Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
net/publication/3273941
CITATIONS READS
25 879
2 authors, including:
Robert G. Olsen
Washington State University
139 PUBLICATIONS 1,867 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Robert G. Olsen on 06 February 2018.
I. INTRODUCTION
Despite its importance as a design parameter, very little re- calculated using the tower or midspan cross-section. A conser-
search on measurement of field contamination levels has been vative estimate of this voltage is obtained by assuming the dry
reported. In fact, measurements at only one location have been band to be an open circuit [8] (dry cable resistance assumed
reported and these are induced current measurements which re- greater than 10 /m—large compared to contamination). This
quire long term placement of equipment [4]. Further, it is not voltage is called the “available dry band voltage.”
known if geographic information is useful for predicting con- It should be noted that dry band voltage is not the same as “in-
tamination levels on ADSS cable [4], [7]. To remedy this sit- duced voltage” on the ADSS cable. Induced voltage is the abso-
uation, work is presently under way at Washington State Uni- lute voltage on the cable with respect to ground assuming con-
versity to develop a portable instrument for rapid field measure- tinuous wetting (e.g. no dry bands) along the span. It is an impor-
ment of ADSS cable contamination levels at many locations. tant parameter for studies of worker safety but not for studying
dry band arcing [9].
B. Space Potential
A second important design parameter is “space potential”. D. Available Arc Current
The electrical potential of the ADSS cable (with respect to
A fourth design parameter which addresses the lack of
ground) due to energized conductors at midspan is approx-
information about “current available to sustain the arc” is
imately that of the space potential with the cable absent. At
the current induced in the ADSS contamination layer prior to
the tower, however, the cable is held at ground potential. This
dry-band formation. This “available arc current” is equivalent
difference in potential causes currents to flow on the cable
to the “short circuit current” in [8]. The larger this current, the
sheath which, as mentioned earlier, can become significant if
larger the current available to a dry-band arc and hence the
the sheath is contaminated and wet. Because this difference in
greater the potential for damaging arcs.
potential (i.e. very roughly equal to the space potential near
Early studies in Great Britain suggest that induced currents of
the dry band) drives dry band arcs and because its calculation
1 mA or greater are required to sustain arcs which cause cable
using a two-dimensional approximation is relatively simple, it
jacket damage [2], [4]. More recent work has refined this crite-
is the most commonly used design criteria.
rion. ADSS jacket types are commonly divided into two cate-
One problem with the space potential parameter is that its
gories: “standard” and “track resistant”. Preliminary studies at
value is different along the ADSS cable path due to different
the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA) have indicated that
sags of the phase conductors and ADSS cable. Since a two-di-
arcs created with an available arc current of 1.5 mA and avail-
mensional model is usually used to calculate space potential, the
able dry band voltage of 26 kV will damage standard jackets but
result depends upon whether the tower or midspan cross-sec-
are resisted almost indefinitely by track resistant jackets [14].
tional geometry is used and the choice of which is proper tends
The same tests showed that arcs with available arc currents near
to be controversial. A second problem is that while the space
5 mA cause significant damage in track resistant jackets. BPA
potential is related to the dry-band voltage it is not equivalent
intends to further refine the tests over a range of currents and
to it [8]. Hence the actual voltage initiating the arc is not known.
voltages.
Dry-band voltage calculation requires a knowledge of contam-
ination level and dry ADSS cable resistance [8]. A third diffi-
culty with using only space potential for design is that dry-band E. Arc Models
arcs require sufficient voltage for ignition and sufficient current It should be further noted that research on the physics of dry
available to sustain the arc. A space potential calculation only band arcs has lead to a circuit model for these arcs [10]. In com-
addresses the first issue. bination with a Thevenin equivalent of the system at a dry band,
Despite these ambiguities, several rules of thumb have been this model may result in an even more refined criteria for pre-
developed. For example, ADSS cable placements in less than dicting dry-band arcing damage and failure. Such a model may
12 kV space potential have been successful. Above 12 kV incorporate the effect of altitude which may have been a factor
space potential, manufacturers recommendations differ. Several in the failure of one cable [12].
manufacturers are willing to install cables with track resistant
sheaths in space potentials of up to 25 kV. In this range,
III. EXISTING ADSS COUPLING MODELS
ADSS cable have been successfully installed and operated
on transmission lines with voltages of up to 500 kV. Above A number of attempts have been made to develop accurate
25 kV, the use of ADSS cable is not generally recommended models for calculating voltages and currents on ADSS cables
although there is at least one case of successful long term in high voltage environments. One solves the problem with a
operation near 40 kV. It is interesting to note that the simple finite element method but is unwieldy [15]. A second is based
space potential criteria for locating ADSS cable has not always on a two-dimensional transmission line model of the system but
been successful. In fact, there are at last two reports of ADSS (except that the ADSS cable potential at the tower is forced to
cable failure in a space potential of less than 12 kV [12], [13]. zero) does not explicitly consider the effect of the tower [10].
A more physically based model developed recently using field
C. Available Dry Band Voltage theory and reciprocity uses a simple model for a tower to calcu-
As mentioned above, a better parameter than space potential late the electric field [8]. This field was then used to calculate
is the voltage across a dry band. The use of this parameter re- the induced currents on the cable and on workers who touch the
solves the controversy of whether the space potential should be cable. However, the influence of sag was not considered nor was
942 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 15, NO. 3, JULY 2000
Fig. 6. Dimensions of 500 kV BPA 238 Series tower with ADSS cable.
Fig. 7. Conductor and ADSS cable sag profiles - Conductors at 2%, ADSS at
ADSS cable (but including the effect of the tower). The unper- 0.5%, 1.25% and 2%.
turbed space potential along the path of the ADSS (prior to cable
installation) must start at zero at the tower and has maxima at
one or more locations along the path. Given the effects of towers
and conductor sag, calculation of unperturbed space potential
generally requires the use of a three dimensional electrostatics
program such as ANSOFT™ or a Monte Carlo program such as
EF3D [1].
In this paper, a simplified two-dimensional calculation [16]
is used as an approximation. For this calculation the towers are
ignored and the energized conductors treated as infinitely long
straight conductors. Note, however, that sag causes the cross
sectional locations of the phase conductors and the ADSS cable
to change with distance from the tower. This problem is resolved
by repeating the two- dimensional space potential calculation
(or alternatively the capacitance calculation) times, once for
the cross section at each segment of the path between the towers.
The resulting space potential is called quasitwo-dimensional
(Q2D). As a final note, phase conductor sag will change with
load. This issue should be considered in any design.
Even though the Q2D space potential does not approach zero
at the grounded tower as required by the physics of the problem,
it has been shown in [8] that, for contamination resistances less
than /m, the use of the Q2D space potential is sufficient.
Basically, the tower has negligible effect and can be ignored for
low contamination resistance. Studies at BPA have confirmed
this conclusion.
Fig. 9. Magnitude of available arc current on ADSS cable for various sags and
conductor phasing. Fig. 10. Magnitude of available dry band voltage on an ADSS cable.
to BAC, the sign of the phase reverses. This change is impor- parameter. It is assumed that /m (heavy contamina-
tant because the phase angle along the ADSS cable now is de- tion) and that the electrical phasing of the conductors is CAB. In
creasing rather increasing. The importance of this change can be this case, the effect of ADSS cable sag on the induced current at
illustrated by referring to Fig. 5. If end effects are ignored then the tower is modest—the maximum induced current varies from
currents propagate from segment to segment according to just above 6 mA to just above 8 mA.
the formula [8] However, as shown in the bottom chart of Fig. 9, the rephasing
of the conductors to BAC (or alternatively moving the ADSS
(2) cable to the opposite side of the tower) has a dramatic effect
on the induced current distribution—but only when the ADSS
where is a propagation constant determined by the frequency
cable sag of different from the conductor sag. As long as the
and the resistance and capacitance per unit length of the ADSS
sag of the ADSS cable is the same as that of the phase conduc-
cable. The space potential at segment m can be written as
tors (both 2% in this example), there is little effect. But at 0.5%
(3) ADSS sag, the induced current at the tower is reduced from over
8 mA to 2.5 mA. Moreover, the maximum induced current now
It follows that the contribution of source m to the current at seg- occurs at a distance of 65 meters from the tower. This dramatic
ment is the product of (2) and (3). If change occurs because of the phase matching conditions dis-
constant then the propagation and source phases are “phase cussed earlier.
matched” and currents at segment n will add in phase resulting The result suggests that, given the proper circumstances,
in a large induced current there. It is clear that changing the dry-band arcing may occur at significant distances from the
sign of will remove the matching condition and result tower—a result that is different from the conventional wisdom.
in a significantly smaller induced current. It will be shown A similar effect can be observed for the available dry band
shortly that this “phase match” can have a dramatic effect on voltage which is plotted in Fig. 10. This is not surprising since
the possibility of dry band arcing. the available arc current equals the available dry band voltage
The effect of sag and conductor phasing on available dry band divided by an input impedance which is essentially independent
voltage and arc current is illustrated in Figs. 9 and 10. In the top of conductor phasing or sag [8].
chart of Fig. 9 the available arc current magnitude is plotted as For a conductor phasing CAB, it can be observed that the
a function of location along the span with ADSS cable sag as a maximum available dry band voltage is near the tower and not
TUOMINEN AND OLSEN: ELECTRICAL DESIGN PARAMETERS OF ADSS FIBER OPTIC CABLE 945
(B5)
where
and
[15] J. C. G. Wheeler, M. L. Lissenburg, J. D. S. Hinchcliffe, and M. E. Robert G. Olsen received the B.S. degree in electrical engineering from Rut-
Slevin, “The development of a track resistant sheathing material for gers University in 1968 and the M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering
aerial optical fiber cables,” in 5th Intl. Conf. On Dielectric Materials from the University of Colorado, Boulder in 1970 and 1974 respectively. He has
and Applications, Canterbury, UK, 1988, pp. 73–76. been a member of the electrical engineering faculty at Washington State Univer-
[16] M. W. Tuominen, “3 phase circuit model for ADSS optical fiber con- sity since 1973. His research interests include the electromagnetic environment
tamination currents,” Bonneville Power Admin., US Dept. of Energy, of power lines, electromagnetic compatibility and electromagnetic scattering.
Engineering Report TNL3-99-1, May 1999. He presently serves as chair of the IEEE Power Engineering Society Corona
Effects Working Group, and is an Associate Editor of Radio Science and the
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY. He is a Fellow
of the IEEE.
Monty W. Tuominen received a B.S.E.E. (with distinction) from Washington
State University in 1968 and an M.S.E.E. in 1974. Military service (1969–1971)
included one year as an Instructor at Ft. Monmouth, New Jersey, and one year
as an Electronics Technician in Nha Trang, Viet Nam. After seven years of de-
signing controls for the forest products industry he came to BPA in 1971. He
is presently an Electrical Engineer in Engineering and Technical Services of
BPA’s Transmission Business Line and responsible for properly locating fiber
optic cables in high voltage electric fields. He is registered as a Professional
Electrical Engineer in the state of Oregon and a Senior Member of IEEE.