Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Review
A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Machining is basically defined as a process of gradual material removal used to finish materials of desired surface
Turning finish and dimensional accuracy. For achieving the desired surface finish and dimensional accuracy every ma-
Textured tool chining operation faces several difficulties such as localization of heat in the cutting zone resulting in various
Rake surface problems such as tool wear, increase in surface roughness, etc. So in order to overcome these problems the most
Flank surface
common technique is to use cutting fluids. Cutting fluids are generally used for cooling and lubricating the
Tribology
machining zone. But there are various environmental constraints on the use of cutting fluids during the ma-
Friction
Cutting force chining. As the continuous use of these cutting fluids have an adverse effect on human health and environment.
Tool wear Therefore it becomes very essential to go for some new technique which can either reduce the use of lubricants
or completely avoid them. Thus surface texturing proved to be one of the promising techniques which helped in
the improvement of tribological properties of textured tools. The surface textures have different geometrical size,
shape and are generally created either on the flank surface or on the rake surface of the cutting tool. The quality
of texture greatly depends on the manufacturing processes which have been used. Thus it becomes very essential
to have a complete understanding of the associated parameters of any process. The basic mechanisms in the
improvement of tribological properties are debris entrapment, reduction in contact length and improvement in
lubrication capacity, which finally helps in improvement in reducing the cutting forces, tool wear and surface
roughness of the work material.
The current article presents an extensive literature survey carried out on the different aspects of textured
cutting tools in machining processes – turning, drilling and milling. It includes the different techniques used in
creating these textures on cutting tool, experimental setups, the mechanism how textured tool is performing
better than conventional tool, different modelling and simulation techniques used and the effect of these textures
on improvement in surface finish, reducing cutting forces, tool wear, friction and cutting temperature.
1. Introduction temperature in the cutting zone becomes very high causing the rapid
tool wear which finally hampers the tool life. One option for reducing
With the continuous development in materials sector, many new the tool wear is by using cutting fluids. The cutting fluids diminish the
kinds of materials are existing in the market each has extraordinary friction between the chip–tool interface which in turn reduces the
properties like high hardness, high strength and these materials are temperature and also helps in improvement of tool life. These cutting
extensively used in today's modern industries. But when it comes to fluids acts as a coolant and lubricant and also helps in carrying away
machine these materials, it becomes a challenge as these materials are the debris which have been formed during machining as detailed in
generally having very less thermal conductivity, due to which the literature [1]. But with the continuous use of these cutting fluids have
Abbreviations: AFM, atomic force microscope; SEM, scanning electron microscope; EDM, Electric Discharge Machining; R-EDM, Reverse-Electric Discharge
Machining; MRR, material removal rate; DOC, depth of Cut; ECM, Electro Chemical Machining; HSS, High Speed Steel; AWJM, abrasive water jet machining; FIB,
focussed ion beam machining; VMT, vibro mechanical texturing; MPS, micro positioning stage; LST, laser surface texturing; ND, neutral density; PDMS, poly-
dimethylsiloxane; PMMA, polymethyl methacrylate; HAZ, heat affected zone; MR, magnetorheological; NMAP, non-magnetic abrasive particle; CIP, carbonyl iron
particle; EDX, energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy; Si3N4, silicon nitride; TiC, titanium carbide; Al2O3, aluminium oxide; TiCN, titanium carbo-nitride; TiN, titanium
nitride; TiAlN, titanium aluminium nitride; WS2, tungsten disulphide; CVD, chemical vapour deposition; PVD, physical vapour deposition; Nd:YAG, neodymium-
doped yttrium aluminium garnet; AlCrN, aluminium chromium nitride; MQL, minimum quantity lubrication; MoS2, molybdenum disulphide; CaF2, calcium fluoride;
LN2, liquid nitrogen; WC, tungsten carbide; PCD, polycrystalline diamond; FEM, finite element modelling; Nd:YVO4, neodymium-doped yttrium orthovandate; BUE,
built up edge
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: somashekhar@iitm.ac.in (S.S. Hiremath).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2019.04.011
Received 28 November 2018; Received in revised form 18 March 2019; Accepted 18 April 2019
Available online 17 May 2019
1526-6125/ © 2019 The Society of Manufacturing Engineers. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
adverse effects on the environment and to human health. Most of the Thus texturing of cutting tool surfaces is one of the methods which
cutting fluids contain harmful chemicals which cause various kinds of helps in improving the friction and lubrication between the chip–tool
skin and lung diseases such as dermatitis as detailed in literature [2]. interface. Surface texture helps in reducing the coefficient of friction by
Also, disposing of these cutting fluids is very difficult and cost of re- decreasing the contact length between the chip–tool interfaces as de-
cycling is very high. According to the report of National Institute of tailed in the literature [32–36]. Blatter et al. [37] and Costa et al. [38]
Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) it has been observed that over have stated that textured surfaces reduces the friction between the
1 million workers are under the influence of toxicology effects caused chip–tool interfaces since the debris produced from the wear gets
by cutting fluids as studied in literature [3]. Because of these negative trapped in the textured surfaces and thus helps in minimizing the
effects and stringent environmental policies, now the research has been ploughing component of friction at the tool–chip interface. The current
more focussed towards minimalizing the application of lubricant or paper intends to highlight a comparative analysis and effect between a
completely avoiding them in machining processes as detailed in lit- textured cutting tool and a conventional tool in metal cutting applica-
erature [4]. tions. If these textured tools are implemented in the manufacturing
Hence the concept of dry machining becomes very popular in recent process, it reduces the friction and wear which results in improvement
years. Dry machining is nothing but machining in absence of cutting of energy efficiency and product life which ultimately helps us in saving
fluids. It is an eco-friendly process which does not cause any water or both raw materials and fuel as detailed in the literature [39]. An ex-
air pollution. It has many advantages such as non-polluting, non-in- tensive literature survey has been carried out and listed below.
jurious and no any disposal problem as stated in literatures [5–8]. Also,
it helps in increasing the productivity by eliminating the unnecessary
machining steps as detailed in literature [9]. At the same time dry 2. Structure of this paper
machining has some drawbacks i.e. there is more friction and adhesion
between the interfaces of tool and the work material which increases This section contains a detailed review on literature pertaining to
the temperature and finally cause the reduction in life of the cutting texturing of cutting tools. It basically contains the different techniques
tool as stated in literatures [10–12]. Various kinds of tool wear which which have been used to create textured surfaces on the cutting tools.
take place during the dry machining are plastic deformation, abrasion The different techniques involves the thermal energy based micro-ma-
wear, and adhesion wear as stated in literature [13]. Due to various chining, mechanical micromachining, electro chemical micro-
wear mechanisms both the material removal rate and surface integrity machining, etc. It contains the different mechanisms involved in per-
of the finished components are affected as detailed in the paper [14]. formance enhancement using textured tools, the effects of these
The above said problems in dry machining can be overcome by textures on input/output characteristics of machining and the adverse
many sustainable techniques in manufacturing such as development of effect of texturing on performance of cutting tool. After discussing the
new cutting tool materials, surface texturing, improvement in tool mechanism of performance enhancement, the paper contains the details
geometry and application of coatings. of different experimental setups along with their basic components such
Of all available methods, surface texturing is one of the promising as various work materials, tool materials, tool coatings, lubricants and
methods as this method allows environmental friendly machining by cutting parameters. The paper also contains the various modelling and
improving the tribological characteristics. Hutchings et al. [15] defined simulation techniques used in improving the machining performances
tribology as a science to study about the interacting surfaces which are such as theoretical modelling, numerical modelling and computational
in relative motion in order to study the properties like friction, wear modelling. Finally the paper is focussed on the work which needs to be
and lubrication. Generation of surface textures in micro scale range on focussed in future for further understanding the mechanism and im-
cutting tools helps in improving the lubrication capacity and reduction proving the machining performances. The detailed classification of the
in adhesion and an observable amount of improvement in tribological research paper has been shown in Fig. 1. The next section gives the
properties has been observed as detailed in the literatures [16–31]. details of the various techniques which have been used in order to
generate textures on the cutting tools.
48
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
3. Different techniques used to create textures sensitivity and positional accuracy of +0.5 μm as detailed in literature
[41]. Raju et al. [40] developed a micro EDM setup which consists of a
Various techniques have been used to generate texture on the tool copper wire of diameter ranging between 300 and 800 μm as tool
surface which varies from thermal energy micro-machining techniques electrode to machine copper plate using a piezoactuator for controlling
to mechanical micro-machining techniques to electro chemical ma- the feed motion of tool, transistor based circuit for pulse generation and
chining technique and finally the micro/nano finishing technique. Here deionised water as the dielectric fluid. The schematic diagram of micro
only those techniques which have been used in the past decades for EDM is shown in Fig. 3. The main advantage of micro EDM is its ability
investigating the tribological properties of the textured surfaces have to produce stress-free cavities of micro size on both semiconducting and
been included. Various authors have used thermal energy micro- conducting materials. It also requires low specific energy for material
machining techniques such as Laser Surface Texturing, Electro removal as a result of which the efficiency of the process is higher as
Discharge Machining and Focussed Ion Beam Machining to create tex- stated in literature [42]. Michel et al. [43] used micro EDM to fabricate
tures of various sizes and shapes on the surface of cutting tools. Some of several micro-components like micro inserts, micro moulds, etc.
the authors have used mechanical micro-machining techniques such as However, there are also some disadvantages of this process such as
Abrasive Water Jet Machining, Micro Grinding, Micro Abrasive low material removal rate, because of which there is a restriction on the
Blasting, Vibro Mechanical Texturing and Hardness Tester to create size of the work material. Also, it has the inability to control the shape
surface textures either on the rake surface or the flank surface of the and size of work material because the tool is not in direct contact with
cutting tools. Some authors have used Electro Chemical Machining the work material as stated in the literature [44]. Jianxin et al. [12]
technique as it does not produce any thermal or mechanical damage on created micro holes on the flank face and rake face of the cemented
the work material. Some authors have used Micro/Nano finishing carbide insert using micro-EDM to study the effects of micro-holes on
technique such as Magnetorheological fluid based nano-texturing to tool wear, friction coefficient and cutting forces. Wenlong et al. [45]
create nano-level textures on the cutting tools and one of the ad- created micro holes on the rake surface of carbide tool using micro-
vantages of this technique is that it can be used for both ferromagnetic EDM to analyse the average friction coefficient, tool wear and cutting
and non-ferromagnetic materials. Some of the authors have also used forces and witnessed an improvement in the machinability of the cut-
Metal Forming techniques such as Micro Casting to create micro-level ting tool. Talla et al. [46] used reverse electric discharge machining (R-
textures as this process is fast and loss of material during the creation of EDM) to fabricate an arrayed structure on mild steel using copper as the
textures is very less. The shape of the textures generated using the tool electrode. They investigated the influence of control variables such
different techniques mentioned above were measured using various as flushing pressure, pulse on time and peak current on the response
instruments such as Atomic force microscope (AFM), Scanning electron characteristics such as Material Removal Rate (MRR), micro-hardness
microscope (SEM), Optical microscope, profilometer and Stereo mi- and cylindricity error. The authors analysed that the peak current was
croscope. Fig. 2 shows the classification of different techniques used in the most important parameter affecting the (MRR), surface roughness
creating the texture. The next section will provide the detailed analysis and taperness. Koshy et al. [47] created continuous texture with over-
of each of the various texture generation techniques along with their lapping craters (areal) and linear texture which comprises of series of
advantages and disadvantages. grooves using sink EDM on the rake surface of the cutting tool using
copper electrode with an average gap voltage of 100 V, discharge cur-
rent of 72 A and on time of 133 μs. The authors observed that areal
3.1. Electro Discharge Machining
texture performed better in comparison to linear texture in the reduc-
tion of the machining forces.
Electro Discharge Machining (EDM) is a thermal machining process
Kim et al. [9] created parallel ridges on the rake surface of tool in
in which a required shape of the object can be obtained as a mirror
the actual direction of chip flow using EDM to study the effects of the
image of the tool. The removal of material takes place through melting
textured tool on the main cutting forces in comparison to the non-tex-
and vaporization of the workpiece material at the point of discharge as
tured tool. Kim et al. [48] created a linear pattern on the rake face of
detailed in literature [40]. Micro EDM works on the same principle as
the cBN tool using a micro size tool of diameter 90 μm through micro
that of EDM. The system contains a servo mechanism which has high
49
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
burrs and debris because in this method metals are dissolved electro-
chemically as a result of which surface finish is excellent.
But the drawback with this process is that the rate of material re-
moval is very slow and thus for increasing the productivity usage of
tools in the batch was introduced in literature (Park et al. [53]). Byun
et al. [54] created micro dimples on AISI 440C using micro ECM with
the pulse on time of 2 μs and nominal machining time of 10 s to study
the effect of the micro-dimples on the coefficient of friction. Fig. 5(a)
shows the schematic setup of micro ECM which basically consists of
brass as the tool electrode having the diameter of 250 μm and AISI 440C
as the work material with Sodium Nitrate as the electrolyte. The side
walls of the tool was insulated with diluted enamel in order to avoid the
overcut and Fig. 5(b) shows the shape of micro dimples created on the
surface of AISI 440C using the above mentioned technique. Quian et al.
[55] created textured surface by through-mask micro ECM. They in-
Fig. 4. Shape of linear texture created using Micro EDM [48]. vestigated the effect of the auxiliary anode in reducing the lateral un-
dercutting and thus improving the localization of surface textures and it
was found that the machining localization could be improved by using
EDM. But one of the problems with this machining process was the
auxiliary anode. Patel et al. [56] used micro ECM to create three dif-
amount of tool wear. Due the tool wear, the created surface texture was
ferent kinds of micro features such as circular micro channels, linear
not flat but inclined. So in order to minimize this problem the authors
micro channels and micro dimples on the cylindrical surface of the
created a linear pattern by removing the material layer by layer by
hypodermic needle for studying the effect of the insertion force using a
maintaining the depth of the removed layer minimum. Thus a linear
textured and non-textured needle.
texture of depth = 50 μm and width = 110 μm was created on the cBN
tool as shown in Fig. 4. They observed the effect of micro-textured tool
on the cutting forces, coefficient of friction and tool wear. Arulk-
3.3. Micro grinding
irubakran et al. [49] created linear texture in parallel, perpendicular
and cross texture on the rake surface of cemented carbide insert using
Micro grinding is very similar to conventional grinding, but it falls
the wire cut EDM process. They authors observed that the machin-
into the category of micromachining because of the size effects such as
ability of Ti–6Al–4V can be enhanced using perpendicular direction
edge radius of tool and minimum thickness of chip. Mahabunphachai
micro textured tool and a maximum reduction in cutting forces was
et al. [57], Heinzel et al. [58] and Hwang et al. [59] described the size
observed using the perpendicular textured tool.
effect as an increase in specific energy at low Depth of Cut (DOC) and
feed rate. It is better in comparison to other mechanical micro-
3.2. Electro Chemical Micro-Machining machining methods because of lesser burr formation as stated in lit-
erature [60]. Stepien et al. [61] used a method called pattern grinding
Electro Chemical Machining (ECM) is the reverse of electroplating, to create texture on the surface of hard steel by using a distinct grinding
and material removal takes place through the anodic dissolution of the wheel whose surface has been shaped at micro level in the fixed pattern
workpiece. It is based on electrolysis in which metals are liberated atom however the aspect ratio which can be maintained is only 0.01 (micro
by atom from the workpiece. Faraday's law of electrolysis is the gov- array height/interval). The objective of using this micro grinding is to
erning principle of micro ECM, and the shape of the workpiece is ap- replace the high energy beam and chemical processes because these
proximately the mirror image of the micro-tool with an inter-electrode processes are costly, requires high processing time and it is very diffi-
gap of around 10–30 μm as detailed in the book [50]. In micro ECM cult to maintain the shape accuracy of the micro-grooves as detailed in
ultra-short pulse voltages are used to machine the work materials, but the literature [62], whereas mechanical processes are inexpensive and
for improving the machining resolution, proper machining conditions productive. But one of the disadvantages in micro grinding is to
should be selected such as pulse on time and electrolyte as stated in maintain the accuracy of the micro level pattern on super hard grinding
literature [51,52]. Micro ECM is better in comparison to other processes wheel as higher will be the aspect ratio, higher will be the grinding
because it does not produce any thermal or mechanical damage, no forces as stated in literature [30]. Xie et al. [62] created orthogonal and
50
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 5. (a) Schematic diagram of electro chemical machining and (b) the micro dimples created on the surface of AISI 440C [54].
diagonal micro-grooves on the rake surface of the carbide tool to per- techniques.
form dry machining of Ti–6Al–4V. Fig. 6(a) shows the experimental Thomas et al. [64] stated that by creating textures using the hard-
setup of micro-grinding for creating micro-grooves on the rake surface ness testers such as Vickers Hardness Tester, Brinell Hardness Tester,
of carbide tool. The setup contains a V-tip diamond wheel with rota- and Diamond dresser involve mechanical forces, so there are very less
tional speed of 3538 rpm, feed rate of 200 mm/min and depth of cut of chances of creation of thermal stresses. Because of the above mentioned
2 μm to create micro-grooves of depth 155.1 μm and mean aspect ratio advantages several authors such as Gajrani et al. [65] used Rockwell
of 0.43 and Fig. 6(b) shows the diagonal micro-grooved pattern created Hardness Tester to create conical micro-dimples on the rake surface of
on the rake face of the cutting tool. The authors investigated the effects the hardened High-Speed Steel (HSS) tool. After that the micro-dimples
of texturing on the surface roughness, shearing angle and tool wear. Xie were filled with MoS2 solid lubricants to observe the effects of textured
et al. [63] created micro-grooved texture on the rake face of carbide tools on friction coefficient, cutting forces, chip thickness, chip length
tool using micro-grinding with the help of a V-tip diamond grinding in solid lubricating environments. They observed a substantial reduc-
wheel. The authors observed the influence of size and shape of micro- tion in the friction coefficient, cutting forces and feed forces. Thomas
grooves on cutting temperature and cutting forces during dry turning of et al. [64] created micro-texture on the rake face of high-speed steel
Ti–6Al–4V alloy. (HSS) M42 Grade S200 using Rockwell Hardness Tester, scratching
with Diamond Dresser and Vickers Hardness Tester. They measured the
3.4. Hardness tester effects of textured tool on cutting forces, surface roughness and cutting
temperature. And an improvement in the machining characteristics was
Hardness tester is generally used to measure hardness of work ma- observed such as temperature at tool–chip interface, cutting forces and
terial and as a result of which indentations are produced on the work surface roughness of the workpiece. Fig. 7(a) depicts the experimental
surface. The shape of the indentation depends on the type of the in- setup of Vickers Hardness Tester for creating micro-textures. It consists
denter used, it may be conical or square in shape. Many authors have of a diamond indenter of pyramid shape with square base, a load ap-
used these indentations as micro-textures on the cutting tools. This plying lever and a microscope for measuring the diagonal of the in-
method of creating texture is advantageous in comparison to other dentation generated on the specimen. A square shaped indentation was
methods such as electric discharge machining, electrochemical ma- created on the rake face of M42 grade high-speed steel as shown in
chining, laser surface texturing, etc. Because the other methods involve Fig. 7(b). Gajrani et al. [66] created micro-texture using a Vickers
heat while creating surface textures and the heat generated causes the hardness tester on the rake surface of plasma nitrided HSS grade tool.
formation of thermal stresses which finally leads to deformation in the The authors studied the effects of mechanically textured surfaces on
tool. Also the thermal based processes cannot assure the repeatability, cutting forces, friction coefficient and tool–chip interface temperature
i.e. the same size cannot be repeated using the same input parameters. in comparison to conventional cutting tools. They inferred a reduction
However generation of texture using the mechanical techniques are in coefficient of friction and surface roughness of the workpiece in
easy, accurate and repeatable in comparison to other thermal based comparison to conventional tool.
51
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
52
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
53
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
to the ordinary cutting methods. So vibro mechanical texturing is cost- higher precision, small debris around the spot which has been ablated
effective, minimum chances of surface damage and high precision. and lesser HAZ as stated in literature [92–94]. Therefore various au-
Hence this process may be newer technique for generating micro-tex- thors have used LST techniques to create textures on the flank/rake face
tures on cutting tools. of the cutting tool for the reduction in wear and friction. Lei et al. [95]
created micro-holes on the rake face of the Tungsten Carbide (WC)
insert near to the cutting edge using the femtosecond laser. The authors
3.10. Laser Surface Texturing (LST) studied machining performance of the cutting tool in lubricated con-
dition in terms of the contact length of tool chip, cutting forces and chip
Lasers are the devices which are primarily used to amplify the co- morphology. Kawasegi et al. [96] employed femtosecond laser to create
herent radiations whose frequencies are in the range of ultraviolet, texture on the rake face of cemented carbide tool in nano and micro-
visible and infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum as detailed scale. The selected pulse duration and frequency were 150 ps and 1 kHz
in book [50]. When the high energy pulse is applied, removal of ma- respectively. Three different types of textures were created that are
terial takes place by laser ablation, i.e., by rapid melting and vapor- linear texture perpendicular, parallel and cross texture in the direction
ization. LST has various advantages such as it provides proper surface of chip flow to study the effect of texture on friction between the
topography and lesser contamination of substrate surface in comparison chip–tool interface and the cutting forces. Ma et al. [97] created micro-
to other methods as stated in literature [87]. But this process also has grooves parallel to the main cutting using the femtosecond laser to
some drawbacks such as Heat Affected Zones (HAZ), periodical struc- study the effect of these micro-grooves in improving the turning per-
tures and surface defects. HAZ is created when the temperature of the formance of the cutting tool. Fig. 12(a) shows the experimental setup of
part being machined increases above the critical transformation point, femtosecond laser used for creating micro-textures. The setup consists
and since the HAZ is brittle in nature, therefore, the area becomes prone of computer controlled translational stage for mounting the cemented
to cracking as detailed in literature [88]. carbide tool. The power of the laser is adjusted through a neutral
Formation of ripple or periodical surface structures have been ob- density filter and then the laser beam is focussed on the surface of the
served in nanosecond and femtosecond laser due to a phenomenon cutting tool to create texture of desired shape and size. Two parallel
called interference, and it has been found that, due to the formation of micro-grooves were created on the rake surface of WC of width 256 μm
these ripples, an increase in the surface roughness of the substrate takes and pitch 335 μm as shown in Fig. 12(b).
place as detailed in literature [89]. Surface defects are nothing but the Jianxin et al. [98] created three different shapes of textures on the
burrs which are created during laser machining. Burrs are produced rake face of tungsten carbide insert using laser machining. The three
when the metal to be removed gets solidified before it has to be re- different types of textures were elliptical grooves, grooves in parallel
moved by assist gas such as oxygen, nitrogen, etc., and it is significant direction to the main cutting edge and linear grooves. They studied the
as it influences the frictional behaviour of the substrate as detailed in effect of texturing on the coefficient of friction between the chip–tool
literature [90,91]. Earlier surface texturing was done by using long interfaces, cutting temperature and cutting forces. Ze et al. [99] created
pulse lasers such as nanosecond Nd: YAG laser, nanosecond excimer micro-features on the flank face and rake face which was very close to
laser, picosecond Nd: YAG laser, etc., but with the development of ul- the main cutting edge on cemented carbide cutting insert using an LD
trafast laser techniques, femtosecond lasers became one of the widely side pumped Nd:YAG laser system having wavelength of 1064 nm,
used lasers in material processing. pulse duration of 20 ns and repetition rate of 2 kHz. They created two
The main benefits of femtosecond lasers in comparison to others are
54
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 10. (a) Shape of the micro holes created using micro casting (b) along with the various steps involved in generating the micro textures [81].
Fig. 11. (a) Schematic diagram of Vibro mechanical texturing and (b) the micro-dimples created on the surface of A2 rod [85].
55
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 12. (a) Experimental setup of femtosecond laser with different components and (b) the micro-grooves created in the direction parallel to main cutting edge [97].
different shapes of grooves, i.e., elliptical and linear grooves on the rake material removal takes place through the NMAPs as detailed in litera-
and flank face of the cutting tool and observed the effect of these tex- ture [101].
tures on the cutting forces, friction coefficient, and tool wear. Lian et al. The removal of material takes place through the shear force which is
[100] created a new kind of tool which was created by firstly creating a induced by the viscoplastic nature of the cutting fluid as stated in lit-
nano-texture on the rake face of uncoated cemented carbide using erature [102]. Singh et al. [103,104] developed a new finishing process
femtosecond laser and then a soft coating of WS2 was deposited on the for creating flat as well as 3D surfaces using a ball end MR tool suitable
textured tool and the authors observed a reduction in cutting forces, for both non-ferromagnetic and ferromagnetic materials and using this
cutting temperature and coefficient of friction using the self lubricated technique a surface roughness smaller than 100 nm was achieved on
rake surface textured tool. copper and EN31 work materials. Thiyagu et al. [102] created nano-
level texture on the cutting tool using MR fluid based nano-texturing to
observe the machinability characteristics of nano-textured cutting tool
3.11. Magneto-rheological (MR) fluid based nano-texturing
in comparison to un-textured tool while turning duplex stainless steel.
They observed a greater stability in tool rake and flank wear using the
Magnetorheological (MR) fluid based nano-texturing is one of the
textured tool. The next section gives the details regarding the me-
nano-finishing techniques used for creating nano level textures on the
chanisms which are involved in improving the machining performances
tool surface to improve the machining characteristics. Fig. 13 shows the
using the textured tools.
experimental setup of MR fluid based finishing technique. MR fluid
consists of Non-Magnetic Abrasive Particles (NMAPs), Magnetic Car-
bonyl Iron Particles (CIPs), surfactants and other carrier liquids. It acts
as Newtonian viscous fluid in the absence of magnetic field, and when
the magnetic field is applied, it starts acting as viscoplastic fluid. CIPs
and magnetic field are essential for producing the MR effect while
56
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
4. Textured cutting tools and observed a reduction in friction in comparison to the conventional
tool. The authors stated that the reduction in friction takes place due to
4.1. Mechanism of performance enhancement in the textured cutting tool the entrapment of debris generated from various wear mechanisms in
the parallel ridges. Sugihara et al. [106] created micro-dimples on the
Generation of specific texture in the form of depressions on smooth rake surface of uncoated cemented carbide tool and observed a reduc-
and flat sliding surfaces is one of the basic approaches to improve the tion in crater wear. The authors stated that tool wear mainly takes place
tribological properties such as friction, wear, and lubrication. The because of the wear debris coming out of the cutting tool and work-
performance of tool and quality of finished product are greatly influ- pieces resulting in ploughing of tool surface. Thus by generating the
enced by these properties. Various authors have studied the effects of micro stripes on the cutting tool, helps in entrapping these wear debris
generation of textures in form of depressions on the face of the cutting which helps in reducing the ploughing action on the surface of tool and
tool during different machining operations and they observed an im- it finally helps in reducing the crater wear. Niketh et al. [107] created
provement in the various properties such as friction between chip tool micro dimples on the flute and margin sides of the drilling tool. The
interface, reduction in wear of the cutting tool and increase in the lu- authors observed a reduction in coefficient of friction using the textured
brication action. They stated that there are basically two mechanisms tool in comparison to the untextured one. The reduction in the coeffi-
which are involved in the improvement of tribological properties be- cient of friction was because of entrapment of the wear particles into
tween the chip and cutting tool interface in machining. the micro dimples and which further avoid the squeezing and rubbing
of wear particles between chip and tool interface resulting in reduction
of coefficient of friction.
4.1.1. Debris entrapment
During the cutting operation wear debris is generated due to various
tool wear mechanisms such as (a) abrasion wear in which wear of tool 4.1.2. Reservoir for lubricants
occurs because of presence of hard particles in the workpiece. (b) Reservoir for lubricants is the other significant effect of surface
Adhesive wear occurs when the small particles from the rake surface are texturing because during machining the lubricants which are trapped
carried away with the chips because of welding action between the two between the tool–chip interfaces permeates into these textured cavities.
metals due to high temperature and pressure. (c) Diffusion wear occurs Thus a thin film of lubrication is produced on the upper surface of the
when the atoms from the cutting tool disperse into the chip due to cavities as stated in literature [108]. Due to the formation of this thin
solubility between two materials under the high contact pressure. The film of lubricants, there is no any direct contact between the tool and
main functions of these surface textures are to trap these wear debris chip interfaces which finally causes the reduction in friction, and as a
particles created due to the above-mentioned wear mechanisms. Thus result, it helps in reducing the cutting forces, tool–chip contact length
the elimination of wear debris from the tool-chip interfaces minimizes and cutting temperature. Lei et al. [95] created small holes near to the
the ploughing action by the wear debris as detailed in literature [24] cutting edge of the turning insert and used different lubrication tech-
which finally helps in improvement of tool life. Neves et al. [105] in- niques such as flood cooling and micro-pool lubrication. They observed
vestigated the effects of textured drill bits in order to machine AISI 304. that a total reduction of 28% in the contact area using micro-pool lu-
The authors observed that textured drill bits observed lesser tool wear brication in comparison to the dry cutting operation. It was because
in comparison to the untextured one because of entrapment of debris during the machining operation temperature between the tool chip
generated during the drilling operation of AISI 304. Enomoto et al. [32] interfaces becomes high. As a result of which the lubricant trapped
created four different types of grooves on the rake surface of cutting between the chip tool interfaces permeates in the micro holes resulting
tool during the machining of carbon steel. The authors observed that in thin film lubrication causing the reduction in friction, which inturns
tool wear resistance of the textured tool significantly improved in leads to reduction in tool wear. Jianxin et al. [98] and Wu et al. [109]
comparison to the conventional tool because these micro-grooved sur- created different shape textures on the rake surface of WC cutting tool
faces entraps the wear particles generated due to various wear me- and filled those textures with MoS2 solid lubricant to machine 45#
chanism during the face milling operation. Kim et al. [9] created ridges carbon steel and Ti–6Al–4V. The authors observed that textured tool
parallel to the direction of chip flow on the rake face of the cutting tool with MoS2 lubricant improved cutting performance. It happened
57
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
because of the formation of the thin lubricating film released from the obtain various forces generated during the operation such as thrust
textures and smeared on the tool surface resulting in reduction of force and cutting force.
coefficient of friction, cutting forces, etc. Ze et al. [99] observed a re- From the force diagram as shown in Fig. 14.
duction in the coefficient of friction on increasing the cutting speed
Ff a w lf τc
using rake face textured tool with MoS2 solid lubricant. The authors Fr = =
sin β sin β (2)
inferred that reduction in friction occurred due the formation of thin
layer of lubricants between the chip and tool interfaces. Sugihara et al. a w lf τc cos(β − γ0)
[110] reported that micro/nano grooves provided lesser friction during Fz = Fr cos(β − γ0) =
sin β (3)
wet machining of A5052 alloy. The authors observed that the reduction
in friction was because of the retention of the cutting fluid by the a w lf τc sin(β − γ0)
micro/nano grooves which finally reduced surface adhesion between Fy = Fr cos(β − γ0) =
sin β (4)
the tool and chip interface. The next section provides the details re-
garding the effect of texturing on machining characteristics. where Fr is the resultant force, Fy is the thrust force, Fz is the main
cutting force, γ0 is the rake angle, β is the angle of friction.
The above equation clearly indicates that the cutting force is di-
4.2. Effect of texturing on machining characteristics rectly related to shear strength and contact length between chip and
tool. The shear strength of MoS2 is around 30–35 MPa as stated in lit-
4.2.1. Effect of texturing on cutting forces erature [112] which is very less in comparison to carbide, i.e.,
The effectiveness of any cutting process depends on the amount of 700–800 MPa [98]. Thus when a lubrication film of MoS2 is present at
generation of cutting forces as the cutting forces are directly dependent the tool–chip interface, then the cutting forces will get reduced ac-
on the cutting tool parameters (tool material, tool geometry), work cording to Eqs. (2)–(4). Jianxin et al. [98] observed cutting speed as one
material parameters (hardness, hot/cold worked) and cutting para- of the main factor influencing the cutting forces, i.e., at speed
meters (depth of cut, speed, feed). (> 120 m/min) there was the maximum reduction in the cutting forces.
Generation of surface textures on the cutting tool helps in reduction And a maximum reduction of 25% in the cutting forces was observed
of the cutting forces which finally results in tool life improvement and with the elliptical textured tool in comparison to the non-textured tool.
the surface finish of machined work material. Various authors have Lei et al. [95] performed turning operation using the micro-textured
used this surface texturing technique and observed that there is a sig- tool in different lubrication conditions. The authors observed that there
nificant reduction in the cutting forces. Jianxin et al. [98] created was a significant decrease in the cutting forces using micro-pool lu-
various geometrical textures on the rake surface of carbide tool insert brication in comparison to dry turning and a reduction of 11% in the
and filled the textures with molybdenum disulfide (MoS2). During the cutting forces was observed using micro-pool lubrication technique in
turning operation of 45# steel, the dry lubricant comes out of the the micro-grooved textured tool. Koshy et al. [47] assessed the per-
textures and forms a thin lubricating film at the chip-tool interfaces. formance of texture in terms of main cutting forces and feed forces. A
Since the shear strength of MoS2 is less in comparison to carbide tool, reduction of 13% and 30% was observed in average cutting and feed
therefore there is a reduction in the friction force which finally results forces. They observed that the decrease in the cutting forces was due
in reduction of cutting forces. the coupling between the friction and shear processes in cutting. With
This phenomenon can be better understood by following equations. the decrease in friction subsequent increase in shear angle was observed
In case of a thin lubricating film formed at the chip–tool interface using which resulted in the formation of thinner chips. In addition to the
solid lubricants in the textured tool, the frictional force (Ff) at the rake reduction of cutting forces, texturing resulted in the reduction of
face of the tool can be calculated using following equations stated in variability in cutting forces as shown in Fig. 15.
literature [111]. Xie et al. [63] observed a relationship between of cutting force,
Ff = a w lf τc (1) depth of texture and material removal rate. They found that increased
depth of grooves caused a significant increase in cutting force because if
where aw is the width of cut, lf is the contact length between tool and the depth of groove will be larger there will be more contact between
chip, τc is the shear strength of lubricating film at the interface of tool rake face of tool and chip as shown in Fig. 16. A reduction of 32.7% in
chip. Fig. 14 shows the schematic force diagram of orthogonal turning the cutting force was observed with the micro-grooved tool in com-
containing a micro-grooved textured tool filled with solid lubricants to parison to the non-textured tool. Xing et al. [113] created nano and
58
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 17. Micrograph of conventional and flank face textured tool [12].
59
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 18. Flank tool wear of different microstructured milling tool [33].
Jianxin et al. [12] created micro-holes on the flank and rake face of which finally enhanced the wear resistance of cutting tool.
cemented carbide and the micro-holes were filled with MoS2 solid lu- Fatima et al. [115] structured the flank face of the cutting tool with
bricants to study the effects of these self-lubricated tools on tool wear. special shape which was very similar to the scales present on skin of
They studied the SEM images of the flank face textured and conven- snake. The authors observed a greater reduction in flank wear of tex-
tional tool as shown in Fig. 17. From the micrograph, it is clear that the tured tool in comparison to the conventional tool because the snake
wear pattern in the flank face textured tool was very less in comparison skin structures acted as better reservoir for the lubricants. Liu et al.
to the conventional tool. It was because of the formation of lubricating [119] created grooves parallel, perpendicular and inclined at an angle
film between the tool and chip interfaces, which was released from the of 45° to the main cutting edge on the flank surface of WC/Co carbide
micro-hole and smeared on the flank and rake surface. Chang et al. [33] tool. They performed dry turning test on the green alumina ceramic
inspected the effects of different microstructures on wear resistance of with different textured tools to study the effect of textures on the wear
the milling cutters. Fig. 18 shows the SEM images of both conventional resistance of the cutting tool. The authors observed very less wear on
and microstructured milling tool and it has been observed that micro- the rake surface of the cutting tool while flank surface of the tool suf-
grooves perpendicular to the direction of cutting edge showed smallest fered a serious abrasive wear. But by creating textures, the flank wear
flank wear in comparison to other textured cutting tools. The reduction could be reduced to a larger extent. Out of all the textured patterns,
in flank wear takes place in microstructured tool because of lesser ad- grooves parallel to the main cutting edge showed higher flank wear
hesion between the tool and work material in comparison to the con- resistance because of a phenomenon called derivative cutting. It is re-
ventional milling tool. ferred as an additional cutting of the hard inclusions through the
Ling et al. [39] created rectangular shape surface textures on the bottom edge of texture between the work material and tool interface. As
margins of drill bits by means of a diode-pumped Nd:YVO4 picosecond a result of which flank wear was reduced in comparison to non-textured
laser for machining titanium plate. The authors observed that texturing cutting tool. Fig. 19 shows the schematic diagram of the mechanism of
exhibit an improvement in the shedding of the adhered chips which wear of flank face textured tool. Fig. 19(c) shows the bottom portion of
leads to reduction in chip adhesion resulting in extended tool life. Xie the cutting tool on which texture was generated and this bottom texture
et al. [62] created diagonal and orthogonal micro-grooves on the tool started acting as a cutting tool and thus finally helps in reducing the
rake face to predict the effects of texture on the tool wear. They ob- influence of hard inclusion between the work material and tool inter-
served that the micro-grooved tools produced lesser tool wear both on face. Arulkirubakaran et al. [120] used textured, un-textured, coated
rake and flank face in comparison to non-textured tool. A reduction of and uncoated cutting tools to study the machinability of Ti–6Al–4V
6.7% in tool wear was observed using the diagonal micro-grooved tool. alloy. They observed that TiAlN coated tool with texture in the per-
It was because the orientation of the texture was in the direction of chip pendicular direction of the chip flow displayed maximum flank wear
flow which enhanced the better transfer of heat from the cutting zone. resistance in comparison to other texture and coated tools. It was be-
Kummel et al. [117] created dimple and channel textures on the cause of better wear resistant of TiAlN coating. Also during machining
rake surface of uncoated cemented carbide to study the effects of tex- of Ti–6Al–4V alloy, there was the formation of Al2O3 which acted as a
tures on adhesive properties of built up edge formation on the cutting reducer of friction between the two contacting surfaces. And which fi-
tool. It was observed that by the application of dimple textured sur- nally improved the thermal stability of the cutting tool. A maximum
faces, the adhesive properties of built up edges increased because of reduction of 29.4% in the flank wear was observed using TiAlN coated
better mechanical interlocking and as a result of which wear rates were perpendicular textured tool in comparison to the uncoated non-textured
minimized in comparison to other textured cutting tools. Sugihara et al. tool.
[118] developed micro-stripes on the flank and rake face of WC/Co
carbide tool during face milling of medium carbon steel. They observed
4.2.3. Effect of texturing on surface finish of machined surface
that micro-stripes helped in suppressing both the crater and flank wear
With the development of advanced materials, the major problem
by serving as micro-trap for entrapment of wear debris. Sun et al. [116]
which we come across during the machining of these materials is their
observed minimum crater wear in hybrid textured tool in comparison to
poor thermal conductivity. It causes greater increase in temperature in
non-textured and micro-grooves tool. It was because of the large
the cutting zone, resulting in higher tool wear and surface roughness.
amount of lubricants got trapped into the hybrid textures which were
This section basically highlights the use of textured tool in improving
smeared on the rake surface, thus forming a thick lubrication film
the surface finish of machined materials.
60
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 19. Schematic diagram of wear mechanism of flank face textured cutting tool [119].
Xie et al. [62] and Xing et al. [113] noticed that texturing has ne- surface roughness was observed during the machining of mild steel and
gative effects on the surface finish of the machined workpiece, i.e., aluminium alloy using the different textured tools.
there was an increase in the surface roughness using the textured tool
because the micro-grooves present on the textured tool get patterned on
4.2.4. Effect of texturing on friction
the work material increasing its surface roughness. However there was
Friction can be defined as the resistance offered by one body while
a decrease in the deviation of surface roughness (ER) in the textured
moving over another body. Bruzzone et al. [121] stated that friction
tool in comparison to the conventional tool. Although conventional tool
depends on materials which are in contact and the tribological system.
produced better surface finish than micro-textured tool but it produced
It has been observed that around 30% of the world's total energy is used
more uneven surface quality which finally resulted in increased chat-
to overcome friction as mentioned in literature [122]. Creation of
tering in conventional tool in comparison to the textured tool.
micro-scale texture is one of the methods to reduce the friction between
Liu et al. [119] created textures of different orientation on the flank
two contacting surfaces. The main reasons behind the reduction in
surface of WC/Co carbide to study the effects of textures on the surface
friction between the contacting surfaces are entrapping the debris in-
roughness of machined surface and they observed that textured tool had
side the micro-textures and improvement in lubrication capacity.
very minimal effect in improving the surface roughness of machined
Wenlong et al. [45] studied the effects of the textured tool on the
green ceramics.
friction between the tool and chip interface using different solid lu-
Arulkirubakaran et al. [120] studied the effects of texturing and
bricants such as (MoS2, CaF2, and graphite). The authors observed that
coating of the cutting tool on the surface finish while machining
textured tool embedded with graphite as solid lubricant showed the
Ti–6Al–4V alloy. The authors observed an improvement in surface
lower coefficient of friction without any great variation in the cutting
finish on increasing the cutting speed because of thermal softening of
speed in comparison to other solid lubricated textured tools. It was
the work material as shown in Fig. 20. Better surface finish on the work
because, during machining, lubricants were released from the textures
material was observed using textured and coated tool, and a minimum
forming a thin lubricating film which resulted in less friction while
of 0.248 μm surface roughness was measured using TiAlN coated per-
sliding of the chip over the rake face of the tool. Ze et al. [99] reported a
pendicular textured tool. Thomas et al. [64] observed an enhancement
descending trend in the coefficient of friction with an increase in cut-
in the surface finish during machining of mild steel (EN3B) and Alu-
ting speed during dry turning of Ti–6Al–4V alloy. They observed that
minium (AA 6351) using the textured tool. The reduction in surface
rake face textured tool showed greater reduction in coefficient of fric-
roughness was due to reduction in adhesion of chip and tool surface,
tion in comparison to flank face textured and conventional tool.
which finally reduced the tool wear. A 15.86% and 23.21% reduction in
Xie et al. [63] observed that the cutting temperature at the tip of the
Fig. 20. Variation of surface roughness of work material with cutting speed for (a) uncoated tool and (b) TiAlN coated tool [120].
61
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 22. Variation in friction coefficient with respect to sliding time for the Fig. 23. Variation of temperature at the tip of cutting edge with cutting speed
textured and non-textured surfaces [107]. during machining of mild steel [64].
62
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
where θo is ambient temperature, R1 is the ratio of the heat which is Most of the research work which has been carried so far on micro-
flowing into the chip to the total heat generated by shear, Vs denotes textured tool machining is on commercially used setups of lathe and
shear velocity, τs indicates the shear strength of the work material, c1 is vertical machining centres. Various authors have used different setups
specific heat of chip, ρ1 denotes density of chip, v is the cutting speed, ϕ for different machining operations such as Kawasegi et al. [96] ma-
indicates the shear angle, R2 is the ratio of the heat flowing into the chip chined A5052 using cemented carbide cutting tool in presence of
to the total amount of heat generated by the friction between chip and Minimum quantity lubrication on Okuma LB105C lathe. The shape of
tool interface, τc denotes shear stress between tool chip interface, a2 is the textures was measured using Atomic force microscope (AFM) and
thermal diffusivity of work material, lf represents contact length at chip Scanning electron microscope (SEM). Sugihara et al. [110] machined
tool interface, ξ indicates the coefficient of deformation of chip, λ2 is A5052 by using micro/nano textured cutting insert in presence of both
the thermal conductivity of work material. It can be clear from Eq. (6) dry and wet machining condition using a vertical machining centre,
that cutting temperature varied conformably with the cutting speed and Yamazaki Mazak Corp. for face milling experiments. The authors cre-
the chip tool contact length was dependent on the cutting temperature. ated micro and nano level textures on the rake surface of cemented
Also the use of solid lubricants reduced the shear strength between chip carbide insert and cutting forces generated during the machining was
and tool interfaces. Thus the textured tool helped in reducing the cut- measured using the Kistler 9257B dynamometer. Wenlong et al. [45]
ting temperature between chip and tool interface. created micro-holes on the rake surface of cemented carbide insert in
Feng et al. [125] created transverse and longitudinal textures on the order to machine 45# hardened steel. The authors used optical mi-
rake surface of ceramic tool to machine 45 # steel and observed an croscope and SEM for measuring the flank and crater wear of the cut-
increment in cutting temperature on increasing the cutting speed. ting tool obtained after machining. The cutting forces were measured
However micro-textured tool showed reduction in temperature in using KISTLER 9257A dynamometer. Ze et al. [99] performed dry
comparison to conventional tool and a maximum reduction of turning of Ti–6Al–4V using a micro textured cutting tool. The micro
10.1–12.3% in the cutting temperature was observed in longitudinal textures on the cutting tool were created on both the flank and rake
textured tool. They inferred that micro-textures reduced the con- surface of cutting tool. SEM and Energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy
centration of temperature distribution near the cutting edge which (EDX) were used to examine the micro structure and chemical
63
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Table 1
Commercially available machining centres used in experimentation with tex-
tured tool.
Authors Machine tool
Fig. 26. Niketh et al. [107] used vertical machining centre, DTC-300 for
Fig. 25. Experimental setup for hard turning process and SEM image of parallel carrying out experiments in drilling via micro textured drilling tool. The
textured tool [9]. micro textures were created on the margin and flute side of the drilling
tool while the cutting forces generated during the operation were
measured using a six components dynamometer with charge amplifier.
List of the commercial lathe, vertical machining centres used in car-
rying out the machining experiments via textured tool are mentioned in
Table 1. The next section gives details regarding the various machining
subsystems such as work materials, tool materials, coatings, lubricants
and the process parameters affecting the machining perforances using
textured cutting tools.
Fig. 26. Micro textured turning setup using sapphire as the cutting tool [68].
5.1.1. Workpiece materials
A variety of workpiece materials have been machined using the
textured cutting tools. The various materials which have been ma-
composition of the worn tool. The cutting temperature and cutting chined are Aluminium alloy A5052, A6061 [47,96,110,133], AISI 1045
forces were measured using a TH5104R thermal imaging camera and [86,97,113]. AISI 1050 [129], 45# hardened steel [98,100,123], AISI
piezoelectric type dynamometer. Kim et al. [9] performed turning op- 52100 [9,48,134]. AISI 4140 [135,115], AISI 316 [130], AISI 4340
eration via a parallel textured tool. The parallel texture was generated [136,137], Titanium alloy (Ti–6Al–4V) [131,138,132], Inconel 718
on the rake surface of the turning insert. The cutting forces were re- [139]. The next section gives the information regarding the various tool
corded using a three component dynamometer. The experimental setup materials on which the surface textures have been created in order to
of the turning operation along with the SEM image of parallel textured improve the machining performances.
tool is shown in Fig. 25. Lian et al. [100] performed machining of
hardened steel using a nano-textured cemented carbide cutting tool and
5.1.2. Tool materials
the nano-textures were filled with solid lubricant WS2 using an ion
A variety of tool materials are available in market ranging from the
planting instrument. SEM and EDX were used to study the morphology
high carbon steel to carbide, ceramic and diamonds, as stated in lit-
and chemical composition of worn tool. The cutting force and the
erature [45,95–98,109,123,135]. Out of these tungsten carbide is one
cutting temperature were measured using piezoelectric type dynam-
of the commonly used cutting tool materials because of their excellent
ometer and TH5104R thermal imaging camera. Xing et al. [113] fab-
wear resistant and hot hardness properties. Many researchers have also
ricated micro-scale texture and nano-scale textures on the rake surface
used ceramic as the cutting tool materials because it maintains its high
of ceramic tool material in order to machine hardened steel AISI 1045.
hardness at elevated temperatures. Various types of ceramic materials
The textured tools were then coated with MoS2 solid lubricants. The
which has been used are Si3N4/TiC ceramic [133], Al2O3/TiC ceramic
cutting force and the tool wear were measured using piezoelectric type
[113,137,140,141], Al2O3/TiCN ceramic [134]. Kim et al. [9,48] and
dynamometer and SEM. Wei et al. [68] performed wet turning opera-
Sugihara et al. [106] used cubic boron nitride as tool material because
tion with sapphire as the cutting tool in order to machine Al-6061 using
of its high impact resistance. Su et al. [138] used Polycrystalline dia-
synthetic misting cutting fluid. The cutting forces were measured using
mond because of its high thermal conductivity and abrasion resistance.
a piezoelectric dynamometer along with the dual mode charge ampli-
Since the above-mentioned cutting tool materials are expensive so some
fiers for converting the obtained electrical signals into voltage signals
of the researchers have also used tool steel as the cutting tool materials
respectively. The experimental setup of the above mentioned wet
such as T-15 HSS [47], M-42 HSS [114]. But the main problem with
turning operation performed via micro-textured tool is shown in
these cutting tool materials is rapid tool wear therefore in order to
64
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
enhance the tool life of the cutting tools various types of coatings have Quantity Lubrication (MQL) and solid lubricants. MQL refers to appli-
been devised such as TiN, TiCN, etc. The coming section gives details cation of very small amount of cutting fluid normally in the range of
regarding the various types of tool coatings which have been used by 50–500 ml/h in form of mist to the machining point as stated in lit-
various authors in order to improve the properties of the cutting tool. erature [144]. Various authors have used different MQL setups and
solid lubricants in order to improve the machining performances. Ka-
5.1.3. Tool coatings wasegi et al. [96] used MQL by supplying daphne cut eco oil in mist
Coating on the cutting tool materials has brought a revolutionary form at a flow rate of 40 cc/h and observed an improvement in fric-
change in the metal cutting industry. Almost 85% of carbide, 50% of tional properties by application of textured tool in MQL conditions.
high-speed steel and almost 40% of the super hard tool used in today's Jianxin et al. [12] created micro-holes on the flank and rake surface of
industries are coated tool as stated in literature [142]. Coatings basi- the cutting tool and filled these micro-holes with molybdenum dis-
cally improve the tool life by reducing the thermal energy flowing into ulphide (MoS2) solid lubricants. The authors observed an improvement
the tool material. Coating materials are basically categorized into four in friction coefficient and cutting forces due to the formation of a self-
groups. The very first group consists of titanium based coating materials lubricating film between the sliding surfaces.
such as TiCN, TiN, and TiAlN. The second group includes ceramic type Wenlong et al. [45] created four micro-holes on the rake face of
coating such as Al2O3. While the third group represents the super hard cutting tool and finally these micro-holes were filled with three dif-
coatings materials such as oxides of Al and Zr. The fourth group re- ferent solid lubricants such as graphite, MoS2 and CaF2 The authors
presents the coating of solid lubricants such as amorphous metal carbon observed a reduction in the tool wear properties and cutting forces in
as detailed in literature [143]. Carbides generally behave as an ex- comparison to non-textured and unlubricated tools. Ze et al. [99] used
cellent substrate for all coatings such as TiCN, TiN, TiAlN, multi-layer MoS2 solid lubricant to fill the textured grooves in order to create a self-
coating and solid lubricant coating. Various authors have used different lubricating tool and observed an improvement in cutting temperature
kinds of coatings in the cutting tool. Obikawa et al. [133] used TiN and forces. Sivaiah et al. [145] performed turning on 17-4 Precipitation
coating on cemented carbide insert using Helicon DC magnetron sput- hardening stainless steel using TiAlN coated WC/Co carbide inserts.
tering technique. Lian et al. [100] used medium frequency magnetron Cutting experiments were performed in both wet and cryogenic con-
sputtering technique to generate soft coating of WS2 on the nano-tex- ditions to compare the performance characteristics in turning such as
tured surface of cemented carbide cutting inserts. They observed that cutting forces, chip morphology, flank wear and cutting temperatures.
nano-textured tool having the soft coating of WS2 showed minimum The authors noticed that cryogenic machining considerably improved
coefficient of friction, cutting forces and cutting temperature in com- the machining performance and quality of products compared to wet
parison to non-textured tools. Da silva et al. [129] used commercial machining.
cemented carbide tool with a three-layer coating of (TiCN–Al2O3–TiN), Sharma et al. [136] used CaF2 solid lubricant in order to make the
generated using Chemical Vapour Deposition (CVD) technique in order cutting tool as self-lubricating tool and observed the effects of these
to observe the effects of laser surface texturing on the wear resistance of self-lubricating tools on chip thickness ratio, cutting forces and surface
coated cemented carbide inserts. Zhang et al. [86] created a coating of roughness of workpiece obtained after machining. Song et al. [146]
TiAlN having a thickness of 2 μm after the laser irradiation using a used self-lubricating tool in which graphite was used as solid lubricant
commercial balzers sputtron system in order to study the effects of the and observed the effects of these micro-textured self-lubricated tool on
coated textured tools on machining performances. Arulkirubakaran tool wear and cutting temperature.
et al. [120] used Physical Vapour Deposition (PVD) technique to coat Dinesh et al. [147] performed orthogonal machining of ZK60
the textured cemented carbide tool with TiN and TiAlN materials up to magnesium alloy using the uncoated textured cutting tool both in dry
a thickness of 4 μm. It has been observed that perpendicular textured and liquid nitrogen (LN2) cooling conditions. The authors studied the
TiAlN coated cutting tool exhibited best results in comparison to non- effects of texturing and LN2 cooling on the surface roughness, cutting
textured and textured tools. Fang et al. [139] used cemented carbide forces, tool wear and cutting temperatures. It was noticed that in the
tool with a single layer coating of aluminium enriched TiAlN using PVD case of cryogenic machining, textured tool witnessed a significant im-
technique and observed an improvement in cutting performance of provement in machinability such as improved surface finish and re-
textured coated tool in comparison to the un-textured tool. Mishra et al. duced cutting forces. Sharma et al. [148] created hybrid textures on the
[132] created a chevron shaped texture using Nd:YAG nanosecond laser rake surface of carbide inserts using CaF2 as the solid lubricant to study
on cemented carbide insert. After that these textured tools as well as the effects of different orientation textured cutting inserts during ma-
conventional tools were coated with AlCrN and AlTiN single layer chining of 4340 hardened steel. They observed that the hybrid textured
coating using cathodic arc evaporation technique and observed a re- tool showed a less chip saw tooth phenomenon resulting in more stable
duction in flank wear and cutting forces. Minimum flank wear was cutting in comparison to un-textured cutting tools. After discussing the
noticed in AlCrN coated tools. As we have learned in the current section various machining subsystems such as tool material, work material, tool
that tool coatings helps in improving the properties of tool material but coatings, cutting fluids. The next very important machining subsystem
at the same time we should not compromise with surface properties of is the process parameters as these parameters directly affects the quality
the work material. For that cutting fluids play very important role in of the products, tool life, etc. So the next section gives the review of the
improving the surface properties of the work material as well as cutting various process parameters which have been used in machining of
tool. Therefore the next section gives details regarding the various types variety of materials.
of cutting fluids and the lubrication techniques used in machining using
textured cutting tools.
5.1.5. Cutting parameters
5.1.4. Cutting fluids and lubrication techniques Process parameters are one of the vital factors which affect the
In today's world the use of cutting fluid has become one of the major quality of products, cutting tool life and finally the production rate.
problems in terms of both the environment and health of the em- These process parameters are selected on the basis of workpiece and
ployees. But we cannot ignore the advantages of cutting fluids, because tool materials. From the literature survey it has been observed that the
the use of cutting fluids causes the economy of tools and it also helps in main cutting parameters in machining are feed, cutting speed and depth
maintaining the surface properties of workpiece without any damage. of cut. Various authors have used different workpieces and textured
Because of these benefits of cutting fluids, some alternatives have to be cutting tool materials at different process parameters under different
found out by minimizing the utilization of cutting fluid in various machining conditions are summed up in Table 2.
machining operations. Some of the alternatives are the use of Minimum
65
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Table 2
Summary of various tool material, work material and cutting parameters used in machining via micro-textured tool.
Author Tool materials Work material Cutting parameters (cutting speed, V (m/min), Lubricants Machining
depth of cut, d (mm), feed, f (mm/rev)) process
Kawasegi et al. [96] WC/Co cemented carbide Aluminium alloy V = 60–600 MQL (Daphne cut Eco) Turning
A5052 d = 0.2
f = 0.1
Lei et al. [95] Tunsten carbide (WC) 1045 steel V = 120 Water based cutting fluid, Turning
d=1 cutting oil, solid powder WS2
f = 0.3
Sugihara et al. Cemented carbide Aluminium alloy V = 380 Dry and wet emulsion type Face milling
[106] A5052 d=3 (JIS A1)
f = 0.12
Enomoto et al. [32] Cemented carbide Aluminium alloy V = 380 Emulsion type, finecut CFS- Face milling
A5052 d=3 100
f = 0.12
Wenlong et al. [45] Cemented carbide 45# hardened steel V = 60–140 MoS2, CaF2 and graphite solid Turning
d = 0.2 lubricant
f = 0.1
Koshy et al. [47] T-15 grade HSS 1045 steel and V = 2–75 Light duty cutting oil Turning
A6061 d=3 (ChemEcol 250A)
f = 0.025–0.1
Enomoto et al. [35] Cemented carbide K10 Carbon steel S53C V = 200 Emulsion type, finecut CFS- Face milling
d=2 100
f = 0.20
Ze et al. [99] WC/Co cemented carbide Ti–6Al–4V V = 60–180 MoS2 solid lubricant Turning
d = 0.2
f = 0.05–0.3
Fatima et al. [135] Cemented carbide 4140 high tensile V = 283 Trefolex cutting oil Turning
alloy steel d = 2.5
f = 0.1
Da silva et al. [129] WC/Co cemented carbide AISI 1050 carbon V = 350 Vegetable based emulsion Turning
steel d=2
f = 2.5
Ling et al. [39] High strength steel Ti–6Al–4V V = 245 rpm Boelube 70104 lubricant Drilling
f = 24.9 m/min
Xing et al. [140] WS2/Zr coated Al2O3/TiC AISI 1045 hardened V = 30–150 Dry machining Turning
ceramic steel d = 0.5
f = 0.1
Wu et al. [109] WC/Co cemented carbide Ti–6Al–4V V = 60–180 MoS2 solid lubricant Turning
d = 0.5 mm
f = 0.3
Xing et al. [113] Al2o3/TiC ceramic AISI 1045 hardened V = 80–260 MoS2 solid lubricant Turning
steel d = 0.2
f = 0.2
Ma et al. [97] WC/Co cemented carbide AISI 1045 V = 120 Dry machining Turning
d=1
f = 0.3
Fatima et al. [115] Cemented carbide AISI 4140 V = 100, 198, 394 Ambient air Turning
d = 2.5
f = 0.1
Kim et al. [9] Cubic boron nitride (cBN) AISI 52100 V = 182 Dry machining Turning
d = 0.203
f = 0.152
Sun et al. [116] WC/Co cemented carbide AISI 1045 V = 60–120 MoS2 solid lubricant Turning
d = 0.2
f = 0.1
Xing et al. [149] Cemented carbide A6061 V = 54.9–439.2 Dry machining Turning
d=2
f = 0.05
Ma et al. [150] WC/Co cemented carbide Ti–6Al–4V V = 100 Dry machining Turning
d=2
f = 0.1
Li et al. [131] Uncoated cemented Ti–6Al–4V V = 50 Dry machining Turning
carbide d=2
f = 0.3
Su et al. [138] Polycrystalline diamond Ti–6Al–4V V = 16.485–125.6 Dry machining Turning
(PCD) d=2
f = 0.19
Vasumathy et al. Uncoated cemented AISI 316 V = 150 Dry machining Turning
[130] carbide d=1
f = 0.16
Sugihara et al. WC/Co cemented carbide Medium carbon steel V = 200 Emulsion type cutting fluid Face milling
[106] d=2
f = 0.20
(continued on next page)
66
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Table 2 (continued)
Author Tool materials Work material Cutting parameters (cutting speed, V (m/min), Lubricants Machining
depth of cut, d (mm), feed, f (mm/rev)) process
Kumar et al. [134] Al2o3/TiCN ceramic tool AISI 52100 At constant f = 0.12, V = 110–180 Dry machining Turning
d = 0.5
At constant V = 110, f = 0.12–0.2, d = 0.5
Mishra et al. [132] Plain cemented carbide Ti–6Al–4V V = 80 Dry machining Turning
insert d=1
f = 0.1
Niketh et al. [107] Carbide drills Ti–6Al–4V V = 30–60 Dry machining Drilling
f = 0.04–0.07
5.1.6. Texture dimensions, geometry and orientation finally results in enhancement of heat transfer from the cutting tool to
The improvement in the performance of machining through a tex- the coolant.
tured tool basically depends on the dimensions of the texture created Ma et al. [154] investigated the effects of micro-grooved textured
such as texture depth, width, pitch, diameter, etc. It also depends on the tools in the dry cutting of Ti–6Al–4V using Advantedge FEM simulation
geometry of the texture such as micro-holes, micro-grooves, micro- software. Fig. 27 shows a FEM turning model using conventional cut-
square pits, wavy grooves, etc. Texture orientation is another important ting tool. They investigated the effects of the micro-groove parameters
factor which affects the cutting performance of textured tool. The or- (micro-groove width to depth ratio, edge distance, and micro-groove
ientation of textures can be in direction parallel/perpendicular to the width) on the chip morphology and cutting forces. The authors ob-
principal cutting edge or in the actual direction of chip flow. Various served that on increasing the width of micro-grooves in the range of
authors have created textures of different dimensions, geometry and 40–120 μm the cutting forces first decreased and then increased and
orientation either on the flank surface or the rake surface of the cutting 50 μm was the optimum width in which the cutting force component
tool which has been summarized in Table 3. was minimum. Finally the author stated that the optimal condition can
For the better understanding of cutting mechanism of the textured only be found out by taking in consideration of all the three texture
tool, it is essential to construct a model for understanding the effect of parameters simultaneously. Ma et al. [97] used Advantedge FEM soft-
various process parameters on the machining characteristics. The next ware to model and simulate the effects of micro-grooved tools in the dry
section gives the detailed information regarding the various modelling turning of AISI 1045. Firstly they validated their FEM model by com-
and simulation techniques useful in understanding the mechanism of paring the results of model predictions with the experimental results.
cutting through textured tool. They observed that simulation results were well capturing the effects of
micro-grooves compared to experimental results as shown in Fig. 28.
Further, they investigated the effects of the micro-groove parameters on
6. Modelling and simulation
tool wear and friction coefficient on both flank face and rake face of the
cutting tool.
In order to understand the cutting mechanism of micro-textured
Gajrani et al. [66] performed structural analysis of both conven-
tools, it is essential to construct a mathematical or numerical model in
tional and micro-textured tool using ANSYS workbench as shown in
order to study the effects of various parameters on output responses.
Fig. 29 and observed that the vonmises stress and strain of both con-
These modelling techniques provide the insight information of the
ventional and textured cutting tools were almost same indicating that
microscopic phenomenon occurring in real life situations of metal
surface texturing has no any effect in decreasing the strength of the
cutting using micro-textured tools. Various authors have used different
cutting tool.
modelling techniques such as Theoretical modelling, Finite element
Orra et al. [137] developed micro level textures on the rake surface
modelling (FEM) and Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to model the
of ceramic tool to improve the cutting performance during the ma-
effect of texturing on the machining performances. In the recent years,
chining of AISI 4340. The authors also developed a theoretical model to
FEM has become very popular in almost all fields including simulation
estimate friction coefficient on the rake surface of the cutting tool. They
of metal cutting because of high precision, freedom in choices of
further observed that the experimental results showing the variation of
making complex shapes and ease of modelling as stated in literature
cutting velocity on the chip reduction coefficient were in good agree-
[151]. Various authors have used FEM techniques to get an insight of
ment with the results obtained theoretically with an approximate error
the actual cutting mechanism. Chen et al. [152] performed metal cut-
of around 5%. Kim et al. [9] developed a 3D turning model using the
ting simulation using Advantedge FEM software. They created five
commercial Deform 3D software. They created three different orienta-
different sizes of micro-grooves to study the relationship between
tion textures such as parallel, perpendicular and rectangular on the rake
parameters of textures and anti-friction behaviour. They observed that
surface of the tool in the chip flow direction and studied the effects of
the smaller texture sized cutting tool effectively reduced the cutting
these different orientation textures on-chip flow angle, cutting forces
forces, cutting temperatures. Ma et al. [153] investigated the perfor-
and effective friction coefficient. They reported a maximum reduction
mance of micro-textured tool in a dry orthogonal turning of AISI 1045.
of 25% in the effective friction coefficient and 6% in the cutting force
The authors used FEM Advantedge software to investigate the effects of
using a perpendicular orientation textured tool in comparison to the
micro-grooves tools on cutting forces and observed a significant re-
conventional/non-textured tool.
duction in cutting and thrust forces under particular combinations of
Arulkirubakaran et al. [120] used Deform 3D commercial software
micro-groove parameters such as groove edge distance, depth, and
to simulate machining of Ti–6Al–4V alloy using uncoated, TiN and
width.
TiAlN coated cutting tools which were created in the perpendicular and
Fang et al. [139] performed turning of Inconel 718 using flank face
parallel direction of the chip flow. The authors observed the effects of
micro textured cutting tool in the presence of high pressure jet coolant.
these textures on chip morphology, cutting forces and temperature
The authors observed a reduction in tool wear and temperature gen-
distribution. It was noticed that the perpendicular textured tool showed
erated during the operation. They further performed CFD analysis of the
better machinability in comparison to parallel and non-textured tool.
coolant flow on the flank surface of the textured cutting tool. The au-
Fig. 30 indicates the variation of main cutting forces using parallel,
thors observed a difference in the flow speed of the coolant outside and
perpendicular, cross textured and non-textured coated tool and it has
inside of the micro-textures resulting in formation of local eddies which
67
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Table 3
Various texture generation techniques along with groove dimensions and geometry.
Author Groove pattern direction Groove dimensions Texture generation technique
68
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Table 3 (continued)
Duan et al. [126] •Linear texture parallel to main cutting edge Width = 50 μm Nd:YAG solid state laser
Depth = 35 μm
Edge distance = 150–350 μm
Wei et al. [68] •Areal texture with numerous surface asperities Edge distance = 100 μm Micro abrasive blasting
Gajrani et al. [66] •Micro-textures Width = 200 μm Vickers hardness tester
Orra et al. [137] •Vertical micro texture in chip flow direction Width = 200, 215 μm Epilog laser
•Horizontal texture in chip flow direction Pitch = 150–222 μm
•Elliptical texture in direction of chip flow
7. Future work
69
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
Fig. 29. Comparative study of Vonmises stress field in (a) conventional tool and (b) micro-textured tool [66].
Fig. 30. Effects of different orientation of textures on the cutting forces in simulated conditions for different types of coating materials. (a) 60 m/min and (b) 90 m/
min [120].
contacting surfaces in the cutting tools by creating micro/nano textures e) Texturing helps in reduction of cutting temperature because tex-
on the rake/flank face. The article highlights the different techniques turing causes an increase in the heat radiating area resulting in
along with its advantages and disadvantages involved in creating tex- better heat dissipation.
tures and its effect in improving the cutting performances such as f) There is no any effect on the strength of cutting edge by creating
cutting temperature, cutting forces, surface finish, and tool wear. It micro-textures on the rake surface of the cutting tool.
indicated the effect of self-lubricating tools in improving the machining g) The textured tool filled with the solid lubricant helps in improving
performances. It also highlighted the areas in which future work can be the lubricity between the chip–tool interface and thus improving the
concentrated. The benefits of using textured tool in enhancing the cutting performances.
machinability of difficult to cut materials are as follows: h) The texturing parameters such as edge distance, depth, width, shape
and orientation of texture has significant effect in improving the
a) Textured tool helps in reduction of cutting forces due to reduction in cutting performance of the cutting tool.
the contact area between the chip and tool interface.
b) It also resulted in reduction of variability in the cutting forces.
c) Textured tools help in enhancing the wear resistance of cutting tools Conflict of Interest
by reducing the adhesion between the chip–tool interfaces.
d) Nano textured tool performs better in comparison to micro-textured The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
because of lesser adherability of the work material with the textured
tool.
70
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
References surfaces – influence on tool life. CIRP Ann - Manuf Technol 2002;51:231–4.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0007-8506(07)61506-6.
[30] Arslan A, Masjuki HH, Varman M, Kalam MA, Quazi MM, Mosarof MH. Effect of
[1] Vamsi Krishna P, Srikant RR, Nageswara Rao D. Experimental investigation on the change in temperature on the tribological performance of micro surface textured
performance of nanoboric acid suspensions in SAE-40 and coconut oil during DLC coating. J Mater Res 2016;31:1837–47. https://doi.org/10.1557/jmr.
turning of AISI 1040 steel. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2010;50:911–6. https://doi. 2016.12.
org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2010.06.001. [31] Etsion I, Halperin G, Brizmer V, Kligerman Y. Experimental investigation of laser
[2] East F, Howes T. Environmental aspects of grinding fluids. CIRP Ann Manuf surface textured parallel thrust bearings. Tribol Lett 2004;17:295–300.
Technol 1991;40:623–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0007-8506(07)61138-X. [32] Enomoto T, Sugihara T. Improving anti-adhesive properties of cutting tool surfaces
[3] Marksberry PW. Micro-flood (MF) technology for sustainable manufacturing op- by nano-/micro-textures. CIRP Ann - Manuf Technol 2010;59:597–600. https://
erations that are coolant less and occupationally friendly. J Clean Prod doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2010.03.130.
2007;15:958–71. [33] Chang W, Sun J, Luo X, Ritchie JM, Mack C. Investigation of microstructured
[4] Klocke F, Eisenblätter G. Dry cutting-state of research. VDI Berichte milling tool for deferring tool wear. Wear 2011;271:2433–7. https://doi.org/10.
1998;1399:159–88. 1016/j.wear.2010.12.026.
[5] Dixit US, Sarma DK, Davim JP. Environmentally friendly machining. Springer [34] Enomoto T, Sugihara T. Improvement of anti-adhesive properties of cutting tool by
Science & Business Media; 2012. nano/micro textures and its mechanism. Procedia Eng 2011;19:100–5. https://doi.
[6] Sreejith PS, Ngoi BKA. Dry machining: machining of the future. J Mater Process org/10.1016/j.proeng.2011.11.086.
Technol 2000;101:287–91. [35] Enomoto T, Sugihara T, Yukinaga S, Hirose K, Satake U. Highly wear-resistant
[7] Lin W, Yu DY, Zhang C, Liu X, Zhang S, Tian Y, et al. A multi-objective teaching- cutting tools with textured surfaces in steel cutting. CIRP Ann Technol
learning-based optimization algorithm to scheduling in turning processes for 2012;61:571–4.
minimizing makespan and carbon footprint. J Clean Prod 2015;101:1–11. https:// [36] Xing YQ, Deng JX, Tan YQ, Zhou HM. Effect of surface textures on friction prop-
doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.03.099. erties of Al2O3/TiC ceramics. Surf Eng 2012;28:605–11. https://doi.org/10.1179/
[8] Khalili NR, Duecker S, Ashton W, Chavez F. From cleaner production to sustainable 1743294412Y.0000000031.
development: the role of academia. J Clean Prod 2015;96:30–43. https://doi.org/ [37] Blatter A, Maillat M, Pimenov SM, Shafeev GA, Simakin AV, Loubnin EN.
10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.01.099. Lubricated sliding performance of laser-patterned sapphire. Wear
[9] Kim DM, Bajpai V, Kim BH, Park HW. Finite element modeling of hard turning 1999;232:226–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0043-1648(99)00150-7.
process via a micro-textured tool. Int J Adv Manuf Technol [38] Costa HL, Hutchings IM. Effects of die surface patterning on lubrication in strip
2015;78(9–12):1393–405. drawing. J Mater Process Technol 2009;209:1175–80. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
[10] Weinert K, Inasaki I, Sutherland JW, Wakabayashi T. Dry machining and minimum jmatprotec.2008.03.026.
quantity lubrication. CIRP Ann - Manuf Technol 2004;53:511–37. https://doi.org/ [39] Ling TD, Liu P, Xiong S, Grzina D, Cao J, Wang QJ, et al. Surface texturing of drill
10.1016/S0007-8506(07)60027-4. bits for adhesion reduction and tool life enhancement. Tribol Lett 2013;52:113–22.
[11] Shokrani A, Dhokia V, Newman ST. Environmentally conscious machining of https://doi.org/10.1007/s11249-013-0198-7.
difficult-to-machine materials with regard to cutting fluids. Int J Mach Tools [40] Raju L, Hiremath SS. A state-of-the-art review on micro electro-discharge ma-
Manuf 2012;57:83–101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2012.02.002. chining. Procedia Technol 2016;25:1281–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.protcy.
[12] Jianxin D, Wenlong S, Hui Z. Design, fabrication and properties of a self-lubricated 2016.08.222.
tool in dry cutting. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2009;49:66–72. https://doi.org/10. [41] Koch O, Ehrfeld W, Michel F, Gruber HP. Recent progress in micro electro dis-
1016/j.ijmachtools.2008.08.001. charge machining-part i: technology. Proc ISEM 2001;13:737–45.
[13] Sharma VS, Dogra M, Suri NM. Cooling techniques for improved productivity in [42] Dhanik S, Joshi SS. Modeling of a single resistance capacitance pulse discharge in
turning. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2009;49:435–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. micro-electro discharge machining. J Manuf Sci Eng 2005;127:759. https://doi.
ijmachtools.2008.12.010. org/10.1115/1.2034512.
[14] Sharma J, Sidhu BS. Investigation of effects of dry and near dry machining on AISI [43] Michel F, Ehrfeld W, Koch O, Gruber HP. EDM for micro fabrication-technology
D2 steel using vegetable oil. J Clean Prod 2014;66:619–23. https://doi.org/10. and applications. Proceedings of International Seminar on Precision Engineering
1016/j.jclepro.2013.11.042. and Micro Technology. 2000.
[15] Hutchings IM. Tribology: friction and wear of engineering materials. Boca Raton: [44] Uhlmann E, Piltz S, Doll U. Machining of micro/miniature dies and moulds by
CRC Press; 1992. p. 137. electrical discharge machining – recent development. J Mater Process Technol
[16] Wang X, Kato K, Adachi K, Aizawa K. The effect of laser texturing of SiC surface on 2005;167:488–93. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2005.06.013.
the critical load for the transition of water lubrication mode from hydrodynamic to [45] Wenlong S, Jianxin D, Ze W, Hui Z, Pei Y, Jun Z, et al. Cutting performance of
mixed. Tribol Int 2001;34:703–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0301-679X(01) cemented-carbides-based self-lubricated tool embedded with different solid lu-
00063-9. bricants. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2011;52:477–85. https://doi.org/10.1007/
[17] Kovalchenko A, Ajayi O, Erdemir A, Fenske G, Etsion I. The effect of laser surface s00170-010-2740-1.
texturing on transitions in lubrication regimes during unidirectional sliding con- [46] Talla G, Gangopadhyay S, Kona NB. Experimental investigation and optimization
tact. Tribol Int 2005;38:219–25. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.triboint.2004.08.004. during the fabrication of arrayed structures using reverse EDM. Mater Manuf
[18] Wakuda M, Yamauchi Y, Kanzaki S, Yasuda Y. Effect of surface texturing on Process 2017;32:958–69. https://doi.org/10.1080/10426914.2016.1221085.
friction reduction between ceramic and steel materials under lubricated sliding [47] Koshy P, Tovey J. Performance of electrical discharge textured cutting tools. CIRP
contact. Wear 2003;254:356–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0043-1648(03) Ann - Manuf Technol 2011;60:153–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2011.03.
00004-8. 104.
[19] Qiu M, Delic A, Raeymaekers B. The effect of texture shape on the load-carrying [48] Kim DM, Lee I, Kim SK, Kim BH, Park HW. Influence of a micropatterned insert on
capacity. Tribol Lett 2012;48:315–27. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11249-012- characteristics of the tool-workpiece interface in a hard turning process. J Mater
0027-4. Process Technol 2016;229:160–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2015.
[20] Etsion I. State of the art in laser surface texturing. J Tribol 2005;127:248. https:// 09.018.
doi.org/10.1115/1.1828070. [49] Arulkirubakaran D, Senthilkumar V, Kumawat V. Effect of micro-textured tools on
[21] Etsion I, Halperin G. A laser surface textured hydrostatic mechanical seal. Tribol machining of Ti–6Al–4V alloy: an experimental and numerical approach. Int J
Trans 2002;45:430–4. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402000208982570. Refract Met Hard Mater 2016;54:165–77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2015.
[22] Chyr A, Qiu M, Speltz JW, Jacobsen RL, Sanders AP, Raeymaekers B. A patterned 07.027.
microtexture to reduce friction and increase longevity of prosthetic hip joints. [50] Jain VK. Introduction to micromachining. New Delhi: Narosa Publishing House;
Wear 2014;315:51–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2014.04.001. 2010.
[23] Xu D, Ng MK, Fan R, Zhou R, Wang HP, Chen J, et al. Enhancement of adhesion [51] Schuster R, Kirchner V, Allongue P, Ertl G. Electrochemical micromachining.
strength by micro-rolling-based surface texturing. Int J Adv Manuf Technol Science 2000;289(5476):98–101.
2015;78:1427–35. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-014-6736-0. [52] Kirchner V, Cagnon L, Schuster R, Ertl G. Electrochemical machining of stainless
[24] Pettersson U, Jacobson S. Influence of surface texture on boundary lubricated steel microelements with ultrashort voltage pulses. Appl Phys Lett
sliding contacts. Tribol Int 2003;36:857–64. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0301-679X 2001;79:1721–3. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1401783.
(03)00104-X. [53] Park MS, Chu CN. Micro-electrochemical machining using multiple tool electrodes.
[25] Raeymaekers B, Etsion I, Talke FE. Enhancing tribological performance of the J Micromech Microeng 2007;17:1451–7. https://doi.org/10.1088/0960-1317/17/
magnetic tape/guide interface by laser surface texturing. Tribol Lett 8/006.
2007;27:89–95. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11249-007-9211-3. [54] Byun JW, Shin HS, Kwon MH, Kim BH, Chu CN. Surface texturing by micro ECM
[26] Arslan A, Masjuki HH, Varman M, Kalam MA, Quazi MM, Al Mahmud KAH, et al. for friction reduction. Int J Precis Eng Manuf 2010;11:747–53. https://doi.org/10.
Effects of texture diameter and depth on the tribological performance of DLC 1007/s12541-010-0088-y.
coating under lubricated sliding condition. Appl Surf Sci 2015;356:1135–9. [55] Qian S, Ji F, Qu N, Li H. Improving the localization of surface texture by elec-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2015.08.194. trochemical machining with auxiliary anode. Mater Manuf Process
[27] Lu X, Khonsari MM. An experimental investigation of dimple effect on the stribeck 2014;29:1488–93. https://doi.org/10.1080/10426914.2014.930950.
curve of journal bearings. Tribol Lett 2007;27:169–76. https://doi.org/10.1007/ [56] Patel DS, Singh A, Jain VK, Ramkumar J, Shrivastava A. Investigations into in-
s11249-007-9217-x. sertion force of electrochemically micro-textured hypodermic needles. Int J Adv
[28] Etsion I. Improving tribological performance of mechanical components by laser Manuf Technol 2017:1–6.
surface texturing. Tribol Lett 2004;17:733–7. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11249- [57] Mahabunphachai S, Koç M. Investigation of size effects on material behavior of
004-8081-1. thin sheet metals using hydraulic bulge testing at micro/meso-scales. Int J Mach
[29] Geiger M, Popp U, Engel U. Excimer laser micro texturing of cold forging tool Tools Manuf 2008;48:1014–29. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2008.01.
71
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
72
P. Ranjan and S.S. Hiremath Journal of Manufacturing Processes 43 (2019) 47–73
[114] Sasi R, Kanmani Subbu S, Palani IA. Performance of laser surface textured high [135] Fatima A, Mativenga PT. Assessment of tool rake surface structure geometry for
speed steel cutting tool in machining of Al7075-T6 aerospace alloy. Surf Coatings enhanced contact phenomena. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2013;69:771–6. https://
Technol 2017;313:337–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2017.01.118. doi.org/10.1007/s00170-013-5079-6.
[115] Fatima A, Mativenga PT. A comparative study on cutting performance of rake- [136] Sharma V, Pandey PM. Geometrical design optimization of hybrid textured self-
flank face structured cutting tool in orthogonal cutting of AISI/SAE 4140, 231. lubricating cutting inserts for turning 4340 hardened steel. Int J Adv Manuf
2015. p. 2097–106. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-6799-6. Technol 2017;89:1575–89. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-9163-6.
[116] Sun J, Zhou Y, Deng J, Zhao J. Effect of hybrid texture combining micro-pits and [137] Orra K, Choudhury SK. Tribological aspects of various geometrically shaped
micro-grooves on cutting performance of WC/Co-based tools. Int J Adv Manuf micro-textures on cutting insert to improve tool life in hard turning process. J
Technol 2016;86:3383–94. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-8452-4. Manuf Process 2018;31:502–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2017.12.005.
[117] Kümmel J, Braun D, Gibmeier J, Schneider J, Greiner C, Schulze V, et al. Study on [138] Su Y, Li Z, Li L, Wang J, Gao H, Wang G. Cutting performance of micro-textured
micro texturing of uncoated cemented carbide cutting tools for wear improvement polycrystalline diamond tool in dry cutting. J Manuf Process 2017;27:1–7. https://
and built-up edge stabilisation. J Mater Process Technol 2015;215:62–70. https:// doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2017.03.013.
doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2014.07.032. [139] Fang Z, Obikawa T. Cooling performance of micro-texture at the tool flank face
[118] Sugihara T, Enomoto T. Crater and flank wear resistance of cutting tools having under high pressure jet coolant assistance. Precis Eng 2017;49:41–51. https://doi.
micro textured surfaces. Precis Eng 2013;37:888–96. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. org/10.1016/j.precisioneng.2017.01.008.
precisioneng.2013.05.007. [140] Xing Y, Deng J, Zhang K, Zhang G, Gao H. Effect of femtosecond laser pretreat-
[119] Liu Y, Deng J, Wu F, Duan R, Zhang X, Hou Y. Wear resistance of carbide tools ment on wear resistance of Al2O3/TiC ceramic tools in dry cutting. Int J Refract
with textured flank-face in dry cutting of green alumina ceramics. Wear Met Hard Mater 2014;43:291–301. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2013.12.
2017;372–373:91–103. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2016.12.001. 015.
[120] Arulkirubakaran D, Senthilkumar V. Performance of TiN and TiAlN coated micro- [141] Xing Y, Deng J, Lian Y, Zhang K, Zhang G, Zhao J. Multiple nanoscale parallel
grooved tools during machining of Ti–6Al–4V alloy. Int J Refract Met Hard Mater grooves formed on Si3N4/TiC ceramic by femtosecond pulsed laser. Appl Surf Sci
2017;62:47–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2016.10.014. 2014;289:62–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2013.10.094.
[121] Bruzzone AAG, Costa HL, Lonardo PM, Lucca DA. Advances in engineered surfaces [142] Astakhov VP. Tribology of metal cutting. Elsevier; 2006.
for functional performance. CIRP Ann - Manuf Technol 2008;57:750–69. https:// [143] Astakhov VP, Davim JP. Tools (geometry and material) and tool wear. Mach
doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2008.09.003. Fundam Recent Adv 2008:29–57. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-84800-213-5_2.
[122] Williams JA. Engineering tribology. New York: Oxford University Press; 1994. [144] Dhar NR, Islam MW, Islam S, Mithu MAH. The influence of minimum quantity of
[123] Deng J, Lian Y, Wu Z, Xing Y. Performance of femtosecond laser-textured cutting lubrication (MQL) on cutting temperature, chip and dimensional accuracy in
tools deposited with WS2 solid lubricant coatings. Surf Coatings Technol turning AISI-1040 steel. J Mater Process Technol 2006;171:93–9. https://doi.org/
2013;222:135–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2013.02.015. 10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2005.06.047.
[124] Riyao C. Principle of metal cutting. Beijing: China Machine Press; 1992. [145] Sivaiah P, Chakradhar D. Influence of cryogenic coolant on turning performance
[125] Feng Y, Zhang J, Wang L, Zhang W, Tian Y, Kong X. Fabrication techniques and characteristics: a comparison with wet machining. Mater Manuf Process
cutting performance of micro-textured self-lubricating ceramic cutting tools by in- 2017;32:1475–85. https://doi.org/10.1080/10426914.2016.1269920.
situ forming of Al2O3–TiC. Int J Refract Metals Hard Mater 2017;68:121–9. [146] Song W, Wang Z, Wang S, Zhou K, Guo Z. Experimental study on the cutting
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2017.07.007. temperature of textured carbide tool embedded with graphite. Int J Adv Manuf
[126] Duan R, Deng J, Ai X, Liu Y, Chen H. Experimental assessment of derivative cutting Technol 2017;93:3419–27. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-017-0683-5.
of micro-textured tools in dry cutting of medium carbon steels. Int J Adv Manuf [147] Dinesh S, Senthilkumar V, Asokan P. Experimental studies on the cryogenic ma-
Technol 2017;92:3531–40. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-017-0360-8. chining of biodegradable ZK60 Mg alloy using micro-textured tools. Mater Manuf
[127] Ma J, Duong NH, Chang S, Lian Y, Deng J, Lei S. Assessment of microgrooved Process 2017;32:979–87. https://doi.org/10.1080/10426914.2016.1221096.
cutting tool in dry machining of AISI 1045 steel. J Manuf Sci Eng [148] Sharma V, Pandey PM. Comparative study of turning of 4340 hardened steel with
2015;137:031001. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4029565. hybrid textured self-lubricating cutting inserts. Mater Manuf Process
[128] Childs T, Maekawa K, Obikawa T, Yamane Y. Metal machining: theory and ap- 2016;31:1904–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/10426914.2015.1127951.
plications. Butterworth-Heinemann; 2000. [149] Xing Y, Deng J, Wang X, Ehmann K, Cao J. Experimental assessment of laser
[129] Da Silva WM, Suarez MP, Machado AR, Costa HL. Effect of laser surface mod- textured cutting tools in dry cutting of aluminum alloys. J Manuf Sci Eng
ification on the micro-abrasive wear resistance of coated cemented carbide tools. 2016;138:071006. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4032263.
Wear 2013;302:1230–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2013.01.035. [150] Ma J, Ge X, Qiu C, Lei S. FEM assessment of performance of microhole textured
[130] Vasumathy D, Meena A. Influence of micro scale textured tools on tribological cutting tool in dry machining of Ti–6Al–4V. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
properties at tool-chip interface in turning AISI 316 austenitic stainless steel. Wear 2016;84:2609–21. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-7918-0.
2017;376-377:1747–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2017.01.024. [151] Mishra SK, Ghosh S, Aravindan S. 3D finite element investigations on textured
[131] Li N, Chen Y, Kong D, Tan S. Experimental investigation with respect to the per- tools with different geometrical shapes for dry machining of titanium alloys. Int J
formance of deep submillimeter-scaled textured tools in dry turning titanium alloy Mech Sci 2018;141:424–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmecsci.2018.04.011.
Ti–6Al–4V. Appl Surf Sci 2017;403:187–99. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc. [152] Chen ZM, Zhang JF, Feng PF, Wu ZJ. A simulation study on the effect of micro-
2017.01.166. textured tools during orthogonal cutting of titanium alloy Ti–6Al–4V. Appl Mech
[132] Mishra SK, Ghosh S, Aravindan S. Characterization and machining performance of Mater 2013;281:389–94. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMM.281.
laser-textured chevron shaped tools coated with AlTiN and AlCrN coatings. Surf 389.
Coatings Technol 2018;334:344–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2017.11. [153] Ma J, Duong H. Assessment of Microgrooved Cutting Tool in Dry Machining of
061. AISI 1045 Steel: A Numerical Study. 2013. p. 1–6.
[133] Obikawa T, Kamio A, Takaoka H, Osada A. Micro-texture at the coated tool face [154] Ma J, Duong NH, Lei S. 3D numerical investigation of the performance of mi-
for high performance cutting. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2011;51:966–72. https:// crogroove textured cutting tool in dry machining of Ti–6Al–4V. Int J Adv Manuf
doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2011.08.013. Technol 2015;79:1313–23. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-6937-1.
[134] Kumar CS, Patel SK. Effect of WEDM surface texturing on Al2O3/TiCN composite [155] Olleak A, Özel T. 3D finite element modeling based investigations of micro-tex-
ceramic tools in dry cutting of hardened steel. Ceram Int 2018;44:2510–23. tured tool designs in machining titanium alloy Ti–6Al–4V. Procedia Manuf
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ceramint.2017.10.236. 2017;10:536–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.promfg.2017.07.042.
73