Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6

Invited Article

Research on Social Work Practice


2019, Vol. 29(6) 687-692
Art and the Social Work Profession: Shall ª The Author(s) 2019
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
Ever the Twain Meet? DOI: 10.1177/1049731519863109
journals.sagepub.com/home/rsw

Marilyn L. Flynn1

Abstract
Despite evidence of widespread increasing interest in the arts as mechanisms for personal and social change, social work
is conspicuous for its lack of organized conceptual attention to this area. This article argues that there are four potential
perspectives that might be adopted as a means of expanding social work science and professional practice: the arts as adjunct to
clinical treatment and healing, the arts as the “work” in social work, the arts as tool for social investment, and the arts as driver of
political and ideological commitment. An argument is presented for a new vision of the profession in academic environments in
which the arts are defined as one of the fundamental pillars. This might lead to reimagining of scholarship, the reconstruction of
social work education, and acceleration of social reform.

Keywords
creativity, expressive therapies, social change, phenomenology, socialist realism

The place of science in social work has advanced rapidly over research, and practice can best be described as idiosyncratic.
the past 25 years, including a rich dialog on the philosophy of The form, purposes, knowledge base, and rationale for use of
science as it applies to the social work profession. In a much the arts therefore vary widely, depending largely on local and
less pervasive but equally important way, the question of how personal initiative. Perhaps most importantly, the creative
the arts relate—or should relate—to the field of social work has activity of scholars, practitioners, and artists themselves does
also gained traction. Discoveries in neuroscience have intro- not translate into a cumulative literature or a systematic body of
duced new empirical grounding for the value of mindfulness, scholarship within the field of social work. We lack a knowl-
expressive therapies, and spirituality (Land, 2015). An expand- edge base, an organized perspective that might lay out the path
ing literature on “socially engaged art” or “social practice” that for more meaningful future development of the arts in social
draws on traditions of advocacy and passion for social justice work practice. This would seem to be the most essential ingre-
among artists themselves has added impetus (Helguera, 2012). dient in forming a vigorous and more defensible area for edu-
In Europe, a rethinking of phenomenology in philosophy has cation, research, and professional engagement. Would
enlivened a fresh examination of social work practice itself as art. recognition of art as a fundamental component of professional
As a consequence, growing numbers of interested students, education change how universities and accrediting bodies
faculty, and professionals across the nation are investigating construct the experience of social work students and require-
the effect of the arts on behavior or harnessing the arts in ments in the curriculum? Would our scholarship be reima-
service of practice. A subtext among these groups is the need gined? Is there even a compelling reason to reexamine the
to harness other dimensions of human experience and under- field in this way?
standing as a necessary counterpoise to the world as interpreted Social work is occupied with the problems of promoting
through quantitative science and technology. Artists are social change, advancing human potential, and increasing
honored as guardians of human emotion and subjective expe- knowledge of the human condition. Art, as one of the earliest
rience. Supporters argue that the arts are liberating in a unique forms of human expression, has purposes that both overlap and
way, that participation and exposure engage soul and mind. extend beyond these aims. Finding the nexus between the two
Yet, this romanticism has not served our field well.
Today, we lack a robust examination of the place of art in
1
social work. One of the primary obstacles to this pursuit is the University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA
lack of philosophical maturity in our field. Social work does
Corresponding Author:
not have much to draw on in constructing a new and more Marilyn L. Flynn, University of Southern California, 214 MRF, Los Angeles,
powerful model of the profession that includes the arts. As a CA 90089, USA.
consequence, formal integration of the arts in teaching, Email: mflynn@usc.edu
688 Research on Social Work Practice 29(6)

must begin with the identification of places of convergence. know or practice. Activists, in contrast, are focused on the
This article proposes three frameworks that capture this con- public at large and on capturing themes of social justice. As
vergence but in significantly different ways. The points of Walton observed, there is a general cacophony. Beneath this
commonality involve the definition of art as social or beha- diversity of perspective lies an even more essential division: art
vioral intervention and also involve an established institutional as universal phenomenon with aesthetic properties that cross
or professional base. These are leverage points that social work national boundaries and cultures or art as locally and histori-
might use to raise the profile of the arts in practice or even as a cally bound and individually perceived (Adajian, 2016). There
new way of conceiving the foundations of our profession. are also side skirmishes about whether art is primarily visual or
The first framework—art in clinical practice as an agent of includes movement and sound, or whether literature, drama,
physical and mental healing—is well established, with funded and interactive games belong in the pantheon. The principles
research and emerging professional recognition outside the that define the properties and elements of art as understood by
social work field. It is most rooted as a part of specialty prac- Western critics cannot be ignored, but at the same time may not
tices in music, theater, painting, and architecture. The second be relevant to social work practice. This will depend on the
framework—art as a tool for social change and reconstruc- models for collaboration or incorporation that are adopted by
tion—draws on traditions of community advocacy and other social work.
techniques that aim at altering the face of under-resourced Another, possibly more productive, approach to the defini-
neighborhoods and reducing social divisions. It draws upon tion of art might be filtered through the lens of our professional
economics, urban planning, and perhaps the settlement move- orientation and all that that implies. Looking outward from our
ment for inspiration and validation. The third framework—art own accepted boundaries of knowledge and skill, the definition
as instrument for producing ideological conformity or building of art as an occupation rather than a profession has important
commitment to national policies—has been employed by gov- consequences (Art, n.d.). Occupations are typically delineated
ernments, nonprofit entities, and others. This avenue builds on by sets of skills that individuals use to earn a livelihood or as a
modern communication methods, marketing, and theories of way of enriching life experience. By contrast, professions as a
psychological influence, with art as the medium for reinforcing modern bureaucratic and social invention are more complex
policy aims. legally and organizationally (Freidson, 1988). Occupations
In sum, the question of the arts in social work can be gradually become designated as professions when they succeed
addressed concerning whether—and how—they might contrib- in specifying their knowledge base, drawing boundaries in
ute to preparation for clinical practice, their potential for accel- relation to other disciplines, setting standards and evaluative
erating social reform, or their value in adding to social cohesion processes for training, and committing to public accountability
and commitment to shared beliefs. Each line of inquiry draws for ethical practice, among many other characteristics (Wheel-
on separate traditions and wellsprings of insight. wright, 2000). Social work today draws upon other occupations
to assist in meeting professional goals and could do so as well
with the arts. In this event, collaboration between artists and
What Is Art? social workers would not require a definition of art itself but
rather how art in all its manifestations would support our pro-
The definition of “art” is a subject that has been mixed through-
fessional skill development.
out history with magic, religion, healing, culture—in short,
Turning the professional lens inward to the nature of prac-
almost every aspect of human interaction and self-expression.
tice itself raises an entirely different potential frame of refer-
Debates among philosophers have raged without satisfactory
ence. As noted earlier, art was omnipresent in the earliest forms
resolution, leading Walton (1997), a philosopher of aesthetics,
of civilization and clearly occupies some universal place in the
to write:
human mind across time and culture. These properties of art
It is not at all clear that these words—“What is art?”—express have been the subject of modern ontology and phenomenology,
anything like a single question, to which competing answers are as philosophy seeks to explain art and its effect on human
given, or whether philosophers proposing answers are even consciousness and human interaction. Modern science and the
engaged in the same debate. The sheer variety of proposed defini- scientific method have made observation and measurement
tions should give us pause. One cannot help wondering whether the sine qua non for knowledge development. Accordingly, the
there is any sense in which they are attempts to clarify the same science of social work today is in part dedicated to the con-
cultural practices, or address the same issue. (p. 148) trolled documentation of transactions and outcomes of practice.
Thus far, few contemporary scholars have successfully applied
This warning language is worth heeding in considering the science to the analysis of practice as an art form. This may
possible intersections between social work and art. It under- require a different philosophical context than the profession has
scores the reality that scholars and activists will enter this used, leading to revised ideas about how observation should
dialog with an unspoken but wide variance in their underlying take place and the criteria for measurement.
assumptions, bringing a halt to real conversation almost before In the present article, we can only hint at the ways in which
it has begun. Philosophers have largely given up on a unifying an analysis of social work practice would be affected by new
theory. Practitioners are self-referential: The arts are what they philosophical underpinnings and implications for a useful
Flynn 689

professional definition of art. As an initial foray, this article and the resulting artwork and comments on struggles the client
suggests what phenomenology might offer, drawing on the is experiencing with social relationships, low self-esteem, or
thinking of Martin Heidegger and Alain Badiou. Both have laid other sources of emotional or psychological pain. The objective
a foundation for a fresh consideration of social work practice as is to improve confidence, cope with addictive behavior, lower
art and the potential linkage to some aspects of science (Badiou anxiety, and restore effective social functioning. As described
& Toscano, 2005; Richardson, 2003). by the American Art Therapy Association (n.d.),
Alternatively, again using a professional social work lens,
the role of art can be defined in relation to shared societal aims Art therapy has the unique ability to unlock emotional expression
as reflected in government and not-for-profit programs has by facilitating nonverbal communication. This is especially useful
taken on a new definition outside traditional spheres—first, in cases where traditional psychotherapy has been ineffectual. Art
as a form of economic investment in promoting social out- and art making are inherently perceptually and sensory based and
comes, and second, as governmental investment in reifying involve the brain and the body in ways that verbal language does
political ideology. While both practices have long-standing not. Art therapy provides an alternative means of communicating
roots in the patronage of kings, popes, and ancient conquerors, for those who cannot find the words to express anxiety, pain, or
the scale and resources are unique to contemporary society. emotions as a result of trauma, combat, physical abuse, loss of
brain function, depression, and other debilitating health conditions.
These activist orientations implicitly support the notion that art
(p. 1)
must have a purpose. Thus, “art for art’s sake” may no longer
In addition to art therapy that relies principally on the visual
have sufficient social justification. As a profession, social
arts, dance therapy and music therapy also play increasingly
workers naturally turn to how our values of social justice,
acknowledged roles in supporting recovery and sustaining health
political liberation, and social well-being might be enhanced (American Dance, n.d.; American Music, n.d.).
by the power of art, which is another arrow in our quiver.
In summary, art is defined in this article from four perspec- Over the past several decades, the connection between art
tives: as an assistive healing agent, as a factor integral to the and healing has received serious attention from the medical
interactive process between social worker and individual or profession. It is estimated that over 300 professional organiza-
group, as a social investment strategy, and as an instrument for tions are attempting to systematically study and document how
political activism and control. The intent is to separate very the arts can affect both the development of illness and subse-
different potentialities in the expanded integration of the arts quent recovery. At the same time, artists have long intuitively
and social work depending on the problem to be solved by the recognized that creative activity seems to engage other human
profession. beings in a way that strengthens their ability to contend with the
impact of disease and to take greater advantage of medical
Art as Clinical Component to Promote interventions. New foundations and associations are develop-
Healing ing that seek to connect the artist, the medical world, and the
community to ensure that research-supported practices are
The capacity of human beings for imagination and powerful linked and more fully available (Taylor & Francis Foundation
subjective experience appears to have been manifested with the for Art and Healing, 2017).
origin of our species somewhere between 50,000 and 100,000 The relationship of art therapy to social work is self-evident,
years ago. Archaeologists suggest that the level of sophistica- and at its most concrete level, could be built out in terms of
tion and integration of artistic behavior was comparatively lit- stronger interprofessional connections such as joint degrees,
tle different from today and was far more advanced than other enhanced specializations and electives in social work programs,
forms of technology or cultural organization. Most signifi- and continuing education. The issue of whether these programs
cantly, a case can be made that the arts were very early asso- produce “good” art is generally subordinated to the perceived
ciated with therapy and healing, apparently as part of magical importance of participation in art activity itself. Consequently, a
rites to fight disease and death. social worker might not be expected to obtain much mastery
Despite a relative lack of empirical evidence, this idea herself. It is also more likely that the art therapist will be assistive
remains firmly rooted in contemporary literature. The arts are to the social worker, psychiatrist, or physician, in which case, art
widely accepted as promoting health and mental health, with is adjunctive rather than central to the healing process. With
collateral beneficial effects on community social cohesion. At sharpened attention to the empirical outcome measurement of
the individual level, participation and creative expression in the art therapy, the standardization of interventions is likely to occur
arts are viewed as a means of achieving recovery for those in the future, intensifying the instrumental focus even further.
suffering from mental illness. The strengthening of interperso-
nal connectedness, empathy, and improved social function are
also expected (Dyer & Hunter, 2009).
Art therapy has emerged as a recognized 21st-century pro-
The Arts as the “Work” in Social Work
fession, defined as a type of expressive therapy in which clients In 1986, English academic Hugh England published Social
create visual art as a means of examining and recognizing their Work as Art, which received wide circulation as a response
feelings. The art therapist follows both the process of creation of the social work profession to overweening empiricism and
690 Research on Social Work Practice 29(6)

orientation toward science as the basis for practice (England, habitual practices and subsequently form the basis for what people
1986). This seminal publication struck out in a fresh way to accept as knowledge (Lock & Strong, 2010).
interpret what might be meant by saying that social work itself In the search for truth, then, empiricism and science offer one
is an art. Rather than referring to social workers themselves as method. The interesting aspect of England’s work and that of
practicing an art, which is familiar ground in the literature, he others is that ontological questions are not avoided but redefined.
focused on the transactional experience between the social Quagmires abound in describing how objective structures can be
worker and client as the source of art. He argued that practi- derived from subjective experience but suffice it to say that the
tioners draw upon their own subjective experience as the basis case can be made. Findings, discoveries, and the results of the
for giving organized meaning to the experience of their clients. transaction between social work and client, whether individual or
As social worker and client engage with each other over time, societal, would then have to be measured in new ways, perhaps
this conscious interchange between client and practitioner gen- borrowing from art criticism. The important point is that mea-
erates a process of mutual discovery and creation. England surement remains possible, objective states can be judged, and
describes this as a phenomenological “attunement” with the outcomes can be redefined. In what might be a false opposition to
client. Attunement is accomplished primarily through intuition science and empiricism, phenomenology and related philosophi-
rather than reference to abstract knowledge or formulaic appli- cal inquiry point to alternative ways in which objective methods
cation of research-supported protocols. can be found that allow for the evaluation of subjective experi-
From this philosophical vantage point, the act of creativity is ence. Even the characterization of change itself in an individual
central to the “work” of social work and lies at the heart of a or society might be assessed by other criteria such as the resur-
social worker’s ability to imagine her client’s world. Her skill gence of imagination or democratic vigor (Walker, 2017).
rests in the degree to which she is effective in using language that
is evocative and expressive in communicating her subjective
understanding. England proposes that irrespective of organiza-
Art as a Tool for Social Investment
tional constraints, policies, or accepted practices, social workers Social work bears all of the agreed-upon markers of a profession,
ultimately always ground their decisions in intuition and emo- especially devotion to social values and ethics. As sociologists
tion in the moment. Thus, any theory of social work that also have observed, the professions are given the latitude to set their
draws on theories of art can help explain the role of subjectivity own standards, discipline their own members, and monopolize
in social work practice. England (1986) claimed that: their domains of practice on one condition: They must give
themselves over to the service of society and endeavor on the
The social worker . . . like the poet, must bring together disparate behalf of their clients and not their own interests. They are
elements of the ordinary world, and . . . must do so with unusually expected to advance social ideals and reflect that commitment
profound understanding, for this understanding must enrich the through a code of ethics. In social work, this translates into a
understanding of . . . clients. It is in this sense that the worker is sense of obligation for achieving social justice and social inclu-
creative; [s/he] is not just a critic understanding the meaning and sion and the guarantees of human rights to health, housing,
expression of others, but an artist giving expression to his own achievement of potential, and adequate income. These values
understanding in a way that others will value. (p. 106–107) are entirely consistent with the roots of the profession.
As public and private resources have gradually been
England and subsequent academics who point to this rela- stretched across an expanding array of social needs and wants,
tionship between social work and art are drawing upon the Western governments and philanthropies alike have grown
language of phenomenology and social constructionism devel- more preoccupied with the uses and the results of dollars spent
oped from many schools of thought during the last century. The on social well-being. Accountability has reigned supreme
varieties of phenomenology defy a single definition. For the among the requirements imposed by funding institutions.
purposes of this article, it is a perspective that is often con- Because social work by definition relies heavily on public sup-
cerned with processes of human consciousness and intuition port, it has more or less subscribed to the idea that social
that unite people with core meanings in experience. As Gray expenditures should be social investments that “buy” improved
and Webb (2008) put it, “Phenomenology is the description of conditions for marginalized or excluded individuals.
phenomena as a person experiences them.” The phenomenol- When applied to the arts, however employed by social workers
ogist avoids imposing hypotheses or prior rules on the formula- or allied professions, the emphasis on economic and social pay-
tion of experience but rather accepts whatever is presented as offs has had some thought-provoking consequences. Investment
real. The emphasis is on opening up rather than on reasoning or in art as a mechanism for spreading social inclusion has been
assessing instrumental value and discovering “intentionality,” popular in England and parts of Europe since the 1980s and, more
the constant structures underlying human experience. recently, in the United States. Both art and social work have been
This way of examining experience can be closely associated intimately involved in urban renewal and community revitaliza-
with social constructionism or theories postulating that the under- tion; both lay claim to motivating and inspiring society’s least-
standing of reality is actually based on jointly constructed inter- resourced citizens. As an instrument of central government social
pretations of reality based on social experience. These experiences or cultural policy, it remains unclear whether the investments
become consolidated through repeated social interactions and have achieved their desired goals. More recently, local
Flynn 691

governments have taken a larger part in independently moving modern history is Soviet socialist realism, which spanned from
these projects along (Sharp, Pollock, & Paddison, 2005). the early 1930s until the turn of the 20th century.
The new lexicon associated with grant seeking, accountabil- Soviet socialist realism is interesting because the criteria for
ity and empirical measures of output in social work and the arts this art form were governmentally imposed, linked clearly to
is pervasive. The Department of Culture Media and Sport in basic tenets of communist ideology, and defined as the only
Great Britain has spoken in recent years of “public investment permissible expression of the artistic impulse in society. Offi-
to deliver outcomes,” for example, (Smith, 1999). The National cials responsible for cultural policies denied the value of crea-
Endowment for the Humanities in the United States now lists tivity and experimentation in art and architecture in the belief
among its primary purposes the goal of “[bringing] financial that the purpose of art was to educate the public and idealize the
benefits to a community by stimulating cultural tourism, creating communist system. Art was expected to follow strictly repre-
jobs, and helping local businesses” (What We Do, 2017). Most sentational lines, consistently purveying positive images of
major grant-making organizations in the United States mirror work, devotion to the communist party and class conscious-
this orientation and therefore influence the scope and direction ness. From a Soviet political perspective, everything in life was
of the arts. For example, in a recent address, Darren Wheeler of expected to serve a purpose, to be functional, and art was no
the Ford Foundation reluctantly argued: exception. Its aim was to portray the ideal of a society orga-
nized around communist principles. As Georgi Plekhanov, a
Listen to the United States Bureau of Economic Analysis. If the Marxist theoretician, stated:
issue is jobs, the arts and culture sector employed 4.8 million
people in 2014. If the issue is trade, our arts and culture sector There can be no doubt that art acquired a social significance only in
produces a trade surplus. And if the issue is the economy, just so far as it depicts, evokes, or conveys actions, emotions and events
remember that the arts contributed more than $730 billion to our that are of significance to society. (Schwartz, 1980, p. 110)
economy in a single year. (Walker, 2017, p. 1)
Socialist realism enjoyed relatively few supporters outside
The more the arts are generally accepted as investments for Eastern Europe, China, and a few other nations. It is often
achieving defined social goals—say, reducing social inequality dismissed as propaganda, given its intentional ties to the
or even creating new sources of employment like crafts pro- advancement of government ideology. It is a clear and eligible
duction—the less we value “art for art’s sake” or even the target for criticism of this kind, especially when accompanied
quality of artistic products. Hull House carried out an interest- by the strict repression of all other artistic styles, as was the
ing experiment in this regard. Initially, like many of her social case in the Soviet Union and the Soviet republics during the
reform–minded peers in 19th-century England, Jane Addams Stalin era. However, to a less systematic degree, all govern-
saw art as a way of creating new jobs for immigrant women. ments have exploited the potential of art to strengthen political
This experiment did not prove successful. identity and to paper over social ills. One intriguing illustration
Addams’s colleague Ellen Gates Starr tried another option, is the endorsement by local governments in the United King-
which was also popular in that era—seeing art as a way of reliev- dom of numerous art and architecture projects in deteriorated
ing the barrenness of poverty and perhaps creating hope (Stankie- urban neighborhoods, with the object of renewing community
wicz, 1989). She believed the display of traditional art works in an life, of changing the image of run-down areas, even of improv-
environment of architectural splendor would “uplift” and connect ing employment. The results were generally seen as disappoint-
displaced and migrant populations to the “best” forms and expres- ing and were attacked as an effort by the government to conceal
sions of society. Today, critics would perhaps describe this form worsening economic conditions by literally painting them over.
of art appreciation as a pathway to cultural assimilation. When does art become propaganda? This question was
Certainly, in more current language, the arts continue to be recently explored by Sheryl Tuttle Ross in the Journal of Aes-
imagined as a means of increasing community participation, thetic Education. She identifies four characteristics of a message
empowering individuals, fostering inclusion, and promoting that she sees as fundamental to propaganda: It is intended to
rebirth in distressed communities (Sharp et al., 2005). However exert influence by a socially organized group or political insti-
appealing this vision may be, from this rationale, the arts remain tution; it is directed at a large and important target audience; and
a tool, an instrument for improving social relationships and eco- it is designed to redirect or to confront others’ thoughts (Ross,
nomic activity. Subjugated to this end, the debates about what is 2002). Ross considers most definitions of propaganda as much
great or what is good in art fall to the wayside. too narrow, emphasizing the importance of the propagandist’s
own beliefs and the context in which propaganda is developed.
She stresses that art has been used for centuries to disseminate
messages to the public, messages that offer new interpretations
Art as Driver of Political and Ideological
of old ideas or that seek to alter people’s perceptions. Because art
Commitment appeals to emotion and not necessarily to truth, it is a logical
Art as a reflection of political ideology and government policy medium. Ross therefore underlines the importance of assessing
aims has a long tradition in Western and Eastern societies alike. art in terms of both the circumstances under which it is produced
Possibly the most conspicuous and sustained example in and the way in which it is used by those to whom it is directed.
692 Research on Social Work Practice 29(6)

Quo Vadis? American Dance Therapy Association. (n.d.). Retrieved June 10,
2017, from https://adta.org/
There are some generalizations that can be made in bringing American Music Therapy Association. (n.d.). Retrieved June 10,
together the ideas presented thus far. The convergence between 2017, from http://www.musictherapy.org/about/musictherapy/
the interests of artists and social workers has been underscored Art. (n.d.). Retrieved June 10, 2017, from https://www.merriam-web
in several ways—as a common connection to creativity, as ster.com/dictionary/art
investment in social and cultural policy, as an instrument of Badiou, A., & Toscano, A. (2005). Handbook of inaesthetics. Stan-
government ideology and control, and as congenial fellow tra- ford, CA: Stanford University Press.
velers in the healing professions. It is conceivable that social Dyer, G., & Hunter, E. (2009). Creative recovery: Art for mental
workers and artists could band together, if they chose, around health’s sake. Australasian Psychiatry, 17, S146–S150.
all of these opportunities for collaboration, joint educational England, H. (1986). Social work as art: Making sense for good prac-
projects, program development, and evaluation. However, that tice. London, England: Allen & Unwin.
course of action—or, rather, inaction—leaves both fields in the Freidson, E. (1988). Professional powers: A study of the institutiona-
same inchoate relationship they presently enjoy. lization of formal knowledge. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
A new vision of the social work profession in the academic Press.
environment might embrace three pillars to support research, ser- Gray, M., & Webb, S. A. (2008). Social work as art revisited. Inter-
vice, and education. The first pillar is science, including training national Journal of Social Welfare, 17, 182–193. doi:10.1111/
in the social sciences, critical thinking and scientific reasoning, j.1468-2397.2008.00548
concepts of evidence, scientific research methods, and evidence- Helguera, P. (2012). Education for socially engaged art: Materials
based practices. The second pillar might be social innovation, and techniques handbook. New York, NY: Jorge Pinto Books.
which is conceptually linked to business, engineering, economics, Land, H. M. (2015). Spirituality, religion, and faith in psychotherapy:
technology, and modern communications theory. Because the Evidence-based expressive methods for mind, brain, and body.
unending mission of social workers is change in social policy, Chicago, IL: Lyceum Books.
communities, and social relationships, a social innovation per- Lock, A., & Strong, T. (2010). Social constructionism: Sources and
spective might significantly strengthen the capacity of the profes- stirrings in theory and practice. New York, NY: Cambridge Uni-
sion to exert influence within and outside traditional domains. The versity Press.
third pillar could be the arts or the shared artistic experience, with Richardson, W. J. (2003). Heidegger through phenomenology to
content linked to the humanities, phenomenology, techniques for thought (4th ed.). New York, NY: Fordham University Press.
the creative discovery of meaning in individual and group rela- Ross, S. T. (2002). Understanding propaganda: The epistemic merit
tionships, neuroscience, new methods of evaluation, and further model and its application to art. Journal of Aesthetic Education,
investigation into the role of the arts in healing and beyond. Ima- 36, 16–30.
gining the field of social work built upon these pillars opens up Schwartz, L. H. (1980). Marxism and culture. Port Washington, NY:
remarkable possibilities for rethinking how the profession relates Kennikat Press.
to traditional partners and to partners yet undiscovered. Sharp, J., Pollock, V., & Paddison, R. (2005). Just art for a just city:
Author’s Note Public art and social inclusion in urban regeneration. Urban
Studies, 42, 1001–1023.
This article was authored as part of the Arts & Social Work Round-
Smith, C. (1999). The contribution of arts and sports to combating
table held at the Islandwood Conference Center on Bainbridge Island
convened on June 19–20, 2017. social exclusion; A Speech by the Secretary of State for Culture,
Media and Sport as cited in Belfiore, E. (2002). Art as a means of
Declaration of Conflicting Interests alleviating social exclusion: Does it really work? A critique of
The author declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to instrumental cultural policies and social impact studies in the
the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. UK. International journal of Cultural Policy, 8, 91–106.
Stankiewicz, M. A. (1989). Art at Hull-House: 1889–1901 Jane
Funding Addams and Ellen Gates Starr. Woman’s Art Journal, 10, 35–39.
The author received no financial support for the research, authorship, Taylor & Francis Foundation for Art and Healing. (2017). Retrieved
and/or publication of this article. from http://artandhealing.org/our-history/
Walker, D. (2017). The art of democracy: Creative expression and
ORCID iD American greatness. Retrieved from http://www.fordfoundatio
Marilyn L. Flynn https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9075-9621 n.org/library/speeches/the-art-of-democracy-creative-expression-
and-american-greatness
References Walton, K. (1997). Review of art and the aesthetic. Philosophical
About the American Art Therapy Association. (n.d.). Retrieved June Review, 86, 97–101.
10, 2017, from https://arttherapy.org/aata-aboutus/ What We Do [Pamphlet]. (2017). National Endowment for the Huma-
Adajian, T. (2016). The definition of art. The Stanford encyclopedia of nities. Retrieved from https://www.neh.gov/files/whatwedo.pdf
philosophy. Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/ Wheelwright, V. (2000). A profession in the future? Discussion doc-
sum2016/entries/art-definition/ ument. Futures, 32, 913–918.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen