Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
This article reviews research related to living with depression and diabetes
in the post–high school and young-adult periods. Clinical lessons for pedi-
atric and adult diabetes care providers are distilled from this evidence base.
1
tance of striving for better glycemic
who have moved away from their mative choices regarding relationships,
control and more receptiveness to
home town are making these decisions occupations, living arrangements,
improving self-care behaviors. Life
in places removed from their closest and financial and health insurance
partners can be important supports
friends and family and possibly where management.
More specifically, after high school, and agents for change, and a shared
they know very few people.
Arnett suggests that individuals many young people with diabetes face sense of investment in the future will
in this first phase are beginning to the following unique challenges: often catalyze improvements in self-
“explore the possibilities available • Relocation away from their paren- care behaviors.5
to them in love and work and move tal home This later period, when lifelong
gradually toward making enduring • An abrupt change in diabetes patterns of behavior are set, can be
choices. Such freedom to explore care providers, which may involve a crucial window of opportunity for
different options is exciting . . . . transitioning from a pediatric mul- diabetes care and educational inter-
However, it is also a time of anxiety tidisciplinary care paradigm to an ventions. 5 Diabetes care providers
and uncertainty .”2 adult care model and educators have a crucial role at
Arnett suggests that these explora- • A distinct shift in relationships this stage in preparing young people
tions also lead young people to feel with parents and siblings for assuming more self-management
unsettled because they do not yet • A dramatic change in diabe- responsibilities and facilitating their
know where their explorations will tes- speci f ic responsibi l it ies , motivation to achieve improved gly-
lead. For young people who have including managing health insur- cemic control.
Diabetes Spectrum Volume 23, Number 1, 2010 33
Research on Depression in Older Research on Depression in Post– of adolescent and young adult females
Adolescents and Young Adults High School Young People Living with type 1 diabetes in the United
The experience of feeling down or With Diabetes Kingdom acknowledged intentional
“depressed,” which is commonly reduction or omission of insulin to
used to describe occasional times Depression and type 1 diabetes control weight. 27 Rydall et al. 28 also
Evidence regarding the prevalence of followed a group of adolescent females
of feeling stressed, sad, or “blue,” is
psychopathology in adolescents with with type 1 diabetes and found high
often confused with major depressive type 1 diabetes is contradictory, with
disorder (MDD), a serious psychiat- rates of microvascular complications
some studies documenting increased in the young women with disordered
ric condition. Unfortunately, MDD prevalence of psychopathology com-
is a common, debilitating, and often eating behavior.
pared to adolescents in the general
chronic illness. MDD is a medi- In the U.K. longitudinal study, 26
population11–14 and others finding no
cal diagnosis that involves clusters psychiatric disorders including MDD
higher prevalence of psychopathol-
of mental symptoms (e.g., sadness, at baseline predicted higher A1C levels
ogy in adolescents with diabetes than
in the general population of adoles- across the 8-year study period, indicat-
loss of interest, and irritability) and
cents.15,16 Some studies have reported ing that psychiatric disorders including
physical symptoms (e.g., fatigue, sleep
a depression prevalence rate of two to depression during later adolescence
difficulties, and dramatic changes in
three times that in the general popu- significantly influenced glycemic con-
appetite) that occur daily for at least 2
lation of adolescents,17 whereas the trol during the young adult period.16
weeks and significantly impair social, Subsequently, Bryden et al.29 published
occupational, and school functioning, more recent SEARCH for Diabetes
in Youth multicenter study18 reported a report that followed a group of
as well as quality of life. Depression young adults 17–25 years of age dur-
that the incidence of depressed mood
is treatable with medications and/or ing an 11-year period into adulthood.
in adolescence with type 1 diabetes
therapy; however, most people with There was no improvement in glyce-
is no higher than that in the general
depression do not receive even mini- population of healthy adolescents.19 mic control during this period. The
mally adequate treatment.6 The variation among studies of proportion of patients having serious
According to the most recent data the prevalence of depression in ado- complications increased during this
from the National Center for Health lescents with type 1 diabetes may period, and females were more likely
Statistics,6 depression is more common be the result of differences in study than males to have multiple diabetes
in females, non-Hispanic black people, design, diagnostic or screening instru- complications. Psychiatric symptoms
and people living below the poverty ments used, and diagnostic or cut-off in late adolescence and young adult-
line. Unfortunately, rates of depres- criteria employed. 20 However, recent hood predicted psychiatric problems
sion were not reported separately for reports consistently document that later in the cohort. Similar conclusions
the 18- to 30-year-old age-group in the presence of psychopathology in about the continuity of adherence and
these data.6 adolescents with diabetes is associ- glycemic control problems over the
With respect to the continuity of ated with poorer glycemic control21,22 late-adolescent and early-adult years
depression during the transition from and increased incidence of hospital- have been reported by Wysocki et al.30
older adolescent to young adult, Rao izations, 23,24 and this puts them at in a study of 18- to 22-year-old young
increased risk for diabetes-related people with type 1 diabetes.
et al.7 studied only females and docu-
complications.25 In summary, the most recent psy-
mented a continuity of adolescent Longitudinal cohort research of
depression during the transition to chosocial research has documented
Bryden et al.26 in the United Kingdom that post-adolescent patients have
adulthood. Investigators who stud- identified a subgroup of young adults
ied both sexes have estimated that unique and specialized needs with
with disordered eating (insulin misuse respect to their diabetes care during
~ 75% of young adults with psychi- for weight management), especially
atric disorders first had a diagnosis the vulnerable and transitional period
females with type 1 diabetes. This
after high school. Moreover, there is a
between the ages of 11 and 18 years.8,9 disordered eating was strongly related
subgroup of adolescent patients with
More recently, Copeland et al.10 to the development of microvascular
complications and mortality among type 1 diabetes, especially females,
reported that adolescent depression
the young adult females in this cohort. who are at an increased risk for the
significantly predicted young-adult
This 8-year follow up study of a downward cycle of mental health
depression and that this effect was problems (especially disordered eating
accounted for by the comorbidity of cohort of adolescents with diabetes
found that behavioral problems during and eating disorders), poor glyce-
adolescent depression with other seri- mic control, and the development of
ous adolescent psychiatric disorders the adolescent years predicted poorer
glycemic control in young adulthood microvascular complications of diabe-
such as oppositional defiant disorder, tes. Longitudinal follow-up studies of
and a significant increase in serious
substance abuse disorders, and gener- adolescent patients have indicated that
microvascular complications.26
alized anxiety disorder. In summary, During the follow-up evaluation, for this subgroup of young people at
we know that MDD in adolescents 54% of the young adult females were high risk for the interrelated problems
often occurs along with other serious overweight (BMI > 25.0 kg/m 2), up of poor control, psychiatric issues, and
psychiatric disorders and that adoles- from 21% at baseline. Weight gain can diabetes complications, these prob-
cent psychiatric disorders including be an important factor contributing to lems only worsen throughout the late
MDD frequently predict young-adult poor ongoing diabetes self-manage- adolescent and emerging adulthood
disorders. ment and adherence. More than 35% years.
34 Diabetes Spectrum Volume 23, Number 1, 2010
Depression and type 2 diabetes clinical trial called Treatment Options tasks for which the young person
The recent SEARCH study19 docu- in Diabetes Type 2 for Adolescents currently has no responsibility
1
cents with type 2 diabetes should have staged approach to transitioning: both diabetes care and mental health
a high index of suspicion for depres- • About 3 years before a young care providers.
sion. Because depression is associated person’s high school graduation, Mental health specialists can pro-
with higher A1C levels, depression someone on his or her pediatric vide help with diagnosing and treating
treatment may be an important part multidisciplinary diabetes team mental health issues in adolescents
of improving glucose control. It is also should introduce the idea of transi- with diabetes. Adolescents with dia-
important to note that, in addition to a tioning to adult care depending on betes for whom there is any suspicion
higher rate of depression, young peo- the young person’s plans and the of depression should be referred to
ple with type 2 diabetes have lower institution’s policies. (Some pedi- a mental health expert for diagnosis
health-related quality of life scores atric facilities require all patients and, if needed, treatment planning.
than young people without diabetes to transfer to adult care when they In summary, psychiatric dis-
or those with type 1 diabetes.33 reach the age of 18 years; others orders in older adolescents with
Because the higher prevalence of have a more flexible policy for diabetes—especially those with type
type 2 diabetes in adolescence is a continuing to provide care for col- 1 diabetes—predict poor control,
relatively recent phenomenon, there lege-age students.) continued psychiatric problems,
are as yet no longitudinal studies of • At subsequent medical visits, the and health complications from poor
the continuity of depression between pediatric provider should work glycemic control in the young adult
the older-adolescent and young-adult with the parent(s) and young per- years. 26,27 Therefore, it is crucial to
years. However, when the multisite son to identify essential diabetes provide diagnosis and treatment for
Diabetes Spectrum Volume 23, Number 1, 2010 35
depression and other mental health diabetes, early diagnosis and treat- Kovacs M, Goldston D, Obrosky DS, Bonar
11
problems as early as possible for youth ment of depression are imperative for LK: Psychiatric disorders in youths with
IDDM: rates and risk factors. Diabetes Care
with diabetes during the high school optimal health outcomes. 20:36–44, 1997
and post–high school years. In summary, the years following 12
Kovacs M, Obrosky DS, Goldston D,
high school represent a vulnerable Drash A: Major depressive disorder in youths
Lessons From Depression Research developmental period for all youth with IDDM: a controlled prospective study
for Adult Medical Care Providers of that is further complicated by the pres- of course and outcome. Diabetes Care
Young Adults With Diabetes ence of type 1 or type 2 diabetes. Both 20:45–51, l997
Young people with type 1 diabetes pediatric and adult diabetes clinicians 13
Northam EA, Matthews LK, Anderson PJ,
may be transitioning geographically, who care for post – high school-age Cameron FJ, Werther GA: Psychiatric mor-
emotionally, and socially during their youth need to be attentive to the pos- bidity and health outcomes in type 1 diabetes:
post–high school years. It is, therefore, sibility of depression in their patients,
perspectives from a prospective longitudinal
important for their adult diabetes care study. Diabetic Med 22:152–157, 2005
as depression can contribute to a
providers to understand the normative vicious cycle of adverse psychiatric
14
Blanz B, Rensch-Riemann B, Frotz-Sigmunc
demands and distractions these young D, Schmidt MH: IDDM is a risk factor for
and diabetes-related health prob- adolescent psychiatric disorders. Diabetes
people may be confronting that may lems. It is especially important for Care 16:1579–1587, 1993
pose realistic barriers to diabetes care. clinicians caring for post–high school
In Transitions in Care: Meeting Jacobson AM, Hauser ST, Willett JB,
15
youth with diabetes to partner with a Wolfsdorf JI, Dvorak R, Herman L, deGroot
the Challenges of Type 1 Diabetes in
mental health professional who can M: Psychological adjustment to IDDM:
Young Adults, 5 Wolpert et al. point 10-year follow-up of an onset cohort of
provide both diagnosis and treatment
out that the focus of care for type 1 child and adolescent patients. Diabetes Care
for depression.
diabetes may need to be on “ensur- 20:811–818, 1997
ing that the young adult has continued 16
Bryden KS, Peveler RC, Stein A, Mayou
medical follow-up with annual urine References RA, Peveler RC, Fairburn CG, Dunger DB:
microalbumin measurements and Clinical and psychological course of diabetes
1
Arnett JJ: Emerging adulthood: a theory of
dilated eye examinations and coun- from adolescence to young adulthood: a
development from the late teens through the
longitudinal cohort study. Diabetes Care
seling concerning issues such as twenties. Am Psychol 55:469–480, 2000
24:1536–1540, 2001
sick-day management, coping with the 2
Arnett JJ: Emerging Adulthood: The 17
Grey M, Whittemore R, Tamborlane W:
impact of diabetes on relationships, Winding Road From the Late Teens Through
Depression in type 1 diabetes in children:
contraception, smoking, preventing the Twenties. New York, Oxford University
natural history and correlates. J Psychosom
alcohol-induced hypoglycemia, and Press, 2004
Res 53:907–911, 2002
the risks of binge drinking.” Wolpert 3
U.S. Bureau of the Census: Statistical 18
SEARCH for Diabetes in Youth Study
et al. also advise that priority should abstracts of the United States: 2000.
Group: SEARCH for Diabetes in Youth: a
Washington, D.C., U. S. Bureau of the
be given to “establishing a strong Census, 2000
multi-center study of the prevalence, inci-
relationship based on acceptance and dence and classification of diabetes mellitus in
mutual respect to ensure 1) contin-
4
Levinson DJ: The Seasons of Man’s Life. youth. Control Clin Trials 25:458–471, 2004
New York, Knopf, 1986
ued follow-up and 2) influence that 19
Lawrence JM, Standiford DA, Loots B,
over time can be directed to promote
5
Wolpert HA, Anderson BJ, Weissberg- Klingensmith GI, Williams DE, Ruggerio
Benchell J: Transitions in Care: Meeting the A, Liese AD, Bell RA, Waitzfelder BE,
improvements in self-care behavior Challenges of Type 1 Diabetes in Young McKeown RE: Prevalence and correlates of
. . . and that the fundamental role of Adults. Alexandria, Va., American Diabetes depressed mood among youth with diabetes:
the adult health professional in dia- Association, 2009 the SEARCH for Diabetes in Youth Study.
betes care is to serve as the patient’s 6
Pratt LA, Debra JB: Depression in the United
Pediatr 117:1348–1358, 2006
guide in making informed choices States household population, 2005–2006. 20
Dantzer C, Swendsen J, Maruice-Tison
about living with diabetes . . . .”5 The NCHS Data Brief. 7 September 2008. S, Salamon R: Anxiety and depression in
authors conclude by emphasizing that, Available online from www.cdc.gov/nchs/ juvenile diabetes: a critical review. Clinical
because “adolescents and young adults data/databriefs/db07.htm Psychol Review 23:787–800, 2003
are usually very sensitive to issues of 7
Rao U, Hammen C, Daley S: Continuity of 21
Hassan K, Loar R, Anderson BJ, Hptulla
control and personal autonomy, there- depression during the transition to adulthood: RA: The role of socioeconomic status, depres-
a 5-year longitudinal study of young women. sion, quality of life, and glycemic control in
fore, highlighting your recognition J Am Child Adol Psychiatry 38:908–915, type 1 diabetes mellitus. J Pediatr 149:526–
that responsibility and control belong 1999 531, 2006
to the patient can be very helpful in 8
Pine DS, Cohen P, Gurley D, Brook J, Ma 22
Lernmark B, Persson B, Fisher L, Radelius
establishing a collaborative relation- Y: The risk for early-adulthood anxiety and PA: Symptoms of depression are important
ship . . . .”5 depressive disorders in adolescents with to psychological adaptation and metabolic
As is true for pediatric diabetes anxiety and depressive disorders. Arch Gen control in children with diabetes mellitus.
care providers, adult clinicians caring Psychiatry 55:56–64, 1998 Diabetic Med 16:14–22, 1999
for young adults with diabetes must 9
Lewinsohn PNM, Rophde P, Klein DN, Rewers A, Chase HP, Mackenzie T,
23
maintain a high index of suspicion Seeley JR: Natural course of adolescent Walravens P, Roback M, Rewers M,
for depression and develop a relation- major depressive disorder I: continuity into Hamman RF, Klingensmith G: Predictors of
young adulthood. J Am Acad Child Adolesc acute complications in children with type 1
ship with a mental health provider in Psychiatry 38:56–63, 1999 diabetes. JAMA 287:2511–2518, 2002
the community who is experienced
in working with young adults with Copeland WE, Shanahan L, Costello J,
10 24
Stewart SM, Rao U, Emslie GJ, Klein D,
Angold A: Childhood and adolescent psychi- White PC: Depressive symptoms predict
diabetes and depression. Because of atric disorders as predictors of young adult hospitalization for adolescents with type 1
the comorbidity of depression and disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 66:764–772, diabetes mellitus. Pediatrics 115:1315–1319,
physical complications in adults with 2009 2005
36 Diabetes Spectrum Volume 23, Number 1, 2010
25
DCCT Research Group: The effect of inten- tes mellitus. N Engl J Med 336:1849–1854, Varni JW, Burwinkle TM, Jacobs JR,
33
sive diabetes treatment on the development 1997 Gottschalk M, Kaufman F, Jones KL: The
Peds QL in type 1 and type 2 diabetes: reli-