Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
net/publication/265098471
CITATIONS READS
3 316
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
New alternatives for living and housing for older adults View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Erja Rappe on 16 October 2014.
Table 1. The meanings, which the elderly in sheltered housing attached to the growing of plants: the categories with examples of
statements
Individual meaning
One’s own growing skills
a) Individual settings and growing methods
“I now have only petunias because they are growing so well.”
“I use that special fertilizer with water.”
b) Interpretation of the plant’s needs and response
“But those geraniums can be without watering two days, they are so modest.”
“I watered Saintpaulia too much and it died. I have a habit of watering plants too much.”
c) Adaptation
“I have noticed that these artificial flowers are best.”
“I have to restrict plants indoors because they aggravate my breathing problems.”
I must always smell the plants first [if they are suitable].”
Continuity of time
“I brought those plants from home.”
“I have bought seeds of flowers early enough in winter, when the selection is comprehensive.”
Creating experiences
“I am caring those flowers because I have no husband to care.”
“This [potted plant] I got last Christmas. It was very little then. I have tried to nurse it as well as I can and it has survived.”
“Flowers are feast for the eye.”
Social meaning
Significant acts for other people
“Yes they come to admire the blooming flowers and praise them very much.”
“He said last autumn that if I need seeds, I just go to pick them from his flowerbed.”
Indications about the gardener:
“…she has always so beautiful flowers. She buys so many plants and changes them if they are withering. They [flowers] are beautiful,
if one can afford money.”
“There are people who do not have plants. They move so poorly that they can not nurse them [plants].”
A feeling of togetherness:
“I am not the only one who has complained that pansies do not succeed.”
“Sometimes we talk about plants when we are sitting on the bench. Yes, it [talking about plants) is very usual.”
nected with plants and feeling of con- ability to form one’s own preferences and activities and thereby promoted
tinuity may strengthen the identity of and evaluate them critically. The third social relationships.
the elderly, as well as promote their dimension is the autonomy of action, Some caution is needed in assess-
sense of autonomy, and their control which means the capability to carry ing the results of this study. First, there
of the environment. The growing of out the plans one has made. Growing were only 12 interviewees who were
plants may also encourage social rela- plants supported the interviewees’ au- selected to participate. All had experi-
tions by creating possibilities for vari- tonomy in all three dimensions. The ence and had learned growing skills at
ous roles and by strengthening a feel- autonomy of thinking was realized in an early age and all but one had lived in
ing of togetherness. The results indi- their ability to understand the reac- countryside or in a small town. Even
cate that growing plants may contrib- tions of plants and the way the plants the only interviewee who had lived in
ute to the social and psychological responded to nurturing. The fact that a city had her roots in the countryside
well-being of the elderly living in insti- there were no rules in the community and had spent her vacations in a sum-
tutions. This is in agreement with other regarding plant cultivation was impor- mer cottage. The dwelling-times of
researchers dealing with issues of tant for the interviewees. The indi- the interviewees in sheltered housing
people-plant interactions (e.g., vidual choice of species and growing were long (only two participants had
Browne, 1992; Lewis, 1996; Stein, methods supported the autonomy of lived there less than 8 years). Hence
1997). wishing. Growing plants enabled indi- the community they formed was ex-
All participants of the study had vidual interaction with the environ- ceptionally well-established.
plants. Even those who were antici- ment. The capability to make interpre- Since all interviewees grew plants,
pated not to be interested in growing tations from the response of the nur- this brings about the question of
plants owned them. A woman, who tured plants and to make adjustments whether growing plants was a social
reported that she did not care about to one’s activities accordingly, as well norm in the community. Was there a
plants at all grew her own plants and as the capability to adapt to aging, all risk to be excluded if one had no
nurtured a rubber plant of a neighbor. supported the autonomy of action. plants? Or was the growing of plants a
Earlier in their lives, most of the According to Lawton (1985), “the result of the restricted opportunities
interviewees had grown plants mainly more one knows about one’s environ- for other outdoor activities?
to provide food for their families. Now ment, the more autonomous one can The analysis of the data is based
in an institutional setting, they did not be for any given level of competence.” on a coding of the statements into
grow plants to achieve economical or Constant environmental experi- various categories. This kind of method
nutritional benefits but for more sub- ences of the elderly support their sense always includes factors attached to the
jective reasons. of control and competence (Golant, researchers and their perspectives.
To promote the well-being of resi- 1984). Consequently, this sense of The subjects in this study were
dents in institutional settings, the en- control fosters their well-being (Ulrich, rural elderly who were in relatively
vironment should support their iden- 1991). The interviewees were used to good health. Further research is needed
tity, autonomy and social relationships. growing plants. This cultivation usu- to examine the interaction of plants
In this study, the participants’ identi- ally gave them successful experiences and elderly of different states of health
ties were strongly related to their com- and seldom did the residents experi- in various contexts. Regarding forth-
petence in growing plants. The envi- ence failure. The interviewees under- coming studies, one should bear in
ronment which enabled the growing stood the causes and consequences of mind that the elderly are constantly
of plants supported the continuity of events connected with their plants and changing: the next cohorts becoming
their identity as growers and prevented could anticipate the future. As a result, old are not so accustomed to growing.
the negative consequences which could the experience of competence and suc- This, in turn, may have an effect on the
result if their identity was solely as a cess felt by interviewees contributed to meanings connected to plants.
resident in a sheltered housing. Other their sense of control over their envi-
residents drew conclusions about the ronment.
interviewees as people from their plants. Furthermore, Ojala (1989) states Literature cited
They were aware of this and used that the feeling of being needed con- Baars, J. 1998. Aika, gerontologia ja
plants to tell others about their own stitutes a central indicator of the per- vanheneminen. Gerontologia 12(2):72–
skills and preferences. This kind of use ception of a high quality of life in old 81.
of plants can be regarded as the non- age. Residents in the homes for elderly Browne, C.A. 1992. The role of nature for
verbal articulation of identity men- often feel lonely and worthless (Noro, the promotion of well-being of the elderly.
tioned by Baars (1998). 1998). Yet, these interviewees felt In: D. Relf (ed.). The role of horticulture
The autonomy of residents living themselves to be necessary not only for in human well-being and social develop-
in institutions is restricted (Lawton, the plants well-being, but for the other ment. Timber Press, Portland, Ore.
1985; Päivärinta, 1997; Stein 1997). residents as well. The participants also Gaskins, S. and L. Forté. 1995. The mean-
Launis (1994) has divided this au- helped each other in the growing ac- ing of hope: Implications for nursing prac-
tonomy into three dimensions. The tivities and gave horticultural products tice and research. J. Gerontol. Nursing 21
first is the autonomy of thinking, which to others. According to Ojala (1989), (3):17–24.
is associated with a person’s ability to meaningful roles that give content to
Glaser, B.G. and A.L. Strauss. 1971. The
consider things rationally and to un- life prevent the elderly from being discovery of grounded theory: Strategies
derstand the results of his or her own depressed from the feeling that they for qualitative research. 4th ed. Aldine,
action. The second dimension is the are not needed. In this community, New York.
autonomy of wishing, which is the growing plants created various roles
Golant, S.M. 1984. The effects of residen- Matsuo, E. 1995. Horticulture helps us to
tial and activity behaviors on old people’s live as human beings: providing balance
environmental experiences. In: I. Altman, and harmony in our behavior and thought
M.P. Lawton, and J.F. Wohlwill (eds.). and life worth living. Acta Hort. 391:19–
Elderly people and the environment. Ple- 29.
num Press, New York.
Noro, A. 1998. Long-term institutional
Grahn, P. 1991. Om parkers betydelse. care among Finnish elderly population.
Stad & Land nr. 93. Sveriges Stakes, Res. Rpt. 87. Gummerrus
lantbruksuniversitet, Institutionen för Kirjapaino OY, Jyväskylä.
landskapsplanering, Alnarp.
Ojala, T. 1989. Livskvaliteten i ålderdomen.
Hartig, T., M. Mang, and G.W. Evans. Folkpensionsanstaltens publikationer
1991. Restorative effects of natural envi- ML:92, Åbo.
ronment experiences. Environ. Behavior
23(1):3–26. Ottosson, J. and P. Grahn. 1998.
Utemiljöns betydelse för äldre med stort
Hill, C.O. and P.D. Relf. 1982. Gardening vårdbehov. Stad & Land nr 155.
as an outdoor activity in geriatric institu- Förvaltningsavdelningens repro vid SLU,
tions. Activities, Adaptations and Aging Alnarp.
3(1):47–54.
Päivärinta, E. 1997. Vanhainkodeista
Hirsijärvi, S. and H. Hurme. 1995. palvelutaloihin- tilat ja toimintaympäristöt
Teemahaastattelu. Yliopistopaino, toimintaa ohjaavien periaatteiden kuvaajina.
Helsinki. Gerontologia 11(3):218-225.
Launis, V. 1994. Kenelle Relf, D. 1992. Human issues in horticul-
itsemääräämisoikeus kuuluu. In: J. ture. HortTechnology 2(2):159–171.
Pietarinen, V. Launis, J. Räikkä, E.
Lagerspetz, M. Rauhala, and M. Oksanen Rowles, G.D. 1984. Aging in rural envi-
(eds.). Oikeus itsemääräämiseen, ronments. In: I. Altman, M.P. Lawton,
Painatuskeskus, Helsinki. and J.F. Wohlwill (eds.). Elderly people
and the environment. Plenum Press, New
Lawton, M.P. 1985. The elderly in con- York.
text. Perspectives from environmental psy-
chology and gerontology. Environ. Be- Sarola, J.P. 1994. Asuinympäristön ja
havior 17(4):501–519. paikan merkitys vanhalle ihmiselle. In: A.
Uutela and J.-E. Ruth (eds.). Muuttuva
Lewis, C.A. 1992. Effects of plants and vanhuus. Gaudeamus, Helsinki.
gardening in creating interpersonal and
community well-being. In: D. Relf (ed.). Stein, L.K. 1997. Horticultural therapy in
The role of horticulture in human well- residential long-term care: applications
being and social development. Timber from research on health, aging and institu-
Press, Portland, Ore. tional life. In: S.E. Wells (ed.). Horticul-
tural therapy and the older adult popula-
Lewis, C.A. 1996. Green nature/human tion. The Haworth Press, Inc., New York.
nature. The meaning of plants in our lives.
University of Illinois Press, Urbana and Stoneham, J. and P. Thoday. 1996. Land-
Chicago. scape design for elderly and disabled people.
Garden Art Press, U.K.
Liukkonen, A. 1995. Life in a nursing
home for the frail elderly. Clinical Nursing Ulrich, R.S. 1991. Effects of interior de-
Res. 4(4):358–372. sign on wellness: Theory and recent scien-
tific research. J. Health Care Interior De-
Lohr, V.I., C.H. Pearson-Mims, and G.K. sign 3:97–109.
Goodwin. 1996. Interior plants may im-
prove worker productivity and reduce stress Ulrich, R.S., R.F. Simons, B.D. Losito, E.
in a windowless environment. J. Environ. Fiorito, M.A. Miles, and M. Zelson. 1991.
Hort. 14(2):97–100. Stress recovery during exposure to natural
and urban environments. J. Environ.
Psychol. 11:201–230.