Sie sind auf Seite 1von 7

The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences

[PP: 69-75]
Peyman Amanolahi Baharvand
Department of English Language and Literature
Islamic Azad University, North Tehran Branch
Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT
This paper traces the impossibility of the fulfillment of the American dream for African-
Americans in August Wilson‟s Fences. It examines why Troy Maxon, as the protagonist of the play,
is not able to fulfill his dreams of freedom, and economic achievements in an environment of
oppression where he finds himself surrounded by hostile whites who hinder his development. It
indicates that the racial discrimination, manifested in various forms including racial segregation
prevalent in the white-dominated American society, impedes Troy‟s progress. A large number of
African-Americans migrated from southern states to the north in 1920s and 1930s in order to find
jobs in industrial northern states. They had been told that the United States was the promised land of
equal chances wherein everyone regardless of race and gender was able to progress from rags to
riches. They left the South, in which racism was still pervasive despite the abolition of slavery, and
moved to the North for the fulfillment of the dreams they had been promised. The advocates of the
American Dream claimed that hard diligence and intelligence could lead a man to material
prosperity. Nevertheless, this paper demonstrates that since African-Americans are considered to be
„„others‟‟ in the white dominated society, financial progress and other aspects of the American
Dream remain impossible dreams for them.
Keywords: The American Dream, Baseball, Negro, Racism, Slave, Fences
ARTICLE The paper received on Reviewed on Accepted after revisions on
INFO 21/09/2017 14/10/2017 17/12/2017
Suggested citation:
Baharvand, P. (2017). The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences. International Journal
of English Language & Translation Studies. 5(4). 69-75.

1. Introduction United States, by European traders in the


August Wilson (1945-2005) was a 1620s. Since African slaves were well-
prominent African-American playwright built and strong individuals for whose
who wrote 15 plays for which he won labor no wage was required, the idea of
many awards. To name only a few of the slavery was of great financial benefits for
prizes Wilson won, one can refer to a slaveholders. Though it is impossible to
Pulitzer Prize and a Tony Award for his think of the exact number, roughly six to
play Fences, and a second Pulitzer Prize seven million slaves were imported to the
for The Piano Lesson. Wilson is generally New World during the seventeenth and
referred to as a dramatist who concentrated eighteenth centuries. African slaves
on the sufferings of African-Americans in worked mainly on cotton, tobacco and rice
his plays. He intended to depict the lands. Every slaveholder possessed on
wretched life of a neglected race in the average fifty slaves who worked in
United States in order to draw the attention extremely wretched conditions. They were
of social reformers throughout the world to hindered from education and other
these miserable people. Fences is the best preliminary social rights. Moreover, most
play in which he portrays this suffering. As of black women were subject to sexual
Wilson's masterpiece, Fences is a play in harassment by their white masters who
which the author foregrounds the troubles took sexual liberty with them. No slave
of an African-American family who fails family could feel secure, because
to fulfill their dream of success and slaveholders did not hesitate to disintegrate
happiness despite the diligence and these families in order to sell them to other
constant efforts of Troy Maxon, the head masters.
of the household. American slaveholders did not face
The first group of African slaves were serious challenges until the
brought to the New World, later to be the accomplishment of American Revolution
International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies (www.eltsjournal.org) ISSN:2308-5460
Volume: 05 Issue: 04 October-December, 2017

in 1183. Many of the northern leaders one of the bloodiest wars in the history of
associated with this revolution opposed the United States. The casualties exceeded
slavery on the basis that it was 600,000 warriors. The war was extremely
incongruous to the constitution of the destructive but black people were satisfied
United States that acknowledged freedom with the result, because the North won the
and equality. They asserted that slavery battle. That is to say, those who defended
was immoral and unethical. After all, slavery were severely defeated.
northern states were mostly industrial ones Consequently, slavery was formally
and unlike southern states did not depend abolished as the 13th Amendment to the
on agriculture and farm crops. As a matter U.S. constitution was enacted in 1865.
of fact, slavery was never widespread in Freed slaves had been supposedly
the North. Consequently, no significant released from wretchedness of life by the
objection against newly formed abolitionist end of slavery, but there was yet a long
movement rose up in the North. Abolition distance to be taken before gaining full
of slavery would evoke an economic crisis citizenship in a country in which many
in the southern states that depended white people were still hostile towards
entirely on the labor of African slaves. blacks. African-Americans like Troy
Therefore, they intensely resisted the Maxson‟s father expected a world full of
freedom of black slaves. options; nevertheless, their hopes were
The Congress of the United States frustrated. They received the right to attend
banned slavery in 1808, but no southern schools and the right to vote but white
state obeyed this law. This law gave rise to oppression was too strong to wane in a few
more and more abolitionist movements. decades even. Racist groups such as the Ku
Many authors served as social reformers Klux Klan never stopped the murder of
and attempted to enlighten their audiences blacks. The former black slaves who found
through the portrayal of sympathetic black themselves among millions of antagonistic
characters. The most prominent author whites in southern stares began to migrate
who reacted against slavery was Harriet to the North where they were supposed to
Beecher Stowe (1811-1896) whose find jobs and better conditions of life in
monumental novel, Uncle Tom’s Cabin industrial states. Nearly eight million
(1852) was a fatal blow to white African-American moved to the North
slaveholders. A lot of fugitive slaves were during the Great Migration. They had fled
assisted to escape northern states by the from the aggression and brutality imposed
strategy of “underground railway”. It was on them by white masters. However, these
conducted neither under the ground nor miserable people realized that they had not
through the railway system. However, escaped inequality and racial
since railway terms were used in this discrimination.
system it got the so-called name. For 2. Review of Literature
instance, those who helped the slaves flee Wilson‟s Fences has been subject to a
to the North; and the secret houses used in variety of critical articles that sought to
this system as shelters were called examine the play based on distinct
“conductor” and “station” respectively. theories. Kiffer (2017) argues that Troy
More than 1000 slaves escaped by the aid Maxon‟s predicament results from the fact
of both white individuals and freed slaves. that he is a black individual. He holds that
The election of Abraham Lincoln blackness is a burden that worsened the
(1809-1865) in 1861 reinforced the gap misery of the poor in the United States in
between the North and the south, because 1930s and 1940s. Kiffer adds that African-
he was absolutely against slave trade and American characters in Fences are in
uncompromisingly argued against it. search of their identity despite the fact that
Furthermore, the economic, social and the country in which they reside has
political discrepancies between the North robbed them of their cultural heritage.
and the south contributed to the Abdelsamie and Abdallah (2015) state
intensification of this gap. One of the that Wilson is concerned, in Fences, with
major debates between the two hostile exhibiting black experience in order to
sides was the political autonomy arouse the community's awareness with
demanded by southern states. The North regard to the plight of African-Americans.
advocated a federal government but the They also maintain that black characters in
south urged for more freedom for states. A Fences are in quest of rediscovering their
war was inevitable in such circumstances. lost identity. Likewise, self-realization and
The American Civil War (1861-1865) was "self-authentication" are significant

Cite this article as: Baharvand, P. (2017). The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences.
International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies. 5(4). 69-75.
Page | 70
The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences Peyman Amanolahi Baharvand

purposes pursued by black characters in later when Troy is fourteen years old. Troy
the play. According to Abdelsamie and forsakes the family out of misery. He
Abdallah, African-Americans in Fences intends to migrate to northern states in
endeavor to overcome their limitations in order to find more options in the industrial
the racist American society by recovering North.
their Africanness, and also through Troy expects to be granted full
recognizing their cultural roots. citizenship in the North, where black
Sayni (2017). holds that Wilson people were supposed to have satisfactory
indicates the silenced voices of African- jobs. He is not a criminal upon his arrival
Americans in Fences. He refers to Wilson to the North. Troy goes to northern states
as a competent and gifted playwright who with good intentions. He is going to escape
adequately delineates the suffering and destitution, find a good job and recover
marginalization of black characters in from all the racial inequalities imposed on
Fences. According to Sayni, Wilson also him in the South. Nevertheless, all his
leaves room for a promising future hopes are frustrated upon her arrival to the
awaiting African-Americans provided that new settlement. Troy realizes that
they maintain their integrity and continue regardless of being in the North or the
to resist the limitations imposed on them South, he is doomed to fail in that he is a
by the white society. “Negro”. The burden of blackness
3. Discussion exacerbates his poverty even in the
This paper seeks to examine the industrial areas of the Unites Stares where
representation of African-Americans a lot of factories exist that might provide
characters' suffering in Wilson's Fences. jobs for freed blacks. Complaining about
Wilson tries to contextualize black his misery even after his migration to the
characters in the white dominated society North, Troy Maxon refers to the hardship
in order to show that the fulfillment of the of lie after migration:
American Dream remains only a dream for I walked on down to Mobile and
black people in a society in which racism hitched up with some of them fellows that
is a great obstacle limiting their was heading this way. Got up here and
achievements. The questions that ought to found out … not only couldn‟t you get a
be answered concern the possibility of job; you couldn‟t find no place to live. I
success for colored characters in Fences. thought I was in freedom. Shhh. Colored
Do they have any chance to promote their folks living down there on the riverbanks
status through attempting the requirements in whatever kind of shelter they could find
of the American Dream? Do they have for themselves. Right down there under the
their own voice in the society? Can they Brady Street Bridge. Living in shacks
compete with their white counterpart? made of sticks and tarpaper. Messed
What are the factors that marginalize Troy around there and went from bad to worse.
Maxon? Started stealing. First it was food. Then I
August Wilson dramatizes the figured, hell, if I steal money I can buy me
suffering of African-Americans in their some food. Buy me some shoes too! One
struggle to improve the wretched thing led to another. (Wilson, 1986, p. 27)
circumstances of their lives. He depicts The so-called burden of blackness
Troy Maxson‟s life in Fences (1985) as an brings about all sorts of restrictions for
aspirant and wishful African-American Troy. He encounters different kinds of
who fails due to the racial prejudice restrictions that affect his ability to earn
imposed on black people by the society. income. The rate of unemployment among
Troy‟ father is a sharecropper in southern Negros was highly noticeable. Even those
United States. He works for a white who were employed could find no better
landlord to receive a meagre share of the jobs that serving as porters, servants or
crop. Having ten children, he cannot make laundresses. Apart from unemployment,
the both ends meet in such an unfair substandard residence was a major
situation. He is not able to afford even problem for African-Americans. They had
food for his children. Harshness of life to live in ghettos, slum areas where colored
among hostile whites, and absolute individuals lived segregated from white
destitution turn him to a “devil” whose people. Ghettos, also called “black
brutal behavior leads to the disintegration bottom” neighborhoods were densely
of his family. Troy‟s mother flees to rid populated. Despite the low quality of life
herself from the savagery of a wicked in ghettos, poor black tenants had to pay
husband. Another escape occurs six years high rents. A lot of black people were

International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies (www.eltsjournal.org) ISSN:2308-5460


Volume: 05 Issue: 04 October-December, 2017
Page | 71
International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies (www.eltsjournal.org) ISSN:2308-5460
Volume: 05 Issue: 04 October-December, 2017

forced to rethink the moral values they had vehicle to control colored people. That is
learned from the Bible. The result was to say. It persuades them to do what the
higher rates of criminal activities and ruling class and factory owners want.
immorality. Penurious Negroes, like Troy Obviously, despite the claim that America
Maxson, who had come to the North with is the land of equal opportunities, not
good intentions turned to robbery to escape everybody has had an equal chance to rise
starvation. Consequently, prisons were from rags to riches. The promise of a
filled with Negros. Meanwhile, Troy kills a comfortable life that comes after rigorous
white man in one of his attempts to steal perseverance and hard work, is not
money: applicable to Troy Maxon and his sons in
Now I got to worry about feeding you that they are considered inferior members
and her. Got to steal three times as much. of the American society whose cheap labor
Went out one day looking for somebody to in factories expedites the production of
rob … that‟s what I was, a robber. I‟ll tell wealth for white American. Nevertheless,
you the truth. I‟m ashamed of it today. But Troy and other black people in August
it‟s the truth. Went to rob this fellow, Wilson‟s Fences even do not have the
pulled out my knife and he pulled out a chance to work as low-paid laborers in a
gun. Shot me in the chest. It felt just like society permeated by injustice and racial
somebody had taken a hot branding iron prejudice.
and laid it on me. When he shot me I Troy and his sons, Lyons and Cory,
jumped at him with my knife. They told confront everywhere in the seemingly
me I killed him and they put me in the propitious society the promising motto of
penitentiary and locked me up for fifteen high incomes and economic security.
years. (ibid p. 27) These slogans seem primarily appealing to
Troy and Bono are imprisoned as the an industrious and strong man like Troy,
result of the crimes they did not willingly but he is finally disillusioned with the
commit. Having no job to handle their American Dream when racial
lives, they begin to steal. They live in a discrimination turns out to be a stubborn
country that was supposed to be the land of that hampers his progress. No African-
equal opportunities, yet they have to American in Fences is able to escape the
tolerate different forms of racial tragic and deleterious consequences of the
discrimination. Troy's failure can be black color of the skin. The burden of
associated with the failure of the American blackness exacerbates the financial
Dream. James Truslow Adams (1878- problems of already destitute Troy Maxon.
1949) was the first major American author August Wilson depicts in the context of his
who used the phrase, the America Dream, play the inaccessibility of a dream the
in his 1931 book Epic of America (1931). basic tenets of which rest on false slogans.
He stated in his prominent book that the Referring to the flaws of the American
American Dream is "that dream of a land Dream, Jennifer Hochschild (1995)
in which life should be better and richer questions its principles as follows:
and fuller for everyone, with opportunity The first tenet, that everyone can
for each according to ability or participate equally and can always start
achievement" (p. 214). Moreover, Adams over, is troubling to the degree that it is not
insists that this dream is not limited to the true. It is, of course, never true in the
pursuit of material prosperity: strongest sense; people cannot shed their
It is not a dream of motor cars and high existing selves as snakes do their skin. So
wages merely, but a dream of social order the myth of the individual mini-state of
in which each man and each woman shall nature is just that—a fantasy to be sought
be able to attain to the fullest stature of but never achieved. (p. 26).
which they are innately capable, and be Hochschild holds that the American
recognized by others for what they are, Dream is a matter that pertains merely to
regardless of the fortuitous circumstances white Americans. She believes that this
of birth or position." (ibid p. 215) dream is an impossible fantasy for African-
Most American people have always Americans in that they have always been
considered the American Dream not only considered as second-class citizens. The
as a slogan that says every individual has inferior position of Troy Maxon, who is a
the right to get wealthy but also as an garbage collector, proves the failure of the
ideology. This ideology promises equal American Dream in the United States.
chances for every person to fulfill his Troy comes to believe that success does
dream. Nevertheless, it functions as a not necessarily results from hard work in a

Cite this article as: Baharvand, P. (2017). The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences.
International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies. 5(4). 69-75.
Page | 72
The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences Peyman Amanolahi Baharvand

society in which black people are star, that he definitely deserves, Troy
paralyzed by racism. No black character in becomes a garbage collector. He dwells in
Fences can succeed based on his/her an environment of oppression that imposes
volition and diligence. All of these segregation. Troy‟s unfulfilled dream
character have the scars of slavery on their resembles the “deferred dream” elaborated
bodies. The misery of wretched People like in Langston Hughes‟s famous poem in
Troy and his family is best described by which the poet imagines the dreams of
Langston Hughes, one of the most African-Americans drying up, stinking or
prominent African-American poets, in his exploding.
monumental poem titled “Let America Be Troy‟s exclusion from baseball league
America Again (1994)”: is rooted in the institutionalized racism that
I am the Negro bearing slavery's scars. is supported by a set of laws entitled Jim
I am the immigrant clutching the hope I seek Crow Laws. Jim Crow was a black
And finding only the same old stupid plan minstrel character in American minstrel
Of dog eat dog, of mighty crush the weak. shows who was depicted as a decrepitude
I am the farmer, bondsman to the soil. Negro wearing shabby clothes. Later on
I am the worker sold to the machine.
Lim Crow became a pejorative name for a
I am the Negro, servant to you all.
I am the people, humble, hungry, mean set of rules imposing racial segregation on
Hungry yet today despite the dream. African-Americans. Numerous speeches
Beaten yet today--O, Pioneers! were made to support these laws. These
I am the man who never got ahead, speeches included harsh critiques of
The poorest worker bartered through the interracial marriages that could lead to “the
years (p. 189-190) mongrelization of the white race.” These
Langston Hughes depicts the affliction laws reinforced the restrictions imposed on
of African-Americans who remained in colored people and relegated them to
chain even after the eradication of slavery. inferior jobs. Jim Crow laws held that
As a gifted baseball player with a muscular white people were superior to Negros in all
body, Troy Maxon expects to fulfill his aspects including morality. Hence, sexual
promised dream in baseball but it turns out intercourse between whites and blacks
to be a futile dream. The proponents of the would result in the impurity of the white
American Dream held that everyone who race. Having seen his dreams turned into
works diligently and utilizes his/her nightmare because of such laws, Troy
intelligence will have the chance to realize complains bitterly about his exclusion
his dreams. Gender and race were not form the professional baseball league:
supposed to prohibit anyone with regard to I done seen a hundred niggers play
the fulfillment of this dream. It is on the baseball better than Jackie Robinson. Hell, I
basis of such a dream that Troy Maxson know some teams Jackie Robinson couldn‟t
endeavors to play in Baseball Major even make! What you talking about Jackie
League. He finds the accomplishment of Robinson. Jackie Robinson wasn‟t nobody.
his American dream in the pursuit of sport I‟m talking about if you could play ball then
they ought to have let you play. Don‟t care
in professional level. Nevertheless, all his
what color you were. Come telling me I come
hopes are frustrated as he comes to know along too early. If you could play … then
that unlike what had been promised, this they ought to have let you play. (Wilson,
dream is not attainable for everyone. 1986, P. 7)
Troy is the embodiment of a failed Troy denigrates both white and black
African-American who has been baseball players in this scene. More than
disillusioned with the possibility of success twenty-five years have passed since Troy‟s
in a society in which black people deprived failure to play in the white league and now
of their social rights. He finds it impossible black players are allowed to play in the
to break the color barriers, hence, is professional league after the abolition of
hindered from any kind of success. Troy Jim Crow Laws. Jackie Robinson was the
goes to the north in order to become an first African-American who managed to
urban citizen able to fulfill his dream play in the Major League. He refers to his
through diligence. Nonetheless, he turns own talent which he was not permitted to
out to be a thief who commits murder. He demonstrate in the professional league.
becomes a professional player of baseball Likewise, he does not allow Cory to play
during his residence in prison but is football. Troy contends that no significant
excluded from the Major League due to change has happened in the society despite
racial discrimination. Instead of playing in some visible signs.
the professional baseball league as a super

International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies (www.eltsjournal.org) ISSN:2308-5460


Volume: 05 Issue: 04 October-December, 2017
Page | 73
International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies (www.eltsjournal.org) ISSN:2308-5460
Volume: 05 Issue: 04 October-December, 2017

Moreover, owning a magnificent house thwarted in their aspirations to fulfill their


comprises a major part of the American dreams due to their blackness. Troy and
Dream, but Troy is ashamed of the house Bono represent all those African-
in which he lives throughout the play. He Americans whose lives was full of missed
owes his shabby house, which is not possibilities despite their undeniable
relevant to the ones described in the capabilities. He relies on the possibility of
American Dream, to his disabled brother, the American Dream to rise from rags to
Gabriel who receives a pension from the riches, but the racial inequality prohibited
army after he became disable in the war. their progress and relegated them to
Not only is he not able to play in the inferior positions. Therefore, Fences might
professional baseball league, Troy cannot a be considered a critique of the American
house. Troy is so destitute that he cannot Dream.
even afford a television. Cory, Troy‟s As a young man, Troy aspires to be a
teenage son, regrets the lack of a television professional athlete in the Major League.
frequently; but his father reminds him that He has always heard about the possibility
repairing the damaged roof of their house of advancement in a country that is
is prior to buying a TV. supposedly the land of equal opportunities.
Hence, as mentioned before, as the Therefore, he strives to realize American
embodiment of a diligent African- Dream through putting his talent into
American, Troy Maxon fails to realize his practice. Nevertheless, the scars of slavery
dreams. It might be more accurate, are not healed even after its abolition. The
however, to assert that the society fails to color of his skin keeps him away from the
provide Troy and other black characters fulfillment of his dream in a society in
with any opportunity, if not equal which the authorities propagate the false
opportunities when compared with the ideology of the American Dream. This
whites, with regard to their advancement. dream remains out of reach and turns to a
As discussed above, the color of skin is a nightmare for black people despite all their
major determinant in Troy's social life. attempts.
Despite the fact that he endeavors to excel References
his white peers, the rules and conventions Adams, J. (1931). The Epic of America.
of the racist society ruin his exceptional Boston: Little Brown and Company.
talent as a basketball player let alone to Abdelsamie, A. M., & Abdallah A. M.
letting him rise from rags to riches, as a lot (2015). The Image of the Afro-
of white Americans did. American in Fences. Global Journal of
The findings of this paper confirm Arts Humanities and Social Sciences.
Kafir's argument concerning the suffering 3(3), 73-86.
of black characters in Fences, for he Bloom, H. (2009). Bloom’s Modern
contends that the burden of blackness is Critical Views: August Wilson. New
the most significant barrier that contributes York: Bloom‟s Literary Criticism.
to the marginalization of a character like Elam, H. (2004). The Past as Present in
Troy. Moreover, Abdelsamie and the Drama of August Wilson. Ann
Abdallah's critical arguments with regard Arbor: Michigan University Press.
to Wilson's perfect depiction of the misery Elkins, M. (1994). August Wilson: A
of black people was also corroborated in Casebook. New York and London:
this paper. That is to say, Wilson Garland.
successfully manages to raise public Hochschild, J. (1995). Facing Up to the
awareness throughout the world American Dream: Race, Class and the
concerning the wretchedness of black Soul of the Nation. Princeton: Princeton
people's lives under severe racism. University press.
Nevertheless, rarely an evidence can be Hughes, L. (1994). “Let America Be
found in the play to suggest that black America Again”. In: Drampresad, A.
character can adequately rediscover their and Rossel, D. (Eds). The Collected
lost cultural heritage. Poems of Langston Hughes. New York:
4. Conclusion Vintage Books.
August Wilson portrays the struggle of Kiffer, Meredih. (2017, 2,2). August
African-Americans to survive among white Wilson: The Search for Black Identity
racists. He intends to show that “there is no and Social Standing in 20th Century
avenue for the participation” of black America. Retrieved from
people in the society. Ambitious and https://augustwilsonblog.files.wordpress
talented “Negros” like Troy Maxson are .com.

Cite this article as: Baharvand, P. (2017). The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences.
International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies. 5(4). 69-75.
Page | 74
The Failure of the American Dream in August Wilson's Fences Peyman Amanolahi Baharvand

Koprjnce, S. (2006). Baseball as History Shannon, S. (2003). August Wilson’s


and Myth in August Wilson's Fences. Fences: A Reference Guide. London:
African American Review, 40: 349-358. Greenwood Press.
Menson-Furr, L. (2008). August Wilson’s Williams, D, and Sandra G. (2004). August
Fences. New York: Continuum Wilson and Black Aesthetics. New
International Publishing Group. York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Pereira, K (1995). August Wilson and the Truslow Adams, James. (1931). Epic of
African-American Odyssey. Urbana and America. London: Transaction
Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Publishers.
Pirnajmuddin, H, and ShirinSharar T. Wilson, A. (1986). Fences. New York:
(2011). Space in August Wilson‟s Plume Press.
Fences. Studies in Literature and Wolfe, Peter. (1999). August Wilson. New
Language, 3: 42-47. York: Twayne Publishers.
Sayni, K. (2017). The Drama of August
Wilson: Fencin a New Identity in
African American Theatrical
Imagination. International Journal of
Advanced Research. 5(1), 1571-1578.

International Journal of English Language & Translation Studies (www.eltsjournal.org) ISSN:2308-5460


Volume: 05 Issue: 04 October-December, 2017
Page | 75

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen