Deputy Estanislau Report 2019

2019- 211277
Use of Deadly Force
Occurred:
03/ 26/ 2019
Location:
1028 Skipper Rd
Tampa, FL 33613
Involved Deputy:
Daniel Estanislau # 253881
Interviews '
FDLE '
NEELFulmore Historical Reports '
Video Surveillance '
Estanislau Statement '
Miscellaneous '
Power Point Presentation

0.
Page: 1
Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office
Professional Standards
Officer Resume
Law Enforcement Deputy Daniel P Estanislau [ 253881]
Part I - Personal Information
Name: Law Enforcement Deputy Daniel P Estanislau

253881 Badge No: 253881 Hire Dt: 10/ 04/ 2015
Department: DPDPS
District/ Division: DPSD1
Bureau:
Part 1I - Incidents
Administrative investigation IA #: 02017- 159 Case #: 17- 304361
Received date: Jun 27, 2017 Occurred date: Apr 30, 2017
Classification:
Allegation( s):
Damage To Or Loss of Motor Vehicle From An Avoidable Traffic Crash - Sustained Jun 30, 2017
4. 6. 11 Damage To Or Loss Of Motor Vehicle From An Avoidable Traffic Crash
Disciplinary action( s)
Letter of Counseling Jun 30, 2017 Days/ hrs suspended:

Loss of Take Home Vehicle Jul 7, 2017 Days/ hrs suspended: 5
Printed: Mar 26, 2019 20: 47 By: Corporal Samuel Portalatin

Transcript for Daniel Estanislau March 29 2019
Details
Name Estanislau, Daniel
Email destanis@hcso. tampa. fl. us
Certificates
Course Title Valid From 1/
CPR Certification - 2018 3/ 1/ 2019 4: 08: 00 AM 2021 4: 08: 00 AM 2/15/
Law Enforcement In-
Service
CPR Certification - 2018 2/ 15/ 2019 4:00: 00 AM Expires 3/ 2021 4:00: 00 AM Course Title
Law Enforcement In -
Service
Courses
Status Score Completion Date Hours 2018 Law
Enforcement In-Complete 3/ 1/ 2019 4: 08:00 AM 24. 00 Service 2018
Law
Enforcement In-Complete 2/ 15/ 2019 4:00:00 AM 24. 00 Service 2018/
10/
22 -
26 Advanced In Progress Report Writing
and Review - Hil sborough Community

College 2019/
02/
21-22 911 Not Started Homicide: Is
the Caller the Killer -Manatee
County Sheriffs Office

Course Title Status Score Completion Date Hours
2019/ 04/ 22- 26 Investigation Not Started
of Motorcycle Crashes-
IPTM @ Hillsborough
Community College
2019/ 08/ 9 Identifying and Not Started
Surviving Hidden Weapons-

SPC
I
Absorb Learning In Progress
Management System
Introduction Video
eWarrants Complete 3/ 1/ 2019 11: 19: 00 PM
FNS Pistol Informational Complete 2/ 1/ 2019 8: 45: 00 PM
Message
Total Credits: 48. 00
Powered by Absorb
I raining History Report Reported b}• -lcudi.c 0 Readiness Suile 10/ 1 W2018
lillsborough County Sheriffs Office For: Estanislau, Daniel P

rraining Division
ARM 253881
slau, Daniel P Person Status Active ' DOB EEOC Hispanic or Latino
SSN Gender Male
mployment - -
Status Organization Title/ Rank Employment Type Appointment Type Dates
Department of Patrol Services ( DPDPS) Law Enforcement 10/ 04/ 2015 -

Active Certified Active - Certified
Primary) Deputy Current
erlifications -
Name Issued Expiration Status
Carbine Qualification 04/ 07/ 2017 10/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active)
ECD 10/ 19/ 2017 0/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active)
LE Quarter 4 10/ 04/ 2015 Never Expires Active ( Active)
OfFDuty Weapon 1 Qualification , 04/ 25/ 2016 10/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active)
PAA 10/ 19/ 2017 10/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active)
Pinebrook Indoor Firearms Range Orientation 12/ 27/ 2017 Never Expires Active ( Active). "
Precision Immobilization Technique - PIT 06/ 03/ 2016 Never Expires Active ( Active)
vy Weapon. Qualification 06/ 03/ 2016 10/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active) _
ndary Weapon Qualification 06/ 03/ 2016 06/ 03/ 2017 Expired ( Inactive)
Shotgun Weapon Qualification 06/ 03/ 2016- 04/ 07/ 2018 Expired ( Inactive)
raining
pcoming, Ongoing, & Unconfirmed
Training
CourselTitle ( Course No.) Training Dates Grade Status Category Hour
Training Division -In Service - HCSO_2018_ Law 10/ 30/ 2018 11/ 01/ 2018 0. 00% Enrolled 21h Or
Enforcement In- Service_ LE_ 39
Training Division- Advanced( Salary Incentive)-

HCC_ 2018_ Advanced Report Writing & . 10/ 22/ 2018 10/ 26/2018 0. 00% Enrolled 40h Or
Review SNV 04
Training Division - Electives - HCSO_ 2018_ Fireamts

01/ 01/ 2018 01/ 31/ 2018 0. 00% Enrolled
Practice SW 01
bpecmuzea training - courtroom -testimony- o/ i° - 1

06/ I5/ 2017 06/ 16/ 2017 • 0. 00%, Enrolled'
16/ 2017 16h01
Total Hours ( 77h Om
urrent Period to Date ( 01/ 01/ 2018 - 10/ 17/ 2018)
Training
CourselThle ( Course No.) Training Dales Grade Status Category How
ing Division - Advanced ( Salary Incentive) - ° Graduated -

OS/ 07/ 2018 OS/ 18/ 2018 0. 00% SOh Or
Basic Traffic Homicide LE 02 05/ 18/ 2018
Training Division - Mandatory _ - - Graduated -. '

HCSO_ 2018 Pinebrook Indoor Firearms Range 12/ 25/ 2017 02/ 018/ 2018 0. 00% Oh 30
01/ 08/ 2018
Orientation SW - Uniform Patrol District I
For Official Use Only Page 202 of 239

training History Report Reporled hy, lcadi02:- Headiness Suile 10117, 2018
3illsborough County Sheriffs Office For: Eslanislau, Daniel P

training Division
ABN# 253881
Total Hours ( 80h 30m
evious Period ( 01/ 01/ 2017 - 12/ 31/ 2017)
Training
Course/ Tirle ( Course No.) Training Dares Grade Status Category Hout
Independent Study - NARCANO Roll Call Video Graduated -

I I/ 01/ 2017 I l/ 17/ 2017
for Law Enforcement 0. 00°/a 11 / 17/ 2017
Speed Measurement( 1158)- 2017 41- 2017- 1158- 2 10/ 30/ 2017 ll/ 03/ 2017 . 100. 00%
Graduated - Salary 40h Or
I 11/ 03/ 2017 Incentive . I
Graduated -
Law Enforcement In -Service - 2017 10/ 17- 19 10/ 17/ 2017 10/ 19/ 2017 0. 00% In -Service 24h Or
10/ 19/ 2017
independent Study - Autism Video - Uniform o

Graduated - -
10/ 01/ 2017 ,- 10/ 24/ 2017 , 100. 00% Ih 0
Patrol District 1 - 10/ 24/ 2017
Graduated -
Firearms - Firearms Practice 10- 2017 09/ 28/ 2017 10/ 30/ 2017 0. 00%
10/ 30/ 2017
Graduated -' , Salar y

Investigative Interview ( 47)'- 201741- 2017- 047- I 07/ 31/ 2017,,_ 08/ 04/ 2017 100. 00%a
08/ 04/ 2017 Incentive
40hOr
I
Graduated -
Firearms - Firearms Practice 04- 2017 03/ 31/ 2017 04/ 13/ 2017 0. 00%
04/ 13/ 2017
rlrearms-./ uli., 3econaaryrweapons uraauatea-

03/ 31/ 2017 : 04/ 12/ N1 7 0. 00/ u
qua] ifications04- 2017( 4- I[ hrd4-12)':. '•04/
; 13/ 2017 • Radio
Systems Abilities and Functions 03/ 03/ 2017 03/ 03/ 2017 N/ A Complete Oh Or 7.
11 Graduated - Firearms -
Firearms Practice 03-2017, 03/ 01/ 2017 .: 03/ 31/ 2017 0. 60% 03/
31/ 2017 Total
Hours (105h Om Iher
Periods ( through 12/ 31/ 2016) Training
Courselfirle (
Course No.)
Training Dares Grade Sraius Category How Independent
Study -
Discriminatory Profiling R 07/ 2h
01/ 20I6 12/ 31/ 2016 0. 00% Graduated - Or Profes ional
Traffic Stops 11/ 01/ 2016 Independent
2h
01/ 2016l ° 12/ Or
10/
Study-Agonal Breathing'- 07/ 31/ 2016 0. 00% Graduated ,
18/ 2016 _ Independent
Study Diabetic
- Emergency and 07/ 2h
01/ 2016 12/ 31/ 2016 0. 00%Graduated - Or Officer
Response 12/ 04/ 2016 1Independent
2h
Study Domestic
- Violence -07/ 01/ 2016 12/ 31/ 2016 0. 00% Graduated - Or 12/
04/ 2016 Independent
12/
Study Juvenile
- Sexual Offender 07/ 01/ 2016 12/ 31/ 2016 0. 00% Graduated - Or Y.
10/ 2016 2h
Stud 'Ph y siolo g teal endent' Res ponse07/ 1h

01/ 2016.- 12/ 31/ 2016 Graduated - Or a1micsTraining
0.00°/ a 12/ 10/ 2016 I Specialized Train g-
Basic Carbine - May 10-

12, 05/ 10/ Or
2016 05/ 12/ 2016 0. 00% Graduated - 24h 2016 05/
12/ 2016 S ecialized
Trainin g -Crisis Intervention 04/ Trainin Graduated - P 18/ g-

2016- 04/ 22/ 2016 100. 00% 40h Or 04/18-
22/ 201G 04/ 22/ 2016 I For Ofical
Use Only Page 203 of 239

I raining History Report Reported by dcudis) Readiness Suile 10/ 17/ 2018
3ilisborough County Sheriffs Office For Blanislau. Daniel P

raining Division
A9N9 253881
Graduated - Mandatory
Enforcement Module Training- SOT 39 03/ 28/ 2016 06/ 03/ 2016 0. 00% 240h ISr
06/03/ 2016 Retraining
Florida' Law Enforcement Academy ( 2000) - SOT Graduated -
10/ 19/ 2015 03/ 23/ 2016 100. 00% 770h 0r
Academy 39 03/ 23/ 2016
Sheriffs Orientation Training ( SOT) - Law Graduated -

10/ 04/ 2015 10/ 16/ 2015
Enforcement SOT 39 0. 00°/a 10/ 16/ 2015
Total Hours ( 1085h 15m
tlucation
Degree Year Education Level Degree Major Minor
2015 College/ Undergraduate Bachelor of Arts Criminal Justice Psychology
liscellaneous
qo miscellaneous data exists
For Official Use Only Page 204 of 239

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE THIRTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA IN AND FOR HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY
CRIMINAL JUSTICE DIVISION
SUBPOENA FOR RECORDS

TO:
By service of this subpoena you are ordered to produce the following requested
information to the STATE OF FLORIDA:
ANY AND ALL ACADEMIC RECORDS TO INCLUDE, BUT NOT

LIMITED TO, DISCIPLINARY AND REMEDIAL ACTIONS
PERTAINING TO
This information is requested pursuant to a matter pending and undetermined in

which the office of ANDREW H. WARREN, STATE ATTORNEY, 130^ Judicial Circuit,
is conducting an investigation.
YOU ARE NOT TO DISCLOSE THE EXISTENCE OF THIS SUBPOENA. ANY
SUCH COULD
DISCLOSURE OBSTRUCT AND IMPEDE THE
INVESTIGATION BEING CONDUCTED, AND THEREBY INTERFERE WITH
THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE LAW.
You may provide this requested information IN PERSON, BY FAX AND/ OR

E- MAIL TO DETECTIVE JOSEPH FLORDO, HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY
SHERIFF' S OFFICE, AT 813- 242- 1866 OR jflorio@hcso. tampa. fl. us. Failure to
comply with this subpoena may subject you to penalty by the Court:
Dated, this 22nd day of April, 2019.
ANDREW H. WARREN
STATE ATTORNEY
13T" JUD L CIRCUIT
BY
PLEASE BILL THE AGENCY LISTED `

ATTORNEYq , S
BELOW FOR ANY SERVICE CHARGE
DETECTIVE JOSEPH FLORIO
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE
2224 FALKENBURG RD.
TAMPA, FLORIDA 33619
813- 247- 8676
HCSO CASE # 19- 211277

TO:
ANY AND ALL SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION AND INCOMING AND

OUTGOING TOLL RECORDS PERTAINING TO
FOR THE TIME PERIOD OF MARCH 26, 2019 AT 0000 HOURS
TO MARCH 27, 2019 AT 2359 HOURS.

which the office of ANDREW H. WARREN, STATE ATTORNEY, 13° i Judicial Circuit,
SUCH DISCLOSURE COULD OBSTRUCT AND IMPEDE THE
INVESTIGATION BEING CONDUCTED, AND THEREBY INTERFERE WITH

THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE LAW.
You may provide this requested information BY FAX AND/ OR E- MAIL TO
DETECTIVE JOSEPH FLORDO, HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF' S
OFFICE, AT 813- 242- 1866 OR jflorio@hcso. tampa. fI. us. Failure to comply with this
subpoena may subject you to penalty by the Court:
Dated, this I" day ol' April, 2019.
ANDREW H. WARREN
STATE ATTORNEY
13ni 11JD10ALCIRCUIT
By
ATTORNEY
PLEASE BILL THE AGENCY LISTED
DETECTIVE JOSEPH FLORIO
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE
2224 FALKENBURG RD.
TAMPA, FLORIDA 336I9
813- 247- 8676
1ICSO CASE H 19- 21 1277

TO:
TAMPA GENERAL HOSPITAL
2 COLUMBIA DRIVE, TAMPA FL 33609
TANYA CORANZA, CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS
PHONE: 813- 844- 3068
ANY AND ALL MEDICAL RECORDS PERTAINING TO

FOR THE TIME PERIOD OF ADMISSION
ON 3/ 26/ 19 THROUGH AND INCLUDING 5/ 14/ 19.

which the office of ANDREW H. WARREN, STATE ATTORNEY, 13` h Judicial Circuit,
SUCH DISCLOSURE COULD OBSTRUCT AND IMPEDE THE INVESTIGATION
BEING CONDUCTED, AND THEREBY INTERFERE WITH THE ENFORCEMENT
OF THE LAW.
ASSISTANT STATE ATTORNEY, SCOTT HARMON AT 813- 274- 1480 OR
1- IARMON_ S a SA013. 1' H. COM; OR TO A STATE ATTORNEY' S OFFICE
INVESTIGATOR OR REPRESENTATIVE IN PERSON. Failure to comply with this
Dated, this 51h day of June, 2019.
ANDREW H. WARREN
STATE ATTORNEY
13Tn JWDtG1 L CIRCUIT
ATTORNEY SI-E k4 LI—

BELOW FOR ANY SERVICE CHARGE SERVED
ASA SCOTT HARMON 5'

STATE ATTORNEY' S OFFICE — 13T11 JUDICIAL CIRCUIT oICt
419 N. PIERCE ST., TAMPA FL 33602 NTH YEAR
813- 274- 1706 9 3> M 3DAY A PM
ANDREW H. WARREN
STATE ATTORNEY
Hillsbomsh C
BY
INV R

TO:
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE
9450 E. COLUMBUS DR.
PAMPA, FL 33619
ANY AND ALL RECORDS PERTAINING TO THE 3/ 26/ 19 RESPONSE TO

1028 SKIPPER ROAD, TAMPA, FL BY RESCUE UNIT 40.

which the office of ANDREW H. WARREN, STATE ATTORNEY, 13" Judicial Circuit,
SUCH DISCLOSURE COULD OBSTRUCT AND IMPEDE THE INVESTIGATION
BEING CONDUCTED, AND THEREBY INTERFERE WITH THE ENFORCEMENT
OF THE LAW.

ASSISTANT STATE ATTORNEY, SCOTT HARMON AT 813- 274- 1480 OR
HARMON_ S@SA013' 1' H. COM; OR TO A STATE ATTORNEY' S OFFICE
INVESTIGATOR OR REPRESENTATIVE IN PERSON. Failure to comply with this
Dated, this 51h day of June, 2019.
ANDREW H. WARREN
STATE ATTORNEY
13T11 JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
ByA
ATTORNEY 6S? Y15
ASA SCOTT HARMON

SERVED
STATE ATTORNEY' S OFFICE- 13T11 JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
419 N. PIERCE ST., TAMPA FL 33602
813- 274- 1706 T
MONTH - DAY,,
TIME AM PM
jo AN
WH. WARREN /
STATE ATTORNEY
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF
GENERAL OFFENSE HARDCOPY
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERI'- I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
General Offense Information

Operational status: ACTIVE/ OPEN
Reported on: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.) 2120
Occurred on: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.) 2120
Approved on: Mar- 27- 2019 ( Wed.) by: 228130 - Schneider, Steven
Report submitted by: 253967 - Weg, Leonard
Org unit:
SKIPPER RD
Municipality: HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY

District: D1 Beat: A03 Grid: HS3322
Felony/ Misdemeanor: FELONY

Special study: Applicability - N/ A ( Not Applicable)
Gang involvement None/ Unknown
Family violence: No
Offenses ( Completed/ Attempted)

Offense: # 1 BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED - COMPLETED
Location: Highway/ Road/ Alley ( Includes streets )

Offender suspected of using: Not Applicable
Weapon type: Handgun
Bias: None ( no bias)
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 1 of 372
ROMINE LAW, P.A.
Stephen L. Romine, Esq.
Florida Bar Board Certified Criminal Trial Law Attorney
600 Bypass Drive, Suite 205
Clearwater, Florida 33765
727) 288- 2258/ Fax ( 727) 288- 2257
Steve@RomineLaw. com
April 12, 2019
Major Frank Losat

2008 E. 81 Avenue
Tampa, Florida 33605
VIA Email: FlosatnaHCSO. Tampa.FL. US
RE: Investigation of March 26, 2019 shooting
Dear Major Losat,
Please find the attached statement from my client, Deputy Daniel Estanislau, regarding the March
26, 2019 shooting of a domestic violence suspect. In addition to the summary of events from the
perspective of Deputy Estanislau, I also wanted to provide your office additional information that
supports our position that this shooting was justified.
The cell phone the suspect held certainly could appear to be a firearm under the circumstances in
this case. It was being held in a manner consistent with a firearm. It was in an area where
individuals carry firearms. It was of a color consistent with a firearm. It was partially concealed.
The fact that Deputy Estanislau immediately verbalized commands to " drop the gun" shows he
believed the suspect had a gun. The fact that his disposition went from trying to calm the suspect
to suddenly becoming alarmed and drawing his gun shows he truly feared what he was faced with.
Significantly, Deputy Estanislau described the cell phone dropped by the suspect as having a
stand" on the back of the phone and that stand was in the " open" position. It is unusual for a
person to cant' a cell phone with the stand in an open position. Stands are meant to prop up a cell
phone on a table or other surface. No one normally carries a cell phone in their waistband or in
their hand with the stand extended.
While a cell phone without a stand attached, or without a stand open, can still be perceived as a
gunl, the stand being open in this case changes the entire profile of a normal cell phone. It further
reinforces Deputy Estanislau' s belief that the suspect was holding a firearm.
I In February this year, FDLE and prosecutors cleared Cocoa Police Officer Xzevies Baez for shooting a man
running towards his vehicle carrying a cell phone. The officer fired at the man six times through his vehicle window
because the officer saw "a black object in his hand" that the man was " about to lift it up ... and that' s when I believe
I was going to be shot at." And it is not just law enforcement mistaking cell phones for firearms. See
htlpsJ/ www fox2lnews wm/ news/ local/ police- called- after- cell- phone- mistaken- for- kun/ 1464604306 ( several
man with a
gun on his hip; it was a large black cell phone).
I understand that your agency has certain duties to not release information during an investigation.
And I understand that the media only can report what information it receives in writing a story.
But the public report that " no weapon was found" in this case unfortunately I believe has created
the impression that nothing was found to explain why the deputy thought the suspect had a gun.
We know the cell phone was on the suspect and that the deputy did not fire his weapon for no
reason. I would anticipate your investigation will confirm this important evidence.
The lighting conditions for Deputy Estanislau to assess this threat were less than ideal. This call
for service reportedly came around 7:45 p.m. and Deputy Estanislau arrived on scene thereafter. I
have attached to this email the U. S. Naval Observatory Sun and Moon Data for Tampa on March
26, 2019. Sunset occurred that day at 7: 44 p. m., before Deputy Estanislau had contact with the
suspect. Civil twilight ended at 8: 08 p. m. Thus, the contact between Deputy Estanislau and the
suspect occurred as dusk was phasing to darkness.
The complaint against the suspect was for violence against his own family, including apparently
striking his own mother. Whether the call alleged a weapon was involved or not does not eliminate
the potential threat that the suspect could be armed. A traffic stop for a simple taillight infraction
has no indication anyone is armed, yet officers still approach that vehicle with an eye towards
assessing that threat, often with one hand on or near their service weapon. Deputy Estanislau knew
he was going to be involved with a person accused of violence against his own family, and that
backdrop to this call matters in assessing the split second decisions he had to make.
Deputy Estanislau has exhibited a history of restraint in using deadly force despite circumstances
that could have warranted it.
In Deputy Estanislau' s performance evaluation review in his personnel file, it was noted that:
As reflected in his August 8, 2017, diary entry, Deputy Estanislau demonstrated poise
and restraint while responding. to a call for service involving a suspect that was
allegedly armed with two hand guns ( 17- 567330). Deputy Estanislau and Deputy
Grace responded and were able to come in contact with the suspect, detained him
without using force and determine the handguns were in fact BB guns. Deputy
Estanislau responded decisively in a critical situation and avoided making an
impulsive decision.
In October of 2018, Deputy Estanislau again exhibited significant restraint in responding to a call
at approximately 9: 52 p. m. of a female with a gun in her hand stating she was " going to shoot
someone." ( HCSO Report 2018- 714004). Upon arrival, bystanders further advised Deputy
Estanislau the female with the gun " was waving, it around."
Deputy Estanislau located the female and observed a " black in color firearm" on her waist. Deputy
Estanislau drew his weapon and advised the female to place her hands on her head, but the female
refused. The female then repeatedly placed her hands back on her waist ( which held the gun) and
into her pockets. It is not hard to envision these circumstances leading some law enforcement
officers to use deadly force when her hands went back towards the area holding the gun. A male
citizen recognized the threat Deputy Estanislau was faced with by the female' s conduct, telling the
female to listen to Deputy Estanislau' s commands or she was " going to lose her life."
2
Despite these dangerous circumstances, Deputy Estanislau showed great restraint and did not fire
his weapon. The firearm tamed out to be a BB gun. The male that witnessed the handling of this
incident stated to Deputy Rivera assisting with this call, " You guys handled that very well and I
glad you guys got here quick."
Two months later, in December 2018, Deputy Estanislau was dispatched to a domestic violence
call where a male was beating a female and had a knife in his hand ( HCSO Report 2018- 885302).
Upon arrival, witnesses pointed out the suspect and advised he had a knife in his pocket. Deputy
Estanislau drew his weapon and advised the suspect in both Spanish and English to place his hands
on a vehicle. The suspect refused, and instead started to advance on Deputy Estanislau. An
individual accused of violence with a knife on his person that charges a deputy -- despite being at
gun point — is a scenario where law enforcement officers may resort to deadly force. It takes just
a second to grab a knife to attempt to stab an officer.
Again, Deputy Estanislau avoided using deadly force. Instead, he hand -checked the suspect that
insanely chose to advance within arn' s reach of Deputy Estanislau while Deputy Estanislau had a
gun pointed at him. Upon pushing the suspect down, two knives approximately seven inches long
fell from the suspect. A witness noted he had one knife in his waistband, and one in his pocket.
This is not a deputy that has a history of being " quick on the trigger" or impulsive. Deputy
Estanislau' s history of facing threats is one of restraint. In the case currently under investigation,
Deputy Estanislau showed that same restraint. He first tried to handle the matter by calming the
suspect. He did not come out of his vehicle aggressively. He tried to simply talk to the suspect
and reason with him in a non -threatening manner. When Deputy Estanislau perceived what he
believed to be a firearm being held by the suspect, he again exercised restraint. He did not fire
immediately. He gave repeated verbal commands.
Had the suspect simply followed the commands given in this case, the outcome would have been
different. All of this could have been avoided if the suspect dropped what he was holding or moved
his hands away from the object.
If a person is carrying a cell phone and a law enforcement officer draws a weapon and verbalizes
they believe the person has a firearm, a reasonable, rational response -- at a minimum — is for the
person to move their hand away from the cell phone or drop it. It is also not unreasonable to expect
that the person would also communicate to the alarmed officer, " It' s just a cell phone, it' s not a
gun," or words to that affect. What is not rational is to ignore the officer' s commands, maintain a
position of holding the object that is a threat to the officer and then make movements with the
object that place the officer in fear of being shot.
This is a very sad incident for everyone involved. However, it is a result that the suspect could
have avoided by simply complying with Deputy Estanislau' s instructions. Thank you for taking
the time to review this. If you have any questions, please let me know.
Sincerely,
Is/ Stephen L. Romine

Stephen L. Romine
3
This summary statement regarding' my use of force is made to the best of my
recollection regarding a very stressful, unexpected situation.
On March 26, 2019, 1 responded to the domestic violence call. As I approached the
call address on Skipper Road, a middle- aged black malewearing glasses on a phone flagged
me down and pointed to the direction of the suspect, stating " that' s him." I turned
my marked vehicle around to make contact with the suspect. The
suspect was on foot walking away from the call address. I puled up towards the
suspect in my vehicle, parked, and exited the vehicle. I asked the suspect if I could
talk to him for a second. He indicated he did not want to talk. During my initial
observations of him,he was sidestepping, glancing back and forth, and would blade
towards me with his left shoulder. I
began to walk towards him, walking past my front bumper, advising that I just wanted
to get his statement about what happened, try to clear this up, words to that affect.
He appeared very agitated and was acting in a way that I thought he may be getting
ready to run. I was trying to calm him down, both in my tone and in my body language.
As
I walked towards him, he turned to face me. That is the first time I noticed he was
holding a black object in his waistband with his right hand. It ap eared to me to
be a gun. Based on my training and experience, it was in an area consistent where guns
are carried and the manner in which the suspect was holding the object was consistent
with holding a gun. In the split second of seeing this and believing it to be
a gun, 1 drew my weapon. I
recal shouting " drop the gun" repeatedly. I may have also told him to show me his
hands or place his hands up,but under the stress and speed of this incident 1 am not
completely sure of my exact words. The suspect did not comply with any of my commands.
Instead he kept blading towards me,still appearing agitated, looking all around,
and not dropping or moving his hand away from what I beli ved to be the gun.
While his left shoulder was bladed towards me,he then made a movement that appeared
to be positioning the gun towards me with his right hand —
inconsistent With
dropping the gun or moving his hand away from the gun. I thought 1 was about to
be shot and feared for my life. That is when 1 im ediately fired two shots.
The suspect fell backwards. The object he was holding came out of his hand and
landed on the ground. That was the first time I saw that it was a black cell phone
with a stand attached to the back. The stand was in the open position. At no time
prior to firing my weapon did I know or believe the object was a cell phone. I recall
advising dispatch shots were fired, hold station, and have EMS stage.
As soon as he fell, I ran to him. As I patted him down, I asked where he was shot.
He indicated his back, which surprised me. I knew 1 did not shoot him from behind.
I turned him over on his stomach and saw one bullet wound near his left shoulder
blade area, which was consistent with the bladed position he had been in. I did not
see an exit wound.
I put on my gloves and began to apply pressure to the wound. The suspect began
trying to get up. I kept telling him to stay down while 1 maintained pressure to the
wound. Upon Deputy Perez arriving, Quick Clot was applied to the wound. Other
deputies then took over the scene.
At no time after I made clear that I believed he had a gun did the suspect say
anything. He never dispossessed what he was holding and never put his hands up in
the air or out to the side to show he had no intention of being a threat to me or others.
Had he simply complied with my commands, dropped the object or placed his hands
away from the object, this incident would have never happened. 1 tried to diffuse
the situation from the outset and did not initiate this contact with my weapon drawn
or with any intent or desire to shoot anyone.
Dated: April 11, 2019
Depu Daniel Estanislau

Sun and Moon Data for One Day
U. S. Naval Observatory
Astronomical Applications Department
Tampa, Hillsborough County, FL ( Longitude W 82a 28', Latitude N 27° 58')
Tuesday, March 26, 2019 Eastern Daylight Time
Sun
Begin civil twilight 7: 04 a. m.
0
Sunrise 7: 27 a. m.
Sun transit 1: 36 p. m.
Sunset 7:44 p. m.
End civil twilight 8: 08 p. m.
Moon
Moonrise 12: 45 a. m.
Moon transit 6: 13 a. m.
Moonset 11: 40 a. m.
Closest Primary Moon Phase: Last Quarter on March 28, 2019 at 12: 10 a. m. ( local daylight time)
Phase of the Moon on March 26, 2019: Waning Gibbous with 65% of the Moon's visible disk illuminated.
1oon image not available.
Back to form
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Related Attachment( s) - MRE Attachments

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW 3- 28- 19 - DEP PEREZ # 254523
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW
CAST? NO. 211277 28

DA' lli March 2019 1031
TIME Hours Conlidenlial
LOCATION Localion Der.
INTERVIEW OF A. Perez, ABN 254523 Dei.
INI' IRVEWD 13Y 19- J. Florio, ABN 205814 FLORIO:
Thursday March 286 the time is 10: 3I. Deiective Florio ABN 2059144 phis is reference
IiCSO case number 2019-211277. Curently in The Land 0 Lakes area at a confidential location with Can \otl State
Four first and last name? PEREZ: Deputy Arm ando Perez, FLORIO: And
what' s your ABN'?PEREZ
254523. FLORIO: 254523. PI RU, Yes
sir FLORIO:
Where do \
ou work' I PEREZ_
I lills' borough County Sheriff' s
Office. FLORI: And what district^ PERIiZ: District 1.
FLORIO: And were you
working on Tuesdav
niglu? PFRLZ.: Yes Sir. FLORIO: Okay. In sour
words... were you
dispatch... if you could, could Noll raise \ our right hand Swear and atfimt c\crN' Ihing
you' re going to Ill me is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth'? PEREZ:
Yes Sir FLORIO: Oka\. I called
you on The
phone to let you know that I was going to come b\ just to get a quick statement I} om vau
in ref rence To the use of deadly force from the other nighl.' 1'hal-s correct" PEREZ:
Yes sir. For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01-2019 (
Wed.) Page 2 of372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY-] BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEWOF DEPUTYARMANDO PEREZ, ABN 254523 Page 2of6

HCSO CASE NO. 19- 2I 1277
F!- ORIO: Okay, If you would could you tell me if you were dispatched to or did you,_ were
you just in route to you lust decided to put yourself in route to the call at
Skipper Road.
PEREZ: I placed myself in route based off of a duplicate call that came out.
FLORIO: Okay,
PEREZ_ So I was working as a razor unit at that time.
FLORIO: Okay,
PERE- Z: And 1 saw the call, They got dispatched but I saw the duplicate so 1 placed myself
51 to it, in route
FLORIO OkaY. Do you remember what time you got to the call'!
PEREZ: What time specifically? I can recall off the top of my head, no.
FLORIO: Okay. Where did you go to?
PEREZ: I went... while I was in route we were updated by the deputy on scene that there
was shots fired,
FLORIO: Okay.
PEREZ.: So l... I came in from the west side and I located him on the sidewalk.
FLORIO: And when you say him who is him?
PEREZ: Deputy listanislau.
FLORIO: Okay_ Were )' au the first person on scene"
PEREZ: Yes sir.
FLORIO: Okay. What is it that you observed?
PI7REZ: I obsen' cd Eslanislau holding the... the subject I believe Fulmore on the ground as
if he was applying pressure.
FLORIO: Okay.
PEREZ: As soon as I got out he said get your quick clot. I grabbed my quick clot and I
started to render aid.
FLORIO: Okay. Do you need to stop to go tend to your Iantily?
GENERAL OFFENSE HARDCOPV
GO# HIS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
IMfERVIEWOF DEPUfYA RDIANDO PEREZ ABN 254523 Page 3 of

HCSO CASE. NO. 19- 211277
PFREZ: Did...
FLORIO: I think your daughter might be calling you.
PEREZ Oh som. Yes Chiquila? Yes.
UNKNOWN: Daddy.
PEREZ : Yes,
UNKNOWN_ inaudible)
PEREZ : I knot% Do con wane... do you . cam me m bring him in here tcith you?
UNKNOWN: Yeah.
PERF7.: Oka% See,
UNKNOWN- I think he want' to because he was...
PEREZ: Okay. Don' t let him out. Okay.
FLORIO: I' ll stop the recorder lentporarily.
END OF RECORDING
FLORIO: Were back on recording with Deputy Perez he had to lake care ofa family matter.
We Icli oliwieh you tycrc the tirsi.,, as you came up m Ucpmy Eslanisluu what did
rou observe?
PEREZ: I observed him applying pressure, whal had seemed like to me like he was applying
pressure with the on the sidewalk. Soon as I got of he asked me In
get the quick clot so 1 grabbed my stuff.. I rendered aid.
FLORIO: Okay. At any point did you engage Deputy Estanislau in any type of conversation"
PERK%: Initially I did. I said... I said are you okay. And I said what happened. And he
as... I can ( ell he was son of in shock the whole situation. His eyes were... were
big and he said... what did he sac" He said... oh he said ask... ask the people if they
sat+t' I here was... at that time it seemed like if people . started to realize what %vas
happening so they started approaching and... and he said ask the guy If he sa\ V. By
that time another deputy arrived and he kind of told the subject to kind of step mcay
from the scene
FLORIO: Who was that deputy"
PERK%: That ts' as I can' t remember off.. I think it was Deputy O' Brien.
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 4 of372
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
IN] ERYIEN' OIF DEPUTY A RMAN DO PFREZ, ABN 254523 Page 4 of

HCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: Okay.
PERE'Z: Uh- huh,
FLORIO. Did Fstanislau... when you asked Fstanislau about whal happened did he tell you
what happened?
PFREZ: No he did not.
FLORIO_ Okay. So there is... so he made no statements to vou9
PI; RFZ: No statement.
FLORID: Okay. Did you end up rendering aid to the subject...
PFREZ- Yes.
FLORIO: that was on the noor?
PFREZ._ By the time Richardson. Deputy Richardson showed up eve.. you can obviously tell
that Deputy Fsianislau was in shock and and he was a bit shaken up.
FLORIO: Okay,
PFRFZ_ So when Richardson showed up he pulled him aside off of cause Fstanislau % vas
still helping me with rendering aid So when Richardson showed up he took him
aside.
I' IARIO: Okay. Is there any other... did you overhear Estanislau make any statements to
anybody else"
PFREZ: No.
FLORIO- Okay. Is there anything that I haven I asked )' ou that you feel would be important
for the investigation"
PER17Z No. No. When... when we were looking for the gunshot wound it was on his back.
So I said,.. so I asked him. -. I asked him is there... did you see an exit wound did
ou See anything like that. He said no. no, 1 don't know how, _,1 don' t know how it
went in his back.
FLORIO: Okay. And who are you referring to when you...
PFRIiZ: Estanislau.
FLORIO: Okav, So,,,
INI ERVIEW OF DEPUTY ARNIANDO PEREZ, ABN 254523 Page 5 of

RCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
PEREZ Immediatel p... immedialely when we were rendering aid we were... I gave him the
quick clot and we were looking for... for the exit wound.
FLORIO: Oka%,
PEREZ : And we couldn' t find it. And then that' s when he said... he said I dndl know hosv
it... how it hit him on the back.
FLORIO: Okay. I low did % ou dctcmtine which was entr%.,. what was an entrance wound'
PERCZ: We... we didn i but we saw that one so were trying to find a dillerent another...
F LOR I O: Oka%,
PEREZ: another one.
FLORIO: That makes . sense.
PEREZ'. Ycs,
FLORIO: And I m just hying to clarify what... what
PERK%: No, no, no. We only saw one puncture wound.
FLORIO: Oka%.
PFR17Z And we were tr) ing to locate another one.
FLORIO: Okay. And Fs'Ianislau did make a statement though about...
PF: REZ: lie said_. he said I don know how I.. I don know how it hit him in the back or
something like that.
FLORIO: Oka%.
PFR17Z- Can I remember % erbatim what he said but something about I dolt know he%%
it... it hit him on the back. And I think that' s what made him go into shock cause he
was — he was like what you know what happened. In my interpretation of his shock
was like what... cause it all happened so fast.
FLORIO: Sure. Did you observe the shots being fired?
PFREZ: No,
FLORIO: Okay. Was there anybody that you interviewed at the scene?
PFR17Z.'. No sir
INTERVIEWOF DEPUr1' ARNIANDO PERE%, AHN254523 Pape 6of6

HCSO CASE, NO. 19- 211277
ITORIO: Okay. Is there any other statements or anything else that you can think of that
would be important for the investigation!
PI? RF/: No.
171- ORIO: Okay. All right. ' I bar is all the questions I have for you. I appreciate your time. Iln
gonna stop the interview at 10: 35.
END OF INTCRVIFW
ig/ April 3, 2019
GO# HS2019- 211277ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Related Attachmi - MRE Attachments

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW 3- 29- 19 - DEP PEREZ # 254523
Reference Number:
Y1NwzkitjMIMtoI YIaMIa1n
CASE NO. 19- 211277

UATE 29 March 2019
TIME 18231loun
LOCATION I ICSO D- 1 14102 North 20" St.. Tampa, Iq
INTERVIEW OF Dep. A. Perez AI3N 254523
I N' fIiRVIF\ A9? D BY Det. 3. Florio. AHN 205814
FLORIO: It' s Fridae March 29`^. The lime is 6: 23 pill. Deteclive I' Iorio AHN 205814 in
relcrcnce to HCSO case number 2019- 211277. I' m currently within my vehicle in
front of the District 1 once at 14102 North 20ih Street. Also %ith me is Depute...
PEREZ: Armando Perez.
FLORIO: And your AHN7
PEREZ: Is 254523,
FLORIO: All right, Deputy Perez ifynu would raise your right hand Do you wear and
anon to tell me the Truth, The whole moh and nothing but the Truth?
PEREZ: Yes siL '
FLORIO. Okay. We spoke }'csierday 1 told you that I' m not going to go through \ our entire
statement again. but there is a follow up question that came up that I would like to
ask you. Is that okay?
PEREZ: Yes sir.
FLORIO: Oka\. As you arrived on scene did you obsme any ph\ sical evidence near the
subject that you guys ended up rendering aid log
PEREZ: Yes,
FLORIO- What did you obsen' c7
PEREZ:
There was a phone, a black phone wish like a black case on it that vas ... that had
like a kick stand an the side" alk above his maybe like right arm area or right
shoulder area about I- d say a fool mvay, a foot or two m\ ay. And there was a... a
baggic of some son of narcotic. It was like a green leaf\ substance or a brown leali,
substance.
FLORIO: Okay. When you talk about the phone did you remove... did you remove an\
property from the subject on the ground'?
GON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF DEPUTY A RNIANDO PER F-% ABN254523 Page 2 of

PEREZ.. No sir.
FLORIO: Okay. As you came up to the... this is just so I' m coffee[, as you came up to the
scene this physical evidence was in the place Where it was, where you observed il'?
PEREZ'. When,,, yes when I shoved up there was a phone on the sidewalk.
FLORIO: Oka),.
PEREZ: Yes.
FLORIO: So in other words you didn' t take any property out of the victim... out of the
subject' s possession for whatever reason, just to gel it away Irom him or to .. or
anything of that son'
PEREZ: No.
FLORIO: Oka. So it was there when you came up?
PEREZ: Yes.
17LORIO: Okay, Do von remember when vent came to the scene exactle who was there?
PEREZ.: Well Deputy Eslanislau was there With the subject.
PLORIO: Okay,
PEREZ: 1 showed up first- Then it Was Deputy O' Brien.
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
PEREZ: And then it was Deputy Richardson.
FLORIO: Okay.
PEREZ: After that I feel like it wasjust, I couldn' t keep track of who showed up next or
who because there Was multiple deputies that arrived shortly alter,
FLORIO: But you were the first person, the first depot% aside liom Eslanislau that was there'
PEREZ: Very first deputy, yes,
FLORIO: Okay. And con did not witness the shooting?
PEREZ: I did not witness the shooting.
1NTERVIEN' OF DEPUTYARDIANDO PERE%. ABN254523 Page 3 of3

FLORID: Okay, All right. That' s all I hace. I' m going to end the recording at 6: 26 pm.
END OF INTERVIM
jg/ April 3. 2019
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Related Attachment( s)
MRE Attachments At achment Description: TRANSCRIBED

INTERVIEW OF DEP K.
O' BRIEN #205814 Reference Number: TRANSCRIBED
INTERVIEW CASK
NO. 19-
211277 DA 117 27
March 2019 TIMfi 1713 Hours
LOCATION Publix Parking
Lot Intersection Florida and Nebraska. Tampa, FI.INTERVIEW OF Dep.
K,
O' Brien. ABN 256560 INTI? RVIEN' ED
BY Det.J.
Florio, ABN 205814 FLORIO: It is
Wednesday March 27ih. The time is 513 part. Detective Florio ABN 205814. This is going to
be in reference to I ICSO case number 2019- 211277, 1 am currently' within my vehicl at...
in
a Publix parking lot at the comer of or at the intersection of Florida Avenue and Nebraska
Avenue- And I am currently with Deputy can you state your first and last
name" O' RKIEN: Kevin O' Brien.
FLORIO: And what is your
ARN' 1 O' BRIEN: 256560. I71-ORIO:
5609 O' BRIEN_
Yes sir. FLORIO:
Spell tour last name.
O' BRIEN O-B-R-
1-17- N_ FLORIO: Okay. Ther ' s an
apostrophe between the O and the B couec19 O' BRIEN: Yes sir. FLORIO:
Okav You' re aware
the interview is recorded correct" O' BRIEN: Yes sir.FLORIO:
Okay. If you would
could you raise your right hand. Do you swear and affirm what you' re going to tell
me is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth? O' BRIEN: I do. FLORIO_
Okay. Were you dispatched
or did you end up going to 1250 Skipper Road last night'' BRIEN: Yes sir_
For:
205814 Printed On: May-
01- 2019 ( Wed.)

Page I I of 372
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIMOPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
N' I' ERVIEW OF DEPU Y KF.YIN OTR I EN, ABN 256560 Page 2 of 4
FLORIO: Okay Which one was it'? Were you dispatched or"
O' BRIEN- I was dispatched I was on the.., another call in at

Which then transformed
into a
FLORK) Okay. Do you remember about What time you gm to ( he scene'!
O' BRIEN: 1 got to the scene it Was about 19... 1947...
FLORIO: Okay_
O' BRIBN: I is about When I got there.
FLORIO: Where did you got to firs(?
O' BRIEN_ At first once 1 heard Deputy Estanislau was 1025 1 Was in the complex driving to
apartment 46 to try to see Where he was. And then he said that there Was a... over
the radio he said shots fired. And I circled through the complex to try to find him
until he said ( hal he was out in,,. on the road. on Skipper Road.
FLORIO: Okay. So you said ) ou... he had said over the radii), meaning Estanislau said over
the radio that he was on Skipper Road. Did you go to him at that point?
O' BRIEN: Yes.
FLORIO: Okay.
O' BRIEN: I immediately went over to him.
FLORIO: Okay Were there any other... were you the first deputy to get with him or was there
somebody else there"
O' BRIEN: I pulled up at the same exact time as... as Deputy Perez.
FLORIO: Okay_ What were... what actions did lnu take once N' Mi got out of the car?
O' BRIFN: As soon as I got out of the car he 1 saw Estanislau was rendering aid to... to the
subject on the ground and I inmlediately said put gloves on. And Perez ended up
getting some of his quick clot and began doing._ began helping do pressure on the
wound. And I ended up there was some people all around us. I ended up kind of
pushing them back to get them away from right on top of us.
FLORIO: Who were these people'?
O' BRIEN: It was... it Was lust pedestrians around. There was a one of the witnesses his first
For: 205814 Printed On: Map- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 12 of372
GENERAL OFFENSE HAREICOPY
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVEIOPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF DEPUTY KEVIN O' BRIEN, ABN 256560 Page 3 of 4

name was Jose, I have it .. I have it written dorm on my notepad. And he said he
saw... he was kind of aware of what happened. fie said that he saw sonic stuffso
w' c kind of... 1 put him to the side and had him wait with... wait on the side where I
was still able to watch him while we... while we rendered aid to him belme .. until
other deputies arrived to interview with him_
FLORIO: Okay Was that the same subject that you guys held onto last night and the detective
ended up talking to him later on?
O' BRIEN: Yes.
FLORIO: Okay Detective Tabor I believe spoke to him_ Is that correct'?
O' BRIFN: Fin not sure who spoke with him because 1_. basically once he Was,.. I put him to
the side Deputy Lamb was with him the whole time. And I end up staying on scene
and watching... watching all the evidence.
FLORIO: Okay_ At any point did you have contact with Deputy Fsianislau?
OBRIFN: When I first got there I just I made sure I just asked are you okay and he said yeah,
Ile goes will ynujusi give me... start doing pressure basically on... and get the
quick clot to put it in his wound.
FLORIO: Okay. Did he... you just asked him if he was okay'! Did you ask him what
happened'
O' BRIFN: I did not ask him what happened.
FLORIO: Okay- And ]- in lust looking at something. You said that the gentleman' s name that
you held onto there was Jose"
O' BRIFN: liis first name was .lose.
FLORIO: Okay. Got pa. And I believe we...
O' BRIEN: And I have his... I have his...
FLORIO: Jose Dclacma?
O' BRIFN: Yeah that' s it.
FLORIO: Okay_All right. But gelling back to the point of this was there any observations that
you made that Were peculiar to you at the scene?
O' BRIBN: No.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED INTERVIEW OF DEPM Y
KEVIN O' BRIEN. ABN 256560 Page i of HCSO CASE NO. 19-
211277 FLORIO: Okay. O' BRIEN',
I mean
I know when I was coming...when 1 was coming through the apartment complex 1 had inn,
window down. I never... I never heard any shots hen 1 was in the complex which was
I mean only maybe a hundred or so yards away, FLORIO: Oka%.O'BRIEN:
But when
1 came up there I didn' t see anythig. anything else. I'LORIO: Oka,.

Did
the subject that aid was being rendered to.did he make any statements, O' BRIEN- No. I
le --
he was making noises but I_.
it wasn' t... I couldn' I tel what he was same or anything. lie
was kind ofjusl moaning. FLORIO: Oka,.All right
Did you collect any evidence from the scene? O'BRIBN- No. I
did not, FLORIO: Did you do...
conduct any actual interviews with any individuals on scene, O' BRIEN: No. FLORIO:
Okay. Thal is
all 1 have for now. Is there anything that 1 haven' t asked you that you think would be important
or on
% feel that you should share for the im cstigation, O'BRIEN'. No. That
s cycn9hing. FLORIO: Okae Then if
that' s eves thing I in going to stop the recorder at 5:

20 pm.END 017 INTERVIEW jg/
April 3. 2019
For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 20I9 (

Ned.) Page 14 of 372

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF DEP L. WEG # 253967
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED IN' FFRVIEW
CASE NO. I9- 211277

DAFE 28 March 2019
TIME 0940 Hours
LOCATION Wesley Chapel Area
INTERVIEW OF Dep, L. Weg, ABN 253967
INl' ERVIEWED BY Del. J. Florio, ABN 205814
FLORIO II is Thursday March 28". The lime is 9: 40 am. Detective Florio ABN 205814. This
is going to be in reference to IICSO case number 2019- 211277, 1 in currently'

within my vehicle in the Wesley Chapel area with can you state your name for me
please°
WEG: Leonard W' cg.
FLORIO: And whal' s your ABN'!
WEG: 253967.
FLORIO: Who do you work for"
WEG: Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office.
FLORIO: I low long have you been ( here?
WE( i: About three and a half Nears.
FLORIO: Three and a half )' cars?
WEG: Yeah.
FLORIO: What district are you assigned to?
WEG- District 1,
FLORIO: What squad do you work on'
WEG: 108,
FLORIO: Is that A shill or B shill?
WEG_ 13 shill nights Bravo area.
FLORIO: Okay. "' ere you working on Tuesday night?
WEG: Yes,
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERYIEN' OF DEPUTY LEONARD WEE. ABN 253967 Page 2 of 7

DCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: Okay. What was.., tt erc %ou dispatched or did you arrive on a call al Skipper
Road?
W17G: Yeah. 1 wasn I dispatched to it. I responded after hearing shots fired over the radio.
FLORIO_ Okay. So when you heard shots fired on the radio do you knot, who had said that
on the radio?
WIiG'. Deputy Esianislou_
FLORIO: Okay. Do you remember what time you got to the scene.'
WIiG'. It was 1949_
FLORIO: You got there at 19499
Wl: G: Yes sir.
FLORIO: Oka%. So when you arrived at 1949 t, here did you arrive to'?
WIiG: So I came... I was coming from Fletcher and 23' d...
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
WEG: leaving a disturbance. I came up Nebraska and went east on Skipper from
Nebraska.
FLORIO: Okae
WI? G: And I parked my car just cast of the incident area along the road.
19- OR10: Oka% On the north side or the south side?
WEG: South side I blocked the cast bound lane of travel on Skipper...
FLORIO: Oka%
WIiG: on the south side of the road.
FLORIO: Oka%. Was there anvbodv else at that scene at that lime"
W I? G: Yes. So when I got out of my car I saw Deputy Estanislau, Deputy Perez and
Deputy 0Brien tending to
FLORIO: Oka%.
WIiG: ho " as on the ground. And then Deputy Richardson approached with his
INTERVIEW OF DEPUTY LEONARD WEG, ABN 253967 Page 3 of 7

FICSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
medical bag.
FLORIO: Okay. What actions did you take when you went to the scene
WEG'. Whch I for there I got out of my, car. As I drove there 1 drove past EMS was staging
so I asked them if it was okay for EMS to come in and then 1 think Deputy O' Brien
got on the radio told them it was. Depmy Richardson then approached
with his bag and Depuy Estanislau stood up and I walked over to him to make sure
he was okay.
FLORIO: Okay. Did you engage Deputy Eslanislau in any conversation?
WEG: No. I mean 1 just told him you know I pill my hand on his shoulder I was like You
know are you good, you know making sure he' s okay. I didnl ask him about what
happened or anything like ( hat.
FLORIO: Did he make any statements to yoti!
WI'. G: Yes. So he was kind of like pacing around You could tell he was frustrated you
knmy upset And he was lust like you know why' d he make me do that. And I
was,,, [ just asked him if he needed water, if he wanted to sit down in my car
anything like that. And he... he just kind of walked around for a little bil. And then
he ended up silting down in the passenger seal in my, car for a minute, 1 of lered him
water you know if he needed food or anything like that. And I sal in the car with
him until a supen• isor came over.
FLORIO: Okay. Did he actually make the statement saying why' d he make me do iluuP
WFG: Yes.
FLORIO: Meaning Deputy Estanislau said why did he make me do Thal?
WEG: Yes.
FLORIO'. Did he otter any other type of statement from there'
wl: c, Alter that when he was sitting in my car you know he was just like you could tell
he was just sitting there you know like 1 said 1 wasn' t asking him anything like that
but he... he was just like how' d L.. how' d I get him in the back. And]... I said to
him did he turn and he kind ofjust stared. And I was like I' m sure it was a blur and
then he didn' t really,,, he didn' t comment after that.
FLORIO: lie said... Estanislau said to you how did 1 gel him in the back'?
WEG: Yeah.
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY -I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIF-\ V OF DEPUII' LEONARD WEG. ABN 253967 Page 4 of 7

FLORIO: Okay. Did he... what... ] wanna break that down a ] title bit.
WEG: Yeah. That' s tine
FLORIO: How did he__ what did he say after that meaning Estanis] au4
WFG: Yeah. Well 1 said to him you know maybe he tamed, did he turn and he didn' t
respond And I was like ]' in sure it was a blur. And then that was prettymuch it.
So I
think at the time he bdicced that he had you know hit him in the back. Which is why'
he said that. FLORIO:
Okay. So but sojust to be clear and I wan a make sure...WEG:
Yeah. FLORIO:
that I have it right. When Deputy Estanislau says to you how did I get him in the back
and then you stated to him maybe he fumed. WEG:
Uh- huh. FLORIO:
Is that correct? WEG:
Correct, FLORIO:
Okay. WEG.
Yeall, FLORID,
And did Deputy Estanislau respond to your statement? WEG:
No. FLORIO:
Okay. So he made no further statement from there'?WEG:
No. FLORIO:
Okay. WEG:
No.' I' hen I moan we stayed in my cur until you know a supen- isors kept coming over
to hint and then he went with Corporal Nikic. FLORIO:
Okar. Was there any other statements made by Estanislau to you whether they be pertinent
or not pertinent to the im' estigalion? WEG:
He asked me if 1 thought he was going to gel fired FLORIO:
When did he say that to you? For:
205814 Printed On:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 18 of372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVEIOPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVI EN' OF DEPUTY LEONA RD N' EG, ABN 253967 Page 5 of 7

BCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
WEG: Toward the end of the time like he was sitting in my car. So all you knots afler he
said you know after he asked about how did he hit him and then we were silting
there. And he was just you know, like I said you could tell he was thinking kind of
in shock, a little bil upset, and I' m sure the %%
heels were spinning. And he Insl was
like you know do you think I' m gonna get fired.
FLORIO: Okay. Did you respond to that question'
WIG: I did. I told him I don' t know but I know you got three great supervisors that' ll you
know have your back.
FLORIO: Okay. Is there any other statements that he would' ve offered from there?
WIG: No.
FLORIO Okay. Did you ask him any other questions at that point?
WEG: No.
FLORID: Is there anything that I loo a asked you... that I ha%ell'[ asked you that you think
would be important as it relates to any statements or... or any circumstances that
you observcd at ( he scene?
WIG: Not... well so when I got there and I think I put it in my supplement.
FLORIO: Okav
WEG: You know I noticed he was laying on the ground and then there was this cell phone
as about two feel west of him on the sidewalk there.
FLORIO: When you say...
WEG: There was a cell phone ( here.
FLORIO: when you say he who is he?
WIG: I guess was laying on the ground and ( hen there was like
a black cell phone on the sidewalk in front of him.
FLORIO: Oka%. So a black cell phone was in the vicinity of
WEG: Correct, correct.
FLORID- Oka%, Do you remember wearing?
WFG: I believe he was wearing a red shin but they had it pulled up as well so cause you
know they were ( ending to his wounds.
INTERVIEW OF DEPUTY LEONARD W F.G. ARN 253967 Page 6 of 7

H CSO CASE: NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO'. Okay. Did you participate in lending to the anything medically %%

ith... with...
WEG: No
FLORIO- I ike any qu ick clot appl ication, any. . anything of that nature?
WEG: No. No the deputies that were on scene were...
FLORIO: Oka}'.
WEG- were doing that by the time I got there.
FLORIO'. And that was O' Brien, Perez and Richardson"
WFG: Yes. I don' t know... I knew Richardson approached with his medical bag.
FLORIO: While con %were approaching'
WEG: Yes.
17LORIO: Okay.
WEG: Yeah.
FLORIO: But Perez was already there!
WEG: Correct.
FLORIO: Oket And what s his first name"
WEG: Armando.
FLORIO: Armando Perez'
WEG: Yes,
FLORID: All right. Okay- So to your knowledge Perez was already on scene when you got
then?
WEG: Correct.
FLORIO: Okay. Is there anything else that I havenl asked you that you' ve or any statements
that %core made that... that made to you pertaining to the investigation at the scene'!
WEG- No,
FLORIO: Okay. That s all I have. Do you have any questions for me as it relates to the

invcstigalion7
WFG: No.
FLORIO'. Okay. Then I' m going to end the recording at 9: 48. Thank you.
GND OI' INTERVIEW
jg/ April 3, 2019
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERN'- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW W ANNETTE GADDY 1ST INT.
Reference Number:
CASH NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
TTNIE 21071lours
LOCATION Inside Assigned IiCSO Vehicle west of Skipper Rd, Tampa, FI.
INTERVIEW OF Annette Gaddy
INTERVIEWED 13Y Det, 1) Tabor, A13N 218707
GADDY: Sec on the ( inaudible)
TABOR: All right. Today' s date is March 26, 2019, It approximately 2107 hours. I' m
Dctcclirc Tabor ABN 218707_ And I' m conducting this interview in reference to
ITCSO investigation 2019- 211100. 1"m her inside of my, car in 1250 Skipper Road or of
1250 Skipper Road It' and Ms. An et Gaddy is that correct ma " am'? GADDY,
That' s correct.
TABOR: Can you spell
your full name for the record for me Nis. Gaddy') GADDY: Annette A- N-
N- F=
I'-
T'-H Gaddy G- A- D- D-
Y.. TABOR_ And when' s
your date of birth Ms.Gaddy? GADDY: April 28. 1958,
IABM And whal" s
a good address tier you? GADDY" 4011 Bain Wood
Coun' fantpa, Florida 33614. TABOR: And your phone
mmrber is'GADDY: 8134697254, IA13OR: All
right. Can
you do me a favor and raise your right hand? And do you stacar and affirm that everylhing you'
re going to tell me tonight is going to be the truth?GADDY: Yes. TABOR: Oka%
Thank you \
cry much, Before eve get started are you currently under the influence of any drugs
or alcohol? GADDY No, TABOR: Are
you currently
on any medications that Nou1d prevent you Gom hating this conversalion with me right
noN?For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

Wed.) Page 22 of 372
INTERVIEW OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 2 of 17

GADDY: No.
TABOR: And you' re feeling other than being scared and a little nervous and everything wi( h
What you witnessed, other than that you' re okay to talk to me?
CADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Okay. You' re in your right state of mind and...
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR:
Okay. We were called here in reference to a deputy in some kind of shooting
investigation is %%hat my understanding is. And 1 was instructed or requested to
come talk to you because you may have Witnessed something.
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Is that correct?
GADDY: Thats correct.
TABOR: All right Can youjust star( from the beginning and ( ell me you knout kind of where
you' re coming from and what you sow.
GADDY` Well ( just dropped my grandson off in Tampa Palms,
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY` So I was coming back, on my way back to my house over on Bain Wood. I usually
cut through off of Bearss onto Skipper Road and then go over to Fletcher. So today
1 saw a light when ]._ police officer' s light when I was... when 1 tamed onto
Skipper Road oB' of Bearss as I was approaching. So traffic was slow coming
through I' m assuming because of the light... because the light was blinking. i here
were probably two cars ahead of me, two or three cars in front of me.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY: that I remember And as I was approaching to pass the police officers car I saW
the officer out of the %chicle and was approaching somebo__ a manor a boy with
red dressed in red, had a like a red hoodic, a Ted shin, long sleeve shin_ As the
officer was approaching I saw the person look back and then start to run. And then 1
just _. 1 heard three pops, pop, pop, pop and then the person fell to the ground.
TABOR: Okay
GADDY: And by then Too like passing and seeing the person on the ground_ And I first
INTERYIE\ Y OP ANNETI' E GADDY Page 3 of 17

pulled over right here by the Rcntalcs.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Then 1 was gonna pull off but then I was like no. I cant. So I just pulled ocer right
here where I ant.
TABOR Oka%.
GADDY and stopped And I just kind of w'aited.' I hen I got out my car and I walked up to
the sign and was asking you know it he was okay. if he was alive %ou know and 1
never did gel anv answer from that so,
TABOR: Oka,. Well I appreciate you having the where with all of stopping and you know
sharing wllh US wllm you witnessed, Okay- And I apologize that you ._. )
On
witnessed Thal. We' re in a car right now and this can' t... this audio recorder doesnt
have a viden camera on IL Oka%.
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: But you' re pointing over here and the car I' m assuming the car that you re pointing
to is...
GADDY MY red.
TABOR: is it this red Explorer?
GADDY: Uh- huh, Yup. And 1 was traveling in that direction,
TABOR: Okay. So ) on re driving that red Iixplorer,
GADDY: Uh- huh_
TABOR: And you' re driving west bound on Skipper Road. Is that currect7
GADDY Uh- huh.
TABOR_ From Bearss?
GADDY- Uh- huh-
TABORS Now you said when you turned on or when you were at Bearss turning onto
Skipper )' ou saw a light?
GADDY- hen I turned,,, afler I turned off of Bearss onto Skipper as 1 was approaching I
saw a light. the police officer' s light flashing___

TABOR: When you say,,.
GADDY: on the car
TABOR: so what colors were the lights'
GADDY Blue 1 think.
TABOR: Were they like...
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR_ what' s on there now'?
CADDY Yeah.
TABOR: So the overheads'
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Okay. Were youhow fordo you think you were away from that car?
GADDY: When I sae the lights9
TABOR- Uh- huh.
GADDY- I was right down there by like where that Iaundroma, that little ph¢ a is as you
come around that curve
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: And I noticed the lights were Dashing. I was on the phone at that time talking to my
daughter And 1 said wow a Sheriff car is down here Dashing. I wonder what. s
going on you know. h was slow so.
TABOR: Where was the car at, the car that had the lights on'?
CADDY It was down there by like... it was past ( hat, down by the US Storage. like right by
the store_ There' s a little store.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY. down there too.
TABOR: Was the cars like parked, stationary or it was moving?
GADDY: II was parked. 1t was parked_ It was sitting still.
INTERVIEW OF ANNET E GADDY Page 5 of 17

TABOR: And was it one of Ihcsc marked curs ( hat sae ShcrilTon ( he side'!
GADDY: Yes,
TABOR: Okay. By the US Storage sign? Is ( hat what N' oure...
GADDY: Iln thinkine, yeah. Cause ( herds another store so it was like between the US
Storage, a little bit passed the storage coming back ( his way.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Cause I know I passed the convenience store.
TABOR: Okay. So do woudo you think it was, and if you don' t know you) usl...
GADDY: And its_.. Near.
TABOR: you don' t know. Tin not...
GADDY Yeah.
TABOR: I' m not...
GADDY: I or not sure, I know it was between that Renmlex and that US storage.
TABOR: Is where that car that had lights on rsas parked?
GADDY. No. The car was a little bit passed that.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Because ( he guy staned running and he started running it was right there h}' the
storage. And then I tiaw film go do\\ n II w' a511" 1 that ISr from that How far is that'? I
can' t see.
TABOR. Well let' s do this. Let' s get out of the car and walk peer to ( ha( tape and maybe that
car is still there.
GADDY: All right.
TABOR: All right? Okay. 1AVII just walk on this side over here. We' re not gonna he going
past that tape but obviously its dark oulslde right mote,
GADDY: Yeah. It' s like right about where the... where ( hat probably where that first car is
right there, where the lights are blink... where the lights are shining, right about
there.
INTERVIEW OP ANNETTE GADDY Page 6 of 17

TABOR: So we got ( his group of people and where that car is al?
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR: Okay, So it technical]) is between the Rentalex sign and the US Storage sign_
GADDY: Now son re talking about the Sheriff car that I saw^
TABOR_ Yes.
GADDY. Oka%.
TABOR: This... is that what we' re talking about?
GADDY: No. See fm thinking it was cause I saw, the car when I was approaching_ So I
passed 1 know I passed those houses down there_.
TABOR: Oka,.
GADDY those units.
TABOR- Uh- huh.
GADDY So the car was like about down that area.
TA13OR: Oka). And it was parked?
GADDY: It was parked and the lights were flashing.
TABOR: Okay. Which direction was it facing"
GADDY: 1 was coming in this direction so the car was facing this direction as well.
TABOR: Okay. All right so but you' re not sure about where that...
GADDY: I m mn sure exactly where cause sec I see a car down there flashing.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY'. I saw the light flashing and then I came down and I saw a SherilTcar sitting on the
side.
1TABOR: Oka% Was it still on the roadway or was it on like ( he shoulder?
GADDY: h was kind of like on the shoulder of the road.
TABOR_ And it was facing west? The same direction you...
INTERVIEW OF ANNET' lE GADDY Page 7 or 17

GADDY: If oas facing this oay, yeah.
TABOR: Oka,.
GADDY: And then I saw the officer out of the car.
TABOR_ Okay, We can go back to my car.
GADDY: 1 didn' t see him gel out.
I' ABM Oka%
GADDY: But I know he was outside the car+ shen I saw him.
TABOR: Was there onlc one car"
GADDY: One car.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Willi a Dashing light that I saw. And then_
TABOR. And you said there were two or three cars in from of vou?
JONES: and then when I came down yeah, there were some other cars in from of me.
TABOR: Okay_
GADDY: Yon sure they saw but Ihcv didnl stop.
TABOR: I understand, So the car bar had its lights on pulls oBon the shoulder, is pulled off
on the shoulder of the road on the north side with his lights on. And.
GADDY Yeah.
TABOR: pod re now approaching'
GADDY: And that was a little ways down and I' m still... I in still coming down, approaching
hen I sec Thal.
TABOR: Ilow fast do con think you' re going'?
GADDY: Oh probably about thirty because it' s slow. Usually con come through this street
you get through okay. Bul I I' m assuming cause the lights were blinking cause
that' s + chy I slowed down. I slowed down because I sa+c lights flashing_ And then
hen I got... I approached a little further then I saw Sheriff.
CON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW' OF ANNEITE- GADDY Page g of 17

TABOR. Okay. So you approached the car or you' re coming, you approach. You see the
deputy standing outside the car^
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: I low manydeputies were there? GADDY'.
One. TABOR:
What
side of the car was he standing on?GADDY
tic
was standing on the left side of the car and he was walking. TABOR:
Would
that be the drivers side or the passenger' s side" GADDY
The.,. that would be the driver s side TABOR:
Okay_
At this point are your windows up or down? GADDY:
My windows are up. TABOR:
All your windows are up"GADDY
All my windows were up_

TABOR:
Okay. What' s the deputy doing when you see him there'! GADDY:
I se him appr__walkine towards the person in the red, TABOR:
Okay. I le' s just walking' GADDY:
Uh- huh. IABOR:
Okay. Is he doing anything? Is his arms moving? Do you see anything in his hands' GADDY
I din' t se his hands moving or anything_ T just saw him walking towards that person.
TABOR:
Can you describe the person he was walking um ards' GADDY',
I...I just assume a man, dressed in red I saw him look back. TABOR:
Who is he? GADDY:
I he man in red and start running. TABOR:
Okay. For:
205814 Printed On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 29 of 372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERI'- AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF ANN' ETTE GADDY Page 9 of 17

GADDY. And that' s when 1 heard the three pops. And I looked and I saw him fall to the
ground.
TABOR. So the man looks back at the deputy. Then he takes off running,
GADDY He starts running.
TA13OR: Which direction does he rmil
GADDY^. This way, the same direction our cars are pointing in,
TABOR: And for the record you' re pointing to the west towards Nebraska Avenue
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR: I low far did he get More you heard the pops'
GADDY: Not... not very far at all, It was a few... ma) be a few steps. It was close I mean it
fell like it was close prosimi( y.
TABOR: And how many pops did you hear?
GADDY : Three.
TABOR: W hat would con describe ( hose pops are'? I mean do you know what they were?
GADDY: I assume it was a gun.
TABOR: Okav,
GADDY: I heard pop, pop. pop. Pop. pop, pop yeah. three times.
TABOR: Where were you at when you heard pop, pop, pop?
GADDY: When I heard? What do you mean?
TABOR: Like so when you heard ( he pop, pop, pop were you passed ( he deputy and the
other guy or_.
GADDY : I was like right there. I was like right cause there were two,_, Iwo cars ahead of me.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY They were like a little bit already passed.
TABOR: Okay.
For: 205814 Primed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 30 of 372
INTERVIEW OF ANNE: TE GADDY Page 10 of 17

GADDY:
So when I heard ( he pop, pop, pop 1 was like right there beside, pretty much beside
passing where they were standing_
TABOR: Okay_
GADDY: And all of us, the first three, four cars put on brakes.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY:
1 know we were all... I know the car in front of me put on brakes. I put on brakes.
And ( hen I look over and that' s kind of saw the guy falling to the ground.
TABOR:
Did you see or did you see anything in the guy' s hands that was " caring red?
GADDY: Huh- uh.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: But I wasn i really looking, von know. I wasn' t looking for anything in anybody' s
hands to be quite honest.
TABOR: Okay, Did that subjce( make any sudden or furtive ntoventents like..'
GADDY: He looked back. He made,.. did this and start running.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: lie looked back, start running,
TABOR: When you initially saw the deputy approaching the subject what was the subject
doing? Was he standing ( here? Was he walking? Was he running?
GADDY: He was walking.
TABOR: And he was walking west?
GADDY: Uh- huhlie was walking this way. TABOR:
Okay. Did you hear the deputy say anything to the guy? GADDY
Huh- uh- I mean I could assume that he was saying something but I di n' t hear anything.
I don' t know what...if they had a conversation rchm it was about or any of
that. TABOR:
So the subjects walking away from the deputy and the deputy' s ap roaching him.At
some point that subject looks back and then lakes off running? For:
205814 Printed On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 31 of372

INTERVIEW OF ANNF. ITE GADDY Page I I of 17

GADDY: Yeah. I so%%the subject walking, I saW the Sheri IT approaching him. I saw him lum
around, the guy in the red turn around_ And I guess saw Elie Sheri O- and start
running, turn around and start running. So he did a quick look back and then stun
running,
TABOR: Okac. You couldn' t hear any comers at ions or commands or anything be the deputy
or the %objeci?
GADDY: I1uh- uh,
TABOR: Did you see any furtive moccments made by the subject? Like going- his hands
like going towards his pockets, his waist bands, anywhere?
GADDY: Hull- uh, I just suw, thisjust looking back and running, looking back and going.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY', That' s all I saw.
TABOR: And when lust to be clear when you heard the pops the Subject Was running awa\'
Irmn the deputy?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Okay. Was anebodv else in your car with eou?
GADDY', I luh- uh, SaW one man he was walking that direction lowards Nebraska. When he
heard... he said when he heard the pops he turned around to come back to see what
happened, But he didn' t sec ancthing. And then there was another man coming up
on this side on a bicycle and he said lie... that it was a good kid. And I was like oh it
was a kid. You know so I don' t knmr. tic said he knew him and he Was a good kid
and he didn' t do anything to anybody. You know but I don' t know. I dolt know if
it was a kid or an adult. I just hope they live.
TABOR: The guy who was walking towards Nebraska and turned back around...
GADDY Uh- huh_
TABOR- after he heard the pops what d that guy look like or is he white...
GADDY tic was...
TA13OR_ Hispanic'
GADDY_ he was a white gue. Ile had like a... kind of what kind of -dark blonde hair.
For: 205814 Printcd On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 32 of 372
GOP HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY- AGGRAVATEU
I NTERYIF- W OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 12 of 17

TABOR', Oka -
GADDY, And he was a older_.. older gentleman,
TABOR: About how old?
GADDY: I would sac late forties, fifties.
TABOR: What was his build?
GADDY I le might -cc been about Gee-_ five four, lice fice, He had facial hair, some beard
you know like he needed to sha%c.
TABOR: What was he wearing'
GADDY Oh gash. I don'( remember what he was wearing. I wanna say a plaid shirt but Iln
not sure.
TABOR: Pants, shorts'?
GADDY Pants_
TABOR: Like jeans or khakis'
GADDY: Like khakis,
TABOR: Do }' ou know what color they were?
GADDY: Like light, the light khaki Ian -
TABOR: Shoes?
GADDY I don' tremember shoes.
TABOR: Did he look din} or clean?
GADDY, tic looked dirty.
TABOR: Like he was homeless maybe'?
GADDY', 1 don' t know if he was homeless,
TABOR: Okay. Anybody else ( hat you saw around?
GADDY. liuh- uh.
TABOR', And that guy that was walking he said he didn' t see... he didn' t actually see whal
GON [ IS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERVA BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF AN; NEI' 7E GADDY Page 13 of 17

IICSO CASE: NO. 19- 211277
happened? lie lust heard the pops?
GADDY: Uh- huh. lie said he heard it but he said it oas good... he' s a good Aid. ) on know,
TABOR: Okay. All right. So I m gonna go ahead and lust sum it up. If I sap something thats
incorrect please lei me know. You wcm taking your grandson home and dropping
him off at lamps Palms'
GADDY Uh- huh.
TABOR: And you were driving back. ) on said you were on the phone with your daughter?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: What' s pour daughter' s name')
GADDY Shannon Simpson.
TABOR: Do eon know her phone number oll' ol' your...
GADDY: Not oR- the lop of my head.
TABOR: You didn't... did you record the incident or anything like that?
GADDY: 1 was getting__ when I was getting ready to record a Sheriff ear came and kind of
pulled in and then I couldn' t... didn' t get to do am9hing else,
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Okay. My daughter' s number is 6132825.
TABOR: 28251
GADDY: IJh- huh.
TABOR'. And that s 813?
GADDY. Uh- huh.
TABOR: So %ou re on the phone with her. You turn from Bearss onto Skipper and you see a
car. a police car, a marked police car that sacs Sheriff on the side facing west bound
with his lights on pulled olfon the shoulder of the road. You kind of described to
me possibly between this Rentalec sign and that US Storage sign. Is that accurate?
GADDY: Uh- hull.
TABOR: Oka%. A couple of cars in front of you. ) on were going about thing miles an hour
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 34 of372
IN' fERYIF- W OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 14 of 17

but it' s starling to slow down because the car is there. You see a deputy standing on
the drivers side You only saw one deputy?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Was he wearing a uniform?
GADDY: If I' m not mistaken he had on a while shin.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: I remember a white shirt and then 1 saw blue gloves. I don' t know when he got the
blue gloves but I remember a white shirt and blue gloves.
TABOR: When you say blue gloves are you talking about like garden gloves or like latex
gloves?
GADDY: Like latex gloves.
TABOR: Okay. So one deputy wearing a white shirt with latex gloves, blue approaching a
subject that was walking west bound wearing all red.
GADDY Uh- huh.
TABOR:
As you gel closer and you re about nest to him ( he guy who' s walking away from
the deputy looks back and then takes on running. And ( hen you hear three pops.
GADDY: Yeah. Let me... I wanna stop von because..
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY'. I didn I sec the latex glove until alter...
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY until after he was... he... wus... until after the man was shot.
TABOR: Okay_ Did you see who shot the man'
GADDY Yeah.
TABOR: Okay. Who shot the man'
GADDY: The deputy.
TABOR: So you actually saw the shooting?

IICSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
CADDY: Yes.
TABOR: Okay. Did von...
GADD)': And I heard three pops.
PABOR: Okay. ) on heard three pops. Did you sec any flashes or...
GADD)': I luh- uh,
TABOR: Nothing?
GADDY: I didn' t_see any flashes.
TABOR: Okav
GADM': At first I thought it was not a gun. I thought it was like_ it seas like that ... but it was
three pops so I was like that had to be a gunIt svasnt his-,
at first I was thinking it was
the laser thing. But I was like no. TABOR:
Did )' on sec any lasers! GAD:»':
I fuh- uh. TABOR:
You just heard three pops? GADDY:
I just heard pops. TA130R:
Did you ever sec a gun in the deputy s hand" GADD)':
I can even saY 1 smv the gun_ TABOR:
Okay_ And I'm not trying to trick you. I m just trying...GADDY:
Can' t even say...

yeah_ TA130R:
lobe clear. GADDY:
I know. iA130R:
You understand what I in saying' GADDY:
Yeah, I do. TABOR:
So you' re saying that you didn I sec a gun in his hand" GADD)':
I di nt sec a gun in his hand. For:
205814 Primed Off:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 36 of 372


TABOR_ And you didn' t see any flashes'?
GADDY And 1 didn I see any flashes.
TABOR_ Okay.
DADDY: I heard pops.
TABOR: But the only two people that }' on saw right there were that deputy...
GADDY: And that man. -
TABOR: and that guy in the red')
GADDY: Yeah,
TABOR: Okay Okay, I just wanted to be clear on that okay.
GADDY Yeah, Yeah. I understand.
TABOR: So then after you see the subject fall down to the ground you stopped there and
then at some point_.
GADDY: I stopped, yeah right there where the available...
TABOR: Signs are'
GADDY_ sign is right there.
TABOR_ Okay. -
GADDY_ I was stopped like between right there on that street.
TABOR- Okay.
GADDY_ And then 1 realized okay I can' t stay right here. I need to pull up_
TABOR: Oka%
GADDY: After I sat there for a minute cause I was kind of shook up- I was like oh my God,
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY. Did ] just see what L_ you knot%
TABOR: What you thought you soy
GOT! HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
IN1 ERYIEW OF ANNETTE. GADDY Page 17 or 17

GADDY: Yeah. And then I that lime I' m talking to m% daughter I' m like oh my God I just
saw somebody get shot. And...
TABOR Okay.
GADDY: so she was like arc you okay. You know and 1 was like I ... I don' t kno, I need to
pull over. So I pulled over and I was like oh my God I have to say something. I
can' t walk... drive away and not say something.
TABOR: Okay. And then you put led over here.
GADDY: And I pulled over right there, yeah,
TABOR: All right. Andjust to be clear you never heard, all your four,,, all your windows
ttnre up?
GADDY: My windows were up.
TABOR: And you stated earlier that you never heard any kind of dialogue between...
GADDY: No dialogue between...
TABOR: the deputy and the subject?
GADDY: no dialogue at all.
TABOR: Okay. All right. I just wanna be clear on that. Is there any other...
GADDY: It was like a silent... a silent movie. I didn' t know anything that was except whal
I... what I could see while I was driving.
TABOR: Okay, All right Is there anything else that you think is imponant that 1 need to
know that you haven' t shared with mc7
GADDY: I luh- uh,
TABOR: All right. At this point I' m going to go ahead and conclude the immiew. It' s
approximately 931 pm. Still March 20, 2019_
END OI' INTERVIEW
jg/ April 4. 2019
MRE Attachments Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED

INTERVIEW W ANNETTE GADDY 2ND INT. Reference Number: Y
Y.n
hYY 71l7 p Y7 f Y p:\

•71 fW CASK NO.19-
211277 DATE 26 March

2019 TIME 2143 flours
LOCATION Inside Assigned
ITCSO Vehicle west of 1250 Skipper Rd., FI.INTERVIEVW OF Annette
Gaddy INTRRVIEWE? D BY
Del.
D. Tabor. ABN 218707 TABOR: All right.
I an back on the record with Ms. Annette Gaddy. Is that correct? GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: This uhhh...
its still March 26. 2019. It's approximately 2143 hours, 1 had told you that I was
gonna go down there and relay the information that you had provided a few minutes ago
and that I'd probably have some follow up questions with you. Is that correct'? GADDY:
Uh-huh.
TABOR: And prior
to me turning this recorder back on did 1 ask Nou any questions pertaining to what
I' m investigating' GAD Y: Yes. Did
you ask me questions'? TABOR: Yeah. Did
I ask you any further questions or did I just kind of explain to you this is what were gonna
do...
were gonna...did I tell you hey would roil mind coming back over answering
a cnuple questions?GAD Y: Yes. TABOR.
And then
I in gonna take you up there to the tape and kind of have you point to the car and then
ask you some specific questions about the positioning of the individual. GADDY: Oka%
TABOR_
Is that...
GADDY- Yes. TABOR_
correct^ GADDY_
Yes. TABOR:
Okay. All
right. Before we move up there did anybody else talk to you before me'? Did any HCSO
personnel.. For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-

2019 ( Wed.)Page 39 of 372
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF ANNh; I' l E GADDY Page 2 01` 8

FICSO CASE. NO. 19- 211277
GADDY: There was...
TABOR: interview you'!
GADDY. there was a Sheriff actually one started, then another one came up, another one
took over.
TABOR: Was it a male or a limale7
GADDY It teas a male. Then a Icmale came. The tcmale passed it onto another male So I
ended up talking to a.,. to a gentleman.
TABOR: Do you krone any of (heir names?
GADDY: I don' t remember any names, She %vas... she started but then she passed... this
young Judy here she passed it over to another gentleman.
TABOR: Okai'.' Ilie first male do you know what he looked like?
GADDY IIuh- uh.
TABOR: Is that who you talked to right there? Is that the female'?
GADDY: I talked to... that' s the female.
TABOR Okae.
GADDY: She started the report. She,,, someone else gave it to her, She staved it. And then
someone asked her to do something and so another gentleman...
TABOR: Oka,.
GADDY: she passed it onto somebody else,
TABOR: Oka,. The gentleman that' s standing with her is that him?
GADDY: I in not sure if its him,
TABOR: If 1 call hint over here do you think you could recognize him'
GADDY: I know that' s not the first one. so yeah if you call him maybe I will.
TABOR: We' re on... we re on a recording right now. She had mentioned that she started
talking to a deputy originally and then that the deputy passed her on to is this her'!
GADDY Yeah.
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVEIOPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
I NTERYIEW OF ANNETTE CADDY Page 3 of

HCSO CASE NO. 19- 21 I277
TABOR Dcputy...
MACRO: Magri).
TABOR: Magro. Okay. And then you passed her onto Deputy
MACRO: Blyth.
TABOR: Blylh- Is that accurate?
GADDY: Yes,
TABOR: Okav-
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR: And he did the interviewwith you?GADDY:
Yes. TABOR:
Okay_ Thanks guys. Okay. At any point when that subject was walking or running did
he ever reach for am thing?GADDY:
I just saw him turn around TABOR:
Okat_ GADDY:
I don' I know if he,,,if he reached for something when he was fuming around, I don'
t know. TABOR:
Okay. GADDY:
Ijust know I saw him look back at the officer He looked back and then he start to go.
TABOR:
Okay, Did he actually stop walking and look back or was he continuing to walk when
he looked back?GADDY:
lie... he stopped. TABOR_
Okay. Was he faced away from the deputy though when he looked back?GADDY:
When he looked back he was facing the deputy cause he was going forward. Ile was
walking lurward, TABOR:
Looked back at the deputy walking forward towards him?For:

INTERVIEW OF ANNE' l- I' E CADDY Page 4 of 8

GADDY: And the deputy was going low ards him as I saw —what I so" was the deputygoing towards
him and then I saw, him look back and slan running_ TABOR:
Okay. I'm sorry. I'm a lit le. . GADDY:
I kno . TABOR:
confused here. So the subject is walking aeay and the depuiv' s ap roaching him.GADDY:
The deputy' s coming from be...

he' s behind. TABOR:
Okay- When the subject looks back does he continue to walk west bound or does he actually
slop' t GAD Y:
lie looked back and started to run. TABOR:
Did he stop when he looked back? GADDY:
Yes, TABOR:
Okay_ So he stops and he looks back. GADDY:
Yes. TA13OR:
Does he look over his right shoulder or his ]ell shoulder" GADDY:
I dolt remember well see-Hes walking this a'a)'.

See I'm turned around this way a
s kind of hard. TA130R:
Well were gonna go over there. If you want wc' lljust... we' ll do it when we eel over
there okay. Macbe IhaYll help when were in the right...the right direction here,
All right for the record I on gonna take Ms. Gaddy up here to the scene so she can
do a lit le bit better of a walk throueh with me. We' ll just stay on this side over here.
Okay. 6yen' thing happens on that side of the road correct'? GADDY`
E% cnlhing s on that side. TABOR:
Okay. All right. Do you see the vehicle that .vas parked on the shoulder that had its lights
on' GADDY:
fm thinking it was like about right here. TABOR:
Okay. GADDY:
Because I pased the store. TABOR:
uh- huh. For:
205814 Printed On:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 42 of 372

INl' ERYIEW OF ANN' ETTE GADDY Page 5 of

GADDY: 1 remember passing the store and 1 remember the light blinking down ( here I saw
the lights ( lashing or (hey -re turned on.
TABOR: Okay, Well ihe}'' re preu}' bright lights so it' s possible you could- ve seen the lights
blinking all the wvav down there.
GADDY: Yeah. And then I saw... yeah. The car was about right here in this area here.
TABOR: Okay. So you see...
GADDI': Is that the car'
TABOR: 1' m... I don' t know.
GADDY: It looks like it. I mean...
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: that' s the area it was...
TABOR: Obviously lire lights are,.. have been fumed on'.
GADDY: Cause I_. yeah. I was about In this area right here.
TABOR: Okay. So the guy in the red, where was he at in relation to the car'
GADDY: Probably right there by that pole.
TABOR: Okay. And at that point when you see him he s walking...
GADDI': I le' s walking.
TABOR: wccsl bound'
GADDI': That way, yes.
TABOR: Okay. And then where' s the deputy at?
GADDY: Standing up 1 wanna say at the front, near the front of his car
TABOR: Okay.
GADDI': Moving, walking that way...
TABOR: All righl.
GADDY: towards the person.
INTERVIEW OF ANNE' I- IE GADDY Page 6 of 8

TABOR: When he starts \ calking towards that subject \ chat... what' s the subject doing?
GADDY tic' s walking.
FABOR: Okay. You play the subiccl.
GADDY: And...
l'ABOR: You see the subject walking, Oka,.
GADDY- he looks This w' a,...
TABOR- So,_,
GADDY. and starts to run.
TABOR: for recording purposes }nu just looked over your left shoulder.
GADDY: He looked that way_
TABOR: Towards the deputy?
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR_ Is he still walking when he looks back or does he. _ does he stop'?
GADDY. Ile no. he stopped.
TABOR: Oka,,
GADDY tic was walking. tic stopped, looked back and then stared running,
TABOR: Oka,. I low far did he gel or how many.,. do you know how many steps'
GADDY: I don' t know cause I heard...
TABOR. Okay.
GADDY: the pops and then I saw him fall down.
TABOR: Okay_ Did... and you don' t... did you see him reach for anything'
GADDY. I luh- uh, I didn' t even sec the deputy reach for any... I didn' t sec anybody reach for
anything,
TABOR: Okay Did you sec where the subject' s anus were ai"
INTERVIEW OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 7 ofe

GADDY: You mean when he fell?
TABOR: No, no while he was running or any1hingP
GADDY: I just saw him run. I didn' t see his arms.
TABOR: Okay
GADDY: lie looks familiar,
TABOR: All these guys, we' ve all worked ( his area.
GADDY: This guy in the coat with the ( inaudible)
TABOR: Yeah. Well but so he looks o%cr his lei! shoulder?
GADDY Yeah. Ile looked back. start running_
TABOR: And I' m saying left shoulder. Is that correct'
GADDY Yes.
TABOR: Oka%. All right. And he didn' t get Mery far it looks like.
GADDY: No, he didn' t gel far at all only a Ice' steps.
TABOR', Okav Just a few steps. All right we can go back. Thank you Im demonstrating that
for me. Does that make it a little bit easier for you to...
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR: kind of recall what you witnessed"
GADDY: What I saw.
TABOR: Okay
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR: Besides ( hose three deputies in the initial stages of the investigation did you talk to
anybody else besides myscl fl
GADDY' Iluh- uh.
TABOR: As far as HCSO personnel goes'
GADDY_ Ifuh- uh.
GON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF AN;NETTE GADDY Page A of

FICSO CASE. NO. 19- 211277
TABOR: Oka%.
GADDY', Nobody else, absolutely not.
TABOR_ All right. Is there anything else that you think you need to share with me or that
ou know or
GADDY: IIuh- uh.
TABOR. Oka%. At any point did you ever tell anybody that you saw the subject reaching lot
anything"
GADDY: I- Iuh- uh.
TABOR: Okay. All right. I don' t have any lusher questions. I' m gonna go ahead and
conclude the interview at 2152 hours still March 26. 2019.
END OF INTERVIEW
jg/ April 4, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW WITH JOSE DELACRUZ
Reference Number:
CASE NO. 19- 211277

UAni 26 March 2019
TIME 2202 Hours
LOCATION West of Rd., Tampa, 171
INTERVIEW OF Jose Dclacruz
INTERVIFWFD I3Y Do. D. Tabor, A13N 218707
TABOR: All right_ l'odays date is March 26, 2019_ If' s approximately 10: 02 pm. I' m here
standing on Skipper Road just west of Road on the side of the street.
I' m Dcicclice' rabor ABN 218707. And For conducting this intemew in reference
to f ICSO in%estigation 2019- 21 0 , I m here with Mr. Jesus._ DELACRIJZ: Jose, TABOR: I'm sorry.
DELACRUZ: Jose.
TABOR: Jose Dc la
Cook. DELACRIJZ:
Cruz, TABOR: Is it...

De
La Cruz.
Is that a C or a Z? DELACRIJZ: Z. TABOR: Z, DFLACRUZ: Z.
like a
zebra, TABOR:
Okay. Can you spel your
name for me' DELACRUZ_ G-O-S-E.TABOR:
Uh- huh. DELACRJZ_ D- F-
L- A-C-
R- U- Z. TABOR: Mr. Delacruz when is your
birthday? DELACRUZZ: 7/
4/55. TABOR: All
right. DELACRIJZ: 41^ of
July - For: 205814
Printed On: May-01-
2019 ( Wed.) Page 47 of 372

INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ Page 2 of 14

TABOR: 4ih of.luly.
DFLACRUZ.: 1955.
TABOR: Got a birthday coming up soon.
DFLAC' RUZ: Uh- huh. Yeah, Okay,
TABOR: Can you raise your right hand for me? Do you swear everything you re going to tell
me today is...
DELACRUZ : Yeah. Is the truth.
TABOR: going to be the truth"
DELACRUZ: The truth.
LABOR: Thank you.
DELACRUZ: And what 1 saw that' s what I tell you.
TABOR: Thank con, You can put your hand back dorm. Are you currently under the
inlluencc of any drugs, or alcohol?
DELACRUZ: No, No but I just drink a couple of shot on my house. 1 just came to play my
Notcerball over here my Mcgamillion in that...
TABOR: Okay.
DELACRUZ: place. I was soon I walking over there.
TABOR: I1old on one second. Let me get to that. You said you had a couple of shots at your
hoist?
DFLACRUZ: Yeah.
TABOR: Of liquor'? Or beer?
DELACRUZ.: Yeah, liquor, liquor.
TABOR: How many shots?
DELACRUZ : It was two shot.
TABOR: Too or three'?
DFLACRUZ: Two, too,
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED INTERVIEW OF JOSE
DELACRUZ Page 3 of 14 HCSO CASE NO.

19-211277 TABOR. Two? DELACRUZ:
Cause I
finish cal. 1 finish cal. TABOR- Whal...what
was it?DELACRUZ: It s
a two shot of\ yhiskey. TABOR: Whiskee? DELACRUZ:
Two shot
of whiskev. TABOR: Just like
a single she('?
DELACRUZ: A single
shot, the single shot after I cat, TABOR: How long
ago was (hall DELACRUZ: Well ( hat._
that happened almost about 7:

00 or 7: 00 something this alter this inaudible) TABOR: Okm'.
flow
long before ( hat before you sac or you witnessed something did you have those shuts?
DELACRUZ: No about
6. 00 o'clock. TABOR: Okay. Are )
on impaired like is anything blocking }' ourjudgemcm? DELACRUZ: No, no. .
lust I' m relaxed. rm lust want to play that my Powerball, go back home Md...TABOR: Okay.
DELACRUZ:
that' s
it and go to bed. That' s it.TABOR: Okay. DELACRUZ:
Like at,
mom say_TABOR: So tell
me what you say. DELACRUZ: When I'
m walking over( here by the gate over there I sac the black guy a old. I - think it' s
a old man, I no think I know this guy outside in the street in front orthe building over there...
TABOR: Okav For:
205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 49 of 372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATE I NTERYIEW OF JOSS
DELACRUZ Page 4 of 14 HCSO CASE NO. 19-

211277 DBLACRUZ ith the phone
in the hand, TABOR: Wil i a phone
in his hand? DBLACRIIZ'. Yeah. TABOR: Okay,
DELACRIIZ'. And
he called...
I sacs the police came from here, from Nebraska go over ( here. And the other one came
from... from Bearss. IABOW Okay, DELACRIJL: file
one from
Nebraska turn around in front of (he guy and came this way. And the black guy left him
Ibis one in red over there, this one going in red oyer there, this one. TABOR: In red''
DELACRIJZ:
Yeah. The one
in red over (here and this is him. his

( is him. TABOR: Okay. DELACRIJZ And
he' s
turn around vroom, IABOR: Okay DELACRIPL: As
soon I
saw ( inaudible) like that 1 saw the guy walking eou know he was inaudible) he s(an
walking like that. I dndt,_
TABOR: Was he wearing
red! DHLACRUZ Yeah, TABOR: Okay_
DELACRUZ. I
le was
in red. And he walkingjust like that, so slow.As soon the guc, the police officer came this way
I said boom. boom. bom. And this I turn around and go back sec (he guy he
disappear already. TABOR: Okay DELACRIJL: But
I don'
t see am'. any con know I saw this guy jus( the police officer ( um around %room so fast
and going Deer there and saw the guc boom, boom. boom. And that' s it.
TABOR: All right. For:
205814 Printed On:
May- 01- Wed.)

2019 ( Pagc 50 of372
INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ. Page 5 of 14

DELACRUZ: That' s what I saw. 1 said why.
TABOR: So let me be.,,
DELACRUZ.
1 said why, why cause I don- t see the guy running. The guy no do nothing but from
there to here I don' t know if hc' s got a gun or don'( a gun or nothing but what I saw
is he lust walking like that
TABOR: Okay. So Tin gonna backtrack and I' m gonna...
DELACRUZ.: Uh- huh.
TABOR: kind of (inaudible) what you' re telling nte. So you' re saying youYe Standing
over here to the front"
DELACRUZ:
No. I came over there by the light, by the pole light over there.
TABOR_ Where the light pole is at?
DELACRUZ: Yeah. Right there,
TABOR. So right next to that Sunny Food Store sign?
DELACRUZ: Yeah right there,
TABOR: Oka,.
DELACRUZ: I came through over there.
TABOR. And there' s a black guy standing out there on the phone"
DELACRUZ: Yeah. On the other side you know a couple of feet front nte. And he come ... the
police. The police turn around. I le say... he point this guv the one in red over there,
his one in red over there.
TABOR: Okay. So the car that goes... so the car comes from Nebraska?
DELACRUZ: Uh- huh. Go over there, turn around when the black guy on the phone say its that
one over ( here with the red, in the red... the one in red is over there, that one, that
one there. Ile sav vroom by his self. I saw him. Came over there in the front of the
guy. I heard a boom, boom, boom.
TABOR: Oka,.
DELACRUZ: And I turn around 1 see the other guy disappear.
TABOR: Okay.
NTERVIE W OF JOSE DELACRUZ Page 6 of 14

DELACRUZ. That' s what I saws.
TABOR: All right. So the car comes down here.
DELACRUZ : Uh- huh_
TA13OR: Did the car stop?
DELACRUZ: Yeah. He stop in front of the guy.
TABOR: Okay.
DI-?LACRIJZ. lie stop in._.
TABOR: Folloae me for a second. So the car stops right?
DELACRUZ: Uh- huh. In front of the guy.
TA13OR: Is that the car right there?
DELACRUZ: I think that one,. it' s one of those car.
TABOR: Okay.
DBLACRUZ. I don' t think it' s ( hat... this one but it' s one of those cars.
TABOR: Is it the one that' s a little further down that war facing that war?
DELACRUZ: Uh- huh_ -that one facing that way.
TABOR: Okay.
DFLACRIJZ.: lie facing (hat wac.
TABOR. So the car slops right'?
DELACRUZ:
Uh- huh. He stop_. he stop on a boom, boom, boom. 1 just heard that.
TABOR: All right.
DELACRUZ: That' s it. When I turn around my face is like. I said the older guy is disappear but I
say why he kill him.
TABOR: Okac.
DELACRUZ:
This guy no running, he don I do nothing.
INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUL Page 7 of 14

TABOR: Okay. Bold on one second. So the car slops right'.'
DELACRU%: Uh- huh.
TABOR: The patrol car stops9
DELACRIPL Uh- huh.
TABOR_ Where is the guv al in red'!
DBLACRU%: In the sidewalk.
TABOR: Okav, Is he passed the car?
DELACRU%: I think he was...
TABOR: Next to the car?
DELAC' RUZ: next to the car but you know in the sidewalk,
TABOR: Do ynu know who the guy in red was?
DELACRU%.
No, no, no, no. I don' t know ... I don' t know who any one of those. I just come to
Elie store so many times but .
TABOR: Okay. Did you see anybody get out of the car?
DELACRU7. No.
TABOR: No'!
DELACRUL', No. 1 don"( see nobody out of the car. 1 don' t sec nobody out of the car. I don' t see
this. _ I just saw the "
hen the guy point the... the officer like that it' s the one in
red...
TABOR, Okay.
DELACRU7', over there. I' m looking this guy he' s just walking like that
TABOR', Okay. So the guy in red' s walking. tic' s walking towards Nebraska?
DELACRU%: Yeah. Yeah.
TABOR: Okay. Did you see the deputy get our of the car?
DELACRUZ No.
For: 205814 Printed On: Mai•-01- 2019 ( Wed.) . Page 53 of372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERN' A BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ, Page 8 of 14

TABOR: Okae.
DELACRUZ: No. I don' t...
TABOR: You didn' t sec the deputy get out of the car?
DELACRUZ: No.
TABOR: All you heard was...
DELACRUZ: Boom, boom, boom.
TA130R: I low many booms did you hear?
DELACRUZ: I think it was two or three, two or three but I think it was Iwo, boom. boom, boom.
But I turn in back when I hear the boom, boom, boom I turn back my face like that.
But the alder guy disappear, tic go inside of the building. I don' t know who the guy
was. lie die already, he die.
TABOR: I don' t know I don' t know if he did I' m here. I really don' t know.
DELACRUZ.: You don' t see this guy over there^
TABOR: 1 didn' t, I got here way atier
DELACRUZ: But they take already?
TABOR: What' s that!
DLLACRUZ: They take already?
TABOR: Yeah. lids.., he gone tic went to the hospital_
DELACRUZ : Oh.
TABOR: So he may be alive, I don' t know.
DELACRUZ: I don' t think so_ I don' t think so because I saw him.
LABOR: Did you sec the guy with red did you see him with any weapons?
DELACRUZ: No. I don' t... like I say I saw the guy walking like that.
7A13OR: But you were pretty far. Were you pretty-..
DELACRUZ: Yeah. Yeah. I' m_. Fin... from here to here.
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 54 of 372
INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ Page 9 of 14

TABOR: you' re down here and he' s down ( here.
DELACRUZ: Yeah, Yeah, Yeah.
TABOR: So that' s one, two. that' s...
DELACRUZ: Too far like you know.
TABOR', three light poles.
DBLACRIJZ: Three light pole you know but I don' t see... but 1 . . I don' t see he go( a gun. I saw
him walking like that.
TABOR: Did you see if the guy ever look off running?
DELACRUZ: No, no. lie no running, he no running,
TABOR: lie wasn' t running or you don' t know if he took off running'
DELACRUZ: No. lie no run. he no in and run. lie no In' and run. I lejust__
TABOR:
Okay Let me ask you this. Could he have ( ook oil running because you were pretty
far away from him!
DILACRUZ: No. No. Ile no try, lie no try and running.
TABOR: Okay
DELACRUZ: lie no trying to run- Ile no try to run because 1 saw_ Ile walk like that. Like uh- huh.
You know I thinking they have trouble, family' problems something like that but I
don' t know. That was.,, I tell you what I saw.
TABOR: The guy that was over thereon the phone did he ( ell you what happened'
JONES: No, no, no. Ile... he just point the police officer, it' s that one in red. it' s ( hat one
over there, you see that one in red, that him, that him that' s what he say. And the
police officer done vroom. But 1 don' t know who the... the... it s a boy a girl or
what. Iic sav the one in red, that one in red over there.
TABOR: Okav, Could you hear any... could you hear anything... could you hear the deputy
saying anything? Could you hear,,,
DBLACRUZ: No, no, no,
TABOR: the guy saying anything?
DELACRUZ: No, no. Because like I said I came from ( his pole over ( here. I can see how the man
INTERVIEWOF JOSE DELACRUZ Page 10 of 14 HCSO

CASE NO. 19- 211277 walking
over (here. And I saw I hear the boom, boom, boom, But I can' t se if he talking
something, he no say nothing but the...with the speaker or something like that
he no say nothing. TABOR:
The deputy'?DBLACRUZ:
Yeah. This deputy well 1 no. I can' t hear nothing. lie says something to the...Isom the
car TABOR:
Let me ask you this is it fair to say because you' re over there... DELACRUZ:
That' s why. TABOR.
and they' re over there...DELACRUZ/

'
Uh- huh. TABOR:
that there could' ve been... DELACRUZ:
From there to here... FABOR:
something...
DELACRUZ:
I can' t hear you. TABOR:
there
could' ve been something being said over there but you couldn' t have hear...
heard It...
DELACRUZ:
And that' s why. TABOR:
because vouTc too tar'?DELACRUZ:
I' m too far away. TABOR:
Okav DELACRUZ:
I' m too far away'. TABOR_
That' s fair to say. DELACRUZ.:
If they say something., he say something from the speaker or something I can hear but
no I can see I can' t hear nothing. TA130R;
Oka\. Was there an\body else out here'?DELACRUZ:
No. I saw many people over there in the. in the store. But They " as over there. For:

INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ Page I I of 14

TABOR: Okay.
DELACRUZ : When 1 heard the shot boom, boom they trying to get away and they say what
happened, what happened. I say you see they shot . the police officer shoot the guy
in the ( inaudible) but they disappear. Everybody disappear...
TABOR: Okay.
DFLACRUZ: when they conic.
TABOR: lire guy in the red was that the onl} guy you saw over ( here?
DFLACRUZ: Uh- huh.
TABOR: And the deputy?
DELACRUZ. I no see the deputy get out of the caL
TABOR: Oka..
DFLACRUZ: I no see the deputy get out of the car. I saw the when the car, walking and that' s it.
TABOR: Okay_ Just saw the guy walking.
DFLACRUZ: Uh- huh.
TABOR: You saw the car pull up. The car stopped and ( hen you heard,.
DELACRUZ: Boom, boom, boom.
TABOR: boom, boom, boom.
DELACRUZ: And that' s it. ? Lars it, That il.
TABOR: Okay. And you didnl hear any conversation between...
DELACRUZ: No, no, no. Because Iln like I say so far away -
TABOR: Did you stay over IherO
DELACRUZ: Over there 1 came from there over here by the pole, the light pole over here.
TABOR: Okay.
DELACRUZ: I been watching ( inaudible) then say something between I can' t hear like I sa)..-
TABOR: Okay.
INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ. Page 12 of 14

DELACRUZ: something. You know I just boom, boom, boom. That' s it.
TABOR: Okay. Do you have any other information'
DELACRUZ: No. That' s all I can say.
TABOR- And a phone number is_-
DELACRUZ.- 8132336730,
TABOR- And cou live at 1430 Four Seasons Boulceard?
DELACRUZ: Yes sir.
TABOR- Oka.,.
DELACRUZ: Anything'
TABOR: Mr. Delacrur. I appreciate it.
DELACRUZ.: Anything you can call mc. Thal s all... ihais all Thal I saw%that' s all I sec, that' s all I
you know.
TABOR: Okay.
DELACRUZ: inaudible) but I get . I gel so sick because I sac why, achy because I no sec the guy
trying to running. I don' t see... I saw this guyjust walking like than.
TABOR: Oka.
DELACRUZ: I think maybe... maybe he' s in jail.
TABOR: Did you ever see the guy running^
DELACRUZ: No, no, no.
TABOR: Did you veer sec that guy with red with red with any weapons?
DELACRIZ: No. I can' t... ) can'( see nothing because he was so far, Ile was over there. I was
over here, Bin I saw him walking like Ihmjusl slow like that.
TABOR: Okay-
DELACRUZ: And I heard boom, boom, boom. When 1 hear the boom, boom, boom I do like that
but the other guy disappear,
TABOR: Okay.
INTERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRU% Page 13 of 14

DELACRUL: And that' s it. and that' s it.
TABOR: All right
DELACRIIL: I didnl see anything else. But I get so sick because I say why he shoot him cause I
don' t see the guy ain' t got no gun. ain' t got no nothing. Well I can see if he got a
gun or something like that but I don' t think so. The other people I think one of
those lady recorded everything when trying to get a handcuff the girl saw
cvenlhing. The other people disappear. They don' t know where from there you
know...
TABOR: Oka,
DELACRU%:
But I... 1 say why, why they kill the people like this. This is — this is twice in this
week Mr the one in,,, in Gregory over here.
TABOR: Uh- huh,
DELACRU%_ 1 don' t know why you know so many violence. So many violence And that' s why I
could say you know I' m_ I got nothing against the police officer you know
because they protect us.
TA13OR: Right,
DELACRU%:
And they supposed to do Iheirjob with those delinquent shit, there so many
delinquent. But when the people like this o%cr ( here he try to cover himself you can
shoot him in the leg, you can put the ( he other electric thing they call it how
they.., how the} say`
TABOR: I oasn-1 there
DELACRU7., Yeah. I know.
TA13OR: And you weren' t... in fairness...
DELACRUZ: Me either Me either.
TABOR: no weredt there and I wasn' t there okay so_
DFLACRUZ% Yeah. That' s it
TABOR: h would be wrong,.,
DELACRU%: And that one too.
TABOR: for me to sit here andjudge anybody.
For: 205814 Printed On: Map- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 59 of 372
GO# HIS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERV- AGGRAVATES
1\ 1 ERVIEW OF JOSE DELACRUZ Page 14 of 14

DFLACRUZ: Yeah. That' s true that s true.
TABOR: You know,
DFLACRUZ: That true.
TABOR, Okay.
DCLACRIJZ: And that s chat the talking about yesterday.
TABOR: Du you have anithing else pertaining to this imestigation"
DFLACRUZ: No,
TABOR: Any other information?
DELACRUZ: That' s it. That all 1 can say.
TA13OR: Okay. ]- in going 10 turn this off and it' s 10: 14 put March 26. 2019.
FND OF INTERVIEW
J€/ April 4, 2019
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACT] VE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF-
Reference Number:
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DATE 27 March 2019
TIME 0214 Hours
LOCATION Pampa General Hospital, Tampa. FI.
INTERVIEW OF
INTERVIEWED BY Do. J. Florio, ABN 5165
ALSO PRESENT' Cpl. G,' Ihomas. ABN 5165
FLORIO: It is Wednesday March 27t'. The time is 2: 14 am. Detective Florio A13N 205814
and I in with Corporal Thomas.
Cpl, ' IHOMAS: ABN 5165.
FLORIO:
This is gonna be in reference to ITCSO case number 2019- 21127T We' re currently
in Tampa General Hospital in a quiet room with sir could you state your first,
middle and last name"
FLORIO: And what s your dale of birth?
FLORIO: it wou would_..
Sixty seven.
FLORIO: could you raise your right hand for me? Do you swear or allinn to ( ell the truth,
the whole truth and nothing but the truth')
Yes.
FLORIO: Okav what made the... %what caused the Sherin' s Office to come out to
our address tonight'
Well this wasn' t the first time. Let me look on my calendar here Just last week
huh- uh. I gotta go yeah, do this real fast cause I in Irving to see what day was that
broke my window.
FLORIO: Did you report this to law enti%rcemenl?
Yes. I need... I might need you to gel a copy too of the police report cause when the
police came I had to follow ( hem all the %way to Nebraska and the police intercepted
him.
GO# US 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
NTERVIEW OF Page 2 of 7
HCSO CASE: NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
But he didn' t arrest him or nothing because he oas only seventeen_
FLORIO: Sure.
And he said yell he can break that window it don " I make no dill' erence. But I didn I
ask him for a police report so I can take it to,.. dosmtown to,,, to get my daughter to
fix mywindow- 171-
ORIO: Sure. THOMAS:
other words sue her in small claims court cause she says it's my fault. 171-
ORIO: But you...and when you say }'

our daughter you're refer ing to Stephanie?
FLORIO:
Okay, THOMAS:
s my daughter. FLORIO:
All right. Okay. So as recently as last week you you called the...
THOMAS:
But they, 1 don' t know what day_FLORIO_
And that fine. What we can do is we can research through your phone number and everything
and I can find the case number that occurred under. HIOMAS:
But I...
it' s a certain day.I think it oas' fuesdac of last week. FLORIO:
Uh- huh, TIIOMAS:
phone will come back up.1 ne d another phone. FLORIO:
That' s okay. But %%

hat... THOMAS:
can yau_-
FLORIO:
what brought us out that... 7NOMAS:
you be able to give me could you be able to gi%c me a police repon for that
day? FLORIO:
Lcl s focus., CPL.'
fHOMAS: Did the deputy... For:
205814 Printcd On:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 62 of 372

HILLSBOROUCH COUNTY SHERIFF
CON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIE W OF Page 3 of 7
FLORIO: on the [ ask at hand right now.
CPL. THOMAS: did the deputy report it'? Do you kr o %"
I don' t know whether he reported it or not. 1 know he...
C' PL. Ti OMAS: We' ll research it.
waited until his mama came...
FLORIO: Yeah.
CPL. THOMAS: Okay.
to pick him up. She had to gel oll' from on the job.
CPI.. THOMAS: We' ll research it.
FLORIO: What I' d like to...
That' s the day he broke my windmc So I told his mama don( bring hint back to my
house.
CPL. THOMAS: Okay.
So he came back tonight and I don( wanna get ahead of myself so what' s your
question"
FLORIO: What I % ould like to do is actualtvjus[ focus on the task at hand What happened
tonight''
Okay, What happened tonight and " hen called the police on my phone it was
7: 41. Okay. and them was outside of [he car.
FLORIO: Uh- huh,
And he was fighting and arguing with his sisters, his two sisters,
F LORIO: Oka%,
So when the mother went out there to tell that a.„ whatever to get on
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
he was trying to break something on the car and she was Irving to stop him- So
she tapped him a little bit.
INTERVIEW OF Page 4 of
FLORIO: Okay,
And that' s %%hen he look her and flipped her or either picked her up and dropped
heron her head.
FLORIO: Did you witness this?
Yeah, I teas standing in my door but,
FLORIO: Oka%
but it didn' t happen in my house. It happened outside around the caL
FLORIO: Okay.
And then after that that s when the two sisters jumped on cause the mama
was down on the ground. She fell like this the curb.
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
She fell up here but then her head fell down and hit that. and hit the concrete.
FLORIO- Okay.
And so that s tt' hen I called ( inaudible) That s when called 9- 1- 1 cause here I ant
sixty scycn years old and I' m scared of He broke my windshield last
night... Iasi week.
FLORIO: Lit - huh.
I ve tried In' tussle with him, to get him to close my door but hejust... he be hard
headed. But she sav he ADI 11) but he' s only seventeen. And I don I put up with that
nonsense I mean you got to be you know limt with a child And sometime she
listen and have her way because that' s her son. And 1 can understand that. You
understand what I' m saying.
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
So after she was down there and was talking to the police on the phone she looked
like she was knocked out for about two seconds cause she couldn' t get up. And she
tried to get up and then she got back.
CPL_ THOMAS: Went back down'
Right. And then that' s when took off which is wltm he did the other day
when he broke in, windshield. But I follotmd him like I said you know like from a
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 64 of' 372
ILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACT] VE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF Page 5 of 7
distance like IIDv yards back here whatever until he got to Nebraska. Then he
lumed Zell and he went on the other side of Circle K and that' s when the police
intercepted. But the same thing happened tonight. Never would' ve thought the
police would shoot him. But when I.. when the police pull up I said there he is
right ( here in the red ove,,, what you call it sweat whatever he had on.
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
So after that... alter I told the police that I went back in the apartments. I said well
Ihey got him.
17111— TI IOMAS_ Su you were out on whal like Skipper Road and saw, (he.,,
Yeah. I came out... ,
CPL_' rHOMAS: an oHiccr' 1
out the apartments cause 1 was following
CPL_ THOMAS: Oka%
like so I can give the dispatcher which way...
CPL. THOMAS: Okay.
he was going.
CPL. THOMAS: Okae,
The same thing I did Iasi week.
FLORIO: Okay.
When he broke my wind... my window,
FLORIO_ So you actually are on the phone telling dispatch hey...
Yeah. Yeah.
FLORIO: he... are you giving a clothing description and...
Yeah. I gave them red.
17LORIO_ Okay.
1 told them he wasnl but seventeen } cars old. He' s a young boy
grandson and he just pipped his mama on her head.
For: 205814 Printed On: Mai•-01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 65 of 372

INTERVIEW of Page 6 of
FLORIO: Oka%.
And he lighting with his sisters.
171- ORIO: Oka%. So and [ hays great because r%c' ll have that recorded and evegthing from
9- 1- 1 call. Do you recall if Iherc was anybody else outside as you were giving
these directions?
No II was._ no it was just... you re talking about when I... when I saw the police on
the sircl: 0
F LORIO: Yes.
No. I onh seen the police. When I turned around there was a police officer And
that- s when I turned around I said [ here he is right there.
FLORID Oka%.
So when he look off I thought evM thing was all right well and iha' s what I went
back and told my daughter the% got him. But she was laying on the couch like she
was like dazed.
FLORID: Uh- huh.
So when I wrm back out to the street to see you knot% look down to see what was
going on 1 heard somebody say something abmil she heard two gunshots. ' I flat S
when I went back and told my daughter I said I think got shot. ' that' s when
she jumped up and went down the streel.
CPL. ' F] IOMAS: Okay.
FLORIO: Okay. That all I ha%re
CPL. TI10MAS`. That' s all 1 have
FLOR10: All right. I appreciate your [ pile sir.
Uh- huh.
FLORID: On con ha%e any questions for me right no"^
No. I wanna know can I get...
FLORIO'. We' ll talk about that in a minute okay.
UIt- huh.
FLORIOAll right. I'm gonna stop the recorder at 220. END
OF INTERVIEW jg/
April 3.2019 For:

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATE
Related Attachment( - MRE Attachments

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF -
Reference Number:
CASE NO. 19- 211277
DATE 27 March 2019

TIME 203 Hours
LOCATION Tampa General I lospital.' I' ampa, 171.
INTERVIEW OF
INTERVIEWI? D BY Del, K_ Renew; A13N 233650
RE' I" rEN': Today' s date is March 27. 2019, ll' s currently 2: 03 am, I in at TGl I
ABN... Detective RenewABN 233650. 1Fhis is in regards to IICSO case number 19-
211277. I' m speaking with Ms.' I' rinitr Fulmorc right? what'
your
date of birth Ms.' frinity? FULMORE: February 25,
said you' re fourteen years old'?FULMORE: Yes,
Do
con known the dincrence between a truth and a lie'!

FULMORE: Yes. RETIE W: Oka,.
told you that tour s , ealshin was pink is that a Imth or a lie^FULMORE: A lie. RET EW: Why
that a
lie? FULMORE: Cause my s, catshirt
blue. RI?"
FTE W:Okay- So
do you promise to (
ell me only the truth while we' re talking today'? FULMORE: Yes. RETTEW: Okay- 1
wanna
talk
to you kind of about wlun happened leading up to the police being called to...I understand
you were al your grandpas house tonight right! FULMORE: Yes. RFITEW: And you
there
wish %% he?For: 205814 Printed On: Map-
01- 2019 ( Wed.)Page 68 of 372

My grandpa, my mom and any sister and my brother.
R17 FIT W', Okay. And
Yes.
Rl' Yriw And your sister you' re referring to
Yes.
RETIT W:
Okay. So " hilt you guys " ere ( here visiting your grandpa what... what took place"
What happened? Did anything happen between you and or your sister and
Not betvicen me and bur " with my sister yeah. lic_ he was fighting_ But he
don' t he " astir Iighling. tic was arguing with her cause he " anted like cause
she... I don' t knots cause she has the key and he was like cause she ... like they were
just arguing. But then they both got out of the car. And that s when he scanted to gel
in the car but then my mom wouldn I Id him. So my mom had the key and she had
hit him on the head cause he was try ing to break into... I ike he was trying to break
the like car, like mess up the car. And then that' s when he had picked her up and
slammed her on the on the floor, on the concrete. That' s when she started
bleeding her head, She had laid down for a second and that' s when my sister had
called ambulance and in), my had called the cops and then that s when
we " waited. My mom " vent in the house and laid on the couch. I went in the
bathroom, We waited for like two minutes and we saw all the cops zoom like
every... like there was a lot of cops going down towards the store and the storage.
So tire and my sister cause like no cop came to the apartment. When we called no
cops came there, They all went down there and we didn' t know what happened. So
me and mt sister and my grandpa we stalked down there. And then that s " when
people was just talking and " c didn' t know what happened. At first we didn' t know
it was We just thought something happened. And that' s when a man he had
came from down there and he had said no, I had asked him " who- " ho got hurl or
like who is il. And he said it was a little boy in a redjumpsuir And then that' s when
me and
then Ihal'. s when the cops cause in' we " wanted to see our
brother. And like to sec if he was okay. And then that' s when.,, that' s when ox
started crying. And my mama had came down. And they had put my sister in
handcuffs cause she was mad And then that' s when my mama had came down. She
was crying cause,,, and ( hen we didn' t know who shot my brother. And yeah-
RE I- fI? W': Okay. I wanna just kind of back up a little bit and talk to you more about what
happened as to why your called and why you goes called for an
ambulance. ) on mentioned . was wanting the keys to the car. And where were
INTERVIEW OF Page J of 6
you at this point when the% were,.. when your sister and were arguing about
the keys?
I was with my mom. And that' s when my mom scent outside and that' s when my
sister mem inside with my grandpa. And that' s when he wanted to gel.. - cause they
both got out the car. And that' s when my mom locked the door and that' s when... 1
wasjust right there with my mom. And it was lust like she wa_s trying to like make
him stop touching the can That' s when he slammed her on the ground. And she hit
her head.
REl' TRW: You mentioned though your mom she was trying to gel him to stop tugging on the
door.
Ycs.
RETTEW: And she ... she hit him at some point?
Yes, She like... she . lust slapped him on the head cause like he don' t listen.
RFF1 F%V: Okay.
I hat' s all. That' s when he got mad and he...
RETTEW: So did she slap him hard'' Was it Just a pal on the head'?
It wash t hard. 11 wasjust a pal on the head.
RETTF\ V Just to like get his attention?
Yeah.
RHTTFW: Okay. And then what happened? What did do alter that?
lie picked her up and slung her... slung her on the ground. That' s " hen she starred
bleeding. And that' s when she just laid down on the floor and we didn' t know what
to do so that's when my sister...
RETTEW: Did you acmalll see him slam her on the ground' So you were standing there when
it happened'?
Yeah. Cause like I was right there by the car.
RETTEW,
Okay So how_ describe it more to me how... how he picked her up and _ did he
physically pick her up oft the ground?
Like he just I don'( know like over his head. 1 don' t ._ yeah,
RETTEW: Okay. And was your mom... what was her reaction? What did she do right after?
All she did was lay on the floor like she just closed her eyes for a second cause 1
guess she was hurt and her back was hurl, and her head was bleeding. And me and
didn' t knot% what to do.
RETTEW: Okay. And so who ended tip calling the police or 9- 1- 11
My called the cops and my sister called the ambulance.
RETTEW:
Okay. And was your mom saying anything at that point'
She was like it' s okay, it' s okay. And then that' s when she got up and went in the
couch, in the bathroom.
RETTEW: And where did go after that?
Ile started walking out cause that' s what he always do. Like he ainl c... like every
time he get mad he walks oil -to take a breather or to calm down,
RE' i- mv: Okav, So after he slammed your mom on the ground he... he talked oil'
somewhere? Did you sec where he went?
lie just went straight down out of the apartments.
RFTll3 W: Did you see which way he went out of the apartments?
No. All I saw was him go out the apartments. 1 didn' t know which way cause I was
in the... I went back in the house to check on my mother.
RETTEW: And what was was he saying anything when he walked onor?
No. lie ain' t say nothing.
RETTEW: What was his demeanor'? Do you know what that means?
tic didn' t say nothing. Like I don' t know what his demeanor was.
RETTEW: Okay.
I was barely looking at him.
RFT7FW: Oka%. So then your calls the police. Your sister calls the ambulance. Did
your mom ever say what she expected to happen when the police showed up?
No.
RETTEW: Or what she wanted to do if the police were to talk to her about getting slammed on
the ground?
She didn' t wanna press charges.
RETTEW: Did she sac that to vou7
Yeah.
RErrEW: Oka.,. Tour._ pour brother has he ever done something like this before acted
aggressive out towards anyone before'!
No. Nol... he never slung her up.' rhal' s the first time he did that to my mom.
RETTEW: This is the first time he' s slammed her. Has he ever been aggressive towards you or
your sister any other time like that?
Not that 1 remember.
RETTEW: Okay Is there anything else that happened during this incident tonight that
you wanna talk about or mention?
No.
RETTEW: Do you have any questions for me that I... if I' m able to answer them? No'?
Why did they shoot him if he wasn' t like... if he wasn' t a threat9 lie was facing this
wac
RETTEW: I don' t...I' m not...
He was showing ( inaudible)
RFTrEW: I' m not gonna talk about anything that happened out there one because I don' t
know all the details. And two even if I did Fin not going to release all that because
we re very early on into what' s going on. There' s a lot of facts and information we
have to gather So I doll wanna... I don' t wanna out of fairness to you and
everybody else 1 don' t wanna ( ell you something without knowing all the facts
Okay, Detective Florio is speaking with your mom right now. Like he mentioned to
her once all the I -acts are gathered and the case is comPletc we' ll be able to release
any and all details that %on or %our mom or your lamily wanna know. Okay. But in
the meantime we' re not gonna release anything nowjnsl because I doll wanna
give you wrong infomtation okay. If you don' t have any other questions Iln going
to end the intemew at 2. 12,
1 iElitl i1
END OF INTERVIEW
jg/ April 4, 2019
GOP HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERYA BATTERY - AGGRAVATED

Reference Number:
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DA1 E 27 March 2019
TIME 2147 flours -
I- OCA' 1' ION I' ampa General I lospiral. Tampa, 17I.
INTERVIEW OF
INTERVIEWED 13Y Del. K. Reacw, A13N 233650
RI I" I' EN': Todac' s date is March 26, 2019. It currently 2147 hours.' 1' his is Detective Renew
A13N 233650 at' I GI I speaking with s
your birthday for the record'
RE' 1 TE W:
IJh- huh,
REYFEW:
And your son
RETIl9W: Okay and rchats his dale of birth^
RF 1- 1' I7W: I know I talked to you briellp before I started the recording. 1
rcanna just reiterate again what happened and why we were called to is it your
residence there on__
My dads.
RI: I- ITW:
Your dads, okay. "' hat happened leading us up to being called out there'
got in an argument. They were fighting. So they were sluing in

the car while I was visiting with my dad or whatever So they started arguing. 1
heard scream so I came outside and look the keys from both of them. Told
them both to gel out of the car. I locked the doors. And then
upside
the head. And he grabbed ore by the ann and he flipped me over his head and
slammed me On the ground 1 was like still for a second like cause it wok a breath
out of me so 1 was catching my breath and then and grandpa said rhey re
gonna call the police. I said don' t worn' about it. It gonna be okay, don I wom
about it. nor said no calling the COPS that you hit your head pretty
hard So got scared and he ran. I caught my breath for a second and then I
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERV- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF
Page 2 of 5
HCSO CASE NO.
went and got up and I laid on the couch. And I teas just waiting_ Then grandpa
came back and said oh they got him- So Fin thinking everything s okay. And then
I... I waited for the police to come but they didnl come. I had to go down there...
RETTEW: Where did this happen? In the outside in the parking lot"
Outside in the parking lot.
RETTEW: So between the car and tour dad' s house?
Yeah,
RETTEIV: Oka,. Did you e, cr... once you hit your head did you ever lose consciousness?
fluh- uh.
RETTEW: Did you go in and out of..
No,
RETTEW: consciousness that con can...
No I was just like shocked for a second.
RETTEW Oka,.
lie took the breath out of mc. I had to catch my breath.
RETTEW: Just stunned a little bit?
Yeah. I think...
RE I' TEW: Ila%c you ever had a con...
like my head nvs ringing you know like I was like cause this... it hit me pretty
hard cause 1 II... I couldn' t belie% c that he ( lipped me that...
RFTTE W: Oka,.
like that so quickly.
RETTEW: So he physically picked you up olTthe ground and... and threw you dorm?
Like just by my arm like he just like body slammed me. Like I just wem like he
grabbed me by my arm like he turned around, he grabbed my arm and he' s like
boom_ And I like flipped over his head, powAnd I hit the ground. I hit my back For:

IN'TERYIE"' OF
Page 3 or 5
HCSO CASK. RO.
and I hit my head. That" s all I remember.
RE I" PEN': Do you know what you hit your head on" Is it the...
I' he concrete, Yeah like the...
RETTEW: Like the curb or the asphalt'!
the curb,
RE"I' PEW: May.
The curb.
RETTEW: And then iehal about Did she have any physical injuries at all''
No,
RIiTTFN': No' Did you see how they were fighting or are they just_._
No. I didn' I hear I didn' I see it.
RF 11" I" EW: sibling fighting or whall
Its sibling fighting.
RETTEW_ Okay"
Just fighting.
RETTEW: And when you say you popped him in the head...
I just ( inaudible) to stop doing that...
RE rTEN'. Just to gel his attention'
yeah.
RETTEN'. Like to break them up from fighting)
Yeah. For him to stop hitting the door... pulling on the door handles.
RE ITEW_ For the car door handles?
Yeah.
INTERVIEW OF
Page 4 of 5
HCSO CASE NO.
REIEW_ Okay.
Cause I wasn' t there when they were fighting. 1 just heard scream he hit
me. So 1 came out and said both of you guys get out the car now.
RETTEW: Oka-,
And so I locked the doors.
RE ---FEW. Okay.
And he got mad and he was messing with the door handles.
RETTEW: Trying to get back in the car?
Yeah.
RETTEW:
Igo( you.
Or actually trying to break the door handle.
RETTEW_
Okay. And then so your is the one who end up calling because he...
Yeah_
RETTEW_ saw you guys fighting and...
No Cause he seen when flipped and he said I hit my head prelty hard. That
I...
RETTEW_ Oka-
needed to be checked out.
RETTF W: Did he see you get flipped or?
lie seen me get flipped.
RE' I" rrE W: OkaY.
Ile was there when I got nipped,
RETTEW: All right.
Yeah.
INTERVIEW OF
Pape 5 of 5
HCSO CASE NO.
RGT717N': Who else was there?
were there uto cause they were like that messed up, why
would you do mama like that.
RIB rTHW: Okay.
Why would you flip her like that. And he said well she shouldn' t ha%c hit me first.
RE 7W: Okay. And did your dad... other than and your dad did anybody else
see N' har happened?
No,
RI ITH W_ Okae And so at that point your said he was calling the police''
He' s calling, the police yeah.
RHTTEW: And that' s when
Ran.
RE' rTEW: ran off Cause he Was seared"
Yeah.
RliTI EW: Okay. Okay.
Yeah,
RF1- FF W: Were gonna tn. to get some pictures of your head . Where is it exactly that you
have an injury? In the back4
Thev say on the back of my head,
RETTrEW: Okay. All right_ I' m gonna end the imen' iew at 2151.
FIND OF INTERVIEW
jg/ April a, 2019
Related Attachment(, - MRE Attachments

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF - JOSE LUIS AVILES
Reference Number:
CAST NO. 19- 211277 DATE 27 March 2019 TIME

16051] ours LOCATION Inside
Assigned I ICSO
Vehicle in front of 1eyota of Tampa Bay, Tampa, PI_
INTERVIEW 0I7 Jose Luis Aviles
INTERVIEWED 13Y Det. J.Florio,
ABN 205814 FLORIO: It is Wednesday March
27". The time is 4: 05 pm. Deieciive Florio ABN 205814. And this is going to
be in reference to I1CSO case number 2019-2I1277. I' m currently within me vehicle in
front of the Tovota of Tampa Bay and I am currently With sir could you state
your first, middle and last name? AVILES- Jose Luis Aviles Junior.
FLORIO: A-V-1-L-
E- S'? AVILES- L- E- S, yup.
17LORIO: I low do you
spell Luis? AVILF3S: 1-U-I-

S.
FLORIO: ' lints why I ask
because [- in...
its spel d several di0erent Ways so. AVILES: Right, right.FLORIO: What
s your date
of birth"AVILES, 8/
4/96. FLORIO:
And what s -sour
address? AVILES: 15455 Plantaion Oaks Drive
apartment 6.
FLORIO: Plantation Oaks Drive apartment
6. Where' s that? Tampa? AVILES_ Tampa, yeah its Tampa,
cup. 171- ORIO- W hats the
zip? AVILES: 33647, FLORIO: And what'
s a
good phone number for vou? AVILES: 813. For: 205814 Printed
On: May-
01- 2019 ( Wed.)Page 108 of 372

INTERVIEW OF JOSE LIJ IS AVILES Page 2 of 18

FLORIO: Uh- huh_
AVIIJS: 4748299.
FLORIO: Mr Aviles before we went on recording I told you I was going to start a recorder is
that correct?
AVILES, Correcl.
FLORIO: And that ( he %%

a) %%e gm in contact %vas I, _ the way I understood it was you had
contacted our office however %%ou corrected me and said that ) on contacted Bay
News 9 who contacted the Sheriff' s 011ice,
AVILES_ Correcl.
FLORIO_ That' s all correc(?
AVILES: Yes.
FLORIO: Okay. If }'ou would could you raise your right hand. Do you swear and affmn the
statement )' ou' re going to give me is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the
truth^
AVILES: Yes.
FLORIO: Okay. As I understand it you contacted Bav News 9 according to what you told me.
What is it Thal you %%cold like to share with us?
AVILES: Just what happened_ I was... I was coming down the road of Skipper going towards
Nebraska.
FLOR10: Oka%,
AVILES: When I noticed there was a Sheriff that was pulling over to the side of the road 1
was behind him. And as he pulled over I slowed down. When he got out ( he car I
pretty much almost came to a complete stop because he was getting our of the car
kind of in the street. As he got out of the car I noticed there was a kid to the right,
like on ( he sidewalk kind of and the kid noticed him, the cop not... the Sheriff
noticed the kid. It' s like they made eye contact. And now the kid was gelling read)'
to tan away. He took... he back pedaled about three steps al ( hat same time the
officer had pulled out his gun, said stop, show me your hands and let off from what
I remember three shots.
FLORIO: Okay. So what kind of car where you in?
AVILES: I was in tar white Integra,
INTERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page S of Is

FLORIO: A w$ he?
AVILES: Acura.
FLORIO: Acura lmegra9
AVILES Yeah.
FLORIO'. Okay. Okay.
AVILES: here was a red Ford Explorer right behind me.
FLORIO: And the red Ford Explorer was behind you"
AVILES: Yeah,
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES: They stopped.
FLORID: Okac_
AVILES: I didn' t... I didn t wanna stop al the time because I just didn' t Hanna deal with that
Sheriff She was alone and you know I... it was just a situation I didn' t wanna be a
pan of.
FLORIO:
Okay. Can you describe who the deputy was speaking to? Or who he was in contact
yilh?
AVILES: The kid?
FLORIO: I he kid. ceah.
AVILES: Yeah. He was.-, he was from what 1 seen he was a African American male Ile was
wearing red.
FLORIO:
Okay. Like all red? Like red pants. red shin or how d Thai go'
AVILFS: I done know__ I know for a fact his... his shin was red- lie might' ve had a hoodic
on.
FLORIO: Okay. Were your windows up or were your windows down?
AVILES:
Mc windows were down. Yeah, My windows were down.
FLORIO'. Your windows were down? Okay.
For: 205814 Printed On: Mac- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 110 oT372
INTERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page i of 18

AVILES: Yes.
FLORIO: Did you have your music on"
AVILES: No,
FLORIO:
Okay, So you can... you have a pretl}' good hearing of what was going on'
AVILES:
Yes, yes my music, yeah.
FLORIO: Okay
AVILES: There teas nothing on.
FLORIO:
About how long was it hefore the... I understand you... von smy the deputy get out
of the car. 1' ou sate him make contact or or...
AVILES: Yes_
F LORIO: however it was.
AVILES: Yes.
FLORIO:
And what made you you made a statement about the kid seemed like he was
gonna run. What made you gel that impression?
AVILES: Oh cause I seen the kid Ile,,, he back pedaled like three limes and he was about to
hum to run when the cop pulled out his gun and shot him.
FLORIO: So at a certain point can you describe the body position of the deputy and the kid'
AVILES: Well the cop was looking at him and at this point he was coming around his door...
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES- to the kid but the kid was about to start running. So the cop at the some time he
just said stop, show me your hands and then let off three shots. There wasnl that
much gap between the waming and the shots.
FLORIO: So let me ask you and and maybe I should rephrase the question a linle bit better.
Where.,. was the deputy lacing the kid'!
AVILES- Yes.
FLORIO: In the red shin'!
AVILES', A hundred percent.
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page III of372
I NI' ERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page 5 of 18

IICSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: Okay. What... whal ens the position of the kid in the red shirt? Was he„ was his
hack to the deputy? Was his front to the deputy" Like howhow did...do you recall?
AVILES-
It might' ve been his side because like when he teas backing up he back pedaled three
spaces and he was gonna turn to his right to turn around. FLORIO:
Okay. So from " bar }' oure des_. AVILES_
Ile was veering to his right side so.FLORIO:
so from what cou described to me.._AVILES:
So probably. . FLORIO-
his fell side would-%

e been exposed to the deputy? AVILES:
Exactly. FLORIO.
Is that correct? AVILES:
Correcl. FLORIO:
Oka- N.So the ...the subject in the red shirt, his IcR . side was to the deputy. Was he looking
at the deputy or was he..AVILES:
lie sported the deputy and was gonna run. FLORIO:
Okay. So...
so it ap eared to you and correct me if Iln "Tong, it ap eared to you that
the%would ve made e%
e contact with one another'' AVILFS:
Right. FLORIO:
Okay. Did you hear any other dialogue? AVILES:
No. FLORIO:
Just stop, show me our

}' hands? AVILES:
Stop. shoo me %
our hands. PLORIO:
Do you recall any other statements being made? AVILES:
No FLORIO'.
When the...
as the deputy' s ap roaching the subject do you notice what his actions are
prior to the shots being fired?For:
205814 Printed On:N1ay- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 112 of 372

INTERVIEN' OF JOSE LIJ IS AVILES Page 6 of IN

AVILES _ The victim' s or the depul%'s?
FLORIO- The deputy' s-
AVILFiS: Well the deputy she...( really cant describe it much cause he was he was really
going fast like he got out of his car, came around the door and as the kid was
getting ready to run that' s when he said stop, show me your hands he had already
drawn his gun And thats when he fired.
FLORIO: That' s kind of whin I was getting at. So was his... his gun was out as he was saying
slop show me your hands?
AVILES: Yes, A hundred percent.
FLORIO: Okay
AVILGS: That' s why you know 1,,, I was so shocked with the situation because as he was
pulling out his gun 1 thought he was just gonna you know Iry to scare the kid,
whatever the case may be I did not think at any point that the cop was gonna lire
and he did. And I was even more shocked about that because I seen ( he kid and I
seen his hands and there was nothing in them. And so I just didn' t understand what
was (he point to shoo( him in... and non being biased towards Sheriff' s or police or
anything. I.., I' m a hundred percent non biased towards that I' m just going purely
based off what T%c seen and heard. You know what 1 mean.
FLORIO: Okay. So can you describe... did you have a good view of the subject in the red
shin? You said that..
AVILES: Of the...
FLORIO_ you could see his hands?
AVILES I did,
FLORIO: Okay. Where were his hands...
AVILES _ Like I said_.
FLORIO- in relation to his body?
AVILES: they were up like this.
FLORIO So we' re not on video. It' s an audio recording.
AVILES: Yeah.
INTERVIEW OF JOSE LEIS A VI LES Page 7 of 18

FLORIO: Your hands are up towards your chest_
AVILES: So towards his chest. yeah. Ile wasn' t like reaching or anything inside his pockets
or arolhing. I even believe though he had basketball shorts on but like I said it s, _ I
can really Tern... remember what exactly he was " caring but I,,, I clearly seen his
hands by his chest like if he was gelling in the motion to start running.
FLORIO: Okay. As the deputy and I know I' m asking a lot here to recall moment by moment
but...
AVILES Yeah. You gotta get down to the facts.
FLORIO: I wanna know exactly and I wanna In- to break it down by moment. As the
deputy is approaching the subject and is stating stop. show me your hands...
AVILES: Well... well he...
FLORIO: what is the subjects movement' s at that put of
AVILES: lie was... he wasnl... he didn I even approach the suspect. l hill' s what I' m saying
like honestly as... as he was drawing his gun and saying that he was standing... he
was standing still. lie wasn' t approaching.
FLORIO: The deputy was'!
AVILES: lie... at the time when he drew his " capon he was standing still.., he was
standing.,_
171- ORIO: And you' re referring to the deputy?
AVILES: in front of his car. Yes.
FLORIO: Okav,
AVILES: The deputy was standing still in front ol' his car,
FLORIO: May And whal was the subject doing at Ilnu point"
AVILES: lie was getting read)' to run.
FLORIO: Okay. Was his left side still exposed to the deputy or was he doing something else"
AVILES: When I say the deputy I saw _.. I heard the shots and the kid was like I just seen him
gel hit and I_. he folded otTlike thislie... he folded down. FLORIO:
And again because we' re on re...nor on video you' rejust kind of clutching.. For:
205814 Printed On:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 114 of 372

INTHRN1 EN' OF JOSE LU IS AVI LES Page 8 of 18

AVILGS: Yeah.
FLORIO: your ] ell side...
AVILFS: Clutching, yeah_
FLORIO: and going and...
AVILHS: YeahAndhe folded. FLORIO:
but he went down to the ground? AVILHS:
Yeah. lie folded down to the ground so h( e cop ( hen proceeded to say still after...
after the shots were fired show, me your hands. like he said show me your hands.
FLORIO:
Oka%,. AVILGS
And The kid obviously was shot. So the depot\, then walked over, approached the su._
the victim. And he..,
he rolled him over. FLORIO.
Oka%. AVILGS
He
rolled him over on his back side. So now the kid was like in cross position and he
was...he was seizing up,so that he was in shock. Like his body was flopping. FLORIO:
Is that something that you are assuming or is that something That...

AVILHS:
No. I witnes d. Like I... I se n. I se n the cop walk over to the kid, flip him over and
the kid lied there and with his arms wide open and was just shaking horribly. FLORIO:
Oka%. AVILES:
So I imagine he was going into shock at that point, FLORIO:
Okay. So where is... as all of this is going on and I am. and this seems like a pret y quick
event Is that correct? Would that be an...AVILI?
S:It was fast. FLORIO:
Oka%. AVILGS:
It was really fast FLORIO:
Where... were you stationary'? In other words was }'

our car stopped the whole time or
were you continually moving? For:

INTERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page 9 of 18

AVILES: I was moving at 1 can' t even say a mile per hour. Like me car was in neutral. I
had ... like so it was rolling by al nor even a walking pace.
FLORIO- Okay. So Your car was...
AVILES: So...
FLORIO- so il' I... tour car...
AVILES: so I had_,
FLORIO_ was idling?
AVILES: idling not but it wasn' t like even in gear so it' s like I came to a complete slop but
as 1 was you know I was... not a complete stop but I came to pretty much almost a
complete stop to where I was slow enough to where I didn' t- I couldn' t like mess
with anything that the deputy was doing...
FLORIO: Uh- huh,
AVILES: because I was giving him his chance to get aut of his car.
FLORIO: Sure.
AVILES: You know what I mean. So as... as he s getting out his car ( flat s when... when he' s
fully out of his car...
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
AVILES: that' s when I was about just getting past his car. So that' s when I seen the
whole_ that s when I was you know._ that s when I .. rhats how I seen e%enthing
because I was already past the car And I was already getting past the car so from
the honl of my car so this is his car, this is my car. From the front of my car he
muslvc been hke three to Irve feel from it
FLORIO: So he
AVILES: from the front of my car.
FLORIO: he was. , the deputy meaning...
AVILES: Yeah.
FLORIO: ssas three to live feel...
AVILES: From the front of my car.

FLORIO: from the front of your car. Okay.
AVILES: Right.
FLORIO: Soso and where...
AVILES So...
FLORIO:
in relation to that would'%% been his... his patrol % chicle?
AVILES: Right next to mines.
FLORIO:
So you N' Onld' ve been almost parallel 10 the patrol car.
AVILES: To the patrol...
FLORIO Is that correct'
AVILES_ chicle. Correct.
FLORIO, Okay. Okay. And the entire time was there anyone else in tour vehicle with vou°
AVILES_ No.' fherc wasn' t anybody. And ( hat... that' s... and I seen the people behind me
slop.
171- ORIO: Uh- huh.
AVILES So...
FLORIO: And you re referring to that red Explorer'
AVILES: The red Explorer, there was b%o oncoming vehicles and there was three behind me
but ( hat... that red Explorer had stopped. I don' t know about the vehicle behind
him.
FLORIO: Oka%
AVILES: But as__ as... the last image I seen was when the kid was,.. was prelty much going
into shock and... and Ijust kept rolling past at that point
FLORIO: So you just drove... just drove oil'?
AVILES: I did drive off
FLORIO: Oka% And there s nothing wrong with Thal. I' m just in ing m get a clear picture
of...
INTERVIEW OF' JOSE LUIS AVI LES Page 11 of 18

AVILES: Right.
FLORIO: cvcrn' thing else. Did you recognize anv other potential w' imcsses in the area?
AVILES: There was a nm ( fiat it can be... like as far as rou can you track ' cut down but [ here
teas a... a guy on a bicycle who had passed the kid prior to the... to the cop
stopping,
FLORIO: So he... so from what you're describing and correct me if I' m wrong...
AVILES: Yeah.
FLORIO- the bic}'clisl would' ve been in front of (he kid in the red shirt?
AVILES: Yes. So so we' re on the,., they' re on the right hand side.
FLORIO. Uh- huh.
AVILES: The cvclisl was going towards Nebraska as I was_
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES:
And ( he kid was also going towards Nebraska but when he... when the deputy had
stopped behind him he looked back and that' s whcn he looked back, seen that II
was a cop cot three shuffles back, was about to turn around again and that' s when
everything had happened.
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES: So the cop... so ( he deputy was already outside of his vehicle at the time that the kid
started shuffling back. Its not when the kid saw the car. lie saw the deputy.
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES: And then he started shuffling back. L.. and me I thought the deputy was going to
chase him. Deputy did not give chase. lie just...
FLORIO: Okav
AVILES:
But it was so fast that that von know what I in saying the kid didn' t c%en get a
chance to start actually running yet You knot%what I mean.
hLORIO: Uh- huh.
AVILES- Ile only got ( hose Iew back pedals.
FLORIO: Oka., But he still would- ve been... his Ich side would' ve been exposed,,,
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 1 I8 of 372
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY -AGGRAVATE

AVILES- Exposed.
FLORIO: to the deputy?
AVILES: Yeah.
FLOR10: So... so he wasn' t fully turned around I Ic was kind of like bladed almost...
AVILES: Right.
FLORIO: to his side,_,
AVILES: Right
FLORIO: to his left side facing the deputy.
AVILES: Right.
FLORIO: Okay. And... and you said bCfnrC and I just w' anna make sure it s clear that they
would' ve been meaning the deputy and the subject in the red shin would' ve been
looking at each other even ( hough the subject in the red shin would' ve
been._ would' ve had his left side exposed to the deputy_ But his head would' ve
been also to the let facing the deputy, correct?
AVILES: Right, Well,.,
FLORIO: Is that... Is that correct or"
AVILES: Well no so when the.,, when the kid spotted the deputy he was completely turned
around. He was. he was facing the deputy' s car and the dep... you know the...
FLORIO: So they would' ve been lace it, face, body to body?
AVILES: But far.
FLORIO: But_.
AVILES: Yeah.
I9- ORIO: a distance...
AVILES: Yeah.
I' LORIO: but still but...
AVILFS: body, eah.,.
INTERVIEW OF JOSE IX IS AVILES Page 13 of 18

FLORIO: but his front %could' ve been facing the deputy- s from.
AVILES: Front
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES: Yes.
FLORIO: So they,,,
AVILES: At the time of.., of them recognizing each other...
FLORIO: Uh- huh.
AVILES: they were lacing face to face preuy much.
FLORIO: Oka%. And then so describe that movement then from there. Like ho"... break it
down sequence by sequence.
AVILES
Okay. So thec spoiled each other and then as the kid got those leek back pedals in
the cop %%'
as already drawing his weapon.
FLORIO: Oka%.
AVILES: As soon as the back pedal started happening he ekas already drawing his " capon.
So I imagine that the kid was already turning around.
FLORIO: Well let s... let' s not imagine_ What do you remember'
AVILES: Thai s... yeah, that s so they %c faced each other, spotted him. I seen the kids eyes
get wide %then he seen the deputy, %% as gonna Stan running, back pedaled three
steps, cop drew his " capon and fired.
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES: And said,,, Said stop, show me your hands and fired. But from the time of the
dra%%...
FLORIO. Uh- huh.
AVILES:
to... In the point of you kno%v when he got on target and shot it was so quick.
FLORIO: Oka%,
AVILES: It was... it was fast like there was no wav you know what Fm saying the kid was
not reaching...
GOP HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
I NIFERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page 14 of 18

FLORIO: At... at...
AVILBS: for anything.
FLORIO: al what point though was the kids IeR side exposed to the deputy'
AVILBS: At the point atlhe shots I think. Like from what I remember 1... 1..
FLORIO: Okay. Cause and „ and.,
AVILBS: I' m not trying to say like 1 think because I... 1 was there like 1- 1 promise you I was
there but the __ it' s just that was a crazy situation for me. I' ve never seen anything
like ( hat happen ever in you know in my life So like but I know that the kid was
about to start running and the cop just stop, show me your hands and shot him.
FLORIO: Okav,
AVILBS: And I seen the kid go down. I seen the deputy walk over to him saystill saving show
me your hands, flipped him over. Now he' s laying on his back and he was shaking
like,shaking like I've never seen.FI.
ORIO: Okay. Sojust in summary again deputy gets out of his car AVILBS:
They spot each other. FLORIO:
They spot each other At this point the deputy is facing the subject and the subject is facing
the deputy_ AVILBS:
Yes_ FLORIO:
As this is hap ening is... IS the deputy moving closer to the subject or is the deputy standing
still? AVILBS:
The deputy was moving closer to the subject. FLORIO:
Okay. So the deputy' s closing distance then on the subject as the subject is backing up.
AVILBS:
Yes. FLORIO:
Is that correct' AVILBS:
Yes FLORIO:
Oka%. And then as the... AVILBS:
So the deputy got...

For:

INTERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page 15 of Is

NCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: the subject is backing up hear me out lirr a second.
AVILES'. Right, right, okay.
FLORIO'. And just correct me if I' m wrong,
AVILES S Okay. Okay.
FLORIO: Because I wanna make sure it' s right.
AVILES: Oka.,
FLORIO: Okay. Ilse deputy and the subject are lacing each other The deputy is walking at
lead advancing towards the subject and then the subject in the red shin is backing
up as that' s happening. Correct so far"
AVILFS: Uh- huh. Correct.
FLORIO: AI that point then the subject,,, the deputy.-. as the deputy is drawing his weapon
the subject is turning to his left.
AVILES: Yes,
FLORIO: Is that what happened"
AVILES: Yes_
FLORIO: Okay. Cause ]. just wanna make sure because there was a couple of ditferences
here... cause Originally y011 Said.., you had Just said that he was, just looking back
at the deputy from his IeJt side.
AVILFS: Yeah, Ile got,,, no, no.
FLORIO: Bw... but now you' re sating that they were facing each other and then that...
AVILES: That is correct.
FLORIO: and then the guy...
AVILES: Thal is correcl.
FLORIO: and then they...
AVILES: Thcy were facing each other and at first.
FLORIO:
Okay. Iles( wanna make sure cause I don' t want there to be any discrepancy in
whal you... what you say.
INTERVIEW OF JOSE LU IS AVILES Page Ib or 18

AVILES_ No, no.
FLORIO_ You know just that' s why I... I asked to make sure you clarity.
AVILES_ Yeah.
FLORIO Okay.
AVILES: So they were facing each other at first. The kid got a couple back steps. The cop got
a few steps in from of his vehicle like you said. The cop advanced just a few steps
in from of his car and then the %ic... the subject was back pedaling at that point so
he was... he back pedaled about three steps,
FLORIO : Okao,.
AVILES: And at that point it was when the cop you know the deputvjust drew his weapon.
FLORIO: Okay. And just now from the point the the depute drew his weapon describe what
the subject in the red shirt' s doing.
AVILES: He was getting ready to turn around and run.
FLORIO: Okae So is he fuming or is he still lacing the deputy'?
AVILES: Ile was fuming.
FLORID He was mming. And he would\ e been turning to his right, to his left? flow does
that work'?
AVILES: To his right.
FLORIO: Okay. So his left side would be exposed then to the depuly?
AVILES: Right,
FLORIO:
Is his face, is the subject' s face still looking at the deputy as this is happening or is
his head completely turned around as tcell? Or can you answer Thal?
AVILES: 1 can' t... I can' t answer that without... with fully knowing that That' s what happened
because I was looking at both... both parties. 1 was looking at thi deputy and I
was looking at him_ But at the ,.. I really paid attention to the deputy when he pulled
out the gun.
FLORIO: Sure,
AVILES: You know what I' m saying so when 1 seen__ svhen I seen him pull out the gun
1' m... my attention is fully focused on him. And then I just saw that... Ijust seen the
CO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF JOSE LUIS AVILES Page 17 of IS

trigger squeezes three shots.
FLORIO'. Okay,
AVILES: So... so to be very honest any attention wasn' t on ( he subject in the red shirt at the
point of the stop, show me your hands and... and him shooting.
11- ORIO So at that point though then you would not hate had an eye on the subject' s... on
the subject in the red shin in his hands at that point'
AVILES: At the point of the lire no.
FLORIO: Okay, Okay. So there could' ve been sonic IN pc of movement of the subject' s hands
at ( hat point"
AVILES: lie was gonna run like_.
FLORIO:
I understand. 1 understand. But what Fm asking you is...
AVILES:
His hands were up ( owards his chest.
FLORIO: Right.
AVILES:
When I took my eyes uH liffin , when I look my eves olYthat' s when the depute was
pulling out his... his gun. So that' s why I' m saying like...
FLORIO:
So your attention focuses on the gun and the deputy at that point!
AVILES: Right_ It was that fast,
FLORIO: Sure
AVILES:
Like as soon as he drew and he got on target it was... he let olY.
FLORIO: Okay.
AVILES: You know what I' m saying so it couldn' t have been Iha( much ofa gap I} om the
time ( hat his hands were up lowards his chest.
FLORIO: Sure.
AVILES: And when the deputy fired.
FLORID Oka¢ So but as ( he deputy is... is drawing his ocapon is he verbalizing anything°
AVILES: The subject?
INTERVIEW OF JOSE WIS AVILES Page IS of 18

FLORIO- No the... either one
AVILES:
The subject I didn' t hear a peep out of The deputy I heard stop, show me your
hands.
FLORIO: Okay. Okay. Excuse me. Is there anything that I haven' t asked you that you think
would be important"
AVILES: No,
FLORIO: Okay. Is there anything about your statement that you wanna make sure is clarified
or change about your statement?
AVILFS: No.
FLORIO: Okay I have no further questions. I' m going to end the interview at 4: 27 pm. Thank
ou.
END 017 IN' I' FRVIF W
jg/ April 3, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF- DEP L WEB ABN 253967
Reference Number:
CASH NO. 19- 211277

DAI 1 28 March 2019
TIME 0940 hours
LOCATION Wesley Chapel Area

KFERVIEW OF Dcp. L_ Weg. ABN 253967
IN ITRVIHWGU BY Ucr J. Florio, ABN 205814
FLORIO: It is Thursday March 28`s. The time is 9: 40 am. Detective Florio ABN 205814 This
is going to be in reference to I ICSO case number 2019- 211277. ]- an currently
within my vehicle in the Wcslee Chapel area oilh can you state %our name for me
please?
WEG: Leonard Weg.
171- ORIO: And what s your ABN'
W 17G: 253967.
FLORIO- Who do you work for'
WEG', 1- lillshorough Couno, Sheriff- s Office.
FLORIO: How long hayc you been Iherc?
WEG: About Three and a half years.
FLORIO: Thrce and a half years'!
WEG: Yeah,
FLORIO: What district are you assigned to?
WEG: District I.
FLORIO: What squad do you work on'?
WEG: 108.
FLORIO: Is that A shift or B shift'?
WEG: B shill nights Bravo area
FLORID:
Okay. Were you working on Tuesday night?
WI: C: Yes.
INTERVI F,WOF DEPUTY LF.ONARD WEG, ABN 253967 Page 2 of 7 HCSO

CASE NO. 19- 211277 FLORIO:
Okay.
What teas...tccre you dispatched or did you arrive on a call at 1250 Read?
WRG:
Yeah. I wasn' t dispatched to it. I responde alter hearing shots fired over the radio. FLORIO:
Okay. So when you heard shots fired on the radio do you know tvho had said that on
the radio'? WEG:
Deputy
lislanislau. FLORIO:
Okay. Do you remember what time you got to the scene?
It was 1949_ FLORIO'.
You got there at 1949" WEG:
Yes sir. FLORIO-
Okay. So when you arrived at 1949 where did you arrive to?WEG:
So
1 came. I was coming from Fletcher and 230, FLORIO_
Uh- huh. WEG:
leaving
a disturbance. I came up Nebraska and went east on Skipper from Nebraska.
FLORID:
Okay. WEG:
And 1 parked my car lust cast of the incident area along the road. FLORIO:
Okay On the north side or the south side? WEG:
South side I blocked the cast bound lane of travel on Skipper.,. FLORIO:
Okay WI7G:
on the south side of the road, FLORIO:
OkaY. Was there anybody else at that scene at that time? WEG:
Yes.
So when I got out of my car I saw Deputy Estanislau, Deputy Perez and Depuy.
O'Brien tending to Mr.
Okay W17G:
who was on the ground And then Deputy Richardson approached with his For:

INTERVIEW OF DEPU I Y LEONARD WEG, ABN 253967 Page 3 or7

medical bag.
FLORID: Oka,. What actions did eou take when you +vcnl to the scene,
WEC- When I got there I got out of my car. As I drove there I drove past FMS was staging
so I asked them if it was okay for EMS to come in and then I think Deputy O' Brien
got on the radio told them it was. Deputy Richardson then approached
with his bag and Deputy Estanislau stood up and I walked over to him to make sure
he was okay.
FLORIO: Oka,. Did von engage Deputy Estanislau in any conrer5ation'
WEG- No. I mean I just told him roil know I put my hand on his shoulder I was like you
know are you good, you know, making sure he' s okay. I didn' t ask him about what
happened or anything like that.
FLORIO: Did he make arty statements to rail?
WEG. Yes. So he was kind of like pacing around. Nou could tell he was frustrated you
know upsel. And he was just like you know why he make me do that. And I
was... ]. just asked him if he needed water, it he wanted to sit down in my car
anything like that And he._ he just kind of walked mound for a little bit And then
he ended up silting down in the passenger seat in my car far a minute. I offered him
water you know ifhe needed food or anything like that. And I sal in the car with
him until a supcn isor came over,
FLORIO: Okay. Did he actually make the statement saying whe' d he make me do Thal?
WEG: Yes.
FLORIO_ Meaning Deputy I9sianislau said why did he make me do [ hat?
WEG: Yes.
FLORIO Did he offer any other type of statement front there"
W' FG: After that when he was sitting in my car you know he was just like you could tell
he wasjusl silting there you know like I said I wasn' t asking him anything like that
but he... he wasjusl like how' d I... how' d I get him in the back. And I ... I said to
him did he turn and he kind ofjust stared. And I was like I' m sure it was a blur and
then he didn' t reallr... he didn i comment after that.
FLORIO, tic said-_ Fsmnislau said to }' oil how did I get him in the back?
WEG, Yeah.

RCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: Okay_ Did he... what- I manna break ( hat down a little bil.
WEG: Yeah Thai' s line.
FLORID: I low did he... what did he say alter that meaning Esianislau^.
WEG: Yeah. Well I said to him you know maybe he turned, did he turn and he didn' t
respond. And I was like I' m sure it was a blur And then ( hat was pretty much it. So
I think at the time he believed that he had you know hi( him in the back. Which is
why he said that.
FLORIO_ Okay. So but so just to be clear and I wanna make sure...
WEG: Yeah.
FLORIO-
that I have it right. When Depulc Estanislau says to you hory did I gel him in the
back and then you stated to him maybe he turned_
WEG: Uh- huh.
FLORIO. Is that correct'
WEG: Correct
FLORIO: Oka%.
WEG- Yeah.
FLORIO: And did Deputy Estanislau respond to your statement?
WL'G: No.
FLORIO: Okae So he made no further statement from there"
WEG: No.
FLORIO: Okay.
WEG: No. ' then I mean we stayed in my car until you know a supervisors kept coming
over to him and then he went with Corporal Nikic.
FLORIO:
Okay. Was there any other statements made by Esianislau to you whether they be
pertinent or not pertinent to the investigation?
WEG: lie asked me if 1 though( he was going to get tired.
FLORIO: When did he say that to you?
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVEIOPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTER VIENV OF DEPUTY LF-ONARD \ VEG. ARN 253967 Page 5 of 7

WEG: Toward the end of the time like he was sitting in my car. So aIt. yyou know after he
said you know after he asked about hcnv did he hit him and then s%e were sill ing
there. And he %% as just you know like I said you could tell he was thinking kind of
in shock, a little bit upset, and I' m sure the olicels were spinning. And he lust was
like you know do you think I' m gonna get fired.
FLORID: Okay. Did you respond to that question'
WEG : I did. I told him I don' t know but 1 kno%%you got three great supervisors thafll you
know have your back,
FLORIO: Okay. Is there any, other statements that he teould-%e offered from there?
WGG. No.
FLORIO:
Okay. Did you ask him any other questions at that point"
WI7G: No.
FLORIO: Is there anything that I have asked you... that I haven' t asked }'ou that }' on think
would be important as it relates to any statements or,., or an) circumstances that
you observed at the scent?
WEG: Not,.. well so \%hen I got there and 1 think I put it in my Supplemenl.
FLORIO: Okay,
WEG: You know I noticed he was laying on the ground and then there was this cell phone
was about too feel west of him on the sidewalk there.
FLORIO: When von say.,,
W17G: There was a cell phone there,
FLORIO_ A% hen you say he who is he'?
WEG: 1 guess was laving on the ground and then there was like
a black cell phone on the sidewalk in front of him.
FLORIO: Okay. So a black cell phone seas in the vicinity of
WEG: Correct, correct-
FLORIO:
Okay. Do you remember what as wearing'?
VEG: I believe he was wearing a red shin but they had it pulled up as well so cause you
know they were tending to his wounds.
For: 205814 Printed OD: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 130 oF372
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERV- AGGRAVATE NTE. RYI E W
OF DEPUTY LEONA RD WEG. ABN 253967 Page 6 of 7 HCSO CASE- NO. 19-
211277 FLORIO: Okay, Did you
participate in lending to the anything medically with... with. WFG: No. FLORIO: like
any quick
clot
application, any...anything of that nature? WEG',No. No the
deputies that were on scene were... FLORIO: Okay. WRG: were
doing that
by the time I got there. FLORIO: And( hot was
O' Brien, Perez and Richardson" WIiG: Yes, I don'
t know,,, I know Richardson approached with his medical bag.FLORIO: While you were
approaching' WF.G:Yes, FLORIO:
Okay, WL' G:
Yeah. FLORIO'.
But Perez was
already there? WEG: Correct. FLORIO: Okay.
And what'
s his first name? WIiG: Armando. FLORIO: Armando
Perez? WIiG:
Yes, FLORIO: All
right. Okay.
So to your knoeiedge Perez was already on scene when you got Ihcrc? WEG: CORCCI. FLORIO:
Okay.
Is there
anything else that 1 haven i asked you that youve or an)statements that were made that...
that made to you pertaining to the investigation at the scene? WIiG No. FLORIO: Okay.
That' s
all 1 have Do you have any questions for me as it relates to the For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 131 of372

IMFERVIEW OF DEPUTY LEONARD N' EG, ABN 253967 Page 7 of 7

HCSO CASE NO. I9- 2I 1277
invesligalion?
WEG: No.
FLORIO'. Okay. Then I to going Io end the recording at 9: 48. thank Nou.
GNU OF IN FERVIGW
jg/ April 3, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF - CPL Al NIKIC ABN 227443
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED KIERVIEW
CASE NO 19- 211277

DATE 29 March 2019
TIME 1921 Hour
LOCATION HCSO D- I 14102 Norlh 20" St., pampa, FI.
INTERVIEW OF CpL M. Nikic, ABN 227443
INTERVIEWED BY Del. J. Florio, ABN 205814
FLORIO: It is Friday March 290, The time is T21 pill. Detective Florio ABN 205814. This is
reference I1CSO case number 2019- 211277, Iln currently within my Vehicle in
front of the District I office at 14102 North 201h Street. I to with Corporal...
NIKIC', Marinko Nikic ABN 227443.
FLORIO_ Okay. Corporal if you would raise your right hand. Do you .swear or affirm
everything you re going to tell me is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the
rulh'?
NIKIC: I do.
FLORIO: Okay. Prior to going on recording I told you that I was not going to go through )' our
entire statement. I just had a follow up question for you. Is that correcl?
NIKIC: Yes sir
FLORIO: Okay. When you arrived on scene did you observe or did you remove any properly
from the subject on the ground?
NIKIC No I did not sir.
FLORIO: Okay. Did you observe anyone remove any properly from the subject on the
ground?
NIKIC: I did nut observe anybody- EMS was working on him so I didn t even sec
any... anybody taking anything Gom him.
FLORIO- Okay. And as I understood it you basically came kind ol' a little bit later in the
investigation.
NIKIC Thal- s correct sir.
FLORIO: Okay. Did you... as you arrived on scene did you recognize anything that you
would perceive to be physical evidence at the scene?
NIKIC I believe I saw a black object which I think was a cell phone laying on the ground,
I NTERVIEWOF CORPORAL RI A R I NKO NIKIC. ABN227443 Page 2of2

17LORIO_
Okay- Was there anything peculiar about that cell phone?
NIKIC: As far as 1 can remember I think it had a little stand If I can remember correcl]_r it
looked to me like it had a little stand
FLORIO, Okay. Did you or do you know of anybody manipulated or moved that object'?
NIKIC: I do not know. I did not touch it and I don' t know if anybody touched it
FLORIO: Okay. That is all the questions I have kir now. Is there anything that' s come up that
you know —that you think would be important that I need to know°
NIKIC No sir,
F LORIO: Okay. Then Fin going to end the recording at 7: 23 pot
FND OF INTERVIEW
jg/ April 3. 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF - CPL M NIKIC ABN 227443
Reference Number:
CASE N0. 19. 211277

DATE 27 March 2019
TIME 1508 Hours
LOCATION Undisclosed Local ion
INTERVIEW OF Cpl. M. Nikic, A13N 227443
INTERVIEWED BY Der J. Florio, ABN 205814
FLORIO: his Wednesday March 27' .' ncc time is 3: 08 pm, Detccli%c Florio ABN 205814_
This is going to be in reference to HCSO case number 2019- 211277, ]- in currently
within my % chicle in a undisclosed location with sir could you state your name and
rank'?
NIKIC Yeah, Marm ko Nikic Corporal with the I I i I Isborugh County Sheri lF's 0Irc , FLORIO:
Okay, And what' s your ABN? NIKIC
227443, FLORIO:
Okay, And corporal if you would could cou raise your right hand? NIKIC:
Yes sir. FLORIO:
Do on swear and anion the statement )' ouTe going to give is the truth, the whole truth
and nothing but the Truth? NIKIC:
Ido. FLORIO-
Okay. What squad do you work on sir? NIKIC
Squad 104 which is the Bravo actually Alpha midnights in district 1.FLORID:
Okay. What shill? NIKIC
It' s 13... 13 rotation. FLORIO:
Okav Were you working Iasi night? NIKIC.
Yes sir I was. FLORIO:
Okay- And are you the direct supervisor of Daniel Estanislau? NIKIC
Yes sir. FLORIO:
Oka% Can you tell me in your own words how you became aware of...
of a call for service
last night in the.. at 1250 For:

INTERVIEWOF COPORAI- NARINKO NIKIC, ABN 227443 Page 2 of

NIKIC The... the call came o%cr the radio. And I didn' t initially hear c%cp5hing (hat %vas
going on. I knew it came in,,. in as a 671 which was a person down which was
changed to a domestic just occurred. And then there was a lot of commotion on the
radio so [ just put myself in route towards the call. On my %% ay there I heard that
the._ one of our deputies discharged a firearm, that we were invohed in a... in a
shooting,
FLORIO: Okav Oa %ou,,, did you recognize the voice or he" did you become aware ol' who
was the actual shower?
NIKIC: 1 didn' t... until I got to the scene I did not know who was the shooter.
FLORIO: Oka}'. Do you remember " hat time you got to the scene?
NIKIC I.. I hit that scene immediately. 1 can look up my_..
FLORIO: Okay. I' ll look that up later.
NIKIC Yeah. yeah.
FLORIO: That' s line. But as you arrived on scene how... how many Sheriff- s Office
personnel %%ere on scene by the time you got there?
NIKIC There was a lot ofthem. they were already pulling the ycllo%%(
ape...
FLORIO: Okay.
NIKIC'.. around it. Fire rescue was already there. And two of our deputies were close by
to the where the lire rescue i%as.
FLORIO: Oka%, So what did you do nest?
NIKIC As I approached I met with the Deputy Weg,
FLORIO- Okay.
NIKIC: W- Ii- G, met with him and I ask him hey did we gel m%olved in this he said yes.
And I said who fired the gun and he told me Deputy Estanislau.
FLORIO: Okay.
NIKIC Deputy Estanislau was close, standing close to Deputy Weg. Deputy Wcg was in
the middle of the roadway. Deputy Estanislau was on the south side of the roadway.
FLORIO: Oka%.
NIKIC Offof Skipper Road.
INTER\' IF.N' OF COPORAL MARINKO NIKIC. ABN 227443 Page 3 of

H CSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
FLORIO: Okay. So on the south side, so on the opposite side of the road where the... the
shooting occurred.
NIKIC That' s correct. yes sir
FLORIO: Okay. What did you do ncxr9
NIKIC I approached Deputy Estanislau and I kind of moved him a little bit further from
the... from the immediate incident scene
FLORIO: Okay,
NIKIC
And he %vas pretty shook up, emotional. lie was almost he ryas kind of holding up
his ( ears. lie wasn' t crying but he was I thought heat one point he may start crying.
He was pretty... pretty, emotional. And 1 told him heycan you just give me a brief synopsis_
Don' t gel into too many details. Just give me a brief synopsis of hat %% happened
so I can relay that to nest in line of like my sergeant, lieutenant and everybody
else. FLORIO:
Okay. And where did this take place? NIKIC
It look place literally just south west of maybe.,. FLORIO:
What I mean by that is were you guys in the car or in the or on the street'? NIKIC:
We were actually on the street. %alkyd towards For not sure if that was Weg' s car. I belive
that was Deputy Weg' s car. FLORIO:
Okay, NIKIC:
Which
N'as a lit le bit...
a lit le bit NCst of where this all took place. FLORIO:
Okay. So and correct tie it I'm %%' rung. Weg informed you that Eslanislau was the shooter"
NIKIC
Yes sir FLORIO:
Okay. So then you approach Estanislau and you asked him forjusl a very brief synopsis
of hat
%% occurred? NIKIC
Yes sit FLORIO:
Okay- And what...and did Deputy Estartislau give you a synopsi ? NIKIC
Yes sir lie did. FLORIO:
What was...
from what you can remember " hat was the gist of that? For:

INTERVIEW OF COPORAL MARINKO NIKIC, ARN 227443 Page 4 of 6
NIKIC He told me that he was actualIN he was on his war to a diRcrem call, it was a
shoplifter in Alpha I.
FLORIO- Okay.
NIKIC This call came out. It' s in his zone so he tells the dispatch to free him up of his 307
and to put him on the domestic.
FLORIO: Okay.
NIKIC: As he arrived he encountered a person, a subject I' m nor sure if its a while male or
female who pointed at Ihe... or subject that was shot,
F LORIO: Okay.
NIKIC: Pointed al him saying hey that' s him, that' s him.
FLORIO: Okay.
NIKIC: Deputy Estanislau pulls his car Inrther mesl. I believe ( lie subject was walking west
bound.
FLORIO: Okay.
NIKIC: Deputy Estanislau pulls his vehicle over there, stops the vehicle, exits the vehicle
and addressed the subject. lie said hey can I talk to 5ou.' fhe subject in
a... according to Deputy Fsmnislau in an abrasive way is like what there' s nothing
to talk about, what do you want to talk about Deputy Fstanislau tells him hey [ just
want to talk to \' ou gmckl\', Ihe\'' re going to talk to the Other part% and well get to
the bottom of il. AI that point Deputy Estanislau obsmcd a black object in the
subject' s waisi band,
FLORIO: Okay,
NIKIC So and it appeared that_.. it appeared m hiol that the subject " as reaching tier it.
FLORIO: Okay.
NIKIC Dcpmv Estanislau drew his " capon, Ore weapon and gave him commands to drop
the eun, drop the gun. drop the gun.
FLORIO: Oka%.
NIKIC And I in not sure how many limes he told him but at least in his words at least two
limes that he told me.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED I NTERVIEWOF COPORAL
MARINKO NIK I C,
ABN 2743 Page 5 of IiCSO CASE NO.
19-211277 FLORIO: Oka% NIKIC:
Maybe even
more 1 don' t know. 1 didn' t ask him specif s. FLORIO: Oka%.

NIKIC:
So at
that
time the subject made a motion like if he was pulling something out, like if he was
pulling out the firearm. FLORID: Oka%.NIMC
And fearing
for his safety Deputy Estanislau fired ...

discharged his firearm. lie told me he fired
Iwo limes. FLORIO: Okay. Did
he
use those words for his safely? NIKIC No he
did nut. FLORIO: Okay. NIKIC:
not,., FLORIO:
What was
his... what was his words that he used? NIKIC I lejust
said
that he thought it was gun and he fired. FLORIO: Okav, Okay,
All
right did you take any other statements front him? NIKIC tic told
me
that alter the subject went down that he went and gave him first aid. FLORIO: Oka%.NIKIC:
lie put
glo% es on and applied pressure on the wound, lie said he was communicating. lie asked
the guy hev were you shot. lie said yeah I was The guy. , the subject
that was on the ground was alert and talking- FLORIO: Okay. NIKIC
lie told
me where., he asked the guy where he said in my back. FLORIO: Okay. NIKIC:
On my
back so he just applied the pressure until other units responded. FLORIO, Okay. Did
you... did he make any other statements to you throughout the night? NIKIC No, I
told him not to.For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 139 of 372

GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED INTERVIEWOIF COPORAL MARINKO
NIKIC,ABN 227443 Page 6af6 HCSO CASE NO.

19-211277 FLORIO: Okay. NIKIC
Unless he
talks to you guys and our legal department. FLOWO: Okay. Okay.
Hate you learned of any other information through other deputies regarding this investigation?
NIKIC No sir
my primary responsibilav . vas Iasi night to stay with Deputy Estanislau and accommodate CID with
whatever needed to so 1 didn t retalk to unles. I mean 1 read some reports
and everything else but I haven' t talked to anybody directly. F LORIO: Okay.
All right. And did he describe any sort of and again I don' t am you " to put what you... whal
he may hayc been implving bill the actual words that he might' ve said. Did he
describe any other movements of the subject!NIKIC: No. No
he did not. FLORIO: Okay, All
right, NIKIC: I just
asked him did you find the gun, I le said no he didn' t alter_..alter the. FLORIO: Okay. NIKIC
the shooting.
I Ic told me he never found a gun =,

where, FLORIO: Was there
any other statements that were made throughout this?NIKIC No sir,
that' s il. FLORIO: Okae All
right. that s all I hayc Do you have any questions for me:'NIKIC No sir.
FLORIO. All right.
I WIII slop the recorder at 3:I6 pal Dtank you. END 017 INTHRVIEW
jg/April 3,
2019 For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-

2019 ( Wed.)Page 140 of 372
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVEIOPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Related Attachments) - MRE Attachments

Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED INTFRVII? W
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DATE 27 Match 2019
TIh11i 1541] ours
LOCATION Tampa General Hospital, Tampa. FI.
INTERVIEW OF
INTERVIEWED BY Det_ K. Rettcte, ABN 233650
RETTEW: Today' s date is March 27, 2019. It' s currently 1: 54 am. This is Detective Renew
ABN 233650 in regards to HCSO case number 19- 211277. I' m speaking with. . at
TGH with
RIiTTEW: oh it' s I' m sorry. right?
Uh- huh.
RIiTTEW: And what' s your date of birth for the record?
RB ITEW Oka) And that makes you seventeen'?
Sixteen I' ll be seventeen.
R17 FIT W_ Sixteen you' ll be seventeen with )' our... okay. can you raise your right hand
for me? Do you swear or affirm to tell me the whole truth and nothing but the
truth?
Yes,
REF1' li\ V: Okap. You can put pour hand down. Do you know what the difference is belo cen a
truth and a lic?
Uh- huh.
REITEW: Okay. So if I told ) ou that blanket was black is that truth or a lie'
A lic.
RIATEW: Why is it a he?
Cause it' s white,
RE TTEW: Okav And while we' re Talking today you promise to tell me the truth about
GOO HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INl' ERYIEW OF Page 2 of

everything?
Yes.
RI TTEW', Okay. I just wanna talk to you about kind of what happened tonight that led... I
understand your is the one who called right?
Uh- huh.
RETTEW: Called the police?
called too but I called for the ambulance for my mom.
RFe' ITEW: Okay.
Yeah.
REITFW: So tell me about that. What... whin happened prior to you calling or why you had to
call?
Me and my brother were arguing over the key cause he wanted to sit in the car but
my mom took ' em. And he was getting mad trying to break the door handle. So she
just slapped on the side the back of his head and he picked her up and slammed her.
She fell on the floor. So my got scared because . she like laid there for a
morale. And called the cops. Then I called the ambulance. called the police but
they transferred over to the ambulance. So I got the ambulance to hum'. And
called the cops. And then walked on,
RE 11 BV. Okay. And when you refer to your brother that.,.
RI- 1- 1 EW Youre talking about right"
Yes.
R171TF- W:
Prior 10 your mom taking the keys away were you guys... ahv %%
ere ) on at that
residence"
I uas seeing in) grandpa.
RETI' I? W:
That' s where your grandpa lives?
Uh- huh.
RI?TTE W.
And were youdid you go inside the house? Were you inside the car" Where were you
guys al't For:

INTERVIEW OF 1` 2ge3 of
HCSO CASE- NO. 19- 211277
I scent inside the house to see my grandpa but we were standing outside the car Me
and my brother we was arguing outside the car
RETTEW: And what were you guys arguing about? Do you remember?
He woulddt give me the keys cause he wanted the keys.
RETTEW: Was there any argument before Iht though?
Iluh- uh. Not with me and him, I don' t know. Ile just„
REITEW',
Not With you and your brother?
Huh- uh_
RETrEW_ Who... Were you...
It Was no arguments, no.
RI?' ITEW_
Okay. Did your brother While you go) s were arguing about the kc)' s did he
ever... did you guys ever gel into a physical altercation?
Yeah. we al vat's do. Ile just like grabbed my head and banged it on the what' s it
called, the car in the car Ilejusl banged my head.
RETTEW: What do you mean he banged your head?
Like he grabbed me by my hair and he just banged my head. But We tight all the
time, Like I hit him back. And he hit me,.
RE' F1l7w: Mai. So just a little sibling...
Uh- huh.
RE F"fE W: like kind of hand fighting type of thing?

Yeah.
RETTEW: So I mean he grabbed your head and hit you against what pan of the car?
Like the ... like I don' t know I couldn' trealiv tell cause he Was like grabbing my
head. 1 can' t see anything,
RIB Lf E W: Okay.
When I got up I just went in the house to tell my grandpa cause I was cq ing. l"hen
he said sorry and he was acting all belligerent. Then my mom came out and look
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERVA BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF Pape 4 of R
the keys from us. And then he slapped... she slapped him.
RF" fTEW: Okay.
And then he slammed her.
RF 1- 1 EW: What do you mean by he was acting belligerent'
Like he just him- Like he sjust a loud person_ So he' s just yelling and stu fisayIng
I' m bothering him. And she just said well give me the keys. Nobody has the keys.
Then she took the keys in that the argument.
RFTTFW_ May So after he hit your head into the car you went in to tell your grandpa that
that happened'?
My grandpa and mymom. RETITW:
You told your mom_. FULMORE:
RE'
I-
I' IiW: that ryas in there too?And so she found out that he hit your or something and.,
FULMORE
KETTEW:
that' s when she look the kevs a va r"Okay. And then what did he do nest once the
keys were taken array? FULMORE:
like,,,she slapped him in the back of the head because he tried m break the door handle
in the door, IJe tried to break The door handle. lie %%
as going around the whole
car. And then when she slapped him he picked her up and then slammed him...
slammed her on the concrete. RE"
I"
YEW: Okay, What do you mean b\'
she slapped hint?Can Non describe hON' that eka5I FULMORE
you know how like discipline your child like don' t do that. Like that' s how she
popped him on the side of his head. RF"
I"
I' EW: Okay. So not like hard but...
FIJLMORE3
Site doesn' t like hit him. RETITW:
just to like tap him'?FULMORE:
RE7TEW:
Just to get his attention or something'? Yes?Okay. For:
205814 Printed On:May- 01-20I9 ( Wed.) Page 144 of 372

GOP HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATE
Yeah.
RETTEW: And then... and that' s when he picked her up.
And slammed her,
RETTEW: And can you describe that? Do you know where he-
Ile picked her up like a...
RETTEW: grabbed her?
like a wrestler, like a wrestler would pick up somebody. Just picked her up and
slammed her,
RETTEW_ So physically picked her off the ground...
Yeah.
RE' r'rEW: and like threw her down into the ground?
But she' s so little and I guess he forgot like who he was,,, he just picked her up and
slammed her, And my grandpa got scared cause he didn' t want. _ Cause she just laid
there. And I was scared too that' s Nfiy I called the ambulance. But he was scared
cause he' s scared of my brother. My brother is... crazy.
RETTEW: Why? What do you mean by ( hat?
No like he' s not like crm. y, crazy. Hes just like ._ he' s just aloud person. Like our
whole family is loud so.
RE TIti W: Okm.
My grandpa was scared for my mom shes on the floor. Cause she fell like on the
curb but she hit her head on the parking lot.
RETTEW: Okay. And what is... how long_. did you see your mom on the ground? What %vas
she acting like or?
Yeah, My mom was like she laid on ( he floor Ibr like a minute and ( hen was
just like staring at her lie was about to cry because he seen what he did. And 1 told
him don' t go near her and then when my... he seen my calling the cops
that' s when he just walked off
RETTEW: walked oM
Yeah,
INTERYI EW OF Page 6 or
RE' I- I' EW:

Okay. What point did you call for the ambulance?
called when she was like ... like offer called. called when seen her like
getting up and she was like acting drowsy. So I though[ something was strong with
her head so called And he transferred me to the ambulance.
RE' 1- fEW: That was after your had already called?
Yeah.
RGTTEW: Said was culling the police?
was calling on his own time.
RGTTEW: Okay,
1 just know called
RETTEW: Okay.. And then so walks all'. Did you see where he went?
No. I know he i, cm out the apartment complex but I didnl know_. if he went that
tea) or this tea)'.
RFTTE11'_ Okay. And did you sec him at all again after that'
Yeah. I seen him " hen he was laying on the floor after that. That s the last time I
saw him.
REYfEW You' re talking about lacing on the floor?
Yeah,
RETTGW: Where was he laying on the floor'?
Down there with the cops and stuff.
RETTGW: Okay. Outside of the apartment complex?
Yeah.
RGTTEW:
And when was ( hat? When you guys were..
When everNihing was o%er and he was like ... like it was like .. like after he walked
out and in, called the cops, And me grandpa came out and said the cops
got hint. So me and ntp sister went to go check. And it was like too many cops for
just one kid. So me and my sister went and looked and they said somebody was on
the floor and had got shot.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED INTERVIEW OF CHASITY
FULMORE Page HCSO CASE NO.

19-211277 RETTEW: Okay. So
who
all was ( here when your mom got slammed on the ground by lames? FULMORE: Me.
and my grandpa. RETTENK And your
sister is Trinity right?FULMORE : huh.
So she
actually saw- FULMORE Yeah, R17
him
gel. h
- im slam your mom too?Okay. Did your mom sap anything when she got off (
he
ground or? FULMORE : No she
she was okay. She told my grandpa no( to call the cop... the police but he said he
gonna anyway just to be safe But she said she was okay. I just wanted to make
sure. RETTEW_ Okay. All
right You say your brother is I guess you said your whole family is loud is what you
said. FULMORE : Yeah. RFTTHW:
las
your brother ever acted like that before with your mom or any of you guys? FULMORE : No. Like
he' s like emotionally like handicapped. So hejust...sumelimes he just bursts out

and does his own thing And if... like sometimes he' ll walk off and do ( hat But
he' s not like. -like all the time bursting out. yelling and like he's just._he' sjust
some... like If he gets m' ad hell walk away- It's like only a little bit of times he
yell. But he' s no( like..yeah. RETTEW Okay. Is
there anything else that happened tonight during that time that you wanna talk about or"
FULMORE No. RETTEW:
Do
you have any ques( ions for me if I can answer ( hem for you? FULMORE: 11uh- uh,
Okay. Where...
and Trinity was right Su is she gonna have kind of the same information that you
do'FULMORE : Yeah. RETTEW
I'
m gonna talk to her a little bit too all right. For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 147 of 372

IN] ERVIEW OF Page 8 of 8

IICSO CASE. NO. 19- 211277
Oka,.
RFTI ENV: All right. I I you don' t have am questions for me I' m going to end the intcn icw at
202.
OAar.
END Ol' INTERVIFW
jg/ April 4, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF - ANNETTE CADDY
Reference Number:
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
TIME 21071[ ours
LOCATION Inside Assigned I ICSO Vehicle west of Skipper Rd.,' I' ampa. FI.
INTERVIEWOF Annette Gaddy
INTERVIEWED BY Der. D_ Tabor, ABN 218707
GADDY: See on the ( inaudible)
TABOR: All right. Today' s date is March 26, 2019, It' s approximately 2107 hours. I' m
De(ective' fabor A13N 218707, And Iln conducting this interview in reference to
I ICSO investigation 2019- 211100. I' m here inside ol' my cur at Skipper Road
or lust " es( of Skipper Road lis myself and Aix. Annette Gaddy is that
correct ma' am'?
GADDY. That' s coffee(.
TABOR_ Can you spell your full name for the record for me Ms_ Gadd}' 7
GADDY: Annette A- N- N- GT- T-E Gaddy G- A- D- D- Y.
TABOR: And when' s your date of binh his. Gaddy'
GADDY: April 28. 1958.
TABOR: And what' s a good address for you?
GADDI': 4011 Bain Wood Courtpampa, Florida 33614. TABOR:
And your phone number is"

CADDY :
8134697254. TABOR:
All righ(. Can you do me a favor and raise your right hand?And do you swear and alloari
that everything youre going to tell me tonight is going to be the truth? GADDY_
Yes. TABOR:
Okay. ' Thank you %

cry much. Before rye get started are you currently under (
he influence
of any drugs or alcohol'? GADDY:
No, TABOR:
Are you currently on any medications that would pre%

enl you from having this conversation
with me right not'!For:

GON HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED INTF. RVIF- N' OF
ANNETTE GADDY Page 2 of 17 HCSO CASE. NO. 19-

211277 GADDY: No. I' ABOR:
And you'
re feeling other than being scared and a little nervous and ev rything with what you witnessed, other
than that )on re okay to talk to tire?GADDY: Uh-huh, TABOR
Okae. You' re
in your right state of mind and GADDY. Yes. TABOR: Okay.
We were
called here in reference to a deputy in some kind of shooting investigation is what my

understanding is. And I was instructed or requstd to conic Talk to you
because you may have witnessed something. GADDY Uh-huh. TA130R:
Is that correct?
GADDY: I hat' s
correct. TABOR: All right. Can
you just Stan from the beginning and tell me you know kind of where you' re coming from
and what cou saw. GADDY Well I just
dropped my grandso off in Tampa Palms. TABOR: Uh- huh. GADDY
So I was
coming
back, on me way back to me house over on Bain Wood. I usually cut through oil" ol
Bearss onto Skipper Road and then go over to Fletcher. So today I saw a light
when( police of icers light when 1 was... when I turned onto Skipper Road off of
Bearss as I was approaching. So Iralic was slow coming Through I'm assuming
because of the light because the light was blinking, 1 here were probably two can
ahead of me. two or three cars in front of me. TABOR Uh-huh, GADDY
that I remember.
And as I was approaching to pas the police officer' s car 1 saw the officer out of
the vehicle and was approaching sorrictm , a man or a boy with red._dres ed in red,
had a like a red ho dic, a red shin, long sle ve shin. As the officer was approaching I
saw the person lo k back and then Stan to run, And then I Just... I heard thre
pops, po , pop, pop and then the person Icll to the ground. TABOR: Okay. GADDY And
by then
I' in like passing and seeing the person on the ground. And I first For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

Wed.) Page 150 of372
I N' rERVIEW OF ANNET' 1' F. GADDY Page 3 of 17

pulled over right here by the Renmlex.
TABOR: Okay,
GADDY:
l"hen I was gonna pull off but then I was like no, I can' t, So I just pulled over right
here where I am_.
TABOR: OkaY.
GADDY:
and stopped. And I just kind of Waited. Then I got out my car and 1 walked up to
the sign and was asking you know if he was okay, if he was alive you know and 1
never did gel any answer from that so.
TA13OR:
Okay. Well I appreciate you having the where With all of stopping and you know
sharing with us what you Tressed. Okay. And I apologize that you ... you
witnessed that. We' re in a car right now and ( his can t_-this audio recorder doesn' t
have a % idea camera on it. Okay.
GADDY: Uh- huh_
TABOR:
But you' re pointing over here and the car I' m assuming the car that you' re pointing
to is...
GADDY: My red.
TABOR: is it this red Explorer?
GADDY: Uh- huh. Yup. And I was traveling in that direction.
TABOR: Okay. So you' re driving that red Explorer.
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: And you' re driving west bound on Skipper Road. Is that correct?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: From Bcarss'?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Now you said when you turned on or when you were at Bearss turning onto
Skipper you saw a light?
GADDY: When I turned... after 1 turned off of Bearss onto Skipper as 1 was approaching I
saw a light, the police officer s light flashing...
INTERVIEW OF ANNE9TE GADDY Page 4 of 17

11CS0 CASE. NO. 19- 2I 1277
TABOR. When you sac...
GADDY: on the car.
TABOR: so what colors were the lights'
GADDY: Blue 1 think.
TABOR: Were they like...
CADDY Yeah.
TABOR what' s on there now'
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR, So the overheads?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Okay. Were you... how far do you think you were away from that car'?
GADDY, When I saw the lights?
TABOR, Uh- huh,
GADDY: I was right down there by like where that laundromal. that little plaza is as you
come around that curve.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY:
And I noticed the lights were ( lashing. I was on the phone at that time talking to my
daughter. And 1 said wow a Sheriff car is down here flashing, 1 wonder what' s
going on you know. It was slow so.
TABOR: Where was the car at, the car that had the lights on'?
GADDY: It was down there by like it was past that, down by the US Storage. like right by
the store_ There' s a little store...
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY down there too.
TABOR: Was the cars like parked, stationary or it was moving?
GADDY It was parked, It Was parked. 1t was silting still.

TABOR: And was it one of these marked cars that say Sheriff on the side?
GADDY Yes.
TABOR:
Okay. By the US Storage sign? Is that what you' re...
GADDY: in thinking. yeah. Cause there' s another store so it was like between the US
Storage, a little bit passed the storage coming back this
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY, Cause I know 1 passed the convenience store.
TABOR: Okay- So do you... do you think it was, and if you don' t know you just-,
GADDY: And it' s... yeah.
TABOR: you don'( know. I' m not_.
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR: I' m not...
GADDY: I in not sure. I know it was between that Remales and that US storage.
TABOR: Is where that car that had lights on was parked^
GADDY: No. The car was a little bit passed that.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Because the guy started running and he started running it was right there by the
storage, And then 1 saw him go dorm it . yasn" I that far from that. flow far is Thal? I
can' t see.
TABOR: Well let' s do this. Lel' s get out of the car and walk over to that tape and maybe that
car is still there.
GADDY: All right.
TABOR: All right? May We' ll. just walk on this side over here. We' re not gonna be going
past that tape but obviously it' s dark outside right no"'.
GADDY: Yeah. It' s like right about where the... where that probably "' here that first car is
right there, where the lights arc blink.,. where the lights are shining, right about
there.
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACT] VE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
INTERVIEW OF ANN' ETrE GADDY Page 6 of 17

HCSO CAST NO. 19- 211277
TA13OR: So we got this group of people and tehere that car is at'?
GADDY Yeah.
TABOR: Okay. So it technically is between the Rentalex sign and the US Storage sign.
GADDY: Now you re talking about the Sheriff car ( hat I saw^
TABOR: Yes,
GADDY: Okay.
TABOR: This... is that what were talking about?
GADDY No. See I' m thinking it was cause I sat%the car when I was approaching. So I
passed 1 know I passed (] rose houses down there...
TABOR: Oka%.
GADDY: those units.
TA130R: Uh- huh.
GADDY: So the car was like about down ( hat area.
TABOR: Okay_ And it was parked?
GADDY It was parked and the lights were Hashing.
TA13OR: Okay. Which direction was it lacing'
GADDY- 1 was coming in this direction so the car was facing this direction as well.
TABOR: Okay. All right so but you' re not sure about where that...
GADDY:
I' m not sure exactly where cause see I see a car down there flashing.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY: I saw the light flashing and then I came down and I sm% a SherilTcar sitting on the
side.
TABOR: Okew. Was it still on the roadway or was it on like the shoulder'?
GADDY It was kind of like on the shoulder of the road.
TABOR: And it was facing west? The same direction you...

GADDY: 11 was facing this way, yeah_
TABOR: OkaY.
GADDY: And then I saw the officer out ollhe car.
TABOR: Okay. We can go back to my car.
GADDY: I didn' t see him gel out.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY_ But 1 knots he was outside the car when 1 saw him.
TABOR: Was there only one car?
GADDY: One car,
TABOR: Okay,
GADDY: With a flashing light that 1 saw_And ( hen
TABOR And You said there Were two or three cars in front of You!
JONES: and then when I came down yeah, there were some other cars in from of me.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY. hm sure they smY but they didn' t stop.
TABOR: I understand. So the car that had its lights on pulls off on the shoulder, is pulled off
on the shoulder of the road on the north side with his lights on, And...
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR_ you' re now approaching'
GADDY: And that was a little ways doom and I' m still... I- m still coming clown, approaching
tthen I sec that.
TABOR: How fast do you think you' re going?
GADDY'. Oh probably about thirty because it' s slow, Usually you come through this street
you get through okay. But I... I' m assuming cause the lights were blinking cause
that s why I slowed down_ I slotted down because I saw lights flashing. And then
when I got L- I approached a lillle further then I saw Sherill'

TA13OR: Okay_ So you approached the car or you' re coming, you approach. You see the
deputy standing outside the car?
GADDY Uh- huh.
TABOR: I low many deputies were there'
GADDY: One,
TABOR: What side of the car was he standing on?
GADDY: lie was standing on the left side of the car and he was walking.
TABOR: Would that be the driver' s side or the passenger' s side'
GADDI": The ._ that would be the driver side.
TABOR Okay. At this point are }' our windows up or down?
GADDY, My windows are up.
TABOR_ All your windows are up'!
GADDY: All my windows were up.
TABOR- Okay. What' s the deputy doing when you see him there?
GADDY: I see him appr._ walking towards the person in the red.
TABOR: Okay. Ile' s just walking?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR Okae Is he doing anvthinti? Is his arms moving' Do you see anything in his hands'!
GADDY:
I didn- 1 see his hands moving or anything. I just saw him walking towards that
person.
TABOR: Can you describe the person he was walking towards'!
GADDY : I,,, I just assume a man, dressed in red. I sas%him look back.
TABOR_ Who is he?
GADDY The man in red and start running.
TABOR- Okay.

GADDY: And that' s when I heard the three pops. And 1 looked and I saw him fall In the
ground.
TABOR: So the man looks back at the deputy, Then he takes on' running.
GADDY: lie starts running.
TABOR: Which direction does he run?
GADDY This way, the same direction our cars are pointing in.
TABOR: And for the record you' re pointing to the west towards Nebraska Avenue.
GADDY: Ycah.
TABOR: How far did he get before you heard the pops?
GADDY: Not... not very far at all. It was a few... maybe a lew steps. It was close I mean it
felt like it was close proximity..
TABOR_ And how many pops did you hear?
GADDY. Three.
TABOR: What would you describe those pops are? I ntcan do you know what they were?
GADDY- I assume it was a gun.
TABOR. Oka,,
GADDY.
I heard pop, pop, pop. Pop, pap, pop yeah, three times,
TABOR_ Where were you al when you heard pop, pop, pop?
GADDY: When 1 heard? What do you mean?
TABOR: Like so when you heard the pop, pop, pop were you passed the depotand the other
guy or...
GADDY:
I was like right there. I was like right cause there were two...
two cars ahead of me. TABOR:
Uh- huh. GADDY:
They were like a lit le bit alreadv passed. TABOR:
Okae For:

INTERVIEW OF ANNEIT I' E GADDY Page IU of 17

GADDY: So when 1 heard the pop, pop, pop 1 was like right there beside, pretty much beside
passing" here ( fie) were standing,
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY:
And all of us, the first three, four cars put on brakes.
TABOR', Uh- huh.
GADDY:
I know we were all... ( know the car in Item of me put on brakes. I put on brakes.
And then I look over and that' s kind of saw the guy falling to the ground.
TABOR:
Did you sec or did you sec anything in the guys hands that was wearing red?
GADDY: I fuh- uh.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY:
But I wasn' t really looking, you know. I wasnl looking for anything in anvbody s
hands to be quite hones(.
TABOR: Okay. Did that subject make any sudden or furtive mcwemems like...
GADDY:
lie looked back. lie made did this and stun running.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY
I -le looked back. Stan running.
TABOR_
When you initially saw the deputy approaching the subject what was the subject
doing' Was he standing there" Was he walking? Was he running'
GADDY: tic was walking.
TABOR: And he was walking wcsr'
OADDY1 Uh- huh. I - le was Walking this way.
TABOR:
Okay. Did you hear the deputy say anything to the guy^
GADDY: I1uh- uh. 1 mean I could assume that he was saving something but I didni hear
anything. I don' t knout what... if they had a conversation what it was about or any
of that.
TABOR:
So the subject' s walking away from the depute and the deputy s approaching him.
At some point that subject looks back and then takes off running'
INTERVIEW OF- ANN F: 1' TF- GADDY Page II of 17

GADDY: Yeah. I saw the subject walking, I s'aw the Sheri ll' approaching him_ I saw him turn
around, the guy in the red turn around And I guess saw the Sheriff and Stan
running, turn around and start running, So he did a quick look back and then stars
running.
TABOR: Okay. You couldn' t hear any conversations or commands or anything by the deputy
or the subject?
GADDY: Huh- uh,
TABOR: Did you see any lurti%e movements made by the subject? Like going... his hands
like going towards his pockets, his waist bands, anywhere?
GADDY: 11uh- uh_ I just saw this lust looking back and running, looking back and going.
TABOR: May.
GADDY: That' s all I saw.
LABOR: And when just to be clear when you heard the pops the subject was running away
from the depmy?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: Okay. Was anybody else in your car with you?
GADDY: Huh- uh. Saw one man he w' as walking that direction towards Nebraska. When he
heard... he said when he heard the pops he fumed around to come back to see what
happened. But he didn' t see anything. And then there was another man coming up
on this side on a bicccle and he said he... that i1 was a good kid. And 1 was like oh it
was a kid. You know so 1 don' t know. I le said he knew him and he was a good kid
and he diddl do anything Io anybody. You know but 1 don' t know I don' t knmy if
it was a kid or an adult- I just hope they lice.
TABOR- The guy who was walking towards Nebraska and turned back around...
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: allcr he heard the pops what d that guy look like or is he white..
GADDY: lie was...
TABOR: Hispanic?
GADDY he was a white guy. lie had like a... kind of what kind of dark blonde hair.
INTERVIEWof ANNETTE GADDY Page 12 of 17

TABOR: Oka%,.
GADDY: And he was a older,,, older gentleman.
TABOR: About how old9
GADDY: I anuld say late forties, Fifties,
TABOR: What was his build?
GADDY: Fie might' ve been about Ove... five four, lice live fie had facial hair, some beard
you know like he needed to shave.
TABOR: What was he wearing?
GADDY: Oh gosh_ 1 don' t remember what he was wearing. I wanna say a plaid shirt but Iln
not sure.
TABOR: Pants. shor10
GADDY: Pants.
TABOR: Like leans or khakis?
OADDY', Like khakis.
TABOR: Do you know what color they were'!
GADDY: Like light, the light khaki tan_
TABOR: Shoes?
GADDY: I don' t remember shoes.
TABOR: Did he look din) or clean°
GADDY', Ile looked din%.
TABOR: Like he was homeless maybe'!
GADDY: I don' t know if he was homeless.
TABOR:
Okac. Anvbody else tha eou saw around^.
GADDY: Huh- uh.
TABOR:
And that guy that was walking he said he didn' t see he didn' t actually see what

happened'? IIc just heard the pops?
GADDY:
Uh- huh. lie said he heard it but he said it was good... he' s a good kid, You know_
TABOR:
Okay- All right. So I' m gonna go ahead and, lust sum it up_ If I say something that
incorrect please let me know, You were taking your grandson home and dropping
him offal Tampa Palms?
GADDY. Uh- huh,
TABOR:
And you were driving back. You said }'on were on the phone with your daughter?
GADDY: Uh- huh,
TABOR:
What' s your daughter' s name'?
GADDY. Shannon Simpson.
TABOR:
Do you know her phone number oil of your,..
GADDY
Not off the top of my head.
TABOR,
You didn' t ... did you record the incident or anything like that?
GADDY: I was getting... when 1 was getting ready to record a Sheriff car came and kind of
pulled in and then I couldn' t,,, didn' t gel to do anything else.
TABOR, Okay.
GADDY Okay. My daughters number is 6132825.
TABOR: 28259
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: And that' s 8137
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR: So you -re on the phone with her You turn from Bearss onto Skipper and %,on see a
car, a police car, a marked police car that says Sheriff on the side facing west bound
with his lights on pulled off on the shoulder of the road_ You kind of described to
me possibly between this Rentalcx sign and that US Storage sign. Is that accurate°
GADDY Uh- huh.
TABOR: Okay_ A couple of cars in front of you ) on were going about thirty, miles an hour
INTERVIE W OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 14 of 17

but it' s starting to sloedown because the car is there. You see a deputy standing on the
driver' s side You only saw one deputy') GADDY:
Uh- huh. TABOR:
Was he wearing a unifonu? GADDY:
If I'm not mistaken he had on a white shin. TABOR:
Oka\. GADDY:
I rem b a white shin and then I sae' blue gloves. I don' t know when he got the blue
gloves but I rem ber a white shin and blue gloves. TABOR:
When you so)'blue gloves are you talking about like garden gloves or like latex gloves;
GADDY,
Like latex gloves. TABOR:
Okae
So one dcpmy %%caring a white shin with latex gloves, blue approaching a subject
that vs
%% walking %,cst bound wearing all red. GADDY.
Uh- huh. TABOR:
As you get closer and you' re about next to him the guy who s walking away from the
deputy looks back and then lakes off running. And then you hear three pops. GADDY.
Yeah. Let me. 1

_. wan a stop you because_, TABOR:
OkaY. GADDY
I di n I sec the latex glove until after...TABOR:
Oka,. GADDY:
until after he was...he...was... until alter the man was shot. TABOR:
Okay. Did you see who shot the man' GADDY:
Yeah. TABOR:
Okay. Who shot the man') GADDY.
The deputy. TABOR:
So you actually saw the shooting? For:

INTERVIEW OF ANNE7TE GADDY Page 15 of 17

GADDY: Yes.
TABOR: Okav Did you.
GADDY: And I heard three pops.
TABOR: Okay. You heard three pops. Did }' on see any flashes or...
GADDY: I luh- uh.
TABOR: Nothing?
GADDY: I didn' t see any flashes.
TABOR: May.
GADDY: AI first I thought it was not a gun. 1 thought it was like... it was like that... but it was
three pops so I %% as like that had to be a gun. It wasn' t his... at first 1 was Thinking it
was the laser thing. But I was like no,
TABOR',
Did you see any lasers?
GADDY: Huh- uh.
TABOR',
Youjust heard three pops'
GADDY', I just heard pops_
TABOR: Did you ever see a gun in the deputy. s hand'
GADDY: I can' t even saY I saw the gun.
TABOR:
Okay. And I m not trying to trick you. I' m just trying...
GADDY: Can' t even say... yeah_
TABOR: to be clear.
GADDY: I knosc
TABOR: You understand what I' m saying?
GADDY: Yeah, 1 do.
TABOR: So you' re saying that you diddl see a gun in his hand?
GADDY: I didn' tsee a gun in his hand.
NTF. RYIF. N' OF ANNE ITF. GADDY Pope 16 of 17

HCSO CASE- NO. 19- 211277
TABOR: And you didn' t sec any flashes'?
GADDY And I didn' t see any flashes.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY I heard pops.
TABOR: But the only two people that you saw right there wen that deputy.
GADDY: And that man.
TABOR: and that guy in the red'
GADDY: Yeah,
TABOR: Okay. Okay. 1 just wanted to be clear on that okay.
GADDY: Yeah. Yeah. I understand.
TABOR. So then alter you see the subject fall dorm to the ground you stopped there and
then at some point...
GADDY: I stopped. yeah right there where the available...
TABOR: Signs arc'
GADDY_ sign is right there.
TA13OR: Okay.
GADDY: I was stopped like between right ( here on that street.
TABOR Oka,,
GADDY And then I realized okay I can' t stay right here, I need to pull up.
TABOR May.
GADDY: After I sat there for a minute cause I was kind of shook up. I was like oh in)- God.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
GADDY:- Did 1 just sec what I... you know.
LABOR: What you Thought you sate,

GADDY: Yeah. And then I that time I' m talking to my daughter I' m like oh my God I just
saw somebody get shot. And...
TABOR: Oka%.
GADDY: so she was like are you okay. You know and I was like 1.. 1 don' t know. I need to
pull over. So 1 pulled over and I was like oh my God I have to sav something. 1
cant walk... drive away and not sav something.
TABOR: Okay. And then you pulled over here.
GADDY: And 1 pulled over right there, yeah,
TABOR: All right. And just to be clear you never heard, all your four... all your windows
were up?
GADDY: My windows were up.
TABOR: And you slated earlier ( hat you never heard any kind of dialogue between...
GADDY: No dialogue between...
TABOR: the deputy and the subject''
GADDY: no dialogue a( all.
TABOR:
Okay_ All right. 1 just wanna be clear on that. Is there any other...
GADDY
It was like a silent ... a silent movie I didn' t know anything that was except what
1.. what I could see while I was driving.
TABOR: Okay. All right. Is ( here anything else that you think is important that I need In
know that you haven' t shared with me?
GADDY: Huh- uh_
TABOR: All right. A( this point I' m going to go ahead and conclude the interview. ItS
approximately 9: 31 pm, Still March 26, 2019.
BND OF INTERVIEW
jg/ A pril 4, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED INTERVIEW OF - ANNETTE CADDY
Reference Number:
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DA' lli 26 March 2019
7 Ihlli 2143 Hours
LOCATION Inside Assigned IICSO Vehicle wcsl of Skipper Rd, Tampa, Fl,
INTERVIEW OF Annette Gaddy
INTERVIEWED 13Y Del. D. Tabor, A13N 218707
TABOR: All right I' m back on the record with Nis. Annette Gaddy. Is that correct?
GADDY Uh- huh.
TABOR: This uhhh._ it' s still March 26. 2019. It' s approximately 2143 hours. I had told you
that I was gonna go down there and relay the information that you had provided a
few minutes ago and that I d probably have some follow up questions with cou. Is
that correct?
GADDY: Uh- huh.
TABOR; And prior to me turning this recorder back on did I ask you anv questions
pertaining to what I' m investigating?
GADDY'. Yes- Did you ask me questions?
TA13OR: Yeah. Did I ask you any further questions or did 1 just kind of explain In pau this is
ohm we' re gonna do... we re gonna ... did I fell cou hev would von mind coming
back over answering a couple questions?
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR:
And then I' m gonna fake you up there to the tape and kind of have you point to the
car and then ask you some specific questions about the positioning of
individual.
GADDY: Oka%.
TABOR: Is That,.,
GADDY Yes.
TABOR: correct?
GADDY: Yes.
TA13OR- Okay. All righl. Before we move up there did anybody else talk to you before me"
Did any lICSO personnel...
For: 205814 Primed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 166 of 372
INTERVIEW OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 2 of

HC50 CASE NO. 19- 211277
GADDY: There teas_..
TABOR'. interview vou?
GADDY: there was a Sheriff actually one started, then another one came up, another one
took over.
TABOR: Was it a male or a female?
GADDY.
It was a male. Then a female came. The Icmale passed it onto another male. So I
ended up talking to a... Io a gentleman,
TABOR: Do YOu know an)' OI their names?
GADDY: I don' t remember any names. She was... she started but then she passed this
young lady here she passed it over to another gentleman.
TABOR: Okay. The firs( male do you know what he looked like'
GADDY: 11uh- uh.
TABOR: Is ( hat who you talked to right there' Is that the female?
GADDY: I talked to... that' s the Icmale.
TABOR: Oka.'.
GADDY: She started the report, She someone else gale it to her, She started it. And then
someone asked her to do something and so another gentleman__
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: she passed it onto somebody else.
TABOR: Okay. The gentleman that' s standing with her is that him?
GADDY: Tm not sure if its him.
TABOR: If I call him over here do you think you could recognize him?
GADDY: I know that' s not the first one, so yeah if you call him maybe I will
TABOR: We' re on... we' re on a recording right now. She had mentioned that she started
talking to a deputy originally and then that... the deputy passed her on to is this her'?
GADDY: Yeah,
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY- AGGRAI' ATED
INTE R V I E W OF ANNE' I- I' E GADDY Page 3 of 8

lICSO CASE. NO. 19- 211277
TABOR: Deputy...
MAGRO: Magro.
TABOR: Magro. Okay. And then you passed her onto Depuy,,.
MACRO: Blyth.
TABOR: 131 11i. Is that accurate'
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR: Okav
GADDY Yes.
l"ABORT And he did the intemew with you?
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR_
Okay. Thanks guys. Okay. AI any point when that subject was walking or running
did he ever reach for anything?
GADDY: I just saw him turn around.
TABOR: Okay.
CADDY: 1 don' t know if he if he reached far something when he Was turning around. I
don' t know.
l' A13OK: Oka%.
GADDY I just know T saw him look back at the officer. lie looked back and then he Stan to
go,
TABOR, Okay Did he actually stop walking and look back ar Was he continuing to Walk
when he looked back'
GADDY lie,.. he stopped,
TABOR: Okay. Was he laced away from the deputy though When he looked bock?
GADDY When he looked back he was lacing the deputy cause he was going forward. He
was Walking forward.
TABOR:
Looked back at the deputy walking lanyard towards him)
INTERVIEW OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 4 of8

H CSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
CADDY
And the deputy was going towards him as I saw.., what I saw was the deputy going
towards him and then I saw him look back and start running_
TABOR: Okay I' m som%.I' m a little..
GADDY: I know.
TABOR: confused here. So the subject is walking away and the deputy' s approaching him_
GADDI': The deputy s coming from be... he' s behind.
TABOR: Okay, When the subject looks back does he continue to walk west bound or does he
actually stop?
GAUDY: He looked back and started to run.
TABOR:
Did he stop when he looked back?
GADDI': Yes,
TABOR: Okay. So he steps and he looks back.
GADDY: ties.
TABOR: Does he look over his right shoulder or his left shoulder?
GADDY:
I dent remember well sec. He' s walking this way. See I' m turned around this way
ifs kind of hard_
TABOR: Well were gonna go over there. If you want we' ll just... %well do it when we get
over there okay. Maybe that ll help when we' re in the right ... the right direction
here. All right for the record I' m gonna take Ms. Gaddy up here to the scene so she
can do a little bit better of a walk through with me. We' ll just stay on this side over
here. Okay. Everything happens on that side of the road correct?
GADDI` Bven thing' s on that side
TABOR: Okaw. All right. Do you see the vehicle that was parked on the shoulder that had its
lights on?
GAUDY: I' m thinking it was like about right here.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Because 1 passed the store.
TABOR: Uh- huh.
INTERVIE W OF ANNE' ITE GADDY Page 5 of 8

GADDY
I remember passing the store and I remember the light blinking dorm there, I saw"
the lights flashing or theme turned on.
TABOR:
Okay, Well iher re pretty bright lights so its possible you could' ve seen the lights
blinking all the w' ay down there.
GADDY Yeah. And then I saw yeah. The car teas about right here in this area here.
TABOR: Okay. So you sec...
GADDY: Is that the car'
TABOR: in , I don t know.
GADDY: It looks like it. I mean...
TABOR. Okay.
GADDY: that' s the area it was...
TABOR: Obviously the lights are have been turned all'_
GADDY: Cause I... % salt. I was about in this area right here.
TABOR: May. So the guy ' in the red, where was he at in relation to the car?
GADDY', Probably right there by that pole.
TABOR:
Mae. And at that point when you see him he' s walking,..
GADDY Ile walking.
TABOR: west bound?
GADDY
That way. yes.
TABOR:
Okay. And then where' s the deputy at'!
GADDY_ Standing up I wonna sac at the front. near the front of his car.
TABOR: Okay.
GADDY: Moving, walking that wm}'_.
TABOR All right.
GADDY: uncards the person_
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY - AGGRAVATE
INTERVIEW OF ANN ETTE GADDY Page 6 of
TABOR: When he starts walking towards that subject what... what' s the subject doing'!
GADDY. He' s walking.
TABOR: Okay. You play the subject
GADDY And...
TABOR: You sec the subject walking. Okay.
GADDY: he looks ( his war...
TABOR: So...
GADDY and starts to run,
TABOR: for recording purposes you just looked over your Iefl shoulder.
GADDY lie looked that Way.
TABOR: Towards the deputy?
GADDY: Yes.
TABOR: Is he still walking when he looks back or does he__ does he stop'
GADDY. He no, he stopped.
TABOR: Oka%.
GADDY Ile was walking_ lie stopped, looked back and then started running.
TABOR: Okay. I low, far did he get or how many... do you know how many steps"
GADDY: I don' t know cause I heard...
TABOR: Oka%.
GADDY the pops and then 1 saw him fall down,
TABOR: Okay. Did and you dent did you sec him reach for anything'
GADDY: I luh- uh. I didn' t even see the deputy reach for any... I didn' t see anybody reach for
anything.
TABOR: Okay. Did you see where the subject' s arms were al?
INTERVIE W OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 7 of S

GADDY: You mean when he fell,
TABOR: No, no while he was running or anything' _
GADDY: I just saw him num. I didnt see his arms.
TABOR_ Okay.
GADDY_ He looks familiar.
TABOR: All these guys. wc'%e all worked this area.
GADDY: This go% in the coat wish the ( inaudible)
TABOR- Yeah. Well but so he looks over his leli shoulder
GADDY: Yeah. lie looked back, start running.
TABOR: And For saying left shoulder. Is that correct^
GADDY Yes,
TABOR: Okay. All right. And he didn' t get very far it looks like.
GADDY: No, he didnl gel far at all only a few steps.
TABOR:
Okay. Just a few steps. All right we can go back, Thank von lift demonstrating that
for tire. Does that make it a little bit easier for you to...
GADDY: Yeah.
TABOR: kind of recall what you witnessed?
GADDY: What I smy.
TA13OR- Oka%,
GADDY Yeah.
TABOR. Besides those three deputies in the initial stages of the investigation did you talk to
anybody else besides myself?
GADDY: Huh- uh.
TABOR: As far as HCSO personnel goes?
GADDY: Huh- uh.
INTERVIEWV OF ANNETTE GADDY Page 8 of 8

TABOR: Okav
GADDY: Nobody else. absolutely not.
TABOR: All right. Is there anything else that you think you need to share with me or that
you know oP
GADDY', Huh- uh.
TABOR: Okay. At anv point did you ever tell anybody that you saw the subject reaching for
anything?
GADDY', Huh- uh,
TABOR:
Okay. All right. I don' t have any lumber questions. I' m gonna go ahead and
conclude the interview at 2152 hours still March 26. 2019,
END OF INTERVIEW
jg/ April 4, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED RADIO TRANSMISSION - 221521
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED RADIO TRANSMISSION
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DALE 26 March 2019
TIME 2215 Hours
CA LL INFO 221521- 221602 DI INFO
OPERATOR: Tuesday March 26. 2019 2215 and 21 seconds.
UNKNOWN: Ile), sir ION on info_
UNKNOWN: Where are con at)
UNKNOWN: Go ahead.
UNKNOWN: Where are con at'
UNKNOWN: Right outside nl Seaford Circle at Screnio Lakes.
UNKNOWN: All right. Then just 41 to 31,
UNKNOWN: It s a 31, lie s advising that a signal 0 teas pointed at him.
UNKNOWN: NI right. 10- 4.
UNKNOWN: I ley guys hump it up one were on inlb.
UNKNOWN: 10- 4.
UNKNOWN: All right We should... we should use a 31.
END OF RECORDING
jg/ April 3, 2019

Reference Number:
CAS17 NO. 19- 211277

DA] Il 26 March 2019
TIh1E 21071] OUTS
CALL INFO 215231 dl info
OPERATOR; Tuesday March 26, 2019 2152 and Iseeconds.
UNKNOWN'. We' ve got the state attorneys office coming I} om the cast side_
IiND OF RIiCORDING
ig/ April 3, 2019

Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED RADIO' IRANSMISSION
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DAI F 26 March 2019
INIE 2012 hours

CALL INFO 201210- 210112 DI INFO
POWELL: 3 Alpha Sierra I Tango 10... 116.
FLORI' S: I le' s on SES sarge. What do you need?
POWELL: lie) it' s 10- 4 to advise mom son is conscious, aeake and 51 to rf' Cl1
FLORES: 26,
POW ELL: lacy also Flores do you know which unit came to 2 5 at the residence on the initial
call"
UNKNOWN: 54 we' re... we' re 97 at the apartment now.
POWELL: Okay. Cause you should have about live units there. . lust advise it y' all need more
help.
UNKNOWN: 10- 4 sir ) eah. We' re at which is just south ot' the main on ice
- and
south orthe pool right here And we have the apartment secured
POWELL: Flores Vmt still there?
FLORES: 104. co ahead surge.
POWELL: All right, Y all gonna ha\' e a hispanic male dark blue hat, blue shirt, dark blue
shorts he' s a little hostile at the scene. tic may be 51 back to the house.
FLORES: Yeah. I Ie arrived on scene We came in contact wish him for a brie) second.
POW ELL: Okay.
UNKNOWN: Okav, Just stop your car ( here.
POWELL: 51 are you on channel?
UNKNOWN', Is there Sergeant Puwcll or Vance on channel,
VANCE: Go ahead.
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATE
INTERVIEW OF
Page 2 of 4
HCSO CASE NO.
POWELL: Can one of von 45 me on my cc119
VANC' E: 104,
UNKNOWN:
C I are you on channel?
DISPATCH:
10- 4 go ahead.
UNKNOWN: We' re at the museum that' s not 10- 19, that' s nut 10- 18. It' s to Skipper Road
in reference to a head laceration to the 38 victim. Female is conscious
and alert just need a laceration checked out
DISPATCH: All right_ 10- 4. You said not 10- 18 or 10- 18?
UNKNOWN: Not 10- 18.
DISPATCH Copy.
POWELL: Hillsborough this is 3 Alpha Sierra 01 due ro the circumstances have them come
10- 18,
DISPATCH: - 10- 4.
UNKNOWN:
Sergeant Powell are you available to 45 to Deputy Hall.
POWELL:
10- 4. I think I got him in the phone.
UNKNOWN: C I we hark a 52 on EMS,
DISPATCHER: 54 I' ll get one for you_
UNKNOWN: Can you 10 65 a tag that was imrolvecI9
DISPATCHER: Go ahead.
UNKNOWN: Florida Lima Echo Victor Romeo Corey LEVR Corey a black Nissan Altima.
DISPATCIIFR: ENIS is pulling in now.
UNKNOWN: 10- 4.
DISPATCHER. Thcy should be pulling in now.
UNKNOWN: 104
UNKNOWN: 7 hey' re pulling 97.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED INTERVIEW OF Page
3 of
4 HCSO CASE NO.
DISPXI' CIIFR: Copy%
thank vou. UNKNOWN: IiCFR engine
5 is 97.UNKNOWN: IIcy guys
we %
e got a black charger coating west bound through the Skipper. Let him through the
tape. UNKNOWN: I ley
-
there s a blue Ford coming eastbound. It' s the one with the public affairs once I told
her to drive up to the tape and someone will 56 her,UNKNOWN: Magro, MAGRO:
Copy. Thank
you sir UNKNOWN: I ley
whocvers on the west side lake names as they come through the tape names and ABNs. MAGRO:
Copy sir.
UNKNOWN: Sergeant Powell_..
Powell our PIO is here. POWELL: Oka- Thanks.
Flare him walk ease if he wants. UNKNOWN: Copy surge.
Weg von there' W HG: Yeah.
Go ahead. MAGRO: I think
that-., my witnesscs' son that' s talking to you in orange WEG: Yeah_ Thars
10- 4.1 was trying to tell him to hang light. I might just send him your way though if
thars all right, UNKNOWN: I got
a Detcive Fisher 51 here.MACRO: Copy that
let him through. N' cg you can send the son over here. lie can stay on the other side of
the tape. W17G: 26. UNKNOWN:
What about
this next car"UNKNOWN Thal' s
another detective just do with the Buick. UNKNOWN- Copy. UNKNOWN:
Yeah. Magro
stop that Buick right there, For: 205814 Printed
On: Alay- 01-

2019 ( Wed.)Page 178 of 372
INTERVIEW OF
Page 4 of 4
HCSO CASE NO.
UNKNOWN: Magro a gray Ford with detective 51 to you.
MACRO: Copy,
UNKNOWN'. Weg what was your last update?
W EG: There was a gray Taurus 51 to Magro down Skipper.
UNKNOWN: That' s the same one.
W EG: Magro a dark pray Charger detectives 51 to you.
MAGRO: Copy Weg.
WEG- Magro another dark gray Taurus 51 to you.
MAGRO: Copy.
W EG: I ley Magro the Chief Deputy and the Sheriff are going in. Magro Not poi a silver
Impala and a black Impala 51 to you.
MAGRO. Copy Weg.
WEG: Magro silver Charger 51 to you. 104.
UNKNOWN: I ley Magro crime scene is 51 here. 51 104,
END 01: RECORDING
j&/ April 3, 2019

Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED TRANSMISSION
CASH NO. 19- 211277

IJA' I' E 26 March 2019
TIAIH 2O041] ours
LOCATION Skipper Road, Tampa, H
CALL IN170 200452- 201213 D I SES
OPGRAI' OR: fucsdav March 26, 2019 2004 and 52 seconds.
UNKNOWN: Next,
UNKNOWN: Then.
UNKNOWN: We' re gonna ride over in Tim' s car,
UNKNOWN: Hey Jernr it in the We' re 10 25 with all the parties in the 38 Jerry
do we know if we' re all on a channel or are then working this from tact 17
UNKNOWN: Hey wc" re gonna be Jusl south of the main office where the pool is.
END 017 RECORDING
jg/ April 3. 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED TRANSMISSION - 195744
Reference Number:
CAST: NO. 19- 211277

DAN 26 March 2019
TIME 1957 Hours

LOCATION Skipper Road, Tampa. FI
CALL INFO 195744 c3
OPERATOR: Tuesday March 26, 2019 1957 and 44 seconds.
phone ringing)
CSI: Crime Scene Michelle.
DISPATCHER_ IIe5 Michelle it' s Katelyn in the comm. center.
CSI: Ili.
DISPATCHER_ Ili, I don' t know if you heard but we have an officer involved shooing.
CSI: No, I did not_
DISPATC1 lER_ Oh well they' re requesting von out at Skipper Road.
CSI: Okay. Do you have a call number for that'
DISPATCHER: Yup. 11 is 211100.
CSI: 21... is it on the call screen?
DISPATCHER: What do you mean'
CSI: Like is it on... 1 don' t know, I' m looking at... okay 1 see it now It says Skipper
Road- Okay,
DISPATCHER: Yup.
CSI: Okay. You said 2111009
DISPNIVI 117W Uh- huh.
CSI: Okay. Do you have any details on that or at least who' s requesting"
DISPA' I' Ci IIX Let me ask. Jiang on. It was Alpha Charlie I who is...
CSI: Alpha Charlie I yeah who is mat'
I GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN

BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
195744 c3 Page 2 of 2
DISMI' MER: I don' t know haw to sav it N- I- K- 1- C.
CSI: N- I- K- 1- C'?
DISPATCHER: Yup,
C' Sl: Okay. All righty. Thank you.
DISPATC1 I E R: Thank you. 133 c_
CSI: Hyc_
GND 0I7 RECORDING
jg/ April 3, 2019

Reference Number:
rRANSCRIRED TRANSMISSION
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
TIME 1947 Hours
LOCATION Skipper Road, Pampa. Fl.
CALL INFO 195008- 195126 DI SITS
OPFRATOR: Tuesday March 26, 2019 1950 and 08 seconds.
UNKNOWN: I Icy Phil I' m gonna break onto go help in this shots fired call.
UNKNOWN: 104. lacy where did that call come our at?
UNKNOWN:
UNKNOWN_ 1Icy for 43 were gonna be over here on Skipper Road where the shots fired.
TANGO SIERRA_ Yeah, Copy,
UNKNOWN: Yeah sarge I think we' re all out here now at this point,
TANGO SIERRA- I kind of figured. One ofy' all give me a call or something.
END OF RECORDING
jg/ April 3, 2019
Related Attachment(, - MRE Attachments

Reference Number:
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
TIME 19501 fours
LOCATION Skipper Road, Tampa. 171.
CALL INFO 195057 DI INFO
OPERAI' OR: Tuesday March 26, 2019 1950 and 57 seconds.
DISPATCHER: inaudible)] his ne, call just came in as a 671 and the second call came in as a 38
END OF RECORDING
ig/ April 3, 2019
For: 205814 Printed On: Map- 01- 2019( Wed.) Page 184 of372

Reference Number:
CAST? NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
TIME 19471[ ours
LOCAFION Skipper Road, Tampa. Fl
CALL INFO 194715 CI
OPERATOR- Tuesday March 26, 2019 1947 and 15 seconds.
phone ringing)
DISPATCHER: I' ve got EMS going.
HCIR: Hillsborough County Fire Rescue recorded line. I low, may I help you9
DISPATCHER: Hey this is the Sheriff' s Office. We are out at a call at Skipper,
Skipper at believe we are apartment 46.
I] CFR: Uh- huh,
DISPATCHER- Hang on. Jos( west of where?
UNKNOWN:
DISPATCHER: we went out there cause there was a domestic issue and someone
was bleeding but when we got there they heard shots fired. So he wants you guys 10
go and just stand by.
lICFR: Okay. Yeah. We' re already staging.
DISPATCHER: Okay. Well stage until I guess until we can clear this clear it.
I1CFR'. Sounds good, Thank you so much.
DISPAI CHER: Thank you.
HCFR: Bye, bye.
END OF CALL
jg/ April 3, 2019
Related Attachment( s) - MIRE Attachments

Reference Number:
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
l'IME 19521lours
LOCATION Skipper Road, Tampa. FI.
CALLIN170 194541 DI
OPERATOR: Tuesday March 26. 2019 1945 and 41 seconds
DISPATCHER: I le is showing 97 at Gracepoint 1945 hours.
2 ALPHA 322 Alpha 39 can poll show me 97 I'm 38 in my zone please. DISIW
CI IFR: 26, 1945 hours. END
017 RITORDING jg/
April 3.
2019 For:
205814 Printed On:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 186 of372 1

GOH HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED CALL - 194332
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED CALL
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DATI? 26 March 2019
TIME 1943 flours
LOCATION
CALL INFO 194332 C TI I
phone ringing) -
IiCFR- Hillsborough County Fire Rescue recorded line. flow may 1 help you?
DISPATCIER: lie), it' s 24 with the Sheriff Can we gel you to come out to
Skipper Road at the
Il s going to be reference a domestic dispute. The complainant is uncooperative
advising that his seventeen year old grandson just knocked out his mother And
that' s all we have so Jar
IiCFR: Are you on scene?
DISPATCHER: We are not.
IiCFR:
Okay. And what' s your operator?
DISPATCHER: 24.
1 IC17R: All right. I' ll get ' emI' ll get ' ern started
DISPATCHER: All right. Thank you_ And you' re going to be staging?
IiCFR: More than likely they re probably going to stage, yeah.
DISPATCHER: All right. Thank you.
IICFR: No problem.
DISPAFCI1ER: Bye.
END OI' CALL
jg/ April 3. 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED 9- 1- 1 CALL - 194202 CT3
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBFI) 9- 1- 1 CALL
CASE NO. 19- 211277

DATE: 26 % larch 2019
TIME 1941 Hours
CALL INFO 194202 CT3
phone ringing.)
DISPATCHER: 9- 1- 1 what' s your emergenev?
Yeah. I lase the police down by Skipper Road please.
DISPATCHER: Whal' I
Ski .. is this the police department?
DISPATCHER_ You gone slurs dorm. I cannot understand what cou re saying.
Can you send the police Skipper Road please
DISPAPC11FR:
Yes ma' am,
IISPATCHEW What' s going on there'
My grandson just knocked his mama out. She on the ground down there. Iie' s not
even supposed to be on this lot.
DISPATCHER: Okae Your grandson just knocked his mother out'
Yeah- She getting up nom. lies seventeen years old.
DISPATCIER: She' s how old'?
lies seventeen.
DISPATCHER: Ilow old is she?
She' s thirty seven. She' ll be thin% eight in August. Can you hurry please? she s
gelling up onihe ground.
DISPAFCFIER: lies gelling her off the ground?
9- 1- 1 CALL Page 2 of
No. She' s getting up by herself She hit her head pretty hard though.
DISPATCHER: Wherc is... wherc is he at?
Shes getting up of the ground walking towards me to the door.
DISPATCI IIiR: He,
It' s okay. It' s okay.
Don' t tell me it' s okay.
It' s okay.
DISPATCHER_ Sir
I told you that old bad ass boy...
DISPAfCHER: Iln asking you where your grandson._
Yes.
DISPAI' CIIER: is at.
Now he just walked through the allcywae going the other way.
DISPATCHER: Going where'? Is he outside or inside"
Yeah_ Ile' s outside ofmy house And last week he broke my window I had it fixed
I Ie' s not supposed to be on this lot period, Now he just knocked his mama out.
DISPATCHER: What is he... is he white. black or Hispanic?
Hes_. lies black.
DISPATCI IFR: What s he wearing?
He wearing all red. lies going out on the road on Skipper Road,
DISPA' IVI117R: And what' s his name?
liis name' s
DISPATCHER: Spell his last name.
9- 1- 1 CALL Pape 3 of 4
DISPAfCIiI: R: And what' s his dale of birth? Ito you know il'?
What' s his date of birth? What' s his date of birth' I
DISPATCHER: And he' s walking towards Skipper Road'?
Yeah. I' m getting ready to walk in there now to see which way he walking. Sojust
stay on the phone lie just walked towards Skipper Road but he had on this loud red
like burgundy. I will be able to see which way he' s walking. I' m walking toward
that way right now. Nail a minute. tic always does ( hat. When you call ( he police
on him he disappears. I in so sick of that bay, I dolt know what to do. Iln sick of
his this every I in scared ( hat my daughter going bring him to my house. All right
I' m almost... I' m almost on... on the 1} om street. Oh yeah he' s right next door at the
Sonny s„- Sonnys Grocery store. Ma' am.
DISPATCI IER: I' m here sir.
Okay. Ile._ okay I no between Nebraska and Hearss on Skipper Road. tic' s gone
towards Nebraska but he' s... right now he' s in from of this store nest to me called
Sonny' s Grocery store.
DISPATCHER: Okay.
It' s a com enience store so he ran over there. 11 look like he going to his trailer
where it look like he gonna get on the side walk now.
DISPATCHER: Okay. Just lei me know when you sec the depm)
And he' s on their way. The deputy just passed me. Wait a minute... him in the red
way walking right there. Yeah. The deputy' s gone to get hint.
DISPATCHER: They' re there'?
lie is now.
DISPATCHER. All right sir Hec. b) c.
Yeah- I le' s walking down the sidewalk. I' m going back inside where my daughter
is.
DISPATCHER: All right. Hyc.
9- 1- 1 CALL Page 4 of 4
OWN.
END OF CALL.
jg/ April 3. 2019
For: 205814 Printcd On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 191 of372
Related Attachments, - MRE Attachments

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED 9- 1- 1 CALL - 194141 CT3
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED 9- 1- 1 CALL
CASK NO. 19- 211277

UAlli 26 March 2019
TIME 19411fours
CALL INFO 194141 CT3
OP17RATOR: Tuesda} March 26, 2019 1941 and 41 seconds.
Me%,
DISPATCHER: Ma' am tchat whal

,., is...
FULMORE:
yelling)My brother pushed (inaudible) DISPATCHER:
pour emergenex FULMORE:
lc In.DISPATCHER:
Bello? 9-1- 1. 171JI-
brother pushed my mom onto the floor and right in front of me DISPATCHER:
Okay. I canot understand eou at all. 17UI-
r no ..My brother pushed my mom on the floor. Her head is ble ding on the floor.
DISPAI
C11I7R: Okay. What' s the address of the emergenc}? FULMORE:
CHER: Apartment 26'!

FULMORE
461
huh. DISPATCl
JER:Okay. 171JLMORE:
DISPATCHER:
And what' s going on'!

FULMORE_
brother took my mom on the floor her head is ble ding. For:

GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED 9-

1- 1 CALL
CHASITY FULMORE Page 2 CASE NO. 19-

211277 DISPATCHER: Okay. Someone' s
bleeding? Are they breathing'? FULMORE: Yes. Nut her
is bleeding. DISPATCI IFR_ Okay, What
is your phone number? FULMORE: It s 8I...
t you the number I'm calling you from? 81350 09 1. DISPATCHER: Okay. And
why are they bleeding? Did they fall?FULMORE Ile threw heron
floor. M%
brother threw heron the floor.DISPATCHER: Oka%.
Brother threw
heron the fluor, Okay. I'

m going to get us on the line with the medical dispatch. We need
to gel an ambulance out there Don' t hang up-FULMORE: I don' t
medical. I ne d a copper. DISPATCIi: R:Oka% FULMORH:
Can you give
uhh_-
DISPATCHER: You said she'
s
bleeding on her head. You' re saying she doesn' t need..,FULMORE: Oh me God.
an ambulance? FULMORF:
Okay. Can you
what you gotta do please. DISPATCHER: Okay. Stay on
the line. dial tone) DISPATCI IHR,
Is he
still there? FULMORE: lie just lcfl
IER'. Hejust IeR?
Okay. HCFR: Hillsborough County Fire
Rescue what is the address of your emergency? FIJLMORHi 1250 Skipper Road
what' s the phone number you re calling from^FIJLMORH', 91350 09 1, For:205814
May- 01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 193 of 372

HCFR: Tell me exactly what happened.
He picked__ he there was the, - he tried to hit the car, he picked her up and
slammed her on the floor and her head won' t stop bleeding, She laid on the floor
for a little bit like and closed her eves.
IiCFR: So somebody slammed her on the ground?
Yes. tier son.
1ICFR: Okay. And are you with her right now?
Yes,
I ICFR: I low old is shc?
She' s like thirty scorn.
IiCFR'. Okay. And is she awake'!
Is mama awake . e17 Yeah. She' s awake now.
IiCFR: Is she breathing?
Yes. But she' s like acting like,,,
I1CFR: Okay_ All right. And is it is the son still there?
No. lie left. Nes.
I ICIR_ Do vau know where he r%cnl^.
No. lie just ] ell. 1 don' t know. I think he fell the apartment compleN.
HCFR: Oka.. And were there any weapons involved or mentioned'! -
No. llejust picked her up and slammed her.
I ICFR: Is there any serious bleeding'!
No. I just know her heads bleeding but I didn' t look at it or touch it.
HCFR:
Okay. Is she completely Men"
Yeah_
IiCFR: Okay_ All right. Well we do have the paramedics dispatched, Okay. Just for the
meantime don let her have an) thing to cat or drink. It might make her sick or
cause further problems-
Okay.
IiCFR:
Okay, Just have her rest comfortably and wait for help to gel there.
Okay.
HCFR:
All right. But if anything does change or does gel worse before we get there give us
a call back immediately I'or further instructions,
Okay.
DISPATCHER: And I- ve got a couple...
IiCFR: All right.
DISPATCIIER: other questions for you ma' am.
Okay
DISPAI' Cl IER: What' s the.., what' s this guy name?
DISPATCIIER: Okay. Do you know his date of birth?
DISPATCIIPR: OkaY. And did he leave on foot or in a car'?
On fool
DISPATCHER: Left on Into? What does he look like? Is he white, black, I lispanic. Asian?
I- Ics,,, he' s black and he has black hair tic' s wearing all red umpsuit.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED 9-

1- 1 CALL
CHASITY FULMORE Page 5 CASE NO. 19-

211277 DISPATC1 IER: All red
jumpsuif?FULMORF Yeah. DISPATCHER: Okay.
we
know... FULMORF: I le' s...
IFR: which way
he was headed? FULMORE, No. I do
tic walked out the apartment complex. DISPATCHER: Okay. I le
walked
out of the apartment complex. ( inaudible) Okay. What' s Your name? FULMORE: Chastiy Fululore,
DISPATCHER:
A-
I ve got your phone number. We' Ye got deputies on the way. Thee should be pulling up
soon. Okay. Give us a call back if you sec your brother or anything changes okay. EMS
is on the way as well. FULMORE: Okay, Okay_ DISPATCHER:
right.')hank
you. END OF CALL jg/
April 3,2019
For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 196 of 372

MRE Attachments Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED

CALL 030823 C3 03-27-19 Reference Number: CAST:
NO. DAI
19- 211277 27
F TINIF March 2019

CALL INFO 0307 1fours 030823
I c3 03-
RANSCRIIBED CALL 27-19 OPERATOR_ Wednesday March
27, 2019 0308 and 23 seconds. phone ringing) lICI7R:
lacy shcrilY
DISPATCHER: Ile),this
132. IiCFR: Uh- huh.
DISPXrCI1ER: I may
need a ten number and engine number. IiCFR: Okay. Which
one? DISPAI C1-IER:
1250 Skipper Road. Let me
make sure I get the right one, Looks like we had like three calls go for that one. Okay. Let
s see. Okay. And this is for the assault is that tight' DISPATCHE R_ Uh- huh.
IiCFR: Okay. Make
sure it' s not the duplicate okay. All right. Su tee have engine 40 I'm sorry engi e 5
and rescue 40. DISPAICI ER: Uh-huh.
IiCFR: And then
somebody was cleared early on.So at first it was engine 5 rescue 40 and then engine 40
and engine 40 cleared it,
engine 5 went on scene. Okay- So yeah it was engine 5
and rescue 40. And then we also had squad 14 let' s see, squad 14 responded as well
and actually] think I had that lack earlier. 1 want to say squad 14 responded at the
request of the engine for man power. I would' ve noted it though. Let me double
check. Ptah. So live got on scene requested for rescue, okay yeah. So we ended
up dropping two engines on it cause we were unsure if there was more than one patient
at the lime.So yeah so it was engine 5, rescue 40 and engine 40 and then squad
14 was requested later. DISPATCIl17R_ Okay. And
then what about the run number' 1ICF R:Oh
I'
m store. And then that run number is going to be 26551. For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 197 of 372

RADIO TRANSMISSION 030823 C3 03- 27- 19 Page 2 or

DISPATCHER: Oka% l' hank you very much,
1107W You' re very %celcome ma' am. You take care.
DISPATCHER: NI right bcc, bye.
llC- FR_ Bye.
END OI' CALL
jg/ April 3, 2019
For: 205814 Prinled On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 198 of 372
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY- AGGRAVATEU

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED CALL - 030733 C3 03- 27- 19
Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBED CALL
CASK NO. 19- 211277
DATI? 27 March 2019

TIME 0307 Hours
CALL INFO 030733 c3 03- 27- 19
OPERATOR: Wednesday March 27, 2019 0307 and 33 seconds.
DISPATCHER', Cl132,
ALPIIA 48: Hey what' s going on. This is Alpha 48. 1 don' t think 1 have 17MS- s line number or
which engine it was that arri%cd on scene for this 38 that occurred in Alpha 3
earlier I can give you the case number. I don' t know...
DISPATCHER: What' s the case number?
ALPHA 48: exactly what 21 1 100,
DISPATCHER: For Skipper Road?
ALPHA 48: Yes,
DISPATCl IER: You need the run number and the engine number?
ALPHA 48: Yes,
DISPATCHER: Okav I' ll add it to the call okay.
AITHA48: Thank you.
DISPATCHER: You' re welcome. All right- Byc. bye.
ALPHA 48: All right.
END OF CALL
Ig/ April 3, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED RADIO TRANSMISSION DI MAIN PART 2
Reference Number:
1RANSCR I I3171) RADIO TRANSMISSION
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DAlli
TIKIF 1957 flours
LOCATION Skipper Road, Tampa, FI_
CALL INFO 19- 211100 DI MAIN pan 2
DISPAI' CFIFR'. Hillsborough to 3 Alpha 42 are you 97"
3ALPHA42: 10- 4_ ,
DISPATCHER: 1957 hours.
DISPATCHER_ 3 Alpha Charlie 1.
3ALPHACFIARI- 113 1: Thant still you. I feel ( inaudihle)
DISPATCIIFR: 10- 4, 200&
3ALPI IASIERRA I: Alpha Sierra 1.
DISPATCHER: Alpha Sierra I.
3ALPI IASIERRA 1: Hare everyone on Skipper Road go to into.
DISPATCHER: All units on the 38 at Skipper Road witch to info.
END 01: RECORDING
jg/ April 3, 2019

Attachment Description: TRANSCRIBED RADIO TRANSMISSION D1 MAIN PART 1
Reference Number:
CASK NO. 19- 211277
DATE 26 March 2019

TIME 19421] ours
LOCATION
CALL INFO 19- 211100 DI MAIN pan I
DISPATCHER:
Alpha A to Alpha 3 zone any unit that can be 51 no unit' s showing close per GPS to
671 at Skipper Road its going to be to
CP is crying saying someone is bleeding any... any
unit.
2 ALPI [A 39: 39 higher priority.
3 AITIJA 37: 3 Alpha 37 Stack my current as handled showing me as 51.
RAZOR 104: Razor 104 show me 51 reference the dupe.
DISPATCHER: 10- 4. h looks like it' s going to be a 380, Subject' s saying her brother threw her on
the floor. 1944 hours.
BRAVO 37: Bravo 37.
DISI' APCIIER_ Bravo 37_
BRAVO 37: Can I have EMS 51 to location unknown medical issue,
DISPATCHER: Do you need them 10- 18?
BRAVO 37: 10- 4.
DISPATCHER: 26 10- 39 command at 1944 hours. ( pause) Alpha 43 10- 1 to your transport.
DISPATCHER: Iillsborough to 3 Alpha 43 104 to your transport, Hillsborough to 3 Alpha 43

Depun Marrero 104 to your transport.
DISPATCHER: Unit showing 97 at Gracepoinl. 1945 hours.
2 ALPHA 39: 2 Alpha 39 can you show me 97. I' m 38 in the zone please.
DISPATCHER: 26 1945 hours- Be advised the subject left on loot black male,
wcaring... with the black hair %rearing all redjumpsuit.
2ALPIIA39: Alpha 39 I' m 10- 25 now,
DISPATCHER: 10- 6. 1946 hours- Razor 108 I0- 1 your 10- 20.
19- 211100 DI MAIN PART I Page 2 of 3

2 ALPIIA 39: Hillsborough. Hillsborough hold your station shots fired.
DISPATCHER; Station 46. Station is going to be 46 for 2 Alpha 39.
2 ALPHA 39: Hillshorough have EMS stage.
DISPA9 CIIER, 26. Stations is going to remain 46 for 2 Alpha 39.
X- RAY 108: X- rav 108 shore me 51 to stack as handled.
DISPATCHER: 26. Station remains 46 for 2 Alpha 39,
1314_ Was he
2 ALPHA 39: U'e are just west of
DISPATCIER: Station remains 46,
RAZOR 104: Razor 104 97_
DISPATCI IER: Razor 104.
UNKNOWN: We need EMS 10- 18.
DISPATCFER: 26.
1314: You can 75 bad man dortin. Good guvs are good,
DISPAPCI lFW 26 stations going to be 75 1948 hours.
LIMA I: Lima I are we involved %,uh fhat4
UNKNOWN: 10- 4.
UNKNOWN: Amonc else involved'?
LIMA I: Copy 51 Hillsborough.
DISPATCI IFR: 26.
3 ALPI IA 37: ALPI LA 37 for EMS_
DISPATCI IER: 26 are you alleging to free HMS or send EMS in'?
3 ALPHA 37'. Send them in.
DISPATCHER: 26. They are 51. 1949 hours.
For: 205814 Primed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 202 of 372
19- 211100 DI MAIN PART I Page 3 of

DCSO CASE NO. 19- 211277
TANGO 116: Tango I... 116 eve just pushed over. Where are they at?
DISPATCl JER: Skipper Readjust west of
TANGO 116: Copy 97.
DISPATCHER: 26 1950 hours.
ALPHA 43: Alpha 43.
DISPAIVIIER: Alpha 43.
ALPHA 43: May I have my case number please.
DISPNIVI117R'. 211025 repeating 211025. Alpha 43 copv?
ALPI IA 43: 10- 4 thank vou,
DISPATCI- II? R: Thank you 1951 hours.
END OF RECORDING
jg/ April 3, 2019

Reference Number:
IRANSCRIBED RADIO TRANSMISSION
CASK NO. 19- 211277

DATE 26 March 2019
I IKIF 210711ours
CALL INFO 210745- 213420 DI SITS
OPERNI OR', Tuesday March 26, 2019 2107 and 45 seconds.
UNKNOWM. Ile) Magro there' s a silver Focus 51 to you.
UNKNOWN: Flores you on this channel?
UNKNOWN: 10- 25 Flores sir.
UNKNOWN: Hev is this his unmarked car over here by the scene"
UNKNOWN: 10- 4.
UNKNOWN:
Hcy can you come by here and orjust unlock the doors and Fm gonna turn of your
emergency lights,
UNKNOWN: 104.
UNKNOWN: I hank you,
UNKNOWN Iley Magro legal is 51_
UNKNOWN: The sit, er Taurus 51 from Nebraska.
UNKNOWN: Hey who' s down at the scene near Nebraska and Skipper?
UNKNOWN: Magro are you there?
UNKNOWN:
Hey be advised 1 was at the railroad tracks' felemundo TV is 97 it you could let the
PIO know.
UNKNOWN: Copy.
UNKNOWN: ABC Nce's is 97.
MAGRO: For 43 if it' s media IT' S 10- 97,
UNKNOWN: Magro Ne" s Channel 8 is pulling up as well.
MAGRO: Copy_
210745- 213420 Page 2 of 2

UNKNOWN: Off -ice here wam units on the east side of the tape.
UNKNOWN: Go ahead Master Sergeant.
POWELL: I ley- I need one of you to break free from there and come to 25 with Ray White and
bring those documents he has for us.
MALL:
Sergeant Potccll I' m 97 at the original scene that' s been going on here- I can do
that.
POWELL: Okay, Thanks Kalin. lie has some eight ... eight and a half by eleven documents that
we need for CID.
HALL 10451 DI.
UNKNOWN: Alpha 01 to Alpha 48,
UNKNOWN: Alpha 48_
UNKNOWN: IIcy Stone how ninny units you got there"
UNKNOWN: Just are and Lamar.
UNKNOWN: Okac Thanks man.
WEG: Iley Magro are you there?
MAGRO: Go ahead Weg.
WEG: 1- Icy someone front the SAO is 51 up in the blue Ford Focus that' s on my 56 the
one at the yellow tape.
MAGRO: Cope I' ll be there in just a second.
END OF RECORDING
g/

Reference Number:
TRANSCRIBRD RADIO TRANSMISSION
CAST NO. 19- 211277

DA1 F 26 March 2019
TIME 2055 Hours
CALL INI70 205542- 205733 DI SRS
OPERATOR: Tucsday March 26. 2019 2055 and 42 seconds,
UNKNOWN'. Is anybody on?
UNKNOWN: Yeah. Go ahead.
UNKNOWN:
We going straight out Io the incident scene?
BALSE RO:
Yeah. lie coming to the convenience store on Skipper road. Sunny Food Store
right here nest to ... well you' ll see us. It' s on the north side of the road on Skipper.
UNKNOWN: Cop}
UNKNOWN: Is Skipper blocked off a1 all? Should we come in from Nebraska or from Bearss?
BALSEIRO- Bearss.
UNKNOWN_ 10- 1.
FND 017 RECORDING
jg/ April 3, 2019

Reference Number:
CAS17 NO. 19- 211277

DATI 26 March 2019
TIME 2029 Hours
CALL INFO 202934 c3
phone ringing)
I IC17R: I fillsborough County Fire Rescue recorded line how may I help you?
DlSPATCIIER: Jiang on.
I- ICFR: Hello. Bello,
DISPATCHER: Sorry, hang on,
IiCFR: Okav,
DISPATCIER: Sorry I have cven' body talking to me right now.
I IC17R: Yeah. I feel you. I feel Thai.
DISPATCI IER: Okay. Do you guys have an ETA for Skipper Road?
IiCFR: Let me see. It looks like they' re about to pull into the neighborhood engine 5.
DISPATCI IER: Okay perfect. Thank you.
IiCFR: You' re welcome, And oh and_..
DISPATCI- IER: liuh?
IiCFR: is the scene secure for hold on 1 just wanna make sure it' s Sheldon... Sheldon and
I- mcbaugh?
DISPATCHER: They haven' t cyen located yet_
IiCFR: Okay. Sounds good, thank you.
DISPATCHER: Thanks. Bye.
IiCFR: Bye
END OF CALL

Reference Number:
YY7a` IsYUtilBpliY7i FiJ16b9DP
CASE N0, 19- 211277

DAni 26 March 2019
TIME 203811ours
CALL INFO 203804- 204437 DI SES
OPERATOR. I uesday March 26, 2019 2038 and 04 seconds.
UNKNOWN: I ley are they working of of a special channel or anything so we can coordinate
croNed control?
BALSEIRO: No. We' re just gonna go over there and stage for now and monitor it Gary are you
still there?
ELSER: Yeah. We re still here. We' rejust checking and circling real quick and we' ll be
heading back,
BALSEIRO: Yeah. They want us to stage in that gas station right outside of
ELSER: Copy.
BALSEIRO_
And if you could reach out to Pablo or any of those other guys if they' re still
dressed have ' em be 51. I know they went home earl\- to try to bum some time lot
imnorrow but just ask' cm d they can turn around and conte back If they' re not
already home and undressed.
UNKNOWN: Copy. We' 11 givc' cm a call.
UNKNOWN: I lep saage I' m posting up at the U- Storage cause there' s a gas station they want us
at and then within the crime scene tape
END OF I N' rGRV IF W
For: 205814 Printed On: Mai•-01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 208 of 372
Related Attachment( s) - FDLE Reports

Attachment Description:
Reference Number:
Florida Deparlmenl of LaaLnIoncemenl Tampa
Bay Regional Dpemuons Cenln Laborwory
Evidence Release Fonn l

Ii]AhummAh (' uurnr Shrrll' 1 Ul ir Limb
I'...:
10 903 364
nrV'
nmrm 0
l'..
19- 111'_ 77 1bnl.
hh< m Ilemr' r nion I
nnc lh+'
A' d. uI' d hn ronldininp h:m Jynu JcunF. J e• I' M- o Polol. 0 ..
vub liehl I6Ali01161olo
11hT1 IInn 4]:

OSI Il 1
1 I l le l l l e . Iod —W manila emvinpe ,noinn, ldauimu l do, ra cj e.lo, ' lined in lams brm l Ilkp
lon>I-I I I.,
N m. J au nrnu nn l Je. n IKJ: n I IN, n. Wn llrod ' IN INI l i¢
I, lad la I I, i a 11111p
o,ln 1 iJgc-,
J. amiJ. c.. e lnnn. nni nJ l D",Ilan nT• b?<

9.11 Onc IIi<
al cJ auIrJ mwila cn,dop conmin , can s.&
I ca• cla d. IdRJ e•- I Ln. uJm Iicod NVIM IirrJ cannCeo
ce.c lrmn maunJ 11)c Imo 173W- 1-
2.04 fi,
NI h, W110201n eiVnm. n
20I9 cy7 am 1ST Ilnnum GaniJV N:!

o N 141 For: 205814
Printed On: May- 01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 209 of 372


Attachment Description: FA RESULTS
Reference Number:
ERROR: undefined
OFFENDING COMMAND: get
STACK:
quit
dictionary-
mark-
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 211 oF372
Related Attachments, - MRE Attachments

Attachment Description: STATEMENT FROM DEPUTY ESTANISLAU
Reference Number:
ROMiNE LAW, P.A.

727) 288. 2258/ Fax ( 727) 288- 2257
Steve@Rominel- aw. com
April 12, 2019
Major Frank Losat
Hillsborough County Shcrifrs Office

2008 E. 8ra Avenue
VIA Email: Flosatn HCSO. Tamna. FL. US
Dcar Major Losat,
perspective of Deputy Estanislou, I also wanted to provide your once additional information that
individuals carry firearms. It was of a color consistent with a ftreamt. It was partially concealed.
person to carry a cell phone with the stand in an open position. Stands are meant to prop up a cell
gun', the stand being open in this case changes the entire profile of a normal cell phone. It further
In February this year, FDI. B and pro rcutors denied Caws Police Officer ) rr vvies Baez for shooting a mark
running towards his vehicle carrying a all phone. The officer fired m the noun su times through his vehicle window
beausa the officer saw " a black object in hu hand" thm the man was " aboutto lift it up ...and that' s when I beli ve I
ws going to be shot st." And it is not just law enforcement mistaking ell phones for firamu. Sm hues://
www. foa2lnews. wMnewa/laal/nolimt llcd-afler- al 1rhonomiskakcn- foreunr1464604306( 1everd cagrn
reported a supicous man with a am an his hip; it was a large black cell phow)- For:
205814 Printed On:May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 212 o1`372

1 understand that your agency has certain duties to not release information during an investigation.
But the public report that " no weapon was found" in this case unfortunately 1 believe has created
the impression that nothing was found to explain why the deputy thought the suspect had a gan.
for service reportedly came around 7: 45 p. m. and Deputy Estnislau arrived on scene thereafter. 1
The complaint againsi the suspect was for violence against his own family, including apparently
assessing that threat, often with one hand on or near their service weapon. Deputy Fsanislau knew
Deputy Estanislau has exhibited a history of restraint in using deadly force despite c mumstanccs
In Deputy Eslanislau' s performance evaluation review in his personnel file, it was noted that:
As reflected in his August 8, 2017, diary entry, Deputy FAmnisbU demonstrated poise
and restraint while responding to a call for service involving a suspect that was
Crace responded and were able to come In contact with the suspect, detained him
impulsive decision.
In October of 2018. Deputy Estanislau again exhibited significant restraint in responding to a call
at approximately 9: 52 p. m. of a female with a gun in her hand slating she was " going to shoot
Estanislau the female with the gun " was waving it around."
female to listen to Deputy Esmoislau' s commands or she was " going to lose her life."
his weapon. The firearm turned out to be a BB gun. The male that witnessed the handling of this
individual accused of violence with a knife on his person that charges a deputy — despite being at
insanely chose to advance within arm' s reach of Deputy Estanislau while Deputy Estanislau had a
gun pointed at him. Upon pushing the suspect down, two knives appmximately seven inches long
This is not a deputy that has a history of being " quick on the trigger' or impulsive. Deputy
and reason with him in a non - threatening manner. When Deputy Estanislau perceived what he
different. All ofthis could have been avoided if the suspect dropped what he was holding ormoved
If a person is carrying a cell phone and a low enforcement officer draws a weapon and verbalizes
they believe the person has a firearm, a reasonable, rational response — at a minimum — is for the
person to move their hand away from the tell phone or drop it. It is also not unreasonable to expect
have avoided by simply complying with Deputy E_stanislau' s instructions. Thank you for taking
Sincerely,
Al Stephen L. Romine
Stephen L. Romine
This summary statement regarding my use of force is made to the best of my

call address on Skipper Road, a middle- aged black male -wearing glasses on a phone
flagged me down and pointed to the direction of the suspect, stating " that' s him." I
turned my marked vehicle around to make contact with the suspect
The suspect was on foot walking away from the call address. 1 pulled up towards
the suspect in my vehicle, parked, and exited the vehicle. I asked the suspect if I
could talk to him for a second. He indicated he did not want to talk. During my
initial observations of him, he was sidestepping, glancing back and forth, and would
blade towards me with his left shoulder.
1 began to walk towards him, walking past my front bumper, advising that 1 just
wanted to get his statement about what happened, try to clear this up, words to that
affect. He appeared very agitated and was acting in a way that I thought he may be
getting ready to run. 1 was trying to calm him down, both in my tone and in my body
language.
As I walked towards him, he turned to face me. That is the first time 1 noticed he
was holding a black object in his waistband with his right hand. It appeared to me
to be a gun. Based on my training and experience, it was in an area consistent where
guns are carried and the manner in which the suspect was holding the object was
consistent with holding a gun. In the split second of seeing this and believing it to
be a gun, I drew my weapon.
I recall shouting " drop the gun" repeatedly. 1 may have also told him to show me
his hands or place his hands up, but under the stress and speed of this incident I am
not completely sure of my exact words. The suspect did not comply with arty of my
commands. Instead he kept blading towards me, still appearing agitated, looking all
around, and not dropping or moving his hand away from what 1 believed to be the
gun. While his left shoulder was bladed towards me, he then made a movement that
appeared to be positioning the gun towards me with his right hand — inconsistent
with dropping the gun or moving his hand away from the gun. 1 thought I was about
to be shot and feared for my life. That is when 1 immediately fired two shots.
prior to firing my weapon did I know or believe the object was a cell phone. 1 recall
As soon as he fell, I tan to him. As 1 patted him down, 1 asked where he was shot.
He indicated his back, which surprised me. I knew I did not shoot him from behind.
1 turned him over on his stomach and saw one bullet wound near his left shoulder
blade area, which was consistent with the bladed position he had been in. 1 did not
see an exit wound.
trying to get up. 1 kept telling him to stay down while I maintained pressure to the
At no time after 1 made clear that 1 believed he had a gun did the suspect say
away from the object, this incident would have never happened. I tried to diffuse
Depu iel Estanislau

Tampa, Hillsborough County, FL ( longitude W 82' 28', latitude N 27' 58')
Sun
Begin civil twilight 7: D4 a. m.
Sunrise 7: 27 a. m.
Sunset
7: 44 p. m.
End civil twilight 8: 08 P. M.
Moon
Closest Primary Moon Phase: cast Quarter on March 28, 2019 at 12: 10 a. m. ( local daylight time)
Phase of the Moon on March 26, 2019: Waning Gibbous with 65% of the Moons visible disk illuminated.
Qaloon image not available.
Back to form
Related Attachments, - FDLE Reports

Attachment Description: FDLE FA SUBMISSION 2
Reference Number:
FE)"LE
Flonda Depanment of Law Enforcement
CASE TRACKING FORM
1 mpo Bey Regional Operations Center
4211 North Loh Ateme

III 1111111111111111111111111111111111111
1- 000- t26- 1140
wwalme., ume. nnr
FDLF SuhLolud By J. FloNo

PRIMARY AGENCY INFORMATION Received By Thomas Carlton
IIIIItborough County SIpnWs OIrRe Receivd On OUWOHI 11: 15 EST

Alm 205814 Flork; J
Cave 201903033M
P. O. But 3371
Tampa, M33601- 3371 Suhmiasicn 2
Packegea with sulnumion I
Phi (813) 247. 8676

H illrhorough County Shetln' s Ocoee
ORI FIA290000
Agency Cue# 19- 211277
Case References: No
OFFENSE INFORMATION
County of 0frense Hillsborough County
OBense Date March 76, 2019
OBenwr the or Fare,
Cont. FDLE Agency Uescnp0on of Cviderue Analysis Requested

Item No Isom No.
4 737694001 SME; need Whitt) - Projectile recovered from Nctlm FA- E
Co.. .
Cue Cammanu: Use at forte. Depoy shot the v cfim. Pleue check fuoecloounry or she Brearm am roWar, e0 easl. p and
pralrctller to the firearm.
Submission Commenls: projectile
Submitted By: Rncelved By:
Tho. 9 Carlson
J. Flono
Crime: Laboratory Technician
Page I of I
Related Event( s)
CP HS2019- 211277
GO HS2019- 211100
Related Person( s)
1. Involved # 1 - ESTANISLAU, DANIEL
Case Specific Information)

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Address: 2008 8TH AV E
Municipality: TAMPA , Florida 33605

District: T3 Beal: TF5 Grid: TA0128
Phone Numbers
Business: ( 813) 247- 8000
Particulars
Additional remarks: ABN # 253881
Linkage factors
Resident status : Resident

Age range : Unknown
Access to firearm : No
2. Witness # 1 - GADDY, ANNETTE

Sex: FEMALE
Race: BLACK/ AFRICAN AMERICAN
Date of birth: Apr- 28- 1958
Address: 4011 BAINWOOD CT

District: D3 Beat: G04 Grid: HS3107
Phone Numbers
Business: ( 813) 949- 0337
Cellular: ( 813) 469- 7254
Particulars
Place of birth: North Carolina

Occupation: PRINCIPAL
Employer: MANISCALCO ELEM 939 DEBUEL RD
Citizenship: America - United States of

Ethnicity: Not of Hispanic Origin
Language( s) spoken: English
Height: 5' 05
Disability: No
Build: Medium Complexion: Medium Brown
Eye color: Brown
Hair color: Black
Hair style: Braided, Medium ( Shoulder Length)
Master Name Index Reference
Name: GADDY, ANNETTE

Sex: FEMALE

Address: 4011 BAINWOOD CT

District: D3 Beat: G04 Grid: HS3107
Phone numbers
Home: ( 813) 469- 7254
Business: ( 813) 949- 0337
Home: ( 813) 469- 7254
Cellular: ( 813) 469- 7254
Linkage factors

Age range : 50- 64 Years
Case Specific Clothing Details

Coat: / Sweat Jacket
Shirt: Red / TShirt
Pants: Blue / Jeans/ Denim
3. Witness # 2 - NIKIC, MARINKO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Florida
Particulars
Occupation: LEO
Employer: HCSO
Additional remarks: HCSO DEPUTY
Name: NIKIC, MARINKO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Phone numbers
Business: -
Linkage factors
Age range: 3049 Years
4. Witness # 3 - O' BRIEN, KEVIN M

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address: 20088TH AV E

District: T3 Beat: TF5 Grid: TA0128
Phone Numbers
Business: ( 813) 247- 0600
Name: OBRIEN, KEVIN M

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address: 2008 8TH AV E
Place: SOC

Phone numbers
Cellular: ( 813)
Business: ( 813) 247- 0600
Linkage factors

5. Witness # 4 - PEREZ, ARMANDO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Particulars
Additional remarks: HCSO DEPUTY
Name: PEREZ, ARMANDO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address:
Municipality:
Linkage factors
Age range : 3049 Years
6. Witness # 5 - WEG, LEONARD C JR

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address: 2008 8TH AN' E

Phone Numbers
Business: ( 813) 247- 8000
Particulars
Occupation: DEPUTY
Employer: HCSO ABN 253967
Name: WEG, LEONARD C JR

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:

Address: 2008 8TH AN' E
Place: SOC

District: T3 Bear TF5 Grid: TA0128
Phone numbers
Business: ( 813) 247- 8000
Linkage factors

7. Witness # 6 - AVILES, JOSE LUIS

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address:
Municipality:
District: T2 Beat: TC2 Grid: TA0222
Phone Numbers
Cellular: ( 813) 474- 8299
Particulars
Occupation: MECHANIC
Employer: TOYOTA OF TAMPA BAY
Name: AVILES, JOSE LUIS

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Aug- 04- 1996

Address: 15455 PLANTATION OAKS DR Apartment: 6
Municipality: TAMPA, Florida 33647
District: T2 Beat: TC2 Grid: TA0222
Phone numbers
Cellular: ( 813) 474- 8299
Linkage factors

8. Witness # 7 - DELACRUZ, JOSE DANILO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Jul- 04- 1955
Address: 1436 FOUR SEASONS BL

District: DI Beat: BOl Grid: HS3324
Phone Numbers
Cellular: ( 813) 233- 6730
Particulars
Name: DELACRUZ, JOSE DANILO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE


Phone numbers
Cellular: ( 813) 233- 6730
Linkage factors

Statement taken : Yes
9. Witness # 8 - SERVICE, JOEL MICHAEL

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Oct- 31- 1990
Address: 14102 20TH ST N

District: D1 Beat: B03 Grid: HS3331
Particulars
Place of birth: Florida

Height: 5' 06 Weight: 160 lbs.
Eye color: Brown
Hair color: Brown
Name: SERVICE, JOEL MICHAEL

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Place: DX01

District: DI Bcat: A05 Grid: HS3331
Linkage factors

10. Witness # 9 - RICHARDSON, SCOTT MARSHALL

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Florida
Particulars
Occupation: DEPUTY
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Employer: HCSO # 246604 14102
20TH ST N Additional remarks: HCSO ABN

246604 Master Name Index Reference
Name: RICHARDSON, SCOTT MARSHALL
Sex: MALE Race: WHITE

Date of
birth: Jun-
01-1991 Florida
Home: -
Linkage factors
Age
range :
22-
29
Years 11. Witness # 10 -MESSINA,
DILLON JOSEPH Case Specific Information) Sex:
MALE Race:WHITE
Date of
birth: Apr-
10-1992 Address:
N
33617
Grid: HS3908 Phone Numbers Home: ( 813)
838-6540
Particulars
New
Jersey Occupation: FIREFIGHTER

BRUCE
DOWNS BL TAMPA, FL Citizenship: America - United States
of Marital status: Single Ethnicity:

Not of Hispanic
Origin Language( s)
spoken: English
Height: 5' 10 Weight:
150lbs. Disabil ty: No Build: Thin
Complexion: Light
Handed: Right Handed Eye
color: Blue Lens
type: None Hair color: Brown Hair
style: Straight, Short
Additional remarks: MET W/
CONCENING CYPRESS CREEK PRESERVE Master Name Index Reference
Name: MESSINA, DILLON JOSEPH
Sex: MALE For:205814

Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

Race: WHITE
Date of birth:

Address:
Municipality:
District: DO Beat: TT Grid: HS3908
Phone numbers
Home: (
Linkage factors
12. Witness # 11 - FONSECA, ANTHONV

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address:
Municipality:
Particulars
Occupation: FIRE LIEUTENANT

Employer: HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY FIRE 16304 N. NEBRASKA AVE LUTZ, FL
Name: FONSECA, ANTHONY

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth:
Address:
Municipality:
Linkage factors

13. Witness # 12 - FLORES, CARLOS D

Sex: MALE

District: DI Bcat: B03 Grid: HS3331
Phone Numbers
Business: ( 813) 247- 0600
Name: FLORES, CARLOS DAVID

Sex: MALE

District: DI Beat: B03 Grid: HS3331
Phone numbers
Home: ( 813)
Business: ( 813)
Cellular: ( 813)
Business: ( 813) 247- 0600
Linkage factors

14. Subject # 1 - GILMORE, STEPHANIE SUE

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE
Address: 13157 AARANS POND DR Apartment: 201

Phone Numbers
Home: ( 813) 289- 2900
Business: ( 407) 3244334
Cellular: ( 352) 208- 6251
Particulars
Occupation: PROPERTY MANG.

Employer: OAK CHASE APTS. 12535 TINSLEY CR

Disability: No
Build: Medium Complexion: Light
Eye color: Brown
Hair color: Brown
Hair style: Ponytail
Additional remarks: REGIONAL MANAGER FOR
Name: GILMORE, STEPHANIE SUE

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE

Address: 13157 AARANS POND DR Apartment: 201

Phone numbers
Home: ( 813) 289- 2900
Cellular: ( 352) 208- 6251
Business: ( 407) 324- 4334
Linkage factors

15. Subject # 2 - REYNOLDS, PATRICK VINCENT

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Dec- 24- 1997
Address: 1108 SKIPPER RD

District: DI Beat: A03 Grid: HS3322
Phone Numbers
Cellular: ( 407) 840- 3891
Particulars
Occupation: MANAGER
Employer: US STORAGE CENTERS 1108 SKIPPER RD TAMPA FI,

Disability: No
Build: Large Complexion: Fair
Hair color: Brown
Hair style: Straight, Short
Name: REYNOLDS, PATRICK VINCENT

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Dec- 24- 1997


Phone numbers
Cellular: ( 407) 840- 3891
Linkage factors

16. Subject # 3 -
Particulars
18. NeighSrvy # 1 - FUENTES, DORA

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE

District: DI Beat: BO1 Grid: HS3324
Phone Numbers
Home: ( 813) 388- 7761
Particulars
Place of birth: Mexico --Use only when state is unknown

Name: FUENTES, DORA

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE

Phone numbers
Home: ( 813) 388- 7761
Linkage factors
19. NeighSrvy # 2 - MIRANDA, LEILANNY

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Jan- 09- 1981
Phone Numbers
Home: ( 813) 4534341
Particulars
Place of birth: Puerto Rico

Occupation: UNEMPLOYED

Marital status: Married
Ethnicity: Hispanic
Disability: No
Build: Thin Complexion: Medium
Handed: Unknown
Eye color: Brown
Hair color: Brown
Hair style: Medium ( Shoulder Length)
Facial hair style: None

Name: MIRANDA FIGUEROA, LEILANNY
Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Jan- 09- 1981
Ethnicity: Hispanic

District: DI Bcat: BOl Grid: HS3324
Phone numbers
Home: ( 813) 453- 4341
Business: ( 813)
Cellular:
Alias( es)/ AKA
Name: Address: Sex: DOB:

MIRANDA, LEILANNY 14738 MORNING DR, HC LUT7_ Florida F Jan- 09- 198
Linkage factors

20. NeighSrvy # 3 - MADERA, FRANSICO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Nov- 01- 1998
Municipality: TAMPA ; Florida 33613

Name: MADERA, FRANSICO

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Nov- 01- 1998

Linkage factors

21. NeighSrvy # 4 - SCHMID, CHRISTOPHER LEE

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Jun- 22- 1985
Address: 1231 FOUR SEASONS BL Apartment: 16

District: DI Beat: 1301 Grid: HS3324
Phone Numbers
Cellular: ( 813) 368- 5935
Business: ( 813) 2704624
Home: ( 813) 368- 5935
Particulars

Occupation: TREE TRIMQMER
Employer: MID FLORDIA FORESTRY TREE SVC SOUTH TAMPA


Disability: No
Build: Medium Complexion: Fair
Handed: Right Handed
Eye color: Green
Hair color: Brown
Hair style: Straight, Short
Facial hair color: Brown
Facial hair style: Goatee, Mustache
Additional remarks: INTERVIEWED REFERENCE A UDF
Name: SCHMID, CHRISTOPHER LEE

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Jun- 22- 1985

Address: 1231 FOUR SEASONS BL Apartment: 16

District: Dl Bcat: B01 Grid: HS3324
Phone numbers
Business: ( 813) 270- 4624
Home: ( 813) 368- 5935
Cellular: ( 813) 368- 5935
Linkage factors

22. NeighSrvy # 5 - MCCARTY, MICHELLE LYNN

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Feb- 17- 1984
Address: 1231 FOUR SEASONS BL Apartment: # 16

District: D1 Beat: B01 Grid: HS3324
Phone Numbers
Home: ( 813) 368- 5935
Home: ( 813) 368- 5935
Particulars
Marital status: Separated

Disability: No
Build: Medium Complexion: Fair
Handed: Unknown
Eye color: Brown Lens type: Glasses
Hair color: Brown
Hair style: Medium ( Shoulder Length)
Additional remarks: INTERVIEWED IN REFERENCE TO A UDF.
Name: MCCARTV, MICHELLE LYNN

Sex: FEMALE
Race: WHITE
Date of birth: Feb- 17- 1984
Address: 1231 FOUR SEASONS BL Apartment: # 16

Phone numbers
Home: ( 813) 368- 5935
Home: ( 813) 368- 5935
Linkage factors

23. Prop Owner # 1 - KRUEGER, ROBERT WALTER

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE
Address: 781 DUQUE RD
Municipality: LUTZ , Florida 33549

Phone Numbers
Business: ( 813) 971- 9990
Cellular: ( 813) 781- 6481
Particulars
Place of birth: Michigan

Occupation: BUSINESS OWNER
Employer: RENTALEX 1022 SKIPPER RD TAMPA, FL 3361


Disability: No
Build: Medium Complexion: Medium
Handed: Right Handed
Eye color: Blue Lens type: None
Hair color: Brown
Hair style: Short
Additional remarks: REPORTING EX -EMPLOYEE IS SELLING EQUIP FROM BUSN ON OFFER -UP
Name: KRUEGER, ROBERT WALTER

Sex: MALE
Race: WHITE

Address: 781 DUQUE RD
Municipality: LUTZ , Florida 33549

Phone numbers
Home: ( 813) 781- 6841
Business: ( 813) 971- 9990
Cellular: ( 813) 781- 6481
Linkage factors

GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERVA BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Municipality: TAMPA ,Florida
33612
TC4 Grid: TA0012 Phone Numbers Business: (
813)272-
3020
Employer:
MONROE
S.
States of Marital status: Single
Ethnicity: Not of
Hispanic Origin Language( s)

spoken:
English Height: 4'10
Weight: 105lbs. Disability: Yes Build:
Medium Complexion:
Dark Handed: Unknown Eye
color: Hazel
Hair color: Black
Hair style: Afro
Master Name Index
Reference Name: FULMORE, CHASITY
NICOLE
BLACWAFRICAN AMERICAN
Date of birth:
Jul- 23- 2002
Hispanic Origin Address: 10019 JASMINE

AV
33612
A03 Grid: HS3322 Phone numbers Business: (
813)272-
3020
Home: (
6524
status :Resident
Age range : 16-

17 Years 26. SubjectJUV # 6 -
FULMORE, TRINITY SHANICE
Sex: FEMALE Race:

BLACK/ AFRICAN
AMERICAN Date of birth:
Feb- 25-2005
AV
On: May- 01-

2019 ( NVed.) Page 238 of 372
Related Business( es)
1. Premise # 1 - RENTALEX

Phone number: ( 813) 971- 9990
Type: Industrial and Manufacturing
Particulars
Security: No
Contact Name Affiliation Phone Numbers
Contact # 1: ANTHONY FARMER COUNTER PERSON ( 813) 447- 8165
Related Text Page( s)

Document: INVESTIGATION
Author: 253967 - Weg, Leonard

Related date/ time: Mar- 27- 2019 ( Wed.) 202
On March 26, 2019 at 1949 hours, I responded to Skipper Rd. just west of
Four Season BL, in front of 1028 Skipper Rd, after I heard Deputy
Estanislau # 253881 voice " shots fired" over the District One Main Radio
Channel. It was daylight at the time of my response, and the weather was
clear.
Upon my arrival, I observed Deputy Estanislau, Deputy Perez # 254523, and
Deputy O' Brien # 256560, rendering aid to a black male wearing a red shirt
who was laying on the north sidewalk. The male was laying on his stomach,
with his head pointing west, and his feet pointing east. There appeared to
be blood running from the subject' s back along his right side. I observed a
black cell phone on the ground approximately two feet west of the subject' s
head. The cell phone appeared to be in a black case with a black stand
coming out of the back of the case. Deputy Richardson # 246604 approached
the subject with a medical bag, to continue rendering aid.
Multiple deputies responded to secure the scene as well as to locate

witnesses ( see supplements).
Deputy Estanislau stood up and I maintained contact with Deputy Estanislau.

Deputy Estanislau sat in the front seat of my marked patrol vehicle. I
remained in contact with Deputy Estanislau until supervisors met with him.
I took a position in my marked patrol vehicle at the intersection of

Nebraska Av N and Skipper Rd. to prevent any vehicle, bicycle, or foot
traffic from traveling east down Skipper Rd. toward the crime scene.
Detectives, crime scene, and supervisors responded to the scene.
I met with regional property manager for

Stephanie Gilmore while at my position. Gilmore advised there were no
functioning surveillance cameras in the apartment complex. I verified
Gilmore' s contact information as she advised to contact her if she can be

of any assistance to HCSO.
I remained at Nebraska Av. and Skipper Rd. until I was released from the
position at 0138 hours.

Document: INTERVIEW - WITNESS
Author: 244912 - Magro, Marisa
Subject: CADDY, AN' NETTE
Related date/ time: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.) 1925
Annette Gaddy stated the following under oath; she was stopped in her
vehicle facing west on Skipper Road in the westbound lane. She observed a
marked Hillsborough County Sheriff' s Office patrol vehicle stopped on the

westbound shoulder facing west, with it' s emergency lights activated. She
observed the suspect walking west on the westbound side of Skipper Road, on
the sidewalk. She observed the Deputy exit his vehicle and approach the
suspect. The suspect turned to look at the Deputy and then began to run
away from the Deputy. The Deputy then drew his firearm and fired multiple
times at the suspect. She heard " pop pop pop." She did not see anything in
the suspect' s hands. She was approximately two car lengths behind the
Deputy' s vehicle.
She never exited her vehicle during the incident.

Document: INTERVIEW - OTHER
Author: 220973 - Ziel, Christopher
Subject: REYNOLDS PATRICK VINCENT
Patrick Reynolds stated the following:
He is the manager for the US Storage Centers on Skipper Rd. He lives in an

apartment attached to the front office of the business. He was in his
apartment at the time of the incident, but he did not hear or see anything.
Patrick Reynolds stated that he can access the video surveillance and can
provide a copy of the video. Patrick Reynolds stated that all of their
video surveillance is stored for 30 days.

Document: SUPPLEMENTAL INVESTIGATION
Author: 254076 - Lamb, Jacob
Related date/ time: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.)
On 03- 27- 2019 at approximately 1957 hours, I responded to the area of

Skipper Rd and Four Seasons B1, Tampa, FL 33613, by the
in reference to a just occurred domestic battery ( see General
Offense Report 19- 211100) in which a Deputy involved shooting occurred.
Upon arrival, I was tasked with maintaining the integrity of the scene of
the shooting and standing by with a witness of the shooting, Jose De La
Cruz, until he could be interviewed by Detectives. I did not conduct any
interviews and did not enter the crime scene.
I was relieved of my duties
at approximately 2148 hours.
I have no further information regarding this incident, for balance of

report, please see all interviews, supplements, related report, and
originating investigation by Deputy L. Weg ( 253967).
Mobile Report Entry ( MRE) Attachments:

None.

Document: CRIME SCENE LOG
Subject: CRIME SCENE LOG
Synopsis
Time In Time Out ABN First Name Last Name Agency

2040 ] 2208 258806 ] Amanda Granit HCSO
2044 ] 0023 5165 ] Greg Thomas HCSO

12048 ] 0023 218707 ] David Tabor HCSO
2049 ] 2208 4176 ] Robin Anderson HCSO

2049 ] 2208 3286 ] Chad Chronister HCSO
2049 ] 2208 3156 ] Donna Lusczynski HCSO
2101 ] 2132 220117 ] Thomas Paradiso HCSO
2101 ] 0000 3664 ] Francis Losat HCSO
2101 ] 0023 5119 ] Moises Garcia HCSO
2104 ] 1223 257973 ] Michelle Hermann HCSO
2104 ] 2208 2527 ] James Bradford HCSO

2114 ] 2208 252174 ] Olivier Lindemann HCSO
2117 ] 2208 5603 ] Charles Hollis HCSO
2135 ] 2325 Scott Harmon SAO
2303 ] 0025 3721 ] Thomas Dirks HCSO

2306 ] 0025 3468 ] Richard Woychowski HCSO
2325 ] 0000 Andrew Warren SAO

l

Author: 256560 - O' Brien, Kevin
Related date/ time: Mar-26- 2019 ( Tue.) 1947
On 3/ 26/ 19 at approximately 1944 hours, I responded to a Domestic Violence

call for service at
Upon my arrival, Deputy Estanislau ABN 253881 voiced over the main radio he
made contact with the suspect who had left the scene on foot prior to us
arriving. Deputy Estanislau then voiced over the main radio " shots fired"
and then updated his location to be on Skipper Road just west of the
At approximately 1947 hours, I arrived to assist Deputy Estanislau, who was

already rendering aid to the subject laying on his stomach on the sidewalk
in front of Rentalex at 1022 Skipper Road. Deputy Perez ABN 254523 also
arrived at the same time and also assisted in rendering aid to the subject
with his agency issued QuikClot. I then assisted in securing the scene by
keeping people back until caution tape was put up.
I remained at the scene and secured the shell casing' s found and the
subject' s clothing/ items for evidence, until Lt. Lewis ABN 3464 advised I
was able to leave.
I conducted a query search of Rentalex at 1022 Skipper Road, and learned

the business owner to be Robert Krueger via RMS. I attempted to contact
Krueger from the number in RMS, but was unsuccessful. I then conducted a
Contact Message ( see 19- 211315) at his listed address in RMS, which was 781
Duque Road Lutz, FL 33549. I advised Krueger there was an ongoing
investigation in front of his business and asked if he was willing to go to
his business for detectives to review video surveillance. Krueger agreed to
assist detectives in reviewing surveillance video and returned to the

scene, where he met with detectives.
I remained at the scene to help keep it secure until CSI finished

photographing the scene.
This concludes my involvement in this case.

Author: 255039 - Service, Joel
On 03/ 26/ 19 at approximately 1949 hours, I responded to 1028 Skipper Rd

Tampa, FL 33613 to assist other deputies reference to a shooting call for
service.
Upon arrival, I observed deputies rendering aid to
was laying on the ground at the listed address on the north side of the
road. had a gun shot wound to his left shoulder that was actively
bleeding. I helped apply pressure to the wound until EMS arrived on scene.
EMS advised was to be transported to Tampa General Hospital as a

trauma alert. Deputy Perez ABN 254523 and myself responded to Tampa General
Hospital with HCFR Rescue 40.
I did not collect any evidence or conduct any interviews in regards to this
investigation.

Author: 257641 - Garcia, Saflra
On 03/ 26/ 19 at approximatel y 1951 hours, I responded to US Storage Centers
located at 1108 Skipper Rd, Tampa, FL 33613 I was accompanied by my Field

Training Officer, Deputy C. Ziel # 220973.
I assisted with the investigation by putting up crime scene tape around the
incident location to secure the scene. The incident location was

approximately 100 feet west from the US Storage Centers entrance I started
and maintained a crime scene log until the scene was released by detectives
at approximately 0133 hours on 03/ 27/ 2019.
This concludes my involvement in the investigation.
MRE Attachments:
None

Author: 220973 - Ziel, Christopher
On 03/ 26/ 2019 at 1951 hours, I responded to US Storage Centers located at

1108 Skipper Rd Tampa, FL 33613 in reference to a deputy involved shooting.
During this incident, I was riding as a two person unit with Dep. S. Garcia
ABN 4257641, as her assigned Field Training Officer.
I assisted with the investigation by making contact with the manager of US

Storage Centers, who I identified as the listed subject, Patrick Reynolds
See interview). Patrick Reynolds accessed the video surveillance system in
use at the business. I obtained a video surveillance clip from 03/ 26/ 2019
at 1943 hours to 19: 47: 39 hours, taken from Camera 1. I observed this was
the only video surveillance camera that faced Skipper Rd. and provided a
view of the sidewalk and roadway. I confirmed the video feed time stamp on
the video surveillance camera was correct. I also observed that the video
surveillance did not capture the actual incident, as it occurred outside of
the camera frame.
I provided a copy of the video surveillance clip to Det. D. Tabor ABN

4218707. I also impounded a compact disc copy of the video surveillance
into District I evidence. I have no further involvement with this
investigation.
MRE Attachments:
None
Related Text Pages

Author: 227443 - Nikic, Marinko
On 03- 26- 2019 at1951 hours, I responded to in

reference to a domestic violence call for service. Upon arrival, I learned
Deputy Estanislau # 253881 has discharged his firearm. I also observed a

subject, later identified as to be conscious and being
medically treated by HCFR on the north side of the road.
I immediately moved Deputy Estanislau further away from the injured subject
and remained with him throughout the evening as his immediate supervisor.
At one point, I transported Deputy Estanislau to the District I Office and
stood by until CID Detectives summoned us back to the scene. I stayed with
Deputy Estanislau the entire time until the investigation was completed.
After the investigation was completed, I transported Deputy Estanislau to
his residence.
I have no other information or involvement in this investigation.
MRE Attachments
NONE
Related Text Paee( s

On 03- 26- 2019 at approximately 1955 hours, I responded to 1028 Skipper
Road, Lutz, FL 33549 ( Rentalex), in reference to a Domestic Violence Call
just occurred which was later updated to a Shooting Call just occurred.
Upon my arrival, I assisted multiple Deputies at scene. I made contact with
Deputy Watts ABN# 224767 who advised he located a single witness to the
incident. Deputy Watts briefly interviewed the witness, Annette Gaddy,
refer to his supplement. A few other bystanders were standing on the
sidewalk, west of the scene but were not involved and were not witnesses.
The bystanders left when the perimeter was secured with crime scene tape.
Gaddy was interviewed under oath.
I maintained the crime scene log on the west side of the crime scene until
completion.
All entities were run through FCIC/ NCIC for wants and warrants. None were
located.
MRE Attachments:
None
For: 205814 Printed On: Map- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 251 of 372
Related Text Pages

Author: 255481 - Antonelli Vincent D
On 3/ 26/ 2019 at approximately 1957 hours, I responded to the area of

Skipper Rd. in reference to a Deputy involved shooting related to HCSO
19- 211100.
Upon arrival, I assisted with this investigation by securing the outside

area around the scene with crime scene tape. This area was approximately
fifty yards east from where Deputy Estanislau made contact with the subject
and was approximately one hundred yards west from where the domestic took
place. At the time of this incident, there was a large crowd forming near
the scene.
I assisted with crowd control and made sure that no one passed
my secured area. I never entered the actual crime scene and did not conduct
any interviews. I remained on scene until approximately 0137 hours on

3/ 27/ 2019. 1 have no further involvement with this investigation.
MRE Attachments:
NONE

Document: CRIME SCENE LOG
Author: 257641 - Garcia, Safira
Subject: CRIME SCENE LOG
Related datcAime: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.) 2012
synopsis
Below are the listed names of personnel who entered the crime scene from the
east end of Skipper Rd:
TIME IN TIME OUT ABN First Name Last Name Agency
2030 2208 256885 Daniel Alvarez HCSO

2030 2351 155902 Chad Cave HCSO
2242 0023 233650 Kevin Rettew HCSO

2036 2310 3925 Kyle Robinson HCSO
1949 2006 255039 Joel Service HCSO
1956 2040 254523 Armando Perez HCSO
2042 2153 167433 Christopher Fisher HCSO

2040 0024 4135 O' Neal Jackson HCSO
2042 0022 205814 Joseph Florio HCSO
2047 0022 136776 Patrick Cole HCSO

2059 0021 136777 Jason Gordillo HCSO
2131 0010 31 Roland Corrales HCSO

2156 0022 Juan Acosta SAO
2121 0008 244917 Andrew Van Guilder HCSO
2322 0135 257563 Angela Anderson - Cobb HCSO

2324 2348 253881 Daniel Estanislau HCSO
2324 2348 227443 Marinko Nikic HCSO
Time In Time Out ABN First Name Last Name Agency

1947 ] 2134 ] 253881 ] Daniel Estanislau HCSO
1947 ] 2121 ] 256560 ] Kevin O' Brien HCSO

1949 ] 0136 ] 253967 ] Leonard Weg HCSO
1949 ] 2149 ] 253966 ] Carlos Flores HCSO
1951 ] 2134 ] 227443 ] Marinko Nikic HCSO
1952 ] 2209 ] 95622 ] Kara Vance HCSO
1953 ] 2355 ] 2523 ] Christopher Powell HCSO
1954 ] 2142 ] 256569 ] Jeremy Hodges HCSO

1955 ] 2137 ] 43898 1 Caleb Steele HCSO
1955 ] 0136 ] 244912 ] Marisa Magro HCSO
1955 ] 0136 ] 258827 ] Jacob Blyth HCSO
1955 ] 2240 ] 253773 ] Clifford Stone HCSO
HILLSBOROUCH COUNTY SHERIFF
GO# HS 2019- 211277ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
1956 2049 246604 ] Scott Richardson HCSO

1956 0026 244603 ] Robert Klocksieben HCSO
1956 0000 244559 ] Kalin Hall HCSO
1956 0009 252160 ] Timothy Hicks HCSO

1957 2240 227093 ] Jamaal Lamar HCSO
2001 2122 129331 ] Steven Ross HCSO
1959 0050 3464 ] Steven Lewis HCSO
2000 2039 224767 ] Matthew Watts HCSO
For: 205814 Priotcd On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 254 of 372

Author: 254523 - Perez, Armando
On 03/ 26/ 19, at approximately 1948 hours, I responded to

in reference to a Domestic - Just Occurred
call for HCSO 19- 211100).
service (
While enroute, the Deputy on scene,
Deputy D. Estanislau ( ABN 253881), was involved in a shooting. I located
Deputy Estanislau just west of the entrance of Skipper Road.
Upon arrival, I observed Deputy Estanislau rendering aide to a downed

subject, later identified as
I assisted in rendering
aide by using my agency issued QuikClot while responding Deputies
established a safe environment by blocking off the road with HCSO crime
scene tape for crowd control. I observed a single puncture wound to the
left upper - middle back of I observed to be alert and
responsive. was patted down for weapons to secure the scene for
EMS. EMS responded ( Rescue # 40, Run # 19- 026551) and began preparing for
transportation to Tampa General Hospital.
I followed EMS to Tampa General Hospital where was placed in

Trauma # 4 for medical attention. I was made aware that was
responsive at all times but could not feel his lower extremities. Detective
K. Rettew ( ABN 233650) responded to Tampa General Hospital. I forwarded all
medical updates to Detective Rettew as he took over the investigation.
I obtained clothing, shoes, and jewelry I later impounded the
articles as evidence into Evidence Control.
I have no further information regarding this case For the balance of

this investigation please see primary report and the other supplements in
this case.
MRE attachments:
None

Author: 227093 - Lamar Jamaal D
03/ 26/ 2019, at approximately 1957 hours, I responded to Skipper Rd in
between Nebraska Av and Bearss Av in reference to a deputy involved

shooting.
Upon my arrival, I was tasked with going to the original incident location
46- 1250 Skipper Rd) to secure this location. While on scene, we put up the
yellow crime scene tape around the incident scene.
I did not interview any
of the family members there were at the incident scene. we stood by at the
original incident scene to make sure nothing was tampered with. At
approximately 2240 hours, we were cleared from the original incident scene.
This is the end of my involvement in this case.

Document: EVIDENCE
Author: 41999 - Roberts, Adam
Subject: FW: EVIDENCE CHECK OUT REQUEST- CO #
From: Cave Chad A

To: EVIDENCE CHECK OUT REQUE
Subject: FW: EVIDENCE CHECK OUT REQUEST - GO #

Date: Wed. Mar 27, 2019 @ 13: 29: 39
ORIGINAL TEXT ########
From: Royal Sean A

To: CAVE CHAD A
Subject: EVIDENCE CHECK OUT REQUEST - GO #
Date: Wed. Mar 27, 2019 @ 13: 23: 15
I request the Evidence Control Section to provide the applying personnel with
the following evidence .
The form is to be completed by the requesting employee
and sent in VMAIL to the Evidence Request handle ( HEVIDR), if approval is
required by a supervisor send the VMAIL to them first. Once approved, the
supervisor will forward the request via Vmail to Evidence Request.]
General Offense # 2019] - [ 211277 ] Purpose
Impounding Deputy Court - Subpoena

Required
Requesting Deputy :[ S ROYAL ] [ ] Investigation

Court Date : [ ] Time: [ ] [ X] Testing - FDLE
Pickup Date :[ Mar- 27- 2019 ] Time: [ 1430 ] [ ] Transfer to ATF
Transfer to DEA
Other ( List Below)
Prop # Item( s) All Description
736555 ] [ 1-][][ FNS PISTOL, MAG, WITH LIGHT GKU0126648 ]

736559 ] [ 1- 2][][ TWO FIRED 9MM CASINGS ]
GOP HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY-] BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
To be completed by Supervisors ONLY
Supervisor Rank ABN Date
END OF ORIGINAL TEXT ########

Document: EVIDENCE
Author: 113100 - Hamilton, Michael

Related date/ time: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1511
From: Cave Chad A
Date: Fri. Mar 29, 2019 @ 14: 49: 53
From: Florio Joseph R

To: CAVE CHAD A
Date: Fri. Mar 29, 2019 @ 14: 32: 35
the following evidence . The form is to be completed by the requesting employee
General Offense # [ 20191-[ 211277 ] Purpose
Impounding Deputy :[ 257973 ] [ ] Court - Subpoena

Required
Requesting Deputy :[ 205814 ] [ X] Investigation
Court Date : [ ] Time: [ ] [ ] Testing - FDLE
Pickup Date :[ Mar- 29- 2019 ] Time: [ l[] Transfer to ATF

Transfer to DEA
Other ( List Below)
736559 ] [ 11- ] [ ] [ CELL PHONE ]
CON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
For: 205814 Primed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 260 of372

Document: EVIDENCE
Author: 258036 - Looney, Caitlyn

Subject: FW: EVIDENCE PROCESSING REQUEST
Related date/ time: Apr- 15- 2019 ( Mon.) 1658
From: Patel Kaminiben K
Subject: FW: EVIDENCE PROCESSING REQUEST
Date: Mon. Apr 15, 2019 @ 16: 52: 48
From: Garcia Moises

To: PATEL KAMINIBEN K
Subject: EVIDENCE PROCESSING REQUEST
Date: Mon. Apr 15, 2019 @ 16: 29: 52
CSI Hall
Evidence Processing Request
Complete the below template and send the VMAIL to Crime Scene handle ( HSCENE).
They will process your evidence and complete a Follow Up with the results.]
Offense # [ 2019 ]-[ 211277 ] Date [ Apr- 15- 2019 ]
Requested By [ GARCIA ] ABN [ 5119 ]

Address of Occurrence [ 1028 SKIPPER RD TAMPA, FL ]
Prop # Item( s) All Description Processing

736559 ] [ 11- ] [ ][ BLACK CELL PHONE ] [ Prints and Touch
DNA]
Processing Request Remarks
CRIME SCENE SECTION ONLY

FORWARD FORM TO THE EVIDENCE REQUEST HANDLE FOR EVIDENCE CHECKOUT
Evidence Section: I will be picking up these items on:

Expected Pickup Date:[ 4/ 15/ 19 ] Time:[ 1700 ] hours
4444444 END OF ORIGINAL TEXT ########

Document: EVIDENCE
Author: 41999 - Roberts, Adam
Related date/ time: Apr- 30- 2019 ( Tue.) 1011
From: Thomas Gregory S

Date: Tue. Apr 30, 2019 @ 10: 01: 24
From: Florio Joseph R
To: THOMAS GREGORY S

Date: Tue. Apr 30, 2019 @ 09: 59: 41
the following evidence . The form is to be completed by the requesting employee
General Offense # ( 20191-[ 211277 ] Purpose
Impounding Deputy :[ 254141 ] [ ] Court - Subpoena
Required
Requesting Deputy :[ 205814 ] [ ] Investigation
Court Date : [ ] Time: [ ] [ X] Testing - FDLE
Pickup Date :[ Apr- 30- 2019 ] Time: [ ] [ ] Transfer to ATF
Transfer to DEA
Other ( List Below)
737694 ] [ 1-][][ PROJECTILE RECOVERED FROM VICTIM ]
G. Thomas ] [ Cpl ] [ 5165 ] [ 04/ 30/ 19 ]
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY -I BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Follow Up Report # HS 1
Assignment Information
Assigned to: 257973 - Hermann, Michelle Rank: Specialist
Capacity: HCSO Crime Lab Org unit: Crime Scene Section CICSO
Assigned on: Mar-27- 2019 ( Wed.) 230 by: 257973 - Hermann, Michelle
Report due on: Apr- 11- 2019 ( Thu.) Submission
Information Submitted
on:Apr- 09- 2019 ( Tue.) 2109 Checked
by: 216374 - Patel, Kaminiben Approved

on: Apr- 15-2019 ( Mon.) by:
216374 - Patel, Kaminiben Follow
Up Conclusion Follow
Up concluded: Yes Narrative
Text Report #1 Document:
CRIME SCENE SECTION PROCESSES Author:

257973 - Hermann, Michelle Subject:
CRIME SCENE SUPPLEMENT Related
date/ time: Apr- 09-2019 ( Tue.) 2108 CASE
NUMBER: 19-211277 REPORTING
OFFICER: M Hermann ( ABN: 257973) OFFENSE
INFORMATION Original
Offense: Use of Deadly Force Date

of Incident: Tuesday, March 26th, 2019 Address
Dispatched: 1016 Skipper Rd.Tampa, FL 33613 Victim:
James
On
Tuesday, March 26th, 2019, at ap roximately 2023 hours, I was dispatched to the above listed address. Upon arrival,
at ap roximately 2103 hours, I met with Detective M. Garcia ( ABN: 51 19) who gave a brief statement of what
occurred and the circumstances. I was requested to photograph the scene and collect evidence. It should be noted
the street lights above the incident scene were not on. PHOTOGRAPHS (
Digital) No.
Description I
Phot placard containing case information ( case number should be 19- 21 1277 not 19- 211 100) For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 265 of 372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY-] BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Follun Up Report # HS I
2- 7 Overalls of north side of Skipper Road

8- 13 Overalls of patrol vehicle 103420
14- 24 Street lights along north side of Skipper Road
25- 27 Street light identification numbers ( going from west to east)
28- 32 Overalls of north side of Skipper Road, with markers ( 1- 9)
33- 34 Patrol vehicle 103420 along north side of Skipper Road, labeled as Marker 1
39- 40 One 9mm fired cartridge case on ground, labeled as Marker 2
41- 43 One 9mm fired cartridge case on ground, labeled as Marker 3
47 Pair of red sweatpants on ground near fence, labeled as Marker 4
50- 52 Plastic bag with green leafy substance on ground, labeled as Marker 5
53 Overall of north side of Skipper Road, with markers ( 5- 9)
54- 55 Red substance on sidewalk, labeled as Marker 6
58 Red sweatshirt on ground, labeled as Marker 7
59 Red beanie hat on ground, labeled as Marker 8
61- 62 Cellphone with black case on sidewalk, labeled as Marker 9
64- 67 Overalls of north side of Skipper Road, utilizing time exposure settings, with markers ( 1- 9)
68 Street light pole 2557446207 east of incident scene
69- 71 Perspective of incident scene from street light pole
72- 74 Overalls of north side of Skipper Road, with markers ( 1- 9, A- B, A)
75- 79 Overalls of north side of Skipper Road, utilizing time exposure settings, with markers ( 1- 9, A-
B, A)
80- 84 Perspective of incident scene from blue marker A

85- 89 Perspective of incident scene from blue marker B
90- 93 Perspective of incident scene from green marker A
94- 95 Headstamp on fired cartridge case from Marker 2 ( Homady 9mm Luger R+ P)
96 Headstamp on fired cartridge case from Marker 3 ( Hornady 9mm Luger R+ P)
97- 102 Overalls of cellphone and black case
103- 105 Fence along north side of Skipper Road
106- 1 10 Hole labeled I on fence
1 11- 113
Measurement of Hole 1 from ground
On Wednesday, March 27th, 2019, the following photographs were taken at the Crime Scene Section:
No. Description
I Photo placard containing case information
2 Front of red sweatshirt
3 Tag on sweatshirt ( Huge, size Extra Large)
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACT] VE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
Follo% Up Report N HS I
4- 5 Hole on front of sweatshirt, with scale

6- 7 Hole 1 on front, middle portion of sweatshirt, with scale
8 Back of red sweatshirt
9- 10 Hole on back of sweatshirt, with scale
11- 12 Hole 2 on back, middle portion of sweatshirt, with scale
13 Front of red sweatpants
14 Tag on sweatpants ( Huge, size Extra Large)
15- 17 Holes on front of sweatpants, with scales
18- 19 Hole I on top, right portion of sweatpants
20 Hole 2 on top, right portion of sweatpants
21- 22 Hole 3 on top, right portion of sweatpants
23- 25 Hole 4 on bottom, left portion of sweatpants
26 Back of red sweatpants
27 Front of red beanie hat
28 Back of red beanie hat
EVIDENCE
The following evidentiary items were collected at 1016 Skipper Road and can be located under Property Report
4HS 736559:
Item Description
I One 9mm fired cartridge case from ground, labeled as Marker 2
2 One 9mm fired cartridge case from ground, labeled as Marker 3
3 Pair of red sweatpants from ground, labeled as Marker 4
4 Plastic bag on ground, labeled as Marker 5
6 Green leafy substance from plastic bag
7 Control swab
8 Swab of red substance from sidewalk, labeled as Marker 6
9 Red sweatshirt from ground, labeled as Marker 7
10 Red beanie hat from ground, labeled as Marker 8
11 " Samsung" cellphone and black case from ground, labeled as Marker 9
LATENTS
On Wednesday, March 27th, 2019, the following item was processed for latent areas. The item was first
processed with cyanoacrylate fuming and examined with the Full Spectrum Imaging System ( FSIS). The results
are as follows:
Item Pies Description
1 0 Plastic bag
The following item was then processed for latent areas utilizing magnetic powder. The results are as follows:
Item Lifts Description
1 0 Plastic bag
Follow Up Report M HS I
The following item was then processed for latent areas with " MSTAR" dyestain and then examined with an
alternate light source. The results are as follows:
Item Pies Description
1 0 Plastic bag
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 (' sVed.) Page 268 of 372
FollowUp Report # HS 2 Fol ow
Up Report # HS 2 As ignment
Information Assigned
to:
257563 - Anderson - Cobb, Angela Rank: Technician Capacity:
HCSO Crime Lab Org unit: Crime Scene Section CICSO Assigned
on: Mar- 27-2019 ( Wed.) 246 by: 257563 - Anderson - Cobb, Angela Report
due on:Apr- 21-2019 ( Sun.) Submission
Information Submitted
on:
Apr- 18-2019 ( Thu.) 1914 Checked
by:3721 - Dirks, Thomas Approved
Apr- 18-2019 ( Thu.) by:
on: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas Follow
Up Conclusion Follow
Up concluded: Yes Narrative
Text Report #I Document:
CRIME SCENE SECTION PROCESSES Author:

257563 - Anderson - Cobb, Angela Related
date/ time: Apr- 09- 2019 ( Tue.) 2204 OFFENSE
INFORMATION Case 919-211277 Original Ofense: Batery Address
Dispatched: Tampa General

Hospital and HCSO District One Address Responded: Tampa General
Hospital and HCSO District One Victim: Fulmore, James PHOTOGRAPHS
At
Hospital
Number Description 1-
16
Overalls of
James Fulmore 17 Left

hand of James Fulmore 18-20
band 21 Bottom of feet
of James Fulmore 22 Right

James Fulmore 23-26
left back of James Fulmore 27 Medical
District One For:
205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 269 of 372

Folio" Up Reporl # HS 2
28- 35 Deputy Daniel Estanislau ABN 253981

36- 40 Hands and red substance on right wrist area of Deputy Daniel Estanislau
41- 42 Magazine " A" with live rounds from duty belt of Deputy Daniel Estanislau
43 Magazine " A" and live rounds unloaded
44- 45 Live rounds unloaded from magazine " A"
46- 48 Magazine " B" removed from duty belt of Deputy Daniel Estanislau
49 Magazine " B" with live rounds unloaded
50- 51 Live rounds unloaded from magazine " B"
52- 54 Magazine with live rounds removed from FN FNS- 19 9mm pistol serial # GKU0126648 on
duty belt of Deputy Daniel Estanislau
55- 57 Magazine from pistol with live rounds unloaded
58- 59 Live rounds unloaded from magazine from pistol
60- 67 FN FNS- 19 9mm pistol serial # GKU0126648 on duty belt of Deputy Daniel Estanislau
68- 69 FN FNS- 19 9mm pistol serial # GKU0126648 on duty belt of Deputy Daniel Estanislau and
live round unloaded from chamber
of same
70- 71 Serial number of FN FNS- 19 9mm pistol serial # GKU0126648 on duty belt of Deputy Daniel
Estanislau
72 Case ID card
EVIDENCE Property # 736555

Item Quantity Description
I I FN FNS- 9 pistol serial # GKU0126648 with magazine and tactical light from duty belt of
Dep. D. Estanislau
2 1 Homady 9mm luger live round from chamber of FN FNS- 9 GKU0126648
3 15 Homady 9mm luger live rounds from magazine of FN FNS- 9 pistol serial # GKU0126648
4 1 9mm FN magazine " A" on duty belt from Dep. D. Estanislau
5 17 Homady 9mm live rounds from magazine " A" on duty belt from Dep. D. Estasnislau
6 1 9mm FN magazine " B" on duty belt from Dep. D. Estanislau
7 17 Homady 9mm live rounds from magazine " B" on duty belt from Dep. D. Estanislau
INVESTIGATION
On 03/ 26/ 2019, at approximately 2012hrs, I was dispatched to the locations of Tampa General Hospital
Emergency Center. Upon arrival at approximately 2240hrs, I was met by Det. K. Rettew ABN 233650 who gave
a brief statement and requested I photograph I photographed including a defect
observed in his left back.
1 next responded to the location of the Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office District One to photograph Deputy
Daniel Estanislau and to photograph and collect all firearms and magazines with ammunition on his duty belt.
These items were entered into the property system and turned over to the Evidence Control Section.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED 1 then responded
H HS 2 3 M. Garcia
to the location of 1250 Skipper Road I met with Det. a brief description 5119 who gave by obtaining measurements
of events, and assisted CS1 Michelle Heenan ABN 25797 preparation of a ABN for For:205814 Printed
scene diagram. All photographs were
uploaded into VeriPic. At this time,
I have no further involvement in the case.

MRE Attachments: Diagram
Follow Up Report
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 271 of 372

Assigned to: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas Rank: Detective
Capacity: Continue Investigation Org unit: Homicide Section

Assigned on: Mar- 27- 2019 ( Wed.) 1626 by: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas
Report due on: Apr- I1- 2019 ( Thu.)
Submission Information
Submitted on: Apr- 06- 2019 ( Sat.) 1629
Checked by: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory

Approved on: Apr- 06- 2019 ( Sat.) by: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory
Follow Up Conclusion
Follow Up concluded: Yes
Narrative Text Report # 1
Document: INTERVIEW -WITNESS

Author: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas
Subject: ( NeighSrvy # 4) SCHMID, CHRISTOPHER L ( DOB: Jun- 22

Related date/ time: Mar- 30- 2019 ( Sat.) 1142
Christopher Schmid stated he and his family were located inside their residence, when the involved
shooting took place. fie also stated he was located inside his bedroom during that time, which was located near
the north end of his trailer. His wife was somewhere in the kitchen, when he overheard an unknown person
outside yell two words, followed immediately by two gunshots. Identifying the noise as gunfire, Mr. Schmid
ran outside, towards the disturbance, which was determined to be just on the other side ( north) of the white PVC
fence separating the trailer park from Skipper Rd. When he approached the fence line, he could not see over
the fence without assistance and decided to jump and briefly pull himself up enough to quickly see onto Skipper
Rd. Mr. Schmid stated he observed what appeared to be an unknown black male, lying on the ground, wearing
a red shirt, red sweater, black pants and red and black shoes. Christopher Schmid lost his grip and responded
to his vehicle, where he obtained a ladder for a better view. fie then went back to the fence line, where he
positioned his ladder for a constant visualization of the unfolding events. fie observed Apparent blood squirting
from an area of the black male' s chest and a deputy appeared to be checking the person' s clothing for weapons.
After checking the unknown person' s clothing, Mr. Schmid stated the same deputy began rendering emergency
medical treatment to the black male lying on the ground. Additional deputies arrived on scene and assisted with
the provided medical treatment. A short time later, Emergency Medical Services arrived, took custody of the
unknown person and drove off with said individual. During his observations, Mr. Schmid stated he never saw
a firearm and or weapon on the ground and reiterated he never observed the actual shooting. lie concluded by
Follon Up Report # HS 3
stating he did not know what happened leading up to his observations, did not know what specifically was yelled
while he was inside his house, and did not know who was responsible for yelling the two words he overhead.
For continuous and additional details pertaining to Christopher Schmid' s statement, see his transcribed
interview.)

Subject: ( NeighSrvy # 5) MCCARTV, MICHELLE L ( DOB: Feb- 17- 1

Related date/ time: Mar- 30- 2019 ( Sat.) 1201
Michelle McCarty stated she and her family were inside their trailer when the shooting took place.
She continued by stating at approximately 1845 hours, she was standing inside her kitchen when she heard
someone outside yell two unknown words, followed by two gunshots. Mrs. McCarty stated her husband ran
outside first, while she situated her children in a safe place. While her older child watched the younger two, Mrs.
McCarty responded outside to find her husband standing on a ladder, looking over the white perimeter fence.
When she responded to that location, she looked over the fence and observed an individual being loaded onto an
ambulance. Once the ambulance departed from the scene, Mrs. McCarty responded back inside her residence, in
order to take care of her three children. Mrs. McCarty concluded by stating she never witnessed the shooting, did
not know specifically what was said prior to that and did not know what happened leading up to shooting itself.
For continuous and additional details pertaining to Michelle McCarty' s statement, see her transcribed interview.)
Follow Up Report 0 HS 3
Document: DETECTIVE FOLLOW UP

Subject: FOLLOW- UP INVESTIGATION
This is my Ist supplemental followup in reference to this investigation and 1 was assigned to this
case as an assisting detective. On 03/ 26/ 2019, at approximately 2200 hours, Major F. Losat # 3664 contacted
me at my residence and informed me of an ongoing Use of Deadly Force Investigation, involving Deputy D.
Estanislau # 253881. The Major asked me to respond to the incident scene, which I later learned was the area of
Skipper Rd., just east of Nebraska Ave. At approximately 2225 hours, I departed from my residence, arriving
on scene at approximately 2300 hours. During that time, I noted a portion of Skipper Rd. was cordoned off with
yellow crime scene tape, with Patrol Deputies securing the roadway of Skipper Rd., between Nebraska Ave. and
Bearss Ave.
Upon my approach, I first met with Lieutenant P. Hollis # 5603, who provided me with the following statement of
the investigated shooting:
Lieutenant Hollis stated the Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office received a 911 call, referencing a Domestic
Violence call for service. The call came into HCSO Dispatch at approximately 1942 hours, with two deputies
dispatched to the residence of As the deputies responded to
the area, Deputy Estanislau observed a black male subject walking westbound on Skipper Rd., which matched
the general description of the suspect involved in the reported domestic altercation. As Deputy Estanislau
approached the individual, some sort of interaction occurred between the two parties, with Deputy Estanislau
discharging two rounds from his agency issued service weapon. One of the rounds supposedly struck the
individual, causing the subject to fall to the ground. Additional deputies arrived on scene, where they rendered
aid to the injured parry. EMS also arrived on scene, transporting the injured individual to Tampa General
Hospital. The injured person was identified as
The Lieutenant concluded by stating two parties, who lived within a trailer park just south of the incident
scene, may have witnessed the incident, with the Lieutenant asking me to interview both individuals. He later
provided me with their address of 1231 Four Seasons Blvd. Lot # 16 Tampa, FI. 33613.
At approximately 2323 hours, 1 responded to the aforementioned address and came into contact with the two
individuals Lieutenant Hollis was speaking of. Both individuals introduced themselves, by providing me with the
following identifying information:
W/ M, Christopher Schmid, DOB 06/ 22/ 1985
W/ F, Michelle McCarty, DOB 02/ 17/ 1984
Once they introduced themselves, I conducted audio recorded interviews of both people and concluded said
process at approximately 2354 hours. I then responded back to the incident scene and noted a white PVC type of
Folio. Up Report # HS 3
fence, separating the residence of Christopher Schmid from the scene where the use of deadly force took place.
I also updated Lieutenant Hollis of the information provided by the two witnesses and remained on scene until
03/ 27/ 2019 at 0028 hours. At that time, Major Losat asked me to respond to the District I Office, located at
14201 N. 20th St. Tampa, FI. 33613. Upon arrival, myself and various Homicide Detectives involved in this
investigation, met in the conference room of the district and received a debriefing of this investigation up to that
point.
At approximately 0340 hours, Major Losat concluded the meeting and I departed the District I Office.
On 03/ 27/ 2019, at approximately 1030 hours, 1 was departing my residence, when Sergeant C. Cave # 155902
contacted me on the phone. The sergeant requested I respond to the Tampa General Hospital, in order to obtain
an updated medical status of injuries. When 1 arrived at approximately 1 130 hours, I responded
to the Emergency Room of TGH, where I was redirected to assigned room, documented as
Pediatric ICU # C508. As I met with the nursing staff of the Pediatric ICU, I was informed the overseeing nurse
of was Danielle Gullo, RN. I then met with Nurse Gullo, who informed me
was awake, not on any pain medication, and was able to provide law enforcement with a statement if need
be. I also asked her to list all the injuries sustained to person, with her providing me with the
following:
sustained an apparent gunshot wound to the upper right portion of his back, and or
shoulder.
He only sustained one gunshot wound, which entered into the upper back but did not exit the body.
Apparent fragmentation was still located within the body of and no future surgeries were
scheduled for the removal of said fragmentation.
Nurse Gullo was unsure if a solid projectile was still inside the person of or if it
fragmented upon its entry into his body.
lie sustained a collapsed right lung
He had a chest tube set in place on the right side of his torso
was experiencing paralysis from the nipple line down, due to the projectile impacting the
T6 vertebrate of his spine.
It appeared to Nurse Gullo the paralysis was complete and not temporary.
The 8th rib, located on the right side of his body was fractured.
was expected to survive his injuries
For this entire week, during the daytime hours, Dr. Bhandare would be the overseeing physician assigned to
After speaking to Nurse Gullo, I was directed to the room of noting he was located in a hospital
bed, with his mother sitting by his side. l introduced myself to the and provided her
with my contact information. I also informed her 1 was checking on the condition of her son and asked her to
contact the if she had any additional questions in reference to this investigation. I contacted Sergeant Cave and
CON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
Follow Up Report H HS 3
updated him with the medical condition of 1 then departed from the hospital, responding to
the CID office.
At approximately 1330 hours, Sergeant Cave asked me to respond back out to TGH and meet with Corporal
G. Thomas # 5165. Upon arrival, I was to meet up with the corporal and attempt an audio recorded interview
of When I arrived at approximately 1405 hours, Corporal Thomas and I responded to the
hospital room of and noted his mother was no longer present inside the room. At that point,
Corporal Thomas contacted the mother on the phone, asking her permission to speak with her son, while she was
not present. granted his request and stated she went home to change clothes, stating it was ok
for us to speak with him, even though she was not there for the interview.
The corporal and I entered the hospital room, introducing ourselves to We asked him if
we could speak with him, referencing the shooting incident, and he immediately shook his head no.
then turned to his side, closed his eyes, and refused to acknowledge our presence within the room.
As it was clear, did not want to speak with us, therefore we did not attempt an interview
with him. At approximately 1435 hours, Corporal Thomas and I departed from the Pediatric ICU, coming into
contact with the father of As we met with him, the Corporal spoke to
the father, infonming him of our wishes to speak with his son. at that point stated his son was being
represented by Attorney Norman Cannella Sr. and his son would not be speaking to law enforcement at this
time. We provided the father with our contact information, updated Sergeant Cave of the failed attempt at an
interview, along with the fact was now represented by Mr. Cannella. We responded back
to the CID office, where I secured my investigation for the day. At this time, I have no further information in
reference to this investigation and I will supplement this case if further leads are obtained.
MRE Attachments:
None
Follow Up Report # HS a
Assigned to: 205814 - Florio, Joseph Rank: Detective

Capacity: Investigate/Case Manager Org unit: Homicide Section
Assigned on: Mar- 28- 2019 ( Thu.) 25 by: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory
Report due on: Apr- 29- 2019 ( Mon.)
Submitted on: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) 1307

Checked by: 155902 - Cave, Chad
Approved May- 01-
on: 2019 ( Wed.) by: 155902 - Cave, Chad
Up Report p HS 4 CASE

Attachment Description: FDLE FA SUBMISSION
Reference Number:
r=
FL%,LE
Florida Department of Law Enforcement
TRACKING FORM III
Pampa Het ReRinnal clpentinn, Tenter
4211
limp..
Nanh Ionia A+. cnm.
Florida 33h14 I I I I IIII III I I III FDLE

1- 1100- 226- 11a0
en. rmeAt. m. n. n+
Suhmined He S. R0+. 1 Recti

PRINANIA6I7NC1' INI' ORMAIION Ililhhnmu0h ed Hr I hm ., Carl-. R.
C...
1, Miro, IIRrc nun: cri, ed Un 03127/ 2019 14: 52 F. Sr cast
205814 Florio d P.
201903031" Sarno ..
O. Has. 3371 Tampa.
1`13601- 3371 Pli., : ian I NnUtil+
u hh eohmi. cian 0 I I ahnr ugh

0U1247- 9676 OrFLNSE
Cm o,Shrdfr, Offer f
1RI F1. 11290000 A
gcn.. r-nca 19- 211277 Pane
Relarrre" No F,
IM ORIIATION Cam",
omkh i.Daniel VICTIMS
of Oflcr' I Iilshomugh Cnunp Alcoa
Wile North Fulmare.

26. 2019 Oncn„'
Use of Fare, Follow
FDLE Itam Orm of F.idence Anal, t,Ite9uc, iN 1

No Agency Nu. Ikaripuon
7305 - 1 SHOS; handgun- FSS- 9 PWoI. m....

I. e. ohil light FA - I: I
GRI0126i 2
7365 94 SSIE; cartridge u+

H, I-Ilarnstil, need 91111 fired carlrider Y. 1-E r
from R,.
and 736559-
2 SMF,:
cartridge u,
ein - 1lornadn prod 91111 fired cartrM¢ e FA- E e
from errand Cam....,
72w
Comm eon: IIw of force. Deputy Mal IAe +in im. Pile... haA funrlinndin nl Ihr firearm and rampart all carinL" and prnjcclilm
In Ihr frtrvrm. Subrantion
Conn rnls: Piero check funcfmalitt of The firearm and compare all casing+ and projectiles to the nrtamr. SubmlHed
By:S. By:1
Thomas
Carlson Crime
Royal Received
Laboratory Tepinidan Pagc
1 nr I For:

Follow Up Report # HIS 4

Author: 205814 - Florio, Joseph
Subject: ( Witness # 2) NIKIC, MARINKO ( DOB:

Related date/ time: Apr- 25- 2019 ( Thu.) 1025
Corporal Marinko Nikic # 227443 related the following on March 27, 2019, under sworn verbal oath
He stated he is the direct supervisor of Deputy Estanislau. He initially did not hear everything that was going on
over the radio. lie heard commotion on the radio, so he placed himself en route to the call. As he was driving
to the call, he heard shots were fired, and HCSO was involved. He did not know initially whom the deputy was
who shot. There were many deputies on scene once he arrived. Fire Rescue also was on scene.
Deputy Weg told him Deputy Estanislau was the deputy who shot his weapon. He observed Deputy Estanislau
standing nearby Deputy Weg, and approached him. lie asked Deputy Estanislau to give him a brief statement as
to what happened. He told Deputy Estanislau to not give him every detail, just a general statement so he could let
the chain of command know. lie described Deputy Estanislau as shook up and emotional.
Deputy Estanislau told him he was on the way to another call when the domestic call went out. When Deputy
Estanislau arrived, he encountered a person who pointed to a subject walking westbound. Deputy Estanislau
pulled his vehicle up to where the subject was walking, exited his vehicle, and addressed the subject. Deputy
Estanislau asked if he could talk to the subject, and the subject was verbally abrasive. Deputy Estanislau advist.
the subject he just wanted to obtain a quick statement from him, and then he would speak to the other parties
involved to figure out what happened. At that point, Deputy Estanislau observed a black object in the subject' s
waistband, and it appeared to Deputy Estanislau that the subject was reaching for it. Deputy Estanislau drew his
weapon, fired his weapon, and gave commands to drop the gun at least twice. Deputy Estanislau advised him the
subject made a motion as if he was pulling something out. Deputy Estanislau advised he fired two times. Deputy
Estanislau advised he gave first aid to the subject after the shooting by applying pressure to the wound.
The above is a synopsis. For complete and accurate details of the interview, refer to the audio recording /
transcription.
Corporal Marinko Nikic # 227443 related the following on March 29, 2019, under sworn verbal oath:
He did not observe anyone on scene remove any property from and he did not remove anything
from lie thought he saw a black cell phone on the ground. If he remembers correctly, lie
thought the cell phone had a stand.
transcription.
For 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 280 of 372
Follow Up Repon # HS 4

Subject: ( Witness # 6) AVILES, JOSE L ( DOB: Aug- 04- 1996)

Jose Aviles related the following on March 27, 2019, under sworn verbal oath:
He originally contacted Bay News 9 about the shooting, but eventually HCSO was contacted. He was driving
on Skipper toward Nebraska when he noticed a deputy pulling to the side of the road. The deputy parked his car
so that it was partially blocking the lane, so he stopped his car behind the deputy' s car. He drives a white Acura
Integra. He noticed a kid on the sidewalk to the right, and it appeared the cop and the kid noticed each other. He
believed the kid was getting ready to run, backed up three steps, and at the same time, the deputy pulled out his
gun. The deputy yelled for the kid to stop and show his hands, and then he heard three gunshots. He stated a red
Ford Explorer was behind him. He believes the Explorer stopped, but he did not want to stop at that time.
He described the kid as an African American male wearing all red. He may have had a hoodie on. His windows
were down at the time he observed the incident. His music was not blasting. He believed the kid was going to
run because of the way he was backing away. The kid was turning when the cop pulled out his gun and shot.
He was asked to describe the body positions of the deputy and the kid. He described the cop was looking at
the kid as he was coming around the door, but the kid was about to start running. At the same time, the cop
said show me your hands and let off three shots. There was not that much time between the warning and the
gunshots. He then stated the kid' s body was turned toward the deputy, and he was tuming to his right when
the shots were fired. He did not hear any other dialogue between the deputy and the kid. The only statement
he heard was "
Stop! Show me your hands!" He advised the deputy' s gun was already out when he made the
statement for the kid to stop and show his hands. He saw the kid' s hands, and there was not anything in them. lie
is not biased toward law enforcement. He described the kid' s hands as being at chest level ( he demonstrated it for
me as having his own hands by his nipple line). The kid was not reaching to his pockets.
He advised the deputy was standing still when he drew his weapon. The kid was getting ready to run. He stated
the kid just fell to the ground clutching his left side. The deputy approached the kid and was still saying, " Show
me
your hands!" The deputy rolled the kid to his back, and he perceived the kid as flopping on the ground as if
he was seizing. He advised the whole event was very fast. He advised as the event was occurring he was barely
moving. As the shooting occurred, he described his vehicle as being just west of the patrol vehicle. He believed
the deputy was three to five feet away from his car when this occurred. There was nobody else in his car at the
time of the shooting. He believed he saw a male on a bicycle passing the kid before he was shot.
He then stated upon initial contact the deputy and the kid were facing each other, but there was some distance
between them. As they spotted each other, the kid backed up and the cop was drawing his weapon. At this
point, he imagined the kid was already turning around. I cautioned him to not imagine, but to think about what
actually happened. He advised the kid' s eyes got wide when he saw the deputy, he was going to start running,
back pedaled three steps, and the cop drew his weapon and fired. The kid' s left side was exposed to the deputy
when the shots were fired.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVEOPN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Fol w Up Report
4 Its 4 Upon recapping his
statement, he advised the deputy and the kid spot each other and are face to face initially. He states the
deputy moves closer to the kid as the kid is backing up (diferent statement from earlier).He states as the subject
is turning, the deputy is drawing his gun. He does not know if the subject' s head is facing the deputy at this
point or not. At this point, he was focusing on the deputy. He did not see the subject' s hands as the gunfire went
off, because his focus was on the deputy. The last time he saw the subject' s hands was at the subject' s chest
level,but once the deputy drew his firearm, he did not notice what the subject' s hands were doing. The above is
a synopsis. For complet and accurate details of the interview, refer to the audio recording / transcription. For:205814
Printed
On: May- 01-

2019 ( Wed.) Page 282 of 372

Subject: ( Witness # 3) O' BRIEN, KEVIN M ( DOB:

Deputy Kevin O' Brien # 256560 related the following on March 27, 2019, under sworn
lie was already on an unrelated call in Skipper Road. He remembered hearing Deputy Estanislau was
1025" while he was driving in the complex looking for him. He then heard Deputy Estanislau state " Shots
fired," and he kept looking for Estanislau' s vehicle. He then heard Estanislau state he was outside of the
complex. He then traveled to Deputy Estanislau. He pulled up at the same time as Deputy Perez. He observed
Estanislau rendering aid to the subject on the ground. He had to move some pedestrians back that were
beginning to come to the incident scene. He stopped a witness named Jose ( determined to be Jose Delacruz), and
moved him to the side for a later interview ( interview conducted by Detective Tabor).
He asked Deputy Estanislau if he was okay, and Estanislau told him he was. Estanislau told him to get his quick
clot and begin rendering aid. Estanislau never told him what happened. When he was in the complex, prior to
the shooting, he never heard the gunshots. His window was down when he was in the complex. While he was
rendering aid, he never heard any statements.
transcription.
Deputy Kevin O' Brien # 256560 related the following on March 29, 2019, under sworn verbal oath:
He did not remove any property from the subject who aid was being rendered to. He did not see any other deputy
remove property from the subject. He noticed a phone near the subject that had a stand on it. The phone was
upright on the stand. He never touched or manipulated the phone, nor did he see anyone else touch the phone.
transcription.

Subject: ( Witness # 5) WEG, LEONARD C ( DOB:
Deputy Leonard Weg 4253967 related the following on March 28, 2019, under sworn verbal oath
He responded to Skipper Road after hearing the call for shots fired. He recognized Deputy Estanislau' s
voice on the radio. He parked east of the incident scene on the south side of the road. He blocked traffic. He
observed Deputy Estanislau, Deputy Perez, and Deputy O' Brien tending to the subject. He advised on the radio
of EMS could proceed to the scene, and Deputy O' Brien advised via the radio to send EMS in.
He advised he went up to Deputy Estanislau and put his hand on his shoulder and asked if he was okay. He did
not ask him what happened. He believed Deputy Estanislau was upset, and he observed him pacing around. He
sat Estanislau in his car and asked him he could get him anything to drink or eat. lie waited with him until a
supervisor got to the scene.
Deputy Estanislau stated at one

point standing outside of the car, " Why did he make me do
while that?" While
in the car, Estanislau stated, " How' d I get him in the back." He asked Estanislau, " Did he turn?"
Estanislau just
stared ahead without answering. Deputy Estanislau also asked him if he thought he would be fired. His respon-
was that he has three great supervisors that will have his back.
He advised he noticed a cell phone on the sidewalk next to the subject.
transcription.
Deputy Leonard Weg # 253967 related the following on March 28, 2019, under sworn verbal oath:
lie did not remove any property from the subject, nor did he observe any other deputies remove property from
the subject. lie observed a phone with a kickstand on the sidewalk near the subject. The phone was standing up
on the kickstand. He did not move any evidence at the scene.
transcription.
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019( Wed.) Page 284 of 372
Follon Up Report # HS 4

Subject: ( Witness # 4) PEREZ, ARMANDO ( DOB:
Deputy Armando Perez # 254523 related the following on March 28, 2019, under sworn
He was working as a Razor Unit the night of the incident, and placed himself on the call due to there being
multiple calls for service. As he was en route to the call, he heard Deputy Estanislau state over the radio that
shots were fired. He was the first deputy to arrive on scene. He observed Deputy Estanislau applying pressure to
the wound on
There was a brief pause in the interview so Deputy Perez could tend to a family matter. Once Deputy Perez
returned, he stated the following:
Deputy Estanislau requested him to get his quick clot. Once he obtained his quick clot, he asked Deputy
Estanislau what happened. Estanislau asked him to ask any of the pedestrians who were beginning to congregate
to see if they saw the incident. He advised Deputy Estanislau did not tell him what happened.
He believed Deputy Estanislau was in shock, and appeared shaken up. He did not hear Deputy Estanislau make
any statements to anyone else.
He then advised when he gave Deputy Estanislau the quick clot, he was looking for an exit wound, because he
observed a wound on back. Deputy Estanislau told him he could not find another wound, and then
stated, " 1 don' t know how it hit him in the back." He believed these were the words Deputy Estanislau used.
He did not observe the shooting. He did not interview any witnesses.
transcription.
Deputy Armando Perez # 254523 related the following on March 29, 2019, under sworn verbal oath:
He observed what he believed to be a black phone with a " kickstand" attached to it. It was located on the
sidewalk near the subject' s right arm or right shoulder area. It was about one to two feet away from the subject.
He also saw a green leafy or brown leafy substance near the subject. He did not remove any property from the
subject, and he did not move any potential evidence on the ground. He was the first deputy aside from Estanislau
on scene. O' Brien came right after him. He did not witness the shooting.
transcription.

Subject: ( Witness # 10) MESSINA, DILLON J ( DOB:
Dillon Messina related the following on March 29, 2019, under sworn verbal oath:
He is a Fire Medic for HCFR and he responded to the incident scene the night of the incident. As he arrived
at the incident scene, he removed shoes. This was the only property he touched at this
time. shirt was already off prior to his arrival. made two statements while they were in the
ambulance. He heard state, " don' t let me die," and " 1 can' t feel my legs."
transcription.
Folio. Up Report N HS 4

Subject: ( Witness # 9) RICHARDSON, SCOTT M ( DOB:

Deputy Scott Richardson # 246604 related the following on March 29, 2019, under sworn
He works dayshift as a FTO, and heard the call over the radio for shots fired as he was driving home. He arrived
on scene and multiple patrol cars were already there. He observed the subject dressed in all red down on the
sidewalk. He observed deputies rendering aid to the subject. He observed Deputy Estanislau standing up near
the subject' s head. He got on the radio and advised the deputies were okay and the subject was down. lie also
advised to clear the station of emergency traffic. He offered quick clot to the deputies rendering aid. He saw an
older Hispanic male trying to get close to the scene, but told him to step back. He retrieved his trauma bag from
his trunk, because EMS had not arrived yet. He assisted with first aid on the subject. He rolled the subject over
to look for additional wounds, but advised he only observed one apparent gunshot wound on the subject' s back.
EMS showed up shortly after.
The subject was on his right side when he first arrived. He noticed the injury was on his back left side. The
subject never made any statements in his presence. He did not speak with Deputy Estanislau. He overheard
Deputy Estanislau state " oh fuck" when Deputy Weg got to the scene. He believed Estanislau was upset. He told
Weg to stay with Estanislau.
He did not remove anything from the subject' s pockets. He helped EMS remove the subject' s clothes once they.
arrived. He remembered seeing a black cell phone standing up on its side on the sidewalk when he first arrived.
He never touched the cell phone.
He remembered the subject stated something about needing air once EMS arrived. The oxygen mask fell off the
subject' s face at one point.
transcription.

Subject: ( Witness # 12) FLORES, CARLOS D ( DOB:
Deputy Carlos Flores # 253966 related the following on March 29, 2019, under sworn verbal oath
He was on a 911 call when he heard the call for shots fired over the radio. He ran lights and sirens to Skipper
Road / Nebraska Avenue. lie was coming from Florida Avenue / 127th Avenue. Once he got to the incident
scene, he observed two deputies rendering aid to a black male on the ground.
He did not render aid to the subject who was shot. lie never went through the victim' s pockets. He assisted in a
search of the area, and marked the area where there were two shell casings with cones.
transcription.
Fo11o% Up Rep" n # HS 4

Subject: ( Subject # 3)
related the following on March 27, 2019, under sworn
is her biological son. She advised got into a fight in the car earlier tonight. She did
not see him hit her, but said he hit her. She told both to get out of the car, and at
some point, she smacked on the side of his head. then took her by her arm, and slammed her to the
ground. She hit her head as a result of the fall. She was dazed as a result of the impact. She advised " grandpa"
heard the impact and advised was calling the cops. got scared and ran. She knows the cops generally
calm down.
She advised law enforcement has been called out numerous times in the past for She could not put
a number on it, but advised it has been more than ten times. has emotional problems and does not
take medication. He just went to two programs. refuses to talk to his doctor. He has been diagnosed
since kindergarten. She advised has been diagnosed with ADHD, developmentally and emotionally
handicapped, and ODD ( oppositional defiance disorder). Ever since his 13th birthday, the problems have gotten
worse.
is 5T' tall, but he is stocky. She described him as being very strong. She cannot restrain him. She
described choking her in the past. has been Baker Acted more than 20 times. has damaged
property in the house in the past. has never indicated he would force someone to harm him as a result of
his own actions. has made statements consistent with not wanting to be " here," and he hated his life. She
believes does this for attention. has been Baker Acted in Pasco as well when they lived up there.
This was approximately two years ago.
She has asked why he would put holes in the walls, and he has told her it was because the voices made him
do it. has not been diagnosed as schizophrenic.
She believes smokes marijuana, but does not know of any other drug use. She believes is a
follower. has completed the 9th grade. is not employed, but receives disability.
She advised always listens to the cops, and he likes the cops. She wants law enforcement to speak to him.
told her " the police grabbed his arm and he ... I think he went to walk away. He snatched away and went
to walk away or something. And then he said the police shot him." She asked if he went into his pockets, and
told her he did not. She then stated, " He could be sedated so I don' t know."
is scared to go back to jail. He did not like the program he was sent to because he was bullied while there.
She has looked into ex parte orders.
Follmi Up Rrporl # HS d
transcription.

related the following on March 2 /, 2019, under swom
This was not the first time HCSO has had to come out to his residence. He tried looking for the exact date for
when he last called HCSO conceming He believed it was one week prior. He told not to bring
back to his residence because broke his window the week prior.
called HCSO tonight at 7: 41 PM. was fighting with his two sisters. mother went out to try
to stop because he was trying to break something on her car. He observed That
is when flipped her over and dropped her on her head. He was standing in his door when this occurred.
It happened outside of car. He saw had hit her head on the concrete. That is when
called the police, because he is scared of He described as being down for a few seconds.
then took off, but he followed him from a distance of about 50 yards. told the police where
was, and he went back to his apartment thinking they would have him. was telling the dispatcher what
was wearing. He did not think there was anyone else on the street when he pointed to where went to the
deputy.
transcription.
Follow Up Report # HS d
Document: INTERVIEW -OTHER

Subject: ( Involved # 1) ESTANISLAU, DANIEL
Deputy Daniel on
He clarified his position and positioning upon initial contact. He described as side
stepping, and glancing back and forth upon contact. lie requested to speak with him, and tried calming
the situation by just wanting to get a statement from lie described as swatting at him with
his left hand and stating he did not want to talk to Deputy Estanislau. He described left shoulder
was bladed toward him, and he could see the front of body. He described as raising his left
arm up, " creating a lane" and then observed right hand reach toward his waistband. He described
right hand was on a black object he perceived as a gun. He described this was a place he knows people
will carry a firearm, as he carries his off d
- uty firearm in his waistband toward his strong side. lie described the
object as being black and on the right side of the front of the waistband. lie described as motioning
with his right hand toward him. He gave commands for to drop the gun, but described as not
complying. His firearm was drawn once he noticed the black object, but he did not immediately fire. He fired
only when made the motion with his right hand pointing toward him. This placed him in fear for his
safety. He described patting down for weapons, and then placing gloves on his hands to perform life
saving measures. He kept pressure on wound until other deputies arrived. He realized the black obje
was a cell phone with some sort of stand affixed to the back of it after it hit the pavement. He did not touch the
object at all. He described the stand on the phone as open, and the phone was standing on its side.
transcription.

Subject: ( Witness # 8) SERVICE, JOEL M ( DOB:
Related date/ time: Map- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) 1302
Deputy Joel Service on marcn 2v, 2u i v, unuer sworn
lie was working as a razor unit the night of the deputy involved shooting. He heard shots were fired via the
radio, and drove to the incident scene. Upon arrival, he observed a black male on the ground who appeared to
be bleeding. He assisted with rendering aid to the black male subject by applying pressure to his shoulder blade
area. He did not remove any property from the black male. He assisted with cutting the black male' s clothing.
He observed a cell phone and a baggie of what he thought was marijuana on the ground. He described the cell
phone was on the black male' s right side. He did not touch the phone. He heard the black male subject state
aloud, " it hurts" several times. He did not hear any statements from Deputy Estanislau.
The above is a synopsis of the interview. Refer to the audio recording for complete details.
Folio" Up Report # HS A

is my first supplement to this case as the
On March 26, 2019, at approximately 2002 hours, I received a phone call from Corporal Gregory
Thomas # 5165 requesting I respond to Skipper Road Tampa, Florida 33613 ( within Hillsborough County)
in reference to a deputy involved shooting. Corporal Thomas advised me 1 would be the lead investigator on
the case. 1 pulled up the call from the CAD, and noted a domestic violence just occurred ( documented under
HCSO case number 2019- 21 1 10 ) and was dispatched at 1942 hours at 1250 1946
hours, unit 2A39 (Deputy Daniel Estanislau # 253881) advised he was in contact with the suspect ( later identified
as James
call stated the suspect was wearing a red
jumpsuit. AT 1947 hours, Deputy Estanislau advises over the radio " shots fired."I
arived in the area of 1028 Skipper Road at ap roximately 2040 hours. I noted Skipper Road was
cordoned off with yellow crime scene tape just east of Nebraska Avenue North, which was the route 1 to k to
get into the area of the scene. I parked my unmarked vehicle on the south side of Skipper Road, west of 1028
Skipper Road. 1 noted multiple layers of crime scene tape throughout Skipper Road, and noticed yellow crime
scene tape further east by the Jasmine was where the original domestic violence
call originated from).
1 met with Sergeant Chad Cave #155902, and advised him I alredy spoke with Corporal
Thomas about being the lead investigator for the case. 1 obtained the biographical information for James
this time from Sergeant Cave and Deputy Estanislau' s information as well. Sergeant Cave and
I waited for other members of the Homicide Section to respond to the incident scene to discuss assignments. Sergeant
Cave advised me Detective Kevin Rettew #233650 was responding to Tampa General Hospital to check
the status of James this time, I was advised James one apparent gunshot wound to
the left side of his back, under the left shoulder. Corporal
Thomas was designated as the assist for this investigation, and Master Detective Moises Garcia #
51 19 was assigned to document the crime scene. Detective David Tabor #218707 assisted with peripheral
interviews (see his supplement for details). Corporal Thomas advised the he informed Assistant State Attorney
Scott Harmon of the incident, who advised he would be responding to the incident scene as well. 1 noted
Corporal Marinko Nikic 4227443 is the direct supervisor of Deputy Estanislau, and was asked to stay with Deputy
Estanislau throughout the night. I observd Corporal Nikic and Deputy Estanislau in a marked patrol vehicle
at the scene. Sergeant
Cave,Corporal Thomas, Master Detective Garcia and l surveyd the north side of Skipper Road
and noted patrol deputies placed orange colored cones in various locations, which designated items of evidentiary
value. Refer to Master Detective Garcia' s sup lem nt for complete and accurate details of the crime scene.
I was advised two spent Homady 9MM shell casings were located under two of the orange cones. This brand
of ammunition is consistent with the ammunition distributed to sworn deputies with the Hil sborough County
Sheriffs Office. Sergeant Cave advised me the Shot Spotter system did not register the two shots For:

Follow Up Report H [ IS 4
fired. l specifically noted the streetlights in the area of the incident scene on the north side of Skipper Road, in
the vicinity of where the actual shooting appeared to have occurred, were not operational. Corporal Thomas
pointed out potential surveillance cameras affixed to the main building of the business known as Rentalex. I
noted a phone number on the sign ( 813- 971- 9990), and attempted to call it. 1 heard the phone ringing inside
the business, but the phone just rang without a voicemail. I have experienced in the past where businesses may
forward a business number to a cellular telephone after hours, however this was not the case with this business.
Sergeant Cave would later advise me a business owner was contacted, and would respond to the scene to have
the surveillance video viewed.
District I patrol personnel were initiating the original domestic violence related incident under
HCSO case number 2019-21 1 10 . Corp al Thomas advised me the use of deadly force encounter would be documented under
HCSO case number 2019- 211277. This action was taken to document the two incidents separately. I learned James Fulmore battered the
two victms in violence incident ( Stephanie Thomas, a black female, date of
apartment 46. The actual of apartment 46.

1 was advised
a black female, date of
The 911 recordings
were requested for review and would later be transcribed for the purposes of the use of deadly
force investigation. Detective Tabor advised me he conducted an
interview with a potential witness to the use of deadly force.Detective Tabor provided me with the
witness information ( Annette Gaddy, a black female, date of birth April 28, 1958).Refer to Detective
Tabor' s supplement for details of the interview. I learned Annette Gaddy was driving westbound on Skipper Road
in a red in color Ford Explorer when she claimed to observe the incident. I noted Detective Tabor advised the
details of his interview with Annette Gaddy to Corporal Thomas, Sergeant Cave, Master Detective Garcia, and HCSO
Legal Counsel Olivier Lindemann #252174. 1 learned HCSO Assistant Legal Counsel Jason Gordilo# 136777
was assigned to represent Deputy Estanislau, and was in contact with Deputy Estanislau at the
District I Office. Lieutenant Charles Hollis # 5603 provided me with an office issued FNS 9MM (serial number GKU01
15590) to provide to Deputy Estanislau. 1 was provided three empty magazines, a new Streamlight TLR-1
tactical light, and a box of Homady 9MM duty ammunition as well to provide to Deputy Estanislau. Corporal Thomas
and I left the incident
scene at approximately 2 13 hours to go to the District I Office to conduct a round count

and observe Deputy Estanislau be photographed by HCSO Crime Scene Investigator Angela Anderson -Cobb # 257563. We arrived
at the District I Office at approximately 2217 hours and waited for Mr. Gordillo to be
done speaking with Deputy Estanislau. Once their interaction was completed, I introduced myself to Deputy Estanislau, and
advised him 1 was the lead investigator for the use of deadly force. I explained to him I was going
to have CSI Anderson - Cob photograph him and we would be conducting an inspection of his weapon and counting his
ammunition. I noted Deputy Estanislau' s duty belt
aperd to have all of the standard equipment issued at the time of the shooting. Deputy Estanislau wears
his duty holster on his right side. Deputy Estanislau was wearing For: 205814 Printed On:May-01-2019 (

Polio" Up Reporl # HS 4
eyeglasses when I observed him at the District I Office. I also noted him to be wearing a shoulder microphone
on his mobile radio, which was clipped to the center of his uniform. Deputy Estanislau was wearing the Class B
uniform of the day at the time of the shooting. I observed him to be wearing his issued bulletproof vest under his
uniform shirt. I noted what appeared to be dried blood on the bottom of his right wrist, specifically on a white
in color fitness tracker he was wearing and on the surface of his skin. The apparent blood was consistent with
transfer. I did not observe any physical injuries to Deputy Estanislau. It should be noted my interaction at this
point with Deputy Estanislau was limited. I refrained from asking him any questions about the incident, and he
did not provide any information to me.
The round count occurred at 2245 hours. It should be noted the HCSO issued FNS 9MM
semiautomatic handgun has a magazine capacity of 17 9MM rounds, with one extra 9MM round chambered
for a fully loaded duty ready weapon. HCSO deputies carry two extra magazines with a capacity of 17 rounds
in each. The total number of live ammunition on a standard duty belt should equal 52 rounds to be considered
ready for duty. I had CSI Anderson -Cobb label the magazines. The one closest to Deputy Estanislau' s radio was
labeled " Magazine A," which had 17 live Homady 9MM rounds inside of it. The magazine closest to the center
of his abdomen was labeled " Magazine B," which had 17 live Homady 9MM rounds inside of it. 1 then asked
Deputy Estanislau to provide me with his issued FNS 9MM, to which he complied. I inspected the weapon,
and it appeared to have no modifications to it. 1 noted he had the issued Streamlight TLR- 1 light affixed to the
weapon, and it was functioning at the time of my inspection. The serial number on Deputy Estanislau' s FNS
9MM is GKU0126648. 1 noted 15 live Homady 9MM rounds in the magazine of Deputy Estanislau' s weapon,
and one live Homady 9MM round in the chamber. This is consistent with the two spent casings found at the
incident scene to show Deputy Estanislau was loaded for duty at the time of the shooting. I provided the new
weapon and accessories mentioned above to Deputy Estanislau. CSI Anderson -Cobb took possession of the
original FNS 9MM, magazines, and live ammunition taken from Deputy Estanislau, and impounded them into
evidence.
Corporal Thomas and 1 departed the District I Office and went back to the incident scene at
approximately 2330 hours. We briefed Major Francis Losat 43664, Lieutenant Hollis, and Sergeant Cave with
the results of the round count. Shortly thereafter, Deputy Estanislau and Mr. Gordillo arrived back at the incident
scene to conduct a walk- thru. The purpose of the walk- thr was to determine positioning at the time of the
shooting. I discussed the specific questions 1 was going to ask Deputy Estanislau with Mr. Gordillo prior to the
walk- thr being conducted. The questions asked were as follows:
Where were you when you first arrived on scene?
Where were you when you first observed the subject?
Where was the subject when you first encountered him?
Where were you standing when you fired the first shot?
Where were you when you fired the second shot?
Did you move between shots?
I advised Mr. Gordillo that the walk- thru process could begin when Deputy Estanislau was ready.
The walk- thr had the following personnel present during the process: Corporal Thomas, Master Detective
For: 205814 Printcd On: May- 01- 2019 ( Ned.) Page 296 of 372
Garcia, CSI Michelle Hermann # 257973, CSI Anderson - Cobb, ASA Harmon, SAO Investigator Juan Acosta,
State Attorney Andrew Warren, HCSO Legal Counsel Gordillo, HCSO Legal Counsel Lindemann, and Deputy
Estanislau. I read Deputy Estanislau his Miranda warnings from a State Attorney' s Office issued Miranda card
dated April 201. 7 at 2339 hours. Deputy Estanislau acknowledged his rights, and agreed to answer questions at
this time. I requested CSI Hermann to have different colored cones to represent the positions Deputy Estanislau
pointed out of where he was and a different colored evidence marker where would have been,
according to Deputy Estanislau. Refer to Master Detective Garcia' s supplement for complete details of the
marker placement. I noted Deputy Estanislau indicated he did not move from the point where he fired his
weapon, nor did he move between shots. position did not change much from the point Deputy
Estanislau first observed him to where he fell after the shots were fired.
Once the walk- thru process was completed, I assisted with looking for a projectile in the Rentalex
parking lot. t noted Master Detective Richard Woychowski # 3468 was able to contact the owner of the business,
and was in the process of obtaining surveillance video. 1 was advised the owner allowed HCSO to search his
property for potential evidence. I observed a possible impact point on the fence line, specifically on a cable area,
that appeared to be going from south to north, consistent with the direction the shooting took place. I searched
the grassy area to the north of the gate and the parking lot, but I was unable to locate a projectile.
convened at the District I Office with personnel involved in the case to discuss the actions taken
in the investigation thus far. Corporal Thomas and 1 then went to Tampa General Hospital ( TGH) to conduct
audio -recorded interviews with family members. Detective Rettew was asked to conduct audio -
recorded interviews with his siblings ( while Corporal Thomas and I interviewed
Corporal Thomas and I interviewed
in a quiet room at TGH at approximately 0154 hours on March 27, 2019.
understood the interview was being audio -recorded and was placed under sworn verbal oath. For complete
and accurate details of the interview, refer to the audio recording / transcription. During the course of her
interview, indicated refuses to take medication, has had multiple encounters
with law enforcement, and has been diagnosed with several mental illnesses. She believed he was bi- polar and
possibly schizophrenic as well. She advised to her knowledge, normally interacts well with law
enforcement. She described multiple domestic violence related incidents over the years involving
as the primary aggressor. 1 did not provide with any details of the use of deadly force, but I
advised her 1 was the lead investigator, and any questions she may have should be directed to me. I provided her
with my direct contact information. indicated a willingness to cooperate in the investigation,
and encouraged me to interview once he was awake and able to speak. I then conducted an
audio -recorded interview with under sworn verbal oath in a quiet room at approximately 0214
hours. was aware the interview was audio -recorded. For complete and accurate details of the
interview, refer to the audio recording / transcription. mirrored a lot of information as to the
background of He indicated was violent earlier in the evening and has been
violent in the past. was forthcoming with information. informed me he was the
person who pointed Deputy Estanislau to where was walking. This is significant, because at this
point 1 did not know who directed Deputy Estanislau to where he ended up using deadly force. I departed TGH
at approximately 0230 hours and concluded my shift for the morning.
Follow Up Report H HS a
I convened with Sergeant Cave at the Criminal Investigations Division on March 27, 2019,
at approximately 1000 hours. We discussed the course of actions needed to be taken, which started with
interviewing the first several deputies who arrived on scene after the shooting took place. I pulled the call log,
and requested all of the radio traffic on all District 1 channels concerning this incident. Sergeant Cave informed
me Detective Sean Royal transported Deputy Estanislau' s FNS 9MM firearm and the spent casings to FDLE ( see
his supplement for details).
I received Deputy Estanislau' s disciplinary history from the Professional Standards Section. I
noted his original hire date was October 4, 2015. lie had one entry on his file, which was a traffic crash on
April 30, 2017 ( HCSO case number 2017- 304361). lie received a letter of counseling as a result of the internal
investigation and lost the use of his take home vehicle for a period of five days. This was the only entry in his
file.
I requested Deputy Estanislau' s training history and last qualifications with his FNS 9MM. I learned
Deputy Estanislau last qualified with the involved FNS 9MM on October 31, 2018 during his annual in- service.
I noted Deputy Estanislau signed up for an advanced training class called " Identifying and Surviving Hidden
Weapons," which is scheduled to begin on August 9, 2019.
I reviewed surveillance video from the Rentalex property, which displays a time approximately
four hours and six minutes slower than real time. The angle of the camera looks south to Skipper Road. I
observed what appears to be a black male wearing all red, which is consistent with what was
wearing, walking westbound on Skipper Road on the sidewalk. I observed Deputy Estanislau' s marked patrol
vehicle pull up to the north side of Skipper Road, partially in the roadway ( as I observed it at the scene).
appears to turn to his left and it appears he looks at Deputy Estanislau' s marked patrol vehicle. As
turns to his left, he raises what appears to be his left arm in a waving fashion toward Deputy
Estanislau ( who has not exited his patrol vehicle at this point) and then continues walking westbound.
goes out of view from this point. Deputy Estanislau exits the driver' s seat of his marked patrol vehicle
and raises his hands up to about chest level while walking toward Deputy Estanislau, takes
several steps forward ( west) and as he crosses the front bumper of his marked patrol vehicle, he drops his
shoulders slightly and draws his issued firearm from his right side. Deputy Estanislau continues advancing
forward ( west) in what appears to be consistent with an isosceles stance. The gunshots are not captured on video,
as Deputy Estanislau also goes out of view from the camera angle. As the above movements are occurring, I
did not observe Annette Gaddy' s red Ford Explorer, which she claimed was parallel to the incident at the time of
the shooting. As Deputy Estanislau goes off camera, a white in color vehicle is observed just behind his marked
patrol vehicle. That vehicle stops briefly, then veers to its left and slowly continues westbound. Annette Gaddy' s
Ford Explorer is observed several car lengths behind the white vehicle. As the white vehicle stops behind the
patrol vehicle, Annette Gaddy' s Ford Explorer is seen stopping several car lengths behind the white vehicle. The
red Ford Explorer then follows a similar path around the [narked patrol vehicle. Annette Gaddy' s statement is not
consistent with the video surveillance.
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 298 of372
Follow Up Report # [ is 4
I was previously scheduled for a motion hearing at the Hillsborough County Courthouse at 1330
hours, so I was unable to go to TGH to attempt to interview Master Detective Dirks and
Corporal Thomas went in my place ( see their respective supplements for details). I learned did
not wish to speak with them, and his father advised Corporal Thomas that he hired an attorney to represent his
son' s interests. Attorney Norman Cannella contacted HCSO on March 27, 2019, at approximately 1431 hours
requesting HCSO not to speak with his client.
1 contacted Corporal Nikic via phone and requested to speak with him in person. 1 met him at
his residence and conducted an audio -recorded interview with him under sworn verbal oath. Corporal Nikic
had the most contact with Deputy Estanislau after the use of deadly force occurred, and I wanted to know of
any statements made by Deputy Estanislau during his contact with him. For complete and accurate details of
the interview, refer to the audio recording / transcription. Corporal Nikic provided me with the statements he
obtained from Deputy Estanislau. He indicated that Deputy Estanislau believed was reaching
into his waistband, and he pulled out a dark object. This was the reason why Deputy Estanislau deployed deadly
force. He described Deputy Estanislau as being distraught during his contact with him. Corporal Nikic did not
ask specific detail oriented questions of Deputy Estanislau during his contact with him. Corporal Nikic was
trying to ascertain what occurred at the time.
I received information from Corporal Thomas about a possible eyewitness to the deadly force
encounter. Corporal Thomas provided me the name " Jose" and a phone number of 813- 474- 8299. 1 immediately
called this number and the person who answered identified himself as " Jose," and was willing to meet with me.
1 drove to the Toyota of Tampa Bay dealership ( located at 1101 East Fletcher Avenue Tampa, Florida 33612)
and met with Jose Aviles ( a white / Hispanic male, date of birth August 4, 1996). Jose Aviles was willing to
speak to me under sworn verbal oath and on audio recording. For complete and accurate details of the interview,
refer to the audio recording / transcription. I learned that Jose Aviles was the driver of the white vehicle seen
stopped just prior to Deputy Estanislau going out of view from the surveillance video at the Rentalex. Jose
Aviles advised he heard Deputy Estanislau state aloud twice, "show me your hands!" This was prior to shots
being fired. He indicated his attention was focused on Deputy Estanislau once he drew his gun. He advised he
noticed hands were at chest level prior to him focusing on Deputy Estanislau. I had him go
through his account of what occurred several times, and had him clarify several points in his statement. I had
him go through the sequence of events step- by- step and where his attention was at each point during each step. I
then updated Corporal Thomas with the information Jose Aviles provided me.
I called Deputy Kevin O' Brien # 256560, and requested to speak with him in person. He agreed to
meet me at the Publix parking lot ( located at 16560 North Nebraska Avenue Lutz, Florida 33549). The interview
was audio -recorded under sworn verbal oath. For complete and accurate details of the interview, refer to the
audio recording / transcription. Deputy O' Brien did not witness the deployment of deadly force. He indicated
he heard the domestic violence call over the radio, and was already inside the on an
unrelated call. Due to the size of the apartment complex, he was trying to locate where Deputy Estanislau was in
reference to the call. He never heard the gunshots, but heard the call for shots fired by Deputy Estanislau via the
radio.
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTER('- 1 BATTER(' - AGGRAVATED
called Deputy Leonard Weg # 253967, who advised me he could meet with me the following day
due to being out of county with his family. On March 28, 2019, 1 went to Deputy Wes s residence to conduct an
audio -recorded interview with him under sworn verbal oath. For complete and accurate details of the interview,
refer to the audio recording / transcription. Deputy Weg arrived at the incident scene after Deputy O' Brien did.
Once the interview was completed, I went to Deputy Armando Perez' s # 254523 residence to conduct an audio -
recorded interview under sworn verbal oath. For complete and accurate details of the interview, refer to the audio
recording / transcription. Deputy Perez was the first deputy on scene after the call for shots fired.
Once the interviews listed above were completed, I went to the Criminal Investigations Division
to review the 911 and radio traffic. I began to make a timeline of events to have a better understanding of
what deputies were actually present at the scene just after the incident occurred. I wanted to ensure I spoke
to every deputy that may have observed the initial scene, or would have had contact with Deputy Estanislau.
I focused on Deputy Estanislau' s radio transmissions as well, to ensure I had an accurate account of what he
was saying and how long it took by the time he arrived at the scene, to when the shots were fired. Deputy
Estanislau' s unit number / call sign on the radio is " 2A39." Deputy Estanislau advises he is " 97" ( on scene) at
1945 hours, " 10- 25" ( in contact with) at 1946 hours, and approximately 28 seconds later, Deputy Estanislau
holds the station " 10- 46" ( emergency traffic) for shots fired. I also requested the GPS locations of all deputies
involved, which was (napped out to show the exact locations of each involved unit on this case. It appeared
Deputy Estanislau' s vehicle was coming off the northbound exit from I- 275 to Bearss Avenue when the domestic
violence call is dispatched. Deputy Estanislau was en -route to a shoplifting call at the time the domestic violenr
call is dispatched, but elects to go to the domestic violence call in lieu of the call he was going to. The domesti,
violence call was in Deputy Estanislau' s assigned geographical area of "A03," so it appeared he was attempting
to take a priority call in his area of primary responsibility. Deputy Estanislau was also fairly close to the priority
call at the time he advised he would be en -route to it. The intersection of 1- 275 / Bearss Avenue is just northwest
of Skipper Road, approximately 1. 1 miles away.
1 began to look into the background of I noted he has a lengthy history of arrests
and Baker Act incidents. As 1 reviewed the material related to the general theme of the reports
was very consistent. has targeted his mother the majority of the incidents involving domestic
violence. has passively resisted law enforcement efforts to take him into custody on multiple
occasions. He refuses to obey verbal commands. which is consistent with his mother' s statement about his
Oppositional Defiance Disorder.
On March 29, 2019, 1 began the day by speaking with on the phone at
approximately 0926 hours. She advised me still had fragments in his spine. She also advised
is right handed. This is significant, because in reviewing the video, Deputy Estanislau appears to
only have a view of left side as he approaches him.
I contacted Deputy Scott Richardson # 246604, who met with me at the Criminal Investigations
Division for an audio -recorded interview under sworn verbal oath. For complete and accurate details of the
interview, refer to the audio recording / transcription. Deputy Richardson showed up to the incident scene at the
end of his shift due to hearing the distress call from Deputy Estanislau. Deputy Richardson noticed the cellular
For: 205814 Printed On: N7ay- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 300 of 372
Follow Up Rep" rl # Hti 4
telephone near was standing up on its side. He described the phone as having a " kickstand." He
did not observe anyone take the phone out of pockets, and to his knowledge, it was like that
when all of the deputies arrived on scene.
1 went to HCFR Station 40, and met with HCFR Fire Medic Dillon Messina # 1471. Dillon Messina
agreed to an audio -recorded interview under sworn verbal oath. For complete and accurate details of the
interview, refer to the audio recording / transcription. Dillon Messina did not remove anything from
pockets, just his shoes. The only statements made to him was, " 1 can' t feel my legs"
and " don' t let me die."
1 waited for the responding deputies who 1 previously interviewed to come back to work to conduct
a followup interview with each. I also learned Deputy Carlos Flores # 253966 and Deputy Joel Service # 255039
arrived on scene around the time of the previously interviewed deputies. I conducted sworn interviews with both
Deputy Flores and Deputy Service ( refer to their respective interviews for details), and then I re -interviewed
Deputy Weg, Deputy O' Brien, Deputy Perez, and Corporal Nikic separately. I clarified with each one of them
if they noticed anything of evidentiary value or if any of the removed anything from pockets.
None of the interviewees removed anything from pockets, and all of them noticed the cell
phone standing up on the sidewalk. For complete details of their interviews, refer to the audio recordings /
transcriptions.
On March 30, 2019, 1 contacted via phone. She advised me has T- 6 and
T- 8 fractures in his spine. He also has lesions on his right lung due to rib fracture. She advised he is paralyzed
from the nipple line down. She has been staying at the hospital to comfort She provided a cell phone
number for On April I, 2019, 1 requested a subpoena for
subscriber and toll information for The subpoena was faxed to
on this date. On April 2, 2019, 1 called at approximately 0906 hours, but there was no audible
response from her. It should be noted this was the last time picked up the phone when 1 tried
calling her. It appears since April 2, 2019; no longer seemed cooperative or willing to hear
any updates regarding case.
The incident was not originally captured via Shot Spotter. HCSO contacted Shot Spotter directly
and inquired about the location of sensors in the area of the incident scene. Shot Spotter was able to locate two
gunshots by manually going into the system. The Shot Spotter report indicated two gunshots were captured
at 19: 46: 44 hours. The shots can be heard on the audio provided by Shot Spotter, and they appear to sound
consecutive. The time the shots are captured is consistent with the radio traffic when Deputy Estanislau advises
he is in contact with 19: 46: 19 hours), the GPS from Deputy Estanislau, and the radio traffic from
Deputy Estanislau after the shots are fired ( approximately four seconds after the Shot Spotter report). On April 8,
2019, 1 learned the incident scene was forensically mapped for accurate distances. The crime scene diagram was
incorporated with the mapping that was completed. I reviewed the surveillance video, and with the assistance
of Corporal John Graves # 4044, we were able to get the approximate location of where Annette Gaddy and Jose
Aviles were at the exact time of the shooting, according to the Shot Spotter report. The measurements were
determined based off fixed points where each of these individual' s vehicles were at the time the shots are heard.
olio% Up Report N HS 4
The video shows neither of these witnesses were where they claimed to be at the time of the shooting. Annette
Gaddy was approximately 152 feet east of where Deputy Estanislau' s approximate firing position was at the
time of the shooting, and approximately 178 feet east of where Deputy Estanislau approximated
to be standing when he was shot. Jose Aviles was approximately 81 feet east of where Deputy Estanislau' s
approximate firing position was at the time of the shooting, and approximately 107 feet east of where Deputy
Estanislau approximated to be standing when he was shot.
On April 13, 2019, 1 impounded test fires from FDLE regarding Deputy Estanislau' s issued firearm.
The test fires were impounded under Property Report 739201- 1. 1 researched FDLE' s online laboratory, and
noted the report was completed. The casings at the incident scene snatched Deputy Estanislau' s issued firearm,
as expected. The firearm was function tested, and there were no reported weapon malfunctions according to the
report. Refer to the attached FDLE report for complete details.
On April 16, 2019, 1 convened with Corporal Thomas and Sergeant Cave, and was made aware
Deputy Estanislau provided a written statement via Attorney Stephen Romine on April 12, 2019. 1 reviewed
the letter, which was dated April 11, 2019, and noted Deputy Estanislau describes the event from initial contact
until after the shooting occurs. For complete and accurate details of the written statement, refer to the attached
statement.
On April 18, 2019, at approximately 1 1 14 hours, Deputy Estanislau and Attorney Stephen Romine
voluntarily came to the Criminal Investigations Division to clarify and demonstrate the movements he describe.
in his written statement. The entire interview was audio -recorded in a conference room. There was an
approximate five- minute break in between the two audio recordings were Assistant Legal Counsel Lindemann
requested to speak with Stephen Romine in private. Once the break was concluded, I turned my audio recording
device back on before any questions were asked. ASA Harmon, SAO Investigator Acosta, Corporal Thomas,
Assistant Legal Counsel Lindemann, Master Detective Garcia, and I were all present for the interview process.
Refer to the audio recording / transcription for complete and accurate details of the interview. It should be noted
Deputy Estanislau demonstrated body position upon initial contact when the shooting occurred.
He described as sidestepping away from him upon contact, which is consistent with the video
surveillance from the Rentalex camera. Deputy Estanislau described as, " creating a lane" with
his left arm extended upward from his body while his left shoulder is bladed toward him. He described being
able to see the front of and noticed right hand grasping a black colored object he
perceived as a fireann. Deputy Estanislau advised he knows it is common for individuals to carry firearms in
their waistband, and advised he carries his off -duty firearm in the front of his waistband, toward the right side.
Deputy Estanislau demonstrated the [notion trade toward him just prior to the shooting, which
was what caused him to fire his weapon. Fie described once bladed his left shoulder toward him,
and he recognized what he believed to be reaching for a fireann with his right hand, he drew
his own firearm and gave commands for to drop the gun. He did not fire right away. Deputy
Estanislau demonstrated a motion trade with his right hand coming upward from the waistband
toward him. He described this motion as happening very quickly, and he perceived this motion as being a threat
to his safety. He believed the motion was consistent with the barrel of a firearm being pointed toward him.
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Fol w Up Report
p HS 4 James Fulmore was
with Deputy Estanislau' s commands to show his hands. He advised James Fulmore never
to him at these moments in time to suggest he only had a cell phone on him. I compared Deputy
Estanilu' s written statement and verbal clarification to the video surveil ance collected. Deputy Estanislau'
s statement is consi ten with the events captured on the video surveil ance. James Fulmore can
sidestepping as Deputy Estanislau' s marked patrol vehicle is approaching him from behind. It appears James
Fulmore' s the patrol vehicle as he is side stepping, and his right arm is bent at the elbow, with
the lower half of his right arm appearing to be in the area of the right side of his waistband. As James Fulmore is
it appears he raises his left arm up as Deputy Estanislau is exiting his patrol vehicle, which
is consistent with when Deputy Estanislau described James Fulmore as him with his left
hand. Deputy Estanislau' s body language as he exits the driver' s side of his marked patrol vehicle does not seem
to be aggressive in nature, as he raises both of his hands in the air trying to engage James Fulmore in
Estanislau' s body language im ediately changes as he crosses the area of the front bumper of his
marked patrol vehicle, which is consistent with the written statement and verbal clarification he provided. On April
24,
2019, 1 received the subpoena records for James Fulmore' s There does not
appear to be any com unication at the time of the shooting. The times on the phone tolls are in UTC format, and
after adjusting the time difference (four hours behind),there are no records to suggest James Fulmore was
phone at the time of the shooting. Refer to the records for details. I impounded the cel phone records into
evidence. On April 24,
2019, 1 received clarification from Master Sergeant Roland Corrales #31 Training
( Division) in reference
to the Homady 9MM Critical Defense round. Master Sergeant Corrales advised me the velocity at the
muzzle of this round when fired is 1,
175 feet per second. On April 30,
2019, 1 reviewed the case file,and noted an additional supplement to the original domestic violence incident (
HCSO case number 2019- 21 1 100) and noted a projectil was removed from James Fulmore on April 3,
2019.
was removed from James Fulmore' s right side (
refer documented by Deputy Elizabeth Rieger # 254141
for details). I was not informed of this update, but after viewing the supplemental report, I went
to the Evidence Section to view the projectile. I requested the property report ( PR 73694- 001)be transferred
from case number 2019- 211100 to this case number, as it is evidence of the use of deadly force investigation.
Evidence Technician Eddie James 43865 facilitated the transfer of property. I noted the projectile appeared relatively
intact. I completed a FDLE submission for the projectil and hand delivered it to FDLE. I spoke
to FDLE Firearms Supervisor John Romeo, and advised him of the update. He advised me to resubmit Deputy Estanislau'
s FNS 9MM again along with the impounde test fires. l returned to the Criminal Investigations Division and completed
an updated submission, which was hand delivered on May I, 2019. 1 am requesting this case
remain active at this time.This case will be presented to the State Attorney' s Office for review. I will assign myself
an additional follow up. For: 205814 Printed On: May-01-2019 (
Wed.) Pagc 303 of372

Assigned to: 3468 - Woychowski, Richard Rank: Detective
Capacity: Other Follow Up Org unit: Technical Assistance Unit

Submitted on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1403

Approved on: Apr- 01- 2019 ( Mon.) by: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory
Related Attachment( s) - Waiver/ Affidavit

Attachment Description: CONSENT TO SEARCH/ WAIVER OF SEARCH WARRANT
Reference Number: 1022 SKIPPER RD
HAhbvmgh Cowry Shdms OtOu Confidential Cass No.

WAIVERS/ AFFIDAVITS Page of
Type of Incident:
D M
I, ( Name of person signing):
Ne' ammia, n
f Oath
Flimcf,"'
nder oath and sxear
earm
or affirm thus ell sulemenu which I give to law Enforcement during this investigation tie
i Fim Neme ad Laa Name
Firu Nemead Isa NSiawnuePrint S

Name and last Name F
signature v/
W Cade Prior First Nana and tau None 6i" cr e Consent
to be Interviewed I.
o
to king in tuviewd by the below lined Hillshorm b Cowry Sheriffs Omce uu Enlargement
consent
Official cmvsmmnS1LPtAjqvc listed invidereeffaue end I furthe untlersnM that 1.

I have the right no remain silem ru -
oke
Nis right as an lime during questioning; i.
If I do matte s SYumen 11 can ad will be ad alswu me inaco 3.
1 have the right m speak with and have m mcam y,present during quenimdn , a.
If I resonat afford an aro acy. one will be appointed to me without charge befure aery g my, is time desire; 6,
If I wish la mane sly statement, I may Invoke my to amomey
right or remain questionn.
to 51ICnt al Ny t dart
6.
1 understand Nest righu end no one ban threatened, coerced or pmmisaf
me anything in mdn to induce me to .
I Ixcsently
wish to make a staem nt and' ur answer gmSions without an anomey, being present. Waiver
of Prosecution Im
1,
request not to by
the HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF' S OFFICE regarding m ed with the mau¢r in which the investigation
was conducted and release the Shenffs Office of any responsibiliN regarding this complaint I requst, my funkier investigation
turn be pursued, davit (
ICis
on
not to be used in lieu of Document of Oath) nnhesreemere
below tined Ilillsborouh CowrySIrcriH'

sVaRenu xcre
rodetoIM
vude. 7—
—- IMM! v
toSearch/ WaiverofSearch Warrant / o3D SKrp/ 62 "ll~.

d, 1;, 3, 3 / 3 1, do
herby'
convened tfal the premias/ vehicie loused et I V R may be
hat by my Hil sbomugh County Sherifrs Office Iaw Enforcement Official, This worsens extends to the main buildurg and arty enclosures fmmd
on the property. 1 further agre that anytior, or tiny strudel, tMt may be found in the search of the presois / vehicle may be and at
trial In my man er of which I may stand accused. I fully WdeRNa my constitutional rights In regard to the search and it is my Im uon to fully
Max! completely waive such rights by this consent I give this convent freely and voluntarily, wWmmt compulsion or threat cfmy kind. Signed this
7 19_
al 6_ 6M hours Subject y
20 _
Witness:
Deputy: tfep
Witness: Ion) Rn,
05111 For: 205814
Printed On: May-01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 305 of 372


Folio" Up Report # HIS S

Author: 3468 - Woychowski, Richard
Subject: DVR RECOVERY
On March 26, 2019 at approximately 2245 hours, I was contacted by Major F. Losat # 3664 of the Criminal
Investigations Division in reference to retrieving video evidence. Upon arrival at 1022 Skipper Road Tampa,
Florida 33613 ( Party Pros of Rentalex) I met with Master Detective M. Garica # 5119 of the Criminal
Investigations Division who directed me to the office where the DVR ( Digital Video Recorder) was located. I
met with the owner W/ M Robert W. Krueger who directed the to a closet in the northeast corner of his office
which housed the DVR. Once inside of the closet on top of a mini refrigerator, 1 observed a monitor on top of
the DVR, which was on top of another DVR, along with a keyboard and mouse. 1 noted that the lower DVR was
not operational at the time I observed it as there were no connections. 1 was advised that the monitor was not
operational which prohibited anyone from viewing the stored video. 1 switched out the monitor and reconnected
another one from a nearby office. It was determined the HDMI ( High - Definition Multimedia Interface) cable
was no longer functional. 1 utilized the HD- 15 ( VGA) connector that was connected to the DVR, at this time
I could now view the live video feed. I noted the DVR was a mace brand, model # MVSQ- DVRI6VA, serial
131 141 1240 .] observed on the rear of the DVR, the video in, audio in,I- IDM1, 14D- 15, network, and power cables were
all connected, and the DVR to be operational. The time stamp generator produced a date of 03- 26-
2019, and a time of 07: 21:58 PM. The current date and time was actually 03-26-2019,and a time of 1 1:
27
PM. Master Detective M Garcia #
5119 advised an approximate time of 7:
40 PM to look for the video. I located the video
clip Master Detective M.Garica #5119 was looking for.1 obtained a thumb- drive media stick froth Corporal G
Thomas #5165 so that I could back- up the video from the DVR. 1 returned the media stick to Corporal G.Thomas #
5165 after I completed the back- up copy of CH03 from the DVR. On March 27, 2019 at ap roximately 0830 hours,
I met with W/ M Robert W. Krueger and obtained a signed consent to Search/ Waiver of Search Warrant
form for the DVR. I disconnected the DVR from all of the attached cables, and transported the DVR, mouse,
and power cord to M.Montano #4926 for processing. I was later conta ed by M.Montano 4926 who advised
me the DVR could be transported back to the location on Skipper Road.Upon arrival, I returned the DVR
to its original location within the closet,and reconnected all of the cables to their original state of operation. 1
obtained a case number of 19-21 l 100 which I put on the Consent to Search/ Waiver of Search Warrant form. 1
will attach this form to this case. On March 29, 2019 Eleven (I I)
photographs from the scene that I took
were downlaed to a CD-R, and impounded at the Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office evidence section. I have
no furthe information to provide for this investigation at this time.For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 011-2019 ( Wed.)Page 306 of 372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVEIOPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Follow Up Repon # HS 6 - NOT COMPLETED
Follow Up Report # HS 6 - NOT COMPLETED

Assigned to: 5119 - Garcia, Moises Rank: Detective
Capacity: Other Follow Up Org unit: Homicide Section

Submitted on: Apr- 22- 2019 ( Mon.) 1544
Follow Up concluded: No

Author: 5119 - Garcia, Moises
Subject: ( Witness # 11) FONSECA, ANTHONY ( DOB:

t. Anthony Fonseca who relayed the following: The initial response

call was for a domestic. It wasn' t until he arrived on scene that he was informed by patrol deputies of the use
of deadly force. When he arrived members on the engine unit were rending to the victim medically. While
transporting the victim to the hospital they had to intubate him due to his breathing becoming more and more
shallow. The only thing the victim ever said was that he could not feel his legs. No other words were spoken by
the victim.
For the complete and accurate interview please listen to the recording and or read the transcripts*****
CO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
FonoK Up Report # HS 6 - NOT CONI PLETED

Author: 5119 - Garcia, Moises
Related date/ time: ADr- 22- 2019 ( Mon.) 959
is is my first supplement reference to this inc
On 03/ 26/ 19, at approximately 2059 hours, I responded to Skipper Rd in reference to a

use of deadly force incident. Upon arrival I met with Cpl. Greg Thomas # 5165 who advised me Det. Joseph
Florio # 205814 would be the lead investigator, and 1 would be tasked with documenting the incident scene. 1
observed the scene to be on the north side of Skipper Rd, east of the railroad tracks, directly in front of Rentalex
Equipment Rental ( 1016 Skipper Rd Tampa, FI). The incident appeared to located on the sidewalk in front of
Rentalex. There were several items of evidence which were already ( narked by patrol units. I waited fora Crime
Scene Unit to arrive and photograph the evidence prior to getting close enough to see the evidence.
Crime Scene Investigator (CSI) Michelle Mermann # 257973 responded to the scene and commenced
photographing and marking the scene. Once CSI. Hemann completed photographing the scene I conducted a
grid line search of the grassy areas next to the sidewalk but met with negative results locating any other evidence.
CSI. Hermann marked the following items with evidence markers:
I - HCSO Patrol Vehicle ( HCSO Tag# ZLY57)
2 - Shell Casing
3 - Shell Casing
4 - Clothing ( Red in color)
5 - Baggie containing possible marijuana inside
6 - Blood
7 - Clothing ( Red in color)

8 - Red watch cap
9 - Samsung cell phone ( standing on its side)
While documenting the items I observed several of the street lights in the area where extinguished.
directed CSI. Hennann to photograph the extinguished street lights to document the conditions. While CSI.
Herman continued photographing and setting up lights to assisting in documenting the scene, I contacted the
HCSO Communication center to request they check their database to locate the owners of Rentalex. Rentalex
had several cameras which were visible from Skipper Rd therefore I wanted to check if their cameras captured
the incident. A short time later I was advised a patrol deputy researched the information and responded to the
owner of Rentalex' s home, contacted the owner, had him respond to the scene, and the owner was standing by
to speak to me. I contacted Robert W. Krueger ( white male D. O. B. 07/ 19/ 65) who is the owner of Rentalex.
Robert Krueger showed the the surveillance system but relayed the monitor is broken and therefore the video
could not be viewed. I notified my supervisors, of the problem with the monitor, who in turn contacted Det. Rick
Woychowski # 3468 to respond to the scene to collect the video. Upon Det. Woychowski arrival 1 introduced him
to Robert Krueger and returned to the scene where CSI. Hermann continued to document and process the scene
with the assistance of Crime Scene Investigator ( CSI) Angela Anderson -Cobb # 257563.
Follow Up Report P HS 6 - NOT CONt PLETED
At approximately 2345 hours, Post -Miranda, Det. Florio conducted a walk through of the scene
with Dep. Daniel Estanislau # 253881 at which time Dep. Estanislau relayed his location during key points of the
incident. During the walk through CSI. Hermann marked where Dep. Estanislau first saw
with a blue A, and where Dep. Estanislau used deadly force with a blue marker B. Based
on Dep. Estanislau' s recollection CSI. Hermann placed a green marker A to indicate location.
Det. Tabor relayed he interviewed a witness who was standing several light poles away from the
incident and asked that we document the approximate distance from the scene the witness was standing. Det.
Tabor relayed the witness was standing in the vicinity of a light pole approximately 100 yards east of the incident
scene. I contacted CSI. Hermann and requested she measure and photograph from the power pole to the incident
scene to get an approximate distance ( see Det. Tabor' s supplement for information relating to the interview).
Myself, Det. Tabor and Det. Florio attempted to locate a projectile from the incident but met with
negative results. We located what we believed to be a strike location on the fence for Rentalex, and had CSI.
Hermann photograph and measure the possible strike point. Without locating the actual projectile there is no way
to be sure what we observed on the fence is a strike point or not. It is merely a possibility and therefore it was
photographed.
Once CSI. Hermann and CSI. Anderson - Cobb completed all of their photographs, video, and
measurements we secured the scene, and 1 secured for the evening.
For the next two weeks 1 was on adverse shift and therefore unavailable to assist on this
investigation*****
On 04/ 16/ 19 at approximately 1500 hours, I served a subpoena to the Hillsborough County School
Board Office of records ( 2010 E. Hillsborough Ave Room 4212 Tampa, FI 33610).
At approximately 1600 hours I contacted, and conducted a digitally recorded interview, with
Hillsborough County Fire Lieutenant Anthony Fonseca. The interview was conducted at the Hillsborough
County Fire Station located at 16304 N. Nebraska Ave Lutz, FI 33549 where Lt. Fonseca relayed the following:
The initial response call was for a domestic. It wasn' t until he arrived on scene that he was infornied by patrol
deputies of the use of deadly force. When he arrived members on the engine unit ivere rending to the victim
medically. While transporting the victim to the hospital they had to intubate him dire to his breathing becoming
more and more shallow. The only thing the victim ever said was that he could not feel his legs. No other words
were spoken by the victim.
For the complete and accurate interview please listen to the recording and or read the
transcripts*****
On 04/ 18/ 19, at approximately 1114 hours, I sat in on a digitally recorded interview with Dep.
Estanislau who came in for an interview with his anomey( See Det. Florio' s supplement).
Follow Up Report N HS 6 - NOT COMPLETED
This concludes my first supplement reference to this incident and my involvement in this case thus
far,
MRE ATTACHMENTS:
None
Assigned to: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory Rank: Patrol Corporal

Capacity: Other Fallow Up Org unit Homicide Section
Submitted on: Apr- 24- 2019 ( Wed.) 927

Approved on: Apr- 24- 2019 ( Wed.) by: 155902 - Cave, Chad
Author: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory

Related date/ time: Apr- 24- 2019 ( Wed.) 923
On 03/ 26/ 2019 at approximately 1950 hours, Corporal P. Cole ABN 136776 contacted me
by phone to advise of a deputy involved shooting taking place near Skipper Rd. within District 1. 1
requested he and his adverse shift detectives, to include Detective D. Tabor ABN 218707 respond to the incident
scene while Detective K. Rettew ABN 233650 respond to the hospital where the subject was transported. I
contacted detectives J. Florio ABN 205814 and M. Garcia ABN 5119 and requested they respond to conduct the
investigation. I departed my residence and arrived on scene at approximately 2044 hours. I noted crime scene
tape affixed across the roadway of Skipper Rd. at the intersection of Nebraska Ave. Upon arrival, I made contact
with patrol supervisors on scene and learned one deputy was involved and the deputy was D. Estanislau ABN
253881. His assigned call sign for the shift was 2A39. Deputy Estanislau was responding to a domestic violence
call ( HCSO call 19- 21 1 10 ) at 1250 Estanislau attempted to contact the subject
involved with the call when the use of force occurred. I learned the subject who was shot, was identified as
James transported to Tampa General Hospital (TGH).After
receiving the above noted information and after arrival of responding detectives, I asigned Det.
Florio as the lead, M/ Det. Garcia as the scene and myself as assist. I noted Det.Rettew had responded to
TGH for purposes of providing updates and contact with Fulmore' Crime Scene Investigator A.
Anderson -
Cobb ABN 257563 responded to TGH while Crime Scene Investigator M.
Hermann ABN 257973 responded
to the incident scene. The sun had already set and I noted the street lights directly over the incident scene
were not operable, therefore requested portable lighting to be set up by CSI. Due to the incident scene For:

GON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY-] BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
Folio" Up Report N HS 7
taking place upon the sidewalk on the north side of Skipper Rd., a search warrant was not required, therefore
processing commenced. Refer to M/ Det. Garcia' s supplement for details.
was advised of potential witnesses standing by outside of the cordoned off crime scene. I requested
Det. Tabor conduct recorded interviews with the witnesses. See his supplement for details.
At 2055 hours, Det. Renew called to advise was alert and talking within the TGH
Emergency room. He appeared to have sustained one gunshot wound. ER staff were evaluating and further
updates will be provided as received.
Surveillance cameras were noted affixed upon the businesses of the Rentalex and US Storage
facilities. Detectives began contacting the business owners/ managers to access potential footage. 1 noted CSI
Hennann arrived at 2107 hours to begin processing. Due to the incident originally being called in to FICSO
cot munications as a domestic violence incident, I requested a new case number assigned to the use of deadly
force incident by the HCSO communications section ( 19- 21 27 ). 1 also requsted both the domestic violence call and the use
of deadly force call linked within the Versaterm system. After requesting the new case number, I advised personnel on
scen to take note and document under the proper numbers. Der. C.Fisher ABN 167433 had responded to the
scene while in adverse capacity. Det. Fisher advised of more potential witnesses while looking for surveillance cameras.
I was provided with the names of Christopher Schmid and Michelle McCarty who reside at 1231
Four Seasons Dr. as well as potential cameras located at 1215 Four Seasons Dr. ( out of range and blocked by a
privacy fence).On scene CID staff elected to call M/Det. T. Dirks ABN 3721, to respond and assist, therefore l assigned
him the task of interviewing the witnesses noted above. See his supplement for further details. A12203 hours,
I received
a status regading Fulmore' s mother' s during the domestic incident. Deputies at the
scene down the street, had conveyed to their supervisors that her injury was minor to include a small laceration
to the back of her head. The injury is consistent with what was conveyed to the 911 operator from the original
call for service. Fulmore' s sister called hours to report Fulmore had body slammed mother upon
the ground in front of her grandfather' s apartment. Der. Florio and 1
left the incident scen and responded to District I patrol office at 2 13 hours, to make contact with Deputy
Estanislau. I took possession of a new FNS 9mm pistol from Lt.Hollis ABN 5603, in reference to collecting
the deputy' s firearm used in the incident. 1 noted the serial number of the new issued weapon is GKU01 15590.
1 received a call from personnel at the scene to update that the regional director for the Jasmine Terrace apartment complex (
was checking to ascertain if the complex security video is functioning.
Refer to initial patrol reports. Upon contact with Deputy Estanislau at the District I patrol office, CSI
Anderson- Cobb took overall photographs of him wearing his class B uniform, his issued firearm and ammunition. I
noted Deputy Estanislau' s magazine pouch upon his belt, contained two FNS 9mm magazines loaded to capacity
with 17 rounds each magazine ( A close to radio,magazine B close to buckle).The magazine within the issued
FNS 91nm pistol, contained 15 rounds and I round chambered, which would account for the two discharged
casings at the incident scene. FNS 9mm pistols are required by HCSO S.O. P. to be carried at full capacity ( 17
rounds within the magazine and I round chambered, totaling 18 rounds within the holstered weapon). The Streamlight TLR
attached light was noted as functional. For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Fol w Up Report #
HS 7 At 2330 hours,
Det. Florio and 1 responded back to the incident scene to conduct a walk through with Deputy Estanislau. Miranda
warning was read by Det. Florio at 2339 hours. Refer to M/Det.Garcia' s supplement for details of
the walk through and positioning. M/Det. R.
Woychowski ABN 3468 responded to the Rentalex business, 1028 Skipper Rd.in reference to obtaining
the surveil ance/ security video from the property. M/Det. Woychowski met with the manager and provided
access to the DVR within the main office of the business. At midnight, I ac ompanied M/Det. Woychowski into
the office to view the surveil ance/ security footage. The time stamp was 4 hours different than the actual
time, confirmed by M/ Det.Woychowski and CSA M.Montano ABN 4926, see their supplements for details. 1
viewed video from a camera at the front of the business, which captures footage upon the north side of Skipper Rd.
This is where the interaction took place between Deputy Estanislau and Fulmore. The actual shooting is not
captured on video, as both subjects move out of the cameras viewing angle. What l observed
was Fulmore walking west the sidewalk of the north side of Skipper Rd.Deputy Estanislau' s
assigned narked patrol vehicle pulls up to the north side of Skipper Rd.and Estanislau is seen exiting his
vehicle and casually make contact with Fulmore who is several vards away.Fulmore is observed
his body slightly left and skipping or side walking west. Fulmore appears to his left arm then walks off
camera view. Estanislau moves to the front bumper ofhis vehicle and immediately responds to the situation he
observed by quickly dropping his center ofgravity, drawing his firearm and assuming a shooting platform.Estanislau then
is seen moving west toward whatever threat he was assessing, while maintaining his shooting platform stance.
Estanislau then moves off the camera viewing angle. Refer to video. M/Det. Woychowski
copied the footage upon an 8GB thumb drive I had upon my key ring. 1 then transferred the
footage upon my laptop/ desktop and copied it upon Det.Florio' s laptop as wel . M/Det. Woychowski removed the
DVR for the purposes of downloading by CSA Montano the following day.At approximately 0040
hours, CID personnel re -

convened at the District I patrol office to debrief and assign further
tasks. Det.Florio and I left the Distrc 1 patrol office after the debriefing and travelled to TGH for the
purposes of making contact with Fulmore' s mother, TGH, Det. Florio and
I made contact with Stephanie Thomas and room of the Emergency room
floor. After we introduced ourselves, both agreed to recorded statements. At 0154 hours Mrs. Thomas provided
statement, see transcribed interview. After completing an interview with Mrs. Thomas, Det.
I conducted a recode statement with Velton Thomas at hours. See transcribed interview and
Det.Florio' s supplement for further details. The following day
on 03/ 27/19 at ap roximately 1320 hours, I responded to TGH and met with M/Det. Dirks for
the purposes of attempting an interview with Fulmore. M/ Det. had ascertained that Fulmore was awake
the intubation tube had been removed. Upon contact with Fulmore within Pediatric
to be awake and able to speak. We did not see his mother present within the room and nursing staff assumed
she had stepped out for a few moments. I called Mrs. Thomas' cell, spoke with her. She provided
permission to speak with her son and advised his father was responding to the hospital today. For: 205814 Printed
On: May- Ol-2019 ( Wed.)Page 313 Lai

GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACT] VE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Fol w Up Reporl
N HS 7 After we identif ed
ourselves, Fulmore said he not want to talk. M/Det. Dirks and I advised him if he wanted to speak, his
mother has our contact information. While leaving the hospital, contact was made with Fulmore' s father,
attempt to obtain a statement from his son was
made after permission was given by Mrs. Thomas to him. Mr. Fulmore advised retained the
services of Attorney Cannella Sr.and do not wish to make any statements. I collected Mr. Fulmore' s
the hospital. Upon return to my office, I received an email and voice mail from Attorney Cannella
Sr.requesting all HCSO personnel refrain from contacting his client. I replied to the email and advised
all investigative personnel of the request. In the following
days, Det. Florio kept me abreast of the status of the investigation. On 04/ 15/19, 1 accessed the
LEFTA training database and reviewed Deputy Estanislau' s field training phase . I noted that he was not
recommended for any remedial training and his daily scores were appropriate and high scoring for the level of
phases. Later in the day,a letter was received from Attorney Stephen Romine, who is representing Deputy Estanislau. A
statement of events was authored by Deputy Estanislau, which explained the actions viewed in the
surveillance/ security video, however further questions would need to be asked for explanation and clarity. HCSO Legal
staff would make inquiry with Attorney Romine if his client wished to provide a statement. Attorney Romine coordinated
with HCSO Legal staff and advised he and Deputy Estanislau would meet at CID on 04/ 18/
19 and provide clarity on the written statement previously mailed. I accessed the Nationl Weather Service and Weather
Underground sites for the climate report on 03/26/2019 at the time of the call for service. The climate reports
indicate sunset at 1944 hours and Fair conditions. On 04/18/
19 at 1 100 hours, I attended the meting with Deputy Estanislau and his Attorney Romine at CID.Also
present was ASA Scott Hannon ( State Attorney' s Office- SAO), SAO Investigator Juan Acosta, M/
Det. M.
Garcia, Det. J. Florio and HCSO Assistant Legal Counsel O.
Lindemann. The interview was audio recorded. Refer to
transcribed copy and Det.Florio' s supplement for details. This concludes my
involvement at this time.Any further investigation will be supplemented accordingly. For: 205814
Printed
On: May- 01-

2019 ( Wed.)Pagc 314 of 372
Follow Up Reporl # HS 8
Assigned to: 233650 - Rettew, Kevin Rank: Detective

Assigned on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1256 by: 233650 - Rettew, Kevin
Report due on: Apr- 19- 2019 ( Fri.)

Approved on: Apr- 06- 2019 ( Sat.) by: 5165 - Thomas, Gregory

Author: 233650 - Rettew, Kevin
Subject: ( Subject # 3) DOB:

The following is a synopsis of my interview with at TGH on 3/ 26/ 19. For full interview
details, please refer to the audio -recorded interview in HCSO Evidence.
made the following statements. Her son is

Tonight she was visiting her dad' s residence and her daughter, got into an
argument and were fighting while sitting in the car. She heard scream, so she came outside, took the keys
away from them, and locked the car door. got mad and tried to break the handles on the car door to get
back inside. She then smacked him on his head and he grabbed her by the arm, flipped her over his head, and
slammed her on the ground. She had to pause a second and catch her breath and and her father said
were calling the police. She told them don' t worry about it, it' s going to be okay, but her father said no, was
calling the cops because she hit her head pretty hard. then got scared and ran away. After she caught her
breath, she went inside and laid on the couch. Her father came back inside and said " they got him" so she thought
everything was okay.
This happened outside her father's residence in the parking lot. When she hit her head, she never lost
consciousness, but she was shocked, it took a breath out of her, and her head was ringing because it hit hard. She
couldn' t believe he picked her up like that, he physically picked her up off the ground and body slammed her.
didn' t have any physical injuries she knows of. Her father,
all witnessed slam her.
Folio" Up Repon N [ IS R
Once I ended the interview and turned the audio - recorder off, continued to talk
about having mental issues and can' t get him on the right medication. She didn' t want the police called, but
since they were already coming, she was just going to have Baker Acted and not arrested.

The following is a synopsis of my interview with at TGH on 3/ 27/ 19. For full interview details,
please refer to the audio -recorded interview in HCSO Evidence.
made the following statements. She knows the difference between a truth and a
lie, demonstrated how she knows, and promised to tell the truth while we were talking. Tonight,
called 911 for the police and called 911 for an ambulance. called because she and her brother were
arguing about the car keys and her mom took them. got mad and tried to break the car door handle and her
morn smacked him on the head. then picked her mom up and slammed her on the floor.
She was there to visit her grandpa and when she was arguing with they were outside by the
car. They were arguing over not giving her the keys. While they were arguing, grabbed her by the
head and banged it on the car. He grabbed her head and hair and hit it against the car. They fight all the time as
siblings. She went inside to tell her grandpa hit her and she was crying. said sorry, but was acting all
belligerent, yelling and being loud. After he slammed her mom down, called 911 and was scared of
walked off out of the apartment complex.
Follow Up Report # HS N

The following is a synopsis of my interview with at TGH on 3/ 27/ 19. For full interview details,
please refer to the audio -recorded interview in HCSO Evidence.
made the following statements. She knows the difference between a truth and a
lie, demonstrated how she knows, and promised to tell the truth while we were talking. She was visiting her
grandfather' s residence tonight with her mom, sister, While they were there,
and her sister were arguing over a key. Her mom locked them both out of the car and took the key. tried
to get back in the car and her mom hit on the head because he was trying to break the car door.
then picked her up and slammed her on the concrete. Her mom laid there for a second, called for an
ambulance, and called the cops. While they were waiting for the cops to come, she saw a bunch
down the road in front of the storage place.
Folio% Up Report # HS 8

This is my first follow up to this investigation
On 3/ 26/ 19 at 2005 hours, while working CID adverse shift, 1 was notified by Cpl. Cole # 136776 of
a deputy involved shooting investigation at Skipper Road Tampa, FL 33613 regarding HCSO CAD Call
19- 21 10 . 1 reviwed CAD Call # 19- 21 1 100, which was recivd by HCSO at 1942 hours. The CAD call notes advised "CP CRYING
SAYING SOMEONE IS BLEEDING". Further call notes advised the complainant' s brother threw her on
the floor and the complainant' s brother left. An ad itonal call was linked ( CAD call 19-211101) which advised "
CP ADV HIS 17 YO GRANDSON JUST KNOCKED OUT HIS MOTHER".Cpl. Cole advised he spoke with Cpl. Thomas #5165
who requested I start to respond to the incident scene for asitance. I departed the CID Office and placed myself
en route to CAD Call #19-21 1100 at 2009 hours. While en route to the incdent scen , prior to ever arriving, I
received a phone call from Cpl. Cole at 2024 hours who requested I instead respond to Tampa General Hospital and obtain the
status of the victim of this incident. At 2026 hours, I added a note to the CAD call to
indicate I was en route to TGH. I arrived to TGH at aproximately 2049 hours and first met
with TGH Security, who directed me to the Emergency Room Trauma Unit. Upon entry into the Trauma
Unit, 1 met with Deputy Perez # 254523 and Deputy Service #255039 who briefd me on what they knew about
the victim. Deputy Perez advised me the victim was James Fulmore (black male, date of birth 4/6/
01)and me Fulmore had one gunshot wound to the left
side of his which traveled towards his spine. Deputy Perez advised while Fulmore was being transported by ambulance, he
told EMS Personnel that couldn' t feel his legs. Fulmore was transported back to the
Trauma Unit from cat scan 2110 hours.I observed Fulmore, unclothed, lying on his back on the hospital
strechr and unable to speak. I observed several medical tubes and wires attached to
Fulmore, including a tube inserted into a port in his right which I learned was done by paramedics.
1 noted Fulmore was lying on top of a pair of red plaid which were cut off him by medical personnel prior
to my arrival. I learned from ER Trauma Dr.Sunderland that Fulmore was under "spinal precautions" meaning he suffered spinal
damage and was no reaction to touch in his feet.Dr.Sunderland wanted to limit
Fulmore' s movement, so I was initial y unable to view the to his back. According to Dr.Sunderland,
Fulmore was heavily sedated and suffered a shattered mid - thoracic and fracture. I obtained Fulmore' s medical
chart number ( MRN:100707460). Crime Scene Investigaor Anderson - arrived on scene to photograph Fulmore
and document his injuries and/or lack of injuries. While Anderson - Cobb was taking
photographs, ER Dr.Drukteinis conducted an exam of the gunshot wound to Fulmore' s back and temporarily
rolled Fulmore onto his left side. time, I was able briefly view the gunshot wound. I observed the
wound to be about mid -way up Fulmore' s back,to his left side with apparent blood oozing CSI Anderson -
Cobb was able to photograph the gunshot wound before Fulmore was rolled back onto his back by Dr.Drukteinis.
I not observe any other apparent gunshot wounds to Fulmore. For: 205814 Printed On:May- 01-2019 W
( ed.)
Page 319
372
Folloe Up Reporl # HS S
I received a phone call from Lt. Hollis # 5603 who advised me he believed mother
and sisters were on the way to TGH and requested
photographs be taken of head injury. 1 was escorted by the TGH Chaplain to the family
conference private rooms in the ER lobby where I met with I observed with an elastic bandage
around her head and gauze covering the back of her head. removed the bandage and I observed a shall
laceration on the back of her head. CSI Anderson - Cobb took photographs of and her head injury. I then
asked if I could interview her specifically about how she received the injury to her head and she agreed.
I conducted an audio -recorded interview with For interview details please refer to the interview text
section of this report and the audio -recorded interview, which was later impounded into evidence.
While interviewing I discovered CSI Anderson - Cobb left TGH. I noted Deputy Perez to
be in possession of a paper bag containing the personal property of removed from him by hospital staff.
The property included shoes, necklace, and earrings. 1 also collected previously mentioned
cut red plaid boxers and placed them in a paper bag. I provided the boxers to Deputy Perez and requested he
impound them into evidence, along with the other property removed from I then departed TGH at 2225
hours. I contacted Cpl. Thomas who requested 1 respond to the incident scene to be available for any assistance if
necessary.
I arrived to the incident scene at 2242 hours. I met with Major Losat # 3664 and provided a brief of
the injury to I observed and statements. I relayed what I learned at the hospital regarding the
gunshot wound to left back and suspected spinal damage. I also relayed statement about bei.
thrown on the ground by hitting her head, and and calling the 911. Following my
briefing, I stood by in the grass area on the very south side of Skipper Road, directly across from 1028 Skipper
Rd. ( Rentalex). I was then asked by Lt. Hollis to assist in searching for a projectile within the already opened
Rentalex parking lot. I conducted a line search along the south fence line of the property and equipment, but I did
not locate a projectile.
At 0023 hours, I departed the incident scene to attend a briefing at the HCSO District I Office.
During the briefing, I was instructed by Major Losat to respond back to TGH with Cpl. Thomas and Detective
Florio # 205814 and conduct interviews with
1 responded back to TGH and met
with within the family conference private rooms. 1 asked for permission to speak with her two
daughters while she was interviewed by Detective Florio and she agreed.
I first met with in a separate conference room and conducted an audio -recorded
interview with her. Next, I met with in a separate conference room and conducted an audio -
recorded interview with her. For details of each interview, please refer to the interview text sections of this report
and the audio -recorded interviews, which were later impounded into evidence. I departed TGH at approximately
0240 hours.
I submitted my three audio -recorded interviews for transcription on 3/ 29/ 19. This concludes my
involvement in this investigation.
For 205814 Primcd On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Pagc 320 of 372
Follow Up Report N US 8
Follow Up Report # Its Q
Assigned to: 136776 - Cole, Patrick Rank: Patrol Corporal
Capacity: Other Follow Up Org unit: SPECIAL VICTIM SECTION

Assigned on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1435 by: 205814 - Florio, Joseph
Report due on: Apr- 19- 2019 ( Fri.)
Submitted on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1910
Checked by: 226133 - Fisher, Justin

Approved on: Apr- 01- 2019 ( Mon.) by: 226133 - Fisher, Justin

Author: 136776 - Cole, Patrick
Related date/ time: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1638
On 03/ 26/ 19, 1 was working the adverse shift for CID. At 1950 hours, I received a phone call from Lt Steve
Lewis # 3464 and he notified the that a deputy was involved in a shooting at Skipper Rd. I then notified
Cpl Greg Thomas # 5165, Sgt Chad Cave # 155902 and Lt Preston Hollis # 5603 via phone about the incident. I
advised Detective Kevin Rettew # 233650 to respond to Tampa General Hospital and Detectives David Tabor
218707 and Chris Fisher # 167433 to respond to the scene. After I arrived on scene, Lt Hollis requested
Detective Fisher to conduct a neighborhood survey in the Village of Tampa MI-IP. I assisted Detective Fisher
with a neighborhood survey with the following results:
1217 Four Seasons Blvd ( no answer at the door / no camera on trailer)
1219 Four Seasons Blvd ( Fransico Madera answered the door and advised he did not see or hear anything / no
camera on trailer)

1229 Four Seasons Blvd ( Dora Fuentes answered the door and advised she did not see or hear anything / no
camera on trailer)
1233 Four Seasons Blvd ( Veilanny Miranda answered the door and advised she did not see or hear anything / no
camera on trailer)
I had no further involvement with the case.
Folio" Up Repon p HS 9
MRE attachments:
None
Folim, Up Report # HS 10
Assigned to: 218707 - Tabor, David Rank: Detective

Assigned on: Mar-29- 2019 ( Fri.) 2140 by: 218707 - Tabor, David
Report due on: Apr- 13- 2019 ( Sat.)
Submitted on: Apr- 18- 2019 ( Thu.) 1437

Approved on: Apr- 19- 2019 ( Fri.) by: 155902 - Cave, Chad

Author: 218707 - Tabor, David
Subject: ( Witness # 1) CADDY, ANNETTE ( DOB: Apr- 28- 1958)
I st recorded interview conducted with Annette Gaddy***
On March 26, 2019, at approximately 2107 hours, Annette Gaddy provided the following information under
sworn verbal oath during an audio recorded interview. During the interview, I noted Ms. Gaddy was visibly
affected by what she had witnessed. She did not appear to be under the influence of alcohol or drugs and I did not
observe any signs of deception.
She was on her way home from dropping her grandson off in Tampa Palms. She was driving west
on Bearss Avenue when she turned onto Skipper Road. When she turned onto Skipper Road she saw a police
officer' s light from his car up ahead of her. There were two or three cars in front of her. As she was approaching
the patrol vehicle, the deputy was out of the vehicle and was approaching a subject wearing all red. As the deputy
was approaching the subject, the subject looked back at the deputy and then took off running west bound on
Skipper Road. Then she heard " 3 pops", and saw the guy dressed in all red fall to the ground. She pulled over to
check on the guy but could not get any more information about what happened. She said she was driving her red
Ford Explorer and the patrol vehicle was a marked vehicle.
She explained she was traveling about 30 m. p. h. and she only saw one deputy who was standing on
the drivers side of the patrol vehicle that was parked. All her windows were in the up position and nobody else
was in her car with her. The man in red, who took off running, only got a few steps away before she heard the
Follow Up Report M HS 10
3 pops". When she heard the " 3 pops" she said she was " right there, where they were standing." She did not see
anything in the subject' s hands but, " was not looking for anything in anybody' s hands." With her windows up she
was unable to hear any dialogue between the deputy and the subject. She did not see the subject make and furtive
movements. She did not see any muzzle flashes and did not see a gun in the deputy' s hand.
After she stopped her vehicle and got out to check on the subject, she saw an older white male walking towards
Nebraska Avenue. She described him with dark blond hair, late 40' s- early 50' s, facial hair, possible wearing a
plaid shirt and khaki pants. There was also another guy riding a bicycle. She does not know the man who was
walking or the man riding the bicycle.
Above is only a synopsis of the interview conducted with Annette Gaddy. See the audio recording or transcribed
interview for the entire interview in detail.
Folio. Up Report # Hs 10

Subject: ( Witness # 1) GADDY, ANNETTE ( DOB: Apr- 28- 1958)
audio recorded interview conducted with Annette
On March 26, 2019, at approximately 2143 hours, Annette Gaddy provided the following information under
sworn verbal oath during the second audio recorded interview.
She does not know if the subject in red reached for anything. When the deputy was approaching
the subject, the subject actually stopped, looked over his left shoulder and then began to run westbound away
from the deputy. She did not see anyone reach for anything and she did not see the subject' s arms when he was
running.
Above is only a synopsis of the interview conducted with Annette Gaddy. See the audio recording or transcribed
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACT] V E/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
Follow Up Report N [ IS 10

Subject: ( Witness # 7) DELACRUZ, JOSE D ( DOB: Jul- 04- 1955)

On March 26, 2019, at approximately 2202 hours, Jose Delacruz provided the following information under sworn
verbal oath during an audio recorded interview. Mr. Delacruz did not appear to be under the influence of drugs or
alcohol and I did not observe any signs of deception.
He was going to the store to play Mega Millon' s. He exited the trailer park when he observed the
old black man standing in the road in front of with a phone in his hand. A police officer came
from Nebraska and met with the old man. He said the old man was yelling " the one in the red, the one in the red."
The old man was pointing to the guy walking down the sidewalk who was wearing red. The deputy then turned
around and drove towards the guy walking in red. He did not see the guy in red running or any guns. He said
the patrol vehicle stopped, the guy in red was on the sidewalk next to the car, and then he heard " boom, boom,
boom." He did not see anyone exit the patrol vehicle. After he heard the " boom' s" the guy disappeared. He was
about 3 light poles away from where the shooting took place. He said the guy in red was not running away from
the deputy. He thinks the guy in red and the old man were having family problems but he is not sure. He could
not hear any discussion between the deputy and the subject in red because he was too far away.
Above is only a synopsis of the interview conducted with Jose Delacruz. See the audio recording or transcribed
Follow Up Report # Its 10

Subject: 1ST SUPPLEMENTAL FOLLOW UP
This is my first supplemental follow up in reference to
On Tuesday, March 26, 2019, I was working as the adverse detective within the Criminal
Investigations Division when I was notified by Corporal P. Cole ABN # 136776 of a Deputy Involved shooting
at approximately 2010 hours. Corporal Cole advised District I Patrol Deputies were responding to a domestic
call for service ( Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office case number 2019- 211 10 ) at 1250 Skipper Terrace
female victim on the ground with an injury to her head. The suspect was identified
as her son who fled the scene prior to the arrival of responding deputies. Deputies eventually came into contact
with the victim' s son who was walking on the sidewalk along Skipper Road away from the incident scene. At
some point during the interaction with the subject, the deputy utilized his firearm to deploy deadly force.The
shooting took place just west of the original call for service, west of the Jasmine Terrace
was struck by a bullet and transported to Tampa General Hospital. I was first requested to respond to Tampa General
Hospital to check the status of the victim. While pulling into the parking lot of Tampa General Hospital, I
was re- routed to the scene to assist with interviews. While en -
route to the shooting scene, I reviewed the Computer Automated Dispatch for HCSO case number
2019-21 1 100 and leamed is was dispatched as a 380 Domestic -Just Oc ur ed. The response location was listed as
1250 Skipper Road Apartment on 03/26/2019 at 1942 hours. In the remarks of
the CAD call I learned of the fol wing information: "CP CRYING SAYING SOMEONE IS BLEEDING."While driving to
the
incident scene, I was contacted by Corp al Gregory Thomas ABN 95165 via phone, who advised I
was going to asit with interviewing two witnesses who may have observed the shooting. The actual location where
the shooting took place was just west of the apartment complex where the original call for service was received.
I further learned Detective Joseph Florio ABN #
205814 was being assigned as the lead detective and Corporal Thomas
was going to be assisting him.Master Detective Moises Garcia ABN #
51 19 was being assigned as the
crime scene detective. At approximately 2047 hours,
1 arrived at the incdent location. I noted it was dark outside. I arrived at the scen from
Nebraska Avenue. Upon arrival, I observed a patrol deputy standing post on Skipper Road between the railroad crossing
and Nebraska Avenue. The deputy was in his marked patrol vehicle and had his emergency lights activated. The
deputy appeared to be preventing through traf ic from proceeding eastbound on Skipper Road.The
deputy allowed me to proceed east on Skipper Road.I proce ded a short distance where I observed yellow Sheriffs
Ofice Crime Scene tape stretching across the roadway from a light pole on the north side of the
road, just west of the Rentalex, to the white PVC fence on the south side of the road. There were multiple HCSO units
on scene to include supervisory personnel. 1 provided my information to Deputy Magro ABN 2#44912 who
was maintaining the crime scene log on the western perimeter. I proceeded to walk For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY-] BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Follow Up Report #
HS 10 east bound on
the south side of the road where 1 made contact with Cpl. Thomas. At this time, Cpl. Thomas proceeded to explain
there were two witnesses who needed to be interviewed. One witness was on the west side of the incident
scene and sitting inside of her vehicle. The other witness was on the east side of the incident scene and was
standing with deputies while waiting to be interviewed. Cpl. Thomas provided me with a brief synopsis at which
time I learned deputies responde to a domestic call for service at 1250 Skipper Road (
victim with an injury to her head. The suspect was identified as her son,who fled the
scene on foot prior to the arrival of deputies. Deputy Estanislau ABN #253881 located the suspect walking westbound, on
the north side sidewalk, away from the incident scene. The suspect was wearing a red long sle ved hoodie.
Deputy Estanislau made contact with the suspect. At some point Deputy Estanislau drew his service weapon
and deployed deadly force. The suspect was struck and subsequently transported to Tampa General Hospital where
he was being treated for his injuries. Cpl. Thomas pointed to the north side of Skipper road and stated
that is approximately where the shooting took place. At that time, I observed an HCSO marked patrol vehicle parked
on the north shoulder of Skipper Road,facing west bound. In front of the vehicle (west of)l observed what
aperd to be red in color clothing. See Master Detective M.Garcia supplement for a detailed description of the
crime scene. I then walked
westbound towards Deputy M. Magro. Deputy Magro pointed to a red in color Ford Explorer that was
parked on the north shoulder of Skipper Road facing west bound. Deputy Magro advised the female witness was
sitting in the driver' s seat of the Ford Explorer. Deputy Magro proceeded to tell me Deputy M. Watts originally
began to interview the female witness before she D( ep.Magro) took over the interview. Shortly into her
interview with the female witness, Deputy J.Blyth ABN #258 27, then took over the interview with the witness.
See respective supplements for further details of those interviews. At approximately 2102
hours, I made contact with the red Ford Explorer ( North Carolina registration plate ADB- 5530)
and noted all four windows were in the up position. I knocked on the drivers' side window and made contact
with the female witness, Annette Gaddy (a black female, date of birth April 28, 1958).1 noted Ms. Gady was
the only occupant inside of the vehicle and she confirmed she was the only occupant inside the vehicle during the
incident. I introduced myself to her and asked if she was wil ing to sit inside of my vehicle where I could
conduct an audio recorded interview with her.Ms.Gaddy agreed to my request. I noted Ms. Gady appeared to be
visibly shaken by what she had witnessed and she did not appear to be under the influence of any alcohol or narcotics.
At ap roximately 2107
hours, I proceeded to conduct the first of two audio recorded interviews with Ms.Gaddy under
sworn verbal oath inside of my vehicle. Those present during the course of the interview were Ms. Gaddy and
myself. The interview lasted approximately 25 minutes in length and was recorded in its entirety. At one point
during the interview, Ms.Gaddy and I exited my vehicle and we walked to the western perimeter of the crime
scene and stopped at the Yellow Sherif s Office crime scene tape. From there Ms. Gaddy explained the patrol vehicle
she saw parked, with the lights on, was between the Rentalex sign and the U.S.Storage sign. It should be
noted, from where Ms. Gaddy and 1 were standing on the western perimeter of the crime scene, she was unable
to identify the exact patrol vehicle the deputy exited prior to approaching the subject in red. It should be noted
during the audio recording 1 stated the interv w was being conducted under HCSO investigation 42019-21 1100.
That is incorrect, as the interview should have been conducted under HCSO investigation For:205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.) Page 329 of 372

Follow Up Report N HS In
2019- 21 27 . See the interviw section for further details. A copy of the interview was later impounded into evidence and submitted for transcription
purposes. At the conclusion of the interview, I asked Ms. Gaddy if she was willing to wait
a few minutes until I could update HCSO personnel with the information I learned via her interview. Ms. Gaddy said
that was fine. Ms.Gaddy proceeded back to her vehicle and I updated HCSO personnel to include Detective Florio.
At ap roximately 2143 hours, I
conducted the second interview with Ms.Gaddy inside of my vehicle. The interview was conducted
under sworn verbal oath and recorded in its entirety. Those present were Ms. Gaddy and myself. During
the course of the 2nd interview Ms.Gaddy and I exited Ivy vehicle and proced to walk into the crime
scene area. We remained on the south side of the roadway and walked over to where she could observe the HCSO patrol
vehicle that was parked facing westbound on the north shoulder of Skipper Road. During this walk through. Ms.
Gaddy advised everything happened on the north side of the roadway. She pointed to the vehicle that was
parked on the north shoulder, facing westbound, and stated that was the area where she observed the patrol vehicle parked.
She pointed west of the front end of the patrol vehicle and said that is where the subject in red was
at.See the interview section for further details. At approximately 2200 hours, I
made contact with witness, Jose Delacruz ( white Hispanic male, date of birth 07/04/
1955).Mr.Delacruz was standing with street crimes deputies awaiting to be interviewed by detectives. At ap roximately 2203
hours, I conducted an audio recorded interviw with Mr. Delacruz under sworn verbal oath. Mr.Delacruz
did not appear to be under the influence of alcohol but did advise he had two shots of whiskey around 6:
00 o'clock. Mr.Delacruz advised he was about 3 light poles east of where the shooti actually took place. It should
be noted during the audio recording I stated the interview was being conducted under HCSO investigation # 2019-21
1 100.That is incor ect, as the interview should have been conducted under HCSO investigation #2019-21 1277.See
the interview section for details of the interview. At approximately 2234 hours, I made
contact with Deputy C.Ziel ABN #220973 who advised he collected video surveillance from the U.
S.
Storage at 1108 Skipper Road, Tampa, Florida 33612. This business is located on the north side
of the street slightly east of the where the shooting took place. I reviewed the video surveillance and noted the camera faces
Skipper Road. While reviewing the video surveillance, l observed a subject dressed in al red walking
westbound on the north sidewalk. He appeared to be agitated as I observed him hit the chain link fence. There
was another subject who was riding a bicycle traveling westbound on the northern sidewalk. The subject on the bicycle
was wearing bright colored clothing and continued past the subject dressed in all red.This subject on
the bicycle may be the person Ms. Gaddy was refer ing to during her interview. The subject continued west on the sidewalk.
1 observed a patrol vehicle traveling from east to west on the north side of Skipper Road. I obtained a
copy of the video surveillance from Deputy C.Ziel and provided same to Detective Florio the following day on March
27,2019. At approximately 2251 hours, I responded
to the Circle K (
14517 Nebraska Avenue North, Tampa, Florida 33613) at the southeast corner
of Nebraska Avenue and Skipper Road in attempts to identify the older white male or the black male
on the bicycle as described by Ms. Gaddy. I made contact with the clerk on duty, Giedarilis Sicard. Ms. Sicard was reluctant
to provide her personal information but did provide a phone number of 813- 277-4850. Furthermore, Ms.
Sicard advised a black male calve into the store and was talking about For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01-
2019 ( Wed.) Page 330 of 372

GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY4 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
FDlloa Up Report p HS ID
witnessing a shooting which occurred down the street on Skipper Road. She described him as a tall black male,
wearing glasses, and riding a bicycle. The black male is between 50 and 60 years old, with facial hair and looks
like he is homeless. She said he comes into the store right after the shooting occurs. She does not know his name
but said he is a regular customer. I was able to obtain video surveillance from the Circle K between 6: 30 P. M.
and 10: 30 P. M. on March 26, 2019. 1 noted the date and time stamp on the live video feed was accurate with my
HCSO issued laptop computer. The purpose for obtaining the surveillance video was to hopefully identify the
individuals described by Ms. Gaddy and attempt to interview them.
Wednesday, March 27, 2019

At approximately 0024 hours, l cleared from the incident scene on Skipper Road and relocated to the
District I Office where I reviewed the video surveillance from the Circle K. While reviewing salve, I observed a
black male enter the Circle K at approximately 7: 48: 00 P. M. He was wearing glasses, fluorescent orange shorts,
a red camouflage vest, with facial hair. This individual appeared to be the same person I observed on video
surveillance obtained from the U. S. Storage. 1 continued to watch the video surveillance in entirety, and I never
observed the older white male described to me by Ms. Gaddy. This information was provided to Det. Florio along
with the video surveillance. The video surveillance was later impounded into evidence by Det. Florio.
At approximately 0323 hours, 1 concluded my tour of duty in regards to this investigation.
This concludes my involvement in this investigation and I have no further information to report at
this time.
MRE attachments:
None
Report H HS I I For: 205814
Assigned to: 244872 - Douglas, Brannon Rank: Technician
Assigned on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) 1530 by: 244872 - Douglas, Brannon
Report due on: Apr- 13- 2019 ( Sat.)
Checked by: 216374 - Patel, Kaminiben

Approved on: Apr- 22- 2019 ( Mon.) by: 216374 - Patel, Kaminiben
Document: CRIME SCENE SECTION PROCESSES

Author: 244872 - Douglas, Brannon
Subject: CRIME SCENE SUPPLEMENT
Related date/ time: Apr- 20- 2019 ( Sat.) 833
SUPPLEMENTAL INVESTIGATION: CASE No: 19- 21 1277 REPOTING OFFICER
Name: B.
Douglas ABN: 244872

OFFENSE INFORMATION
Original Offense:
Date of
Occurrence: Address of
Occurrence: Address Dispatched:
VICTIM INFORMATION
Name: Fulmore,
Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 332 of372

Follow Up Report N HS I I
Number Description
1- 3 Overalls of the sealed envelope
4 Overalls of the contents of the envelope
5- 8 Overalls of black Samsung cell phone
9- 15 Overalls of the cell phone and phone case
16- 22 Overalls of the phone case
INVESTIGATION
On March 29, 2019, at approx. 1505 hrs, I met with Det. Florio ( ABN: 205814). Det. Florio
requested photographs of property number 736559- 1 1, a sealed envelope containing a cell phone. Photographs
were taken of the cell phone. The cell phone was repackaged and returned to Det. Florio. Det. Florio stood -by
while the photographs were taken and retained custody of the cell phone. I completed the task at approx. 1525
hrs.
MRE Attachments: None
Assigned to: 4857 - Hager, Nancy Rank: Technician

Assigned on: Apr- 08- 2019 ( Mon.) 1640 by: 4857 - Hager, Nancy
Report due on: Apr- 23- 2019 ( Tue.)

Approved on: Apr- 16- 2019 ( Tue.) by: 216374 - Patel, Kaminiben
Narrative Text Report # I
Author: 4857 - Hager, Nancy

Related date/ time: ADr- I1- 2019 ( Thu.) 757
SUPPLEMENTAL INVESTIGATION Case No.

19- 21 1277
REPORTING OFFICER:
Name: Hager, N. Bur:
FSB
ABN: 4857
OFFENSE INFORMATION:
Original Offense:
Date of Occurrence:
HCSO Aviation
SCENE/ TANGIBLE EVIDENCE:
Was Scene Processed: Yes
Deputy/ CSI Assigned: Hager
PHOTOGRAPHS
I Identifier
2- 43 Aerial photos of scene/ area
LATENTS
N/ A
EVIDENCE
N/ A
INVESTIGATION:
On 03/ 28/ 19, at the request of GMI Patel ( ABN # 216374), 1 took aerial photographs of the listed scene/ area.
GOO HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
Follow Up Report p [ is IJ
Assigned to: 257951 - Smith, Hurley Rank: Technician

Assigned on: Apr- 08- 2019 ( Mon.) 2313 by: 257951 - Smith, Hurley
Checked by: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas

Approved on: Apr- 18- 2019 ( Thu.) by: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas
Author: 257951 - Smith, Hurley

Subject: CRIME SCENE
CASE NUMBER: 19- 21 1277
REPORTING OFFICER:
Name: H. Smith ABN: 257951
OFFENSE INFORMATION:
Original Offense: Use of deadly

Date of Occurrence: 4- 8- 19
Address Dispatched: 1016 Skipper Rd
VICTIM INFORMATION:
Name:
For: 205814 Printed On: Nlay- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 336 ot372
Folio% Up Report # Its 13
PHOTOGRAPHS ( Digital):
No. Description
NONE
LATENTS
Property Report #:
NONE
EVIDENCE
Property Report #:
Item Qty Description
NONE
INVESTIGATION:
On Monday, April8, 2019, at approximately 1219 hrs I was en route to the listed address and arrived
at approximately 1301 hrs. Once on scene, I met with Cpl. Graves ( 4044), Del. Fisher ( 167433), and CSI B.
Douglas ( 244872). 1 assisted CSI B. Douglas with scanning the area with the FARO. Please refer to his report for
further information.
At approximately 1310 hrs we began scanning. At approximately 1451 hrs we cleared the scene.
MRE ATTACHMENTS: None
HS V Name: K. Hall
Assigned to: 247812 - Hall, Katelyn Rank: Technician

Assigned on: Apr- 15- 2019 ( Mon.) 1830 by: 216374 - Patel, Kaminiben
Checked by: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas

Approved on: Apr- 18- 2019 ( Thu.) by: 3721 - Dirks, Thomas

Author: 247812 - Hall, Katelyn
Subject: CRIME SCENE
Related date/ time: Aor- 18- 2019 ( Thu.) 2138
SUPPLEMENTAL INVESTIGATION: CASE No: 19- 21 27 REPORTING OFICER Services
Folio"Up
Division: CID BUR: Forensic ABN: 247812 Section:

Report #
Crime Scene OFFENSE INFORMATION LATENTS
Original Offense:
of Force Date of Occurrence:

March 26, 2019 Address of Occurrence:
Scene Section ( CSS)Examined with FSIS:
Use
For:205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 338 of 372

Follow Up Report N [ IS 14
Under Property # 736559)

Item Photos Description
11 2 Battery from phone

I 1 I Inside battery area of phone
Processed with cyanoacrylate fuming and black powder:
Under Property 4736559)

I l 2 Battery from phone

I I I Inside battery area of phone
EVIDENCE IMPOUNDED
Property # 739515
Item Qty/ Wgt Description
Control swab of distilled water
Swab from black cell phone and case
INVESTIGATION
On April 15, 2019, at the request of Det. Garcia ( ABN: 5119), writer swabbed the phone and case
for possible touch DNA. Writer examined the phone and case with the Full Spectrum Imaging System ( FSIS)
with the above listed results. Writer processed the phone and case for latent prints with cyanoacrylate fuming
and black powder with the above listed results. Writer further processed the case with " MSTAR" dye stain.
Writer examined the case with an alternate light source with negative results. Latents were forwarded to the
Identification Section under property number 739566.
GMI Kamini Patel observed writer process the phone and case in its entirety.
Follox Up Report N HS 15
Assigned to: 167433 - Fisher, Christopher Rank: Detective
Capacity: Continue Investigation Org unit: Traffic Homicide Section

Assigned on: Apr- 16- 2019 ( Tue.) 1411 by: 167433 - Fisher, Christopher
Submitted on: Apr- 16- 2019 ( Tue.) 1412

Approved on: Apr- 18- 2019 ( Thu.) by: 155902 - Cave, Chad
Narrative Text Report # I

Author: 167433 - Fisher, Christopher
Related date/ time: Apr- 16- 2019 ( Tue.) 1412
On 03/ 26/ 19 at approximately 2043 hours, I responded to 1028 Skipper Road, Tampa, FL. 33613. Cpl. P. Cole
136776 and I began canvassing for surveillance video within the Village of Tampa, located at 1201 East Skipper
Road. I looked for video at the following addresses with the listed results:
1215 Four Seasons Boulevard - I made contact with Cynthia Wilcher, B/ F, 1/ 22/ 79 and learned she has a
surveillance system installed. Three of her cameras ( 2, 5, & 6) point north, toward Skipper Road. Those cameras
may provide a limited view of Skipper Road directly behind her residence, which is approximately 450 feet east
of the shooting scene. 1 advised Ms. Wilcher someone may come to retrieve video from her system.
1223 Four Seasons Boulevard - No cameras

1231 Four Seasons Boulevard - Christopher Schmid, W/ M, 06/ 22/ 85 and his wife, Michelle McCarty, W/ F,
02/ 17/ 84, both stated they heard someone yell and then heard gunshots. Their residence is less than 150 feet
directly south of the shooting scene. l advised them both they would be contacted by a detective for an interview.
At 2153 hours, I was directed to an unrelated incident and left the scene. Before my departure, I passed the results
from my canvassing on to Detective G. Thomas # 5165 for followup.
Follow Up Repon # HS 15
This concludes my involvement in this case.
GOP HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
Follow Up Report # HS 1°
Assigned to: 4791 - Zackery, Wesley Rank: Other

Capacity: Identification Org unit: Identification Section CIIDO
Assigned on: Apr- 17- 2019 ( Wed.) 946 by: 4791 - Zackery, Wesley

Checked by: 139536 - Jarvis, Nicole
Approved on: Apr- 17- 2019 ( Wed.) by: 139536 - Jarvis, Nicole
Document: IDENTIFICATION SECTION PROCESSES
Author: 4791 - Zackery, Wesley

Property #' s 739566- 1 and 739566- 2 ( Processed by CSI K. Hall, ABN 247812)
The latent prints received for the above listed property numbers are not of value for comparison to known
subjects or search in the Automated Fingerprint Identification Systems ( AFIS).
CON HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY -AGGRAVATED
Follox Up Report # HS 17
Assigned to: 4926 - Montano Mark J Rank: Community Service Aide

Capacity: Other Follow Up Org unit: Intelligence Coordination Section SIICU
Assigned on: Mar- 27- 2019 ( Wed.) 1255 by: 4926 - Montano Mark J
Report due on: Apr- 10- 2019 ( Wed.)

Approved on: Apr- 19- 2019 ( Fri.) by: 155902 - Cave, Chad

Author: 4926 - Montano Mark J
On 3/ 27/ 2019, 1 met with Master Detective R. Woychowski # 3468 at the Special Investigation Division who
provided me with a DVR which had been recovered from 1028 Skipper Rd. After securing the DVR, 1 noted the
following:
Brand: Mace
Model: MVSQ- DVRI6VA

SIN: 132141124000040
Channel Capacity 16
HDD: Western Digital 2. 0 TB
HDD Model: W D20EURS
HDD S/ N: WMC4M0536169
HDD Build Date 11 / 27/ 2012
Date/ Time Differential:

Format: MM DD YYYY - 12 HR
DVR Date/ Time: 3/ 27/ 2019 8: 46: 20 ( Live View)
Actual Date/ Time: 3/ 27/ 2019 12: 51: 55 ( U. S. Naval Observatory)
Date Differential: None
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Follow Up Reporl N
HS 17 Time Dif er ntial:- 4 hours
5 Minutes 35 Seconds behind actual time Recording Configuration: Chanel Resolution
Frame Rate
Bitrate Channel 1 DI 7
FPS VBR Channel 2 CIF 30

FPS CBR Channel 3 CIF 30

FPS CBR CIF Resolution: 352 X
240 DI Resolution: 704 X

480 Recording Mode: Continuous and
Motion Export Formats: ASF / DAV
I exported the video
from the DVR hard drive via a Wiebetech Forensic Ultra Dock write blocker utilizing DVR Examiner v2.6.
0 Filesystem v3. 0. 4505 and provided same to Det. Garcia (see export report). I did not review the content of
the video and 1 have no further involemnt at this time.For:
205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

Folio. Up Report # HS IS
Assigned to: 244872 - Douglas, Brannon Rank: Technician
Assigned on: Apr-20- 2019 ( Sat.) 834 by: 244872 - Douglas, Brannon
Report due on: May- 05- 2019 ( Sun.)

Approved on: Apr- 22- 2019 ( Mon.) by: 216374 - Patel, Kaminiben

Author: 244872 - Douglas, Brannon
Subject: CRIME SCENE SUPPLEMENT
Related date/ time: Apr- 20- 2019 ( Sat.) 837
SUPPLEMENTAL INVESTIGATION: CASE No: 19- 211277
REPORTING OFFICER
Name: B. Douglas BUR: Forensic Services

ABN: 244872
OFFENSE INFORMATION
Original Offense:
Date of Occurrence:
GO# HS 2019- 21I277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY - I BATTERY - AGGRAVATED
EVIDENCE IMPOUNDED
Property # 738996)
Item Qty/ Wgt Description
FARO Scan data
INVESTIGATION
On April 8, 2019, at approx. 1300 hrs, I met with Cpl Graves ( ABN: 4044), Det. Fisher (ABN:
167433), and CSI Smith ( ABN: 257951) at 1016 Skipper Rd. Cpl Graves requested FARO scans of the area. The
scans were complete at approx. 1451 hrs. I' cleared the scene and returned to the Crime Scene Section. The scans
were processed and registered. I burned a copy of the scan data to a CD and submitted it to the Evidence Control
Section.
MRE Attachments: None
Follow Up Report # HS 19 - NOT COMPLETE D
Follow Up Report # HS 19 - NOT COMPLETED

Assigned to: 205814 - Florio, Joseph Rank: Detective

Capacity: Continue Investigation Org unit: Homicide Section
Assigned on: Apr- 29- 2019 ( Mon.) 1006 by: 205814 - Florio, Joseph
Report due on: May-29- 2019 ( Wed.)
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Clearance Information Agency: Hillsborough
County Cleared
status: Not Applicable -
Not Applicable Cleared on: Mar- 27-
2019 (Wed.) ComplainantNictim notified: No For:
205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (

Related Property Report( s)

Report Information
Property Report #: 736542

Property case status: EVIDENCE
Submitted on: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.) by: Perez, Armando
Related:
Offense: GO HS 2019- 211277
Location: 1250 SKIPPER RD
Related items: 4
Articles - Evidence
Status: EVIDENCE Tag #: HS736542- 1
Article: YCLOTHE- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NIKE
Model: of pieces: 1
Serial # I: UNKNOWN OAN:
Value: $ 0. 00 Color: Black
Description: BLK AIR JORDAN
Recovered date:- Recovered value: $ 0. 00
Flags: * e
Current Location: WI GEN/ 04/ 1/ 11/ C
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Value: $ 0. 00 Color: Red, Black
Description: PLAID BOXER BRIEFS
Recovered date:- Recovered value: $ 0.00
Flags: * e
Current Location: W1 B1O/ Ol/ B/ 07/ G
Jewelry - Evidence
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736542- 2 Article: Necklace

Gender: Unisex of pieces: 1
Metal type: Silver Karat:
Engraving/ Serial #: UNKNOWN

Value: $ 0. 00 Color: Gray
Description: GRAY CHAIN
Recovered date: - Recovered value: $ 0.00
Flags: x* e
Current Location: WI VAU/ 03/ B/ 04/ A
Jewelry - Evidence
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736542- 4 Article: Jewelry ( not included elsewhere charms)

Gender: Unisex of pieces: 2
Metal type: White Colored Karat:
of stones: 2 Shape of stone: Round
Engraving/ Serial #: UNKNOWN

Value: $ 0. 00 Color: White
Description: WHITE COLORED STONE EARINGS
Recovered date: - Recovered value: $ 0. 00
Flags: x* e
Current Location: WI VAU/ 03/ B/ 04/ A
Flags = d ( disposed) x ( x- reference) it ( entered on NCIC) * c ( evidence)

Report Information

Submitted on: Mar- 26- 2019 ( Tue.) by: Anderson -Cobb, Angela
Related:
Location: 14102 20TH ST N

District: D1 Zone: B03
Related items: 7
Articles

Article: YGUNMAG- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Value: $ 0. 00 Color:
Description: 17 ROUND 9MM FN MAGAZINE " A" DUTY BELT FROM D. ESTANISLAU
Current Location: W1 GEN/ 03/ 3/ 07/ H
Articles

Article: YGUNMAG- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Description: 17 ROUND FN 9MM MAGAZINE " B" DUTY BELT D. ESTANISLAU
Current Location: WI GEN/ 03/ J/ 07/ H
Firearm
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736555- 1
Make: FNH USA
Item: Pistol Type: Semi -Auto
Model: FNS- 9 Caliber: 9MM
Barrel length: 4. 0 Finish: BILK
Serial #: GKU0126648
OAN: Value: $ 0. 00
Description: FNS- 9 PISTOL/ MAGAZINE/ LIGHT FROM D. ESTANISLAU
Current Location: FDLE LAB
Firearm
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736555- 2
Item: Ammunition Type: Semi -Auto

Model: Caliber: 9MM
OAN: Value: $ 0. 00
Description: HORNADV 9MM LUGER LIVE ROUND FROM CHA OF FNS- 9 GKU0126648
Current Location: W1 CEN/ 03/ J/ 07/ H
Firearm
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736555- 3
Model: Caliber: 9MM
OAN: Value: $ 0. 00
Description: 15 HORNADV 9MM LUGER LIVE ROUNDS FROM MAG FNS- 9 GKU0126648
Firearm
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736555- 5
Model: Caliber: 9MM
OAN: Value: $ 0. 00
Description: 17 HORNADV 9MM LIVE ROUNDS MAC " A" D. ESTASNISLAU DUTY BELT
Firearm
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736555- 7
Model: Caliber: 9MM
OAN: Values $ 0. 00
Description: 17 HORNADV 91VIM LIVE ROUNDS MAG " B" DUTY BELT D. ESTANISLAU
Current Location: WI CEN/ 03/ J/ 07/ H
Flags = d ( disposed) x ( x- reference) n ( entered on NCIC) * c ( evidence)

Report Information

Submitted on: Mar- 27- 2019 ( Wed.) by: Ziel, Christopher
Related:
Related items: 1
Articles - Evidence

Article: RCDISC- RADIO, TV, ENTERTAINMENT DEVICES
Make: NO BRA
Model: DISC of pieces: 1
Serial # L UNKNOWN OAN:
Value: $ 0. 00 Color: Silver/ Aluminum
Description: COMPACT DISC CONTAINING VIDEO SURVEILLANCE
Flags: * e
Current Location: Wl GEN/ 06/ B/ 02/ B

Report Information

Submitted on: Mar- 27- 2019 ( Wed.) by: Hermann, Michelle
Related:

District: D1 Zone: A03
Related items: 12
Articles
Status: EVIDENCE Tag #: HS736559- I

Article: YAMMUS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: HORNAD
Model: of pieces: 1
Description: ONE 9MM FIRED CARTRIDGE CASE FROM GROUND ( MARKER 2)
Current Location: W1 GEN/ 01/ E/ 09/ C
Articles
Status: EVIDENCE Tag#: HS736559- 2

Make: HORNAD
Model: of pieces:
Description: ONE 9MM FIRED CARTRIDGE CASE FROM GROUND ( MARKER 3)
Current Location: WI GEN/ 01/ E/ 09/ C
Articles

Make: NO BRA
Model: # of pieces:
Description: PAIR OF RED SWEATPANTS FROM GROUND ( MARKER 4)
Current Location: W1 BIO/ Ol/ D/ OS/ H
Articles

Article: VBAG- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Serial # 1: UNKNOWN OAN:
Description: PLASTIC BAG FROM GROUND ( MARKER 5)
Current Location: WI DRU/ 02/ B/ 08/ F
Articles

Article: YSWAB- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Serial # l: UNKNOWN OAN:
Values $ 0. 00 Color:
Description: CONTROL SWAB
Current Location: WI GEN/ 02/ A/ 03/ C
Articles

Article: VFORENS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Description: SWAB FROM EDGES OF PLASTIC BAG
Current Location: WI GEN/ 02/ A/ 03/ C
Articles

Article: YFORENS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Description: SWAB OF RED SUBSTANCE FROM GROUND ( MARKER 6)
Current Location: Wl GEN/ 02/ A/ 03/ C
Articles

Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
GO# HS 2019- 211277 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED'

Description: RED HOODIE FROM GROUND ( MARKER 7)
Current Location: WI BIO/ 02/ C/ Il/ D
Articles

Article: PRAT- PERSONAL ACCESSORIES
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Serial # 1: UNKNOWN CAN:
Value: $ 0.00 Color:
Description: RED BEANIE HAT FROM GROUND ( MARKER 8)
Current Location: W1 BIO/ 02/ A/ 06/ G
Articles

Article: DCELLPH- DATA PROCESSING EQUIPMENT
Make: SAMSUN
Model: SM- J260TI of pieces: 2
Serial # I: UNKNOWN CAN:
Description: BLACK SAMSUNG CELLPHONE W/ BLACK CASE FROM GROUND ( MARKER 9)
Current Location: WI GEN/ 03/ A/ 07/ F
Articles

Article: RCDPLAV- RADIO, TV, ENTERTAINMENT DEVICES
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Description: SCENE VIDEO TAKEN AT 1250 SKIPPER ROAD
Current Location: Wl GEN/ 04/ I/ 07/ D
Drugs
Status: EVIDENCE
Tag #: HS736559- 5
Name: Unknown Type Drug

Form: Plant Quantity: 0. 400
Unit: Gram Value: $ 0. 00
Description: 0. 4GM GREEN LEAFY SUBSTANCE FROM PLASTIC BAG
Flags: x
Current Location: Wl DRU/ 02/ B/ 08/ F
Flags = d ( disposed) x ( x- reference) n ( entered on NCIC) * e ( evidence)

Report Information

Submitted on: Mar-27- 2019 ( Wed.) by: Dirks, Thomas
Related:
Location: 2224 FALKENBURG RD N

District: D5 Zone: NOI
General remarks: CD OF AUDIO RECORDINGS
Related items:
Articles - Evidence
Article: YOFFICI- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Serial # 1: UNKNOWN CAN:
Description: CD - AUDIO REC INT - CHRIS SCHMID / MICHELLE MCCARTY
Flags: * e
Current Location: WI GEN/ 03/ 1/ 04/ 13
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BAT ERY- I BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Related Property Report(s)
Report Information Property Report #:

736961 Property
case status: EVIDENCE

Submitted on:Mar- 29-
2019 (
Fri.) by:Montano Mark J Related: Offense: GO HS
2019-
211277 General remarks: 1208 TECH
BL Related items: 1 Articles
Status: EVIDENCE Tag #:
HS736961-
1 Article: ZCDISC- LOST OR

STOLEN ITEMS ( PUBLIC SAFETY, HOMELAND SECURITY) Make: NO BRA Model:
of pieces: 1
Serial # I:
UNKNOWN OAN:
Value: 0. 00 Color:
Description: CD OF ( 2)
PHOTOGRAPHS OF DVR HARD DRIVE AND DVR MODEL/ SN Recovered date:-Recovered value: $
0.
00 Current Location: Wl GEN/
06/C/08/ H Flags = d (disposed) x (
x-reference) n entered (
on NCIC) *
c ( evidence) For: 205814 Printed On:
May- 01- 2019 (Wed.) Page 359 of 372

Related Property Report(s)

Report Information

Submitted on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) by: Woychowski, Richard
Related:

District: D1 Zone: A03
General remarks: DVR
Related items: 1
Articles

Article: ZCDISC- LOST OR STOLEN ITEMS ( PUBLIC SAFETY, HOMELAND SECUIRTY)
Make: NO BRA
Model: # of pieces: 1
Description: SCENE PHOTOGRAPHS OF DVR RECOVERY
Current Location: WI GEN/ 06/ C/ 08/ H
Related Proaerty ReDort( s

Report Information

Submitted on: Mar-29- 2019 ( Fri.) by: Florio, Joseph
Related:

District: D5 Zone: , N'01
General remarks: INTERVIEWS/ SURVEILLANCE/ RADIO
Related items: 3
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Description: 91 I/ RADIO TRAFFIC 03/ 26/ 19
Flags: * e
Current Location: W1 GEN/ 06/ C/ 08/ H
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Description: INTERVIEWS- DEPUTIES, S. THOMAS, V. THOMAS, AVILES
Flags: * e
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Description: CIRCLE K SURVEILLANCE

Flags: * e
GO# HS 2019- 21 27 ACTIVE/ OPEN BATTERY- 1 BATTERY - AGGRAVATED Related Property Report(
s)
Report Information Property
Report #:
736990
Property case status:

EVIDENCE Submitted on: Mar-
29-2019 ( Fri.)by: Rettew, Kevin Related: Offense: GO
HS
2019- 211277 Location: 1 TAMPA

GENERAL CR Municipality: TAMPA District:
TI Zone:
TB4 Related items: Articles -
Evidence Status:
EVIDENCE Tag #:
HS736990- 1 Article: YOFFICI- OTHER

ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS) Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces:
Serial # l:
UNKNOWN
OAN: Value:$ 0. 00
Color: Description: CD W
REC INTRVS W STEPHANIE THOMAS/ CHASTITY+
value: 0.
$ 00 Flags: * e Current
Location: WI
GEN/ 06/ C/ 08/ H Flags = d (

disposed)
x (
x- reference) n ( entered on NCIC) * c evidence)(
For: 205814 Printed
On: May- 01-2019 ( Wed.)Page 363 of 372


Report Information

Submitted on: Mar- 29- 2019 ( Fri.) by: Tabor, David
Related:

District: D5 Zone: N01
Related items: 1
Articles

Make: NO BRA
Description: INT WITH ANNETTE GADDY ( X2) AND JOSE DELACRUZ
Current Location: WI GEN/ 05/ G/ 04/ A

Report Information

Submitted on: Apr- 12- 2019 ( Fri.) by: Douglas, Brannon
Related:

Related items:
Articles
Status: EVIDENCE Tag#: HS738996-

Article: YEVIDEN- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Model: of pieces: 1
Description: FARO SCAN DATA
Current Location: Wl GEN/ O1/ K/ 04/ F
Related Property Report(s)

Report Information

Submitted on: Apr- 13- 2019 ( Sat.) by: Florio, Joseph
Related:


District: D5 Zone: NO1
General remarks: FDLE TEST FIRES
Related items: 1
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: I
Serial # l: UNKNOWN CAN:
Description: ITEM LI- TEST FIRES
Flags: * e
Related Properly Report( s)

Report Information

Submitted on: Apr- 15- 2019 ( Mon.) by: Hall, Katelyn
Related:

Related items: 2
Articles

Article: YSWAB- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: I
Description: CONTROL SWAB OF DISTILLED WATER
Current Location: W1 GEN/ 02/ D/ 09/ B
Articles

Article: YFORENS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 1
Description: SWAB FROM BLACK CELL PHONE AND CASE
Current Location: WI GEN/ 02/ D/ 09/ B
Related Proaerty ReDort( s

Report Information
Property case status: LATENT PRINT

Submitted on: Apr- 15- 2019 ( Mon.) by: Hall, Katelyn
Related:
Municipality: HILLSBOROUCH COUNTY

General remarks: LATENTS- ACC BATT- 2 ENV
Related items: 2
Articles
Status: LATENT PRINT Tag #: HS739566- I

Article: YPRINTS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 2
Description: LATENTS- AGG BATT- 2 CARDS
Current Location: IDENTIFICATION SECTION
Articles
Status: LATENT PRINT Tag #: HS739566- 2

Article: YPRINTS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces: 3
Description: LATENTS- AGG BATT- 3 PHOTOS VERIPIC ( FSIS)
Current Location: IDENTIFICATION SECTION

Report Information

Submitted on: Apr- 18- 2019 ( Thu.) by: Garcia, Moises
Related:

Related items: 1
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Description: CD CONT INT OF HCFR LT. ANTHONY FONSECA
Flags: * e

Reoorl Information

Submitted on: Apr- 25- 2019 ( Thu.) by: Florio, Joseph
Related:

General remarks: METRO PCS RECORDS
Related items:
Articles - Evidence

Make: NO BRA
Model: # of pieces:
Description: METRO PCS RECORDS FOR
Flags: * e
Current Location: WI GEN/ 04/ F/ 11/ A

Resort Information

Submitted on: Apr- 03- 2019 ( Wed.) by: Rieger, Elizabeth
Related:
Location: 1 TAMPA GENERAL CR
Municipality: TAMPA
District: TI Zone: TB4
General remarks: BULLET EVIDENCE
Related items: 1
Articles - Evidence

Article: VAMMUS- OTHER ITEMS ( MISCELLANEOUS)
Make: NO BRA
Model: of pieces:
Value: $ 0. 00 Color: Bronze
Description: SPENT PROJECTILE RECOVERED FROM VICTIM
Flags: * e
Flags = d ( disposed) x ( x- reference) n ( entered on NCIQ *c ( evidence)
END OF HARDCOPY ***
For: 205814 Printed On: May- 01- 2019 ( Wed.) Page 372 oF372
ROMINE LAW, P.A.
727) 288- 2258/ Fax ( 727) 288- 2257
Steve@RomineLaw. com
April 12, 2019
Major Frank Losat

2008 E. 81 Avenue
VIA Email: FlosatnaHCSO. Tampa.FL. US
Dear Major Losat,
perspective of Deputy Estanislau, I also wanted to provide your office additional information that
individuals carry firearms. It was of a color consistent with a firearm. It was partially concealed.
person to cant' a cell phone with the stand in an open position. Stands are meant to prop up a cell
gunl, the stand being open in this case changes the entire profile of a normal cell phone. It further
I In February this year, FDLE and prosecutors cleared Cocoa Police Officer Xzevies Baez for shooting a man
running towards his vehicle carrying a cell phone. The officer fired at the man six times through his vehicle window
because the officer saw "a black object in his hand" that the man was " about to lift it up ... and that' s when I believe
I was going to be shot at." And it is not just law enforcement mistaking cell phones for firearms. See
htlpsJ/ www fox2lnews wm/ news/ local/ police- called- after- cell- phone- mistaken- for- kun/ 1464604306 ( several
man with a
gun on his hip; it was a large black cell phone).
I understand that your agency has certain duties to not release information during an investigation.
But the public report that " no weapon was found" in this case unfortunately I believe has created
the impression that nothing was found to explain why the deputy thought the suspect had a gun.
for service reportedly came around 7:45 p.m. and Deputy Estanislau arrived on scene thereafter. I
The complaint against the suspect was for violence against his own family, including apparently
assessing that threat, often with one hand on or near their service weapon. Deputy Estanislau knew
Deputy Estanislau has exhibited a history of restraint in using deadly force despite circumstances
In Deputy Estanislau' s performance evaluation review in his personnel file, it was noted that:
As reflected in his August 8, 2017, diary entry, Deputy Estanislau demonstrated poise
and restraint while responding. to a call for service involving a suspect that was
Grace responded and were able to come in contact with the suspect, detained him
impulsive decision.
In October of 2018, Deputy Estanislau again exhibited significant restraint in responding to a call
at approximately 9: 52 p. m. of a female with a gun in her hand stating she was " going to shoot
Estanislau the female with the gun " was waving, it around."
female to listen to Deputy Estanislau' s commands or she was " going to lose her life."
2
his weapon. The firearm tamed out to be a BB gun. The male that witnessed the handling of this
individual accused of violence with a knife on his person that charges a deputy -- despite being at
insanely chose to advance within arn' s reach of Deputy Estanislau while Deputy Estanislau had a
gun pointed at him. Upon pushing the suspect down, two knives approximately seven inches long
This is not a deputy that has a history of being " quick on the trigger" or impulsive. Deputy
and reason with him in a non -threatening manner. When Deputy Estanislau perceived what he
different. All of this could have been avoided if the suspect dropped what he was holding or moved
If a person is carrying a cell phone and a law enforcement officer draws a weapon and verbalizes
they believe the person has a firearm, a reasonable, rational response -- at a minimum — is for the
person to move their hand away from the cell phone or drop it. It is also not unreasonable to expect
have avoided by simply complying with Deputy Estanislau' s instructions. Thank you for taking
Sincerely,
Is/ Stephen L. Romine

Stephen L. Romine
3
This summary statement regarding' my use of force is made to the best of my
call address on Skipper Road, a middle- aged black malewearing glasses on a phone flagged
me down and pointed to the direction of the suspect, stating " that' s him." I turned
my marked vehicle around to make contact with the suspect. The
suspect was on foot walking away from the call address. I puled up towards the
suspect in my vehicle, parked, and exited the vehicle. I asked the suspect if I could
talk to him for a second. He indicated he did not want to talk. During my initial
observations of him,he was sidestepping, glancing back and forth, and would blade
towards me with his left shoulder. I
began to walk towards him, walking past my front bumper, advising that I just wanted
to get his statement about what happened, try to clear this up, words to that affect.
He appeared very agitated and was acting in a way that I thought he may be getting
ready to run. I was trying to calm him down, both in my tone and in my body language.
As
I walked towards him, he turned to face me. That is the first time I noticed he was
holding a black object in his waistband with his right hand. It ap eared to me to
be a gun. Based on my training and experience, it was in an area consistent where guns
are carried and the manner in which the suspect was holding the object was consistent
with holding a gun. In the split second of seeing this and believing it to be
a gun, 1 drew my weapon. I
recal shouting " drop the gun" repeatedly. I may have also told him to show me his
hands or place his hands up,but under the stress and speed of this incident 1 am not
completely sure of my exact words. The suspect did not comply with any of my commands.
Instead he kept blading towards me,still appearing agitated, looking all around,
and not dropping or moving his hand away from what I beli ved to be the gun.
While his left shoulder was bladed towards me,he then made a movement that appeared
to be positioning the gun towards me with his right hand —
inconsistent With
dropping the gun or moving his hand away from the gun. I thought 1 was about to
be shot and feared for my life. That is when 1 im ediately fired two shots.
prior to firing my weapon did I know or believe the object was a cell phone. I recall
As soon as he fell, I ran to him. As I patted him down, I asked where he was shot.
He indicated his back, which surprised me. I knew 1 did not shoot him from behind.
I turned him over on his stomach and saw one bullet wound near his left shoulder
blade area, which was consistent with the bladed position he had been in. I did not
see an exit wound.
trying to get up. I kept telling him to stay down while 1 maintained pressure to the
At no time after I made clear that I believed he had a gun did the suspect say
away from the object, this incident would have never happened. 1 tried to diffuse
Depu Daniel Estanislau

Tampa, Hillsborough County, FL ( Longitude W 82a 28', Latitude N 27° 58')
Sun
Begin civil twilight 7: 04 a. m.
0
Sunrise 7: 27 a. m.
Sunset 7:44 p. m.
End civil twilight 8: 08 p. m.
Moon
Closest Primary Moon Phase: Last Quarter on March 28, 2019 at 12: 10 a. m. ( local daylight time)
Phase of the Moon on March 26, 2019: Waning Gibbous with 65% of the Moon's visible disk illuminated.
1oon image not available.
Back to form
i
1 IN THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY

OF THE THIRTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
2 HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, FLORIDA
3
IN RE:
4
SAO INVESTIGATION
5
7
SWORN STATEMENT OF:
8
TAKEN: Pursuant to Notice
9
TIME: Beginning at 11: 05
10 Concluded at 12: 04 p. m.
11 DATE: June 12, 2019
12 PLACE:
Tampa General Hospital
13 1 Tampa General Circle
Tamp, Florida 33602
14
15 BEFORE: RALPH D. MILLS, CVR, CP

Certified Verbatim Reporter
16 Notary Public
State of Florida at Large
17
18
19 Pages 1- 46
20
21
22
23
24
25
ORIGINIL
MILLS REPORTING GROUP, INC.
813) 272- 1814

E
I APPEARANCES:
2
On behalf of the State:
3
JAY PRUNER, ESQUIRE
4 State Attorney' s Office
419 North Pierce Street
5 3rd Floor
6 813) 272- 5400
8 On behalf of the Witness:
9 MANUEL ALVAREZ, ESQUIRE

Rywant, Alvarez, Jones, Russo & Guyton
10 109 North Brush Street
Suite 500
11 Tampa, Florida 33602
813) 229- 7007
12
MICHAEL T. DAVIS, ESQUIRE
13 Kuehne Davis Law P. A.
100 Southeast 2nd Street
14 Suite 3550
Miami, Florida 33131- 2112
15 305) 739- 5989
16
Also Present:
17
Suzanna Zamora
18 Victim' s Assistance
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
813) 272- 1814

3
1 C O N T E N T S
2 PAGE
3 Mr. Pruner 4
Examination by
4 Mr. Alvarez 42
Examination by
5 Mr. Davis 43
Examination by
6 Examination by Mr. Davis 44
7 Certificate of Oath 45
8 Certificate of Court Reporter 46
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

813) 272- 1814
4
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
3 was called as a witness,

and being duly sworn by the
4 Notary, was examined and testified as follows:
5 THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.
6 THE COURT REPORTER: Very good. Go right
7 ahead.
8 DIRECT EXAMINATION
9 BY MR. PRUNER:
10 Q Would you state your -- your full name for
11 me, please?
12 A
13 Q May I call you
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q Okay. What is your date of birth?
16 A
17 Q Okay. Sir, my name is Jay Pruner. You can
18 call me Jay. I' m an attorney, prosecutor here. And
19 I' m here to ask you questions about the incident
20 that -- that led you to be in the hospital.
21 A Yes, sir.
22 Q Okay. I' m not going to ask you questions
23 that are meant to be tricky or

anything, but
24 sometimes my words don' t come out like I mean them
25 to.
813) 272- 1814

5
1 A Yes, sir.
2 Q So if I say something you don' t understand,
3 just say, can you say that again or repeat it. Okay?
4 A Yes, sir.
5 Q Because all I want to do is find out what
6 you remember about what happened. Okay? I may ask
7 you some details, and you take as much time that you
8 want to think about it. If you -- if you need to
9 think about it or --
10 A Yes.
11 Q -- answer however you remember. Whatever" s
12 the truth as you remember it. Okay?
13 A Yes, sir.
14 Q If you want a minute to stop to or to
15 take a break, you just tell us. We' re not going to
16 be that long. If you want to talk to Mr. Davis or
17 Mr. Alvarez privately, you just say that, and we' ll
18 step out. And you can talk to them or even or
19 your mom.
Okay?
20 A Yes, sir.
21 Q All right. Now, on March 26 of this year,
22 as I understand it, you were involved with an
23 incident with your sisters and mom. And we' re not
24 going to go into that much. It' s not that important
25 for what we' re here today. Okay? But at the
813) 272- 1814

6
1 is that were your grandfather
2 lives?
3 A Yes, sir.
4 Q And what is your grandfather' s name?
5 A His name is
6 Q Okay.
7 A Yes, sir.
8 Q Okay. And tell me if you would what your
9 mom' s name and your brother' s and sister' s names?
10 A
11 Q That' s your mother?
12 A Yes, sir. And two of them is
13
14 Q
15 A
16 Q Okay.
17 THE COURT REPORTER:
18 THE WITNESS: Yes.
19 BY MR. PRUNER:
20 Q Are those your only sisters?
21 A Yes, sir.
22 Q Do you have any brothers?
23 A No, sir.
24 Q Okay. So again,
we' re not going to go into
25 a lot of details about it. But do you remember there
813) 272- 1814

7
1 being some type of incident or -- involving you and
2 your mom and your sisters at the -- in the -- at that
3 apartments that night?
4 A I' m sorry.
5 Q Do you remember seeing your mother and your
6 sisters outside of the apartment?
7 A Yes. Yes, ma' am. Yes, sir.
8 Q Okay. And there was some type of incident
9 between -- involving you and your sisters. Do you
10 remember that?
11 A Yes, sir.
12 Q Okay. And as a result of that incident, did
13 you walk away from the apartments?
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q Okay. So what I want to do is just to have
16 you say in your own words what you remember
17 happening. And then when you' re done telling me
18 everything you remember,

I may come and ask you some
19 more details. Okay?
20 A Yes, sir.
21 Q So tell me from the point when you walked
22 away from your mother and your sisters where you went
23 and what you recall happening. Okay?
24 A Yes, sir. When -- well, when I was walking
25 away, you know, I -- you know, went to go cool off my

813) 272- 1814
1 anger because, you know, I got anger problems. So I
2 when to go cool off my anger.
3 So I seen the police come past me. You
4 know, he came past me. So I turned around, looking
5 back. And he was talking to some dude, and I don' t
6 know who -- what dude he was talking to. So I just
7 kept on
walking. And that' s when he came behind me,
8 and like he jumped out of the car. And as he was
9 jumping out of the car, he said, hey, I want to talk
10 to you for a second. And that' s when he drawed the
11 gun. He drawed the gun on me.
12 And I turned around, and I was, you know,
13 trying to show him my hands that is, you know, it' s
14 clearly I ain' t got no weapon. So he still got the
15 gun drawn on me. And as he' s drawing the gun on me,
16 I turned around and was fixing to get ready to run,
17 and that' s when he shot me.
18 Q I' d like to take it kind of step- by- step,
19 okay, and -- and get in some more details. Okay?
20 A Okay.
21 Q All right. So there' s the incident that
22 happens with your mom and your sisters. And you
23 decided to walk away from them; is that right?
24 A From the situation, yes, sir.
25 Q Okay. And was that situation in the

813) 272- 1814
9
1 apartment complex parking lot?
2 A Yes, sir.
3 Q Okay. So you walked away from the parking
4 lot. Do you remember where you walked to?
5 A No, sir.
6 Q Okay. Do you know -- was it -- did you go
7 to the main street nearby?
8 A I' m not sure.
9 Q Okay. I know that there' s a road right in
10 front of those apartments called Skipper Road. Does
11 that name does that -- do you recognize that name,
12 Skipper Road?
13 A Yes, sir.
14 Q Okay. When you walked away from the parking
15 lot, did you go to the next street over, the nearest
16 street?
17 A No, sir.
18 Q Okay. Well, let me ask you this: Was the
19 deputy that shot you, was he in a car before he got
20 out it? Was he in a car?
21 A Yes, sir.
22 Q Okay. So he must have been driving on the
23 street, is that right?
24 A Yes, sir.
25 Q Had -- were -- had you been walking down
813) 272- 1814

10
1 that street for a little bit?
2 A Yes, sir.
3 Q Okay. When you were walking down the
4 street, do you remember were you walking in the road
5 or on the sidewalk or in the grass?
6 A No. I was walking on the sidewalk.
7 Q The sidewalk? Okay.
8 A Yes, sir.
9 Q You -- you said you were walking to --
10 and -- and these are

my words, maybe not exactly what
11 you said. Kind of to walk off your anger?
12 A Yes.
13 Q Okay.
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q Because of what happened before?
16 A Yes, sir.
17 Q Okay. As -- as
you were walking -- now,
18 there' s going to be a lot of questions I ask that I
19 have no idea what the answer is. Okay? So just
20 because I ask a question, don' t think: Why is he
21 asking that because he may know something I don' t
22 know? I -- there' s -- there' s a lot of questions I
23 have to ask that may not have anything to do with
24 this. So just bear with me if you could. Okay?
25 As you' re -- as you' re walking down the

813) 272- 1814
11
1 street, was there -- were there cars going up and
2 down the street? Do you remember?
3 A Yes, sir.
4 Q Okay. Were you paying much attention to
5 them?
6 A No, sir.
7 Q All right. As -- as best as you can
8 remember, tell me what you were thinking or feeling
9 as you were walking down the street.
10 A Just wanted to cool off my anger.
11 Q Okay. All right. Do you remember how you
12 were dressed that day?
13 A I was dressed in all red and my Jordans.
14 Q Okay. Tennis shoes?
15 A Yes, sir.
16 Q All right. I' d like to tell -- I' d like you
17 to tell me everything that you had, you were carrying
18 or had in your pockets or anything like that.
19 Everything anything you can remember, whether it
20 be -- be gum or change or anything. Just tell me
21 whatever you recall having in your hands as you' re
22 walking or in your pockets or -- or anywhere on you.
23 A No. No, sir. I never did.
24 Q Okay.
25 A I didn' t have nothing in my pockets.
MILLS REPORTING GROUP, INC

813) 272- 1814
12
1 Q Okay. Did you have a cell phone?
2 A Yes, sir.
3 Q Okay. Did you have a wallet?
4 A No, sir.
5 Q All right. Did you have any paper money or
6 change or anything?
7 A No, sir.
8 Q Okay. And you -- I think I know the answer
9 because you -- you kind of told me. But I have to
10 ask it this way. Did you have any type of weapons on
11 you?
12 A No, sir.
13 Q Okay. So you have the -- is that the -- the
14 same phone or a similar phone?
15 A No. It was a different phone.
16 Q Okay. Do you remember -- and we' re talking
17 about a cell phone, right?
18 A Yes, sir.
19 Q All right. And the one in front of you has
20 a black case, a dark case.
21 A Yes, sir.
22 Q What was the color of the case was the one
23 that you had?
24 A It was all black.
25 Q Okay. All right. Do you remember -- was

813) 272- 1814
13
1 that the only thing you were carrying that day
2 A Yes, sir.
3 Q wallet -- any keys?
4 A No, sir.
5 Q Okay. As you were walking down the street
6 away from the -- that apartment complex --
7 A Yes, sir.
8 Q where was your cell phone?
9 A It was in my pocket.
10 Q Okay. Tell me the -- did you have long
11 pants on?
12 A Yes, sir.
13 Q And what were you wearing? What was the red
14 that you were wearing on your upper body?
15 A It was like a suit, it was like a -- like
16 a --
17 Q Jacket?
18 A Yeah.
19 Q Okay.
20 A A sweater.
21 Q All right. Did it have full- length arms?
22 A Yes, sir.
23 Q All right. You said your cell phone was in
24 your pocket; is that correct?
25 A Yes, sir.

813) 272- 1814
14
1 Q Okay. And the reason I can see you shake
2 your head, but we have to answer out loud. Okay?
3 A Yes, sir.
4 Q Al right. Thank you. So which pocket was
5 your cell phone in?
6 A It was in the right.
7 Q Right pants or jacket pocket?
8 A No. Right jacket pocket.
9 Q Okay. All right. And you' ve kind of
10 gestured towards where the right side of your stomach
11 would be. Would that be that -- about that pocket
12 where that was?
13 A Yes, sir.
14 Q Okay. So when did you first see a -- a
15 deputy in a --
in a patrol car?
16 A When he like went past me.
17 Q Okay. Was -- you say went past you. Did he
18 go past you with his front facing you or with his --
19 A No. More like we was facing each other.
20 Q Okay. And I see. So he was coming from the
21 opposite direction; is that right?
22 A Yes, sir.
23 Q All right. And when

you saw him, did he
24 gesture to you or say anything or do anything towards
25 you?

813) 272- 1814
15
1 A No, sir.
2 Q Do you remember whether the lights were on
3 in his car?
4 A No, sir.
5 Q Meaning the overhead red and blues?
6 A No, sir.
7 Q Okay. Do you recall whether or not you said
8 anything or made any kind of gesture to that deputy
9 as he drove past you?
10 A No, sir.
11 Q Okay. So after you see that deputy go past
12 you in the opposite direction --
13 A Yes, sir.
14 Q what do you do?
15 A I kept walking.
16 Q In the same direction you were before?
17 A Yes, sir.
18 Q All right. At some point, do you see
19 another
a deputy vehicle?
20 A No, sir.
21 Q Okay. What is the next thing that you see
22 or hear that tells you there' s a deputy somewhere
23 nearby?
24 A All I just turn -- did is just turn my head,
25 and he was right behind me.

813) 272- 1814
16
1 Q Okay. And was that a -- a deputy?
2 A Yes, sir.
3 Q Okay. Do you -- do you recall whether --
4 how that person was dressed?
5 A He was dressed in white.
6 Q Okay. Did you recognize him as being a
7 deputy right away?
8 A Yes, sir.
9 Q Like from his uniform?
10 A Yes, sir. Like, yeah, when he got out of
11 the car.
12 Q Okay. When he got out of the car, which way
13 was his car pointed on the street?
14 A His car was like pulled over on the side of
15 the sidewalk.
16 Q Okay.
17 A And he was right behind me, and I turned
18 around.
19 Q Okay. All right. Was the front of his car
20 pointed in the same direction that you were walking
21 before?
22 A Yes, sir.
23 Q All right. And so when you first turned
24 around, was the deputy in the car? Or had he already
25 been -- gotten out of the car? Do you remember?

813) 272- 1814
17
1 A I' m not sure. What are you talking about?
2 Q Okay. I -- if I -- if I remember right, you
3 told me you turned around and saw the deputy. Is
4 that right?
5 A Yes, sir.
6 Q Okay. At that moment, was the deputy still
7 in the car, or was he getting out of the car?
8 A He was getting out of the car.
9 Q He was getting out of the car?
10 A Yes, sir.
11 Q Okay. When -- did you see him get out of
12 the car all the way?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Okay. And what did you see the deputy do
15 once he got out of the car all the way?
16 A He -- he said clearly he wanted to talk to
17 me for a second, but -- and then he drawed the gun.
18 Q Okay. Did he say he wanted to talk to you?
19 Is that what --
20 A Yes, sir.
21 Q Okay.
22 A He said it.
23 Q As -- as close to what he said as you can
24 remember,
what do you remember him saying?
25 A No. That' s all I heard, that he wanted to

813) 272- 1814
18
1 talk to me for a second.
2 Q Okay. Did he tell you what he wanted to
3 talk to you about?
4 A No, sir. He didn' t even give me a chance.
5 Q Okay. When he said he wanted to talk to
6 you, do you remember where he was standing?
7 A He was standing like right by his car with
8 the door open, right behind the door and drawing the
9 gun.
10 Q Okay. All right. He -- and I want to kind
11 of go into the details a little bit. He was standing
12 with his car door open,

standing behind the open
13 door? Is that what you' re telling me?
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q All right. And when he said he he wanted
16 to talk to you, are you indicating that he already
17 had his gun out?
18 A No, sir.
19 Q Okay. So you see him behind the door?
20 A Yes, sir.
21 Q He' s out of the car?
22 A Yes, sir.
23 Q He indicates he wants to talk to you. Do
24 you say anything back to him?
25 A No, sir.

813) 272- 1814
19
1 Q Okay. What does the deputy do after he said
2 that to you?
3 A He took his gun off his hip, but then he
4 just tried to draw on me.
5 Q You' re -- you' re indicating his gun out with
6 his right hand?
7 A Yeah. He took his gun out.
8 Q Okay.
9 A And drawed the gun on me.
10 Q All right.
11 A He didn' t give me no chance.
12 Q Okay. And I think I understand what you
13 mean by draw the gun out at you, but I need to ask to
14 kind of some more details. Okay? Did you see where
15 he had the gun pointed?
16 A Pointed right at me.
17 Q Okay. Do you -- at that moment, do you
18 remember about how far away from you he was?
19 A No, sir. I' m not sure.
20 Q And I -- I won' t hold you to inches or feet
21 or anything. Was he as close as you and I are in
22 this room or further?
23 A I' m not sure.
24 Q Okay. All right. Did you have any
25 difficulty hearing him, whatever distance it was --

813) 272- 1814
O
1 A No, sir.
2 Q from when he said that to you?
3 A No, sir.
4 Q Okay. When he pointed the gun at you,
5 what' s the next thing you remember that he did? Did
6 he say anything more?
7 A No, sir.
8 Q Did you say anything?
9 A No, sir.
10 Q All right. Did you -- do you recall at the
11 moment that he had the gun pointed at you if he was
12 still behind that door of his car?
13 A Yes, sir.
14 Q Okay. And do you remember at that moment
15 how you were standing, meaning were you face- to- face
16 like we are? Or you tell me in your own words. How
17 were standing in relation to where he was?
18 A Well, I was like -- when I had turned
19 around, my body was facing the road. And I turned
20 around like this ( indicating). Like put my hands up.
21 And I --
22 Q Okay. Go ahead.
23 A And I clearly had a phone in my hand, so --
24 Q Okay. I could see what you' re
demonstrating, but I want to make sure what' s taken
2511
813) 272- 1814
21
1 down reflects what you' re

demonstrating. And you
2 tell me if I' m saying it wrong. You indicated you
3 raised both of your hands up to about how high,
4 compared to your shoulder, your ears, your top of
5 your head?
6 A It was like compared with my shoulders, like
7 my ears.
8 Q Okay. I think what you' re showing me is
9 when your hands are about even with your ears. Would
10 that be about right?
11 A Yes, sir.
12 Q Okay. And you have both of them with the
13 palms facing the deputy; is that right?
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q Okay. Did you just -- did -- did you have
16 that -- your cell phone in one of your hands?
17 A Yes, sir.
My right.
18 Q In your right hand. Okay. And I see how
19 you picked it up for me

just a minute ago. But let
20 me ask you, the cell phone that you had then on this
21 day, was it like that one in front of you in -- in --
22 meaning, did it have a dark black side on one side
23 and a -- a like a plastic or a glass shiny front on
24 the other?
25 A Yes, sir.
813) 272- 1814

22
1 Q Kind of like, you know, most cell phones,
2 like mine.
3 A Oh, Yes, sir.
4 Q You know what I' m

saying? The one side is
5 dark black, and the other side is a screen, well, lit
6 up now. So ignore that. That' s my dog. But see it
7 has the glass?
8 A Yes, sir.
9 Q Which side did you have -- as you' re raising
10 it, do you remember which side you had facing the
11 deputy. If you --
12 A I' m not sure.
13 Q Okay. All right. So you -- you raised your
14 hands like you just showed us, up to your ears with
15 your palms facing him with your cell phone in one
16 hand?
17 A Yes, sir.
18 Q What did the deputy do when you put your
19 hands up like that? Did he say anything to you?
20 A No, sir.
21 Q Okay. And what did he do at that point?
22 A He -- I started to turn around, and he still
23 had the gun drawn on me.
24 Q Okay. Turning around in which direction?
25 A Getting ready to run from him.
813) 272- 1814

23
1 Q Okay. So I think I understand from the way
2 you' ve described it to me sitting there today, okay.
3 But for the purpose of what' s being taken down today,
4 is it correct that originally the deputy comes up
5 from behind and parks the car along the side of the
6 road?
7 A Yes, sir.
8 Q And -- and is it my -- is it correct that
9 as -- as
you' ve described it, that you turned kind of
10 a half turn to where you' re -- you are facing the
11 road and looking back at him? Is -- is that right?
12 Or did you turn all the way around so that your front
13 of yours?
14 A I turned all the way around.
15 Q Okay. So at the time that you had your
16 hands up as high as your ears, then would you have
17 been face- to- face with him, meaning your front was
18 seeing his front?
19 A Yes, sir.
20 Q Okay. All right. And then after he pointed
21 the gun at you after

you raised your hands, you
22 indicated you turned to run. Is -- is that right?
23 A Yes, sir.
24 Q Was there anything that I' ve left out that
25 happened in that time between when he told he wanted
813) 272- 1814

24
1 to talk to you until you turned to run that we
2 haven' t already talked about?
3 A I' m not sure what you' re talking about.
4 Q Okay. We' ve gone into some pretty good
5 detail about he -- he said he wanted to talk to you
6 and how you were standing and -- and had the hands
7 raised. Have we covered everything at that point?
8 A Yes, sir.
9 Q Where there any other words that either he
10 said or you said before you turn to run other than --
11 A No, sir.
12 Q he said to you I wanted to talk to you?
13 A No, sir.
14 Q Okay. All right. So when you turned to
15 run --
16 A Excuse me.
17 Q That' s fine. When you turned to run, did
18 you turn to your right or turn to your left to run?
19 Do you remember?
20 A I -- I turned to my right.
21 Q Okay. So you turned to your right to run?
22 A Yes, sir.
23 Q Did you hear anything further from the
24 deputy?
25 A I heard gunshots.

813) 272- 1814
25
1 Q Okay. Had you -- had you -- were you able
2 to even take a step or two or more in the attempt to
3 run before you heard the shots?
4 A I' m not sure.
5 Q Okay. Al right. And I think I understand
6 from what you already told me. But I have to ask
7 specifically. When you last saw the deputy, where
8 was the deputy in relation to his car? Do you
9 understand my question?
10 A No, sir.
11 Q Okay. He parked his car along side the
12 road, right. Is that correct?
13 A Yes, sir.
14 Q Okay. You said you saw him. He had the gun
15 pointed at you as he stood outside of his car behind
16 his door?
17 A Yes, sir.
18 Q Okay. Where was he when you last had your
19 eyes on the deputy? The last time you saw him, where
20 was he before the last -- last time you can
21 remember seeing him, where was he, the deputy?
22 A I' m not sure.
23 Q Okay. All right. Let me ask it this way.
24 Did you ever see the deputy walk towards you?
25 A No --
MILLS REPORTING GROUP, INC

813) 272- 1814
O
1 Q Okay.
2 A sir.
3 Q I' m sorry?
4 A I said no, sir.
5 Q Oh, okay. Okay. I' m just trying to make
6 sure I cover everything because I know this is
7 putting you through a lot, so I don' t want to forget
8 anything.
9 A Uh - huh.
10 Q Do you remember how many shots you heard?
11 A Like two.
12 Q Okay.
13 A Two shots.
14 Q Okay. Can you tell me why you turned to
15 run?
16 A Because he was trying to kill me.
17 Q Okay. And you thought -- and you thought
18 that -- you felt that way because why? You tell me
19 in your own words.
20 A He was going to kill me.
21 Q And I -- I understand that' s what was in
22 your mind. Can you tell me why you felt that way?
23 A Because like I only like he was going to
24 kill me.
25 Q Okay.

813) 272- 1814
27
1 A That' s why I turned to run to get away from
2 him.
3 Q All right. Did the deputy say anything that
4 you remember about shooting or -- shooting you? Did
5 he say anything like that?
6 A No, sir.
7 Q Did he give you any other directions or
8 instructions or tell you to do anything else other
9 than he wanted to talk to you?
11 Q I' m
sorry. I didn' t hear the last part.
12 A I said no, sir. I' m not sure.
13 Q Okay. All right. Thank you. Other than
14 raising your hands like you showed us a few moments
15 ago where you raised your hands up to your ear level
16 with the palms facing the deputy, before you raised
17 your hands like that, did you make any other
18 movements or gestures with your arms that you can
19 remember?
20 A No, sir.
21 Q Of any kind?
22 A No, sir.
23 Q All right. When you turned to run, tell me
24 how -- where your hands were at that point. Do
25 you do you understand my question?

813) 272- 1814
28
1 A Uh- uh.
2 Q Okay. At some point, you said your hands
3 were up with your palms facing the deputy, right?
4 A Yes, sir.
5 Q And then you decided to turn to run.
6 A Yes, sir.
7 Q When you turned to run, were you -- did you
8 keep your hands up like near

your ears? Or were they
9 dropped in any fashion or lowered or what do --
10 A I' m not sure. I' m not sure.
11 Q Okay.
12 A Just I can' t remember.
13 Q All right. You indicated you turned to run,
14 and you heard two shots; is that right?
15 A Yes, sir.
16 Q Is it correct -- and tell me otherwise if
17 I' m wrong that as we talk about it today, you
18 can' t remember whether you were able to take any
19 steps to run.
20 A No, sir. I' m not -- I can' t remember.
21 Q You can' t remember whether or not you took
22 any steps?
23 A No, sir. I don' t remember.
24 Q You don' t remember.

Okay. All right.
25 When you heard those shots, did you feel any
813) 272- 1814

29
1 pain right away or feel anything?
2 A No, sir.
3 Q Okay. Do you know what happened to you
4 after you heard the shots?
5 A I got shot.
6 Q Okay. But I guess what I mean is, did
7 you -- were -- were you able to remain standing? Or
8 do you know if you fell or anything like that or --

9 A I' m not sure.
10 Q Okay. Do you have any memory of -- of
11 falling to the ground?
12 A Yes, sir.
13 Q Okay. And tell me what you remember in your
14 own words happening after you fell to the ground.
15 A I' m not sure.
16 Q Do you -- do you have a memory of what
17 happened after that?
18 A No, sir.
19 Q It' s my understanding that some emergency
20 medical persons came to where you were to -- to give
21 you medical assistance. Do you have any memory of
22 them giving you medical assistance at that location
23 at the scene where you were shot?
24 A Medical assistance?
25 Q You know, trying to stop bleeding or trying
813) 272- 1814

30
1 to help you in any fashion. You' ve seen an ambulance
2 or,
you know, the fire trucks, the Fire Rescue
3 things?
4 A Well, I do remember that I was coughing up
5 blood.
6 Q Okay.
7 A Yeah.
8 Q All right. Where there people there trying
9 to help you?
10 A Yes, sir. The fire department.
11 Q The fire department. Okay. After you were
12 shot, did you ever see that deputy again that shot
13 you?
14 A No, sir.
15 Q Okay. This -- and I' d like you to describe
16 for me as best as you can.
17 A I' m sorry.
18 Q No. No. You take as much time, as much
19 water as you need. The deputy that you have
20 described as pointing the gun at you, a man or a
21 woman? Was it a man or a woman?
22 A It was a man.
23 Q Okay. As much as you can tell me about how
24 that man looked, what color of his skin or race do
25 you recall that person to be.
813) 272- 1814

31
1 A He was white.
2 Q Okay. Do you remember the color of -- if he
3 had hair, do you remember the color of his hair
4 whether it be dark or light or a bald or anything
5 like that?
6 A I' m not sure.
7 Q Okay. When he had the gun pointed at you,
8 do you remember whether he was pointing or had it in
9 one hand or both hands or do you -- do you recall
10 anything like that?
12 Q Okay. Was it a smaller handgun or a long
13 gun like a rifle?
14 A It was a handgun, like a pistol.
15 Q Okay. What -- as you sit here now many
16 weeks later, what is your memory as to how much time

17 passed between when you first saw the deputy outside
18 of his car when you got shot?
19 A I' m not sure.
20 Q Okay. All right. When you fell to the
21 ground after being shot, do you know what happened to
22 your cell phone?
24 Q At the time that you got shot, do you know
25 whether your cell phone was still in your hand or

813) 272- 1814
32
1 whether it had been put back in your pocket or
2 dropped or anything like that?
4 Q Okay. At some point, they took you to the
5 hospital, obviously, because that' s where you are --
6 are today. Before you were taken from that scene to
7 the hospital, do you remember

any -- any other
8 deputies saying anything near you?
9 A No.
10 Q About anything?
11 A No, sir.
12 Q Do you -- do you remember the ride to the
13 hospital?
14 A Yes, sir.
15 Q Okay. During the hospital, were you in a
16 great deal of pain? Do you remember? Or --
17 A No, sir.
18 Q Okay. And you don' t remember -- I asked you
19 two questions there. I' m sorry. Do you remember,
20 were you in -- in a great deal of pain during the
21 hospital?
22 A No.
23 Q Or during the ride to the hospital, if you
24 remember?
813) 272- 1814

33
1 Q Okay. Did anybody ask you questions during
2 the ride to the hospital that you remember?
3 A I' m not sure.
4 Q Do you remember
anybody, whether it be the
5 Fire Rescue or any deputy. And. I don' t know if -- I
6 don' t know who was in that ride. So I' m just kind of
7 guessing here. Did you remember anybody making
8 statements to you about what happened during the ride
9 to the hospital?
10 A No, sir.
11 Q Okay. Now, this may sound like a dumb
12 question because you already kind of told me this.
13 But when the deputy pointed the gun at you, were you
14 in fear for your life?
15 A Yes, sir.
16 Q And I' m --
I' m trying to be careful so I
17 don' t put words in your mouth. Okay? Were you in
18 fear for your life because of what you saw the deputy
19 do or what he said or both? Or in something that
20 happened to you in the past or --
21 A No. I was fear for my life because of what
22 he -- when he drawed the gun on me.
23 Q Okay. But what -- from that act?
24 A Yes, sir.
25 Q Okay. All right. And this is one of those
813) 272- 1814

34
1 questions when I' m kind of fishing because I -- I --
2 I have not read every police report that was ever

3 created or anything like that. But had you ever had
4 any kind of contact with police where you felt like
5 your life was in danger before, before that day?
6 A I' m not sure.
7 Q Did you understand my question?
8 A No, sir.
9 Q Okay. So -- oh, here' s some -- if we need
10 to stop, we can stop. I' m really close to being
11 done.
12
14 MR. ALVAREZ: Let' s take a short break.
15 ( A discussion was held off the record.)
16 BY MR. PRUNER:
17 Q Okay, I just have a few more
18 questions, and I appreciate your patience with me
19 today. Okay? Before the day that you got shot, it' s
20 my understanding that you' ve had previous contacts
21 with law enforcement officers. Oh, and the
22 circumstances, to me, are not important. But
23 throughout the last few years, you' ve had some
24 contacts where
you -- they' ve come to you or you' ve
25 come to them or
something. You -- and I' m not going

813) 272- 1814
35
1 to go into details. I don' t care about all that.
2 Okay. Is that correct, though, that you' ve had some
3 contacts with law enforcement before?
4 A Yes, sir.
5 Q Okay. In any of those contacts, did -- law
6 enforcement treat you in such a way that you were in
7 fear for your life in the -- in the past?
8 A Yes, sir.
9 Q Okay. Was -- was that once or more than
10 once,
or how many times do you recall that?
11 A More than once.
12 Q All right. And I don' t want to get -- go
13 into all the details of anything that -- that you had
14 contact with law enforcement. But I want to ask you
15 this: Was there ever any time in the past when a law
16 enforcement officer either a Tampa police officer or
17 deputy sheriff had pointed their gun at you before?
18 A Yes, sir.
19 Q Okay. All right. Had there ever been a
20 point in the past where a law enforcement officer
21 shot at you in the past?
22 A No, sir.
23 Q Okay. Had there ever been a point in the
24 past where a law enforcement officer had threatened
25 to shoot you?
813) 272- 1814

36
1 A No, sir.
2 Q Okay. Do you have an idea or as you sit
3 here today I kind of asked this a little bit
4 earlier. I want to try to ask it a different way.
5 Do you have an idea about how long this all took,
6 meaning how long it -- your involvement with the
7 officer took that -- the day that you got shot?
8 A Oh, no. I' m not sure.
9 Q Okay.
10 A I' m not sure.
11 Q All right. And I know I' m kind of jumping
12 around at you because I' m trying to go back in my
13 head the things I may have forgotten to ask you.
14 Okay. When you got shot -- I' m sorry. Let me just
15 forget that.
16 If you can recall, when you heard the two
17 shots, were you already completely turned around or
18 in the process of turning around or just started
19 turning around to run? Or do you -- do you know what
20 I' m asking?
21 A I' m not sure.
22 Q Okay.
23 A No. I don' t know what you' re asking me.
24 Q You don' t know what I' m

asking. Okay?
25 A Can you please repeat that?
813) 272- 1814

37
1 Q Sure. Sure. You' ve -- you' ve told me a
2 couple times and I' m trying not to be repetitive,
3 that at one point after you saw the gun pointed at
4 you, you decided to run.
5 A Yes, sir.
6 Q And that you decided to turn to your right
7 to run?
8 A Yes, sir.
9 Q And at some point, you heard two shots?
10 A Yes, sir.
11 Q Do you remember --
and I know it' s a very
12 detailed question. At the time that you heard the
13 shots, whether you were still turning to your right
14 or you had already completely turned to your right
15 and were facing the opposite direction? Do -- do you
16 know?
17 A I turned to my right.
18 Q Yes.
19 A And like went to running to the opposite
20 direction.
21 Q Okay. If you -- if you know and if you
22 remember, okay, at the time you heard your gunshots,
23 not your gunshots. If you -- at the time you heard
24 the two gunshots.
25 A Excuse me.

813) 272- 1814
38
1 Q No. You' re fine. At the time you heard the
2 two gunshots, was your back completely turned towards
3 the officer so that you could --
4 A Yes, sir.
5 Q -- run?
Okay. And I' m sorry for the delay.
6 I' m just trying to make sure I ask everything we need
7 to talk about today. Okay?
8. Mind if we take a -- a brief break for just
9 a minute or two?
10 MR. ALVAREZ: Sure.
11 MR. PRUNER: I want to make a call -- I want
12 to make a call and make sure that I have covered
13 everything since I' m kind of pitch - hitting and --
14 MR. ALVAREZ: Yeah. That -- that would
15 be -- that would be fine.
16 MR. PRUNER: Okay. Thank you. I just need
17 about two minutes to make a phone call to make
18 sure that I have asked you everything we need to.
19 Okay?
20 ( A discussion was held off the record.)
21 BY MR. PRUNER:
22 Q I just -- I just have a few more
23 questions for you, and then we' ll be done. Okay.
24 So I' m going to go back to when the deputy

25 gets out of the car and you hear him say something to
813) 272- 1814

39
1 you. And I want you to -- to tell me if you can, the
2 exact words the deputy said to you.
3 A He said, hey, I want to talk to you for a
4 second.
5 Q Okay. Can you tell me -- you are very soft
6 spoken.
7 A Me?
8 Q Well, today we are. You know, it' s fine.
9 A You got it recorded.
10 Q Yeah, no. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I heard you.
11 But what I' m

saying -- and you' ll understand where
12 I' m going with this. Okay. When the deputy said
13 that to you, was he using the soft tones that we are
14 today, or did he say it louder or softer? Did he
15 yell? Did he command?
16 A No. He said it like -- he said it loud.
17 Like --
18 Q Okay.
19 A I' m saying he didn' t say it that loud. But
20 he said, hey, I want to talk to you for a second.
21 Q Okay. At any time -- and I kind of asked
22 this in a different way. At any time did the deputy
23 say to you anything like drop the weapon?
24 A No, sir.
25 Q Okay. Or put the weapon down? Did he say
813) 272- 1814

40
1 anything like that?
2 A No, sir.
3 Q Are you
4 MR. DAVIS: Are you okay?
5 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
6 MR. DAVIS: I saw you moving around in the
7 chair.
8 THE WITNESS: No. I had to. No. I don' t
9 want to get my butt sore.
10 BY MR. PRUNER:
11 Q Oh, okay. And is it correct -- and if I' m
12 wrong you tell me, okay. Because this is -- I
13 want -- I want it to be what you remember. Is it
14 correct that you never saw the deputy get out from
15 behind his door?
16 A No, sir.
17 Q That' s not correct or --
18 A No, sir.
19 Q Okay. Now, let me ask it -- I think I did a
20 double negative here. Did you ever see the deputy
21 get out from behind his open door?
22 A No, sir.
23 Q Okay. I thought I understood you correctly.
24 All right. After you got struck, did you hear
25 any deputy curse?
813) 272- 1814

41
1 A Well, yes.
2 Q Tell me about that, please.
3 A He was like F, S, you know, all types of
4 curse words.
5 Q Do you know what deputy said that?
6 A The deputy who shot me.
7 Q Okay. Do you know where he was at that
8 time, if he was still near his car or he was near you
9 or do you know?
10 A No. He was still by his car.
11 Q Okay. Was he -- in -- in your mind -- I' m
12 trying to get your understanding. Was he cursing at
13 you or was he cursing in frustration?
14 A He was
cursing in frustration, like he was
15 mad. Yes.
16 Q Okay. But okay. Did -- as you remember,
17 did any deputy curse at you, direct any of this
18 profanity
19 A No, sir.
20 Q towards you? Okay. is there
21 anything about that night -- because it was about
22 7: 46, 7: 45, right around sunset. Is there anything
23 about that night that you remember that we haven' t
24 talked about?
25 A No, sir.
813) 272- 1814

42
1 Q Okay.
2 A I' m not sure.
3 Q Are there any other details that I -- that
4 maybe I didn' t cover about your contact or
5 interaction or
your -- or seeing that deputy? Any
6 other details that we haven' t talked about that you
7 remember?
8 A No, sir. I don' t remember.
9 Q All right. All right, I appreciate
10 you talking to me today. I hope your recovery
11 continues, and you can get home soon. Okay, sir.
12 A Thank you, sir.
13 Q Thank you. All right.
14 THE COURT REPORTER: You guys got anything?
15 MR. PRUNER: If you want to. I' m sorry. If
16 you wanted, sure.
17 EXAMINATION
18 BY MR. ALVAREZ:
19 Q I -- I have just one question. As
20 you recall, was it still daylight out,
21 A Oh, it was still daylight.
22 Q Could you clearly see the deputy?
23 A Yes, sir.
24 Q Could the deputy clearly see you?
25 A Yes, sir.
813) 272- 1814

43
1 EXAMINATION
2 BY MR. DAVIS:
3 Q Yeah. He asked you a question about coming
4 from behind the door. Do you know what that term
5 means or that phrase?
6 A After when he shot me, I' m not sure if he
7 came around the door or -- I' m not sure because I was
8 on the ground bleeding and coughing up blood, so I' m
9 not sure.
10 MR. DAVIS: That' s it.
11 MR. PRUNER: Okay. Thank you, again,
12 I appreciate your cooperation with us today.
13 Thanks.
14 THE WITNESS: You' re welcome.
15 MR. ALVAREZ: All right. we' re good.
16 We' re off the record.
17 A discussion was held off the record.)
18 THE COURT REPORTER: Do you want to go back
19 on?
20 MR. DAVIS: Oh, I don' t know. If we
21 could -- if we want. Yeah. One of the questions
22 you asked, is why did you turn around. Did you
23 fully get an answer, get a full answer to that?
24 MR. PRUNER: I -- I thought I did. I mean,
25 as best as he could articulate, I thought. And
813) 272- 1814

44
1 he said because he thought you were going to get
2 killed.
3 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
4 MR. PRUNER: Or was afraid of getting
5 killed. I think that' s what he said.
6 EXAMINATION
7 BY MR. DAVIS:
8 Q And what in particular made you afraid of
9 being killed by this deputy?
10 A I don' t know. Just I was scared for my
11 life.
12 MR. PRUNER: Okay. Great. Thank you.
13 The deposition concluded at 12: 04 p. m.)
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

813) 272- 1814
45
1 CERTIFICATE OF OATH
2 STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF HILLSBOROUGH
5 I, the undersigned authority, certify that
6 personally appeared before me on
7 June 12, 2019 and was duly sworn.
8 WITNESS my hand and official seal
9 June 15. 2019.
10
11
12 12aiply M vLLk
13
14 Ralph D. Mills, CVR, CP
15 Notary Public, State of Florida
16
17 Commission No.: GG 295472
18 Expires: May 2, 2023
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

813) 272- 1814
46
1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
2 STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF HILLSBOROUGH
5 I, RALPH D. MILLS, CVR, CP, do hereby
6 certify that I was authorized to and did report
7 the deposition of the aforementioned witness;
8 that a review of the transcript was not
9 requested; and that the transcript is a true and
10 complete record of my stenomask recording and
11 notes thereof.
12 I FURTHER CERTIFY that I am not a relative,
13 employee, attorney or counsel of any of the
14 parties, nor am I a relative or employee of any
15 of the parties' attorneys or counsel connected
16 with the action, nor am I financially interested
17 in the action.
18 DATED this June 15, 2019.
19
20
21 Ralph. M aL k
22
23 Ralph Mills, CVR, CP
24
25

813) 272- 1814

Deputy Estanislau Report 2019

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Deputy Estanislau Report 2019

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

2019- 211277

Use of Deadly Force

NEELFulmore Historical Reports '

Video Surveillance '

Estanislau Statement '

Power Point Presentation

Hillsborough County Sheriffs Office

Law Enforcement Deputy Daniel P Estanislau [ 253881]

Part I - Personal Information

Name: Law Enforcement Deputy Daniel P Estanislau

Administrative investigation IA #: 02017- 159 Case #: 17- 304361

Letter of Counseling Jun 30, 2017 Days/ hrs suspended:

Printed: Mar 26, 2019 20: 47 By: Corporal Samuel Portalatin

Name Estanislau, Daniel

Email destanis@hcso. tampa. fl. us

Course Title Valid From 1/

CPR Certification - 2018 3/ 1/ 2019 4: 08: 00 AM 2021 4: 08: 00 AM 2/15/

Law Enforcement In-

Status Score Completion Date Hours 2018 Law

Enforcement In-Complete 3/ 1/ 2019 4: 08:00 AM 24. 00 Service 2018

Enforcement In-Complete 2/ 15/ 2019 4:00:00 AM 24. 00 Service 2018/

and Review - Hil sborough Community

21-22 911 Not Started Homicide: Is

the Caller the Killer -Manatee

County Sheriffs Office

2019/ 04/ 22- 26 Investigation Not Started

2019/ 08/ 9 Identifying and Not Started

Surviving Hidden Weapons-

Absorb Learning In Progress

eWarrants Complete 3/ 1/ 2019 11: 19: 00 PM

FNS Pistol Informational Complete 2/ 1/ 2019 8: 45: 00 PM

Total Credits: 48. 00

lillsborough County Sheriffs Office For: Estanislau, Daniel P

SSN Gender Male

Status Organization Title/ Rank Employment Type Appointment Type Dates

Department of Patrol Services ( DPDPS) Law Enforcement 10/ 04/ 2015 -

Name Issued Expiration Status

ECD 10/ 19/ 2017 0/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active)

LE Quarter 4 10/ 04/ 2015 Never Expires Active ( Active)

PAA 10/ 19/ 2017 10/ 19/ 2018 Active ( Active)

pcoming, Ongoing, & Unconfirmed

Training Division- Advanced( Salary Incentive)-

Training Division - Electives - HCSO_ 2018_ Fireamts

bpecmuzea training - courtroom -testimony- o/ i° - 1

urrent Period to Date ( 01/ 01/ 2018 - 10/ 17/ 2018)

ing Division - Advanced ( Salary Incentive) - ° Graduated -

Training Division - Mandatory _ - - Graduated -. '

For Official Use Only Page 202 of 239

3illsborough County Sheriffs Office For: Eslanislau, Daniel P

Total Hours ( 80h 30m

evious Period ( 01/ 01/ 2017 - 12/ 31/ 2017)

Independent Study - NARCANO Roll Call Video Graduated -

independent Study - Autism Video - Uniform o

Graduated -' , Salar y

rlrearms-./ uli., 3econaaryrweapons uraauatea-

Hours (105h Om Iher

Periods ( through 12/ 31/ 2016) Training

Stud 'Ph y siolo g teal endent' Res ponse07/ 1h

Basic Carbine - May 10-

Trainin g -Crisis Intervention 04/ Trainin Graduated - P 18/ g-

Use Only Page 203 of 239

3ilisborough County Sheriffs Office For Blanislau. Daniel P

Sheriffs Orientation Training ( SOT) - Law Graduated -

Degree Year Education Level Degree Major Minor