Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
net/publication/228940704
CITATIONS READS
6 34
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Piercarlo Maggiolini on 02 June 2014.
Keywords: e-Government, job marketplace, services to employment, employment information systems, and
statistical information systems
1. Introduction
Public Employment Services are getting more and more important for Public Organizations since
they have enormous social implications, e.g.: sustainability, workforce mobility and equal
opportunities, therefore this topic plays a strategic role for any Government. As an example,
EURES (EURES 2005) is currently the system closest to the vision of a single over-national e-
Employment market, although its envisaged architecture seems not fully respondent to EIF (EIF
2005) recommendations on organizational, semantic, and technical perspectives. In order to fulfil
their duties, Public Administrations (PAs) are changing the way they deliver services: i) by re-
organizing their internal structure, through the automation of most procedures; ii) by accomplishing
new user needs which led to a change both in the modes and in the type of service provisioning.
Therefore, PAs began to massively include ICT in their day-by-day procedures.
In this context, Italy started its National Plan of e-Government, in 2002, with a set of projects
involving all the Regions and Provinces and focusing on administrative changes.
The purpose of this paper is to describe two Italian e-Government projects. The former is the Italian
Employment Information System (EIS), regulated by the law dated October 23rd, 2003, and locally
developed in the Lombardia Region (BLL 2005) (successively extended at a National level), to
promote the job matching procedures. The latter is AMeRIcA, promoted by the Municipality of
Milan, aimed at loading a Statistical Information System (SIS) from administrative data through a
large cleaning, filtering, and quality assurance procedure. The SIS thus becomes a powerful means
to analyze the poverty levels of the population, and can be integrated in the Italian EIS in order to
57
6th European Conference on e-Government
provide a Data Warehouse to monitor the actual Job Market trends. In the sequel of this section,
we briefly survey some related works.
The paper is organized as follows. In section 2, the main issues of the Italian EIS are presented:
from its design, through its technological guidelines to the future integration within the Single
European Employment Marketplace (SEEMP) project 1 , recently launched by the EU. Section 3
explains in details how information flows are the key feature of process innovation in electronic job
recruitment. Moreover, the active role of administrative sources to support employment is reported
through some sample of analyses. The conclusive section states the future perspectives of the
integration among the EIS and the SIS.
In recent years there is a marked tendency towards re-using statistical data, notably administrative
sources (Hoffmann 1995), (Thomson et al. 1998). This, in turn, has sharply increased the demand
for easy access to a variety of pre-existing data sources (Sundgren 1996). An attempt to feed a SIS
using PA’s or large enterprises’ archives is reported in (Buzzigoli 2002) focusing on the
organizational issues necessary to build an efficient Information System inside a PA structure.
However, a discussion concerning data quality, consistency, archive integration, and the
elaboration required to turn administrative data into statistical archives is still an open issue in the
research area.
By means of some projects activated by local PAs, (BLL 2005, SINTESI 2005), the Italian
Government put the basis for a national EIS to support the R/O match at the national level through
a network of local nodes. The reference scenario of the EIS is depicted in figure 1.
End-users (citizens, companies, PAs, Centres for Employment, private work agencies, and
educational institutions) load information: personal data, CVs, job offers and educational
programmes (Fugini et al. 2003). Loaded data are used according to a Service Model set up after a
preliminary negotiation and a standardization activity. The Service Model is replicated at the
national node (managed by the Ministry of Welfare), and at the local nodes (Regions and
Provinces). Detailed information regarding job matching events is moved into the SIS portion of the
EIS: for example (figure 1), the SIS developed in the AMeRIcA project, using Data Warehouse
technology, computes synthetic information for statistical purposes. The SIS operates as a monitor
1
EU-STREP Project n.°27347
58
Mirko Cesarini, Mariagrazia Fugini, Piercarlo Maggiolini et al
about the occupational situation in that, being consultable at various aggregation levels; it can be
used to observe the job market trends to forward the adoption of proactive workfare policies.
A first group of services (figure 2) regards the R/O match: it comprises Search Services, Data
Management Services (which provide both data collection and management of the stored data
along time, enabling owners to act on them according to the users profiles established by the
technological and organizational guidelines), and Administrative Services. In addition, Presentation
Services and applications related to a correct users’ access to the Information System itself are
inserted in the architecture. The second group of services regards Access and Integration
Services. It allows users to personalize the system Portals according to their needs, and manages
the Web sessions and the security procedures both in browsing both a portal and other domains for
a different service. In the bottom layer of the architecture, all the services involved in applicative
cooperation among the federate domains are installed (Coulouris et al. 1994).
The system Portals are available in a public section of the EIS containing the job profiles currently
requested by the enterprises to those citizens who looks for an employ. They can apply for a
specific position, or insert the CV to be stored in the EIS database. These operations must
necessarily follow the registration and authentication procedures (Fugini et al. 2003). The citizen
enters the credentials (user identification and password), which are required at each access to the
federation. Since one main feature of the EIS is to promote job mobility in the territory, the citizen,
upon insertion of his/, can choose on which level of the federation it should circulate. The
federation is spread over three levels, or domains (figure 3):
The National domain of the network, managed by the Ministry of Welfare;
The Regional domain composed of Regional nodes mutually linked through the National
domain;
The Provincial level: job portals at local sites on the territory are connected to the regional level
and mutually exchange data through access to the Region.
59
6th European Conference on e-Government
S e a r c h S e r v ic e s
D a t a M a n a g e m e n t S e r v ic e s
A d m i n is t r a t i v e S e r v ic e s
P r e s e n t a t io n S e r v ic e s
S y s t e m M a n a g e m e n t S e r v ic e s
R e g is tr a t io n L o g g in g
S u b s c r ib in g A ccess
N o t if ic a t io n
A c c e s s a n d I n t e g r a t io n S e r v ic e s
P e r s o n a liz a t io n S e c u r it y a n d N e t w o r k
W o r k f lo w M a n a g e m e n t
D a t a O r g a n iz a t io n C o n te n t m a n a g e m e n t
I n f o r m a t io n S e r v ic e s A p p lic a t io n S e r v ic e s C o lla b o r a t io n S e r v ic e s
A g g r e g a t io n S e a rc h
D a ta
M anagem ent E x p e r ie n c e C o lla b o r a t io n
M in in g F o r m a t t in g
P ro v. 1
P ro v. q
P ro v. 2
R e g io n 1
P ro v. 1 R e g io n 2
R e g io n P ro v. 1
N a tio na l
20 L e ve l
R e g io n 3
P ro v. q
P ro v. q
R e g io n n
Furthermore, the services offered to Work Agencies and Centres for Employment are basically
similar to those for Companies: in fact, as job selectors, they supply the same information and have
the same company services’ requirements.
Schools and universities have different service requirements: in fact, they are involved in
continuous educational programmes, and hence they exchange both information about students
(using statistical indicators) and promote educational events, such as stages, job re-qualification
60
Mirko Cesarini, Mariagrazia Fugini, Piercarlo Maggiolini et al
courses for long time unemployed and so on. In order to give learning services, they must register
to the federation.
Finally, the Ministry of Welfare extracts information upon the marketplace using the SIS tools to
analyse the situation, to adopt suitable policies for the improvement both offer and quality. Other
National Entities, such as the Pension Office, operate on the system by accessing shared
information about retirements, contributions, taxations, being always updated with the actual
employment status of each citizen. Moreover, the Pension Office plays the role of Certification
Authority in the system, in charge of generating, managing, and distributing authentication
credentials to all the actors in the EIS.
The EIS allows actors to connect to the federation from any domain, and to retrieve information
independently from the data location. The domains are cooperative, in that a user request for a
service, available on a different domain, can be fulfilled through access to the network, via secure
credentials. In fact, the EIS registers users in a domain of competence, where data are collected,
and makes them accessible from any node of the network thanks to cooperativeness and
interoperability.
A p p lic a t io n S e r v ic e s ET L
E xtr a c ti o n
EIS
P r e s e n ta ti o n ti e r T r a n s fo rm a ti o n
s e r v ice s
L o a din g
B u s i n e s s ti e r A d m i n i s tr a tiv e
S e rv ic e s
In te g r a ti o n ti e r O r i e n ta ti v e A n a l ys i s a n d
D a ta M i n i n g
services S ta ti s ti c a l
E n g ine
P r o d u c ti o n s
S ta g e
services
D a ta b a s e ti e r
61
6th European Conference on e-Government
taxonomies, semantically enabled Web services for distributed knowledge access and sharing. The
SEEMP project will develop a European Interoperability Framework (EIF) compliant federated
architecture and interoperability middleware as well as applicative plug-in services to allow existing
National/Local job marketplaces and Data Warehouses to interoperate at a pan-European level. On
top of this ICT infrastructure, SEEMP will develop knowledge discovery-mining services for cross-
governmental decision support. SEEMP addresses the problem of cross-governmental decisional,
business and administrative processes as well as the interoperability of taxonomies and ontology
sets. Moreover, a specific Decision Support System will be developed for specific legislative,
policy-making purposes by synthesising existing local indicators into pan-EU ones, supporting a
European Employment Strategy.
SEEMP is designed.as an extension and improvement of the EURES system, based on EIF
guidelines.
The organizational Service Model has to be defined to support information exchange and access
among the nodes of the participating Regions, under the principle that retrieved information has to
remain within the node where it has been generated. Secondly, the model is based on the creation
of a network of access points enabling local operators or end users to directly query/browse the
system. The implementation of such a model is possible through the use of non-invasive
technological tools (e.g., advanced search engines, and semantic Web services).
In order to improve the Quality of Service, the project aims at creating statistical databases
containing aggregated data about European occupational trends. These databases are regarded
as an integration area of data coming from the regional sources. This draws a synthetic view of
R/O trends, as well as of the most requested jobs, skills, or professions, in a way that is easily
readable, and rich in terms of quantity, quality, and localization. Finally, the semantic
interoperability research activities in SEEMP are aligned with existing standards and those under
development Web Services Modelling Ontology (WSMO 2005) and Language (WSML).
The aforementioned considerations highlight the need of rethinking the Service Model, the enacting
of active policies supporting Employment and the services supporting Job Marketplaces.
The innovation key for a real Service Model evolution is gathering information about the market-
players. In this perspective, information related to individual and collective needs plays a relevant
role, and a deep knowledge of the observed phenomena, as well as an increased degree of
timeliness, quality and efficiency are required. Methodologies for obtaining synthetic and statistical
information capable of effectively describing the real field of interest are necessary.
62
Mirko Cesarini, Mariagrazia Fugini, Piercarlo Maggiolini et al
In these scenarios, a key role is assumed by the development of a SIS aimed at providing support
for decision, analysis, monitoring, and control activities on the Job Marketplace. Using experience
gained in the AMeRIcA project, where administrative databases have been used for statistical and
decision-making purposes, we noted that a basic problem in constructing a SIS out of
administrative data is the presence of errors, duplications, inconsistencies, and unsuitability. Such
errors do not affect the regular use of the archives for administrative purposes, therefore they are
hardly noticed, and, even when discovered, they are usually tolerated. Nevertheless, these errors
and low quality data do negatively impact on the required analysis. Hence, before being an input
for any analysis, data sources undergo a quality improvement pre-process, which is performed by
applying a set of data cleaning actions, each one focusing on a specific issue. The output archives
are, then, integrated into a global one used as the primary source to feed the SIS. The original
archives were not designed to address the integration issues (e.g., schema incompatibility,
dictionary problems may arise), these problems are fixed in this step. The topics have been carried
out within the AMeRIcA project (Cesarini 2006). The project (2003 -2006), sponsored by the
Municipality of Milan (Italy) was launched with the purpose of deriving statistics about actual
income of subjects and families in Milan. The administrative archives available from the Registry
Office of the Milan Municipality and from the Income Office are the starting points for the AMeRIcA
SIS. These archives are databases created to collect data regarding the tax system, the citizen’s
address, family and employment status. Some experiences show that the integrated use of tax-
related databases together with Registry databases enable to obtain good information about both
income trends and citizens (Statistics Denmark 2000). In such a streamline, AMeRIcA applies
statistical analysis to data taken from PAs administrative sources, which represent the whole
population, rather than from sample surveys. However, nowadays, the only available data in the
context of national statistics come from National Observatories and are built on a survey basis.
Using information managed by the SIS, we have analysed a sample of people belonging to the
working age between 20 and 49 who have lost, found, and then definitively lost a job in the time
63
6th European Conference on e-Government
range 2000-2003. Based on the information extracted by the SIS, some considerations can be
drawn: the average income for young people (namely people between 20 and 29 years old) is
almost independent from the contract relationship (referring to unlimited vs. atypical-flexible
contracts); on the contrary, in the 40-49 years class, we can observe that people with unlimited
contracts have a quite higher income than ones having atypical-flexible contracts (namely:
Temporary Agency and Fixed-term Contracts). Average speaking an atypical flexible contract in the
40-49 years class is characterized by an average income quite lower in respect to the average
income of the unlimited contracts in the same age class. Moreover, it seems to introduce instability
in the working life of an individual (although in the considered subset of people, which all have lost
their job, the unlimited contracts have an average duration of approximately one year, therefore the
unlimited one does not seem to be more secure compared to the atypical-flexible ones). This
requires further screening and analysis; however, it highlights a suffering condition affecting a
certain class of people, which should be addressed by the decision makers in charge of enacting
active policies. We would like to point out that this suffering condition would have been hardly
discovered in short time using the traditional methods; such SIS applications allows to move from
reactive policy making to proactive and effective job decision making by reducing decision making
timeliness. The time difference required to get a feedback about the enacted job placement policies
with the traditional methods and with the SIS installed in the EIS is compared in figure 5.
Data Extraction from
Administrative
Results
Sources and
Evaluation
Loading into the SIS
Problem Active Policy New Problem Active Policy New Problem Active Policy
Examination Enactment Examination Enactment Examination Enactment
Time
Time required for traditional Assessment Activities
Assessment Time
required with SIS
Figure 5: Time required to assess the results of active policies using a SIS and traditional sampling
methods
4. Concluding remarks
This paper has described two projects framed in the Italian e-Government Plan. The first one
introduces the constitution of an Italian EIS spread on three levels: the national level; the ring
joining together the 20 Italian Regions, while the third level involves the Provinces domains. The
EIS executes primarily the R/O matching procedures on local as well as on a national level, in
order to increase competition and enable workers to update their own skills more frequently than
they used to.
The second project, called AMeRIcA, regards an active component of the EIS, namely the SIS,
designed with the purpose of making the basis for Italian Government to adopt policies to solve the
occupational crisis. The SIS is fed by the end-users’ information entered in the network (CVs, job
requests, educational programmes, stages, re-qualification courses): its task is to receive the
disaggregate input information and transform it into a synthetic information generated to
understand the actual situation in the Job environment. The paper has detailed, in this sense, the
AMeRIcA project, led by the Municipality of Milan. It essentially consists in a SIS deriving statistics
about the employment status on the basis of income data fed by the Income Offices, the Registry
Office of the Municipality, and the Centres for Employment in the District of Milan.
The consequence of these argumentations is the inclusion of the entire Italian EIS into a European
EIS, whose advantages are twofold. On the first side, the job matching events will be conducted on
four levels (Provincial, Regional, National and European), hence promoting the achievement of a
European knowledge based economy, as competences and personal skills become visible in a
64
Mirko Cesarini, Mariagrazia Fugini, Piercarlo Maggiolini et al
global framework. On the other side, the inclusion of the Italian EIS into a wider over national one,
will promote workers mobility within a communitarian job marketplace.
References
Borsa Lavoro Lombardia, (2005). http://www.borsalavorolombardia.net
Buzzigoli, L., (2002) “The new role of statistics in local public administration”. In Proceedings of the
conference quantitative methods in economics (multiple criteria decision making xi) pp. 28-
34. Faculty of Economics and Management, Slovak Agricultural University, Nitra (SK).
Cesarini, M., Fugini., M., Mezzanzanica, M. (2006) “Analysis-sensitive Conversion of Administrative
Data into Statistical Information Systems”. To appear in the 8th International Conference
on Enterprise Information Systems, 23 - 27 May 2006, Paphos – Cyprus
CNIPA (2002) Handbooks, Network Services offered on Web sites by Italian Regions and
Autonomous Provinces, July
Coulouris, G., Dollimore, J., Kindberg, T. (1994) Distributed Systems, Concepts and Design,
Addison-Wesley
EURES (2005) http://www.europa.eu.int/eures
European Interoperability Framework (2005) http://www.europa.en.int/idabc
Fugini, M., Mezzanzanica, M. (2003) “An application within the plan for E-Government: the
Workfare Portal”, Volume VI of Annals of Cases on Information Technology (ACIT), IDEA
Group Publisher
Fugini, M., Mezzanzanica, M. (2003) “Development of a Security Methodology for Cooperative
Information Systems”, in 11th European Conference on Information Systems, Naples,
June
Fugini, M., Plebani, P. (2002) “A Methodology for Development of Trusted Cooperative Information
Systems”, in Conference on Information Resource Management, Seattle, May
Hoffmann, E. (1995) ”We must use administrative data for official statistics - but how should we use
them?”, in Statistical Journal of the United Nations/ECE, 12, pp. 41-48.
Liikanen, E. (2003) “E-Government and the European Union”, UPGrade, Vol. IV, No. 2, April
Milis, G.M., Symeonidis, A.L., Mitkas, P.A. (2003) “Ergasiognomon – a Model System of Advanced
Digital Services Designed and Developed to Support the Job Marketplace”, in 9th Pan-
Hellenic Conference on Informatics, pp. 388-401, Thessalonica, Greece, November 21-23
SINTESI (2005) http://www.sintesi.provincia.milano.it
Statistics Denmark (2000) “The use of administrative sources for statistics and international
comparability” (invited paper). In Conference of European Statisticians, 48th plenary
session, Paris (FR). Statistical Commission and Economic Commission for Europe.
Sundgren, B. (1996) “Making statistical Data more available”. International Statistical Review, Vol.
64, No. 1.
Thomson, I., Holmy, A. (1998) “Combining data from surveys and administrative record systems
the Norwegian experience”, International Statistical Review, 66(2), pp. 201-221.
UNECE (2000) “Statistical Metadata”. In Conference on European Statisticians Statistical
Standards and Studies - No. 53, Geneva (CH).
WSMO Web Service Modelling Ontology (2005) http://www.wsmo.org
65