Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
IMPROVING
Mar’atus Sholihah
113 13 156
SALATIGA
2019
The Effectiveness of Pre-Reading Plan (PreP) Strategy in Improving the Students’
Reading Comprehension On Narrative Text
Research Proposal
they are listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Listening and reading are receptive
skills, while speaking and writing are productive skills (Jeremy Harmer.:1991). As
even problem solution. Therefore, the ability to read the text in any form will give a
great deal of advantages in our life. Reading becomes the main goal of language
teaching which is a skill and a part of the teaching program. Its purposes are to enable
someone’s perception and thought (Pang et.: 2003). Moreover, by reading people can
get message from what they read. This is not simple activity because the readers use
their perception and thought to recognition refers to the process of how written
written materials such as news, papers, magazines, novels, academic books, and so
on. As in learning at school from elementary to college level, reading is a skill that
must be possessed by each student besides other skills, there are listening skill,
writing skill, and speaking skill, because the four skills are related to each other. So
2
that, when people talk about reading, it might be automatically related to
comprehension or understanding.
One of reading skill is reading comprehension. A reader who understands what
he reads can answer questions about it. Especially for students who want develop and
obtaining progress. Students can extend their knowledge by reading books. Through
reading, students can improve their knowledge in many fields and sciences. It means
school curriculum based on new curriculum ( Kurikulum 2013), there are several texts
which are ought to be learned by senior high school students in Indonesia. According
to the Standard of Competence (SK) and Basic Competence (KD) in the curriculum
K13, some of those texts are procedure text, descriptive text, argumentative text,
the most interesting one. Anderson and Anderson (2003) explain that a narrative text
tells story and, in doing so, entertains the audience. It has characters, settings, and
action. Students must be able to analyze social functions, text structures, and
(KD) of the high school syllabus. But, students have many problems to understand the
main idea of the text, and they found difficulties to comprehend the generic structure
done on July until September 2017 in SMA Islam Sudirman Ambarawa, the other
were students having difficulties in the understanding English vocabulary and the
3
contents of the text also the lack of background knowledge and experience students
is still related to teacher factors. Teacher weaknesses and the use of strategies,
methods, and learning techniques that are not appropriate when teaching reading this
do not involve students thinking about reading, that is causing students to have
difficulty reading, especially understanding texts (Dias Ratna: 2014). So, if the
teacher used one of strategies, students can be understand the material easily. While
students will feel bored, because the teachers just ask the students to translate the text,
whereas it is ineffective method. Absolutely, the students can not understand and
interested in reading activity (Lia Maretnowati :2014. p.2). And also, the strategies
reading text. One of the strategies is Pre-Reading Plan (Pre-P) strategies, which can
about the text they read while they are reading it (Marrianne Celce-Murcia.: 1991). In
the reading there is a pre-reading stage which will help students easily understand the
text. According to Sara Puspitasari (2007) in her graduating paper, the pre-reading
stage is a phase before the students are given the reading text. The teacher usually
brainstroms or arises students’ attention about the text. In pre-reading stage, the
teacher will encourage the students to activate their background knowledge with the
theme they learn. So, by having this kind strategy students will be more active in
reading, the reading of narrative text will be more interesting and later on hopefully
4
Based on the problem and explanation above, the writer is interested in
(PReP) strategy?
3. Is there any significant effects of using Pre-Reading Plan (PreP) strategy towards
Plan strategy of the first grade Senior High School. In this study, the researcher
focusses on the students’ reading comprehension in a text. So many kind of text such
as, narrative, descriptive, recount, etc. The researcher chooses narrative text, because
it text is fiction story, thus the students will be more interesting to read the story.
Based on the identification of the problem above, some the students cannot
comprehend narrative text. The students get some difficulties to find the overall
meaning of text, some of the students have no enthusiasm and the teaching strategy
5
used by the teacher do not give a good result. Therefore, the reseacher limit the
researcher hopes that this research gives some contributions for educational field
especially for teaching learning process in English education. If this study shows a
guidance in doing identical research. Beside, it will be very useful for teachers in
toward reading comprehension in narrative text. There are some variables to control
about a given topic and predict what they will read or hear. Before students read
any text, teachers can direct their attention of how a text is organized, teach
unfamiliar vocabulary or other concepts, search for the main idea, and provide
students with a purpose for reading or listening. Most importantly, teachers can
6
It is defined as an active cognitive process of interacting with print and monitoring
15).
4. Narrative text
in different ways. Narrative deals with problematic events wich lead to a crisis or
G. Benefits of Research
This research has several benefits for the researcher, the reader, the students
and the teachers. The results of this research can be keep connected in English
School. In this research, the researcher hopes that the results of this research are
useful for :
1. The reseacher
The reseacher finds out whether Pre-Reading Plan strategy can enhance students’
2. The reader
The results of this research can be used as referance for other reader that interested
3. The students
7
Students can improve their reading comprehension on narrative texts by using this
4. The teachers
The results of this research is may become an alternative strategy for teachers to
H. Theoritical Frames
In this study, the researcher takes 3 previous researches. The first previous
SMA N 2 Singingi”. The result of her research is the students who taught by using
Pre-Reading Plan strategy was better than students who taught without using Pre-
Reading Plan Strat egy. It can be concluded that Pre-Reading Plan strategy gives a
better result toward reading comprehension of the first year student at SMA N 2
Singingi.
Students’ Reading Comprehension”. The result of his research shows that schema
of this theory provides theoritical support for the use of such strategies in classes,
which do not merely aim at activating prior knowledge, but also help construct
8
The last previous research is conducted by Jessica Marinacco entitled “The
strategies. She was surprised to find that the importance of teachers activating
comprehension. And the findings showed the importance of teachers knowing the
information and their own students before providing the students with a strategy
Narrative text.
This stragtegy can be used to help students to sctivate their prior knowledge
can be activates the easier for students to comprehend a text will be.
learning than IQ, which suggests that if teachers elicit, clarify and organize
9
prior knowledge, and thereby increase provisional understanding,
processing and recall for all students that will be increased. The explanation
another students advantages. They would knew their friend’s ideas which
could promote another students to share their own idea too, because each
student has same opportunity before the new knowledge, vocabulary and
2) Pre-reading Procedure
et.al, teaching reading by using PreP Strategy will used three phases as
follows :
10
that can be presented to the students to start a discussion on the topic.
the discussion could begin with a question by the teacher such as,
“Have you ever read stories?”. During this word phase, the goal is to
concept as possible.
teachers asks questions such as, “What were the stories about?” and
“Do you have any new ideas about Issumboshi?” often, the students
11
responses in the first phase, that is, the use of super ordinate concepts,
d) The students read the assigned text and review associations made.
know about...?”,”How do you know that?”, and “Do you have any new
for students the need to consider information that they already have, to
on new information
language preparation that might be needed for coping with passage, and to
There are several points that describe the main purposes of the Pre-
Reading strategy:
12
a. Assess students’ background knowledge of the topic and linguistic
of the text, or activate the existing knowledge that the student posses.
d. Make students aware of the type of text they will reading and the
purposes of reading.
discussion activities.
The main goal of the pre-reading stage is founded upon the notion
understand the text using pre-reading activity (Sara Puspita Sari graduation
papers’ :2007).
b. Reading Comprehension
13
use information that they already possess to filter, interpret, organize and
a person with less. Because all readers use their prior knowledge to bring
Douglas Fisher. Therefore, it stands to reason that the more relevant prior
knowledge a reader possesses, and the greater his or her ability to access and
will be.
within certain genres of text structures, when drawing inferences and when
the text.
c. Narrative text
A narrative text is a text taht tell a story and, in doing so, entertains the
mainly to inform often contains large passage arranging the events in a story
tales, mysteries, fables, romances, and adventure stories, myths and legends).
humour, romance, crime, real life fiction, historical fiction, mystery, fantasy,
14
From the explanation above, narrative text is story occured in past time
follows:
1. Characters
In every story, there must be characters that play on it. There are two
characters take place within a story. They are main characters and
weaknesses.
2. Settings
Setting are what author writers to describe where and when the story
takes place. The setting addressed the location (where) and period
(when) of the story whether the story tells a readers among realistic,
3. Plot
15
4. Conclusion
The writer ends up the story by summirizing and telling the solution
of the problem in the story. This the last part is called by conclusion.
a) Orientation
b) Complication
In this part, crisis of the story arises. The story is pushed along
This complication will involve the main character and often serve to
c) Resolution
I. Research Method
1. Research Method
16
This research method is experimental research. According to Sukardi
because the result of this research method can answer the hypothesis if the research
is done well. Experimental research needs hard work to select the requirements.
and experimental units, the treatments are to measure the goal. Two classes will be
conducted in experimental research. The first class is experimental class and the
2. Research Design
education term although we may find the different meaning of research design in
different studies. The design of this research was quasi experimental research.
create groups for the experiment (John W. Creswell:2008). Gay and Peter (2000:36)
participants to groups in several cases. For example , researcher can get permission
Moreover, there were two variables in this research. The first was independent
variable and the second one was dependent variable. Using Pre-reading plan (PreP)
strategy was independent variable symbolized by “X” and the students’ reading
17
research, there were two classes involved. The first was experimental class. The
Before performing the treatment, the researcher administers pre-test for both
classes and at the end of treatment, the researcher administers post-test both of them.
Technique
Class
Strategy (PreP)
Class Post-test
To obtain the data needed in this research, the writer uses multiple choice
research, they are pre-test and post-test, each of tests consisted of 25 items. The
18
test will do twice, before and after treatment intend to obatain students’ reading
comprehension.
1) Pre-test : Pre-test given to the students before the students are taught by
using PreP strategy. It is going to use to measure the students’ reading
comprehension especially in Narrative text before they will teach by using
PreP strategy.
3) Post-test : Post test is a test given to the students after they were taught by
using PreP strategy. It used to know whether the students can easily
comprehend the text especially narrative text by using PreP strategy or
not.
1) Pre-test : Pre-test given by the teacher before the students are taught by
students are going to ask to read narrative text by the teacher, then the
teacher will help them to find the unfamiliar words, then the teacher asked
3) Post-test : Post test will given to the students after they were taught by
using three phase technique. It is going to use to know wether the students
19
able to comprehend narrative text well by using three phase technique or
not.
This study uses Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) for analyze
the data. According to Sabine Landau and Brian S.Everitt (2003:1) SPSS is a
manipulating, analyzing, and presenting data program which is used in the social
and behavior science. In practice, the researcher will use SPSS Base. It has a
number of add-on modules that extented the range og data entry, statistical, of
reporting capabilities. That also provides methods for data description, simple
After analyzing the data, the researcher will present the result of analysis by
answer the statement of the problem of using PreP strategy in improving students’
reading comprehension on narrative text for the first grade of SMK PGRI 1
This study is written systematically in order that easier to read and understand.
This study is divided into five chapters and each chapters several subchapters. They
are :
20
Chapter two is theoretical framework. The writer discuss about : Reading,
Chapter four are findings and discussions which contains descriptive analysis
text.
Chapter V is the closure which contains the conclusion and the suggestions, for the
21
Biliography
Anderson, Mark and Kathy Anderson. 1998. Text Types in English 3, South Yarra :Mc.Millan
Harmer,Jeremy. 1991. The Practice of English Language Teaching. New York: Longman
Publishing, p.16
Landau, Sabine and Brian S. Everitt. 2004. A Handbook of Statistical Analysis using SPSS.
Lapp, Diane, James Flood and Nancy Fernan. 1989. Content Area Reading and Learning:
Marinaccio, Jessica. 2012. The Most Effective Pre-reading Strategies for Comprehension.
Neil, Anderson. David, Nunan (ed). 2003. Practical English Language Teaching. New York:
McGraw-Hill, p.66
Oehlert, G.W. 2010. A First Course in Design and Analysis of Experiments. Minesota:
22
Pang, Elisabeth., Angaluki Muaka, Elizabeth, B., & Michael, L. Kamil. 2003. Teaching
Hidayatullah Jakarta
S. Chatman and B. Attebery. 1993. Reading Narrative Fiction, New York :McMillan
Ratna, Dias P. 2014. Efektivitas Penerapan Pre Reading Plan Technique Terhadap
https://id.scribd.com/doc/146626227/The-Effect-of-Think-Aloud-Strategy-toward-Students-
Reading-Skill
23
CHAPTER II
THEORITICAL FRAMEWORK
A. READING
Most people see reading as a simple process with the reader processing each
letter in turn, producing the appropriate sounds, and forming words (Richard
Allington and Michael Strange: 1990. p.15). Some people considered reading as a
thinking process through which meaning is obtained from printed symbols (Verna
1. Definitions of Reading
24
2. Parts of Reading Lesson
B. READING COMPREHENSION
computer. Messages are constantly coming in about what you see, hear, smell, touch,
or taste. Your brain receives this mesages, interprets them, shorts them, and saves
them (Beatrice and Linda Jeffries: p. 14). It is the same process happens when we are
reading comprehension.
25
3. Goals of Pre-Reading Strategy
D. NARRATIVE TEXT
E. EFFECTIVENESS
26