Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Year 8
Paul Kelly
‘Winter Coat’
We were lovers once long ago
Walking through cold city streets like lovers do
Stopped inside a market
Kissed behind a stall
Someone said you'd better move on
If you're not buying at all
My winter coat
My winter coat
My winter coat
My winter coat
Analysis of ‘Winter Coat’
1. Dramatic situation
Who is the speaker?
To whom is he or she speaking? What is the situation?
2. Summary
Write a one to three sentence summary of the song, include both explicit
and implicit meanings. (This exercise should help you focus in on the
central idea of the song.)
3. Figurative language
Point out any examples of personification, simile, metaphor, metonymy,
or allusion. Explain (briefly) how these examples contribute to (or fail to
contribute to) the effectiveness of the song.
4. Literary techniques
Point out and explain any symbols.
5. Aural Techniques
What are the aural techniques you can identify?
6. Overview
What is the subject of the song? (What is its central focus?)
What is the theme of the song? (What does the song tell you about the
subject?) Explain why the theme is universal or specific.
What personal insights, feelings, or comments do you have about the
poem?
Paul Kelly pens ode to Shakespeare and Sherrins
Paul Kelly has broken into verse about his excitement at a new football season, focusing on the
Sherrin. The singer songwriter posted the following on his Facebook page, borrowing from
Shakespeare, and in that spirit we have borrowed from him, because it deserved a wider audience.
"Footy's back! At least for me and my pals in the park," Kelly wrote. "We start the year with a new
football. And a new football's worth a new poem. So with a little help from Shakespeare's Sonnet
60 …
They always came for Bradman 'cause fortune used to hide in the palm of his hand
Summer 1932 and Captain Douglas had a plan
When Larwood bowled to Bradman it was more than man to man
And staid Adelaide nearly boiled over as rage ruled over sense
When Oldfield hit the ground they nearly jumped the fence
Now Bill Woodill was as fine a man as ever went to wicket
And the bruises on his body that day showed that he could stick it
But to this day he's still quoted and only he could wear it
"There's two teams out there today and only one of them's playing cricket."
Now shadows they grow longer and there's so mush more yet to be told
But we're not getting any younger, so let the part tell the whole
Now the players all wear colours, the circus is in town
I can no longer go down there, down to that sacred ground
Analysis of ‘Bradman’
Have you ever seen Kings Cross when the rain is falling soft?
I came in on the evening bus, from Oxford Street I cut across
And if the rain don't fall too hard everything shines just like a postcard
Everything goes on just the same
Fair-weather friends are the hungriest friends
I keep my mouth well shut, I cross their open hands
...here was a song about exile and regret, perennial themes of folk music, yet rooted in the here
and now of a contemporary Australian setting. Other songwriters had used local reference
points before, as anyone who had heard Cold Chisel or Skyhooks (or Slim Dusty or Banjo
Paterson) could tell you. But 'From St Kilda To Kings Cross' had the protean lyrical detail of
experience actually lived, dropping you instantly into a wholly realised world.
The song's 14 lines sketched a tale of its narrator leaving Melbourne for Sydney, swapping one
seedy red-light district for another, arriving in soft rain to see the streets shining like a postcard,
only to discover that 'everything goes on just the same'. His grasping friends circle him
with hands outstretched, and the closing verse finds him longing for the ragged palm trees and
tired vistas of the home he's just left. The closing line—'I'd give you all of Sydney Harbour/
(All that land and all that water)/ For that one sweet promenade'—was a wry
provocation only an Australian could fully appreciate.
The places in the song ground this universal story of fear and longing to Australian specifics as
does the following – a very different view of an Australian city.
‘Adelaide’
8. In this song, Kelly alludes to nursery rhymes. Why do you think he does so?
9. Identify the rhyming pattern of each stanza.
10. How do these changes evoke the persona’s attitude to Adelaide?
11. Read the extracts and then compare these to the song. You may find it useful to build on the
following scaffold.
12. Describe a place, person or event to evoke a strong sense of longing. Limit this to 160 words, making
sure each word choice is used to deliberately capture a sense of place and the feelings associated
with it.
13. Everyone remembers places in different ways. Read the following extracts from two people who
remember Adelaide very differently. Compare these to Kelly’s description in the poem. How are they
similar and how are they different?
I’ve lived in Adelaide for little less than half my life, but it has always been my city. When I was a child,
everyone in my family, like the rest of our small South Australian farming community, referred to
Adelaide as ‘Town’. The word always had an audible capital as though ‘Town’ were Adelaide’s real name;
from the vantage point of the farm, Town was the archetypal metropolis, the place where all human
needs and desires could be met. Town was a place of traffic and bright lights, of department stores,
medical specialists, movies, buses, and the newfangled discount supermarkets where you could buy a
carload of non- perishable groceries in bulk for a fraction of their country cost: three months’ supply of
cornflour and cornflakes, ...crammed into the back of the station wagon for the three-hour drive home.
Town meant the paternal grandparents, the orthodontist, the Royal Adelaide Show, the crowded beaches,
the buying of shoes and winter clothes. Town was where the sporty kids from school went to compete at
higher levels, and where the clever kids went away to do fifth year of high school as sad but stoic
boarders.
... When I remember the Midlands, it is almost always serene, windless and sunlit. It has a kind of
enchantment. Yet I know we arrived in winter, that the frosts and winds can be bleak and bitter. In
contrast, I remember Adelaide in much darker hues. Although I know its reputation as a beautiful,
graceful city, all my memories of it are imbued with the emotional texture of my early childhood. The past
rises up ... distorting my memory of the climate. I spent many blistering, suffocating summers there
visiting our father, my cotton dresses soaked with sweat. Yet when I conjure up a memory of Adelaide it is
always cold, a permanent winter.
This is because my parents split in that dark winter after so many years of turmoil, and we left on a
wintry night.
So this is Life: Scenes from a Country Childhood by Anne Manne Melbourne University
Press, 2009, pp5-6
In Australian texts, this sense of alienation is explored in the attitudes of Europeans to land as something
that needs to be bounded, tamed and exploited – the land is something which is owned. For indigenous
peoples the land is a place of belonging, a place of personal identity. Rather than the land belonging to
them, they belong to the land.
Love for the land and the meaning of it – mutually held but with insightful differences– is at the core of the
music track ‘The Land is Mine/The Land is Me’ within Paul Kelly’s ‘One Night The Moon’. We discover
quickly that stories of the land formation and their cultural and spiritual meaning are at the heart of the
Indigenous culture. This connection to the land and their people’s relationship with it are evoked quite
extensively throughout the course of the film and quite specifically addressed within the music clip.
This song brilliantly encapsulates the differences between Indigenous and white Australian responses and
attitudes to land and landscape. For Jim, the land he has struggled over rightfully belongs to him and he
fiercely announces that the bank ‘‘won’t take it away’’. This is juxtaposed by Albert’s expression ‘This land
is me’ rather than ‘this land is mine’. This emphasises that for Albert, the land is his very being. It embodies
him and his spirit in ways that are evocative but intensely difficult for white people to deeply comprehend
or accept.
Structured like a dialogue, this song contrasts the white farmer’s possessiveness of his farm with the
Indigenous tracker’s conception of the land. While the farmer is worried about making the land productive,
the tracker sees the whole landscape as part of his being. Both speakers share a fear of dispossession.
Questions
1. As you view and listen to the song annotate the script. Underline or highlight anything to do
with a sense of place or feeling displaced.
2. Why do you think Kelly has used to two different voices? What might be the impact of this?
3. What does the title immediately reveal to the reader?
4. What is the tone adopted by the voice in the first two stanzas?
5. What is revealed by the farmer’s references to his land? What effect did fences have on
traditional use of the land?
6. What does the farmer means when he says “I’m working hard just to make it pay”? What
does this further reveal about how the white farmer uses the land?
7. To what does the farmer refer when he says “I signed on the dotted line”?
8. Examine the use of imagery in the next two line: “Campfires on the creek bed / Bank
breathing down my neck.” What is the effect of Kelly juxtaposing these two lines?
9. What does the tracker’s use of language reveal about his relationship with the land?
10. The 4th stanza is the only one beginning with a new line. Why do you think this is?
11. What is the effect of the final three lines of the song (note the repetition)?
12. Describe and explain three visual images that represent the white farmer’s relationship with
the land.
13. Describe and explain three images that represent the separation of the black tracker from
the crowd and his alternative relationship with the land.
‘This Land is Mine/This Land is Me’
THE BACK PADDOCK
DAY
The VOLUNTEERS form up in a rough semi-circle. The FATHER sensing ALBERT's gaze, turns his back
on him to look out across the paddock. He finishes saddling his horse.
FATHER
BACK FENCE
DAY
Meanwhile ALBERT has been grabbing his swag and now walks off in the other direction.
ALBERT
This land is me
VERANDAH
DAY
This land is me
The TRACKER looks back toward the house and sees the MOTHER at the window looking out at him.
VERANDAH
DAY
The MOTHER shuts EMILY's bedroom window, closes the curtains and sits down on the bed.
END OF EXTRACT
MusicArtsDance films
Pty Ltd Writers: John Romeril and Rachel Perkins Director: Rachel Perkins Composers: Mairead Hannan, Kev Carmody and Paul Kelly
Songs about Relationships
‘Careless’
How many cabs in New York City, how many angels on a pin?
How many times did you call my name, knock at the door but you couldn't get in?
I know I've been careless,
I've been wrapped up in a shell, nothing could get through to me
How many cabs in New York City, how many angels on a pin?
How many times did you call my name, knock at the door but you couldn't get in?
How many stars in the milky way, how many ways can you lose a friend?
Analysis of ‘Careless’
1. In pairs, consider each question in lines 1 to 3 one at a time and in order. For each of these
questions, answer the following:
What is the effect of each on the listener?
What is the effect of all of them together?
2. What do you imagine the question: How many angels on a pin means?
3. What is Paul Kelly saying about the persona in the song by using this expression?
4. How does the music and Paul Kelly’s voice capture the punctuation in the song? Consider
5. Each stanza of the song has a similar structure but modifies the pattern as the song
progresses. Graphically represent the structure to demonstrate its development, noting its
repetitions and variations. Compare your representation with others in the class.
6. Listen to the performance again and describe how the music varies for different parts of the
argument.
7. What do you think is the purpose of the persona’s argument in the song? How effective is it?
‘Deep Water’
And the child feels safe, yeah the child feels brave
Well the years hurry by and the woman loves the man
Then one night in the dark she grabs hold of his hand
And the man gets a shiver right up and down his spine
Psalm 23
Psalms are songs of praise and were originally sung. King David, the purported
author, was a poet and musician as well as a warrior and king.
Student activity:
1. Highlight the metaphors in Paul Kelly’s song that are taken directly from the King James’ version of
Psalm 23.
2. What are the differences in the wording of the two texts?
3. Who is speaking in each text? How does this affect the meaning?
4. What is the hymn inviting you to feel? What is the song inviting you to feel?
5. Both texts are strongly metaphorical. Which metaphor is your favourite in each text?
Explain your
choice.
6. What do you think is intended by meeting “in the middle of the air”?
7. How does intertextuality contribute to the effects of this contemporary song?
8. What is the effect of the chorus and its frequent repetition?
Come and meet me in the middle of the air
I will meet you in the middle of the air
2. List five things that Joe will miss while he is away on Christmas Day.
emotion: a
3. Why will Joe miss Roger?
mental state
4. Do you think Joe regrets his crime? Explain your answer. experienced by
humans in reaction
5. What does he not mean to say to Dan? Why does Joe say this? Is this a fair thing to to their thoughts or
say? the external world;
examples include
6. Describe the relationship between Joe and Rita. How does Joe feel about Rita? joy, sadness, fear
What does he think she will do for him? Would you wait for a partner if he or she were sent to prison?
Explain.
7. At the end of the song, Joe declares that he will make gravy again one day. Why do you think Joe cares so
much about making gravy? (Use a dictionary or the internet to find out the connotations of making gravy
8. Joe’s family celebrates Christmas in a particular way. Does his family seem close? Justify your answer by
providing evidence from the song.
9. What do you think Paul Kelly (the songwriter) is trying to say to his audience about family? Does he think
family is important? Explain.
Why are we reading a song about a guy in prison? People’s emotions are complicated. By analysing
this song, you will learn how to comprehend the obvious and hidden meanings in what people say.
This will make you a better judge of character and enable you to
communicate better at home and at work.
[Verse 1]
Hello Dan, it's Joe here
I hope you're keeping well
It's the 21st of December
And now they're ringing the last bells
[Verse 2]
I guess the brothers are driving down from Queensland
And Stella's flying in from the coast
They say it's gonna be a hundred degrees, even more maybe
But that won't stop the roast
[Chorus]
And give my love to Angus
And to Frank and Dolly
Tell 'em all I'm sorry
I screwed up this time