/13
DD 20.06 .2013
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 27/06/2013
Crediting amount 3,824,100.00
Credit from Armadale Business Services LLP (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13178510075439, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 5, ARMADALE
BUSINESS SERVICES LLP, reg . nr. SO303756, konts
LV07AIZK0000010356537, Bo3spaT I/IHBeCTl/ll..1111111
Summary description Return on investment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was EUR 11,470,800. The EUR 3,824,100 funds
received from Armadale Business Services LLP was transferred
onwards as follows:
7
This payment was used to fund the non-performing loans cession agreement in BEM, described further in Section 7 of
the Detailed Report.
Figure 4: Transfer of funds rece ived from Armadale Business Services LLP to Plus Operations
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 22.05.2013 ITdz 20.09.2013
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
Val0ta EUR
Parskata periods 22.05.2013 - 20.09.2013
Sakuma atlikums +0.00 Debe\a apg rozTj ums -57 54 1 500 .00
Beigu atlikums +0.00 KredTta apgrozijums +57 541 500.00
(t.sk. nakotne pieejamas summas) (t.sk. nakotne pieejamas summas)
DarTjuma
datums/
valutesanas DarTjuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13178088073234, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 11, SALVADOR
27.06.2013 TRADE LP, reg. nr. 11011, konts LV11AIZK0000010356465, BoJspaT +3 824 000.00
t-1HBeCT1114t,1i1
FT13178544780876, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 2, DALLINGTON
27.06.2013 INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, reg . nr. 3284508, konts +3 823 300.00
LV26AIZK0000010360366, Bo3BpaT L,1HBecrn4t-1i1
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Plus Operations Ltd
Account number LV59AIZK0000010366659
Account currency EUR
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 27/06/2013
Crediting amount 2,194,500.00
Credit from Regional Group Ltd (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13178858062807, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 5,
REGIONALGROUP LTD., reg . nr. 132,474, konts
LV49AIZK0000010367518,lllHBeCT111L\111111
Summary description Investments
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was EUR 137,614.17. The credit of EUR
2,194,500 from Regional Group Ltd was transferred as follows:
Figure 5: Transfer of funds rece ivecl from Regional Group Ltd to various accoun ts
I
f
- /
Primoteks import LP
/1
(ABL\/)
II 27/06/ 2013
1 27/06/ 20,3
EUR 09,700 Wang and Lee LP
EUR 190,000 / /-, (ABLV)
I i Gl/07/2013
27/06/2013 / EUR 24,500 //
EUR 572,636 - USD 745,000 / / I /
(EUR 435,0 22 attributable) / / /
I / ;7 Division Top LLP
-
28/06/2013 / / , 1 ,,, / (ABLVI
EUR94.593 -·uso 123,500 / / 27, 06, 2013 ,,,,.,,,,. '
: / / aJ_R 45,200 /
01/07/2013 / / / ,,,,,,,,
EUR 1,200 -USO 1, 55 1/ / // //
I / / / / _,,,,,,,.,.,, Blue Fontein LlP
02i07/ 2013
<':UR 153,716 - USO 20 ,000
rJ. I / 27/0' ' 20
' o, l
3 _,,,, ,-
----- (AB LI/)
(<:UR 8, 267 attributable) / / / §UR 4 ?,300 ,,.- _,,,,
' I I / ,,,,.,,,,. 21/06/2013 _,,,,
-
f / / ,,,,.,,,,. B..!RS0,100
-----
1 I I / / _., ,- -- -- -- -- -- insseb (PTY) Ltd
/ / / / _,,,,,,.-__, 27/06/2013 ---- (ABLI/)
I I I ,:;../ / ----·EUR 7,100
I,~ .. ~.,,..,,...,.._ _...--------
27/06/ 2013
27/06/2013 - - - ~ - :::------- EUP.91,468 ----,;,- =
EUR 2, 194,500 ~ ----- - -> USO !!9.000
Regional Group Ltd Plus Operations Ltd ---._ - - _ Plus Operations Ltd
(~.BLV) EUR '- ---._....__ --27/06/ 2013 USO
(ABL\/) "'-.'- ....__....__....__ EUP.Sl,200 - _ (ABLV)
I \ ' \ "'-. '-..____ ---......__ '-----~=-...-:;-=:--------'
\ \ '\' '-, ----27/06/2013 - --
\ \ ' \ ' , '-..____ EU?. 95,400
\
\
\
\
'\
'\
' '
'-
27/06j'l.013
--------
------------
Ion Cojocaru
{ABLV)
\ \ '\ ' , EUR 26, 500 ---._..__,_
\
\
\
\
'\
'\
"-
27/06/ 2013 '-,
...... , -----
-
\ \ '\EUR l04, 500 '- '- Elma Union LLP
\ \ '\ "'-. '.. (A.3LV)
\ \ 27/06/ 2013', '- , .
\ \ EUR 14,!00 , ~
01/07/2013
\
\\
\
\
.'\
'\ ' \
''
EUR !,650 \ 's., 5unburough !~?ustries LP
I \ 27/06/2013 '\ ', (ASL, )
I \ EUP.,2w, 100 '\ --..,,.
I 27/06/20 13 26/0~2013 '\
I EUR ?00, lOO EUR 5 l, 500 '\ _ .
I \ \ ' \' orprom Urnversal LP
-
I 27/06/2iJ 13 \ '\ (ASLV)
I a rR t9~,ooo \ '\
I 27/0o/1m \
I EUR 50,0~0 \\
I Ekovold Project Limited
- -
I \ \ (ABLY)
I \ \
'v
" ""
Neonila System LLD P.anaroom Mana.Qement LLP ::den Amance LP
(A6 LV) (ASL\/) (ABLV)
www.ablv.com
Kanta parskats
No 22.05.2013 ITdz 01.01.2014
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13175876629260, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 143, 247706.42 EUR=>
24.06.2013 -247 706 .42
324000.00 USO, kurss 1.308
FT13176524400901, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 4, ARMAOALE
25.06 .2013 BUSINESS SERVICES LLP, reg. nr. S0303756, konts +4 394 700.00
LV07AIZK0000010356537, B03epar 111HeecrnL1111lii
FT13176040823300, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 146, 4412325.53 EUR=>
25.06.2013 -4 41 2 32 5.53 ·
5785000.00 USO, kurss 1.3111
FT13176177136086, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 148, 19236.64 EUR=> '
25.06.2013 -1 9 23'6:64
25200.00 USO, kurss 1.31
FT13176718003058, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
25.06.2013 -4.00
6000.00 EUR no 25/06/2013
FT13176718003058, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 150, Ion Cojocaru, \
25.06.2013 . -6 000.00
konts LV55AIZK0000010111330, Alt1Blt1AEHTbl
FT13176739098091, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 151 , 124444.78 EUR=>
25.06.2013 - 124 444.78
162500.00 USO, kurss 1.3058
FT13177891813917, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
26.06.2013 -4.00
75000.00 EUR no 26/06/2013
FT13177891813917, ieksbankas maksajums, nr.153, WANG ANO ;:_:
26.06 .2013 -75 000.00
LEE LP, konts LV97 AIZK0000010366557, lt1HsecT111L\111111
FT13178120152370, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
27.06.2013 -4 .00
21100.00 EUR no 27/06/2013
FT13178120152370, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 154, RQl:DON
27.06.2013 -21 100.00
CAPITAL CORP., konts LV22AIZK0000010367519, lt1Heegt111L1111111 Balance b/lwd USO 137 ,614 .17
FT13178858062807 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 5, REGIONAL
27 .06.2013 GROUP LTD., reg . nr. 132,474, konts LV49AIZK0000010367518, +2 194 500.00
lt1HBeCTll1L\111111 ', .>
DarTjuma
datums/
valutesanas DarTjuma registracijas numurs, darTjuma veids,
datums informacija par darTjumu Debets KredTts
---
FT13178748838940, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 164, VISSETI (PTY)
27 .06.2013 -7 100.00
LTD , konls LV06AIZK0000010367516, 1!1Hsecn14v1v1
---
FT13178275440651, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
27.06.2013 -4 .00
80100.00 EUR no 27/06/2013
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Plus Operations Ltd
Account number LV59AIZK0000010366659
Account currency USD
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments USD 119,800 is within +/-1% ofUSD 119,000 .
-
Figure 6: Conversion of funds rece ived from Regional Group Ltd to USO and transfer to Ion Cojocaru
Darijuma
datums I
valutesanas Darijuma registriicijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informiicija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13172782910252, ieksbankas maksiijums, nr. 141, EKOVOLD
21 .06.2013 -500.00
PROJECT LIMITED, konts LV43AIZK0000010366559, lllHBecrnl..lllllll
FT13175876629260, val0tas konvertiicija, nr. 143, 247706.42 EUR=>
24.06.2013 +324 000.00
324000.00 USO, kurss 1.308
FT13175558096347, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
24.06.2013 -5.30
50100.00 USO no 24/06/2013
FT13175558096347, ieksbankas maksiijums, nr. 144, ROMANFORD
24 .06.2013 -50 100.0·0
SOLUTIONS LP, konts LV60AIZK0000010365671 , 111Heecrnl..llllill
FT13175707563230, komisija par maksajumu, maksiijuma summa
24.06.2013 -5.30
214000.00 USD no 24/06/2013
FT13175707563230, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 145, WANG AND
24. 06.2013 · -'214 000.00
LEE LP, konts LV97AIZK0000010366557, 111Hsecrnl..lillill
FT13175748067704, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 6, WESTER
,·
25 .06.2013 ALLIANCE LLP, reg . nr. SO303115, konts LV12AIZK0000010337532, +1 659 700.00
B03Bpar VIHBeCTilll.llllH
FT13176040823300, val0tas konvertacija, nr. 146, 4412325.53 EUR=>
25.06.2013 +5 785 000.00
5785000.00 USO, kurss 1.3111
FT13176791963701 , komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa . :; · ·
25 .06.2013 -5.29
8032100.00 USO no 25/06/2013
FT13176791963701 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr.147, PANAROdM
25 .06.2013 -8 032 100 .00
MANAGEMENT LLP, konts LV67AIZK0000010347503, lllHBeC,1111..lilllll
FT13176177136086, val0tas konvertacija, nr. 148, 19236.94 EUR=>
25.06.2013 +25 200.00
25200.00 USD, kurss 1.31
FT13176779927122, komisija par maksajumu, maksiijuma summa
25.06.2013 -5.29
25200.00 USD no 25/06/2013
FT13176779927122, ieksbankas maksajums, nr, 1'49, PRIMOTEKS
25.06.2013 IMPORT LP, konts LV66AIZK0000010357803, ltl1-1BeCT1111..lillOHHafl -2 5 200.00
Aef!Te/lbHOCTb
FT13176739098091, val0tas konvertacija:·rir. 151, 124444.78 EUR=>
25.06.2013 +162 500.00
162500.00 USD, kurss 1.3058
FT13176027320369, komisija par m?ksiijumu, maksajuma summa
25.06.2013 -5.29
162300.00 USD no 25/06/2013
FT13176027320369, ieksbankas maksiijums, nr. 152, PANAROOM
25 .06.2013 -162 300.00
MANAGEMENT LLP, konts LV67AIZK0000010347503, lllHsecTllll..lillill
FT13178730954387, val0tas .konvertiicija, nr. 156, 572636.43 EUR=>
27.06.2013 +745 000.00
745000.00 USD, kurss qo1
FT13178608496805, korriisija par maksajumu, maksiijuma summa
27.06.2013 -5 .23
223000.00 USO no 27i 06/2013
FT131786084968Qi; ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 161 , WANG AND
27.06.2013 -223 000.00
LEE LP, konts LV97AIZK0000010366557,
:, .
lllHsecTllll..lillill
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Ion Cojocaru
Account number LV55AIZK0000010111330
Account currency USO
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 27/06/2013
Crediting amount 119,800.00
Credit from Plus Operations Ltd
Description (as per statement) FT13178208297913, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 175, PLUS
OPERATIONS LTD., reg. nr. 132,467, konts
LV59AIZK0000010366659, ,Ql/lBl/1,QEHTbl
Summary description Dividends
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was nil. The transfer from Plus Operations Ltd was
distributed as follows :
USO 16,600 was paid to Tudor Negru 8 - not traced on for the
purposes of this example
USO 3,900 was paid to Vasile Lasco - not traced on for the
purposes of this example
USO 41,200 was paid to Maria Gutuleac 9 - not traced on for the
purposes of this example
USO 33,400 was paid to Lupov Veaceslav 10 - not traced on for
the purposes of this example
:Oso 9,800 was paidt o Alexandr Maclovici - amount traced for
the purposes of this example
USO 14,900 was paid to Mester Moisei - not traced on for the
purposes of this example
8
Tudor Negru and Vasile Lasco both had accounts at Alef Bank that transferred money to accounts at ABL V /
Privatbank linked to suspected fraud funds (see Confidential Working Papers Part I).
9
Maria Gutuleac, Alexandr Maclovici and Mester Moisei all have Alef Bank accounts that were used to fund UB
shareholders, as detailed in Section 7 of the Detailed Report.
10
Veaceslav Lupov is a shareholder of UB (as detailed in Section 7 of the Detailed Report) . An Alef Bank account in the
name of Lupov transferred money to accounts at ABL V / Privatbank linked to suspected fraud funds (see Confidential
Working Papers Part I).
Figure 7: Transfer of funds received from Plus Operations Ltd to various individua ls, including Maclovici
/
/
/,?/
-
l"-leoruTudor
(ABL'>/)
27i1}6/2013
USD 16,600 ,,,,,,_,..,,.
-
/ .
/ ,,,-, /. Vasile Lasco
/ ./ (ABLV)
/ 27/06/2013
/ USD 3,900
/
/
,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,, ,-"'}'
----- ------
/ ,,,-,/ .--USO 41, 200 (ABL\I}
/ ,/_
/,,,-,/
- - - - - - 27/06i2013 - - - - -- ::::-- .,.-- 27/06/2013 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _,+ _ __
USD119,800 m:::""' ----- USD9, 800
Plus Operations Ltd Ic,n Cojocaru ' ; : - - -- __ Alexandr Madovid
(ABL'tl} {ABLV) '-...___ -------- (ABLV)
', ------,27i06F2013
'- USO~, 4.-n
27/ D6i2013 j~, ,J'--J>.
www.ablv.com
Kanta parskats
No 29.10.2012 ITdz 15.06.2015
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 27/06/2013
Crediting amount 9,800.00
Credit from Ion Cojocaru (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13178825766736, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 18, Ion
Cojocaru, reg. nr. 0970502489132, konts
LV55AIZK00000 10111330, nononHeHl/le C4eTa
Summary description Account replenishment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd is nil. The USO 9,800 was traced on to the
following transfers:
USO 100 was paid in bank charges - amount not traced on for
the purposes of this example
l!JSD 9,700 was transferred to Alexandr Maclovici (Alef Ban~)
-
Figure 8: Tra nsfer of funds received fro m Ion Cojocaru to Alexandr Maclovici (Metroba nk)
/
/ 7 Bank d1aroes
-
// (A.BL\/)
27/06/ 20 l 3
,..,USO 100
/
//
/
-------'27/06/ 20 13_ _ _ _ _ _ _ , 27/06/2013 _ _ _ _ _~ ,
USO 9,800 a:::"' USD 9.700
Ion Coiocaru Alexandr Madovid Alexandr Madovid
(ASL\/) (AB LV) (Alef Bank)
www.ablv.com
Kanta parskats
No 06.09.2012 ITdz 17.03.2014
3.4 Example 2
Example 2 involves the transfer of USO 10,100 of the funds from a loan issued by Banca Sociala
to Agercom Grup SRL on 29 August 2013 which was transferred to Maclovici on the same day. The
funds were transferred from Agercom Grup SRL's loan account to Agercom Grup SRL's MDL and
EUR accounts, and through three ABLV accounts prior to being transferred to Maclovici.
The funds transited the following accounts, all on the same date (29 August 2013), prior to being
transferred to Maclovici's bank account:
., Agercom Grup SRL, Banca Sociala (Moldova, account number 222470308530) ;
• Agercom Grul SRL, Banca Sociala (Moldova, account number 2224703085302) ;
• Sun bu rough Industries LP, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV87 AIZK000001036567);
• Plus Operations Ltd, ABLV (Latvia, LV59AIZK0000010366659); and
., Ion Cojocaru , ABLV (Latvia, account number LV55AIZK0000010111330) .
Payment descriptions do not show the purposes of the loan issued to Agercom Grup SRL.
The loan was partially repaid from later loans issued to Shor Group companies at the Three
Moldovan Banks:
Loan Nr 238/2013 issued by BS to Biro Media Sri (MDL 12.9 million); and ,
Loan Nr 240/2013 issued by BS to Voximar Com Sri (MDL 49 million).
A portion of the loan was also repaid from an amount of USO 50 million transferred to ICS Sisteme
lnformationale Integrate Sri from Regional Naya Finansovaya Company at Gazprombank (Russia).
This amount was part of a shareholder loan granted by ICS Sisteme lnformationale Integrate to
BEM, described in more detail in Section 11 of the Detailed Report.
02/6/2013
U5D sn.oov.ooo
Re~i::-na/Nay~ Fin5nS(IVCY5 Ct•m~eny !CS Ssterr.e inform~tt'T"l-a!e !ntecrate S L
- ~702s.:;iJ2oooc1000nss LISD -
(Gazoron;) (5:'M)
U5D 3,315,250 rI
30/06/ 2013
a;;:: 2.500,00G
I
30/0S/2013
U!:,D 2.SIJ0,000
(:L~ 2,457,110 transferred on to Sunburcugh !ndus:tries LP)
! 30/C,S/2013
:'LR 2,565 ,450
30/08/20 13
EUR 2,655,450 •> MDL "19,005.910
I
EUR "118, 750 30/ 08/ 20 13
(CUR 174,956 fr:::,m i:-luefunteln LP; MD!.. .;9,C•05.91Ct
EUR 243,765 from Frc:-;ces Trad;n;;, LP) I
I 04;09/201 3
~-'·T""
29/tlS,'2013
MDL 12 67,200 04/09/ 2013
1
EUR 177.135
(EUR 177, !35 from Frances Trcd1no LP)
I .
29/l)S/2013 - 2~/08/ 20 ! 3 _ 29jQS/2013 ~
~L 12,66 7, !96 ·> £l!;!. 752.~6---;,.. ll ii : UP.752.,..;l}O~ EU?. 752,500
f:i:ro M~d·a Sri Biro Media Sri 5luefon!ein LP Plus C::>era t'ons Ltd
MDL
(3$)
£LR
$S)
(A5 LV) (A5f)
Loan i;,ccownt l-i2l7C•308 53002
Loc!nreference Nr 237/ 2013 din 29 ,06 . 2013
2,rs,
30/06/2013
: u;,, !00
(SS)
1
---j.,~Ci}~21~~~9.; -----;,- (;iq j ~~-~,-i~,2~~ 2.SSS, 4 50~ Lt..- 30/03/20!3
£l);t 2,685,4 50
Voxfrn:ar Com~I
Loencccour;t :!.42 17030643902. MD, Vox•mer Cc•m S~L ~ranees Trcci:flg LP
Loc!n referen:::e f•!r 240/ 20 13 d,n 30.C,S.2013 (5S) :LR (A5L\')
(ES)
Statement details
Bank BS
Account holder Agercom Grup SRL
Account number 222470308530
Account currency MDL
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29/08/2013
Crediting amount 51 ,999 ,884.96
Credit from Loan proceeds (BS)
Description (as per statement) Eliberarea creditului In conf. cu contr. de credit Nr. 237 /2013 din
29.08.2013
Summary description Issuance of a loan, reference number: 237/2013 on 29.08.2013
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
Statement details
Bank BS
Account holder Agercom Grup SRL
Account number 2224703085302
Account currency EUR
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29/08/2013
Crediting amount 3,040,680 .00
--
Credit from Agercom Grup SRL (BS)
Description (as per statement) INREGISTRARE VALUTA CUMPARATA LA LICITATIE.
Summary description Currency transfer
IBasis of trace
Basis of trace I Exact match
3.4.3 Example 2, Transaction 3 - Funds received from Agercom Grup Sri (BS)
mixed with other funds and transferred to Plus Operations Ltd (ABLV)
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Sunburough Industries LP
Account number LV87 AIZK0000010365670
Account currency EUR
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29/08/2013
Crediting amount 3,040,680 .00
Credit from Agercom Grup SRL (BS)
Description (as per statement) FT13241421017549, ienakosais maksajums, nr.
FAAS324103910100, AGERCOM GRUP SRL 2032, STR
SARMIZEGETUSA, 92, 204, CHISINAU, MOLDOVA, BC BANCA
SOCIALA SA (BSOCMD2XXXX), konts MD41
BS000002224703085302, OUR, K.F/N DD 20.08 .2013 INV.F/N
DD 20.08.2013 AVANS TEHNICA DE CALCUL
Summary description Invoice - advance payment for computer equipment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was EUR 193.37 (treated as nil according to the
funds tracing methodology).
Figure 12.· Funds received from Agercom Grup Sri mixed with other funds anc! transferred on to Plus
Operations Lief
,_;:
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 01 .05.2013 ITdz 01.11.2013
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13241824010444, ienakosais maksajums, nr. FAAS324104580900,
ICS SISTEME INFORMATIONALE INTEGRATE S.R.L. STR. IZMAIL
52, CHISINAU, MOLDOVA, BANCA DE ECONOMII S.A.
29.08.2013 +2 500 000.00
(BECOMD2XXXX), konts MD86BE000222490197801521, OUR,
PREPMT FOR ELECTRONIC GOODS CONTR W/O NR.DD
12.08.2013 INV W/O NR. DD 12.08.2013
FT13241420520229, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
29.08.2013 -4.00
5540600.00 EUR no 29/08/2013 Balance b/fwd EUR 5,540,869
FT13241420520229, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 26, PLUS \
29.08.2013 OPERATIONS LTD., konts LV59AIZK0000010366659, BoaspaT -5 54 0_600.00
111Hsecn,11.-1111iil
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Plus Operations Ltd
Account number LV59AIZK0000010366659
Account currency EUR
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29108/2013
Crediting amount 5,540,600.00
Credit from Sunburough Industries LP (ABL V)
Description (as per statement) FT13241420520229, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 26,
SUNBUROUGHINDUSTRIES LP, reg. nr. SL 11751 , konts
LV87 AIZK0000010365670, B03BpaT IIIHBecrn4111111
Summary description Payment relating to investments
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was 336,600. According to the forensic tracing
methodology, the EUR 5,540,600 was transferred as follows:
Figure 13: Transfe r of amounl received from Sunburough lnclustries LP to various accounts
,,,,,,,- ,,,,-
(EUR 193,600 atrributable)
---- --
// __,.__.EUR 470,100 (ABLV)
/ /
- 29/08 ,2013
- - - - - EUR S 540 6□0----➔ --== :,.:::-----
---
29/08/ 20 13
EUR 1,001,631 ·> -
-
~-
' ' ._._._ . USO 1, 323,350
Sunburough Industries LP Plus Operations Ltd , ·29i08/2013 Plus Operations Ltd
(ABLI/) EUR '- --.._EUR 2,896,100 ._ USO
(ABLI/) '-....._ ._._._ (ABLV)
' - ,29/08/20 13
EUR 2,145,6 55
...._-..-..
(EUR 979,169 transferred from
Sunburough industries LP) Frances Tradino LP
' ' (ASL\/) -
www.ablv.com
Kanta parskats
No 22.05.2013 ITdz 01 .01.2014
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
24.05.201 3
FT13144106604507, l<0misija pflr
maksajumu, maksajuma summa
-5.14
1880500.00 USO no 24/05/2013
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Plus Operations Ltd
Account number LV59AIZK0000010366659
Account currency USO
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29/08/2013
Crediting amount 1,326,360.00
Credit from Internal transfer - currency exchange from EUR to USO.
Description (as per statement) FT13241073387394, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 458, 1001631.17
EUR =>1326360 .00 USO, kurss 1.3242
Summary description Currency exchange from EUR to USO. Exchange rate 1.3242.
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was USO 5,468.11. According to the forensic
tracing methodology, the USO 1,326,360 was transferred as
follows:
USO 58, 100 was paid to Ekovold Project Limited (ABLV) - not
traced on for the purposes of this example
Figure 14: Funds received from Sun/Jurough Industries LP transferred to va rious accounts
Frances Tradino LP
(.u.B LV) -
DarTjuma
datums I
valutesanas DarTjuma registracijas numurs, darTjuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets KredTts
FT13240576507603, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 448, WANG AND
28 .08.2013 -455 150.00
LEE LP, konts LV97AIZK0000010366557, v1Heecrn4111111
FT13240441271882, val0tas konvertacija, nr. 449, 20316.03 EUR=>
28 .08.2013 +27 000 .00
27000.00 USO , kurss 1.329
FT13240371862737, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
28.08.2013 -5.35
27300.00 USO no 28/08/2013
FT13240371862737, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 450, FRANCES
28 .08.2013 -2 7 300.00
TRADING LP, konts LV16AIZK0000010365008, v1Heecrn4111111
FT13241073387394, val0tas konvertacija, nr. 458, 1001631.17 EUR=>
29 .08.2013 +1 326 360 .00
1326360.00 USO, kurss 1.3242
FT13241222933006, komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
29.08.2013 -5.35
124400.00 USO no 29/08/2013
FT13241222933006, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 464, Ion Cojocaru,
- --
29 .08.2013 -124 400.00
konts LV55AIZK0000010111330, Llv1Bv1LIEHTbl
--
FT13241329078063 , komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
29.08.2013 -5.35
1011 300 .00 USO no 29/08/2013
FT13241329078063, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 460, WANG AND
29 .08.2013 -1 011 300.00
LEE LP, konts LV97AIZK0000010366557 , v1Heecrn4111111
-
FT13241477638476, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summii
29.08.2013 -5. 35
133100.00 USO no 29/08/2013 ..• "'
FT13241477638476, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 461 , SUNBlJROUGH
29.08.2013 -133 100.00
INDUSTRIES LP, konts LV87AIZK0000010365670, v1Hee~r.L114111111
FT13241477642032 , komisija par maksajumu , maksajuri/a summa
29.08.2013 -5. 35
58100 .00 USO no 29/08/2013 ·
FT13241477642032, ieksbankas mal<sajums, nr. 462'. EKOVOLD
29.08.2013 -5B 100.00
PROJECT LIMITED, konts LV43AIZK00000103~6559 , v1Heecrn4111111
FT13241690601015, val0tas konvertacija , nr.-465 , 74667.47 EUR=>
29.08.2013 +98 800.00
98800.00 USO, kurss 1.3232 •
FT13241502218560, komisija pa r maksaji.jmu, maksajuma summa
29 .08.2013 -5. 35
98800.00 USO no 29/08/2013
FT13241502218560, ieksbankas ma ~~ajums, nr. 466, FRANCES
29.08.2013 -98 800 .00
TRADING LP, konts LV16AIZK0000010365008, v1Hsecrn4111111
FT13241894791281 , val0tas l\onvertacija , nr. 470 , 133560.35 EUR=>
29.08.2013 +176 500.00
176500.00 USO , kurss 1.321 !i..·
FT13241286856648, komisi]a par maksajumu, maksajuma sum ma
29.08.2013 -5.35
26500 .00 USO no 29/08/~013
FT1324128685664B, i~Ksbankas maksajums, nr. 472, Ion Cojocaru,
29 .08.2013 -26 500.00
konts LV55AIZK00Od010111330, Llv1Bv1LIEHTbl
·L·
---
FT132412868529~5. komisija par maksajumu , maksajuma summa
29 .08 .2013 -5. 35
150100.00 USD,rio 29/08/2013
.·, - -
FT132412868.52095, ieksbankas mal<sajums, nr. 471, FRANCES
29 .08.2013 -1501 00 .00
TRADING_LP, konts LV16AIZK000001036500B, v1Hsecrn4111111
FT1324--{ 564456342, valotas konvertacija , nr. 480, 4556 .85 EUR=>
29.08.2013 +6 000.00
6000, (i,O USO, kurss 1.3167
FT,1.3241733064948 , komisija par maksajumu , mal<Sajuma summa
29 .08.2013 -5.35
.1o·o·oo.oo uso no 29/08/2013
'~FT13241733064948, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 481, IT-LOG
29 .08.2013 -10 000.00
ALLIANCE LLP, konts LV83AIZK0000010347506, v1Hsecrn4111111
FT13242720519622, valotas konvertacija , nr. 489 , 550295.41 EUR=>
30.08.2013 +726 500.00
726500.00 USO , kurss 1.3202
FT13242698129502, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
30.08.2013 , -5.32
726500.00 USO no 30/08/2013
FT13242698129502, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 490 , FRANCES
30 .08.2013 -726 500.00
TRADING LP, konts LV16AIZK0000010365008, v1Hsecrn4111111
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Ion Cojocaru
Account number LV55AIZK0000010111330
Account currency USO
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29/08/2013
Crediting amount 124,400.00
Credit from Plus Operations Ltd (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13241222933006, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 464, PLUS
OPERATIONS LTD., reg. nr. 132,467, konts
LV59AIZK0000010366659, ,QI/IBl/l,QEHTbl
Summary description Payment of dividends
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was USO 564.16 (disregarded according to the
tracing methodology). The USO 124,400 from Plus Operations
Ltd was transferred on as follows:
USO 4,000 was paid to Vasile Lasco 12 (ABLV) - not traced on for
the purposes of this example
11
Maria Gutuleac and Alexandr Maclovici have Alef Bank accounts that were used to fund UB shareholders, as
detailed in the Confidential Working Papers Part I.
12
Vasile Lasco had an account at Alef Bank that transferred money to accounts at ABLV / Privatbank linked to
suspected fraud funds (see Confidential Working Papers Part I).
13
Veaceslav Lupov was a shareholder of UB . An Alef Bank account in the name of Veaceslav Lupov was used to
transfer funds to accounts at ABLV / Privatbanl<.
USO 15.400 was paid to Moisei Mester (ABLV) - not traced on for
the purposes of this example
Figure 15: Transfer of funds received from Plus Operations Ltd to va rious acco unts
ffiiiiiiil
Maria Gutuleac
29j08/ 2013 _,,. ;,t (ABLVj
USD 42,600
,,
/
30/09/ 20 i3 -
,USO 41,300 7
) USO 700 atb·ibu;qle).r;,asile Lasco
/ _,,,, / (ABLV)
/ / 29/08/20 13
/ ,,..uso 4,000
//
// /
// __,. .-- .- .--
-----7"
LrJpov Veace,;lav
/ / / 29i08/20 13 _, (.A.BLY)
---- -------
/ / _, USO 34, 500
./ /
_ _ _ _ _ 29i08/ 2013 - - - ~- :::---
/ ,/' 29/08/ 2013 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
USO 124,400 - = i - --- --- USO 10, 100
Plus Operations Ltd [on Coj ocaru ' - :..._- --- ..._-... Alexandr Madovid
(ABLV) (ABLV) "'- --- -... ..._ (ABLV)
', ..._ -29/08/ 2013
"'- ..____ USD 15,400- -...
' ----.:;..
' ' 2 9/08/ 20 13 Moisei Mester
USO 17,100 (ABLV)
' '
' ~
Neoru
0
Tudo:·
.A.B LV)
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 29.10.2012 ITdz 15.06.2015
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13193164059826, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
12.07.2013 -5 .25
6500 .00 USO no 12/07/2013
Darijuma
datums/ Ba lance b/fwd USO 43 ,842 .76
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT13241049276750, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 61, Alexandr
29.08.2013 -10 100.00
Maclovici, konts LV65AIZK0000010358015, nononHeHi,,e cYeTa
FT13241253187842, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
29.08.2013 -5,35
15400.00 USO no 29/08/2013
FT13241253187842, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 62, Moisei Mester,
29.08.2013 - 15 400.00
konts LV76AIZK0000010358011, nononHeH"1e cYeTa
FT13241585939244, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
29.08.2013 -5.35
17100.00 USO no 29/08/2013
FT13241585939244, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 63, Negru Tudor,
29.08.2013 -17- 100 .00
konts LV82AIZK0000010354896, nononHeH"1e cYeTa
FT13241286856648, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 472, PLUS Ba lance IJ/fwd USO 1,232 ,.06
29.08.2013 OPERATIONS LTD ., reg . nr. 132,467, konts LV59AIZK0000010366659, +26 500.00
,Qv1Bv1,QEHT61
FT13241550098373, komisija par maksajumu, maksajuma summa
29.08.2013 -5.35
27400.00 USO no 29/08/2013
FT13241550098373, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 64, Ilona Sor, konts
29.08.2013 -27 400.00
LV28AIZK0000010366441, nononHeHi,,e CYeTa
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 29/08/2013
Crediting amount 10,100.00
Credit from Ion Cojocaru (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) FT13210544240410, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 30, Ion
Cojocaru, reg. nr. 0970502489132, konts
LV55AIZK0000010111330, nonoJ1HeHV1e C4eTa
Summary description Account replenishment
IBasis of trace
Basis of trace lExact match
Figure 16: Transfer of funds rece ived fro m Ion Coj ocaru to Alexandr Maclovici (A lef Ba nk)
Ion Cojocaru
29/08/ 20 13
---- USD ltJ , 100 ----- _ _ _ 29/08/2013 ----4-
Alexandr Maclovici
USD 10, 100 -
.aJexandr Madovid
(ASL\/} (ABLV) (Alef Bank)
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 06.09.2012 ITdz 17.03.2014
In Confidential Working Papers Part I, we have identified a number of payments received by her for
notary services.
Two of these payments were made to Bondarciuc's bank accounts at UB (Moldova, account numbers
280608561395840 and 279428560011840), in August and November 2013, together totalling USO
1.1 million . These two transactions were traced further2 to identify the source of funds and
provide evidence to Bondarciuc's receipt of suspected fraud funds at UB, account number, as detailed
r8mrtip11E below: Date Bank account number Debit Currency
Number
1 13/08/2012 280608561395840 862,050 USO
2 28/11/2012 279428560011840 224,000 USO
Two other transactions of USO 370,272 (made to UB account number 223448560049(8) and USO
125.12 (made to a Moldindconbank account) respectively were made to other accounts in her name.
A search of bank statements provided to Kroll identified 15 additional transactions made to accounts
in
her name between December 2008 and June 2013 and totalling USO 102,916.33. Based on
analysis conducted to date, these transactions could not be directly linked to the suspected fraud at
the Three Moldovan Banks. According to the payment descriptions on the bank statements, these
payments were made in MDL for notary services. These were made to bank accounts held at
Energbank (Moldova, account number 222462768), and Victoriabank (Moldova, account number
2251603871).
As described further in Section 7 of the Detailed Report. Kroll traced USO 0.8 million in funds used by
Bondarciuc linked to the acquisition of a stake in UB to accounts at Alef Bank and other Moldovan
banks.
It appears that this payment was made in part to acquire the share capital at UB, of which Olga
Bondarciuc became an owner with a share capital of MDL 5.6 million on 17 August 2012. At the
exchange rates at the time, the value of her shareholding was equal to approximately USO 450,000.
USO 862,050 was transferred to Bondarciuc's UB bank account just four days prior to this acquisition.
3
Mester Moisei was the founder and director of Moldclassica International, a Shor Group Company which
received loan proceeds from the Three Moldovan Banks.
4
As is detailed in Section 11 of the Detailed Report, the funds which Qppear to enter the Core Laundering
Mechanism from accounts linked to Shor Group companies at Alef Bank have been treated as having
originated from suspected fraudulent loans or actions within the Three Moldovan Banks.
5
The accounts in the names of Elmington Limited , Unitrade Association Ltd and Harrogate Consulting LP
were included in the Core Laundering Mechanism, detailed in Section 8 of the Detailed Report.
Mester Moisei
{Alef Bank)
I
10 /08/ 20 12
USD 2,000,000
1
Elmington Limited
{AB L\f)
I
13 /08/ 2012
USDT,°''
_ _ _ 13/08/ 20 12 ____ _ _ _ _ 13 /08/ 2013 - - - -
USO 862, 700 -=:- USD 862,050
Unitrade Association Ltd Harroaate Consultina LP Olaa Bandard uc
(ABLlf} - (ABLV) - - (UBi
6
The accounts in the names of Hanlay Solutions LLP, Unitrade Association Ltd and Harrogate Consulting LP were
included in the Core Laundering Mechanism, detailed in Section 8 of the Core Laundering Mechanism .
., ,·
~ /
SC Dufremol Srl
Lo~r. eccour1t 142170904/MDL
(Mold1nci conbank)
I
25/ ll/ 201 2
MDL 75,000.000
.I,
SC Dufremol Sri
Lo6n Accour1t 1-42 170964/MDL
(Moldindconbank)
c~r •o
28/ 11/ 20 12
The Moldindconbank loan granted to SC Dufremol Sri was repaid on 8 August 2013 with funds traced
back to funds received from BEM shareholder Sisteme lnformationale Integrate ("Sil"), detailed
in Figure 3. The funds were part of a USO 50.0 million transfer made to SSI from an
account at Gazprombank in the name of Regional Naya Finansovaya, described further in
Section 11 of the Detailed Report. These funds were part of a circular flow of funds between
BEM accounts, Core Laundering Accounts and Gazprombank accounts, potentially used to
increase the liquid assets held by BEM . The repayment of the Moldindconbank loan funds used to
pay Olga Bondarciuc was therefore connected to the suspected fraudulent loans at the Three
Moldovan Banks.
07,~SFl20l3
USD 9 , 200,C®
I 02/05/ 20 l3
USO S0,000,QC!C·
- --
02/06/20 13
- USO SO,C·00,000 _ _ __
_ OS/OS/ 20l3 ~ -
USD S,200 ,C.OO -
- GS/CS/ "dJD ---7" _
USO 9,2')0 ,0GO _,
_ _ 0S/OS/ 2(H3
USO 995,SGO
------,i , -
Reg·onll Na}·a Fi.'1! M:)1.-! ya S1sterr.e !1\fu:m.!ton!!e In~.?tE- A.-ma~e61.1s:ne un1kes
~ e ?tt.:s Opere~:i:is Sn-;o lk:'.tin LP
(t:ar,r.crrb an!.:) (SEM) .
222.;aa:OU"',t
(ASLV} {ASL'J)
I (ASL\?
I
OS/08/2013
08/vS/20!3 0S/06/ 2,J 1 3 uso9is,aeo
-..:
/ 'SD4,627,600 0~ 0 l -r~:l7Q
-
- /
P.2r.ero:mMa."l.!; ement
(AS L\/)
/
OS/08/ iG13
WS~l,SQ':?, 170
Eden Aliance L?
(ASLV)
Alub.Js Com
(r-~~'.dnda>r,bar~} USO
OS/06/20 13
I
USDS95,S00 ··>i MDL 12,S!i.; , ~85
-~I
SC Dufremol SRL
(Mo'. IU'ld c:>nbarv,;) AJ.Jtus Com
{Mo!d;n:for.bar.k} • f' v:>L
(US O)
I
Ci6,106/ 2013
05/08/2013
U~D 4,QSS, 420 1,909, :!.JU · •>t•'DL 24 ,092,4 51
t
06/0S/20 !3
•"•
c:r oJfrem:,15.:'.!.. MD'.·!2,]564,185
(i.,;,,,;ncoodo._,;;) ~ /06/2013
06
M-:Y 24,092,. ;
l S~ .
4.3 Example 1
Example 1 shows fund flows originating from Mester Mosei's account atAlef Bank, Russia (account
number 40820840800000132888) to Bondarciuc's UB account (number 280608561395840) .
Tracing identified a payment of USO 862,050 on 13 August 2012 to Olga Bondarciuc, USO 640,500
of which was traced back to Mester Moisei's Alef Bank bank account. The funds were transferred
to Olga Bondarciuc 4 days prior to her acquisition of 4.58% of shares in UB on 17 August 2012.
The funds were transferred through the following three accounts, all on the same date (13 August
2012), prior to being transferred to Olga Bondarciuc's bank account:
• Elmington Limited, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV86AIZK0000010322814)
• Unitrade Association Ltd, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV631ZK0000010347478)
• Harrogate Consulting LP, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV24AIZK000001034 7501)
The purpose of the payment received from Mester Moisei's account at Alef Bank as stated in the
bank statement description was a real estate purchase and sale contract dated 09 August 2012.
The loan proceeds were traced through the above accounts at ABLV. A part of the amount is then
used to make the payment to Bondarciuc, with the description on the bank statement indicating
that the payment was for a loan repayment dated 13 August 2012. Therefore, the purpose of the
transaction detail (as per the bank statements) does not appear to be consistent with the use of
funds .
As described in more detail in Section 11 of the Detailed Report, funds from a number of accounts
at Alef Bank (Russia) in the name of individuals and Shor Group companies, including that in the
name of Mester Moisei, were used to further disguise the flow of funds . Funds were transferred in
a circular mechanism between these accounts and accounts used in the Core Laundering
Mechanism . These funds were treated as being linked to the suspected fraud.
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 10/08/2012
Credit amount USO 2,000 ,000 .00
Credit from Mester Moisei (Alef Bank)
Description (as per statement) PAYMENT BY REAL ESTATE PURCHASE AND SALE
CONTRACT DD 09.08.2012
Basis of trace
[U.§D~~.OQil..BeldJQ UrutrsgeA§soc1s1t1on.LtdJABL~ •
~mount.tra.c.ed...on,ior
tl1e.P11m.oses oUhts.examm.g
Figure 4: Transfer of funds received from Mesler Moisei to Unitrade Associai'ion Ltd
l3j08 / 20 l 2
10/08/ 201 2 - - - - - ~- US0493,000 * -
USD 2,00Q,000 --- ' -
. . . l 3jOS /20 L2 . , .
Mester Moisei Elnungton Limited USO 147 500 Un,trade Assocation Ltd
(Alef Bank) (ll.BLV) ', ' (A.BL\/)
* USO 493,000 transfer was traced on with the USO 147,500 for the purposes of this example
Example 1, Transaction 1 USD account cover page
Elmington Limited ABLV statement extract (USD)
ABLV Bank, AS Tel: +371 6777 5222
23 Elizabetes Street Fax: +371 6777 5200
Riga, LV-1010, Latvia Client line: +371 6777 5555
E-mail: info@ablv.com
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 06.05.2010 lidz 15.06.2015
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT12198980251013, ienakosais maksajums, nr. 5595900198FC,
STORAD GRUP SRL STR. TIGHINA, 12, CHISINAU, MOLDOVA,
16.07.2012 JOINT STOCK COMMERCIAL BANK UNIBANK (JSCUMD2XXXX) , +1 500 000.00
konts 222498560951840, SHA, /RFBIJELEZ1607170458 PREPMNT
FOR GOODS CONTR. W N DD 06.07.2012, INV. W N DD 06.07.12
FT12201621152130, ienakosais maksajums, nr. 5711300201FC,
ALUTUS COM SRL STR. TIGHINA 12, CHISINAU, MOLDOVA, JOINT
19.07.2012 STOCK COMMERCIAL BANK UNIBANK (JSCUMD2XXXX), konts +481 927.00
222458560913840, SHA, /RFB/JELEZ1907184648 PREPMNT FOR
FURNITURE CONTR. W N D010.07.2012, INV. W N DD 10.07.2012
FT12209406465706, komisija par maksajumu, parskaitTjuma summa
27 .07.2012 ._-: -1.21
899325.00 USO no 27/07/2012
FT12209406465706, ieksbankas maksajums , nr. 24, BOSCO
SOLUTIONS S.A., reg . nr. 545467/1042500, konts
27.07.2012 -899 325.00
LV19AIZK0001140086318, Payment according to contract from
27.07.2012 for equipment
FT12212007435532, ienakosais maksajums, nr. 6252500212FC, \
STORAD GRUP SRL MD-2001 STR TIGHINA 12, CHISINAU,
MOLDOVA, BANCA DE ECONOMII S.A. (BECOMD2XXXX), konts
30.07.2012 +342 356.00
22248018402776, SHA, /RFB/PAY12/6296 PREPMT FOR
SPORTSWEAR CONTR W O NR DD 11 .07.2012, INV W O NR DD .,_..,
11.07.2012
FT12213438067402, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 554, PARSELOT
31 .07.2012 LTD., reg. nr. 5940320, konts LV38AIZK0001140081126, nondnHeH~e +295 000 .00
C4eTa ''
FT12213900310160 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 19, UNIT RADE
31 .07.2012 ASSOCIATION LTD., reg . nr. 100103, l<onts LV63AIZK0000010347478, +152 800 .00
nononHeH~e C4eTa
FT12213485995493, valOtas konvertacija, nr. 2q, 1860460.20 USO=>
31.07.2012 -1 860 460 .20
1513800.00 EUR, kurss 1.229 \
31 .07.2012 1003321 .ABLV.CURR.MNTH .FEE.2012073 { : komisija par konta
-24.87
(01 .08.2012) apkalposanu ·
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 13/08/2012
Crediting amount USO 493,000.00
Credit from Elmington Limited (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) nononHeH111e c4eTa
Summary description Account replenishment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd was USO 363.77 (disregarded according to the
tracing methodology) .
The USO 493,000 paid from Elmington Limited was blended with
funds of USO 222,600 received from Tomton Trade Corp and
USO 147,500 received from Elmington Limited, and transferred
onwards as USD 862,700 to Harrogate Consulting Limited.
Figure 5: Transfer of funds received from Elmington Limited and Tom tom Trade Cotp
to Harrogate Consulting LP
/ ''"'" '/
_/D 222 ·o-
,Ol'
TomtonTrade Corp
(AB LV)
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 27.01.2012 lidz 15.06.2015
. ,'
Konta ipasnieks UNITRADE ASSOCIATION LTD.
Reg. Nr./ Pers. kods 100103
Adrese 103 SHAM PENG TONG PL~,. VICTORIA,MAHE, SEYCHELLES
Darijuma
datums/
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT12156860180946, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 6, PANAROOM
04.06.2012 MANAGEMENT LLP, reg. nr. OC361239, konts - 101 200 .00
LV67 AIZK0000010347503, nononHeHi,,e ccieTa
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Harrogate Consulting LP
Country of company United Kingdom
registration
Account number LV24 AIZK 0000 0103 4750 1
Account currency USO
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 13/08/2012
Crediting amount USO 862,700 .00
Credit from Unitrade Association Ltd (ABLV)
Description (as per statement) nono11HeH111e c4eTa
Summary description Account replenishment
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments USO 862,050 is within +/-1% of USO 862,700
Figure 6: Tra nsfer of fun ds from Unilrade Associa tion Ltd lo Olga Bondarciuc
www.ablv.com
Kanta parskats
No 26.01.2012 ITdz 15.06.2015
4.4 Example 2
Example 2 shows a trace of a portion of loan funds issued by Moldinconbank to SC Dufremol SRL
on 28/11/2012 to Olga Bondarciuc's UB (account number 279428560011840). Tracing identified a
payment of USO 224,000 to this account on 28 November 2012. This amount can be wholly traced
back to proceeds of the loan issued to SC Dufremol SRL. The funds were transferred from SC
Dufremol SRL's loan account, to SC Dufremol SRL's USO account, and through 3 ABLV accounts
prior being transferred to Olga Bondarciuc, all on the same date, 28 November 2012. On the same
date and from the same source of funds, Harrogate Consulting LP also made transfers to the UB
accounts of Rita Tvic and Vladimir Novosadiuc who both acquired shares in UB on 17 August 2012,
the same date as Bondarciuc.
The funds transited the following 4 accounts, all on the same date (28 November 2012), prior to
being transferred to Bondarciuc's bank account:
• SC Dufremol SRL, Moldinconbank (Moldova, account number
MD18ML000000000142170964)
• Hanlay Solutions LLP, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV54AIZK0000010356467)
• Unitrade Association Ltd, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV63IZK0000010347478)
• Harrogate Consulting LP, ABLV (Latvia, account number LV24AIZK0000010347501)
The purpose of the loan according to the bank statement description was the purchase of alcoholic
beverages. Kroll has traced the loan payment through the above accounts in ABLV. A part of the
amount is then used to make the payment to Bondarciuc, with the description on the bank statement
indicating that the payment was for a loan repayment. Therefore, the purpose of the transaction
detail (as per the bank statements) does not appear to be consistent with the use of funds.
The Moldindconbank loan granted to SC Dufremol Sri was repaid on 8 August 2013 with funds
traced back to funds received from BEM shareholder Sisteme lnformationale Integrate ("SIi"),
detailed in Figure 3. The funds were part of a USO 50.0 million transfer made to SSI from an
account at Gazprombank in the name of Regional Naya Finansovaya, described further in Section
11 of the Detailed Report. These funds were part of a circular flow of funds between BEM accounts,
Core Laundering Accounts and Gazprombank accounts, potentially used to increase the liquid
assets held by BEM. The repayment of the Moldindconbank loan funds used to pay Olga
Bondarciuc was therefore connected to the suspected fraudulent loans at the Three Moldovan
Banks.
07/08/2013
USO ~.200,0GO
0.2!08/2013
······~--- 1
0Z/GB.'2013 00i03/20B ___..,. _ 0(?/08/2013 _. 08108120!3 a::....:I
USD ;o,OGD,000 •·• - uso ~.200.000 USD 9.200,0D0 - - -usD 9~s.sro______..
~~cf--i:,r.!!l N=,yc Fln.:r,~-¢'°'i·rc1 ~~~me !;c1r,rm;ti::;;i.a 1i::- Ink;r3ie Arrrr-Ed!l€ ~ 1r.c!;~ ~rvlcE!i .. i=1L'~ Openrll•:>.'1!:. Sr.,,! Union LP
- {C--czoro.r,::,:~!() ( 3:'.:Ml (~.SLVJ
___ ,,,.,.··
_/_.,... .. { ASLVl . 1· ,
t AS1 V'
222•i Et:COL;r,t_
OB/03/2013 I 08/06,'20!3
uso7s,soo
_yso-~,s21,eM
C'S/08/~013
u--o
~ ••1. ,.I
1 90Q 1 -0
.,,,..,,,.,.,,,.
, ...,,.,....
AIIJ:l~Corr.
(Molj injc~nt,ank) USO
P=:leroom t-1:nc~Em'!n: Eden AJlicnc~ LP
iABlVJ
/
(AS LVJ
OOiQS/1013
I
oa/oa/2013 U5D S95,800 --:,. MDL l2.5€A,1B5
USO 1,909,!70
)I
!
5C thJfr11n·;eJ SR:L
(M.')!t:iln.:i,:~nb-:mk) ti.lutu::; Corr,
(USO) (Moldlndi:r.t-ank) • MC1L
0Bi08i2013
I
03/(13/2013
IJ SD ~,053/126 1,909,170 __ .,. MDL 2,:,osz,.-;51
+
OS/OB/2013
MOL H,36-1,153
(~~~~:::~;i\~---,. . ·- - -~. . ......
.0S/00:' 2013
MDL 2-·~.0;2.-t51
05/ 05/2013 .. ··-..............
MDL 4~. 250.975 ....
_ C:6:'0e:;~1oii i1'~it:~~~ri26-,.. y .. i
0~:/DB/2013
._,. . ___ MDL 57 500.,000______.. .. .,.
1
08/03/ 2:DD
Irrfcton<o-rn Jnfotr;,n-Com MDL 6. 966,351 SC Dutrernol ~rl SC Dufr!:-mol Srl
(~•'li:tldfr,Oi:onbcn<, • EUrt ( Mtidi!'\Ccndb-3nk) Lo;!n Account USD
{Moldinc,:,r,banl<) (t·1?1dinc.,nb-an l< )
Statement details
Bank Moldindconbank
Account holder SC Dufremol Sri (Loan account)
Country of company Moldova
registration
Account number MD 18ML000000000 142170964
Account currency MDL
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 08/08/2013
Crediting amount 75,000,000.00
Credit from Loan proceeds (Moldindconbank)
Description (as per statement) None
Summary description None
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments MDL 75 million converted to USO 6 million
Figure 8: Release of loan funds from /l//oldindconbank to SC Dufremol Sri and conversion to USO
Denumirea: SC
11
Dufremol" Valuta: MDL
SRL
Clientul: SC
"Dufremol" Codul fiscal: 1.0026E+12
SRL
Deschis: 27/11/2012
MD18MLOOOO
IBAN: 00000142170
964
Inchis: 08/09/2013
~ ~ Codul Contul
Contul Beneficiar Desti nat ia
Date document Debit Cred it documentulu doc ument beneflpiat cod fil. Repeta pentru perioada:
co resp . / plati t or pla t ii :
u l ui ! .!d!!!l itorului
28/11/2012
2251709570/
USO
61044933 75,000,000.00
60 2251709570/
MDL
SC
"Dufremol"
SRL
09
bautura
MOLDMD2X3 alcoolice conf
contr f/nr din
Pina la: ..
16.11.12
invoice f/nr
din 16.11.12
CUMPARARE
A VALUTEI P-
U BAUTURA
ALCOOUCE
SC
2251709570/ 60 2251709570/ MOLDMD2X3 CONF CONTR
29/11/2012 611 23031 12,500,000.00 "Dufremol" Alte optiuni:
USO MDL 09 F/NR DIN
SRL
16.11.12
INVOICE
F/NR
16.11.12
08/08/2013
2251709570/
MDL
71269354 87,500,000.00
2251709570/
MDL .. ~chivalentul
Imprima
f"i"ort creat la data de 15:27 Ultima operatiune in cont la data de 08/08/2013
~ .I
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 28/11/2012
Crediting amount 6,000,000.00
Credit from Loan proceeds (Moldindconbank)
Description (as per statement) Cumparare valute p-u bautura alcoolice conf contr f/nr din
16.11 .12 invoicef/nrdin 16.11 .12
Summary description Purchase of alcoholic beverages
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments
Denumirea: SC
"Dufremol" Valuta: USO
SRL
Clientul: SC
"Dufremol" Codul fiscal: 1002600042306
SRL
Deschis: 15/11/2010
MD79MLOOOO
IBAN: 00002251709
570
-Nr.
Date document Debit Credit -Nr. Benefi ciar/
cod fil.
Destinatia
documentu lui 12 latito r 12lat ii :
ului
-_,;J
Sold initial 0.00
Plata in avans --
pentru
Hanlay
bautura
Solutions
alcoolice conf
28/11/2012 61015 584 6,000,000.00 3 LLP,Birmingh 280101325
contr f/nr din
am, United
16.11.12,invo
Kingdom
ice f/nr din
16.11.12
Cumparare
valute p-u
bautura
SC
MOLDMD2X3 alcoolice conf
28/11/2012 61044933 6,000,000.00 "Dufremol"
09 contr f/nr din
SRL
16.11.12
invoice f/nr
din 16.11.12
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Hanlay Solutions LLP
Country of company United Kingdom
registration
Account number LV54 AIZK 0000 0103 5646 7
Account currency USO
Transaction details
Credit transaction date 28/11/2012
Crediting amount 6,000,000.00
Credit from SC Dufremol Sri (Moldindconbank)
Description (as per statement) FT12333229356802, ienakosais maksajums, nr.
4243800333FC, SC'DUFREMOL' SRL MOLDOVA CHISINAU
TIGHINA 12 CF1002600042306, MOLDINDCONBANK
(MOLDMD2XXXX), kontsMD79ML000000002251709570, SHA,
/RFB/S1128103015584 PLATAIN AVANS PENTRU BAUTURA
ALCO OLICE CONF CONTR F NR DIN16.11.12 ,INVOICE F
NR
DIN 16.11.12
Summary description Purchase of alcoholic beverages
Basis of trace
Basis of trace Exact match
Additional comments USO 6,000,200 is within +/-1% of USO 6,000,000
Figure 10: Transfer offunds received from SC Dufremol Sri lo Unitrade Association Ud
.,.
C'.111
· - - - 2 8/• 11120
J 12 ·6,000,0 0 0 ~-_...,
- - - - 2 8 ;• 11 I 2012 ·6,000,201)~ -
SC Dufremol Sri Hanlay Solutions LLP Uniirade Association Ltd
USO (A.Bl\/) (AB LV)
·Moldinconbank'
Kanta parskats
No 04.09.2012 lidz 02.04.2014
Transaction details
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd immediately before the incoming transfer of USO
6,000,000 was USO 165.77 (disregarded as nil according to the
funds tracing methodology) . The USO 6,000,200 was
transferred onwards as follows:
USO 2,800,100 paid to Algora LLP (ABLV) - not traced further for
the purposes of this example
USO 1,000,100 paid to Zonitech Properties Limited (ABLV) - not
traced further for the purposes of this example
USO 683,600 paid to Harwood United LLP (ABVL) - not traced
further for the purposes of this example
[mo-=sze:200 Bfild..tqJ:iarrQQate.-Cpnsulting LP.,(~BL Y) - amount
lfracecLon.tor..the. purp_oses..of.this.exam~
USO 234,900 paid to Rosslyn Trade LP (ABLV) - not traced
further for the purposes of this example
USO 455,600 paid to La Costa Trade LLP (ABLV) - not traced
further for the purposes of this example
Figure ·t 1: Transfer of funds received from Han lay Solutions LP to various accounts
/ 9 ~.Igora LLP
// (A6 LI/)
/
28j!l[2G 12
USD 2,8GQ, 100
/
/
/
/
/
/ 28/ ll/2012 ,,;,Zonitech Properbes Limited
// USD l,00~100_,. (~BL\/)
/ / ----
_,,.,-28ill/2012
/ _,,.,.,,,. USD 677,000
/ _,,.,.,,,.
/ .,,,.,,..,----
/ /
/
/
.,,-, ,,..,----
- - - - 2Sf lli20!2 _ _ _ c:.J __,,, 28/ 11/ 2•)l2 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
USD6,000,200 -=.--, -...-....._......._ US0679,ZOO ...-
Hanlay SohJtions LL? Unitrade Association Ltd -... -.... --. _ Harrogate ConsiJlting LP
(-"BLV) (AELV) ', --. ...... ___ (AB LV)
'- '- ---28/11/201 2
,
' ' ,' us,:>-6in:EJJO--
-.....__
--➔
' '
"-.
'
' ' 28/ ll/2012 Hamo~d Urited LLP
"-.
"' USD 234,900
-,
(ABLV)
'28/ll/ 2012
USD 455,6,J,J
'
', " - ,
,
"' ~
"' Ros~111 Trade LP
' ''
(AEI/L)
'" '::!.
www.ablv.com
Konta parskats
No 27.01.2012 lidz 15.06.2015
DarTjuma
datums/
valutesanas DarTjuma registracijas numurs, darTjuma veids,
datums informacija par darTjumu Debets Kredits
28.11.2012
f:
FT1233304693551 komisija par maksajumu, parskaitTjuma sum ma
-130
1000100.00 USO
' !;
no 28/11/2012
FT12333046,935517, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 90, ZONITECH
28.11.2012 PROPERTl~S LIMITED, reg. nr. 94659, konts -1000 100.00
LV91AIZK00b0010320493, nononHeH111e cYeTa
FT123_ 3 3776303675, komisija par maksajumu, parskaitTjuma summa
28.11.2012 -1.30
683600.00
, . USO no 28/11/2012
-
FT1·2333776303675, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 91, HARWOOD
28.11.2012 lJNITED LLP, reg. nr. SO303618, konts LV94AIZK0000010347502, -683 600.00
'nononHeHl!le C4eTa
Statement details
Bank ABLV
Account holder Harrogate Consulting LP
Country of company United Kingdom
registration
Account number LV24 AIZK 0000 0103 4750 1
Account currency USO
Transaction details
Basis of trace
Basis of trace FIFO
Additional comments Balance b/fwd: USO 509.33 immediately prior to the credit of USO
679,200. The credit of USO 679,200 was transferred onwards as
follows:
Figure 12: Transfer of funds received from Unitrade Association Ltd to various UB shareholders
:JI
Vladimir Novosadiuc
(UB)
,:;t
/
/
28/1 1/ 20 12
USD 227,000
/
/
/
_ _ _ _ 28/ 11/ 20 12 --:,>-- - - - 28/ 11/ 20 12 ------:l'- ... i.ji
USD 679,200 -=:I USD 224,000
Unitrade Association Ltd Harrooate Consulting LP Olaa Bondarduc
(AB LV) - (ABLI/) - - {U B)
""
" 28/ 11/ 20 12
USD 227,000
"" ~
l,jJ
RitaTvic
(UB)
Darijuma
datums I
valutesanas Darijuma registracijas numurs, darijuma veids,
datums informacija par darijumu Debets Kredits
FT12286244142608, ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 3, UNITRADE
12.10.2012 ASSOCIATION LTD ., reg. nr.100103, konts LV63AIZK0000010347478, -2 500 000 00
nononHeHi,,e cYera
FT12289681392097, komisija par maksajumu, parskai!Tjuma summa
15.10.2012 -1.29
2000000.00 USO no 15/10/2012
FT12289681392097, ieks bankas maksajums, nr. 4, UNITRADE
15.10.2012 ASSOCIATION LTD., reg. nr. 100103, konts LV63AIZK0000010347478, -2 ooo 000 OD:
nononHeHi,,e cYera
FT12297090800428, ieksbankas maksajums, ABLV BANK, AS, reg . nr.
23 .10.2012 50003149401, konts PL52900, Return 13.08.Commission for account +373.41
opening Balance b/fwd : USO 509.33
FT12333776308133 , ieksbankas maksajums, nr. 92, UNITRADE
28 .11 .2012 ASSOCIATION LTD., reg. nr. 100103, konts LV63AIZK0000010347478, +679 200.00
nononHeHi,,e cyera