t TECHNICAL FORUM
Red rivers of segregation
BU Manrelal cake MM Ute atal el fol g lan eae lec me a Me aTel ue el rime (Leese) [ol Ot -Te gle] Coa
Pees
the clinker cooler.
Para ae Ag
this month's Technical Forum
{focusses on the phenomenon of,
segregation in the cement manufacturing
process, lets start with a definition of
segregation. The Oxford English Dictionary
states that segregation is: “The action or
state of setting someone or something
apart from others" ie, the separation
cof people, or separation of objects, I
is this separation of objects within a
‘material that we encounter in the cement
‘manufacturing process. Other sources
state that the separation of objects can be
‘an enrichment ofa material constituent at
a free surface or an internal interface of a
‘material, the tendency of particulate solids
tosegregate by size, density, shape and
other properties, or magnetic-activated
call sorting, a method for separation of
various cell populations depending on
their surface antigens.
‘The positive side of segregation
Inthe cement manufacturing process
segregation refers mainly tothe tendency
of particulate solids to segregate by ize,
density, shape, and other properties the
‘main subject of this Technical Forurn
However, there are examples where this
tendency is used for sorting. For example,
‘magnetic activated sorting in metal
detectors on the feed to vertical roller mills
orroll presses is used. n the processing,
of alternative fuels such asrefuse-dorived
fuels (RDA), different factions are sorted
using compressed ar, with the different
masses of particles beingrelated to their
‘composition and usefulness Flotation
cells mightbe used forthe removal of
deleterious fractionsin raw materials. The
coal tofire the kilns has probably gone
through a coal washing plant where the
ash contentis controlled by lating off
part of the clay (ash) fraction.
These are somewhat exotic examples
of sorting by segregation, However, itis
common to use the fact that differentsize
fractions ofthe primary raw material feed
eR MARCH 2016
ST eaee Means Ke oN
‘toacrusher have different compositions.
‘AtHope cement works in the UK the
{feed tothe primary gyratory crusher
used tobe screened to remove fluoride
‘contamination that concentrated in the
finer fractions of the limestone. At the RAK
White cement factory, UAE, the feed to the
limestone intake was screened to reduce
clay input, which concentrated inthe
finer fraction. At the Bahau cement plant
in Malaysia the product from the primary
yratory crushers screened to remove
sulphide bearing clay contamination,
‘These are|ustthree examples where
the tendency of the composition to
segregate by particle size allows the input
of contaminating materials to the cement
manufacturing process to bereduced
and uses the tendency of segregation
toimprove the cement manufacturing
process. Of course rejecting part ofthe
feed or product from a crushing process
potentially increases the raw material
‘consumption ofthe process and perhaps
‘the waste from the process, which snot
so good.
Segregation to avoid
(Once the materfals are partofthe cement
rmarvfacturing process, segregation
becomes more of anissue.
critical impli
erieneacerna
Raw material crushing and blending,
Crushed raw materials are carefully
stacked on blendingbed, butif that
blending bedis longitudinal using the
chevron stacking method then the larger
particles, wit their different composition,
roll down to the base ofthe pile. This does
not present any issues ifreciaiming takes
place over the entire width ofthe pile until,
the end cone is reached, where the larger
particles will ave accumulated. Windrow
stacking or a circular blending bed will
get round this, but both involve higher
capital costs. The end cones can also be
recirculated to the beginning ofthe next
pile, but thatinvolves double-handling
‘them, and there isa cost attached to any
double-handling.
Premixed material storage and
raw mill feed
‘Once reclaimed the premixed materials
stored ina premix bin before feeding to the
ravi mill to avold the need to continuously
run the reclaimer while the raw mills
in operation, In addition, to control the
chemistry ofthe mill product, the flow rate
‘of the reclaimed material tothe raw mill,
needs to be regulated. However the issue
is thatthe premixed material segregatesin
the premixbin.‘As the level ofthe material in the premix
bin changes so does the composition ofthe
‘material being delivered ta the raw mill,
The problem can be resolved by setting the
remixbin's high and low filing levelsvery
lose together, so thatthe bin level remains
‘almost constant. However, this means that
the reclaimer has to run almost all ofthe
time while the aw mills operating,
Kiln feed segregation in the
homogenisation silo and preheater
‘The sameissueis encountered in the
homogenization sito, whereby the
composition ofthe kiln feed changes as
the level ofthe ilo goes down due tothe
‘segregation ofthe material within thesilo,
Sotthe homogenisation effect ofthe stois
‘negated by segregation of matcralin the slo.
One solution s to reduce the raw mill
feed rate to match the kiln feed rate and
‘therefore keep the homogenisation silo
level constant. However, that means that
‘the raw mill has to run for more hours and
the eleciricity consumed per tonne of
feed increases.
Once the kiln feed is delivered to
the preheater, the cyclones collect the
preheated feed from the kiln exhaust gases
and pass that feed down to thenext stage
‘of the preheater. The collection efficiency
‘of the cyclones depends on the particle
Size ofthe preheated particles being,
collected. Coarser, and therefore heavier,
particles are more readily collected than
fines lighter particles. The coarser particles
also have. different composition to the
finer particles, being usually higher in silica
due to silica being harder to grind than,
calcium carbonate. So the dust lost from
the top ofthe preheater is predominantly
the finer calcium carbonate and therefore
hhas a higher lime saturation than the
liln feed. The material that is collected
and passed down the preheater to make
clinker hasa lover lime saturation than
the kiln feed ~ an unwelcome example of
inadvertent sorting by segregation in the
Production process.
(Once the dust leaves the preheater
itis amalgamated with the raw mill
product to form the kiln feed within
‘the homogenisation silo, Theresa
cycle between the preheater and the
homogenisation silo, and considerations
‘ofa mass balance mean that samples of
‘aw mill product including the dust are not
representative ofthe inputs to the process,
The weighted composition of the raw
‘material feeds to the raw mill are the true
inputs. When the rav mils stopped the
“Thankfully, in modern
coolers equipped with
walking floors, the
aeration of the clinker
bed and the transport of
clinker along the cooler
are separated. The
transport speed of the
floor and clinker across
the bed can be adjusted
tocombat the tendency to
formared river.”
dust continues to be lost from the preheater,
but theres ro raw mill product to mix
\with it How will the dust be handled when
the rew mils stopped? Storedin adust
bin? Or delivered to the homogenisation
silo changing the chemistryin the slo? Or
recirculated tothe kiln feed? Each strategy
hasits pros and cons, allof which are a
consequence o the segregation of the kln
feed in the preheater.
Red rivers in the coolers
Once the feed has passed down the
preheater the consequences of segregation
‘are not over. Segregation by particle
size continuesin the rotary kiln and this,
«an lead to a particulary troublesome
consequence inthe process: red river of
clinkerin the grate cooler. The moderator
witnessed a particularly spectacular
example in 2 10,000tpd kin in late 2015,
Red rivers are caused by the segregation
ofthe clinker falinginto the cooler induced
by the rotation oftheklin. Finer clinker
climbs the walls ofthe kiln higher with the
rotation ofthe Kiln, while coarse clinker rolls
down the ascending wall and accumulates
atthe bottom ofthe kiln, As the clinker,
clscharged into the cooler the coarse clinker
is discharged first tothe centre ofthe cooler
hile finer fractions re discharged later
towvards the edge of the cooler on the rising
side of the kiln rotation, This segregation of
the clinker provides fr diferent resistance
ofthe clinker bed to the cooling ar biown,
through. The coarser clinker provides an
easier path forthe cooling at, while the fine
clinker becomes aerated rather than cooled
and lows down the cooler ina red river
‘The ssue with a redriverin the cooler
is thatred-hot clinker flows down tothe
discharge ofthe cooler. Energy isnt
recovered to the combustion airforthe
TECHNICAL FORUM
kiln, increasing energy losses from the
kn and overall kiln fuel consumption.
However, much more problematicis that
red-hot clinkeris discharged from the
cooler. This s no major issue on the metal
an conveyors transporting the clinker
to storage, but when that still very hot
clinkeris extracted from storage there
is the danger of res on the rubber belt
conveyors transporting the clinker to
the cement mills The belts also become
cembrittied due to overheating. The cement
‘ills become prone to overheating and the
srinding efficiency falls away,
Dealing with red rivers
How to combat a red river in aclinker
‘cooler? Thankfully, in modern coolers
equipped with walking floors, the aeration
ofthe clinker bed and the transport of
ker along the cooler are separated. The
transport speed of the floor and clinker
across the bed can be adjusted to combat
the tendency to form ared river.
With older, chamber-aerated coolers
that isnot possible. In this case the best
solution sto change the granulometry
ofthe clinker tobe coarserand therefore
‘vod fines being segregated tothe kiln
rising side ofthe cooler. Changing the
grenulometry ofthe clinker requires
changes tothe clinker chemistry and
ensuring thereis no heavy circulation of,
sulphurin the kin, therefore optimising
the combustion concitionsin the kiln
Adjustment ofslica and alumina modulus
will affect the clinkering range inthe ln
and, therefore, the granulometry of clinker.
Alternatively, the segregation tendency
‘of the clinker can be reduced by slowing
the rotation ofthe kil. However, that can
lead to problems of overburning ofthe
clinker. in general the moderator prefers
‘ constant high rotational speed for
precalciner cement kilns.
Another possibility isto make physical
‘changes to the cooler to try to push the red
Fiver into the centre ofthe cooler and remix
the fines with the coarser elinker. One
‘option isto install blank grate plates on
the affected side ofthe cooler or refractory
dams and deflectors, The moderator
does not favour such solutions as they