RIYADH METRO PROJECT (RMP)

SUPPLIER/SUBCONTRACT TECHNICAL REVIEW SHEET (STRS)

PO/SO Number M-BCW-1F8000-CMEP-SUB-000003 PO/SO Title Zamil Projects
Supplier Transmittal Ref. BNR-STRAN-001478 STRS Identification M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-TRV-000016 Revision: 002

Transmittal / Document Title MSD - Central Battery System Status Code Code 3

100% Design Package CRS

Document Type SDR SDR Please Select
Code & No. Submission
(Internal) 02
IFC Design Package CRS Number
Date 4/Aug/18 Code & No.
Please Select

Discipline Involved CELD Reviewed by (BACS) Sign

Prepared by (RMTC)
Location 1F8DS0 Reviewed by (RMTC)
Approved by (RMTC) Sign

Disclaimer : Permission to proceed does not constitute acceptance or approval of design details, calculations, analyses, test methods or materials developed or selected by the subcontractor/supplier and does not relieve subcontractor/supplier from full compliance with contractual obligations or
release any "holds" placed on the contract.

BACS Status Codes : 1 - Work may proceed; 2 - Revise and Resubmit. Work may Proceed Subject to Resolution of Indicated Comments; 3 - Revise and resubmit. Work may Not Proceed; 4 – Review Not Required. Work may Proceed; Rejected – Rejected. Work may Not Proceed

RMTC Status Codes : A - Reviewed; Work may proceed; B - Reviewed with comments; Revise & resubmit. Work may proceed subject to incorporation of comments; C - Objection; Revise & resubmit; Work not proceed; D - Rejected; E - Review not required; Work may proceed

Note to Supplier/Subcontractor: Approval coding by BACS is for information only. Final approval to be provided by RMTC.

BACS Review

No. Document Number Rev BACS Comments (Designer, ICE, other) Comments Made by Initial Status Supplier / Fabricator / Subcontractor Response Responded By Revised Status

1 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040300 001 Please Select

Sub-contractor changed to the revit exported layers which is not

2 002 Najib Khneisser Code 3 Noted. The issues related to presentation are improved in this revision
acceptable. This is not the LOD required for the shop drawing.

Noted. Sections were added. But added sections are not

acceptable and do not contain the proper information. In Many sections with the required information had been added in each
3 002 Najib Khneisser Code 3
addition, some section taken are not important, while some floor in order comply with BACS requirments
congested areas have no sections.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040301
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040302 The orange layer is marked as busbar. Howerver, in P03 it
4 002 Najib Khneisser Code 3 Rectified
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040303 represents the Siemens equipment. There is no busbar in P03.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040304
5 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040305 002 The support for the cable trays is not clear on the layouts Najib Khneisser Code 3 Noted. The issues related to presentation are improved in this revision

6 002 All BMS and FA cable trays are to be cable trunks. Najib Khneisser Code 3 Complied

7 002 Cable containment must be coordinated with all MEP services. Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted & Complied

8 002 The text in the drawings need to be clearer. Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted. The issues related to presentation are improved in this revision

Those drawings can be combined with other drawings as follows:

- The containment table should also be found in the calculation
9 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040306 001 sheets. Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted and Complied
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040307 - The cable tray sections can be combined with those in
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040308 drawings 016 and 025.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040309

Form No. : M-BAC-000000-GQ00-FOR-000013 Rev.: 006 Page 1 of 5 08/22/2019

 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040306
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040307
No. M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040308
Document Number Rev BACS Comments (Designer, ICE, other) Comments Made by Initial Status Supplier / Fabricator / Subcontractor Response Responded By Revised Status
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040309

10 001 The text in the drawings is not very clear. Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted. The issues related to presentation are improved in this revision

11
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040310
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040311
12
13
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040312
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040313
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040314
14 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040315
Proper shop drawing for the electrical rooms shall have more
details. Ex: panels shall be drawn in its full details including
complied and please refer M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040331, M-
001 showing all compartments, dimensions, … Najib Khneisser Code 3
BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040332
This drawing just shows a representation of the room and cannot
be viewed as an electrical room shop drawing.
The panel boards in the electrical room should be drawn as per
complied and please refer M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040331, M-
001 panel selection in the shop drawing. Do we have selected Najib Khneisser Code 3
BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040332
panels?
These sections are unacceptable:
- section just exported from revit with no adjustments Many sections with the required information had been added in each
001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
- trays, trunks and supports should be drawn as per actual floor in order comply with BACS requirments
selection. (proper shop drawing)
Minimum clearance between layers of 250mm should be
001 between the top of the tray in the lower layer to the bottom of the Najib Khneisser Code 3 Complied
tray in the upper layer.

15 001 The text in the drawings need to be clearer. Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted. The issues related to presentation are improved in this revision

It is advisavle to combine these drawings. Ex:

16 001 each table to have its corresponding cable tray section on the Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted
same sheet.
The numbers on the cables in drawings 022 to 025 have no
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040316
17 001 reference. Thus is it better to have the cable tray corresponding Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted and Complied
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040317
calculation table on the same sheet.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040318
18 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040319 001 The text in the drawings need to be clearer. Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted. The issues related to presentation are improved in this revision
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040320
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040321 Drawing "M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040316" is referenced as
19 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040322 001 containment calculation, However it is MEP sections. To be Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040323 adjusted.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040324
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040325 Information in the Verification and calculation tables must be
20 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted
matching with the actual routing of the calbes.

The cable sizes in the verification and calculation tables must be

21 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2 Noted & Complied
matching with the cables shown in the Voltage drop calculation.

Please
RMTC Review Required Yes/No
Select

RMTC Review

BACS Transmittal Ref. RMTC Review due by:

Responded By Revised Status
No. Document Number Rev RMTC Comments Comments Made by Code Supplier / Fabricator / Subcontractor Response

1 Please Select

Form No. : M-BAC-000000-GQ00-FOR-000013 Rev.: 006 Page 2 of 5 08/22/2019

M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040301
The orange layer is marked as
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040302
busbar. Howerver, in P03 it
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040303
represents the Siemens equipment.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040304
There is no busbar in P03.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040305

Proper shop drawing for the electrical

rooms shall have more details. Ex:
panels shall be drawn in its full
details including showing all
compartments, dimensions, …
This drawing just shows a
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040310 representation of the room and
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-040311 cannot be viewed as an electrical
room shop drawing.

The panel boards in the electrical

room should be drawn as per panel
selection in the shop drawing. Do we
have selected panels?
Najib Khneisser Code 3

Najib Khneisser Code 3

Najib Khneisser Code 3

 Zamil Comments

Remove the tags provided to the equipment and

show it in a light layer. The bus bar routing
drawings received from Busbar vendor is attached
herewith - In levels Ground and L01. You can
download the bus duct drawings from vendor via
below email

RE 1F8 revised bus duct drawings.msg

We have made the equipment layouts as per the

latest panel drawings received from Panel vendor.
Refer the attachment "M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-
040300-001_P03". If anything to be changed, revise
and let us know. Kindly reflect this in the
containment layout wherever applicable. this
attachement can be submitted as "M-BNR-1F8DS0-
CELD-SDR-040300-002" - Equipment layout instead
of the one made by CCG

Also check for if any cable size has been changed in

this level. Check the attachment - Excel sheet -
"Changes in Cable size"