Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
–
E i
Environmental
t l iissues:
During manufacturing
During use
During recycling/disposal
1
The basic issues
Automobiles
- consume energy during their use → issue of efficiency (car weight, engine type)
-p
pollute during
g their use → issue of fuel type
yp
→ issue of used oil disposal (minor issue)
A rough calculation:
Manufacturing:
Use:
2
Adding a few extra considerations, such as fuel processing and insurance:
Lion’s share of toxics
release during
manufacture
Lion’s share of
energy consumed
during use
Energy consumed over the lifetime of a typical Toxic releases over the lifetime of a
car. The total amount of energy represented by typical car. The total releases
the pie is 1.2 million MJ. represented by the pie are 66.3 kg.
Environmental Customer’s
Impact Basis for Decision
Lack of alignment !
3
In applying Design for Environment (DfE) to the automobile, keep in mind the time horizon.
According to BMW:
20 to 24 years!
Toward
shallow From tinkering at the margin to the social revolution!
redesign
4
Levels at which effort are being concentrated:
1. Design for fuel efficiency: - streamlined aerodynamics (pretty much at its limit by now)
- materials for lighter weight
- hybrid engines; plug-in hybrids
- electric car
Stage 1:
AUTOMOBILE MANUFACTURING
(http://blog.autospeed.ccom/)
5
Environmental impacts during manufacturing
A typical car contains about 15,000
??? parts, but the first few account for most of the
weight of the vehicle (chassis, engine, body panels, etc.)
imager.cc/page2/explodedcarparts/
88%
12%
6
Average material distribution of automobiles in 1998
(http://1877endoflifevehicles.com/rematerials.cfm)
7
Steel on a per-car basis
(1995 numbers)
680.60 kg recycled
102 kg waste
2.5 kg recycled
8
Much better numbers
now from the CES
database !
Clearly, making a lighter car gives a better environmental return than recycling materials.
9
Comparing the making and running of different cars:
Lean Manufacturing
(http://www.venturecapital.org/nvt/parte/example_e11.html)
10
Lean Manufacturing of the Smart Car
(www.echostudiochicago.com/learn/smart-car
)
(Planning for an Environment-Friendly Car, by Udo Mildenberger and
Anshuman Khlare, Technovation, Vol. 20, 2000, pages 205-214.)
4.8 L/100km
= 49 mpg
Manufacturing plant in Hambach, France:
- Green building - Press-fit plastic panels
- Workers trained in separating wastes - Other DfRecycling measures >10% in
- Environmentally conscious suppliers - Minimization of transport recycled
- Just-in-time manufacturing - etc. content
• Air emissions – Paint processes are subject to local authority regulation and visits from the
authorities to ensure compliance. VOC emissions are the main concern, due to their potential to
cause respiratory problems particularly for workers and local communities. European VOC Directives
lowers emissions limits requiring either more capital equipment for abatement or alternative low
solvent paints such as high solids, water-based paints or powder coats.
• Solid Waste – The primary source of hazardous waste from automotive plants is from painting,
mostly from cleaning processes in the paint department. Solvents and heavy metals left in residues
force the waste to be classified as hazardous. Although much material is recovered, this waste is
typically around 25% of a plant’s total hazardous waste by weight.
• Energy – Curing ovens use vast amounts of energy for the paint to dry in an acceptable time. The
shorter the curing time, the higher the energy use. This is further exacerbated by water-based paint
requiring more time in curing ovens than solvent-based paint. Powder coats also require more use of
ovens because of the thicker coats.
11
Dilemma: Organic-solvent or water-based paints?
Old way – purchase: Assembly plant purchases paints by the bucket from a paint
supplier (chemical company). It is in the paint supplier’s interest to sell as much paint
as possible. The more waste, the better from the paint supplier.
New way – service: Assembly plant hires people from the paint supplier to do the painting
of its cars. The paint supplier is paid not by the amount of paint used but by the number of
cars painted. It is now in the paint supplier’s interest to use the least paint possible,
certainly to waste the least paint possible. Waste is reduced.
Stage 2:
AUTOMOBILE USAGE
12
Environmental impacts during use
Pollution / unit of fuel (reduce by switching to an alternative fuel that pollutes less)
No idling
p://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/atv.shtml)
Direct drive –
No driveline losses
13
A Comparison of Two Engines
14
For reference, gasoline contains 13,000 Wh/kg 4,550 Wh delivered
but the internal combustion engine is only 35% efficient per kg of gasoline
15
HYBRIDS
Battery
+ -
Series hybrid
+ +
Gas Alter- Electric Wheel
nator
Battery Motor
Engine - -
16
Modes of functioning of a parallel hybrid system
starting cruising
Plug-in hybrids
A plug-in hybrid (PHEV) is a hybrid car with larger batteries and an extension cord.
It can be filled up at the gas station or plugged in into a domestic 110-volt outlet.
“It's like having a second fuel tank that you always use first – only you fill up at home,
from a regular outlet”, at an equivalent cost of under $1/gallon.
From the opposite perspective, the car can also be seen as an electric vehicle with a
gas-tank backup.
g p
There is more:
17
What other alternatives do we have besides hybrids
and plug-in hybrids?
18
Here, view NOVA documentary with the Car-Talk guys:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/car/program.html
19
Winner?
20
Could ethanol vehicles pose a significant risk to health?
"We found that E85 vehicles reduce atmospheric levels of two carcinogens, benzene
and butadiene, but increase two others—formaldehyde and acetaldehyde," Jacobson
said. "As a result, cancer rates for E85 are likely to be similar to those for gasoline.
However, in some parts of the country, E85 significantly increased ozone, a prime
ingredient of smog."
http://news-service.stanford.edu/news/2007/april18/ethanol-041807.html
Examples of fuel-cell
vehicle prototypes
21
Making it into
mainstream
media
... and there even existed for a brief time a fuel-cell motorcycle !
22
The complete fuel-cell system is
more than the cell stack…
23
Ultracapacitors
(to assist with
regenerative braking)
Power
control
unit
Hydrogen
filler
mouth
Cooling Hydrogen
system tanks
Humidifier
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/sciencenow/3210/01-car-nf.html
The body is a light shell that can be easily placed on the platform and
changed to meet the desires of the driver.
24
25
Study comparing efficiencies if source of energy is oil
1. The fuel cell car does not have an internal combustion engine at all and therefore
needs no transmission. This reduces the drive train loss from 31% to 10%.
26
Paths to get there:
(T. E. Graedel & B. R. Allenby, 1998, Industrial Ecology and the Automobile, page 207)
Source: http://www.teslamotors.com/goelectric/efficiency
27
The Tesla electric car
Roadster
Model S
The top three international car companies are getting prepared for electric cars.
e-RAV4
News item:
December 01, 2011
GM offers
ff to
t buy
b back
b k
Chevrolet Volts from
fearful owners Golf e-Motion
News item:
Tesla Falls as Toyota Prices Electric RAV4 Near $50,000
By Alan Ohnsman - May 8, 2012 – Bloomberg Report
28
Stage 3:
AUTOMOBILE RECYCLING
Old cars are typically hauled to an automobile dismantler, where reusable parts are
removed. After removing the reusable parts and other items like batteries, tires and
fluids, the hulks are usually shipped to ferrous scrap processors where they are weighed
for payment and unloaded.
The iron and steel is then shipped to end markets or steel mills where it is recycled to
produce new steel, most of it going to the construction industry.
By weight, the typical passenger car consists of about 65% steel and iron. The steel
used in car bodies is made with about 25% recycled steel.
Environmental benefits
Recycling steel saves energy and natural resources. The steel industry annually saves
the equivalent energy to power about 18 million households for a year. Recycling one
ton of steel conserves 2500 pounds of iron ore, 1400 pounds of coal and 120 pounds of
limestone.
http://www.recycle-steel.org/PDFs/brochures/auto.pdf
29
ELV =
End-of-Life Vehicle
ASR =
Automotive
Shredder
Residue
30
(www.apraa.com/Environmental_issues.html)
31
RAINING PLASTIC – Chemist Joe
Pomykala checks the flow of polyolefin
coming from a tank that separates the
recycled auto plastic concentrate into
its constituent parts.
RECYCLED AUTO PLASTICS – Project Manager Sam Jody holds a knee bolster
for a car processed from recovered polyolefin. Automotive plastic recycling begins
with auto shredder residue (left), is separated into specific plastics (right) – in this
case polyolefins – and made into plastic parts for new cars.
32
Recycled plastics in the BMW 3-series
http://www.esd.orrnl.gov/iab/iab8-8.htm
The study estimated that during the coming decade the quantity of energy used in the manufacture of
automobiles will increase (because of the increased use of plastics and aluminum); the energy consumed
during the life of the automobile will decrease (in response to new technologies and lightweight materials);
and, somewhat surprisingly, the energy savings from the recycling of automobiles will increase (primarily
because of the increased recycling of aluminum).
The adoption of new recycling technologies and approaches (e.g., thermoplastic recycling and incineration
of automobile shredder residue) will have little impact on energy savings at the recycle step.
33
Tires: A real problem at end of life
A few statistics:
“Recycling”: 15%
Use in highways: 31%
Burning as tire-derived fuel: 51%
I i
Incinerated
t d or landfilled:
l dfill d 2%
Tire “recycling” is really cascading: use in playground, artificial reefs, floor mats, dock
bumpers, carpet padding, tracks and athletic surfaces.
- Economics:
Low-value parts and materials make it difficult to run a profitable business
Prices on the recycling markets fluctuate greatly.
A t Shredder
Auto Sh dd residueid (ASR) hash to t be
b landfilled
l dfill d att a cost.
t
- Sorting of plastics:
Plastics recycling requires sorting, and a large variety of similar looking
plastics creates complications.
Labeling of plastics has helped greatly, but it is still absent in older models.
- Environmental regulations:
Contamination by spilled fluids and handling of hazardous materials
have been the object of strict regulations
regulations.
Incineration and landfilling of ASR is subject to regulations as well.
34
APPENDIX: Some useful numbers when considering automobiles
14 L / 100 km = 16
16.8
8 mpg
10 L / 100 km = 23.6 mpg
7 L / 100 km = 33.7 mpg
3.9 L / 100 km = 60.4 mpg
The average fuel efficiency of cars in the U.S. is 22.4 mpg (10.5 L / 100 km)
1 hp = 0.74570 kW
35