Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
To cite this article: James L. Chan (2003) Government Accounting: An Assessment of Theory, Purposes and Standards,
Public Money & Management, 23:1, 13-20
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained
in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of
the Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,
and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied
upon and should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall
not be liable for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other
liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or
arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
13
Government Accounting: An
Assessment of Theory, Purposes
and Standards
James L. Chan
Government accounting and financial reporting aims to protect and manage
public money and discharge accountability. These purposes, and the nature of
public goods and tax financing, give rise to differences with commercial
accounting. This is not yet reflected either in government accounting standards in
English-speaking developed nations or in international public sector accounting
Downloaded by [University of Alberta] at 04:53 10 November 2014
standards. All of these are heavily influenced by private sector practices, which
favour the accrual basis and consolidated reporting. This article argues for a
gradual symmetric approach to accruals and a combination of government-wide
and fund reporting. The author also proposes some broad accounting principles
to promote political and economic accountability.
At the international level, government accounting fundamentally due to the greater demand for James Chan is
has attracted considerable attention for several accountability in a democracy and market Professor of
reasons: economy. Democratic governance and market Accounting at the
transactions require and foster the norm of University of Illinois
•The scale and functions of modern reciprocity—the expectation of exchange of at Chicago and
governments, in both relative and absolute benefits of comparable value—upon which Consulting Professor
terms (World Bank, 1997). More money accountability is based. Accounting information at Shanghai
requires more financial accounting. Managing can be used to monitor and enforce the terms University of
with less money necessitates a different kind of economic, social and political contracts. When Finance and
of accounting—cost accounting—for a government engages in market transactions— Economics and
improving efficiency and economy. whether buying or selling services, lending or Xiamen University.
•Accounting is regarded as a weapon against borrowing money—it is subject to economic He is an active
fraud and waste in government. Donor nations accountability. When it levies taxes to finance member of the
and international organizations have realized public services, it incurs political accountability. comparative
the value of accounting in maintaining sound The development of government international
financial systems. Without reliable accounting accounting is related to the constitutional form government
numbers, they do not know where the money of government that provides for separation of accounting research
went, let alone how well it was spent. powers, and checks and balances among the (CIGAR) network,
•The accounting profession has discovered the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of and founded
potential for extending its skills and services to government (Chan and Rubin, 1987). While all Research in
the public sector. governments engage in some degree of Governmental and
•English-speaking developed nations have planning and control, only democratic Nonprofit
coalesced to champion a new kind of governments are mandated to open their Accounting.
government accounting. books—directly to auditors and indirectly to
•Two global networks—Comparative the public through financial reports. Fiscal
International Government Accounting transparency is therefore an attribute of limited
Research (CIGAR) and the International government, for to give out information is to
Public Management Network (IPMN)—have cede authority. Government officials rationally
created visible forums for lively exchange do not volunteer more information than is
among academics and practitioners across required or in their interest. It is therefore not
borders and in cyberspace. surprising that, while some accounting is done
on a voluntary basis, financial disclosure is
From Accountability to Accounting often made only in response to demand.
The global rise of government accounting is The regulatory structure for government
financial disclosure mirrors the pattern of also occur in a democracy, despite the checks
accountability in government and the political and balances built into the machinery of
system. In an administrative hierarchy, the government to thwart and expose fiscal
superior holds subordinates accountable and misconduct. For example, more than a century
requires feedback information on their after its Declaration of Independence, the
performance. A legislature monitors the United States still needed a municipal reform
conduct of the executive branch, for example, movement to emphasize basic financial record-
in executing the approved budget. keeping to fight corruption in local
Furthermore, a government has the incentive governments (Chan, 2001).
to disclose information in order to induce others The intermediate purpose of government
to provide resources to it. These include accounting is to facilitate sound financial
potential buyers of government securities; management. Financial management includes
vendors of goods and services on credit; and activities such as collecting taxes and other
grantors of financial aid. In these voluntary revenues, paying bills, borrowing and repaying
exchanges, information is used to predict a debts. In a well-run government, these activities
government’s ability to carry out the terms of are budgeted or otherwise planned. Their
contracts. After the transactions are made, execution through duly authorized transactions
accounting information is used to monitor is recorded in the financial accounting system.
Downloaded by [University of Alberta] at 04:53 10 November 2014
Jefferson (quoted by Arthur Andersen, 1986) are hard to come by. The same problems arise
wished to see ‘the finance of the Union as clear in the case of natural resources and heritage
and intelligible as a merchant’s books, so that assets. On the liability side, it is not easy to draw
every member of Congress, and every man of the line between a national government’s
any mind in the Union, should be able to contractual or legal obligations and its political
comprehend them to investigate abuses, and commitments and social responsibilities for the
consequently to control them’. Is it possible general welfare. In contrast to corporations’
that government and business accounting are limited liabilities, governments in a democracy
fundamentally alike in unimportant respects— are prone to expand their responsibilities,
as public and private management are (Allison, resulting in larger budgets and frequent deficits
1980)? What are the important respects that set (Buchanan and Wagner, 1977).
government accounting apart from its business Accounting principles allow a business,
counterpart? whether private or state-owned, to recognize
In order to serve the three identified revenues only to the extent of goods or services
purposes, financial accounting and provided. Governments uniquely provide
management accounting cannot be so neatly public goods and finance them through
compartmentalized in the public sector, where taxation. Public goods are consumed
management accounting refers to budgeting collectively, and non-payers cannot be
Downloaded by [University of Alberta] at 04:53 10 November 2014
and control, rather than accounting solely in excluded—hence requiring tax financing.
the service of managers. The budget is an These characteristics sever the link between
expression of public policy and political service delivery and revenue recognition,
preferences. It is an instrument of fiscal policy making it impossible to match revenues and
on revenue and spending to achieve expenses (Sunder, 1997). This accounting
macroeconomic objectives. It provides problem is also exacerbated by the involuntary
benchmarks for performance measured partly nature of many transactions between
by the accounting system. Given their close government and people. The government’s
relationship, it is often difficult to tell where operating statement tracks resource flows, and
budgeting ends and accounting begins. They only incidentally measures the government’s
reinforce each other in demonstrating and service efforts and accomplishments.
discharging fiscal accountability to the These unique characteristics of government
government’s stakeholders, who are more are the primary source of the differences
numerous and diverse than the owners of a between government and commercial
firm. Indeed, governments do not have owners. accounting. These differences, argues Sunder
The absence of ownership in government (1997, p. 198), ‘do not constitute prima facie
makes it problematic to apply the accounting evidence that the former are defective and
equation (assets = liabilities + owners’ equity) should be altered to conform to the latter’.
and its corollary (profit = revenues – expenses) More specifically, Nobes (1988, p. 198)
to the public sector. An exception may be local challenged the assertion that ‘Anglo-Saxon
governments. These are municipal commercial accounting involving accruals-
corporations chartered by the state to perform based annual financial statements is necessary
certain public services, which in many cases are for accountability, control and decision-making
private goods (for example water) or only quasi- relating to government’.
public goods (for example elementary From the research perspective, theories
education). These entities have clear origins, underlying government accounting standards
and own identifiable assets and liabilities. are mostly normative, in contrast to the
Unfortunately, the assets and liabilities of development of positive theory in (business)
the national government of a sovereign state financial accounting. The latter (Watts, 1977;
are difficult to identify and harder still to Watts and Zimmerman, 1978, 1990) draws its
measure in financial terms. With regard to inspiration from the contract-cost theory of the
assets, except in rare instances (such as the firm originating from Coase (1937). A similar
United States’ purchase of Louisiana from incipient conceptual revolution started
France, or Alaska from Russia), few nations tentatively with Zimmerman’s (1977) paper
acquire new territories through buy-and-sell linking government financial reporting to
transactions. Most occupy their ancestral lands political incentives. It is time to resume the
and some acquired their territories through search for a positive theory of government
military conquests or colonization. Historical accounting standards. One way would be to
costs, even if data are available, are not build on the work of Chester Barnard and
meaningful, yet market prices, even if justifiable, Herbert Simon.
At about the same time Coase wrote his the popular notion that business accounting (at
famous paper explaining the existence of the least before the 2002 Enron/Arthur Andersen
firm in terms of transaction costs, Barnard scandal) stood for financial discipline and
(1938) identified the functions of the executive integrity. Furthermore, the New Public
as securing the co-operation of the stakeholders Management literature has raised expectations
of an organization. Barnard’s work is currently about the ability of accounting to make
enjoying a revival, primarily through the efforts government more efficient (see Olsen et al.,
of Oliver Williamson (1990). Much earlier, 1998, for a review). IPSASs could raise the
Simon (1945) applied Barnard’s insight to prestige of government accountants, who are
government in his book Administrative Behavior. often regarded more as bureaucrats than
In Simon’s view, an organization is in credentialled professionals like certified/
equilibrium if Barnard’s executive succeeds in chartered accountants. IPSASs might facilitate
securing the contributions of stakeholders by the entry of private sector accountants and
offering them adequate inducements to stay in auditors into the public sector. Perhaps IPSASs
the organizational coalition. A business can be might serve as a catalyst for including
viewed in the same way (Cohen and Cyert, government accounting in the common body
1965). In both types of organization, the of knowledge expected of all accountants.
challenge for managers is to negotiate Finally, the financial support of international
Downloaded by [University of Alberta] at 04:53 10 November 2014
satisfactory terms of contracts to keep the organizations, such as the World Bank and the
coalition intact. In such a theory, owners are IMF, constitutes a favourable assessment of the
important as contributors of equity capital, but expected contribution of IPSASs to government
they are not the only group managers try to financial accountability.
please. In other words, the owner-centred However, it would be naive to exaggerate
theory of the firm and the single-principal governments’ propensity to reform their
agency theory are a special case of the Barnard- accounting systems on the basis of IPSASs. A
Simon organization theory. sovereign nation is likely to zealously guard its
This theory can be used to identify potential authority to determine its own government
users of government’s financial information by accounting standards. This resistance might be
postulating that they use the information to overcome if the introduction of IPSASs were
predict their inducements from government made a condition for receiving international
(Chan, 1981). Recently, Sunder (1997) applied grants and loans. The enforceability of IPSASs
contract-cost theory to explain and justify the would be higher if it were invoked in
differences between accounting for government international agreements or treaties (similar to
and nonprofit organizations and business the Maastricht Treaty) specifying convergence
accounting. Much more research is needed criteria for fiscal policy. Another way to promote
before the multiple-stakeholder perspective IPSASs is to link it to membership obligations
can have an impact on standards. In the to international organizations, such as the
meantime, government accounting has shifted United Nations, the World Bank, the IMF, the
closer to the business (financial) accounting Organization for Economic Co-operation and
model. Development (OECD), and the European
Union. Better still, is for these international
Changes for the Better? organizations to set an example by adopting
Among the numerous changes in government the IPSASs themselves, as the OECD has done.
accounting in recent years, the emergence of Each country’s own way of adopting
International Public Sector Accounting government accounting standards will affect
Standards (IPSASs) stands out as the most their likelihood of using IPSASs. Countries
significant development (see Sutcliffe, 2003). using independent boards may find it easier to
The initial set of IPSASs, unfortunately, has import IPSASs than those that legislate
rather uncritically emulated the business government accounting standards. Unless there
accounting standards set by the International are scandals or financial crises linked to bad
Accounting Standards Board’s predecessor accounting or reporting practices, changes
(Chan, 2002). They are detailed technical would be slow and infrequent. As Machiavelli
provisions designed by accountants for (1513, quoted by Rogers, 1983) counselled his
accountants, not for public policy-makers whose Prince: ‘There is nothing more difficult to plan,
support is critical for their successful more doubtful of success, nor more dangerous
implementation. Even so, IPSASs have some to manage than the creation of a new order of
symbolic value. By basing the initial IPSASs on things’. Lüder (1992) emphasized the uncertain
IASC standards, the IPSASs might benefit from prospect of adopting government accounting
innovations and the necessity of overcoming down the above list to admit items onto the
numerous barriers. As in corporate accounting balance sheet (Chan, 1999). A gradual
and financial reporting (Ball, 2001), IPSASs symmetric approach to accruals is preferable.
need infrastructural support in the form of a Accrual accounting should proceed gradually
robust legal system and a culture of because stronger forms of accrual are more
accountability. Rigorous accounting standards risky. They create more measurement
may run counter to the interests of a problems, have less theoretical support, and
government. The support of the institutions are more subjective. Few accountants would
that hold resources of value to governments— argue against mild and moderate forms of
the international lenders, donors, bond-rating accrual. But consensus begins to break down
agencies—may prove to be indispensable. with capital assets, and radical accrual hardly
IPSASs and the latest accounting standards has any support. Symmetrical accruals means
in English-speaking developed nations have aligning assets and liabilities of similar nature
two things in common: they all favour the and maturity. This would avoid distortion and
accrual basis of accounting and government- manipulation (for example recognize more
wide financial presentation. Are these changes assets and less liabilities).
for the better? When a government’s budget is expressed
on the cash basis, the accrual bases of accounting
Downloaded by [University of Alberta] at 04:53 10 November 2014
PMPA Publications
The Public Management and Policy Association publishes a range of reports on topics of key
interest to everyone involved in the planning, management and delivery of public services.
Current titles include:
The Governance Narrative: Key Findings and Lessons from the ESRC’s Whitehall Programme
R. A. W. Rhodes (August 2000)
Individual copies are available at £10 each plus post and packing. PMPA members receive one
free copy of each report when it is published and can buy additional copies at 75% of the cover
price. Orders of 10 or more of any one title also qualify for a discount.