Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Submitted By :
Jyoti Gupta
Enrolment No. 135607014
The work embodied in this dissertation entitled “The Influence of Dietary Practice
and Nutritional Status on Pulmonary Tuberculosis (TB) Children (10-12 Years)”
has been carried out by me under the supervision of Prof. Deeksha Kapur. This
work is original and has not been submitted by me for the award of any other
degree to this or any other university.
Date:
Jyoti Gupta
M.Sc DFSM (IGNOU)
Enrolment No- 135607014
I certify that the candidate Mrs. Jyoti Gupta has planned and counted the research
study entitled “The Influence of Dietary Practice and Nutritional Status on
Pulmonary Tuberculosis (TB) Children (10-12 Years)” under my guidance and
supervision and that the report submitted here is a bonafide work done by the
candidate in Delhi.
Date:
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
As I begin to think of all the people to whom I would like to express my gratitude
and appreciation for their support and suggestions in making this dissertation
possible, the list continues to grow.
First of all, I owe it all to GOD for granting me the wisdom, health, strength and
helping me throughout this research task and enabling me to complete it by
various mediums.
I wish to express my sincere gratitude to my supervisor Prof. Deeksha Kapur who
was abundantly helpful and offered her invaluable guidance and support. I cannot
express how much helpful she was to me in developing an idea and making it a
reality. Your valuable inputs, timely help and healthy criticism has made possible
the successful completion of the dissertation.
I wish to express a huge thanks to my mother Mrs. Prema Devi, my husband Mr.
Shiv Dutt, my family and my friends for providing me moral support throughout
my study.
Last but not the least I am deeply indebted to all those people who participated in
the study, which was very essential for the completion of the study.
Jyoti Gupta
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
ABSTRACT 09
INTRODUCTION 10-12
IMPORTANCE OF STUDY 12
OBJECTIVES 12
CHAPTER 1: REVIEW OF LITERATURE 13-29
1.1 Tuberculosis 13
1.2 Types of Tuberculosis 14
1.2.1 Latent TB Infection 14
1.2.2 Active TB Disease 14
1.3 Signs and Symptoms 15
1.3.1 Pulmonary Tuberculosis 15
1.3.2 Extra-Pulmonary Tuberculosis 15
1.4 Diagnosis 16
1.4.1 TB Culture Test 16
1.4.2 The TB Skin Test 16
1.4.3 TB Interferon Gamma Release Assays 16
1.4.4 Sputum Smear Microscopy as a Test for TB 16
1.4.5 Fluorescent Microscopy 17
1.4.6 Chest X-Ray as a TB Test 17
1.4.7 Serological Test for TB 17
1.4.8 TB Molecular Tests 17
1.5 Complications of tuberculosis 17
1.6 Nutrition in tuberculosis 18
1.7 Studies on tuberculosis 18
1.7.1 Nutritional Assessment of Tuberculosis Children 18
3
1.7.2 Investigate the Nutrient Intake 21
In relation to their Eating Habits
1.7.3 Knowledge, Attitude and Practice of TB patients 24
4
3.4.3 Nutritional Attitude Assessment 45
3.4.4 Nutritional Practice Assessment 47
5
LIST OF TABLES
Title
Table no. Page no.
2.1 Percentile cut off BMI for age for children by WHO 33
6
LIST OF FIGURES
42
3.2 Comparative graphical presentation of percentage
nutrient intake of the children.
7
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
8
ABSTRACT
Dietary intake, nutritional status and knowledge about tuberculosis are considered
key in the prevention, treatment and management of tuberculosis. The aim of this
study was to assess the influence of dietary practice and nutritional status on
pulmonary tuberculosis children (10-12 years).
The present study is a descriptive cross sectional study that involved 100
tuberculosis children attending OPD at two different tuberculosis centers in Delhi
region. The height and weight of subjects were taken and BMI was determined.
Food and nutrient intake of the subjects was assessed using 24 hour dietary recall
method. A questionnaire was designed, administered to collect information
regarding socio-demographic status, knowledge, attitude and dietary practices of
the subjects regarding tuberculosis and nutrition.
The study included 34% males and 66% females. Data related to anthropometry
revealed that majority (51%) of participants were underweight followed by
normal weight (39%) and overweight (10%).
Data related to mean food intake revealed that intake of cereal and millets, green
leafy vegetables, fruits, sugar and edible oils was low meeting 31%-45%
adequacy in both the groups. Intake of pulses was almost adequate for both the
groups meeting 88%-96%. Intake of roots and tubers was observed to be more
than adequate, meeting 104%-107%. Intake of milk and milk products and other
vegetables met 57%-71% adequacy in both the groups.
Overall Mean±SD knowledge score was 7.98±2.96 which reflects that parents
possessed fair knowledge and positive attitude (mean attitude score 0.79±0.40)
towards nutrition. Level of nutritional practice can be a contributing factor to their
poor dietary intake and food consumption pattern which could lead to poor
growth.
9
INTRODUCTION
10
in dwellings with high population density (many people sleeping in the same
room), and in buildings with poor ventilation (Carvalho, et al. 2018).
Most children will develop Active Tuberculosis within a year after becoming
infected. Childhood TB is rarely sputum-smear positive on microscopy. That is
probably the reason for the lower priority traditionally given to children by TB
control programs compared to that of adult disease (Savicevi, et al., 2012).
The rapid growth period of infancy and childhood can only be maintained if a
child‟s nutrient intake is optimal. The provision of adequate energy and nutrients
for a child with TB is very important, since the child has increased requirements
as a result of both growth and TB. In meeting their requirements it should be born
in mind that children have limited stomach capacity and appetites and as such plan
the diet carefully to ensure adequate intake of food (NICUS, 2007).
There is increasing attention from clinicians and public health perspectives about
this trend, as new occurrence of TB in children is a sentinel event and an indicator
of ongoing transmission in the community (Ki, et al., 2017). The World Health
Organisation approved The End TB Strategy, which is in alignment with the
United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. The new strategy adopts the
11
vision of “A world free of tuberculosis - zero deaths, disease and suffering due to
tuberculosis” and has the goal of ending the global epidemic and eliminating
tuberculosis in low-incidence countries. The goals, to be met by 2035, are a 90%
reduction in the incidence rate and a 95% reduction in the number of deaths due to
tuberculosis-both in comparison with the rates reported for 2015 (Raviglione,
2007).
IMPORTANCE OF STUDY
The study provides an opportunity to observe the influence of dietary practice and
nutritional status on pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) Children. The study also
promotes awareness about the impact of dietary practices on pulmonary
tuberculosis children and lifestyle followed by children of this age group. From
this study the early diagnosis of tuberculosis in children is possible. This study
will be helpful to provide valuable information to health/nutrition care providers,
policy makers, administrators planning and concerned bodies for health/nutrition
care utilization and for allocating resources efficiently and also planning for
effective preventive and therapeutic education programmes. The future
improvements in nutritional counselling will helpful in reducing progression of
tuberculosis in children.
OBJECTIVES
The overall objectives of this study are:
2. To investigate the food and nutrient intake of the active tuberculosis patients in
relation to their eating habits.
12
CHAPTER-1
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Tuberculosis (TB) is an old disease – studies of human skeletons show that it has
affected humans for thousands of years. The cause remained unknown until 24
March 1882, when Dr Robert Koch announced that he had discovered the bacillus
Mycobacterium tuberculosis, an event that is now commemorated every year as
World TB Day. The disease is spread when people who are sick with TB expel
bacteria into the air (WHO, 2018).
1.1 Tuberculosis
Tuberculosis (TB) is one of the most ancient diseases of mankind and has co-
evolved with humans for many thousands of years or perhaps for several million
years. In 1882, the bacillus causing tuberculosis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
was discovered by Robert Koch. Tuberculosis is caused by a group of closely
related bacterial species termed Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (Barberis,
et al., 2017).
Tuberculosis (TB) has affected humanity for more than 4,000 years. It is a
common infectious disease and in most cases fatal. Tuberculosis (TB) is viewed
in two groupings: Active Tuberculosis and Latent Infection. Active TB is an
ailment whereby the TB bacteria are precipitously burgeoning and plaguing
various organs of the body whereas latent phase goes undetected most the times
(Nthiga, 2017).
In some people, TB bacteria overcome the defenses of the immune system and
begin to multiply, resulting in the progression from latent TB infection to TB
13
disease. Not everyone infected with TB bacteria becomes sick. As a result, two
TB-related conditions exist: latent TB infection and TB disease.
There are two general stages of the tuberculosis. First is called Latent
Tuberculosis and second is Active Tuberculosis.
Persons with latent TB infection do not feel sick and do not have any symptoms.
They are infected with M. tuberculosis, but do not have TB disease. Persons with
latent TB infection are not infectious and cannot spread TB infection to others.
Overall, without treatment, about 5 to 10% of infected persons will develop TB
disease at some time in their lives. About half of those people who develop TB
will do so within the first two years of infection. For persons whose immune
systems are weak, especially those with HIV infection, the risk of developing TB
disease is considerably higher than for persons with normal immune systems
(CDC, 2014).
14
1.3 Signs and Symptoms
Tuberculosis may infect any part of the body, but most commonly occurs in
the lungs (known as pulmonary tuberculosis) Extra- pulmonary TB occurs when
tuberculosis develops outside of the lungs, although extra- pulmonary TB may
coexist with pulmonary TB.
Extra -pulmonary TB is a rare form of active disease that occurs when TB bacteria
find their way into the bloodstream. In this form, the bacteria quickly spread all
over the body in tiny nodules and affect multiple organs at once. This form of TB
can be rapidly fatal. Extra pulmonary disease represented 4.5% of all new cases of
active tuberculosis and tended to occur in older patients than in previous reports.
Sites of involvement included lymph nodes, blood, genitourinary tract, bone and
articular sites, the meninges, peritoneum, adrenal glands, pericardium, and
miscellaneous sites, in this order. Diagnosis was confirmed by a variety of
techniques whose relative merits are discussed. Overall, 14 deaths occurred
among the 136 patients. One-half of the deaths resulted from causes other than
tuberculosis and two patients died before diagnosis and initiation of therapy
(Alvarez, et al., 1984).
15
1.4 Diagnosis
In the case of the TB culture test the test is to see if the TB bacteria
Mycobacterium tuberculosis, are present. The bacteria are usually contained in a
sputum sample taken from the patient suspected of having TB in their lungs.
The TB skin test is a widely used test for diagnosing TB. The Mantoux TB test is
the type of TB test most often used. A positive mantoux test at 72 hours indicates
infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis, tuberculin sensitivity develops 3
weeks to 3 months after inhalation of the bacilli and remains for the child‟s
lifetime.
The Interferon Gamma Release Assays (IGRAs) are a new type of more accurate
TB test. IGRAs are blood tests that measure a person‟s immune response to the
bacteria that cause TB.
Smear microscopy of sputum is often the first TB test to be used in countries with
a high rate of TB infection. A sample of sputum is usually collected by the person
coughing. To test for TB several samples of sputum will normally be collected.
16
1.4.5 Fluorescent microscopy
If a person has had TB bacteria which have caused inflammation in the lungs, an
abnormal shadow may be visible on a chest x-ray.12 Also, acute pulmonary TB
can be easily seen on an X-ray. However, what it shows is not specific. A normal
chest X-ray cannot exclude extra pulmonary TB.
Serological tests for TB are tests carried out on samples of blood, and they claim
to be able to diagnose TB by detecting antibodies in the blood.
Some new molecular tests such as the Genexpert test and the TrueNat test are now
beginning to be available. They are though too expensive to be widely used in
many countries.
Delayed diagnosis may result in more extensive disease , more complications and
lead to a higher mortality. It also leads to an increased period of infectivity in the
community without treatment, tuberculosis can be fatal. Untreated active disease
typically affects your lungs, but it can spread to other parts of your body through
your bloodstream.
17
1.6 Nutrition in Tuberculosis
In the following sections literature review of some previous studies done on the
topic are presented as per the topic in Table 1.1
18
Summary of some recent studies on nutritional status of TB patients is presented
in Table 1.1.
Serial Author,
Subjects Parameters Findings
number year
19
Bora, et al., (2018) was conducted a descriptive, cross sectional study to assess the
nutritional status tuberculosis children in rural population. The study was done in
department of paediatrics in which patient attending outdoor facility at the
institute. The result showed that 86 children were included out of which 65.3%
females had MAM and 13% had SAM. While of 20 male TB contact children
infected with TB, 55% had MAM and 25% had SAM. There was statistically no
significant difference of the nutritional status of the nutritional status of the TB
infected contact children in their gender.
20
Sidabutar, et al., (2004) conducted a retrospective study at the Directly Observed
Treatment Short-course (DOTS) of Cipto Mangunkusumo (hospital) through a
structured interview of 279 patients attending outdoor facility at the hospital. The
result showed the nutritional status of the subjects was 1 well nourished child
changed to overweight , 67 undernourished children changed to well nourished, 4
severe malnourished children undernourished. 202 children were stayed in their
former nutritional status (97 were well nourished 101 were undernourished and 4
were severe malnourished) before and after six months therapy.
The rapid growth periods of infancy and childhood can only be maintained if
a child's nutrient intake is optimal. Insufficient intake can cause impaired
growth and result in diseases such as malnutrition. Because of the previously
described link between malnutrition and TB, all children presenting with
malnutrition or with failure to gain adequately in weight must be evaluated
for possible TB. The provision of adequate energy and nutrients for a child
21
with TB is very important, since the child has increased requirements as a
result of both growth and TB. In meeting their requirements, it should be
born in mind that children have limited stomach capacity and appetites and as
such meeting nutrient requirements presents a difficult challenge. It is
therefore necessary to modify and plan the diet carefully to ensure adequate
intake of food (Anigbo, et al., 2000).
Summary of some recent studies on nutrient intake in relation to the eating habits
of TB patients is presented in Table 1.2.
22
Gurung, et al., (2018) conducted a cross-sectional descriptive study which was
carried out among 133 TB patients taking anti-tubercular drug. More than half of
the patients had Pulmonary TB. 57.9% TB patients started medication in less than
1 month after diagnosis. The majority (78.2%) of the participants consumed a
sufficient amount of calories, whereas 21.8% did not. Factors which are associated
with calorie intake were Working conditions and food intake frequency were
significantly associated with calorie intake. Socio-demographic factors and
disease-related factors were not found to be associated with calorie intake. Factors
that are associated with recent nutritional status of TB patients were food
frequency, calorie intake, TB types, and nutritional status at the time of
registration were significantly associated with the recent nutritional status of the
participants. The nutritional status among TB patients was the Mean weight and
height were 51.98 kg and 1.57 m, respectively. Relatively, a higher percent were
underweight (21.8%) than overweight (17.3%).
Nthiga, et al., (2017) conducted a cross sectional analytical study. The study was
done in Lodwar County and Referral Hospital. 242 subjects was chosen using the
systematic sampling method. The dietary practices analysis involved a 24-hour
recall, food frequency questionnaire, and dietary diversity score. The mean energy
intake for the study population was 2228 kcal/day and 1870 Kcal/day for males
and females, respectively. The energy intake of TB patients meeting 85% for males
and 81% for females of the RDA. Males consumed 86% and females taking 83%
carbohydrate of the recommended dietary intake. The protein was not consumed
as per recommended dietary allowances. The mean protein intake was 37±22g/day
where males and females were found to have consumed 39% and 46% of the RDA
for TB patients respectively. Micronutrients in TB management including
Vitamins A, D, B1, B2, B6, C, zinc, selenium and folate were consumed at levels
lower than the RDA.
Swart and Visser, (2016) conducted a case- control study in which 43 newly
diagnosed patients (cases)with tuberculosis and 43 tuberculosis- free control were
matched according to age, gender and race. Each participant was interviewed and
completed a structured questionnaire to provide demographic information.
23
Weight, height, Mid-upper-arm circumference and skinfold thickness were also
measured. The 24-hour dietary recall method was used to obtain dietary
information and analysed in the nutrition database of the Medical Research
Council in order to translate foods into nutrients. Biochemical analyses were
carried out to measure concentrations of transferrin, albumin, C-reactive protein
(CRP), ferritin, zinc, copper and vitamins A and E. Means (± standard deviation)
and confidence intervals were used to describe serum micronutrient and
biochemical levels. A significant difference in weight and MUAC was seen.
between groups. Albumin , serum zinc, and serum vitamin A were lower in cases.
Newly diagnosed patients with tuberculosis have a poorer nutritional status than
their tuberculosis-free counterparts.
Fox, et al., (2015) conducted a study in which total of 200 residents of a village
in Northern Quebec were investigated during a tuberculosis outbreak and
identified to have active tuberculosis, the median daily nutrient intake and the
proportion of subjects with inadequate intake of each nutrient and food group.
Energy intake was poor (Only 11%) which was derived from traditional sources
study participants with new infection ( in case–control study 1) were more likely
to report an inadequate intake of fruit and vegetables. Intake of carbohydrate,
vitamin A, thiamin, niacin, folate, magnesium, iron, and selenium was low.
There was no association between active disease (in case–control study 2) and
the reported dietary intake of diet groupings, or individual nutrients after
adjustment for age, sex, personal income, smoking status, and prior infection.
Food insecurity was reported by 76 of 105 (72.4%) subjects and 149 of 197
(75.6%) subjects in the whole study population.
A good knowledge , attitude and practice helps in preventing and delaying the
onset of tuberculosis related complications Assessment of knowledge, attitude,
and practice (KAP) of community toward TB, is very essential to collect
information for planning public health programs, problem cognition and planning
intervention based on the gaps. Knowledge, attitude, and health-seeking practice
24
and associated factors toward tuberculosis and it transmission (Hibstu, et al.,
2016).Summary on some recent studies on knowledge, Attitude and Practice in
relation to their dietary practices is presented in Table 1.3.
Serial Author,
Subjects Parameters Findings
number year
25
5. Babu, et al., 113 KAP. 53, 59, 1 patients
2015 subjects. were found to have
poor medium and
high KAP,
respectively.
Ayed, (2019) conducted a cross- sectional study. The study was carried out by a
questionnaire. Parents of children aged ≤14 years, were contacted and requested to
participate in the study. 544 parents were participated in the study. During 6
months of the study, 431 parents had taken their children to physicians. Only 7.2%
reported not being prescribed any antibiotics, whereas 66.8% were prescribed an
oral antibiotic one or two times and 26% were more than three times. 373 of the
parents (68.6%) purchased antibiotics without a prescription, whereas 171
(31.4%) purchased it only after obtaining a prescription. However, only seven
26
(1.3%) followed instructions regarding antibiotic usage, whereas 50% did not
receive any advice from their doctor regarding use.
Hussein et al. (2018) carried out a study based on KAP were assessed by a piloted
questionnaire. Convenience sampling was performed, Knowledge and attitudes
were assessed by creating composite scores. Associations between socio
demographic characteristics and knowledge and attitudes were investigated using
logistic regression to compute odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals. A total of
407 participants took part; 49% were males and 51% were females. 53% of
participants had low level of knowledge whereas, 63% patients had favourable
attitude regarding TB. Female participants were twice more likely to have a
favourable attitude than males. Those with high knowledge are twice more likely
to have a favourable attitude towards TB.
Chinnasami, et al., 2016 carried out a cross- sectional quantitative study. 491
respondents of age 20-50 were participated in the study. A standard questionnaire
was prepared for the respondents. Majority of participants were young and
educated parents. 17% of the parents agreeing that antibiotics have no role against
viruses. only 20% accepted that antibiotics are not necessary for short duration
fever and common cold. Around 60% of the parents agreed about the full course
of antibiotics should be completed. Participants had 18 times better knowledge
about antibiotics with prior medical training as compared to general public.
27
Babu, et al., (2015) conducted a Prospective-Educational Interventional study on
113 patients, receiving DOTS therapy was conducted on DOT's centres in
Hoskote region for a period of six months. Patient's level of knowledge attitude
and practice were assessed using suitable KAP questionnaire. Out of 113 patients
studied, 46.9 % were found to have poor KAP, 52.2% were found to have medium
KAP and only 0.88% were found to have high KAP during the baseline interview.
Only sixteen percent of the respondent's family had acceptable attitude whereas
eighty two percent of the respondents had non-acceptable attitude. From the study
it was clear that there is still a need to strengthen the educational activities on TB
through mass media; they are excellent venues for information-dissemination and
pharmacist assisted care/counseling.
28
breath (29.4%). The majority of respondents, 76.8% (324) believed that TB is a
curable disease and 60.4% (255) of anybody were at risk of acquiring the disease.
Similarly, 278 (65.9%) respondents stated that the disease is curable with modern
therapy but 22.5% (95) of respondents did not know how it is cured. Only 43.1%
of respondents knew the current free service of diagnosis and treatment of TB and
50.5% did not know its service. The mean and median knowledge score of
respondents toward pulmonary tuberculosis was 6.81 and 7, respectively. In
studying the attitudes and practices of respondents, 36.5% (153) of the study
subjects thought PTB as very serious. About 45.3% (191) of the respondents
pursued a self-treatment option as a choice for primary health care; however, only
13.7% (58) of respondents visited a governmental clinic/hospital two or more
times per year.
29
CHAPTER-2
METHODOLGY
This study was designed to see the influence of dietary practice and nutritional
status on pulmonary tuberculosis patients. This chapter compiles the detailed
information related to different methods and materials used to achieve the
objectives of the study.
30
Exclusion criteria
Child who have Extra -Pulmonary Tuberculosis.
Child not willing to participate.
Not complete follow up.
A detailed interview schedule was prepared for the collection of data. The
questions were asked to the patients keeping in mind their feasibility and comfort,
after assuring that their data won‟t get leaked out. The following methods were
used for gathering information.
The Demographic profile of the subjects were assessed on the basis of following
parameters- age, gender, education qualification and occupation of parents, socio-
economic status, family type, type of houses and facilities, number of children,
duration and family history of TB by means of self- reported general information
questionnaire attached at Annexure A.
31
1. Height
The height of the patient was measured using the following procedure
1. Patient was asked to remove shoes, heavy outer clothing, hair clips and undo
braids etc.
2. Patient was stood straight with his/her back and feet against the wall, heels
Close together, legs straight, arms at sides and shoulders relaxed.
3. Then, the patient was asked to stand in straight position on a non- carpeted
floor.
4. After that, Patient must inhale deeply and stand fully erect without altering
heel position or allowing heels to rise off the floor.
5. Patient was asked to look straight ahead with head erect.
6. After that, we noted down the measurement.
2. Weight
The weight of the patient was measured using the following procedure
1. We must see the scale which should be on zero, before the patient steps on the
weighing machine.
2. Patient was asked to remove shoes and bulky clothing (no jackets). Patient
was asked to empty his/her pockets.
3. Then, Patient stood with back facing the sliding beam or other readout, both
feet on the centre of the platform, and not touch other objects or persons.
4. After that, we recorded the weight of the child.
After recording the height and weight of the children, BMI (Body Mass Index) of
the children were calculated.
Calculated BMI was used to determine the BMI for AGE (percentiles) given by
WHO (2007). Highlighted in the Table 2.1
32
Table 2.1-Percentile cut off-BMI-for-Age for children by WHO (2007)
Diet is a vital determinant of health and nutritional status of people. The dietary
habits of individuals/families/communities vary according to socio-economic
factors, regional customs and traditions.
The food and nutrient assessment of all the tuberculosis patients was done by
using 24 recall method. This helped to get an idea of the amount of different raw
ingredients used in the preparations consumed by the respondents. At least a 3
days 24-hour recall including 2 weekdays (i.e. Monday and Thursday) and one
week end that was Saturday were conducted.
Prior to collection of the actual data the respondents were explained in detail
about the survey to ensure that they furnish the required information correctly.
The nutrients that are energy, protein, carbohydrates, fats, vitamin A, vitamin C,
iron, calcium and zinc values for these amounts were then calculated using
ICMR‟s “Nutrition Composition Table.” The day‟s total intake of different
nutrients assessed and compared with the RDA (ICMR, 2010) and the nutrient
adequacy ratio was calculated as follow
Nutrient adequacy ratio = Mean intake X 100
Recommended intake
33
Intake of various foods consumed by the children was estimated and food
adequacy ratio was calculated then compared with that of the balanced diet as by
ICMR (2010) for children (10-12 years old) to access the consumptions of the
food intake of the children.
34
on the scale were positive. Respondents rated their degree of agreement with the
statement. Their responses showed both the direction (for or against) and intensity
(strength) of their attitude. After the attitude questionnaire was filled, the scoring
was done in the following manner:-2= Strongly Disagree, -1= Disgree, 0=
Undecided, 1=Agree, 2= Strongly Agree. Since the statements were positive, a
high overall score reflected a positive attitude and al low overall score indicated a
negative attitude. The attitude questionnaire has been attached at appendix C.
35
CHAPTER-3
RESULTS
Presented in this chapter are the study findings as per the objectives: Demographic
characteristics of the study population, their nutritional status, knowledge about
tuberculosis, food & nutrient intake.
36
Socio-Economic Status Percentage (%)
Upper class (I) 0
Upper middle class (II) 14
Lower middle class (III) 37
Upper lower class (IV) 43
Lower (V) 6
37
Duration Of Tuberculosis Percentage (%)
More than 6 months 8
4-6 Months 31
2-4 Months 45
0-2 Months 16
As depicted data from Table 3.1, a total 66 (66%) females and 34 (34%) males of
age group 10-12 years were participated in the study. About 31% of mothers and
37% of fathers had higher secondary certificate. Most of the mother (74%) were
housewives and father (51%) were working as skilled worker. The data regarding
socio- economic status revealed that the majority of the population was belongs to
upper lower class (43%) followed by lower middle class (37%) and upper middle
class (14%) and lower class (6%) and no one belongs to upper class. 57% of
subjects stayed in nuclear family followed by 43% in joint family. Most of the
children (54%) live in rented house with 1- 2 rooms. 46% of the parents had 1
bike or scooter as a vehicle. Most of the participants had public facilities like
hospitals/ other health services (87%), electricity (86%), trash box (73%), water
connection (69%) and park/ playground facilities (56%) near their area. About
37% of the parents had 2 children. Maximum children suffering from tuberculosis
were second child of their parents. Majority of subjects (45%) had TB from last 2-
4 months followed by 31% (4-6 months), 16% (0-2 months) and 8% (>6 months).
71% of the subjects didn‟t have family history of TB. 62% subjects were non-
vegetarian.
38
3.2.1. Anthropometric assessment
Anthropometric measurements were recorded and presented in Table 3.2. It shows
the nutritional status of the subjects with respect to their height, weight and BMI.
Mean± SD
S.No. Parameters
Female Male
The data was further analysed and classification of subjects into different grades
of malnutrition is presented in Table 3.3.
Female Male
Total
BMI for (n=66) (n=34)
S. Classifi
Age Percen Perce Percen
No. cation
Percentile No. tage No. ntage No. tage
(%) (%) (%)
85th to 95th Over
1 5 7.3 5 14.7 10 10
Percentile weight
5th to 85th Normal
2 24 36.7 15 44 39 39
Percentile weight
<5th Under
3 37 56 14 41.3 51 51
Percentile weight
As data presented in Table 3.3 revealed that 51% of the children were underweight.
Underweight was more prevalent in females (56%) than males (41.3%). 39% of the
subjects were found to be in normal category, normal weight was more prevalent in
females (56%) than males (51%). Only 10% of the children were found to be in
overweight category (7.6% and 14.7% in females and males, respectively).
39
3.3 Food and Nutrient Intake of the Subjects
Food and nutrient intake of the subjects were recorded and data presented
herewith.
The average food intake was collected and presented in Table 3.4
Table 3.4 : Mean ± SD of food ntake (g) by the children (10-12) Years.
As data presented in Table 3.4 revealed that, intake of pulses and root and tubers
was adequate meeting 88%-107%. The consumption of other vegetables was close
to adequate among most children, with adequacy 68%-71%. Intake of cereals and
millets, milk and milk products, green leafy vegetables, fruits, sugar and fat was
inadequate in both females and males meeting only 22%-63% adequacy.
40
The comparison between adequacy of food intake of female and male presented in
the figure 3.1.
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Male Female
The average food intake was collected and presented in Table 3.5
41
Table 3.5 : Mean ± SD values of daily intake of the nutrients of the
children (10-12 years )
ZINC (mg)
IRON (mg)
CALCIUM (mg)
VITAMIN_C (mg)
VITAMIN_B6 (mg)
VITAMIN_A…
FAT (g)
PROTEIN (g)
ENERGY (kcal)
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Female Male
42
3.4. Nutritional Knowledge, Attitude and Practices of the Children in
Relation to Tuberculosis.
Nutritional knowledge, attitude and practices of the children were assessed and
presented in this section.
(N=100)
Total
Mean±SD
Category
Percentage
N
(%)
Good knowledge of
Tuberculosis 24 21.1
(10-14)
Fair knowledge of
Tuberculosis (6-9) 83 72.8
7.98±2.96
Poor knowledge of
Tuberculosis (0-5) 7 6.1
It can be inferred from table 3.6 that 21.1% of parents had good knowledge about
TB. Most of the parent that is 72.8% had fair knowledge about TB. 6.1% parent
scored between 0 to 5 i.e., they had poor knowledge about TB.
43
Table 3.7 : Frequency distribution of correct response of knowledge towards TB.
(N=100)
Correct Response
Parameters
Percentage (%)
Balance Diet means 43
Meals taken per day 16
Good source of
29
protein
Good source of iron 30
Function of iron 30
Good source of
14
Vitamin A
Junk Food 20
Importance of
37
weighing during TB
Kind of TB (disease) 25
Severity of TB 22
Symptom of TB 33
Spreading of TB 33
Mostly affected part
35
during TB
Condition in which
31
TB spread more
As data presented in Table 3.7 revealed that, knowledge among parents was fair
29%- 43% correct responses were received regarding balance diet, food and
nutrition items. 25%- 37% correct responses were obtained regarding symptoms,
spreading, kind of disease, mostly affected part and condition in spread more
disease indicating moderate knowledge. Knowledge about meals taken per day
(16%), Vitamin- A source (14%) and HFSS food (20%) was very poor and only
22% of parents aware about severity of TB.
44
3.4.2 Knowledge of parents regarding overweight, normal weight and
underweight of patients
All the parents were assessed for their awareness about various aspects of
underweight during tuberculosis by means of a pre-designed questionnaire. The
mean and standard deviation of knowledge score was found to be (maximum
score of 14) revealing fair knowledge score.
As data presented in Table 3.9 revealed that, since the statement were positive a
high positive score means positive attitude while a lower to negative score
indicated negative and unfavourable attitude towards the item studied. The data
revealed that overall attitude towards childhood TB was moderately positive
0.79± 0.34.
The attitude towards the balance diet food preferences, nutrient and vitamins,
wearing mask, regular check-ups, continuation of treatment, importance of diet
was favorable (score 0.82- 1.18). However, attitude towards nutritious food, HFSS
food, TB exposure, TB heredity were less favourable (score 0.10-0.54).
45
Table 3.9 Parents response of attitude towards TB.
(N=100)
46
3.4.4 Practices adopted by children for tuberculosis
After the assessment of nutrition knowledge and attitude, next step was to know
the practice adopted by parents in children daily life in respect to knowledge they
had. To know the practices, questionnaire was conducted and presented in the
Table 3.10
47
Do you give medicines to your child on regular basis ?
Yes 96
No 4
Sometimes 0
How many hours in the day do your child play outdoor games ?
Half an hour 18
More than 1 hour 42
More than 2 hour 20
He/she don‟t 20
Where do you get most of the information about how to get and keep your child
healthy?
Percentage (%)
Hardly Ever Sometimes Often Always
School 62 38 0 0
Friends 34 32 22 12
TV 26 30 31 15
Others 29 28 25 18
Where do you get most of the information about how to get and keep your child
healthy?
Percentage (%)
Hardly Ever Sometimes Often Always
School 58 34 8 0
Friends 38 36 16 10
TV 28 54 16 2
Others 38 38 18 6
As data presented in Table 3.7 revealed that, 39% of the children like to have
HFSS food twice a week, 46% of the children eat fruits while they were hungry
followed by Noodles (22%), biscuit and khichdi (14%) and pizza (2%). Majority
of the children that is take Milk (90%), breakfast (100%) as well as medicines
(96%) on the daily basis. Most of the children like to spend most of their pocket
money on buying juices (58%). 42% of the children play outdoor games for more
48
than 1 hour followed by more than 2 hour or he/she don‟t 20% and half an hour
18%. It can inferred that subjects should not take HFSS food.
Most of the parents i.e. 58% of the parents hardly get any information from the
school about how to keep their child healthy and the no. increases to 62% in case
of having information about the nutritious diet to be given to the subjects. Parents
get hardly any information from their parents, 38% in case of information about
how to keep their child healthy followed by 34% in case of nutritious diet to be
given.. Some parents (38%) get information about how to keep their child healthy
and 30% get information about the diet from their friends sometimes. 38% of
people and acquire information about how to keep their child healthy and 29%
acquire information about the diet from TV Ads hardly followed by 34% and 28%
from books respectively. Only 24 people get information from other scores out of
which 50% hardly get any information about way to keep their child healthy. 15
people knew about the diet of the subjects from other sources out of which 40%
hardly get information, 32% sometimes acquire information from other sources.
49
CHAPTER- 4
DISCUSSION
The overall aim of this study was to gain a deeper understanding of nutritional
status, awareness level about TB, lifestyle and food and nutrient intake of
Pulmonary TB. This chapter presents the discussions regarding the finding. This
chapter presents the discussions regarding the findings of the study.
Majority of parents had higher secondary certificate 31% and 37% of mother and
father, respectively. Most of the parents i.e., 74% mother were housewives and
51% father were skilled worker. Most of the parents 43% belong to upper lower
class, the similar findings were documented by previous researchers also who
found that many persons suffering from tuberculosis were more frequently, worst
of the socio economic conditions for all the patients. Education, crowding type of
housing water supply and numbers of consumer articles in the household was
found to be independently and significant associated with a higher risk of
tuberculosis (Gupta, 2004).
The present study revealed that 29% of TB patients have positive family history
of TB and 71% have negative family history of TB. Some similar observation
showed the similar findings where it was found that family history play no role in
the transmission and acquisition of TB. TB is not a hereditary disease (HCDCP,
2011).
50
overweight. According to WHO, the upsurge in cases of TB is being propelled by
the growing prevalence of HFSS foods.
Food intake and percentage adequacy related to the daily mean intake was also
found to be inadequate for both males and females. The mean intake for different
food groups i.e. for cereals (40%-45%), milk and milk products (57%-63%), green
leafy vegetables (22%-33%), fruits (32%). other vegetables (68%-71%) and oil
(~43%) was low among both the groups. Pulses was almost adequate for both the
groups (88%-96%), whereas the intake of roots and tubers (104%-107%) was
found to be high in both the groups. The reason for this under nutrition was that
majority of subjects were suffering from underweight. Some similar studies
shows the same findings where new infection was associated with inadequate
intake of food, other vegetables, vitamin and minerals (Lee, et al., 2015).
In the present study it was observed that subjects were meeting only 44%-46%
adequacy of energy with 18% deriving from fat. Intake of protein (75%-86%),
vitamin B6 (91%-103%) and vitamin C (86%-93%) was fairly good meeting.
Intake of calcium and zinc met 61%-67% adequacy. Intake of iron and vitamin A
(retinol) was poor met 31%-47% adequacy. Some similar studies also found the
same result that nutritional status with respect to the micronutrients vitamin A,
zinc and iron. Low concentrations of these nutrients may affect host defense.
Vitamin A deficiency was found to be common among adults with TB and human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection in Rwanda (Rwanganbwoba, et al.,
1998). Zinc has been shown to be essential in vitamin A metabolism because it is
required to mobilize vitamin A from the liver (Smith et al. 1973). Iron deficiency
anemia has been reported in patients with pulmonary TB, as indicated by low
hemoglobin concentrations, serum iron and total iron-binding capacity (Saha, et
al., 1989). Energy intake, protein, concentration of blood haemoglobin, plasma
51
retinol and plasma zinc were lower in TB patients than in well nourished healthy
controls (Karyadi, et al., 2000).
The results of the present study provide the insight into the level of knowledge,
attitude and practice about TB among parents. Overall Mean±SD knowledge score
was 7.98±2.96 which reflects that parents possessed fair knowledge and positive
attitude (mean attitude score 0.79±0.40) towards nutrition. Level of nutritional
practice can be a contributing factor to their poor dietary intake and food
consumption pattern which could lead to poor growth.
Some similar studies done in DOTS centres in Logos state where 64.3% of
respondents were able to correctly answer the knowledge questionnaire. Attitude
were mostly in compliance to TB infection control guidelines (Ekuma, et al.
2016). The parents of the TB partners showed good knowledge (57% of the
sample population) about the disease: its presenting symptoms; its infectiousness
and curability; modes of transmission; and the diagnostic modalities needed for
TB. 61%of the respondents had good attitudes and practices with respect to the
disease. (Domingo and Lim, 2009)
52
CHAPTER- 5
The present study was a descriptive (cross sectional study) in which 100 subjects
suffering from tuberculosis from two different regions (Kailash Colony and Budh
nagar) of Delhi. All the tuberculosis subjects were selected by simple random
method in the age group of 10-12 years. The anthropometric measurements of
subjects was done, their height, weight, body mass index (BMI). A pre-designed
questionnaire was given to parents to obtain general information and their
nutritional knowledge. The food and nutrient intake was recorded with the help of
24 hour dietary recall method for three consecutive days which was then
compared with the modified RDA given by ICMR, 2010. Subjects were assessed
for their nutritional status, knowledge, attitude and practices regarding nutrition.
Specially designed questionnaires were used to collect data regarding
demographic profile, food and nutrient consumption, knowledge, attitude and
practices.
In our study out of 100 patients, majority of patients were female (66%), followed
by (34%) male. 31% of mother and 37% of father had higher secondary
certificate. Most of mothers (74%) were housewives whereas, fathers (51%) were
working as skilled worker. The data regarding socio-economic status revealed that
the majority of the population was belongs to upper lower class (43%) followed
by lower middle class (37%) and upper middle class (14%) and lower class (6%)
and no one belongs to upper class.
The BMI of the subjects were found to be 14.84±2.12 kg/m2 for females and
14.95±1.67 kg/m2 for males. According to their BMI scores. 51% of the children
were underweight. 39% of the subjects were found in normal category, Only 10%
of the children were found in overweight category.
53
The mean intake for different food groups i.e cereal and millets, green leafy
vegetables, fruits, sugar and edible oils was low meeting 31%-45% adequacy in
both the groups. Intake of pulses was almost adequate for both the groups meeting
88%-96%. Intake of roots and tubers was observed to be more than adequate,
meeting 104%-107%. Intake of milk and milk products and other vegetables met
57%-71% adequacy in both the groups.
Fair knowledge score was 7.98±2.96 and positive attitude (mean attitude score
0.79±0.40) towards nutrition. Level of nutritional practice shows poor dietary
intake and food consumption pattern which could lead to poor growth.
In conclusion, the present study shows that, decreased BMI, poor diet poor
sanitation, low immunity (because of not having balance diet) and inadequate
knowledge about tuberculosis are important predictors of tuberculosis.
It was concluded that balanced diet and tuberculosis goes hand in hand. The
consumption pattern of the respondents was not satisfactory and it is not optimal
to meet their nutrition needs. To increase the community well-being and thus
decrease the economic burden of tuberculosis, it is essential to educate the
population in general about childhood tuberculosis to help proper monitoring and
management of this disease. General public awareness on importance of
maintaining good weight and strategies of attaining the same should be enhanced.
The inadequate level of knowledge about tuberculosis need to be tackled
immediately through mass media and counseling by health care providers.
54
CHAPTER-6
RECOMMENDATIONS
55
and try to make healthy food items more palatable for them.
9. Avoid foods high in fat, fried preparation, organ meats, red meats and
refined sugars.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
56
Brinza N, Mihaescu T. Difficulties in the Treatment of Pulmonary Tuberculosis in
Children. Medical-Surgical Journal of the Society of Physicians and Naturalists.
2007;111(4):852-5.
Domingo MCNB and Lim ALO. Descriptive Study of the Knowledge, Attitudes
and Practices on Tuberculosis among Treatment Partners of Pediatric Patients in
Tarlac City. 2009 Jan-Dec;10(1):28-34.
Dieu BND, Gray KAW, Augustin MM, Robert LM, Erick T, Stanislas WO and
Oscar LN. Nutritional Status of Tuberculosis Children Diagnosed and Treated in
an Urban Area in DR Congo. Open Access Library Journal. 2017;4:1-9.
57
Fox GJ., Robyn S., Lucas M , Khan FA , Proul JF, Hornby K, Jung S, Benedetti
A, Behr MA and Menzies D. Inadequate Diet is Associated with Acquiring
Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Infection in an Inuit Community. A Case Control
Study. 2015;22(6):1153-62.
Gupta, D., Das, K., Balamurugesh, T., Asutosh, N., Agrawal. Role of
Socio Economic factors in tuberculosis prevalence. Indian Journal
Tuberculosis. 2004;(51):27-31.
Gurung LM, Bhatt LD, Karmacharya I, and Yadav DK. Dietary Practice and
Nutritional Status of Tuberculosis Patients in Pokhara: A Cross Sectional Study.
Frontiers in Nutrition. 2018;(8):5-63.
Haasnoot PJ, Boeting TE, Kuney MO and Roosmalen JV. Knowledge, Attitudes,
and Practice of Tuberculosis among Maasai in Simanjiro District, Tanzania. Am J
Trop Med Hyg, 2010;83(4):902–905.
Harries AD, Ade S, Burney P, Hoa NB, Schluger NW, Castro JL. Successfully
Treated But not Fit for Purpose: Paying Attention to Chronic Lung Impairment
after TB Treatment. International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease.
2016;20(8):1010-13.
58
Hibstu DT and Bago BJ. Knowledge, Attitude and Practice of Tuberculosis and its
Transmission among High School Students in Yirgacheffe Town, Gedeo Zone,
Southern Ethiopia. 2016;(12):2329-31.
Karyadi E, Schultink W, Nelwan RH, Gross R, Amin Z, Dolmans WM, et al. Poor
Micronutrient Status of Active Pulmonary tuberculosis in Indonesia. Nutrition
Journal. 2000:2953–8.
Mehta S, Mugusi FM, Bosch RJ, Aboud S, Chatterjee A, Finkelstein JL, Fataki
J, Kisenge R and Fawzi WW. A Randomised Trial of Multivitamin
Supplementation in Children with Tuberculosis in Tanzania. Nutrition Journal.
2011;(10):120.
59
Hospital, Turkana County, Kenya. International Journal of Food and Nutrition,
2017;7(1):123-127.
Ortiz AB, Carcamo CP, Sanchez JF and Rios J. Weight Variation over Time and
Its Association with Tuberculosis Treatment Outcome: A Longitudinal Analysis.
2011;6(4).
Raviglione MC. The new Stop TB Strategy and the Global Plan to Stop TB,
2006–2015. 2007 May;85(5):327.
60
Sidabutar B, Soedibyo S and Tumbelaka A. Nutritional Status of Under-Five
Pulmonary Tuberculosis Patients Before and After Six Month Therapy.
Paediatrica Indonesiana. 2004;2:1-4.
Storla DG, Yimer S, Bjune GA. A Systematic Review of Delay in the diagnosis
and Treatment of Tuberculosis. BMC Public Health. 2008;14:8–15.
Swart R and Visser ME. The Nutritional Status of Patients with Tuberculosis in
Comparison with Tuberculosis-Free Contacts in Delft, Western Cape. Division of
Nutrition and Dietetics,2012;25(4):180-185.
The Stop TB Strategy. Building on and enhancing DOTS to meet the TB-related
Millennium Development Goals. Geneva: WHO;2006.
61
Zar HJ, Eley B, Nicol MP, Figaji A, Hawkridge A. Advances in Childhood.
2012;12(4):36.
QUESTIONNAIRE
Fill the relevant information on the space provided and put a tick mark in
the boxes whichever is applicable to you.
Serial no.
Date:
Patient Name ................................
BOD …………………………………………
S.No. Duration
a. Less than 9
b. More than 6 months
c. 4-6 months
d. 1-3 months
Is he/she on medication ?
Yes No
For how long he/she is on medication ?
S.No. Duration
a. >6 months
62
b. 4-6 months
c. 2-4 months
d. <1 month
a
Post Graduate & above
b
Graduate
c Higher Secondary Certificate
d
High School Certificate
e
Middle School Certificate
f
Literate, less than Middle School Certificate
g
Illiterate
a Semi-Professional
b Arithmetic Skill Jobs
c Skilled Worker
63
d Semi-Skilled Worker
e Unskilled Worker
f
Unemployed
c Three
d More then three
e None
d With friends
64
Tick the
S.No. 0 children you 1are having?
8. No. of 2 More than 2
correct answer
a
Car 1
Scooter
b 2
Bike
c 3
Cycle
d 4
None
e >4
c Third
d Fourth
e If other, please specify ………………….
Tick the
S.No. 10. Public Facilities in your area. correct answer
a Park/playground of children
b latipuoH
tiswphiteausisesioHus
c Electricity
d Trash box
i reteW connection
65
KNOWLEDGE ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRE
Here is a questionnaire, please read the statement. You have to put a tick mark on
the option whichever you agree or is applicable to you.
(With the help of this questionnaire we will check your knowledge about
Tuberculosis)
1. A „Balance‟ diet means.
A. A group of food that contains spicy food.
B. A diet which provides all the nutrients that our body needs in right quantities
and quality.
C. A meal that only has a one kind of food.
D. I don‟t know
66
E. I don‟t know
5. What is the function of Iron?
A. Helping in formation of blood.
B. Help in formation of strong teeth.
C. Help in good eye vision.
D. I don‟t know
6.tavshieavewpuocpuesedsphsepteoecaaWe ?
A. Potato
B. Almond
C. Carrot
D. I don‟t know
67
D. I don‟t know
11. What is the symptom of TB?
A. Headache
B. Nausea
C. Fever
D. Dizziness
E. I don‟t know
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
B A A B A C A A A C C C C B
68
ATTITUDE ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRE
Here is a questionnaire, please read the statement. You have to put a tick mark on
the option whichever you agree or is applicable to you.
(With the help of this questionnaire we will check your attitude about
Tuberculosis)
69
PRACTICE ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRE
Here is a questionnaire, please read the statement. You have to put a tick mark on
the option whichever you agree or is applicable to you.
(With the help of this questionnaire we will check your practice about
Tuberculosis)
2. Which food do youW dhemd like toeet when hesshe feels hungry ?
A. Pizza
B. Fruits
C. Khichdi
D. Noodles
E. Biscuit
F. If other, please specify ………………….
70
5. Where does he/she spend pocket money mostly ?
A. On noodles
B. On juice
C. On biscuits
D. On chocolates
D. He/she don‟t
8. Where do you get most of your information about how to get & keep your child
healthy?
9. Where do you get information about what kind of food you should give to your
child to eat?
71
DIETARY ASSESSMENT
Here dietary data for 2 working (between Monday-Friday) and 1 non-working day
(Saturday/Sunday) is noted down.
Breakfast
Mid morning
Lunch
Evening
Dinner
Post dinner
72