Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Predictor of Work-Related
Musculoskeletal Disorders
in Malaysian Nursing
Professionals
Nur Azma Amin1, Kia Fatt Quek2, Jennifer Anne Oxley3,
Rahim Noah1, Rusli Nordin2
Abstract
Background: Emotional distress is becoming a great concern and is more common in both 1
Universiti Kuala Lum-
developed and developing countries. It is associated with several disease conditions. pur-Institute of Medical
Science Technology,
Malaysia
Objective: To determine the prevalence of self-perceived emotional distress and its relation 2
Jeffrey Cheah School
to work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WRMSDs) in nurses. of Medicine and Health
Sciences, Monash
Methods: A self-administered questionnaire survey was carried out on 660 female nurses University, Malaysia
working in public hospitals in the Klang Valley, Malaysia. The validated Malay version of the
3
Monash Injury
Research Institute,
standardized Nordic musculoskeletal questionnaire (M-SNMQ) was used to identify the an- Monash University,
nual prevalence of WRMSDs; perceived emotional distress was assessed using the validated Australia
Malay short version, depression, anxiety, and stress (M-DASS) instrument. In addition,
socio-demographic and occupational profiles of the participants were considered. Factors as-
sociated with WRMSDs were identified using logistic regression analysis.
Results: A total of 376 nurses completed the survey (response rate 83.3%). 73.1% of the
nursing staffs experienced WRMSDs in at least one anatomical site 12 months prior to the
study. 75% of nurses expressed emotional distress. Of these, over half also reported anxiety
and stress. Multiple logistic regression analysis showed that stress and anxiety significantly
increased the risk of WRMSDs by approximately twofold.
Conclusion: There were significant associations between emotional distress and WRMSDs.
Future longitudinal studies are therefore needed to investigate and identify the sources of
emotional distress (non-occupational and occupational) to be used to establish preventive
strategies to reduce the risk of WRMSDs.
R
Correspondence to
apid urbanization, higher life ex- in both developed and developing coun- Nur Azma Amin, Univer-
tries. In 2003, it was estimated that over siti Kuala Lumpur- Insti-
pectancy and lack of social support tute of Medical Science
are among significant determinants 450 million people suffered from men- Technology, Taman
Kajang Sentral, 43000
of emotional distress in the population.1 tal or behavioral disorders with depres- Kajang, Selangor,
Malaysia
Cite this article as: Amin NA, Quek KF, Oxley JA, et al. Emotional distress as a predictor of work-related muscu- E-mail: wnm7912@
loskeletal disorders in Malaysian nursing professionals. Int J Occup Environ Med 2018;9:69-78. doi:10.15171/ gmail.com
Received: Sep 19, 2017
ijoem.2018.1158 Accepted: Dec 26, 2017
sion and stress being the most prevalent with the use of sophisticated technologi-
with an annual prevalence of up to 20%.2 cal equipment compared to those in the
The Third National Health and Morbid- general wards. Moreover, nurses working
ity Survey (NHMS) reported that 29.2% in rotating shifts are more prone to expe-
of Malaysian adults aged above 16 years rience work-related stress than those who
experienced mental problem. At least one work the day shift only.8
out of three workers sustained emotional Presence of mental health symptoms
distress.3 Hospitals are known for stressful such as stress, depression, and anxiety is
environment. Therefore, the occurrence usually associated with poor health out-
of emotional distress is expected among comes including immunosuppression,
nursing personnel. A study among Austra- common cold, gastroenteritis, and mus-
lian nurses revealed that 11.4%, 15.2%, and culoskeletal disorders.9 There are a num-
13.6% of them suffer from stress, anxiety, ber of epidemiological studies linking the
For more informa- and depressive symptoms, respectively, occurrence of work-related musculoskel-
tion on risk factors for
developing work-re- with at least moderate severity.4 Previous etal disorders (WRMSDs) with mental
lated musculoskeletal local surveys among critical care nurses of health. However, the findings are incon-
disorders during dairy
farming see tertiary health care facilities revealed that clusive. Bonzini, et al,10 in a longitudinal
http://www.theijoem. the majority of the nurses exhibited anxi- study among Italian nurses, suggest that
com/ijoem/index.php/
ijoem/article/view/861 ety (81%), depression (40.5%), and stress although the stressed nurses were seen to
(37.8%).5 develop musculoskeletal pain, no signifi-
Nurses are often the backbone and key cant evidence in the study was available
contacts within the hospital organization. to show that stress significantly increases
Their task is diversified and nurses need the risk of musculoskeletal pain. However,
to juggle many jobs in different units. This nurses with musculoskeletal pain were
includes providing direct care to patients, more likely to develop stress symptoms.
such as conducting assessment of patients, Harcombe, et al,11 in a cross-sectional sur-
attending to their needs, administering vey among New Zealand workers, as part
daily medications, monitoring patients' of the Cultural and Psychosocial Influ-
conditions, and also being involved in ad- ences on Disability (CUPID) study, found
ministrative work. This creates a highly significant evidence that those with better
demanding work environment and leads to mental health were at lower risk of devel-
the occurrence of mental health problems. oping neck pain compared to workers with
A local survey performed among nurses in mental health symptoms. In the context
private hospitals, reported that occupa- of patient care, presence of mental health
tional factors, such as excessive workload problems among nursing staffs is often as-
due to role ambiguity, procedural injus- sociated with reduction in patient safety
tice, and being harmed by the work-family and quality of patient care.12
conflicts were among significant contrib- We therefore conducted this study to
uting factors of poor mental health, espe- determine the relationship between emo-
cially stress, among nurses.6 In line with tional health and WRMSDs among nurs-
this finding, higher prevalence of stress ing personnel.
was also reported among Japanese nurses
attached to palliative care wards.7 This is Materials and Methods
expected because the nurses were fully ac-
countable for taking care of critically ill
Study Design and Participants
patients, endured high demands from the
patients and their relatives and also coped A cross-sectional study was performed at
N. A. Amin, K. F. Quek, et al
educational level, and average household (6 items), anxiety (7 items), and stress (7
income) and job information (length of items) over the last seven days. A study
employment, years attached to the cur- suggested that M-DASS20 is a valid and
rent unit and hospital, location of work- reliable instrument to assess the symp-
station, and time spent at work per week). toms of emotional distress among the
The nurses were required to indicate if nursing population.19 Each item comprises
they were pregnant, at menopausal age, or of a statement and four ordinal responses
breastfed a child. In addition, the nurses that ranged from ‘0’ (did not apply to me
were to inform history of non-occupation- at all) to ‘3’ (applied to me very much, or
al MSDs in lifetime. most of the time). Scores from each set
of subscales were summed to yield a sin-
Symptoms of WRMSDs gle subscale score and were interpreted
In the second section of SAQ, the nurses according to a predetermined criterion
were to identify the symptoms of WRMS- based on cut-off percentiles as either “nor-
Ds over the past 12 months using a vali- mal” (score 0–78), “mild” (score 79–87),
dated Malay version of the Standardized “moderate” (score 88–95), “severe” (score
Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire 96–98), and “extremely severe” (score 99–
(M-SNMQ) that was based on the original 100). Higher scores indicated greater se-
version.16 In an earlier reliability study, 21 verity of depression, anxiety and or stress.
items of M-SNMQ showed strong level of The emotional status (stress, anxiety, and
agreement (κ≥0.75).17 An anatomical dia- depression) of the nurses was dichoto-
gram of nine body regions (neck, shoulder, mized into either “normal” or “emotional
upper and lower back, hands/wrists, arms, distress.”18 Emotional distress refers to
knee, thighs, and feet) was appended to nurses who presented at least one symp-
facilitate the identification of the ana- toms of depression, anxiety, or stress.
tomical location of the WRMSDs symp-
Ethics
toms. The participants were requested to
indicate “yes” or “no” to any encountered The study was granted ethics approval
symptom16 of WRMSDs (pain, numbness, from Institutional Review Boards of the
tingling, aching, stiffness, and burning) in Ministry of Health (MREC) (NMRR-
the preceding 12 months. Then, the body 12-234-11176) and Monash University
regions were grouped into four anatomical (MUHREC) (CF12/506-2012000809).
regions—region 1 (neck and shoulders),
Statistical Analysis
region 2 (wrists, arms, and hands), region
3 (upper and lower back), and region 4 Data were analysed with IBM SPSS® ver
(thighs, knees, ankles, and feet)—for data 22.0. Questionnaires were checked for
analyses. completeness. Data distribution was ex-
amined for normality using the one-sam-
Symptoms of Emotional Distress (Depres- ple Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. Means and
sion, Anxiety and Stress) (M-DASS) standard deviations were reported for
In the third section, the presence of emo- continuous variables with normal distri-
tional distress symptoms was assessed us- bution. Frequencies and percentages were
ing a self-reported Malay-translated short presented for categorical data. Presence of
version of the 20-item Depression Anxiety WRMSDs symptoms was taken to be a de-
Stress Scale (M-DASS20).18 pendent variable. Self-perceived depres-
M-DASS20 consists of three subscales sion, stress, anxiety, demographic, and
that measure the symptoms of depression occupational variables were considered
N. A. Amin, K. F. Quek, et al
Table 2: Relationship between self-perceived symptoms of emotional distress (depression, anxiety and stress) and
WRMSDs symptoms across four body regions among 376 female nursing personnel studied
DASS Region 1 Region 2 Region 3 Region 4
Subscale Model* (n=209)† (n=99)† (n=133)† (n=195)†
Depression I 1.10 (0.72 to 1.69) 1.37 (0.85 to 2.20) 1.08 (0.71 to 1.65) 1.33 (0.87 to 2.03)
II 1.14 (0.74 to 1.76) 1.33 (0.82 to 2.14) 1.05 (0.68 to 1.62) 1.32 (0.86 to 2.02)
Anxiety I 2.40 (1.52 to 3.79) 1.31 (1.18 to 2.23) 1.64 (1.04 to 2.59) 2.04 (1.29 to 3.22)
II 2.34 (1.48 to 3.71) 1.66 (1.04 to 2.65) 1.59 (1.01 to 2.53) 2.05 (1.29 to 3.25)
Stress I 1.10 (1.05 to 1.18) 2.26 (1.39 to 3.67) 1.88 (1.25 to 2.84) 2.16 (1.43 to 3.26)
II 1.89 (1.25 to 2.86) 2.36 (1.44 to 3.86) 1.81 (1.19 to 2.75) 2.12 (1.40 to 3.21)
*Model I: Crude OR (95% CI);
Model II: OR (95% CI) adjusted for age, type of ward, marital status, BMI, and working hours
†
Number of nurses reporting WRMSDs in that body region
larly, self-perceived stress had significantly ence of WRMSDs symptoms were com-
elevated odds of WRMSDs symptoms in all mon due to their nature of job.25 The most
body regions with the highest OR reported frequently reported body regions associ-
for region 2 (wrists, arms and hand; OR ated with WRMSDs symptoms were the
2.26, 95% CI 1.39 to 3.67). Logistic regres- neck (48.9%), feet/ankles (47.2%), upper
sion analyses were undertaken to inves- back (40.7%), shoulders (37%), and lower
tigate the relationship between self-per- back (35.3%). A study conducted on Aus-
ceived depression, anxiety and stress, and tralian nurses26 revealed that WRMSDs
the presence of WRMSDs symptoms in symptoms were commonly reported in the
four body regions (Table 2). After adjust- lower back (71%), neck (67.4%) and feet/
ment for covariates, self-perceived anxiety ankles (55.3%).
and stress were found to be independent Nurses are known to experience a high
predictors of WRMSDs symptoms across prevalence of emotional distress, includ-
the four body regions with adjusted ORs ing depression, anxiety and stress because
ranging from 1.59 to 2.36. of their high job demand.27 Three quarters
of the studied nurses reported at least one
Discussion symptom of emotional distress. This sup-
ported the hypothesis that nursing profes-
In the context of WRMSDs, three of four sionals were at greater risk of emotional
nurses in our study reported symptoms distress compare to other professions.28,29
of WRMSDs in at least one body region Of these, over half of the studied nurses
in the past one year. Nevertheless, the suffered from anxiety and stress symp-
prevalence found in this study was slightly toms as compared to only 35% of the
lower than those reported among nurses nurses reporting depressive symptoms.
surveyed using the SNMQ in other studies This might possibly be due to the nurse to
conducted in Iran,20,21 Japan,22 Estonia,23 patient ratio in Malaysia, which was much
and Brazil,24 which varied between 81% lower (1:333) than the recommended val-
and 95%. This might possibly reflect the ue of 1:200 made by the World Health Or-
level of awareness of the studied nurses. ganization (WHO).30 The lower nurse to
The nurses may have found that the pres- patient ratio has increased the workload
N. A. Amin, K. F. Quek, et al
of the studied nurses causing mental and ies on nurses in Australia and Greece. The
physical exhaustion and consequent emo- study from Australia39 revealed that stress
tional distress.31 The prevalence of stress was not significantly related to WRMSDs
was twice that reported in an earlier lo- in the wrists or hands. A cross-sectional
cal study on nurses.32 Furthermore, in study conducted on 420 nurses working
comparison to a recent study conducted in six hospitals in Greece also reported no
on Egyptian nurses of critical care units,12 significant relationship between stress and
our results showed a higher prevalence for developing low back pain.40
anxiety (69.0%) and stress (51.6%), but a Little is known on the association be-
lower prevalence of depressive symptoms tween anxiety and WRMSDs in nursing
(50.8%). The deterioration of the nurse's population. We found that nurses pre-
emotional health might also closely be re- senting with anxiety symptoms were more
lated to the difficulties they experienced in likely to suffer from WRMSDs, particularly
meeting the patients' and their relatives' in their neck and shoulders compared to
demands and also inadequate job train- those free from the symptoms. Blozik, et
ing.33 al,9 in a cross-sectional survey in Germa-
Several researchers have so far dis- ny, reported consistent evidence that anxi-
cussed the adverse effects of poor emo- ety was significantly associated with neck
tional health that have been positively pain (OR 1.87, 95% CI 1.48 to 2.25). An
associated with the presence of WRMSDs anxious person tends to over-react in vari-
among nurses.21,34 The results of our study ous situations, particularly when avoiding
also supported the existing findings sug- potentially threatening environment. This
gesting that stressed nurses are more like- leads to non-adaptive responses, which
ly to suffer from WRMSDs in various occu- can intensify pain resulting in fear that can
pational settings. This was in line with the further increase functional disability of the
results of a cross-sectional study conduct- musculoskeletal system.41
ed on a group of Iranian nurses showing Although there is evidence in favor
that stressful nurses were prone to report of association between depression and
WRMSDs at the neck, wrists, upper back, WRMSDs in various occupational set-
and ankles/feet with an OR up to 3.21 Earli- tings, our study documented contrasting
er, Warming, et al,35 confirmed that stress findings. A recent systematic review docu-
can double the risk of low back pain (LBP). mented strong evidence for the association
A cross sectional study on female nursing between knee pain and depression.42 Kim,
students also documented significant as- et al,44 reported that depressed firefighters
sociation between stress and occurrence of have an OR of WRMSDs twice than those
low back pain.36 without depression. This was also con-
These findings might be associated firmed by Blozik, et al,9 in a cross-sectional
with the presence of stress-induced mus- study, where depression was found to dou-
cle strain, causing muscle fatigue, which ble the risk of neck pain.
could possibly lead to even injury.37 There Our study had certain limitations. The
are many sources of stress for nurses in data were obtained from a cross-sectional
the hospital environment including the design; the results should therefore be in-
workstation,7 dealing with death and dying terpreted with caution as it is a difficult
patients,38 lack of social support from the task to determine the causality, ie, whether
supervisor and colleagues,33 and shift rota- the presence of emotional distress contrib-
tion8. On the other hand, we found differ- uted to the risk of WRMSDs. Furthermore,
ent findings from those of previous stud- because the data were self-reported the
N. A. Amin, K. F. Quek, et al
between nature of work and psychosocial among lence and risk factors for foot and ankle muscu-
nurses working in Hospital Selayang, Selangor. loskeletal disorders experienced by nurses. BMC
Malaysian J Public Heal Med 2006;6:56-61. Musculoskelet Disord 2014;15:196.
14. Daniel WW. Biostatistics: A Foundation for Analysis 27. Nia HS, Akbar A, Beheshti Z, et al. Relationship
in the Health Sciences. New York, John Wiley & between backache and psychological and psy-
Sons, Inc, 1999. chosocial job factors among the nurses. Int J Nurs
Midwifery 2011;3:86-91.
15. Tinubu BMS, Mbada CE, Oyeyemi AL, Fabunmi
AA. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders 28. McVicar A. Workplace stress in nursing:A literature
among nurses in Ibadan, South-west Nigeria: a review. J Adv Nurs 2003;44:633-42.
cross-sectional survey. BMC Musculoskelet Disord
29. Schmidt DRC, Dantas RAS, Marziale MHP. Anxi-
2010;11:1-8.
ety and depression among nursing professionals
16. Kuorinka I, Jonsson B, Kilbom A, et al. Standardised who work in surgical units. Rev Esc Enferm USP
Nordic questionnaires for the analysis of musculo- 2011;45:487-93.
skeletal symptoms. Appl Ergon 1987;18:233-7.
30. Ministry of Health Malaysia. Ministry of Health
17. Fleiss JL. Statistical Methods for Rates and Propor- Health Facts 2014. Putrajaya, Malaysia, 2014.
tions. 2nd ed. New York, John Willey & Sons, 1981.
31. Janda R, Jandova E. Symptoms of posttraumatic
18. Lovibond SH, Lovibond PF. Manual for the Depres- stress disorder, anxiety and depression among
sion Anxiety Stress Scales. 2nd ed. Sydney, Austra- Czech critical care and general surgical and medical
lia, School of Psychology, University of New South ward nurses. J Res Nurs 2015;20:298-309.
Wales, 1996.
32. Sharifah Zainiyah A, Afiq I, Chow C, Siti Sara D.
19. Nur Azma B, Rusli B, Quek K, Noah RM. Psychomet- Stress and its associated factor amongst ward
ric properties of the Malay version of the Depres- nurses in a Public Hospital Kuala Lumpur. Malay-
sion Anxiety Stress Scale-21 ( M-DASS21 ) among sian J Public Heal Med 2011;11:78-85.
nurses in public hospitals in the Klang Valley. Int J
33. Sveinsdottir H, Biering P, Ramel A. Occupational
Collab Res Intern Med Public Heal2014;6:109-20.
stress, job satisfaction, and working environment
20. Abedini R, Choobineh A, Hasanzadeh J. Musculo- among Icelandic nurses: a cross-sectional question-
skeletal Load Assessment in Hospital Nurses with naire survey. Int J Nurs Stud 2006;43:875-89.
Patient Transfer Activity. Int J Occup Hyg 2008;5:39-
34. McFarlane AC. Stress-related musculoskeletal pain.
45.
Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol 2007;21:549-65.
21. Mehrdad R, Dennerlein JT, Haghigat, M, Aminian
35. Warming S, Precht DH, Suadicani P, Ebbehøj
O. Association Between Psychosocial Factors and
NE. Musculoskeletal complaints among nurses
Musculoskeletal Symptoms Among Iranian Nurses.
related to patient handling tasks and psychosocial
Am J Ind Med 2010;53:1032-9.
factors--based on logbook registrations. Appl Ergon
22. Smith DR, Mihashi M, Adachi Y, et al. A detailed 2009;40:569-76.
analysis of musculoskeletal disorder risk factors
36. Mitchell T, O'Sullivan PB, Smith A, et al. Biopsycho-
among Japanese nurses. J Safety Res 2006;37:195-
social factors are associated with low back pain in
200.
female nursing students: a cross-sectional study. Int
23. Freimann T, Coggon D, Merisalu E, et al. Risk factors J Nurs Stud 2009;46:678-88.
for musculoskeletal pain amongst nurses in Estonia:
37. Leino P. Symptoms of stress predict musculo-
a cross-sectional study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord
skeletal disorders. J Epidemiol Community Heal
2013;14:334.
1989;43:293-300.
24. Magnago TSB, Lisboa MTL, Griep RH, et al. Psycho-
38. Melvin CS. Professional compassion fatigue: what
social aspects of work and musculoskeletal disor-
is the true cost of nurses caring for the dying? Int J
ders in nursing workers. Rev Lat Am Enfermagem.
Palliat Nurs 2012;18:606-11.
2010;18:429-35.
39. Surawera IK, Hoe VCW, Kelsall HL, et al. Physical
25. Kee D, Seo SR. Musculoskeletal disorders among
and psychosocial factors associated with wrist or
nursing personnel in Korea. Int J Ind Ergon
hand pain among Australian hospital-based nurses.
2007;37:207-12.
Inj Prev 2013;19:13-8.
26. Reed LF, Battistutta D, Young J, Newman B. Preva-
40. Alexopoulos EC, Burdorf A, Kalokerinou A. Risk
factors for musculoskeletal disorders among nurs- factors for knee pain? A systematic review. BMC
ing personnel in Greek hospitals. Int Arch Occup Musculoskelet Disord 2014;15:10.
Environ Health 2003;76:289-294.
43. Kim M, Kim KS, Ryoo JH, Yoo SW. Relationship
41. Louw A, Diener I, Butler DS, Puentedura EJ. The between Occupational Stress and Work-related
Effect of Neuroscience Education on Pain, Disability, Musculoskeletal Disorders in Korean Male Firefight-
Anxiety, and Stress in Chronic Musculoskeletal Pain. ers. Ann Occup Environ Med 2013;25:9.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92:2041-56.
44. Yoon SL, Kim JH. Job-related stress, emotional
42. Phyomaung P, Dubowitz J, Cicuttini F, et al. Are labor, and depressive symptoms among Korean
depression, anxiety and poor mental health risk nurses. J Nurs Scholarsh 2013;45:169-76.